Abstract
Background
Calcium sulfate and phosphate have a long clinical history of use as bone-void fillers (BVF) with established biocompatibility and resorption profiles. It has been widely reported that the addition of ‘impurity’ elements such as Silicon, Strontium and Zinc to calcium phosphate is advantageous, resulting in an improved bone healing response.
Methods
This study examined the in vivo response of two formulations of calcium sulfate, as 3mm diameter hemispherical beads, in critical sized defects created in cancellous bone of distal femur and proximal tibia (10mm diameter × 13mm depth) in adult sheep; beads prepared from recrystallised pharmaceutical grade calcium sulfate (RPCS, Stimulan, Biocomposites Ltd, UK) and a lower purity medical grade material containing 1% strontium (SrCS). The animals were sacrificed at 3, 6 and 12 weeks post implantation and the surgical sites analysed using microCT and decalcified histology.
Results
Radiographic analysis showed a slower resorption for SrCS compared to RPCS. Radiographic analysis for both materials confirmed little residual beads at three weeks post implantation. Radiographs at sacrifice confirmed no adverse reactions at any sites at 3, 6 and 12 weeks. Radiographic data alone was not adequate to determine the status of the bone formation and the implant resorption at the implant site. Histological analysis confirmed little or no adverse tissue reactions to either material. However, RPCS outperformed the modified material in terms of new bone formation at all time points post implantation. At 3 weeks histology for RPCS confirmed that residual beads were still visible with active new bone growth appearing to penetrate centripetally into the defect with some resorption of the implant material. By 6 weeks significant new bone was present throughout the defect. In comparison, absorption of the modified material was slower, and penetration of new bone into the defect was less progressed.
Conclusions
The rapid bone regenerative ability of the recrystallised pharmaceutical grade calcium sulfate was demonstrated. The presence of 1% Strontium impurity acted to delay implant absorption and bone healing in this model.
