Abstract
Introduction
Detailed analysis of retrieved total hip replacements (THRs) is valuable for assessing implant and material successes and failures. Reduction of bearing wear and corrosion and fretting of the head-neck trunnion is essential to implant durability and patient health. This research quantifies and characterizes taper and bearing surface damage on retrieved oxidized zirconium THRs.
Methods
Initially, 11 retrieved oxidized zirconium femoral heads were examined along with their associated femoral stems. Relevant patient and retrieval data was collected from clinical charts and radiographs. Taper corrosion (Figure 1) and fretting damage (Figure 2) scoring was performed following the Dyrkacz [1] method. A coordinate measuring machine was used to obtain a detailed surface map of the male and female taper surfaces. Taper surface maps were best-fit with an idealized cone followed by volume subtraction to quantify the amount of material removed as a result of fretting and corrosion processes. Scanning electron microscopy was performed on select samples to identify specific damage modes.
Unique surface bumps were noted on the articular surface of select femoral heads (Figure 3). Seventeen femoral heads were added to the analysis specifically for identification of these bumps. Articular surfaces were searched under SEM magnification and bumps were identified and counted. Parametric statistical correlations were performed with SAS v9.3.
Results
Mean patient age was 61 years (Range: 35–95) with mean implantation period being 2.0 years (Range: 0.1–11.4) and mean body mass index of 29 kg/m2 (Range: 22–46). Revision for infection (n=11), peri-prosthetic fracture (n=5) and dislocation (n=5) were the main reasons for revision. Mean corrosion damage scores were 2.0 and 3.6 (head, neck) while mean fretting damage scores were 8.5 and 5.8 (head, neck). Fretting damage score was weakly correlated with implantation period (p=0.07) while corrosion damage score was not. Mean corrosion and fretting volume measured 0.40 mm3 and 0.87 mm3(head, neck). Volume of corrosion and fretting damage did not correlate with implantation period; however neck volume correlated with inclination angle of the acetabular cup (p<0.01). Bearing diameter was not found to correlate with corrosion and fretting damage score or volume.
The unique surface bumps were identified in 12 of 28 samples, with 3 samples having <10 bumps. Presence of these bumps did not appear to be related to bearing diameter, implantation period, or any damage metrics.
Conclusion
Fretting damage was found to correlate with implantation period, suggesting that is a continuous in vivo process; however, this was not found for corrosion damage. Fretting damage volume correlated with acetabular cup angle; however, this may be coincidence as only 8 samples were included in the analysis. Overall, our corrosion damage scores (2.0–3.6) were lower than previously published values for 28mm & 36mm cobalt-chrome heads (4.5–13.1) [1]. However, our fretting damage scores (5.8–8.5) were higher than previously published (2.8–4.4) [1]. Greater fretting damage on the oxidized zirconium heads may be explained by the softer zirconium alloy compared to that of cobalt-chromium. Further subsurface investigation of the surface bumps is underway using a focused ion beam mill.
