Abstract
Background
The second generation metal-on-metal (MoM) prosthesis of the hip became a worldwide success in the 90s. However, after the placement of a MoM prosthesis the cobalt ion concentrations raise significantly. This may lead to systemic complaints and even cobalt toxicity.
Methods
Sixty-one patients (26F/35M) with both an unilateral and bilateral resurfacing or large-head MoM (LHMoM) hip prosthesis were included. At last follow-up (5.77 ± 1.57 yrs) cobalt concentrations in the blood were determined by ICP-MS. Based on the known cobalt toxicity symptoms we developed a non-validated questionnaire. Analysis was done on two groups; a low cobalt concentration group and a high cobalt concentration group. We used 170 nmol/L as the upper limit of well functioning prosthesis as defined by the Dutch Orthopaedic Society (NOV). Independent samples T test and Pearson correlation coefficient were done.
Results
In 61 patients, 70 prosthesis were implanted: 44 resurfacings and 26 LHMoM. Mean cobalt and chromium ion concentrations were 110 ± 138 (9 – 833) and 104 ± 138 (6 – 592) nmol/L. The low cobalt concentration group consisted of 52 patients, while the high cobalt concentration group consisted of 9 hips. With respect to the systemic complaints, the subjects in the high or low group reported no significant differences. A trend towards more complaints with visual problems (75% vs 51.9%, P = .089) and dizziness (62.5% vs 38.9%, P = .098) was notable in the high cobalt concentration group.
Conclusions
Metal on metal hip arthroplasty stays controversial for the possible side-effects. This study shows trends, but no significance, in systemic complaints from high cobalt ion concentrations. Complaints of neuro-ocular toxicity are most common. This is in correspondence with other literature, although the upper limit for cobalt ion concentrations remains uncertain.
Level of Evidence
2b
Disclosure
no financial or nonfinancial relationships to disclose.
