Abstract
Introduction
Between 2002–2009 we operatively treated 193 acetabular fracture. Among these 44 both-columns fractures according to the classification of Letournel and Judet have been reviewed in order to evaluate the results. These fractures are rare, difficult to treat and often have poor clinical results.
Patients and Methods
44 cases of ORIF of displaced both columns fractures have been studied at a mean 37 months follow-up (range, 13 to 76 months) after the injury. 40 hips were operated with the ilioinguinal approach alone, 1 with Kocker Langenbeck and Smith petersen combined. The 3 remaining hips were operated with a double Kocher-Langenbeck and ilioinguinal approach. Every case was evalueted on X-rays according to Matta criteria and clinically with the Harris hip score and the WOMAC score.
Results
The mean Harris hip score has been 85,8% (range 30%–100%) while the mean WOMAC score has been 88,3 points (range 39,1–100). The main complications were 4 early post-traumatic arthritis operated by hip replacement. One patient instead developed a gastric carcinoma.
Discussion
The rate of anatomical reduction decreased with the complexity of the fracture, the age, and the interval between the injury and the reduction. The clinical result was adversely affected by associated injuries of the femoral head, an older age of the patient. It was positively affected by an anatomical reduction and postoperative congruity between the femoral head and the acetabular roof.
Conclusions
These findings indicate that in many patients who have a complex acetabular fracture the hip joint can be preserved and post-traumatic osteoarthritis can be avoided if an anatomical reduction is achieved. Both column acetabular fractures can be reduced with a combined surgical approaches or with ilioinguinal alone. We used the ilioinguinal approach alone in 91% of cases reaching good results, even comparing Letournel and Matta's results.
Surgeon experience and a long learning curve can help in decision making and in obtaining an anatomical reduction with a low rate of post-operative complications.
