Abstract
Introduction
Tibial component malrotation is associated with pain, stiffness and altered patellofemoral kinematics in total knee arthroplasty (TKA). However, accurately measuring tibial component rotation following TKA is difficult. Proposed protocols utilizing computed tomography (CT) are not well validated and can be time consuming. This study aimed to; 1) Validate and compare the reproducibility of the Berger (2D-CT) and Mayo (3D-CT) protocols; 2) Validate a simple, and potentially rapid screening measurement using an anatomical distance on 2D axial CT- the Centre of Tibial Tray to Tibial Tubercle (CTTT) distance.
Methods
Rotational alignment of 70 TKA patients were evaluated by 3 independent observers using the Berger, and Mayo protocols, which have been previously described, and a new CTTT protocol (Figure 1). The inter and intra-rater interclass correlation coefficients (ICC's), mean difference between measurements and the mean measurement times were calculated. Linear regression analysis was performed to give a coefficient of determination (R2).
Results
The intra-rater reliability for all 3 protocols was rated as “very good” (Mayo 0.96, Berger 0.85 and CTTT 0.85). The inter-rater reliability for the Mayo and the Berger method was rated as “very good” (0.87 and 0.83 respectively), the CTTT was rated as “good” (0.79). The Mayo method had a lower mean difference in intra-rater measurements than the Berger method (1.42° vs 2.60° p= <0.01). Comparing the CTTT to the Mayo method produced an R2 value of 0.73 indicating strong correlation. As a screening tool, 92% of patients with CTTT ≤ 6mm had < 9° of tibial component internal rotation (IR), and 93% of patients with a CTTT ≥ 10mm had ≥ 9° IR. The Mayo method takes 3 minutes, 29 seconds; Berger method: 2 minutes, 5 seconds; CTTT method: 39 seconds to perform.
Conclusion
3D CT is the gold standard for formally determining tibial component rotational alignment. The CTTT has the strongest correlation to the Mayo method, and is the least time consuming. The CTTT method can be used as a reliable, simple and rapid screening tool in daily clinical practice to assess tibial component rotational alignment following TKA, prior to formal measurement.
For any figures or tables, please contact authors directly.