THE ROLE OF PATIENT FACTORS IN SQUEAKING OF CERAMIC ON CERAMIC TOTAL HIP ARTHROPLASTY

Abstract

Background: Squeaking in hip arthroplasty is a phenomenon that was described decades ago, but has only been brought back to attention recently. It occurs predominantly in ceramic on ceramic bearings, and has a reported incidence from less than 1% to 21%. The cause and the implication of squeaking are still unknown and many factors have been suggested to contribute. This study has looked into the patient factors to investigate if any clinical features are associated with an increased risk of squeaking.

Methods: All primary total hip arthroplasties with ceramic on ceramic bearing that were performed at our unit were reviewed and all squeaking hips presented are included in the study. Patient demographics and clinical outcome data were analysed and compared with matched controls from the silent hips.

Results: Between 1997 and 2008, 3375 primary hip arthroplasties in 3182 patients with ceramic on ceramic bearing were performed in our unit. Seventy one hips (2.1%) presented with squeaking on direct questioning and self reporting. Those patients were found to be taller, heavier and younger. They also have a significantly higher post-operative range of hip motion and higher Harris hip score when compared to matched controls. There was no difference in the satisfaction score. Only 4 patients (5.6%) presented with pain as well as squeaking, and 2 (2.8%) resulted in revision surgery for problematic squeaking.

Conclusions: We present the largest series of squeaking primary hip arthroplasties with ceramic on ceramic bearing to date. A number of patient factors were found to be associated with squeaking. The taller, heavier and younger patients with more flexible and functional hips were at a higher risk, presumably because these patients put greater mechanical demands on their hips. Majority of the patients with squeaking are pain free and there is only a small risk of requiring revision surgery.