COMPARISON OF OUTCOME FOLLOWING EITHER ONE OR TWO SCREWS FOR MEDIAL MALLEOLAR FRACTURE FIXATION

Abstract

Introduction: Ankle fractures are common in trauma practice. Traditional teaching has been to use two screws for medial malleolar fixation to achieve better rotational control. However, the evidence for this is limited. This study compares the outcome following either one or two screws for medial malleolar fracture fixation.

Materials and Methods: Retrospective analysis of case notes and x-rays of all medial malleolar fracture fixations performed between 2002 to 2007. Two groups were formed (group-I and group-II) depending upon the use of either one or two screws, respectively.

Both groups were age and sex matched. Besides patient demographics, fracture pattern according to Dennis–Webber classification, orientation of the medial malleolar fracture, position of screw in relation to fracture, post-operative fracture displacement and union (bony and clinical) were assessed. Patients were also contacted to assess whether they had returned to their pre-injury level of activities.

Results: There were total of 76 patients (group-I had 37 and group-II had 39 patients). The majority were females with age range between 19 and 84 years with involvement of the right ankle mostly.

In group-I, 15 patients had bi-malleolar Dennis-Webber type B fractures, 9 had bi-malleolar Dennis-Webber type C and 10 had tri-malleolar fractures. 3 had uni-malleolar fracture.

In group-II, 20 patients had bi-malleolar Dennis-Webber type B fractures, 9 had bi-malleolar Dennis-Webber type C fractures and there were 5 tri-malleolar fractures. 5 had uni-malleolar fracture.

The fracture orientation in both the groups was mostly horizontal than oblique and the screw placement was at an angle to the fracture in the majority of cases in both of them.

There was no significant difference between the two groups, in terms of clinical union, post-operative fracture displacement and return of patients to their pre-injury level of activity.

Conclusion: Medial malleolar fractures can be efficiently fixed with one screw only, which does not increase the risk of post-operative fracture fragment displacement, compared to using two screws.