CORRELATIONS BETWEEN COMMONLY USED CLINICAL OUTCOME SCALES AND PATIENT SATISFACTION AFTER TKA

Abstract

Patient satisfaction is becoming increasingly important as a crucial outcome measure for total knee arthroplasty (TKA). We aimed to determine how well commonly-used clinical outcome scales correlate with patient satisfaction after TKA. In particular, we sought to determine whether patient satisfactions correlate better with absolute postoperative scores or preoperative to 12-month postoperative changes. Patient satisfaction was evaluated using four grades (enthusiastic, satisfied, noncommittal, and disappointed) for 438 replaced knees that were followed for longer than one year. Outcomes scales used AKS, WOMAC and SF-36 scores. Correlation analyses were performed to investigate the relation between patient satisfaction and the 2 different aspects of the outcome scales: postoperative scores evaluated at latest follow-ups and pre- to postoperative changes. The WOMAC function score was most strongly correlated with satisfaction (correlation Coefficient = 0.45). Absolute postoperative scores were better correlated with satisfaction than the pre- to postoperative changes for all scales. This study demonstrates that patient satisfaction correlates better with patient-derived and disease specific scales (WOMAC) than physician-driven (AKS) or generic (SF-36) measures. The present study also shows that absolute postoperative status is more important pre- to postoperative change when determining patient satisfaction.