ACL RECONSTRUCTION IN SKELETALLY IMMATURE ATHLETES BY COMPLETE TRANSPHYSEAL TECHNIQUE. SHORT TERM PROSPECTIVE EVALUATION OF RESULTS.

Abstract

In the last decades the number of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury in skeletally immature patients (SIP) increased as a result of the participation in competitive sports at younger age and improved diagnostic tools allowing early diagnosis of ACL injury. Although the eminence avulsion fracture is more frequent in SIP and considered the ACL injury pediatric equivalent, intra-substance ACL injury in children is a growing problem. With torn ACL injured knee remains unstable. This instability is poorly tolerated in teens since it is difficult to limit their activity and leads to meniscal and chondral tears and causes resignation from sport carrier. Intraarticular transphyseal ACL reconstruction seems to be effective technique to restore knee stability despite potential iatrogenic complications such as epiphisiodesis, leg length discrepancy and axial malalignment. The main aim of this study was to evaluate the efficacy and results of this method and assess frequency of potential complications.

Material: From 2006 to 2007 we performed 15 reconstructions (7 boys, 8 girls) of ACL in skeletally immature patients (Tanner 3). All patients were athletes. Average age of girls was 11,2 years and boys 12,3 years. The period from injury to reconstruction were shorter than 10 months. All patients were operated by the same surgeon using the same surgical technique – gracilis-semitendinosus autograft, with transphyseal tibial and femoral tunnels and extraarticular fixation with AO screws. Average tunnel diameter was 7 mm. All beside one ACL injuries were isolated, with 1 meniscus tear.

Methods: In prospective study without control group patients were examined before reconstruction, and 6, 12, 24 months after surgery IKDC, Lysholm and Tegner score. We assessed the growth, leg length and axial disturbances by clinical and radiological assessment and the return to prior level of sport activity.

Results: In 12 and 24 months follow-up no disturbance of angular and longitudinal growth were observed, 11/12 patients returned to previous sport activity after mean of 7 months post- op with scores: IKDC 96,5 after 12 months and 97 after 24 months, Lysholm 95 after 12 months and 96 after 24 months. Average gain of growth was 5,5cm/12 months on average.

Conclusion: The use of complete transphyseal reconstruction is a safe, reliable technique in patients who have significant growth remaining, providing adequate knee stability, good satisfaction and allowing return to sport activity.