DOES EARLY PREOPERATIVE OSTEOARTHRITIS AFFECT OUTCOME AFTER AUTOLOGOUS CHONDROCYTE IMPLANTATION?

Abstract

Purpose: We attempted to identify whether patients with early evidence of osteoarthritis (OA) on their pre-operative radiographs were associated with poorer outcomes after Autologous Chondrocyte Implantation (ACI).

Methods: We retrospectively reviewed radiographs of 94 consecutive patients who underwent ACI and had already had their knee function assessed according to the Modified Cincinatti Score 2 years following surgery. Changes were graded according to The Kellgren and Lawrence (K& L) and the Stanmore grading system. Two independent observers analysed the films to assess the reproducibility and accuracy of these grading systems for assessment of OA in the knee.

Results: Patients were divided into 2 groups; Group A were patients with excellent/good outcome (52 patients), those with fair/poor outcome were Group B (42 patients).13 patients in Group A and 21 patients in Group B had radiographic evidence of OA (p< 0.025). In 34 patients who had OA (mean age 33.6) the increase in Cincinatti score following surgery was minimal (33.5 to 37.5). In 60 patients where there was no evidence of OA (mean age 33.7) the score increased from 40 to 53.4. The inter-observer variation was greater using K& L (Kappa=0.31) compared with the Stanmore grading systems (Kappa=0.72).

Conclusions: Patients with early radiographic evidence of OA are unlikely to gain maximum benefit from ACI. Furthermore, we recommend the use of Stanmore grading system for the assessment of OA as it is more reproducible than the K& L grading system.