Abstract
Purpose
Evaluation of our experience on the treatment of comminuted, radial head fractures, and of the outcomes of pyrocarbon prosthetic replacement in such cases.
Materials and Methods
We evaluated 47 cases of prosthetic replacement, performed from May 2003 to July 2008. There were 18 males and 29 females with an average follow-up of 48 months (12 to 60). The Hotchkiss classification was used to characterize the fractures. The indicators for the procedure were type III fractures in 27 cases, type IV fractures in 10 cases, comminuted radial head fractures (associated with disruption in medial collateral ligament) in 3 cases, Monteggia variant in 5 cases, and Essex Lopresti in 2 cases. Functional outcomes were assessed using the Mayo Elbow Performance Index and the Visual Analog Scales (VAS) of pain, joint motion, and stability.
Results
The mean VAS score for elbow pain was 1 (0.5–2.1). Patients showed an average arch of motion from 6 degrees to 140, with 75 degrees of pronation, and 67 of supination. By the Mayo Elbow Performance Index, 42 patients had good to excellent results, 3 fair, and 2 poor. The complications that we have encountered were: implant dislocations (2 cases), elbow stiffness (1), implant dissociation (1), stem rupture (1), and transient PIN palsy (2 cases with complete recovery of nervous function at 5 and 8 weeks). There was no persistent instability, infection, synosthosis, severe degenerative changes, or impingement.
Conclusion
The pyrocarbon implants are a good treatment option in complicated, radial head fractures, but the outcome depends on the severity of the initial fracture and the associated lesions. We have also encountered a tendency towards overestimating the prosthesis size, causing restriction of motion, impingement, overstuffing, or dislocation. For these results we are now using the non-modular prosthesis in our center, but further studies are required.
