Abstract
Current implant designs and materials provide a high grade of quality and safety, but aseptic implant loosening is still the main reason for total hip revision. Highly cross-linked polyethylene (HX-PE) is used successfully in total hip replacements (THR) since several years. The good wear properties lead to a reduction of wear debris and may contribute to a longer survival time of the THRs. Furthermore, thin HX-PE liner allows the use of larger femoral heads associated with a decreased risk of dislocation and an improved range of motion. However, the cross-linking process is associated with a loss of mechanical properties of the polyethylene material which compromise the use of thin HX-PE liner in terms of high stress situations.
The aim of the present study was the experimental wear analysis of HX-PE liner under steep acetabular cup position. Furthermore, a finite element analysis (FEA) was performed in order to calculate the stress within the HX-PE material in case of steep cup position under physiological loading.
Experimental wear testing was performed for 5 Mio load cycles, using highly cross-linked polyethylene (HX-PE) acetabular liner combined with 44 mm ceramic femoral heads at a standard position of the acetabular cup (30° inclination) according to ISO 14242 as well as at 60° cup inclination. The wall thickness of the HX-PE liner was 3.8 mm. A hip wear simulator, according to ISO 14242 (EndoLab GmbH, Rosenheim, Germany), was used and wear was determined gravimetrically. Moreover, finite element models of the THR system at standard and steep cup position was created by Abaqus/CAE (Dessault Systemes Providence, USA). Using the finite element software Abaqus (Dessault Systemes Providence, USA) the total hip implants were physiologically loaded with maximum force of the gait cycle (3.0 kN). Thereby, the stresses within the HX-PE material were analysed.
The average gravimetrical wear rates of the HX-PE liners at standard implant position (30°) and 60° cup inclination showed small wear amounts of 3.15 ± 0.32 mg and 1.92 ± 1.00 mg per million cycles, respectively. The FEA revealed a clear increase of stresses at the HX-PE liner with respect to steep cup position (von Mises stress of 8.78 MPa) compared to ISO standard implant position (von Mises stress of 5.70 MPa).
The wear simulator tests could not demonstrate significant differences of gravimetrical wear amount of HX-PE liners under steep hip cup position compared to standard implant position. The small contact surface between the femoral head and the SX-PE liner during the wear testing may lead to the low wear rate of the misaligned acetabluar cup. Moreover, the FEA showed that the effect of a misaligned acetabular cup on the stresses within the polyethylene liner can be critical. Although an increase of wear could not be detected a steeper acetabular cup position using thin HX-PE liners should be avoided due to higher stresses preventing implant failure in clinical application.
