122. LOAD AND FAILURE BEHAVIOR OF 6 ARTHROSCOPIC KNOTS AND 8 HIGH STRENGTH SUTURES

Abstract

Purpose: New high-strength sutures demonstrate high failure loads, but may be more likely to slip compared with polyester sutures. The purpose of this study was to determine the knot security and ultimate failure load of 8 common sutures tied with 6 arthroscopic knots. The hypothesis was that knots tied using high-strength sutures would not slip and demonstrate greater tensile strengths than polyester suture.

Method: Eight different sutures (Ethibond, FiberWire, ForceFiber, Hi-Fi, MagnumWire, Maxbraid, Ortho-cord and Ultrabraid) were tied with 6 arthroscopic knots (Duncan, Revo, San Diego, SMC, Tennessee and Weston.) Knots were backed up with 4 reversed half-hitches on alternating posts. Each suture-knot combination was tied 10 times for a total of 480 knots tested. Cyclic testing was performed followed by loading to failure. Mode of failure, ultimate failure load and force during slippage was recorded.

Results: FiberWire demonstrated the highest failure load (259.70N+/−85.81) and Ethibond the lowest (143.92N+/−16.56) (p< 0.05). Knots tied with Ethibond slipped 22.4% of the time compared with 31.7%–40.0% for high-strength sutures. Frequent slippage occurred with Duncan loops (97.5%) and Weston knots (86.3%) while the SMC (1.3%) and Revo knots (3.6%) rarely slipped (p< 0.05). Mean failure loads were highest for the Revo (280.99N +/− 57.01) and SMC knots (274.89N +/−57.90) compared with all others (p< 0.05).

Conclusion: Our results demonstrate that knots tied with Ethibond were least likely to slip and yielded a more consistent (narrow standard deviation) but overall lower ultimate tensile strength than all of the high strength sutures. Early slippage of some knots tied with high-strength suture was responsible for greater variability with some failing at sub-maximal loads. The Duncan loop and Weston knots were the most likely to slip.