Abstract
Introduction: Infections associated with prosthetic joints cause significant morbidity and account for substantial costs for health care systems. The management of prosthetic joint infections is less standardized, because of the variable clinical presentations and the lack of data from randomized, controlled trials.
We evaluated the results of surgical one stage versus two stage exchange of patients diagnosed positive for prosthetic infection following total hip replacement in correlation with a classification described by Mc Pherson.
Material and Methods: 94 patients were diagnosed positive for prosthetic joint infection following total hip replacement in the years 1995 to 2004: gender distribution was 45 male and 49 female patients. 37 patients were treated with a one stage exchange, 57 patients underwent a two step procedure. Patients were further divided into two groups following the mentioned classification described by Mc Pherson as infection type I+II and III. Further characterisation was performed following systemic host grade (A versus B+C) and local extremity grade 1 versus 2+3.
Results: Eradication of prosthetic infection was achieved in 94, 5% (n=52) within the group of two stage exchange and 56, 8% (n=21) of patients treated with a one stage procedure. Outcome of patients following a one stage or a two step exchange was overall significantly different with p< .001. Further deviations between the described two procedures were noted in the subgroups following the classification described by Mc Pherson. A benefit of patients who underwent a two step procedure was seen according the severity of the classification following Mc Pherson.
Conclusion: Eradication rate of prosthetic joint infections differs statistically significant overall and in the subgroups following Mc Pherson in dependence of the surgical procedure. For this reason the individual surgical procedure should be geared to an algorithm, following the classification described by Mc Pherson.
Correspondence should be addressed to Vienna Medical Academy, Alser Strasse 4, A-1090 Vienna, Austria. Phone: +43 1 4051383 0, Fax: +43 1 4078274, Email: ebjis2009@medacad.org
