Receive monthly Table of Contents alerts from Orthopaedic Proceedings
Comprehensive article alerts can be set up and managed through your account settings
View my account settings
Self-selected walking (Neutral), Toe out walking (10o>
self-selected, velocity +/− 0.1 m/s of self-selected) and Toe in walking (10o
a reduction in the overall knee adduction moment (captured by PC1), a reduction in the late stance magnitude of the knee adduction moment magnitude (captured by PC2 and PC3) and an increase in the early stance knee adduction moment magnitude (captured by PC2) (p<
0.05).
standardization of surgical and post-surgical care resulted in superior care among the SPRINT centres and surgeons and proscription of surgery until after 6 months. Optimizing peri-operative care and avoiding premature re-operation may substantially decrease the need for re-operation in tibial fracture patients.
The ability to mask the surgeons (the proportion of radiographs in which the surgeons were able to correctly identify the implant and the Bang Blinding Index); Surgeons’ ability to accurately rate the quality of reduction in blinded images; Surgeons’ perceptions of difficulties rating the blinded images.
General Attitude of Orthopaedic Surgeon Towards IPV, Attitude of Orthopaedic Surgeon Towards Victims and Batterers and Clinical Relevance of IPV in Orthopaedic Surgery.
Up to 3 follow up mailings were performed to enhance response rates.
femoral bone graft obtained using the RIA {n=10} chronOS washed with RIA filtrate {n=10}and a mixture of these two materials {n=10}.
chronOS (alone) was used as control {n=10}. These materials were implanted into a sub-muscular pouch in athymic rats (to eliminate rejection of the xenograft). Rat serum levels of BMP-2, VEG-F, TGF-β and IL-10 were obtained at days 7, 14, 21 and 28. Rats were sacrificed at day 28 and radiographic and histologic examinations and histomorphometric analyses were performed.
First, to investigate whether a cylindrical, biodegradable load-bearing scaffold, stabilized with an intramedullary (IM) nail, will facilitate early weight bearing in a critical sized canine defect model. The second objective is to investigate if rhBMP-2, transported by the biodegradable carrier, will enhance bone formation and healing across a critical sized canine defect.
To measure the edge angle of the medial (alpha) and lateral (beta) talar dome, curves were adjusted along the medial and lateral talar body and on top of the talar dome measuring the angles in-between. To measure the radius, circles were fitted into the medial and lateral talar dome (rm and rl).
accessory naviculars of adequate size underwent an ORIF (10), and accessory naviculars of smaller size underwent a modified Kidner procedure (7).
Corrective osteotomies and/or soft-tissue procedures were performed concomitantly in nine patients to address pes planus. Pre- and postoperatively, patients were assessed radiographically. Preoperative MRI scans were analyzed to see if there was any correlation between MRI findings and success of ORIF. Patients were evaluated with the AOFAS midfoot clinical rating system (max 100 points).
The current fellowship hiring process is decentralized, poorly functioning, unraveled and generally unfair. It creates anxiety for residents, residency directors, and fellowship directors alike. Residents are facing exploding offers, limited exposure to fellowship programs and, ultimately, an unraveling hiring market. Residents are in favor of changing the current decentralized process into either a more centralized clearing-house system or subspecialty-based match approach. In either system, accountability for both residents and fellowship directors is critical. Both the AOA and AAOS should devote resources to improve the fellowship hiring process.
apply the CLEAR NPT to orthopaedic RCTs across multiple journals from 2004–2005, and survey authors when items in the CLEAR NPT were not reported to determine if they were actually conducted.
We hypothesized that “lack of reporting” did not necessarily correlate with “not being conducted”.
Surgery time
CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Targeting the altered blood flow response to pressure in patients with spinal cord injuries, pharmacologically or mechanically, may lead to a reduction in the incidence of decubital ulcers.
Patients with blunt cervical trauma are at risk for vertebral artery injury, which can result in significant neurological sequalae Antthrombotic therapy can lessen the likilihood of neurological sequalae following a vertebral artery injury Screening for vertebral artery injury following blunt cervical trauma should be done for C1–C3 fractures, fractures through transverse foramen and significant subluxation or dislocation of the cervical spine CT angiogram is an accurate screening method, but should be done only if antithrombotic therapy can be initiated.
The Hb concentration in the deep drain was gradually decreasing over the first 24 hours after the operation when compared to the patient’s Hb which means that the total volume of the drain loss doesn’t mean an equal volume of blood loss. The second drain which was inserted superficial to the iliotibial tract showed blood loss with an average of 11.2% of the total blood loss and this amount is usually missed in calculating the blood loss when using one deep drain only. The average blood loss responsible for the drop of one gram Hb was variable. It was 258 ml when comparing intraoperative blood loss with the immediate postoperative patient’s Hb. This increased to 341 ml when comparing the drain blood with the patient’s Hb 24 hours after the operation due to the above mentioned changes in RBCs concentration in the drain over the first 24 hours postoperatively. IVF has no effect in giving false readings of the Hb
In the Irish orthopaedic unit 42 consecutive hip and knee arthroplasty patients from a single consultant were included. There were 26 women and 16 men with average age of 63.9 years (range 36 to 88 years). The average LOS was 6.5 days (range, 3 to 10 days), with 24 patients going to a rehabilitation facility and 18 directly home.
There was no correlation found between LOS and either comorbidities, social factors or complications, in both groups although one patient had a delayed discharge due to haematoma and wound drainage in the US. Prolonged LOS in both groups was correlated with delays in rehabilitation bed and transportation availability, reported short staffing in hospital and weekend stays.
Both groups were well matched for comparison. The average shorter LOS noted in the US unit appears to be almost entirely attributable to an implemented perioperative care pathway and a more proactive coordinated approach to discharge planning.
Overnight fasting can induce post operative insulin resistance. Insulin resistance is related to infectious morbidity and increased hospital length of stay (HLOS). Previously this concept was only important in diabetic patients. Surgery places the body under metabolic stress and even a short period of fasting will change the metabolic state of the patient. Indeed physical trauma can cause a triad known as the “diabetes of injury”: insulin resistance, hyperglycaemia and glucose intolerance. Preparation for surgery by maintaining a fasted state and catabolic metabolism may have deleterious consequences for the patient.
Previous studies on elective patients has shown that pre operative carbohydrate loading can reduce insulin resistance and mitigate the inflammatory response by immunomodulation. It has not previously been shown to have an effect in the hip fracture population. This particular group of patients are often elderly and require medical and anaesthetic work up. This delay can mean that the patient is kept fasting for prolonged periods and often overnight.
The modes of failure were aseptic loosening (4), progression of osteoarthritis (2), instability (3), infection (2), dislocated insert (1) and persistent pain after UKA (2). Tibia insert exchange was done in one patient and the rest were converted to primary Scorpio and PFC components. Three of the patients had significant defect in femoral condyle. Fourteen percent of cases required femoral stem extension or metal wedge augmentation.
Nine of the 14 knees (64%) were followed up for an average of 15 months. The mean WOMAC and SF-36 scores at latest follow up were 33.33 and 63.79 respectively.
Each shear test was then repeated at four different normal loads so as to generate a family of stress-strain graphs. The Mohr-Coulomb failure envelope from which the shear strength and interlocking vales are derived was plotted for each test.
Within the region of Northern Ireland, we have investigated the indications for revision hip procedures, carried out from April 2006 to March 2007. We wanted to establish if the indications of revision surgery are comparable to other national registers.
The best type of stem fixation for revision hip arthroplasty is still controversial with regard to medium and long tem results. We wanted to ascertain the medium term results of revision hip arthroplasty using cemented collarless polished tapered femoral stem.
Periprosthetic fractures after total hip arthroplasty are challenging, with potential difficulties associated not only with the fracture but also with implant loosening and bone loss. The incidence of periprosthetic fractures is gradually increasing. We undertook this study to evaluate the periprosthetic fractures presenting to our unit in terms of mechanism of failure, classification and treatment. Charts of patients with periprosthetic fractures presenting within the past six years were retrospectively analysed for demographic and injury details and corresponding radiographs were reviewed to classify the fracture and follow treatment. 45 fractures were identified, with an average age of 78.3 years. The male to female ratio was 5:4. Only 4 fractures occurred in revision prostheses. Two fractures were intraoperative.
The Vancouver system was used to classify the fractures, which can also form a basis for treatment. Three fractures of Vancouver type A were managed conservatively without complication. Thirteen fractures were Vancouver type B1, 12 of which underwent internal fixation, mostly plate osteosynthesis; two of these subsequently failed. Recent fractures have been stabilised using locking plates, with no recorded failures. Fifteen fractures were Vancouver type B2, 11 of which were greater than 5 years post arthroplasty. Most underwent revision of the femoral component. Five of these patients had reported pain for some time preceding fracture. Seven fractures were Vancouver type B3, all occurring greater than 7 years post arthroplasty. Most underwent femoral revision. Seven fractures were Vancouver type C, all underwent plate fixation without failure.
Although there is variability within the group studied, this series demonstrates gradual standardisation of treatment with use of locking plates and a preferred long revision femoral stem. The reports of pain preceding fracture in a proportion of the Vancouver B2 group prompts greater postoperative surveillance in patients with early signs of femoral loosening.
As the numbers of revision total knee arthroplasty (RTKA) rise, we continually need current information regarding the etiology/modes of failure and functional disability of patients presenting for RTKA. We used a prospective cohort study to assess these fundamental aspects of RTKA.
290 consecutive subjects presenting for RTKA had relevant clinical information, including modes of failure, collected from surgeon-completed documents. Patients themselves also completed quality of life and functional questionnaires, including the SF-36 and WOMAC Osteoarthritis Index.
Mean patient age was 68.6 years (55 to 79 years). Mean SF-36 and WOMAC score at baseline indicated significant functional disability. The mean time from primary procedure to RTKA was 7.9 years (6 months to 27 years). Our series included 31 percent ‘early’ (under 2 years) revisions and 69 percent ‘late’ revisions. Sepsis was the cause of 10.4 percent revisions. The tibia needed revision in 78 percent, femur in 71 percent and patella in 31 percent of cases. The predominant modes of failure (non-exclusive frequency values as patients could have more than one cause) were (in percentages): instability (28.9), malalignment (27.5), tibial osteolysis (27.5), polyethylene wear (24.5), femoral osteolysis (22.5) and tibial loosening (22.2).
These patients are relatively young, and considerably disabled by their failed primary procedure. Many modes of failure are within surgical control and direct us toward improved techniques and approaches. Other modes confirm the need for continued development of implants and materials. Information gained here will allow better formulation of measures and resource allocation that may prevent RTKAs.
46.4% of the cases had positive cultures from the deep tissues. Staphylococcus species were responsible for 62% of cases, while enterococci, pseudomonas, streptococcus pneumonia, and MRSA have similar occurrences. The mean total cost per case was € 21,895 (13,597 for aseptic revision) a 61% increase in cost for cases revised for non septic reasons.
51(19.77%) from the first group reported stiffness of toes at 6 weeks review whilst only 3(3.61%) out of the second group.18 (6.98%) reported discomfort and stiffness of the hip from the first group in comparison to only 2(2.25%) patients in group two. From the first group 27(10.47%) reported knee stiffness while only one patient in the second group. The incidence of clinically significant low back pain was 12(4.65%) in the first group and 5(5.61%) patients in the second group.
Ankle intra-articular pathology after acute injury is common and often under-diagnosed. While the majority of soft tissue injuries improve with rehabilitation, up to 40% of patients experience chronic pain, stiffness or instability. MRI is increasingly used in the investigation of such patients; however interpretation of MRI findings requires specialist expertise. The aim of this study was to determine the diagnostic potential of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) compared to ankle arthroscopy.
Forty consecutive patients presenting with ankle pain of at least three months duration were included in the study. This cohort of patients underwent magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and then arthroscopy.
Pre-operative MRI reported findings were compared with the arthroscopic findings. The sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive value of MRI for diagnosing ankle pathology was then assessed. The 2 senior authors reviewed the MRI scans and their findings correlated.
The average time between injury and presentation to our service was 2.2 years. This interval ranged from 3 months to 10 years. 51% of patients gave history of inversion and/or plantar flexion injuries. 14 % had symptoms, which persisted following an ankle fracture. At arthroscopic evaluation 23 patients had osteochondral defects and 37 had evidence of synovitis. MRI identified 50% of the osteochondral defects with sensitivity 50% and specificity 100%. Synovitis was not identified in any of the patients on preoperative MRI but 33% of the preoperative MRI did demonstrate a joint effusion.
Despite the high rate of discordance between MR imaging and arthroscopy in our study MRI still remains a useful adjunct in the investigation of ankle pain. The implications for practice and further study are discussed.
During a 3-year period in which 348 hallux valgus correction were performed, 10 patients with symptomatic hallux valgus deformity underwent triple osteotomies. All the 10 patients had intermetatarsal 1–2 angle of over 20 degrees and DMAA angle of over −10 degrees and no degenerative changes at MTP joint. They were studied retrospectively at an average follow-up of 9.7 months.
The surgical technique comprised a proximal open medial based wedge first metatarsl osteotomy and a distal closing medial based wedge first metatarsal osteotomy and a closing medial basal wedge phalangeal osteotomy. The average age of the patients at the time of surgery was 53.4 years.
At final follow-up, the average hallux valgus correction measured 22 degrees and the average intermetatarsal 1–2 angle correction was 9 degrees postoperatively. The DMAA averaged −4 degrees postoperatively the average length of the 1st metatarsal was shorter 2.43 mm postoperatively.
The average of the (VAS FA) score was improved from 55 preoperatively to 83.9 postoperatively.
8 patients were very satisfied, one patient was satisfied and one patient was unsatisfied. A hallux valgus deformity with an increased 1–2 intermetatasal angle over 20 degrees can be successfully treated with triple first ray osteotomies that maintain articular congruity of the the first metatarsophalangeal joint.
Injection of the plantar fascia under general anaesthesia is a safe and effective method for the relief of conservatively unmanageable heel pain due to plantar fasciitis. A larger patient population and a greater than 1 year follow up would be helpful to determine the long term benefits & outcomes of this treatment.
This multicentre audit assessed the total Tip Apex Distance (TAD) of sliding hip screws for intertrochanteric hip fractures in the 3 fracture hospitals in Northern Ireland (Ulster Hospital, Royal Victoria Hospital & Altnagelvin Hospital). Patient demographics and anaesthetic information was also reviewed. A sample of 140 patients with adequate screening films (39 UHD, 50 RVH & 51 Altnagelvin) were selected. The TAD was measured on AP & lateral screening films and compared to the standard of 25mm or less (total in 2 views) as recommended by Baumgaertner et al (JBJS (Am) 1995).
All 3 hospitals had an average of under 25mm (22.1, 19.9 & 19.6mm respectively) with overall average of 20.4mm, and a TAD of 25mm or less was achieved in 66.7%, 82% & 80.4% in respective hospitals (77.1% of patients overall). No patients were readmitted due to cut-out, despite 22.9% of patients having a TAD greater than 25mm. Among patients with TAD over 25mm the average TAD was 30.1mm
Demographics showed a 77.8% of patients to be female, with a slight predominance of left sided injuries. Most patients were of ASA grading 2–3. Anaesthetic method preferences varied between hospitals. Patients with TAD over 25mm were not significantly different from those with TAD of 25mm or less in age, gender, ASA or operated side.
Following the recent publication in April 2007 of NICE guidelines on venous thromboembolism, we report our practice and experience of VTE in adult hip and knee arthroplasty.
It is generally agreed that the 2 major complications of VTE are sudden death as a result of pulmonary embolism and post thrombotic syndrome. NICE guide-lines make 2 assumptions:
That chemical and mechanical prophylaxis can reduce these complications That Orthopaedic surgery, in particular elective Primary Joint Replacements are particularly high risk procedures with respect to these 2 complications.
We performed a retrospective analysis of consecutive patients undergoing primary total knee and hip replacement from November 2002 to November 2007. In total 2050 patients had total knee replacement and 2203 patients had total hip replacement. All patients were treated at one specialist centre under the care of one surgeon. Data was complete and accurate for all patients at 90 days post-operatively.
Standard practice was the use of 150mg Aspirin from Day 1 post-operatively for a total of six weeks combined with spinal anaesthesia and early mobilisation.
The overall rate for Fatal Pulmonary embolism 0.07% (3/4253), overall death rate 0.31%(13/4253), for treated non-fatal PE 0.66% (28/4253) and for treated above knee DVT was 0.33%(14/4253).
At present patients who require shoulder hemiarthroplasty in our unit routinely have two units of blood cross matched pre-operatively. Our observation was that blood transfusion rarely required after open shoulder surgery. We therefore decided to look at the crossmatch-transfusion ratio for the following procedures in our department; elective shoulder hemiarthroplasty, reverse total shoulder replacement, open rotator cuff repair, shoulder hemi-arthroplasty for trauma, open reduction and internal fixation of proximal humeral fractures.
We undertook a retrospective review of all such patients during the period of 2002 to 2005. All trauma and elective surgery included. Hospital notes were analysed to include age, sex, pre operative haemoglobin level, blood transfusion intra-operatively and post-operatively.
A total of 211 patients were included in the study. There were 63 elective procedures and 148 trauma procedures during that period. No patient required intra-operative or post operative transfusion. Three patients who required transfusions post operatively, due to other associated injury (liver laceration x1, spleen injuries x 2) were excluded from the study. Crossmatch-transfuison ratio was > 2.
There should be a clear equation between cross-match and its use, intra-operatively and post operatively. This study highlighted unnecessary cross-matching for shoulder operations in our unit which puts extra pressure on the laboratory staff, the blood bank and also has financial implications. We recommend, Standardised approach for pre-operative cross match practise, pre-operative group and screen to detect atypical antibodies and efficient hospital pathology services, to provide blood for transfusion within specified time, for atypical antibody negative blood, should it require.
Hurler syndrome is an autosomal recessive metabolic storage disease, with specific musculoskeletal abnormalities termed dysostosis multiplex. Haematopoietic Stem Cell Transplant (HSCT) increases life expectancy, but its effects on the progression of dysostosis multiplex are less certain. We detail the ongoing follow up of 23 patients (range 2.6 – 20.7 years) at a mean of 8.5 years after successful HSCT, the largest series reported in the literature to date.
All patients were clinically examined at an annual multidisciplinary clinic, and serial radiological studies were reviewed to assess development and management of hip dysplasia and genu valgum.
All patients demonstrated characteristic acetabular dysplasia and failure of ossification of the superolateral femoral head. Thirteen patients have undergone hip containment, including eight bilateral combined pelvic osteotomy and femoral derotation, at a mean of 4.4 years. Mean preoperative acetabular angle was 34 ± 5°. Long term follow up of older patients (> 8 years, mean 9.9 years after surgery) demonstrated adequate femoral head cover, with mean centre-edge angle of 40 ± 5° (range 32 – 48°). More recently, isolated innominate osteotomy has been used.
Genu valgum of variable severity due to failure of ossification of the lateral aspect of the proximal tibial metaphysis was more variable, and seven patients underwent medial epiphyseal stapling at a mean of 7.8 years, decreasing tibiofemoral angle by a mean of 7°. Staple dislodgment, however, was seen in four children. All patients remain independently mobile, but hip stiffness and valgus knees contribute to the early fatigue and hip discomfort seen in older children.
Based on our series, we conclude that hip containment surgery has been successful at least into early adolescence, with overall mobility being well preserved. We recommend plating of the proximal tibial epiphysis. Further follow up will monitor the effectiveness of orthopaedic intervention.
We aimed to perform a randomized prospective study to determine the outcome of Buried versus Exposed K wire placement.
Patient details were collected and follow up was performed at 2 and 6 weeks post op.
Infection at pin sites was measured on a 0 to 6 point scale. Superficial radial nerve was assessed with light touch and 2 point discrimination. EPL tendon was also assessed for damage.
No damage to EPL tendon was recorded in either group at 6/52 follow up.
There was a slight increased rate of superficial infection at exposed pin sites noted at 2/52 follow up however this was not seen at the 6/52 follow up. Superficial radial nerve damage was noted in one case only. This was in the buried k wire group and occurred following removal of the radial wire.
Thus it would appear that leaving k wires exposed is the safer and more convenient method of K wiring the displaced distal radius fracture.
In a prospective randomized trial, we divided a group of patients with a clinically suspicious, although radiographically normal, acute fracture of the scaphoid into 2 groups, 1 treated with a cast (group I), the other with a splint (group II). There were 14 patients in group I, and 18 in group II. Patients were reviewed at 2,6, and 12 weeks for range of movement, grip strength, pain and satisfaction rating. Work disability costs were also calculated for both groups. Patients in group II had better range of movement and grip strength at 2 weeks, although complained of more pain. There was no difference in range of movement, grip strength, or pain at 6 or 12 weeks. Group II was more satisfied at 2 weeks, although not at 6 or 12 weeks. Group I required more time off work, and disability costs were significantly higher [€15,209 per person compared to €3,317 per person]. We recommend that all patients, with only a clinical suspicion of a fractured scaphoid, should have a short period of splint immobilization until symptoms resolve, or until further investigations reveal a fracture which can be appropriately treated. This policy is cost efficient and improves the short term outcome.
In the past autogenous bone grafting has been the mainstay of treatment in patients with fracture non-unions. The harvesting of bone graft is, however associated with significant donor site morbidity. Recently there has been much interest in the use of synthetic osteo-inductive agents.
We performed a review series of thirteen patients with sixteen non-unions in whom op-1, a bone morphogenetic protein (available commercially as Osigraft) was used to promote union.
This was a retrospective chart review and union was judged on the basis of radiological union as reported by the radiology department and documented by the surgeon responsible and clinical union based on the ability to weight bear with minimal or no pain as documented in the patients’ records.
At nine months twelve of sixteen non-unions (75%) had achieved clinical and radiographic union. Three patients had repeat grafting, all of whom went on to union. Mean time to grafting after initial treatment for all patients was 8.9 +/−6.1 months. Mean time to union was 5.1 +/− 1.6 months.
We conclude that the use of osteo-inductive agents, in particular BMP-7 (op-1) results in good clinical and radiological outcomes. What remains unclear is whether they are superior to the traditional approach of autogenous grafting.
We compared all cases of closed intra-articluar fractures (AO types C2 and C3) fixed by the method described above in a one year period (June 2004 – June 2005) – Group 1 (n = 26), with the immediate previous one year period (June 2003 – June 2004) of matched closed fracture pattern fixed by formal open reduction and internal fixation – Group 2 (n = 16).
Mean follow up was 26 months. All bony and soft tissue complications were recorded. A specific assessment of outcome was undertaken using the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Score (AOFAS). Scoring was undertaken on two separate occasions at a mean of 9 and 24 months post operatively.
Nonunions and segmental bone defects associated with infection are challenging problems faced by the orthopaedic surgeon. Antibiotic cement-coated (ACC) interlocking nails, prepared in the operating theatre using nails and materials generally available, can be used to treat these conditions. Two different types of moulds can be used (reusable or disposable).
Lateral patellar dislocation is a common cause of acute traumatic haemarthrosis in young active patients, usually occurring during sporting activites. However, patellar dislocation is usually transient with patients often unaware it has occurred. Often magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) offers the first diagnosis. Most patellar dislocations are treated conservatively with an emphasis on early return to movement.
We report on a series of 30 patients who were diagnosed as having had a transient patellar dislocation by MRI from December 2001 to October 2007 as evidenced by the characteristic countercoup pattern of bone bruising seen on the lateral femoral condyle. In addition to the patellar findings, the images were reviewed with specific reference to the medial collateral ligament, a heretofore undescribed concomitant injury.
During the study period, 30 patients (26 males, 4 females) were diagnosed on MRI as having had transient patellar dislocation. The mean age (mean +/− standard deviation) of the cohort was 23.1+/−6.1 years (range:14 – 36 years). In all but one case, normal anatomical alignment had been restored. In addition to multiple patellar chondral findings, the condition of the MCL was commented upon in 29 cases (97%). Of these, 12 (41%) had documented damage to the MCL. These injuries were classified as grade 1 (n=7), grade 2 (n=3) and grade 2/3 as defined by incomplete detachment of the MCL from the medial femoral condyle (n=2).
These results serve to highlight the co-existence of MCL injuries with patellar dislocation to a relatively high incidence. This injury should be suspected and examined for in the case of prolonged symptoms after dislocation. In addition, the current vogue for early rehabilitation needs to be regarded with some circumspection.
We used the SF-36 score as a surrogate marker of overall subjective health and quality of life. The average preoperative SF-36 score was 50.93 (5 to 94.4). The average SF-36 score at 1st Joint Review Clinic visit was 77.55 (23.77–100). This demonstrates an average improvement of 24.44 (−17.69 to 59.75)
As a measure of arthritis severity we will use the WOMAC 3.0 score as a surrogate. The average preoperative WOMAC score was 52.95 (4–92) and the average WOMAC score at 1st Joint Registry Review was 16.11 (0–75). This demonstrates an average decrease in WOMAC score of 34.46 (−29 to 83)
142 patients experienced significant postoperative morbidity consisting of 24 myocardial infarctions, 46 respiratory tract infections, 33 urinary tract infections, 3 cerebral vascular accidents and 36 exacerbations of congestive cardiac failure. There was no correlation between morbidity and location or type of fracture. The mean age (86.1 yrs) and length of stay (26 days) was greater in the morbidity group (p< 0.05). The overall post operative in-patient mortality rate was 9%, rising to 50% in those who suffered a myocardial infarction and 33% in those with exacerbations of congestive cardiac failure.
Metastatic bone disease is increasing in association with ever improving medical management of osteophylic malignant conditions. The precise timing of surgical intervention for secondary lesions in long bones can be difficult to determine. This paper aims to validate a classic scoring system.
All radiographs were examined twice by 3 orthopaedic oncologists and scored according to the Mirels’ scoring system. The Kappa statistic was used for the purpose of statistical analysis.
The results show agreement between observers (κ=0.35–0.61) for overall scores at the 2 time intervals. Inter-observer agreement was also seen with subset analysis of size (κ=0.27–0.60), site (κ=0.77–1.0) and nature of the lesion (κ=0.55–0.81). Similarly, low levels of intra-observer variability were noted for each of the 3 surgeons (κ=0.34, 0.39, 0.78 respectively).
These results validate the Mirels’ scoring system across a wide spectrum of malignant pathology. We continue to advocate its use in the management of patients with long bone metastases.
Total Elbow arthroplasty can be a valuable treatment option in the painful or stiff elbow but outcomes have been disappointing previously. The history of total elbow arthroplasty has been disappointing in the past. Implants initially were a coupled articulation and were a rigid hinge. There was then a move to resurfacing type of designs although there was an issue with instability postoperatively with these implants. The semiconstrained coupled implant was developed in the mid 1970s by Coonrad. The idea behind the implant was that the loose polyethylene coupling provides inherent stability while decreasing the amount of loosening that was seen with the rigid hinge implants previously. We are reporting our results of our experience with a single type of semiconstrained implant that has been used in our unit since 1999.
A semiconstrained total elbow arthroplasty was performed in thirteen patients over a period of 7 years period in our unit. Mean age at time of surgery was 60 years (44–70) M:F ratio 11:2. The aetiology of the joint pathology was Rheumatoid Arthritis (n= 10), psoriatic arthritis (n= 2) & posttraumatic (n =1).
The patients were followed up for a mean duration of 4.5 years. They were assessed for range of motion, Mayo elbow function scores and radiographic evaluation and complication rate. 9 of the 13 elbows had a good to excellent result. There were 5 complications overall. There was two ulnar neuropathies that eventually resolved and one ulnar component that had to be revised 2 weeks after initial insertion. 3 had condylar fractures none of which required further operation. One patient had evidence of radiographic loosening but was asymptomatic.
In our experience the semiconstrained total elbow replacement is a valuable option in the treatment of painful stiff the elbow.
We also present the reasons for delay at each stage including transfer delays, medical delays and limited emergency theatre availability.
Epigenetic DNA de-methylation at specific CpG promoter sites is associated with abnormal synthesis of matrix-degrading enzymes in human osteoarthritis (Arthritis Rheum 52:3110–24), but the mechanisms that trigger or cause loss of DNA methylation are not known. Since inflammatory cytokines are known to induce abnormal gene expression in cultured chondrocytes, we wanted to know whether this induction also involved loss of DNA methylation. If so, the abnormal gene expression would be permanent and transmitted to daughter cells rather than a simple up-regulation. To test this hypothesis, we selected IL-1b as the abnormally expressed gene. Healthy chondrocytes, harvested from human femoral head cartilage following a fracture, were divided into five groups: non-culture; control culture; culture with the de-methylating agent 5-aza-deoxycyti-dine (5-aza-dC); culture with the inflammatory cytokine IL-1b; or with TNF-a/oncostatin M. Total RNA and genomic DNA were extracted at confluency, relative mRNA expression of IL-1b was quantified by Syb-rGreen-based real-time PCR, and a method for quantifying the percent of cells with DNA methylation at a specific CpG site was developed (Epigenetics 2: 86–95).
The methylation status of 16 CpG sites in the promoter of IL-1b was determined by the bisulfite modification method. The two CpG sites important for the epigenetic regulation of IL-1b were at -247bp and -290bp, the latter was selected to quantify DNA methylation. 5-aza-dC halved DNA methylation, which resulted in 4–8 fold increases in IL-1b expression; showing that DNA de-methylation per se increases gene expression. However, far greater effects were seen with the inflammatory cytokines. IL-1b increased its own expression 50–100 fold, whereas TNF-a/OSM increased IL-1b expression 500–1000 fold. DNA methylation varied inversely, IL-1b reducing methylation to ~15% and TNF-a/OSM abolishing DNA methylation almost completely.
This is the first demonstration that inflammatory cytokines have the capacity to cause loss of DNA methylation. We also confirmed previous work that IL-1b induces its own expression in healthy chondrocytes, thus setting up a dangerous positive feed-back mechanism. If true in vivo, both the auto-induction and the heritable expression of IL-1b by a growing number of chondrocytes could explain the unrelenting progression of osteoarthritis.
Approximately 5 – 10% of all bone fractures are associated with impaired healing. It is thought that regenerative medicine has the potential to improve on existing treatments for non-union fractures, and the European market for such treatments is projected to reach £2.2 billion in 2010. The use of scaffolds for the delivery of both growth factors and human Marrow Stromal Cells (hMSCs) is thought to be a promising approach. It may be desirable to promote proliferation and chemotaxis of hMSCs at the defect site shortly after implantation, and differentiation in the longer term. This is likely to require a dual delivery system, capable of releasing multiple drugs with different release profiles. Our aim has been to develop a polymer scaffold capable of releasing bioactive molecules that are able to direct the differentiation of primary hMSCs down the osteoblastic lineage. We have examined two mutually compatible drug delivery systems: collagen coating for short term release, and polymer encapsulation for longer term release.
Polymer scaffolds were manufactured and coated with Type I Collagen containing BMP-7. hMSCs from three different patient sources were exposed to the scaffolds for 14 days. The cells were then histochemically stained for Alkaline Phosphatase (ALP) and photographed. The areas of ALP staining were then normalised against the total cell count.
Normalised ALP expression was increased compared to the controls for three different patients (‘110 ± 39% SE, n=6, p=0.005’, ‘540 ± 270% SE, n=6, p=0.001’, and ‘32 ± 17% SE, n=6’). Scaffolds were also manufactured either with 1,25 Vitamin D3 (another active compound) in a coating of Collagen, or encapsulated using proprietary methodologies. It was found that both treatments significantly increased normalised Alkaline Phosphatase expression within the 14d experimental period demonstrating release of the active 1,25 Vitamin D3 (’88 ± 37% SE, n=6, p=0.012’ and ‘100 ± 32% SE, n=6, p=0.012’ respectively).
Our findings suggest that, subject to future testing and development, such bioactive scaffolds could form the basis for a dual drug delivery system, suitable for applications in bone regenerative medicine.
Total hip arthroplasty (THA) wear debris induced macrophage expression of pro-inflammatory cytokines has been associated with osteolysis both in vitro and in animal and human subjects. Interleukin-1 receptor antagonist (IL-1RA) is an anti-inflammatory cytokine which may limit bone destruction. Polymorphisms (SNPs) within the IL-1RN gene are associated with differences in susceptibility to infectious and inflammatory conditions and disorders of bone remodelling. This study investigated the association between the IL-1RA+2018T/C SNP (rs419598) and osteolysis after THA, and with mRNA and protein expression in an in-vitro wear debris-macrophage stimulation assay.
611 North European Caucasians who had received a cemented THA for primary osteoarthritis were genotyped for the IL-1RN+2018 SNP using Taqman methods. 62 subjects with a Charnley THA were selected from the genotyping population. Control subjects had no radiographic osteolysis and the osteolysis group had previously undergone revision surgery for aseptic loosening. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells were extracted and stimulated with endotoxin-stripped titanium particles (TiCL, endotoxin level 0 Eu/ml) and endotoxin-stripped particles with adherent LPS added back (TiAB, endotoxin level 140 Eu/ml); non-stimulated and LPS-stimulated cells were used as negative and positive controls. Cell lysate IL-1RA mRNA levels were assessed by rqRT-PCT following a 3-hour stimulation. Cell supernatant IL-1RA protein levels were assayed after 24 hours stimulation using a multiplex method.
The IL-1RN+2018C allele was underrepresented in patients with osteolysis after THA versus control THA subjects (chi-squared test 5.96, P=0.015). After correction for other risk factors for osteolysis, the adjusted odds ratio for osteolysis associated with carriage of the IL-1RN+2018C SNP was 0.69 (0.48 to 0.99, p=0.048). IL-1RA mRNA expression increased linearly with IL-1RN+2018C allele copy number in gene-dose dependent manner (ANOVA p=0.013). The IL-1RA+2018C allele did not significantly affect IL-1RA protein expression (ANOVA p> 0.05), however a similar trend towards increased levels with increased C allele copy number was observed.
Carriage of the IL-1RA+2018C allele is associated with both a decreased risk of osteolysis after THA and increased IL-1RA mRNA expression in-vitro. The mechanism for this functional effect remains unclear, however these findings support the importance of the IL-1RA in osteolysis and aseptic loosening.
Non-union is poorly understood. It is unknown if multipotent cells are present in non-union tissue or whether the activity of such cells is dysfunctional. Clinically, this is important as it may predict the success of novel therapies such as BMP treatments and cell-transplantation. This study aimed to study the characteristics of cell types present in human fracture non-union tissue, in comparison with bone marrow stromal cells (BMSC) from the patient and other healthy patients.
Non-union tissue was harvested (n=8) from long bones. Cells were isolated enzymatically and cultured in monolayer. BMSC were isolated by density gradient centrifugation of iliac crest biopsies. Their phenotype was assessed by FACS analysis for CD34, 45 and 105 markers. Their comparative growth kinetics was examined, as was their osteogenic and adipogenic capacity following extended culture in defined medium. Cell differentiation status was evaluated using alkaline phosphatase, von Kossa and oil-red O staining. Cell senescence was assessed via cell morphology, senescence associated Beta-galactosidase (SA-Beta)-Gal) activity.
Non-union cells grew in monolayer, but showed different morphologies; many non-union cells contained stress filaments (typical of senescent cells) or were of stellate appearance. In addition, significantly more non-union cells were positive for SA-Beta-Gal activity compared to BMSC (P=0.0006). Growth kinetics showed longer doubling times for cells isolated from non-union tissue when compared to BMSC isolated from the patient. Long term culture of non-union cells showed early growth arrest at passages 3–8. FACS analysis showed isolated cells to be CD34/45 negative and CD105 positive. Both non-union cells and BMSC differentiated along osteogenic and adipogenic lineages to varying extents.
Our novel results show that cells from non-union tissue exhibit senescence in culture. Hence, cell senescence is potentially involved in the aetiopathogenesis of non-unions. Whether or not this senescence has arisen through cell division (during failed repair attempts) or via abnormal biomechanical loading warrants further study. The influence of senescent cells on the healing process also requires investigation. Clearly these cells are able to differentiate into osteoblasts in vitro but may have an aberrant influence on union in vivo.
Activated leukocyte cell adhesion molecule (ALCAM) has been shown to be involved in cell migration and in both homotypic/homophilic adhesion and heterotypic/heterophilic adhesion. It has been shown that a decreased level of ALCAM expression in human breast cancer tissue correlated with a significantly poor prognosis.
Primary breast cancer tissues (n=234) and non-neoplastic mammary tissue (n=34) were collected and patients were routinely followed up clinically after surgery. The immunohistochemical distribution and location of ALCAM was assessed in the normal breast tissue and carcinoma and the level of ALCAM transcripts in the frozen tissue was determined using real-time quantitative PCR. The results were analysed against the clinical data looking principally at the levels in patients with skeletal metastasis but also in relation to the nodal involvement, ER status, Nottingham Prognostic Index and survival.
The immunohistochemical staining intensity shows that the cytoplasmic staining in normal breast tissue is significantly stronger than that in breast cancer tissue (p=0.023) and also the breast cancer tissue from patients who went onto develop skeletal metastasis (p=0.048). The ALCAM transcript levels were the lowest in patient with skeletal metastasis (p=0.0048) compared to those who were disease free. Significantly lower transcript levels were also found the patients who developed local recurrence (p=0.040), and who died from breast cancer (p= 0.0075). Other indicators of poor prognosis show a significant difference: patients with moderate and poor NPI prognosis lower levels than those with a good prognosis (p=0.05, p=0.0089 respectively); and lower in patients with a positive ER status than those ER negative patients (p=0.043).
This study has for the first time shown that the patient who went on to develop skeletal metastasis tended to have the lowest levels of ALCAM transcript in their breast cancers. This fact could be used to provide patient with a more accurate prognosis and identify those who may benefit enhanced monitoring and early medical and orthopaedic treatment.
Regenerative medicine provides the hope for many intractable diseases as a treatment option and the area is currently the subject of intense investigation in academia and industry. Human bone marrow stromal cells (HBMSCs) possess the ability to differentiate into a variety of cell types of the stromal lineage including cells of the osteogenic and chondrogenic lineages. However, the process of in vitro differentiation is usually inefficient, difficult to reproduce in many cases and, to date, unable to produce homogenous cell populations, which is critical for tissue engineering. Epigenetic regulation of gene expression is recognized as a key mechanism governing cell determination, commitment, and differentiation as well as maintenance of those states. The main components of epigenetic control are DNA methylation and histone acetylation. During development, the epigenetic status changes as cells differentiate along specific lineages. We reasoned that epigenetic modifiers might direct the differentiation pathway of HBMSCs towards either osteogenic or chondrogenic lineage. HBMSCs were serum-starved for 24 hours to synchronise the cell cycle, then treated on three consecutive days either with the DNA demethylating agent 5-Aza-deoxycytidine (5-Aza-dC) 1?M, or the histone deacetylase inhibitor Trichostatin A (TSA) 100 nM or a combination of both. After confluency, the cells were grown in pellet culture for 21 days to facilitate formation of an extracellular matrix. 5-Aza-dC increased the amount of osteoid in the pellet by at least 5 fold compared with controls as assessed by histochemistry, whereas TSA enhanced formation of a cartilage matrix. The differentiation was further enhanced by culturing the pellets in osteogenic or chondrogenic media. These studies suggest that loss of DNA methylation stimulates osteogenic differentiation, whereas inhibition of histone deacetylation favours chondrogenesis. Epigenetic changes thus play an important role in HBMSCs differentiation and offer new approaches in skeletal tissue engineering programs. The challenge will be to define the crucial genes in which loss of DNA methylation has taken place or how changes in histone acetylation (and other histone modifications) affect lineage differentiation.
Articular cartilage is attached to subchondral bone but little is known regarding bone-cartilage interactions important for chondrocyte survival. In this study, bovine articular cartilage has been evaluated in vitro to determine if the presence of subchondral bone influences chondrocyte survival. We hypothesised that
Excision of subchondral bone from articular cartilage would increase in situ chondrocyte death in explant culture and, Chondrocyte death could be abrogated by co-culturing articular cartilage with the excised subchondral bone.
Articular cartilage explants (n=132) harvested from the metacarpophalangeal joints of three-year old cows (N=12) were placed into three groups:
subchondral bone excised from articular cartilage (Group A) sub-chondral bone left attached to articular cartilage (Group B) subchondral bone excised, but co-cultured with articular cartilage (Group C).
Explants were cultured in serum-free media over 7 days with or without media changes to assess the effect of potential soluble mediators. Using confocal laser scanning microscopy to image in situ chondrocytes, fluorescent probes to determine cell viability and biochemical assays to detect alterations in the culture media, differences in the chondrocyte responses (cell density, spatial distribution, percentage cell death) and culture medium composition between Groups A, B and C were quantified over time (2.5 hours versus 7 days).
There was no significant change in cell density for Groups A, B and C over 7 days (t-test, p> 0.05). With excision of subchondral bone from articular cartilage (Group A), there was a marked increase in chondrocyte death over 7 days primarily within the superficial zone involving an extensive area of the articular surface (p< 0.05). There was no significant increase in chondrocyte death over the same time period for Groups B and C (p> 0.05). Corresponding increases in the protein content of the culture media for Groups B and C but not for Group A, suggested that the release of soluble factors from subchondral bone may have influenced chondrocyte survival in the superficial zone.
Subchondral bone interacts with articular cartilage in vitro and promotes chondrocyte survival in the superficial zone. These data support the concept of a functional bone-cartilage system in vivo.
Chondrocytes are responsible for the mechanical resilience of cartilage by controlling the synthesis/degradation of the extracellular matrix. In osteoarthritis (OA), increased activity of cytokines/degradative enzymes (e.g. IL-1beta, MMP-13) play a key role leading to matrix breakdown/cartilage loss. Studying early events in OA might identify targets for limiting the deleterious changes to cartilage stability. Human chondrocyte shape in situ is normally elipsoidal/spheroidal however abnormal forms within otherwise macroscopically normal cartilage are present. Changes to cell shape can alter ECM metabolism and thus these abnormal forms might be an early event in OA. We have investigated whether levels of IL-1beta and MMP-13 are altered in human chondrocytes of abnormal morphology.
Tibial plateau cartilage was obtained from patients undergoing knee arthroplasty and only areas graded 0 or 0–1 studied. The shape of fluorescently-labelled in situ chondrocytes was classified by confocal scanning laser microscopy with cartilage depth, and cells characterised as normal (no cytoplasmic processes) or abnormal (one/more cytoplasmic process). Within grade 0 cartilage about 40% of the cells demonstrated abnormal morphology with a reduced proportion in deep zones. Fluorescence immunohistochemistry of antibodies for IL-1beta or MMP-13 was studied in the same cells and quantified. There was an increase in IL-1beta fluorescence with abnormal chondrocytes within the superficial (p=0.033; 21 joints > 190 cells) and deep zones (p=0.001; 8 joints > 100 cells). There were no differences between MMP-13 labelling of normal compared to abnormal chondrocytes within either the superficial or deep zones.
Our results suggest that in relatively non-degenerate cartilage, a proportion of the chondrocyte population demonstrated abnormal morphology and that these cells have elevated levels of IL-1beta but not MMP-13. However, we do not know if chondrocyte shape alters cytokine levels, or vice versa. Additionally, the role of cartilage age is unclear, as although the cartilage samples were relatively normal they were obtained from aged individuals. Nevertheless these results show changes to chondrocyte morphology and increased levels of IL-1beta, and thus presumably matrix catabolism - in relatively normal human articular cartilage, raising the possibility that this is an early event in cartilage degeneration.
Supported by the Wellcome Trust (075753).
Excessive apoptosis has been found in torn supraspinatus tendon1 and mechanically loaded tendon cells2. Following oxidative and other forms of stress, one family of proteins that is often unregulated are Heat Shock Proteins (HSPs). The purpose of this study was to determine if HSPs were unregulated in human and rat models of tendinopathy and to determine if this was associated with increased expression of regulators of apoptosis (cFLIP, Caspases 3& 8).
A running rat supraspinatus tendinopathy overuse model 3 was used with custom microarrays consisting of 5760 rat oligonucleotides in duplicate. Seventeen torn supraspinatus tendon and matched intact subscapularis tendon samples were collected from patients undergoing arthroscopic shoulder surgery. Control samples of subscapularis tendon were collected from ten patients undergoing arthroscopic stabilisation surgery and evaluated using semiquantative RT-PCR and immunohistochemistry.
Rat Microarray: Upregulation of HSP 27 (×3.4) & 70 (×2.5) and cFLIP (×2.2) receptor was noted in degenerative rat supraspinatus tendon subjected to daily treadmill running for 14 days compared to tendons of animals subject to cage activity only. Histological analysis: All torn human supraspinatus tendons exhibited changes consistent with marked tendinopathy. Matched subscapularis tendon showed appearances of moderate-advanced degenerative change. Apoptosis mRNA expression: The expression levels of caspase 3 & 8 and HSPs 27 & 70 were significantly higher in the torn edges of supraspinatus when compared to matched subscapularis tendon and control tendon (p< 0.01). cFLIP showed significantly greater (p< 0.001) expression in matched subscapularis compared to supraspinatus and control tendon. Immunohistochemical analysis: cFLIP, Caspase 3 & 8 and HSP 27 and 70 was confirmed in all samples of torn supraspinatus tendon. Significantly increased immunoactivity of Caspase 3& 8 and HSP 27 & 70 were found in torn supraspinatus (p< 0.001) compared to matched and normal subscapularis. The proteins were localized to tendon cells.
The finding of significantly increased levels of Heat Shock Proteins in human and rat models of tendinopathy with the co-expression of other regulators of apoptosis suggests that Heat Shock Proteins play a role in the cascade of stress activated-programmed cell death and degeneration in tendinopathy.
Resurfacing metal-on-metal hip arthroplasty is currently showing promising clinical results. However there are concerns related to such implants, including the elevated levels of metal ions typically seen in patients. Valuable data can be obtained from explanted prostheses but due to their recent introduction few retrieval studies on resurfacing hip prostheses have been published.
Five ASR hip resurfacing prostheses were revised due to pain. From two patients, head and cup were available for independent explant analysis. In the other three cases only femoral components were available. All were removed from female patients and all were revised to ceramic-on-ceramic hip prostheses. Post-operative radiographic measurements of cup inclination and ante-version were obtained using the EBRA software. The surface roughness values of the articulating surfaces of the explants were measured using a non-contacting profilometer. A co-ordinate measuring machine was used to measure the diameter of the head and the cup and thus the diametral clearance. The same measurements were then taken from a new unused ASR prosthesis and compared. Using elastohydrodynamic theory the minimum effective film thickness of the implant was calculated. In turn this allowed the lubrication regime to be determined.
The average roughness values of the head and the cup of one implant were found to be 0.135microns and 0.058microns respectively, with a diametral clearance of 110microns. These results indicated that, at the time of removal, the prosthesis would have operated in the boundary lubrication regime. Other explants showed evidence of localised contact between the head and the rim of the acetabular cup, and these showed articulating surfaces with typical roughness values of between 0.025microns and 0.050microns. The new ASR had head and cup surface roughness values of 0.010microns and 0.012microns respectively and a diametral clearance of 87microns, implying that a new implant would operate under fluid film lubrication. All cups five were implanted with inclination angles over 45 degrees and anteversion over 25 degrees.
These results suggest that components with high inclination and anteversion angles display greater than expected wear and may operate in boundary rather than fluid film lubrication which may eventually lead to early failure.
Metal-on-metal (MoM) bearing technology, made of cobalt-chromium (Co-Cr) alloys, is being used in anticipation of extending the durability of hip replacements. Increasingly, concern has been expressed that long term exposure to Co2+ and Cr3+ could cause DNA damage and immune dysfunction; specifically a reduction in the circulating number of CD8+ cytotoxic cells. More recently, we reported that Co2+ and Cr3+ affected the differentiation of osteoclast precursors into bone-resorbing osteoclasts. Despite these observations the effects of metal ions on osteoblast activity have been poorly investigated. The aim of the current study was to elucidate the effects of various metal ions on osteoblast activity in vitro.
Cells of the human osteosarcoma cell line SaOS-2 were cultured in the presence of 0, 1, 10 and 100 μM Co2+ and Cr3+. The morphology, viability, cytokine release (TNFalpha, IL-1beta, IL-6, LIGHT, MIP-1alpha and VEGF) and alkaline phosphatase activity were investigated after 24h and 48h in contact with metal ions. Finally the capacity of SaOS-2 to produce and mineralize a new bone matrix was assessed by the Alizarin red method. All experiments were repeated at least 5 times and the differences between each were determined using non-parametric Mann-Whitney test.
Compared to untreated cultures, although the morphology looked normal after 48h, the viability indicated that Co2+ and Cr3+ ions at high concentrations induced some significant and irreversible damages to the osteoblast cells. Interestingly, any of the cytokines investigated were released in contact with metal ions after 24h or 48h. The alkaline phosphatase activity was significantly increased by low concentrations of Co2+ and decreased by high concentrations of Cr3+ after 24h and 48h. Moreover, the degree of mineralization of a new bone matrix in vitro was significantly reduced when the SaOS-2 cells were exposed to high concentrations of Cr3+, but significantly increased when they were exposed to Co2+.
Our results indicated that irreversible damages are caused to the cells as soon as 24h with high concentrations of metal ions. For osteoblasts cells, Co2+ appeared to be less toxic than Cr3+ at high concentrations.
This study was supported by Furlong Research Charitable Foundation
Total disc replacement is an alternative to spinal fusion in treating degenerative disc disease, whilst preserving motion and reducing the risk of subsequent DDD at adjacent levels. Current designs have evolved from technology used in total hip replacements with metal-metal or metal-PE bearing surfaces. These articulating systems may be prone to wear and it is essential the medical engineering community assess their performance using appropriate simulators
Utilising previous Leeds simulation design experience, current knowledge on spinal kinetics and prevailing Standards for spinal testing, a comprehensive set of requirements was generated from which a simulator design was produced. The Leeds Spine wear simulator, developed in conjunction with Simulation Solutions Ltd, incorporates five active degrees of freedom: axial compression, axial rotation, flexion-extension, lateral bending and anterior-posterior displacement. The fifth DOF, unique to the Leeds simulator, is anticipated to be particularly important for the study of mobile bearing devices such as the Charité. Loads and motions are applied by electro-mechanical actuators, providing accurate and precise control without the low band width suffered from pneumatics or contamination from hydraulic systems. This validation study determines the accuracy and precision of the simulator with regards to the degrees of freedom required by the newly published standard ISO 18192-1. Here, loads and motions have to be within ±5% of the maximum value and ±0.5degrees, respectively. The simulator’s response to demand input signals was determined for load and motion using independent measuring devices; a digital inclinometer for motions and load cell for force.
The load calibration was found to be within ±1% of the maximum load within the specified load range of 600–2000N. Flexion-extension, lateral bending and axial rotation were found to be within ±0.5, ±0.3 and ±0.5 degrees respectively, within and beyond the operating ranges specified by ISO.
The Leeds spine wear simulator is the first orthopaedic wear simulator to include electro-mechanical actuators for all active DOF, and the first spinal wear simulator to include a minimum of 5 active DOF. This novel simulator meets the demanding tolerances required by ISO for testing of total disc replacements. Validation of the simulator is currently being undertaken to determine its suitability against explanted devices and debris located within tissues.
The adequacy of cement mantles around some impaction-grafting systems has been criticised yet good clinical results have been reported. This study investigates this contradiction by asking
Does cement mantle thickness affect cement penetration depth? Does cement mantle thickness affect early mechanical stability?
Twelve artificial femora were prepared to simulate cavitary defects. Porcine cancellous bone was morselized. The defect was reconstructed by impaction grafting, using a size 0, 1 or 2 tamp. Bone cement was injected, and a size 0, 1 or 2 Exeter stem inserted. By using all nine tamp/prosthesis combinations, 0–4 mm thick cement mantles were produced. Femora were positioned in a testing machine and loaded with 2500 cycles of 2500 N. Prosthesis subsidence and retroversion were measured. Each femur was sliced transversely and the sections digitised. Solid cement mantle thickness and cement penetration depth were measured using image analysis. Correlation analysis was used to find if tamp/stem mismatch (nominal mantle thickness) influenced actual solid mantle thickness and cement penetration. We then analysed if tamp size, stem size, solid mantle thickness or cement penetration determined stem subsidence and retroversion.
Cement mantles were produced with an average thickness of 1.7–2.2 mm, with largest variations proximally (1.5–2.8 mm). Average cement penetration was 0.3–2.0 mm, with largest variations proximally (0.4–3.5 mm). Thicker solid mantles gave less penetration (r=−0.62). Stem subsidence ranged from 0.4–2.5 mm and correlated significantly with tamp size (r=0.59, p< .05). Better correlations were found with solid mantle thickness (r=0.90, p< 0.05) and cement penetration depth (r=−0.81). Stem retroversion ranged from 0.1–2.0 degrees and correlated with stem size (r=−0.53) but not with tamp size.
Tamp/stem mismatch determined the thickness of the solid cement mantle around impaction-grafted stems, and thinner mantles were associated with deeper cement penetration. Thinner mantles and deeper penetration were associated with reduced stem subsidence. Stem retroversion was associated with stem size only, and larger for thinner stems. Thinner cement mantles will therefore be associated with deeper penetration and reduced stem subsidence upon loading. This association may explain the good long-term results of impaction-grafted Exeter stems, despite deficient solid cement mantles.
Total meniscectomy has been shown to induce osteoarthritic changes in the underlying articular cartilage(AC) and bone in the natural knee (Fairbank 1948; McDermott 2006). This indicates the meniscus plays an important protective role, providing joint congruity and distributing contact forces, hence reducing contact stress. However, no friction and wear studies have been performed on meniscectomy. The aim of this study was to study the tribological response of the medial compartmental natural knee with and without the intact meniscus, under physiological dynamic loading and motion. The effect of normal and reduced loading was investigated.
Eighteen month old bovine medial compartmental knees were used. A pendulum friction simulator (Simulation Solutions, UK) was used to apply a dynamic axial loads with peak loads of 1000N (normal) and 260N (reduced). Flexion-extension of amplitude 23degrees was applied and the experiments ran for 3600 cycles at 1Hz. Lubricant was 25% bovine serum in saline. A 9.4 Tesla MRI (Bruker) scanner and Analyze software (Mayo Clinic, US) were used to calculate wear volumes. A surface profilometer (Talysurf, Taylor-Hobson, UK) was used to measure the surface roughness of the specimen before and after the test.
Coefficient of friction was found to increase with increased loading, with and without meniscus. With meniscus intact, no wear was found on AC and contact stresses were 4.9MPa and 2.8MPa, for normal and reduced loading respectively. On removal of meniscus, friction was higher at both loading conditions and surface fibrillation found on some of the AC surfaces. Contact stresses rose to 17.2MPa and 8.6MPa for normal and reduced loading.
This study has shown for the first time, the direct elevation of the coefficient of friction, immediate surface fibrillation and biomechanical wear of AC upon removal of the meniscus. On removal of meniscus, peak stresses rose and surface damage occurred on AC surfaces. The removal of the meniscus means forces act across smaller areas and contact stresses are increased. Wear is increased due to the subsequent increase in direct solid-solid contact and loss of fluid support due to the unique biphasic nature of AC. This further supports retaining meniscus whenever possible in knee joint surgery.
Numerous in vitro studies have utilised bone models for the assessment of orthopaedic medical devices and interventions. The drivers for this usage are the low cost, reduced health concerns and lower inter-specimen variability when compared to animal or human cadaveric tissues. Given this widespread exploitation of these models the push for their use in the assessment of spinal augmentation applications would appear strong. The aim of the research was to investigate the use of surrogate-bone vertebral models in the mechanical assessment of vertebroplasty.
Nine surrogate-bone whole vertebral models with an open-cell trabeculae configuration were acquired. Initial μCT scans were performed and a bone marrow substitute with appropriate rheological properties was injected into the trabeculae. Quasistatic loading was performed to determine the initial fracture strength in a manner previously used with human cadaveric vertebrae. Following fracture, vertebroplasty was undertaken in which there was a nominal 20% volume fill. Following augmentation the VBs were imaged using uCT and then subjected to an axial load using the same protocol.
The surrogate models had a substantially thicker cortex than that of human osteoporotic vertebrae. During compression, the surrogate-bone models did not exhibit the characteristic ‘toe-region’ observed in the load-deformation profile of cadaveric vertebrae. The mean initial and post-augmentation failure strength of the surrogate vertebrae were 1.35kN ± 0.15kN and 1.90kN ± 0.68kN, respectively. This equates to a statistically significant post-vertebroplasty increase by a factor of 1.38. In comparison with human osteoporotic bone, no significant difference was noted in the relative increase in fracture strength between the artificial and human VB following augmentation.
Despite the apparent equivalence of the strength and stiffness of the artificial vertebrae compared to that of the cadaveric specimens, there are significant differences in both pre- and post augmentation behaviour. In particular, the load-deformation curve shows significant differences in shape particularly at the toe end and in post failure behaviour. There are also issues surrounding where the marrow and cement flows during the injection process thus affecting the final distribution of the cement.
In the mid-1980s we produced and characterised several monoclonal antibodies ‘mAbs 3-B-3(−); 4-C-3, 6-C-3 & 7-D-4) that recognised unique native sulphation motifs in chondroitin sulphate (CS) glycosaminoglycan (GAG) chains on connective tissue proteoglycans (PGs).
These antibodies were shown to specifically locate CS-PGs in the pericellular regions surrounding putative sites where haemopoietic stem cells were undergoing lymphopoiesis in the Bursa of Fabricius of embryonic chicks. In later studies, we also observed immunostaining for some of these mAbs ‘3-B-3(-) & 7-D-4’ in chondrocyte clusters present in tissue sections from late-stage osteoarthritic cartilage from canine and human patients. In a recent study ‘Hayes et al (2008), J. Histochem Cytochem. 56: 125–128’ we have used these anti-CS sulphation motif mAbs to specifically identify stem/chondroprogenitor cells in the surface/superficial zone of hyaline articular cartilage. Furthermore, we used these mAbs in FACS analyses to sort and isolate chondroprogenitor cells for potential pluripotent cell enrichment in tissue engineering/tissue regeneration technologies. We have also used several of these mAbs to identify stem/progenitor cells in different anatomical and functional regions of the tendon; i.e. where the tendon wraps around bone in compressed regions where the cells exhibit a more chondrogenic phenotype and also in the outer zones of the tendon surrounding pericytes where vascularisation occurs. In the developing intervertebral some of these mAbs specifically recognise stem/progenitor cells at the interzone between the outer and inner anulus an also the boundary of the nucleus with the inner annulus, these results indicating their use for stem/progenitor cell identification and isolation in other musculoskeletal tissues. Interestingly, these mAbs also immunostained the pericellular environment (stem cell niche) in the crypts of the gut and the limbus of the eye where stem cells reside. Collectively, this data strongly suggests that these mAbs recognising CS sulphation motifs can be used as biomarkers to identify stem cell niches in numerous tissues of the body and that they can be used for stem/progenitor cell isolation for use in tissue engineering/regeneration procedures.
This work was supported by BBSRC and ARC funding.
Bone allograft use in trauma and orthopaedic surgery is limited by the potential for cross infection due to inadequate acceptable decontamination methods. Current methods for allograft decontamination either put the recipient at risk of potentially pathogenic organisms or markedly reduce the mechanical strength and biological properties of bone. This study developed a technique of sterilization of donor bone which also maintains its mechanical properties.
Whole mature rat femurs were studied, as analogous to strut allograft. Bones were inoculated by vortexing in a solution of pathogens likely to cause cross infection in the human bone graft situation. Inoculated bones were subjected to supercritical carbon dioxide at 250 bar pressure at 35 degrees celsius for different experimental time periods until a set of conditions for sterilization was achieved. Decontamination was assessed by vortexing the treated bone in culture broth and plating this on suitable culture medium for 24 hours. The broth was also subcultured. Controls were untreated-, gamma irradiated- and dehydrated bone. Mechanical testing of the bones by precision three-point bending to failure was performed and the dimensions and cross-section digitally assessed so values could be expressed in terms of stress.
Mechanical testing revealed bone treated with supercritical carbon dioxide was consistently significantly stronger than that subjected to gamma irradiation and bones having no treatment (due to the minor dehydrating effect of the carbon dioxide). Terminal sterilization of bone is achieved using supercritical carbon dioxide and this method maintains the mechanical properties.
The new technique greatly enhances potential for bone allograft in orthopaedic surgery.
Prosthetic joint infection (PJI) is an increasing problem and management commonly involves prosthesis removal with serious consequences. Biofilm-forming staphylococci are the most common causative organisms with Staphylococcus aureus being most virulent and methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) more than doubling the infection mortality rate. Bacterial adhesion is an essential primary event in biofilm formation and infection establishment. The development of a novel combination vaccine programme to prevent staphylococcal PJI by directing antibody against factors involved in adhesion and biofilm formation, and investigation of S. aureus binding-domains as potential vaccine components for adhesion inhibition is described.
Selected target antigens included the S. aureus fibronectin-binding protein (FnBP) and iron-regulated surface determinant (IsdA), which have been shown to be important for infection establishment and predominantly bind to host fibronectin and fibrinogen respectively. Escherichia coli clones harbouring recombinant S. aureus binding-domain DNA sequences were used for expression and purification of antigen domains. In vitro antibody evaluation determined whether immune inhibition of bacteria - ligand binding can significantly impact on attachment to plasma-conditioned biomaterial (in presence of other bacterial ligands).
Adhesion of homologous and heterologous (MRSA PJI isolate) S. aureus to plasma-conditioned steel was significantly reduced (approximately 50 percent average reduction, p < 0.0001) when pre-exposed to anti-rFnBP-A antiserum (with pre-immune serum control) that was 50-fold more dilute than the actual titre from immunisation. Inhibition was related to ligand presence but not staphylococcal Protein A, and reduced adhesion was not observed with the mutant strain, indicating specific inhibitory antibody involvement, and demonstrating for the first time the potential of rFnBP-A for prevention of S. aureus PJI. Adhesion-inhibitory activity was also observed with a purified IgG-fraction of rIsdA antiserum but this activity appeared to be masked by non-IsdA - related interactions when non-IgG - purified antiserum was assessed.
Paratenonitis describes inflammation of the paratenon and commonly presents as an overuse injury. The paratenon is the connective tissue sheath that surrounds tendons - including tendo Achilles, and serves to minimise friction with the outer layer of the tendon, the epitenon. Whilst this conjunction allows the tendon to glide smoothly on muscular contraction, the presentation of paratenonitis typically follows periods of frequent, repetitive musculoskeletal movements; hence, paratenonitis commonly afflicts the elite and, albeit to a lesser extent, amateur athlete. The extent to which friction at the epitenon-paratenon juncture contributes to this tendinopathy remains unclear, and this study is therefore concerned with the coefficient of friction and the lubrication regime.
By using a specially designed and validated apparatus, the in vivo paratenon-epitenon conjunction was approximated using bovine flexor tendon paratenon and a glass disc; this is being an equivalent experimental set-up to that used in other studies exploring soft tissue contacts. Bovine synovial fluid was used to lubricate the conjunction at 37 deg C, and the frictional characteristics were analysed over a range of sliding speeds and loads.
The coefficient of friction was found to generally lie between 0.1 – 0.01. This range suggests that a system of mixed lubrication applies - where the synovial fluid is causing partial separation of the two surfaces. However, when the data is plotted in the form of a Stribeck curve, the trend suggests that boundary lubrication prevails - where lubrication is determined by surface-bound proteins.
The coefficient of friction at the epitenon-paratenon interface appears to be approximately one order of magnitude greater than that typically reported within the healthy synovial joint. Additionally, the synovial joint is thought to exhibit some fluid film lubrication (i.e. total surface separation), whereas the epitenon-paratenon lubrication regime appears to vary only between the inferior mixed and boundary systems - depending on the specific biomechanical conditions. This data would suggest that the coefficient of friction at the epitenon-paratenon interface is relatively high and thus is potentially significant in the incidence of paratenonitis. Such a hypothesis could be of particular interest to sports-medicine and orthopaedic specialists.
There is an ever-increasing clinical need for the regeneration and replacement of tissue to replace soft tissue lost due to trauma, disease and cosmetic surgery. A potential alternative to the current treatment modalities is the use of tissue engineering applications using mesenchymal stem cells that have been identified in many tissue including the infrapatellar fat pad. In this study, stem cells isolated from the infrapatellar fat pad were characterised to ascertain their origin, and allowed to undergo adipogenic differentiation to confirm multilineage differentiation potential.
The infrapatellar fat pad was obtained from total knee replacement for osteoarthritis. Cells were isolated and expanded in monolayer culture. Cells at passage 2 stained strongly for CD13, CD29, CD44, CD90 and CD105 (mesenchymal stem cell markers). The cells stained poorly for LNGFR and STRO1 (markers for freshly isolated bone marrow derived stem cells), and sparsely for 3G5 (pericyte marker). Staining for CD34 (haematopoetic marker) and CD56 (neural and myogenic lineage marker) was negative. {BR}For adipogenic differentiation, cells were cultured in adipogenic inducing medium consisting of basic medium with 10ug/ml insulin, 1uM dexamthasone, 100uM indomethacin and 500uM 3-isobutyl-1-methyl xanthine. By day 16, many cells had lipid vacuoles occupying most of the cytoplasm. On gene expression analyses, the cells cultured under adipogenic conditions had almost a 1,000 fold increase in expression of peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor gamma-2 (PPAR gamma-2) and 1,000,000 fold increase in expression of lipoprotein lipase (LPL). Oil red O staining confirmed the adipogenic nature of the observed vacuoles and showed failure of staining in control cells.
Our results show that the human infrapatellar fat pad is a viable potential autogeneic source for mesenchymal stem cells capable of adipogenic differentiation as well as previously documented ostegenic and chondrogenic differentiation. This cell source has potential use in tissue engineering applications.
0.9% Saline and Hartmann’s are commonly used joint irrigating solutions during articular surgery. The objective of the study was to determine whether the osmolarity of these solutions affects chondrocyte death in mechanically injured articular cartilage.
The osmolarity of 0.9% Saline (285 mOsm) and Hartmann’s (255 mOsm) solutions was varied from 100–600 mOsm by the addition of distilled water or sucrose. Osteochondral explants (rectangular blocks, n=72) harvested from the metacarpophalangeal joints of six different three-year old cows were exposed to prepared solutions of different osmolarity for 2 minutes to allow in situ chondrocytes (cells embedded within their native extracellular matrix) to respond to the altered osmotic environment. Explants were then mechanically injured through the full thickness of articular cartilage with a fresh scalpel and incubated in the same solution for 2.5 hours. Using confocal laser scanning microscopy (CLSM) and fluorescent probes to determine cell viability, percentage cell death (PCD, 100 × number of dead cells/number of dead and live cells) was quantified within the full thickness of mechanically injured articular cartilage as a function of solution osmolarity.
Cell death was localised to the superficial zone (first 100 microns from the articular surface) of injured cartilage for explants exposed to the control 0.9% Saline (285 mOsm) and Hartmann’s (255 mOsm) solutions, with relative sparing of the middle and deep zones (analysis of variance (ANOVA), p< 0.05). Compared to the control explants exposed to 0.9% Saline, PCD in the superficial zone was greatest for the low osmolarity (100 mOsm) saline solution and least for the high osmolarity (600 mOsm) saline solution (ANOVA, p=0.04). PCD in the superficial zone significantly decreased for explants exposed to 600 mOsm solutions of 0.9% Saline and Hartmann’s, compared to their respective control solutions (p< 0.05 for paired comparisons). There was no significant difference in the PCD between 600 mOsm solutions of 0.9% Saline and Hartmann’s (p=0.5).
Increasing the osmolarity of 0.9% Saline and Hartmann’s solutions is chondroprotective in a surgically relevant model of mechanical cartilage injury. These experiments have important clinical relevance for the design of irrigation solutions during arthroscopic and open articular surgery.
Articular cartilage has limited regenerative potential. Regeneration via autografts or cell therapy is clinically efficacious but the extent of regenerative success depends upon use of an appropriate cell source. The aim of this study was to compare the proliferative and chondrogenic potentials of three human cell types (human bone marrow stromal cells - HBMSCs, neonatal and adult chondrocytes) commonly used in cartilage tissue engineering.
HBMSCs, neonatal and adult chondrocytes (passage 2) were cultured in basal and chondrogenic media. At 2, 4 and 6 days, the cells were analysed for morphology and doubling time. Alkaline phosphatase specific activity (ALPSA) was quantified for each group at 2, 4 and 6 weeks. Chondrogenic potential of each cell type was assessed via a pellet culture model. Cryosections were stained with Alcian blue/Sirius Red.
HBMSCs showed either elongated or polymorphic phenotypes, with a doubling time of 40 h. Neonatal chondrocytes showed a uniform spindle shape and had the shortest doubling time (16 h). Adult chondrocytes, were also spindle shaped, though slightly larger than the neonatal cells, with a longer doubling time of 22 h. Expression of ALPSA in basal media was of the order HBMSCs > adult chondrocytes > , neonatal chondrocytes. In chondrogenic culture, this order changed to adult chondrocytes > HBMSCs > neonatal chondrocytes. In 3D pellet cultures, all three cell types stained positive for Alcian Blue and showed the presence of chondrocyte-like cells enclosed in lacunae.
This comparative study suggests that neonatal chondrocytes are the most proliferative with lowest ALP expression. However, in terms of clinical applications, HBMSCs may be better for cartilage regeneration given their lower ALP expression under chondrogenic conditions when compared with adult chondrocytes under the same conditions. The study has provided information to inform clinical cell therapy for cartilage regeneration.
Rotator cuff tendons are typically reattached to the proximal humerus using either transosseous sutures or suture anchors. Their primary mode of failure is at the tendon bone interface 1. Surgical adhesives are used to bond cartilage, tendons and bone, and to close wounds. In an attempt to increase the tendon-bone interface we investigated the addition of a novel adhesive secreted from a species of Australian frog (Notaden bennetti) 2 to different methods of rotator cuff repair.
Forty two fresh frozen sheep infraspinatus tendons were repaired using 3 different techniques: transosseous sutures; two Mitek RC Quickanchors with 1 suture per anchor and two Opus Magnum anchors with 1 suture per anchor all using a mattress stitch configuration. In each group 7 shoulders were repaired with the addition of a small amount of frog glue to the infraspinatus footprint while 7 were used as control with no adhesive. Mechanical testing was performed using a mechanical tensile testing machine.
The strongest construct in the control groups was the Mitek suture anchors (mean 86±5 N) followed by the Opus suture anchor (69±6N) and transosseous repair (50±6N). This proved significant (p< 0.05) between both metallic anchors and the transosseous repair.{BR}The addition of frog glue resulted in a significant increase in load to failure and total energy required until failure in all repair techniques (p< 0.01). There was a 2 fold increase in load to failure of both the Opus Magnum (143±8N) and Mitek RC Fastin (165N±20 N) anchors while the transosseous repair (86± 8 N) had a 1.7 fold increase in its load to failure.
This data suggests that:
suture anchor fixation is a stronger construct requiring a larger amount of total force to fail than transosseous repair using a one suture repair technique, that the addition of an adhesive to the tendon-bone interface significantly enhances both ultimate load and total energy required to failure in all repair types.
The unique properties of this frog glue (strong, flexible, sets in water and biocompatibility) may ultimately lead to the production of a useful adjunct for rotator cuff repair in humans.
Anteromedial Osteoarthritis of the Knee (AMOA) is a distinct phenotype of OA. Within this pattern of disease, the anterior third of the medial tibial plateau exhibits full thickness cartilage loss. The middle third has damaged partial thickness cartilage, and the posterior third has retained cartilage, which is seen on macroscopic visual assessment to be normal. This study investigates the molecular features of progressive severities of cartilage damage within this phenotype.
Ten medial tibial plateau specimens were collected from patients undergoing unicompartmental knee replacements. The cartilage within the area of macroscopic damage was divided into equal thirds: T1(most damaged), to T3 (least damaged). The area of macroscopically undamaged cartilage was taken as a 4th sample, N. The specimens were prepared for histological (Safranin-O) and immunohistochemical analysis (Type I and II Collagen, proliferation and apoptosis). Immunoassays were undertaken for Collagens I and II and GAG content. Real time PCR compared gene expression between areas T and N.
There was a decrease in OARSI grade across the four areas, with progressively less fibrillation between areas T1, T2 and T3. Area N had a grade of 0 (normal). The GAG immunoassay showed decreased levels with increasing severity of cartilage damage (p< 0.0001). Proliferation and apoptosis, as expected, were increased in the more damaged areas. There was no significant difference in the Collagen II content or gene expression between areas. The Collagen I immunohistochemistry showed increased staining within chondrocyte pericellular areas in the undamaged region (N) and immunoassays showed that the Collagen I content of this macroscopically and histologically normal cartilage, was significantly higher than the damaged areas (p< 0.0001). Furthermore, real time PCR showed a significant increase in Collagen I expression in the macroscopically normal areas compared to the damaged areas (p=0.04).
We conclude that in this phenotype the Collagen I increase, in areas of macroscopically and histologically normal cartilage, may represent very early changes of the cartilage matrix within the osteoarthritic disease process. This may be able to be used as an assay of early disease and as a therapeutic target for disease modification or treatment.
Soft tissue balance is known to be an important factor for the success of Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA). This is of particular relevance in the surgical management of a valgus knee which has both bony and soft tissue abnormalities which need addressing. The correction of instability, particularly in severely valgus knees is essential to post operative outcome as instability is often a component of pre-operative functional disability. Traditional surgical techniques involve soft tissue releases and bony cuts to achieve the correct balance. Evaluation of balance is currently based on subjective intra-operative clinical assessment, or the feel of the knee. More recently, an instrument to objectively measure soft tissue balance following bony cuts has been developed. Soft tissue releases using this instrument may be extensive.
502 patients aged 45–90 years underwent 522 Kine-max TKAs, performed by seven surgeons in five centres between October 1999 and December 2002. Soft tissue releases were recorded and objective soft tissue balance recorded using a balancer device. Independent observers assessed patients using 3 outcome measures for a minimum of 12 months. Pre-operative alignment was divided into 6 groups according to the degree of varus or valgus deformity (mild, moderate, severe varus or valgus).
There is a significant difference in the improvement of the knee scores between the severely valgus knees and all varus knees (ANOVA p=0.000). Significant differences were found between pre-operative pain scores, knee scores and medio-lateral stability between severely varus and severely valgus knees (ANOVA p=0.029, p=0.000 & p=0.000 respectively).
Knees with severe valgus deformities have significantly worse pre operative scores and show greater improvement with equivocal post-operative outcome, when compared to those with severe varus deformity. In addition to pain relief, is the correction of instability the key to this improvement in this group of patients?
Injections of hyaluronic acid solutions, often known as visco-supplements, into the joints of patients suffering from osteoarthritis are an accepted therapy. In most replacement joints, wear of the biomaterials used in them is a critical concern. For in vitro wear tests of such materials the recommended lubricant is one based on bovine serum. However, unlike synovial fluid, bovine serum does not contain hyaluronic acid. The aim of the work reported here was to take a clinically used hyaluronic acid solution, Ostenil, and to investigate its influence on the wear of two orthopaedic biopolymers
Ultra high molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE) and poly tetra fluoro ethylene (PTFE) were tested in turn using a four-station, multi-directional, pin-on-plate wear test rig which had previously been shown to reproduce clinical wear factors for UHMWPE, PTFE and polyacetal. For each biopolymer three lubricants were employed: 33% bovine serum (2 stations); 33% bovine serum + Ostenil (1 station); and distilled water + Ostenil (1 station). Polymeric test pins were subject to a load of 40N and articulated against polished stainless steel plates. Wear factors were determined by dividing the volume lost by the product of the load and the sliding distance (units × 10-6mm3/Nm).
The UHMWPE wear tests ran to 66.3km sliding distance. The addition of Ostenil to dilute bovine serum resulted in a wear factor of 1.4 × 10-6mm3/Nm for UHMWPE. The wear factor was 1.6 × 10-6mm3/Nm when dilute bovine serum alone was used as the lubricant. This shows good agreement with a wear factor of 2.1 × 10-6mm3/Nm reported for failed UHMWPE acetabular cups. PTFE provides an accelerated wear test with clinical validity. In the presence of 33% bovine serum a mean wear factor for PTFE of 40 × 10-6mm3/Nm was measured. The wear factor was 59 × 10-6mm3/Nm for dilute bovine serum plus Ostenil. For explanted PTFE acetabular cups a wear factor of 37 × 10-6mm3/Nm has been calculated. For both polymers wear was least when the lubricant was distilled water plus Ostenil. However a transfer film was found and such films are not clinically valid.
WITHDRAWN
The diagnosis of musculoskeletal infection is an ongoing problem. Multiple specimens and histology peri-operatively have been used to increase the accuracy of the diagnosis. However, to determine antibiotic resistance profiling it is essential to grow bacteria from the patient. The aim of this prospective study was to evaluate whether there is an increase in the rate of isolation of micro-organisms from musculoskeletal tissue samples sent directly in broth culture or whether there is an over-diagnosis due to false positive contaminants.
Samples were taken from patients undergoing planned orthopaedic surgery (some with and some without suspected infection). Each specimen was harvested with separate instruments. The specimens were placed into universal containers without broth according to our standard protocol and also into containers with broth. These samples were cultured and the results analysed for any difference in culture growth. A total of 72 specimens were taken in the operating theatre (36 in broth, 36 without broth). The results of culture were compared to a diagnosis of infection from clinical and histological data.
Overall there were 24 true positive samples in the study (sensitivity of 66.7%) and 32 true negative samples (specificity of 88.9%). The isolation of bacteria from the culture of samples sent in broth had a sensitivity of 77.8% and a specificity of 83.3%. Whereas, the sensitivity and specificity of musculoskeletal specimens sent without broth were 55.6% and 94.4%, respectively.
The results of the study show that there is an increase in the rate of isolation of micro-organisms from musculoskeletal tissue samples sent directly in broth culture, compared to specimens sent without broth. However, the broth samples resulted in a higher rate of false positives. This study concludes that placing musculoskeletal specimens directly in broth in the operating theatre for culture improves the rate of microbiologial diagnosis. However, a larger study with more patients would be of use to confirm this.
Optimal cup orientation for metal-on-metal hip resurfacing has yet to be established. Guidance is based on hip replacement data and in vitro studies. We sought to determine the influence of component size and positioning on early clinical outcome.
This study comprises a consecutive series of 200 hip resurfacings. All had Harris Hip Scores (HHS) at one-year review. Acetabular inclination angles were measured on pre-operative radiographs, and cup inclination/anteversion angles on 3-month post-operative films using EBRA. Restoration of anatomy was defined as placement of the cup within +/−5 degrees of pre-operative inclination. The difference between pre-operative acetabular and post-operative cup inclination was termed cup-angle difference (CAD).
HHS inversely correlated with CAD (P=0.023) and anteversion (P=0.003), and directly correlated with femoral head size (P< 0.001). In patients with restoration of inclination anatomy mean HHS at one year was significantly higher at 98.7 compared with cups placed outside the normal anatomy restoration limits (93.8, P=0.003). Patients with anteversion > 20 degrees had a significantly lower HHS (P=0.010) compared with cups anteverted < 20 degrees. 96% of patients with HHS < 90 had malaligned cups (inclination over 45 degrees, anteversion over 20 degrees).
Restoring pre-operative cup inclination, anteverting the cup < 20 degrees and using large femoral heads improves early clinical outcome following MonM hip resurfacing. We recommend accurate pre-operative planning and meticulous attention to intra-operative cup positioning with these results in mind.
The purpose of this study was to describe our experience of the Calaxo Osteoconductive interference screw (Smith & Nephew) when used for both femoral and tibial graft fixation in Double Bundle ACL reconstruction.
Since May 2006, all patients with an ACL deficient knee were reconstructed using the Double Bundle technique. All were followed prospectively and outcome data collected. Evidence of fixation failure was established subjectively by clinical examination (Lachman, Anterior Draw, Pivot Shift) and objectively via KT-1000 arthrometer. Following ethical approval, post-operative CT scans (immediate and 1 year) were performed on our first 10 patients allowing assessment of tunnel dimensions/fill.
Thirty two patients (29 male, 3 female) with a mean age of 30 (range 18-46) were included. At last follow-up, no evidence of graft/fixation failure was found; KT-1000 mean side-side difference 1.4mm (range −3 to +6). All patients had a positive pivot shift preoperatively which was abolished postoperatively. One patient had a postoperative infection with no other complications reported. Radiologically the screws did not show complete resorption but areas of new bone were identified.
We have shown satisfactory results with use of the Calaxo screw when used in Double Bundle Reconstruction. We have not had any cases of the adverse local soft tissue reaction, which has led to this screw being withdrawn from clinical use. Even when using a total of four screws in each knee. A previous study published by Seibold (2007) has shown tunnel widening and communication when suspensory fixation is used in Double Bundle reconstruction. This has the potential risk of leading to fracture between the tunnels. This has not been seen with the Calaxo screw which may be a result of the biological action of the screw which should ultimately lead to a reduction in these risks.
Recent reports suggest that long-term alendronate therapy may result in an unusual pattern of femoral subtrochanteric fracture. We aimed to determine if the presence of a specific radiographic feature in patients on alendronate could be used to predict an impending insufficiency fracture and thereby prevent its occurrence through further investigations and prophylactic fixation in high-risk patients.
Sixty-two subtrochanteric fractures treated surgically from 2001 to 2007 were reviewed and radiographs of 25 low-energy fractures were independently evaluated. Incidence of alendronate therapy, clinical data, and other investigations like bone mineral density (BMD) scans were recorded.
Seventeen fractures (68%) were associated with alendronate therapy. Hypertrophy of the lateral cortex of the femur with splaying of the fracture ends was noted in 70.1% of patients on alendronate; initial radiographs were not available in 17.6% and 11.8% had stress fractures identified by bone scan. None of the fractures in the non-alendronate group had this pattern. The fracture configuration in the alendronate group suggested that an ellipsoid thickening in the lateral cortex had been present prior to fracture. Indeed, 6 patients on alendronate (35.3%) had pre-existing radiographs as early as 3 years prior to fracture and all had this feature. Four of them had bone scans, which confirmed a stress fracture. Hip pain was often associated with this radiographic sign but may not be specific as patients were already on follow-up for other musculoskeletal conditions. BMD scans were not predictive of an impending fracture as they were mostly in the osteopaenic range. Only 50% with proven stress fractures had prophylactic fixation, while the remainder sustained overt fractures.
Alendronate-related subtrochanteric fractures are associated with a specific pre-existing radiographic abnormality. We recommend that all patients on long-term alendronate - particularly those with hip pain or a previous subtrochanteric fracture - be routinely followed-up with plain radiographs of the pelvis. If an ellipsoid feature is noted in the subtrochanteric region, further investigations like bone scan or MRI should be sought. Patients with evidence of stress fracture should be strongly considered for prophylactic operative fixation. We believe this is a cost-effective strategy to prevent subtrochanteric insufficiency fractures in patients on alendronate.
Skeletal metastases are an increasing sequaelae for patients with a wide range of neoplastic lesions owing to the increasing incidences of cancer. The diagnosis of a skeletal metastasis is, however, at present a terminal diagnosis representing uncontrolled tumour dissemination. The metastatic destruction of the bone reduces its load bearing capabilities progressing to the principle orthopaedic complication, that of complete loss of cortical integrity.
This is a retrospective study of all patients within the Cardiff centre who underwent an operation for a metastatic bone lesion over a 10 year period (n=140). The patients were identified using pathological records created when samples were sent at the time of the operations. The patients were all followed up for a minimum of 24 months. The demographics of the patients were collected and a detailed analysis of the primary tumour, the surgical procedure, the mobility, and survival of the patients was undertaken. The patients data was then cross referenced with the database at the regional cancer centre and the post operative radiotherapy treatment regimen were collected.
Patients who underwent prophylactic surgical stabilization had a significant survival advantage compared to those stabilized following a fracture (p=0.002). The morbidity postoperatively, defined by the patients functional mobility, also shows the benefits of prophylactic stabilization with significantly improved mobility when compared to the mobility following fracture stabilization (p=0.033). It has also been shown that there is a significant postoperative survival benefit for those patients who were able to regain mobility (p< 0.01).
Our results show a significant survival benefit of prophylactic fixation rather than fixation following fracture which is in line with previous studies We have also, for the first time in a large number study, shown that there is a survival benefit for patients who are able to mobilize following surgery and if prophylactic stabilization was undertaken patients were significantly more mobile postoperatively.
Four operations were secondary procedures following previous non-grower implant failures (1 infection of previous EPR, 1 IM nail non-union, 1 failed allograft and a revision of a proximal femoral EPR to a total femoral prosthesis). Five patients required revision of the primary prosthesis (2 with motor failures, 3 due to prosthesis infections).
Mean time to start lengthening from surgery was 12.2 months. The mean number of lengthenings was 4 with an average total length of 30 mm achieved, mean leg length difference was 0.8 cm. All lengthenings were undertaken with the patient fully alert, no adverse incidents occurred at the time or after lengthening.
We could not show that delay in diagnosis led to a worse prognosis.
Complications developed in seven patients: two implants failed requiring revision, one peri-prosthetic fracture occurred, one developed a flexion deformity of 25 degrees at the knee joint, which was subsequently overcome and three died of disseminated disease.
The most frequently performed reconstruction was a rectus abdominis musculo-cutaneous flap. Six patients developed post operative complications.
Complete/adequate surgical margins were achieved in seven patients. A further five patients had margins designated as “narrow” or “marginal”.
Six patients received post operative radiotherapy based on the multidisciplinary clinic review. Three patients were referred for radiotherapy but did not receive treatment. Five patients developed recurrences and four of these patients died.
The anatomical topography makes complete surgical excision difficult without available reconstructive techniques and complication rates can be high.
Referral of these patients to the regional sarcoma service is often delayed whilst exploration or biopsy is performed. This delay can persist even after a diagnosis of sarcoma has been made. Communication with colleagues in other centres may be the key to improving this side of management.
Five patients with recurrent disease were treated prior to establishment of the sarcoma network. Two patients, before the establishment of the network underwent resection and staging in another unit and the exact time to recurrence is unknown. One patient is currently under investigation for recurrence.
The average time to recurrence was 29.2 months (Range 12–48 months).
Three of the five patients with original pathology available had complete resection with mean margins of 6.25mm (range 5–7.5mm). Two had incomplete excisions carried out by other specialities, only presenting to our unit with recurrent disease.
Overall cumulative patient survival was 58% at 5 years and 44% at 10 years. Locally recurrent disease occurred in 350 patients (14%), 204 patients (8%) presented with and 720 patients (30%) subsequently developed metastatic disease.
Prognostic factors for locally recurrent disease were arm tumours (p=0.003, HR=0.3), hip tumours (p=0.01, HR=0.31), thigh tumours (p=0.002, HR=0.52), intralesional margins (p< 0.0001, HR=3.7), high grade tumours (p=0.03, HR=1.8), tumour size 3–6cm (p=0.04, HR=0.54) and tumour size 6–10cm (p=0.03, HR=0.63).
Prognostic factors for patient survival were deep location (p=0.02, HR=1.6), high grade tumours (p< 0.0001, HR=4.7), intermediate grade tumours (p< 0.0001, HR=3.4), surgical margins (p=0.04), age at diagnosis (p< 0.0001, HR=1.02), size of tumour < 3cms (p=0.04, HR=0.29), 3–6cms (p< 0.0001, HR=0.41), 6–10cms (p=0.007, HR=0.63), no locally recurrent disease (p=0.0001, HR=0.59).
those 7 whose LR was inoperable due to size, those 7 patients with LR_5cm who had concomitant metastases and in the 5 patients who already had maximum doses of radiotherapy.
Endoprosthetic replacement is often the preferred treatment for neoplastic lesions as internal fixation has been shown to have a high failure rate. Due to anatomical location, disease factors and patient factors internal fixation may be the treatment of choice. No reports exist in the literature regarding the use of locking plates in the management of neoplastic long bone lesions.
Data was collected prospectively on the first 10 patients who underwent locking plate fixation of neoplastic long bone lesions. Data was collected on the nature of the lesion, surgery performed, complications and outcome.
The patients mean age was 56.6 (15–88). Six lesions were metastatic, one haematological (myeloma) and 3 were primary bone lesions (lymphoma, Giant cell tumour, simple bone cyst). In nine cases a fracture through the lesion had occurred. Anatomical locations of the lesions were; proximal humerus (four), proximal tibia (three), distal femur (two) and distal tibia (one). Cement augmentation of significant bone defects was necessary in seven cases.
The mean hospital stay was 8 days (3–20). There were no inpatient complications. Five patients received adjuvant radiotherapy and one patient received neo-adjuvant radiotherapy to the lesion. There have been 3 deaths. All were due to metastatic disease and occurred between 6 and 12 months after surgery. The mean follow up in the surviving patients is currently 9 months (5–16). There have been no fixation related complications. Patients who had suffered a fracture had restoration of their WHO performance status. At last follow up the mean MSTS was 78% (57–90) for lower limb surgery and 70% (63–76) for upper limb surgery. These figures compare favourably with the results of endoprosthetic replacement.
The early results of locking plate fixation for neoplastic long bone lesions are excellent. Follow up continues to observe how these devices perform in the long term.
The treatment of acetabular metastases with total hip arthroplasty is technically challenging often with significant loss of structural continuity in the medial wall and roof of the acetabulum, as described by Harrington in 1981 as class III defects. Traditionally the acetabular component is stabilised with Harrington rods but the risk of post-operative complications, especially bleeding is significant.
We performed 10 consecutive total hip arthroplasties in patients with metastases involving the acetabulum with Harrington class III defects. The first three patients had acetabular reconstruction with a Kerboull cage, (Stryker Howmedica.) The cage was secured using a combination of screw fixation to the ileum and PMMA cement filling voids behind the cage. A polyethylene acetabular cup is then cemented into the cage. There was concern about the superior fixation using this implant and so the remaining 7 patients were treated using the Graft Augmentation Prosthesis (GAP II), (Stryker How-medica.) This is a titanium reconstruction cage with two superior flanges allowing extensive screw fixation onto the ileum. Two patients had very large defects where there was not sufficient support to use this cage alone, so the technique was augmented with Harrington rods.
No implants have failed to date. One patient, an 83 year old female, died 23 days post-operatively after suffering a stroke. Two patients died of their disease 95 and 115 days after surgery. The remaining patients continue to have good pain and mobility following surgery as demonstrated by the Oxford hip score.
We conclude that in suitable patients with extensive metastatic involvement of the acetabulum, a flanged acetabular reconstruction cage prosthesis is much improved way of providing support for a total hip replacement. This procedure can greatly improve quality of life, and to date we have had no mechanical failures of fixation using this technique.
The more notable conditions were two synovial sarcomas, three haemangiomas and a Giant cell tumour of the tendon sheath. All patients were treated successfully with complete excision. No recurrences were recorded at the end of 3 year follow-up and all patients were symptom free.
The five most common histopathological diagnoses were chondrosarcoma (9%), osteosarcoma (9%), meta-static renal carcinoma (8%), giant-cell tumour (6%), lymphoma (5%).
77% of biopsies yielded a tissue diagnosis. The remaining 23% underwent open biopsy, repeat image-guided needle biopsy or were not further investigated.
In the 30 cases (23%) of non-diagnostic biopsies 80% of these lesions had no extra-osseous component to them and the remaining 20% had a very small extra-osseous component.
Of the 7242 patients with soft tissue lumps, 476 had a past history of malignancy. Of these patients, only 12% actually had a soft tissue metastasis while 28% had a benign diagnosis, 55% a soft tissue sarcoma and 5% other malignancy.
On this basis we would recommend that all patients have the biopsy site marked at the time of biopsy and a further audit will be carried out to evaluate this change in practice.
We believe this technique provides good oncological and functional results and recommend this treatment option is considered in young active patients required distal fibula excisions for sarcoma.
Presented with anterior knee pain. Examination revealed supra-patellar fullness and tenderness. MRI scan showed a suspicious soft tissue tumour. Histology confirmed PVNS after excision biopsy. Presented with medial knee pain, most pronounced after exercise. McMurray test was positive for a meniscal tear. MRI confirmed meniscal tear and additional localised PVNS. The patient underwent repair of the meniscal injury but continued to complain of pain. Following excision of PVNS there was marked improvement in the patients’ symptoms. Presented as massive soft tissue swelling of the right knee. Past medical history included a diagnosis of tuberculosis and fibrosarcoma on the knee. She was referred to our centre following two diagnoses, three surgeries and a supracondylar femoral fracture. The patient was previously advised an above knee amputation which she refused. A repeat biopsy with immunohistochemistry studies at our unit confirmed the diagnosis of a PVNS. Patient is awaiting a total knee replacement with subtotal synovectomy. Presented with swollen right knee, pain and restriction of movement. MRI scan suggested a diagnosis of PVNS. The patient underwent subtotal synovectomy and histology confirmed this to be PVNS. Subsequently the patient had two recurrences, the first at 2 years and later at 4 years from initial surgery. Repeat MRI scan showed extensive third recurrence. The patient is awaiting a further open synovectomy, followed by low dose radiotherapy.
apply the CLEAR NPT to orthopaedic RCTs and survey authors when items in the CLEAR NPT were not reported, to determine if they were actually conducted.
During the last decades numerous studies have reported the critical impact of physical activity on bone repair. While most studies have evaluated the tissue response to the local mechanical environment within the fracture gap, there is a lack of information on the systemic role of physical activity during fracture healing. Therefore, the aim of this study was to standardize the mechanical environment in the fracture gap by developing a rotationally and axially stable murine fracture model, and thereby to analyze the systemic influence of physical activity on early bone repair.
After stable fixation of a closed femoral fracture, mice (n=18) were housed in cages supplied with running wheels (running distance > 500m/d). At 2 weeks animals were sacrificed and bones were prepared for histomorphometric (n=7), biomechanical (n=7), and protein biochemical analyses (n=4). Additional mice (n=22), which were housed in standard cages, served as controls.
Histomorphometric evaluation showed no influence of increased physical activity on bone repair in terms of callus size and tissue composition. Accordingly, also biomechanical testing of the callus revealed no differences between both groups in rotational stiffness, peak rotation angle, and load at failure. Western blot analyses demonstrated no alterations in callus expression of proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) and vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) after daily running when compared to controls.
We conclude that increased physical activity under standardized mechanical conditions in the fracture gap does not affect early bone repair in mice.
Objective: to analyze influence of propranolol, a beta-blocker, on fracture healing in a mouse model.
Deficiencies of folate and vitamin B6 and B12 as well as increased methionine serum concentrations have been indicated to disturb bone metabolism, most probably due to an induction of hyperhomocysteinemia (HHCY). However, there is a complete lack of information on whether these metabolic changes affect fracture healing.
Therefore, the aim of this study was to analyze the impact of a methionine-enriched (n=13) and a B vitamin-deficient diet (n=14) on bone repair in mice. Controls were fed by the accordant standard diet (n=12 and n=13). Four weeks after stable fixation of a closed femoral fracture, animals were sacrificed to prepare bones for histomorphometric and biomechanical analyses. In addition, blood samples were obtained to evaluate serum concentrations of homocysteine (HCY), folate, and vitamin B12.
Quantitative analysis of blood samples revealed significantly increased serum concentrations of HCY associated with significantly decreased serum concentrations of folate and vitamin B12 in animals fed with the methionine-enriched diet or the B vitamin-deficient diet when compared to controls. Biomechanical evaluation showed no significant differences in bending stiffness between bones of the experimental and those of the control groups. In accordance, the histomorphometric analysis demonstrated a comparable size and tissue composition of the callus in all groups analyzed.
We conclude that a methionine-enriched and a B vitamin-deficient diet leads to HHCY, however, without affecting bone repair in mice.
After 10 days this device was distracted 0.3 mm, twice a day until a distance of 6 mm was achieved (n=10). In the control group (n=10), the titanium plate was adjusted to a distance of 6 mm. All sheep received fluorescence labeling. 10 weeks p. o., bone formation underneath the titanium plate was investigated using pQCT, x-ray and histomorphology.
Besides these groups 15 more DM rats were used for PECAM-1 staining for angiogenesis (7 with 1 loss at a 3 week time point) and mechanical testing (8 at a 9 week time point).
WITHDRAWN
To examine the mechanical performance of the Son-icPin in a realistic fracture model 12 fresh frozen tibiae were osteotomized through the medial apex of the pla-fond, simulating a horizontal fracture of the medial malleolus. The tibiae were treated with either the Son-icPin or with 4.0-millimeter partially threaded titanium screws. Mechanical testing was performed by applying a compressive load 17 degrees from the long axis of the tibia to simulate supination-adduction loading.
The healing index, external fixation time divided by length gain, is commonly used as an outcome measure in distraction osteogenesis. This can be imprecise, and experimentally, regenerate stiffness is the accepted measure, but this can be difficult to measure clinically. The aim of this study was to investigate whether radiostereometric analysis (RSA) may be used to determine stiffness of new bone.
Two Ilizarov frames of differing stiffness were constructed around Sawbones tibiae. Known loads were applied to the frames and RSA was used to analyse the movement that occurred at the distraction gap. The axial stiffness of the frames was calculated. The distraction gap was filled with materials with a range of stiffnesses, representative of regenerate at different stages of consolidation. Loads were applied and RSA was used to measure the stiffness of the construct. A simple load share model was then used to estimate stiffness of the materials, and these values compared with those obtained from a materials testing machine.
The measured stiffnesses of the frames were 94N/mm and 55N/mm. RSA tended to underestimate the material properties of the ‘regenerate’, and this effect became greater at higher stiffness. There was also a 30% difference in estimated stiffness of the ‘regenerate’ when comparing the two fixators.
RSA is a very precise non-invasive method for measuring regenerate displacement. However, simple models to estimate stiffness tend to underestimate the true value, and assumptions made in basic engineering models are not valid when the stiffness of the regenerate approaches that of surrounding bone.
METHODS: Forty consecutive female osteoporotic patients with pertrochanteric fractures were selected. The inclusion criteria were: female; age ≥65 years; pertrochanteric fracture resulting from minor trauma. Patients were randomized by a computer-generated list to receive either IMHS fixed with stainless steel lag screws (Group A) or IMHS fixed with HA-coated pins (Group B).
RESULTS: Average patient age was 82 ± 8 years in Group A and 78 ± 6 years in Group B. Average BMD was 512 ± 177 in Group A, and 471 ± 231 in Group B. Average intraoperative time was 64 ± 6 minutes in Group A and 34 ± 5 minutes in Group B (p < 0.005). In Group A, all patients had post-operative blood transfusions averaged 2.0 ± 0.1. In Group B, there were no blood transfusions (p < 0.0001). In Group A, the reduction over time in the femoral neck-shaft angle was 6 ± 8, while in Group B, the reduction was 2 ± 1 (p < 0.002).
Conclusion: This study showed that intramedullary hip screw with HA-coated lag screw is an effective treatment for unstable fractures in this patient population. The operative time is brief, the fixation is adequate, and the reduction is maintained over time.
The anterolateral surgical exposure to the distal tibia for pilon fractures has become more popular. One of the potential benefits over the commonly used anteromedial approach is a reduction in wound complications due to the improved soft tissue coverage of the anterolateral tibia. Minimal data exists regarding the rate of complications with the anterolateral approach. The purpose of this study was to evaluate wound complications in the early postoperative period associated with the use of the anterolateral approach for pilon fractures.
The influence of controlled mechanical loading on osseointegration was investigated using an in vivo device implanted in the distal lateral femur of five male rabbits. Compressive loads (1 MPa, 1 Hz, 50 cycles/day, 4 weeks) were applied to a porous coated titanium cylindrical implant (5mm diameter, 2mm width, 75% porosity, 350ìm average pore diameter) and the underlying cancellous bone.. The contralateral limb served as an unloaded control. MicroCT scans at 28 μm resolution were taken of a 4 × 4mm cylindrical region of interest that included cancellous bone below the implant. A scanning electron microscope with a backscattered electron (BSE) detector was used to quantify the percent bone ingrowth and periprosthetic bone in undecalcified sections through the same region of interest. A mixed effects model was used to account for the correlation of the outcome measures within rabbits.. The percent bone ingrowth was significantly greater in the loaded limb (19 +/− 4%) compared to the unloaded control limb (16 +/− 4%, p=0.016) as measured by BSE imaging. The underlying cancellous periprosthetic tissue bone volume fraction was not different between the loaded (0.26 +/− 0.06) and unloaded control limb (0.27 +/− 0.07, p=0.81) by microCT. BSE imaging also showed no difference in the percent area of periprosthetic bone (27 +/− 10% loaded vs. 23 +/− 10% unloaded, p=0.25). Cyclic mechanical loading significantly enhanced bone ingrowth into a titanium porous coated surface compared to the unloaded controls.
The aim of this study was to examine the therapeutic potential of locally transplanted MSCs or osteoprogenitor cells (OPCs) in delayed unions. Autologous MSCs were cultured in DMEM or osteogenic medium. A femoral osteotomy was created in rats and stabilized with an external fixator. Except for the Control-group (C-group), a delayed union was induced by cauterization of the periosteum and bone marrow removal. After 2 days, these animals received an injection of DMEM in the gap containing MSCs (MSC-group), OPCs (OPC-group) or no cells (Sham-group). Histomorphometrical analysis showed significant differences in the fraction of mineralized bone, cartilage and connective tissue between the C- and the Sham-group after 2 (p=0.001) and 8 weeks (p≤0.009). After 2 weeks, the MSC- and OPC-groups developed a larger cartilage fraction (each p=0.019) compared to the Sham-group. Biomechanical testing after 8 weeks demonstrated a significantly lower torsional stiffness (p=0.001) in the Sham-group compared to the C-group. Both the MSC and OPC groups showed a higher torsional stiffness than the Sham-group with statistically significant differences (p< 0.002) in the OPC-group. Locally applied MSCs and OPCs slightly improved the healing in this model. The MSCs were less effective compared to the OPCs. The less than expected healing improvement of both cell treatments may be related to an unfavourable microenvironment at the application time. An explanation for the superior outcome of the OPCs might be that the OPCs may be protected by macroscopically visible matrix at the transplantation time point.
Patients undergoing programmed hip/knee arthroplasties frequently have abnormal preoperative urine analysis. Up to 4% of patients undergoing programmed hip/knee arthroplasties have preoperative asymptomatic UTI. Up to now no patient with an abnormal analysis/UTI has developed an arthroplasty infection.
Provides an excellent clinical and functional result, assessed by KSS. There is survival of 91% of the implants at 14.5 years.
If we include all reoperations, survival free of reintervention was 84%.
The ability of optimised MRI to detect periarticular bony and soft tissue pathology in the post-arthroplasty hip is well documented; specifically it is able to detect early stages of particle disease well before osteolysis is apparent on radiographs. This is a prospective study designed to utilise MRI for the detection of early particle disease in asymptomatic patients after total hip arthroplasty.
Patients who underwent routine non-cemented THA were recruited from three different groups: metal-on-polyethylene, ceramic-on-ceramic, and ceramic-on-polyethylene bearing surfaces. All patients enrolled underwent optimised MRI one to three years (mean 1.7) after the index procedure. Images were analyzed for the presence of synovial proliferation, fibrous membrane formation or osteolysis. Particle disease was correlated with type of bearing surface, pain, activity level, patient satisfaction, and clinical outcome scales.
Thirty-two hips have been enrolled in the study to date. Early particle disease was seen in two of seven metal-on-polyethylene hips (29%), four of twelve ceramic-on-ceramic hips (33%), and six of thirteen ceramic-on-polyethylene hips (46%). Focal osteolysis was seen in one patient with a ceramic-on-polyethylene hip. These values were not statistically significant among the groups. The presence of early particle disease did not correlate with pain, activity level, patient satisfaction, or other clinical outcome scales.
This study allows patients with a well functioning total hip arthroplasty to be prospectively followed with MRI. It is the first to document the natural history of particle disease in vivo and considerably enhances our knowledge of periarticular pathology in the post-operative hip. These results demonstrate early particle disease is relatively common yet asymptomatic; they do not demonstrate advantages of any bearing couple over another for protection against particle disease at short-term follow-up.
Young and active patients require bearing materials that can last up to 200 million walking steps, ten fold greater than conventional polyethylene bearings.
Cross linked polyethylene provides reduced wear rate compared to conventional polyethylene, and further advantage is gained from using ceramic femoral heads. However in polyethylene bearings wear increases with the head diameter, and there is currently little opportunity to use head sizes greater then 36mm diameter. There is evidence of polyethylene fracture with steeply positioned cups.
Ceramic on ceramic bearings provide substantially lower wear rates than polyethylene bearings. Steep cups, lateralised heads or neck impingement can lead to head contact on superior rim of the cup and stripe wear, but this still results in very low wear rates. Recently developed ceramic matrix composites Biolox Delta provide greater resistance to stripe wear. In a few patients stripe wear may lead to squeaking.
Metal on metal bearings also provide substantially lower wear than polyethylene bearings. However there remains concern about elevated metal ion levels in a few patients and resultant risk of hypersensitivity reactions. In metal on metal bearings larger head sizes and reduced diametrical clearance can lead to reduced wear. Increased wear is associated with steep cups and lateralised heads resulting in rim wear.
Ceramic on metal bearings have been introduced recently as the first differential hard on hard bearings. These bearings show substantial reduction in wear, corrosive wear mechanisms, metal ion levels in laboratory simulators and initial clinical studies have shown a reduction in metal ion levels in vivo compared to metal on metal bearings.
Although total hip arthroplasty (THA) is quite predictable and durable in older patients, young and active patients have higher rates of revision and these rates are especially increased when the etiology is osteonecrosis. Recent advancement of hip resurfacing technology, HRA has been revived again. Numerous advantages and promising results of HRA have been published. But patient selection and techniques etc still remain issues for HRA in general and especially for patients with osteonecrosis. In the case of HRA in patients with osteoarthritis, the bone quality is stronger and there is no head necrosis and surgical techniques are fundamentally different when compared to osteonecrosis. In osteonecrosis, there is a higher risk and greater concern of the neck fracture due to necrosis and osteoporosis, insecure fixations as well as a progression of necrosis in the subchondral bone. These factors should be considered when assessing hips with osteonecrosis. The ultimate assessment is the condition of the prepared femoral head. This makes resurfacing arthroplasty for osteonecrosis a challenging procedure.
This study was performed to assess the overall clinical and radiological results of the total resurfacing arthroplasty for the patients with osteonecrosis of the femoral head(ONFH) after a minimum 5 year-follow-up.
444 hips of ONFH received resurfacing arthroplasty from Sep 1998 to Mar.2008. 88 hips which were followed up minimally 5 years were included in this study.
Among 88 hips(79 patients) of ONFH that have underwent hip resurfacing arthroplasties from Dec 1998 to Apr 2003, 85 hips(76 patients) were available for the complete study. The mean age at the time of operation was 37 (16–67) years old. The average follow-up period was 80 (60–112) months. The patients were clinically evaluated with the Harris hip score, hip or thigh pain, limb length discrepancy and range of motion. As a radiological evaluation, we observed the changes of implant position, patterns of bone remodeling in the neck and complications such as femoral neck fracture, loosening and osteolysis. Metal ion in the serum was also analysed.
The Harris hip score increased from 77.8 preoperatively to 98.4 at the final visit. Hip abduction/adduction and rotations significantly improved after the operation. Flexion contracture disappeared and further flexion also returned to almost normal. No patient complained of limb length discrepancy and pain on the hip or thigh at the last visit. Although they are not related to the clinical result, some cases showed various types of radiographic changes in the neck of the proximal femur. Neck narrowing was observed in 3 hips. There was no detectable wear or change of position of the acetabular cup and femoral stem.
Our experience with resurfacing arthroplasty in osteonecrosis of the femoral head indicates that the overall results are superior to conventional THA in the aspect of pain relief, the range of hip motion, earlier rehabilitation and earlier return to preoperative activity. This procedure of his resurfacing arthroplasty could be an alternative between joint preserving procedures and THA in the case of early-to-mid staged osteonecrosis of the femoral head especially in younger patients who need arthroplasty. Extent and location of necrosis, and bone quality are the most important factors in resurfacing arthroplasty in osteonecrosis. Precise preoperative planning and meticulous surgical technique is needed to perform resurfacing arthroplasty. But long-term studies are needed to determine the survivorship and to evaluate the metal toxicity after resurfacing arthroplasty.
Since 1984, we began to use Interface Bioactive Bone Cement (IBBC) technique by interposing osteoconductive and not resorbable crystalline HA granules of 0.3 to 0.6 mm in diameter between bone and bone cement at cementation during surgery. We expected super long term longevity of bone/bone cement bonding in IBBC technique.
Specimens were retrieved at the revision THA from the eight patients. They were operated for hip due to OA and RA. Revision THAs were done 4, 6, 8, 10, 13, 14, 18, 19 and 21 years after primary THA due to separation of polyethylene cup with metal-back from the bone cement, late infection and ceramic cup breakage. The specimens were obtained in bloc to keep the bone cement-HA granules-bone interfaces intact. Non-decalcified specimens were cut perpendicular to the interface and were stained by Toluidine blue. They were investigated by an optical microscopy.
Cancellous bone entered into the space of HA granules from the cancellous bone base and cortical bone entered into the space of HA granules from the cortical bone base. When several layers of HA granules were smeared densely on the bone, bone ingrowth into the spaces of HA granules was obvious and thick bone layer with HA granules directly contacted to the bone cement. When HA granules were smeared sparsely even if several layer of HA granules were smeared, bone ingrowth into the spaces of HA granules was not dense. Even if one layer of HA granules was smeared sparsely, bone formation was seen around the HA. Through out 4 to 21 years bone ingrowth into the spaces of HA granules was the same at the interface of bone/bone cement. However, at the area existing no HA granule, bone formation at the interface of bone/bone cement decreased after the onset of osteoporosis due to aging.
When HA granules were smeared in several layers and densely, thick bone layer with HA granules directly contacted to the bone cement even after 21 years after surgery and after onset of osteoporosis due to aging. As previously reported, the appearance rate of radiolucent line on the radiograph was extremely low even 21 years after surgery. Form these clinical results long term longevity over 30 to 40 years could be expected.
Sixty primary hip arthroplasties were performed in Crowe grade 2 to 4 hip dysplasia since 1973 using a modified transtrochanteric osteotomy which is reliable short cut to reach down the lateral aspect of the greater trochanter. Our hypothesis consists of the adaptability of Thomas test to show the reducibility of the disloction in the coronal plane. In practice, if the dynamic potential while abduction and flexion exceeds from the 90° to coronal plane, the femoral head slips down to the acetabulum through poor sciatic notch. Thereby led to Protrusio acetabulii which implicative compromised capsular insufficiency but assessment of outcome study has been improved.
The results have been reasonably acceptable, with the longest follow-up greater than 35 years. We confirmed that the frog leg lateral radiography is effective for determining the operative indication of high riding dislocation of the DDH. However irreducible frog leg lateral position is absolutely contraindicated in these situation. We also aware of not only the complexity in abductor length but abundant amount of vastus lateralis when reattaching the trochanter, which may arises against stability of the abductors and vastus lateralis in continuity.
Femoral revision is frequent, due to femoral loosening, thigh pain, recurrent dislocation, osteolysis or sepsis. Whatever the reason, with the exception of some difficult septic cases, our strategic approach is similar. Some of our expertise concern femoral stem retrieval. Our reconstruction strategy is different if we are revising total hip in active and young patient or if it is an old and inactive one.
First step is always an large “en bloc” tissue excision. For old and inactive, it is sometimes possible to retain the stem if not loosed and perform a “in cement” cementation; In this group we select usually metal or alumina on polyethylene couple and cemented implants; In young and active, we select alumina on alumina combination which resumed in cementless acetabular fixation, and cementless or cemented stem.
Stem retrieval of a well fixed cementless stem is performed via a large transtrochanteric approach associated with a transfemoral one. Repair is performed using cerclage and long cemented stem.
Cement retrieval is performed since 9 years using Ultra sound (Oscar*) material, which in our hand is very successful specially for cement retractor retrieval. Then medullary canal is reamed in order to get a bloody healthy bone receive either a cemented or sometimes a cementless stem, depending on the bone quality.
To compensate femoral bone destruction and enhance cemented stem fixation, we used a modified Ling technique replacing allogenic morcellised bone by hydroxyapatite granules. Granules of 5 mm in diameter are made of 70% HA and 30% of β TCP. Mechanical resistance is excellent and biological activity is high. Thus stem stability can be obtained easily. This can be done either with a cemented or a cementless stem (about 60 cases).
In case of very severe bone loss and osteolysis, we performed massive allogenic bone transplant associated with long cemented stem and distal HA granules with cement.(17 cases).
As we usually performed one stage revision for septic cases, strategy is not different; It is only in selected cases with many sepsis recurrence and specially aggressive bacteria that we performed a two stage procedure.
Kinematics of human joints have been studied using various methods of observation for millennia, including cadaver dissection, mechanical tests, and more recently photogrammetric gait analysis. For just over sixteen years, dynamic single-plane radiographic observations have been used to quantitatively characterize the motions of anatomic and prosthetically replaced joints. These observations have improved the understanding, in particular, of knee function and the influence of prosthetic design and surgical technique on knee kinematics and patient function. Other studies have reported the kinematics of the hip, shoulder, spine and foot/ankle. It is clear that advances in the technologies to acquire and quantify radiographic images of the skeleton in motion can have a major impact on joint mechanics research and, ultimately, clinical diagnosis. This lecture will highlight two avenues of development in our laboratory: open-source software for determining skeletal kinematics from radiographic images, and a novel robotic imaging platform for observing the skeleton in motion.
Our group is working on an open-source shape-matching software application that will be freely available to anyone who wishes to use it (sourceforge.net/projects/jointtrack). This flexible platform will allow the modular addition of new capabilities as plug-in components written in a wide range of languages (C++, Python, Java, etc.), and makes heavy use of other open-source and public libraries (I.C.E., OpenGL, VTK, ITK). All of our future developments will use this platform so that the latest results will be available to all, and hopefully other users will share their advances collaboratively. We currently have created a graphical user interface for performing single-plane model-image registration, and are currently working to expand this to handle bi-plane imaging.
We also are developing a robotic platform to permit radiographic imaging of human joints during normal, unrestricted, dynamic activities. This platform will move the x-ray source and sensor in response to the patient’s unconstrained motion, providing views with greater diagnostic potential than are acquired with fixed or c-arm imaging systems. This same imaging platform will also provide an extremely flexible platform for cone-beam tomography, so that a single system will be able to perform all imaging functions required for skeletal model-image registration based kinematic measurements.
The goal of these endeavors is to advance the possibility that dynamic radiographic analysis of joint motion will soon be a useful, accurate, and routine diagnostic and measurement tool available to enhance the efforts of orthopaedic surgeons in the treatment of their patients.
Periprosthetic osteolysis following total knee replacement is a well recognized intermediate to long term complication. Over the last four decades, the prevalence of osteolysis following total knee replacement has increased. Development of periprosthetic osteolysis after knee replacment surgery is related to three factors, generation of wear debris, access of that debris to bone, and the biologic reaction to the wear debris. Although more common in association with loose components, osteolysis can occur with stable cementless implants and less commonly stable cemented implants.
Polyethylene particles have been isolated from tissue around failed total knee replacements. When compared to total hip replacements, polyethylene wear particles from knee replacesments are larger. However, the majority of particles are still less than one micron in size and are biologically active. Several important factors impact polyethylene wear. The polyethylene itself is one of the most important variables. Research over the past decade has demonstrated the importance of manufacturing technique, sterilization methods, packaging and shelf life on wear performance. It is now known that polyethylene sterilized with gamma radiation and stored in oxygen with a long shelf life is associated with higher prevalence of osteolysis. Oxidized polyethylene has a lower resistance to wear thus increasing the particle load.
Modularity has been associated with a higher prevalence of osteolysis most likely because it can result in a higher particle load from backside wear. One study compared the prevalence of osteolysis with all polyethylene tibial components and modular tibial components. At comparable follow-up, none of the patients with all polyethylene tibial components developed osteolysis. In contrast, 18% of the patients with modular tibial base-plates developed peri-prosthetic osteolysis. Although there was a bias in favor of the all polyethylene components since they had been implanted in lower demand patients, this study suggests that backside wear is a clinically important source of biologically important wear particles. The stability of the tibial insert locking mechanisms impacts backside wear. Excessive insert motion can accelerate backside wear and result in the generation of both polyethylene and metallic particles. Knee implant design has attempted to improve the effectiveness of tibial locking mechanisms to decrease backside motion and thus wear debris generation. Mobile bearing designs address this issue by using polished cobalt chrome tibial base plates to minimize the debris generation between the insert and base plate. It is unclear whether the total particle load is less with a mobile bearing design compared to a modular fixed bearing design with a well-designed insert lock detail.
Technical issues that effect knee alignment and ligament balancing can impact wear. Perfect alignment is difficult to achieve. Slight malalignment may not represent a functional problem for the patient, but can result in increased stresses in the polyethylene and potentially accelerate wear. Ligament balancing and implant design act in concert to dictate knee stability. A tight flexion gap most commonly associated with under release of the posterior cruciate in cruciate retaining knee designs, can lead to accelerated polyethylene wear posteromedially. Patients with a loose flexion gap and minimally conforming implants are prone to increase anterior-posterior translation of the femur on the tibia during gait, so called “paradoxical motion.” Translation of the femur on the tibia increases shear stresses in the polyethylene and may accelerate wear.
Finally, the patients who undergo total knee replacement have changed dramatically over that time period. Many total knee replacement patients today expect to return to active lives. Higher activity creates greater wear volume that in turn increases the likelihood of osteolysis. A study from Charlotte, North Caroline documented the multi-factorial nature of osteolysis. Of the 1287 Press-Fit Condylar knees with more than five year follow-up, 8.3% had a wear related failure. Cox hazard analysis demonstrated five factors that correlated with a wear related failure. These included patient age, patient gender, polyethylene shelf life, polyethylene finishing method and polyethylene sheet vendor. This study emphasized the fact that relatively small changes in polyethylene manufacturing can have a significant effect on wear. It should also be noted that these inserts were gamma sterilized in air and the results cannot be generalized to implants sterilized by other methods.
Access to the implant bone interface and peri-prosthetic bone is affected by implant design and surgical technique. In general, access to bone is more of an issue with cementless components compared to cemented components. Wear debris can gain access to periprosthetic bone through screw holes in the tibial baseplate and regions of the implant bone interface that lack bone ingrowth. Incomplete porous coatings also provide an access channel for wear debris. So called “hybrid cemented technique” for tibial implantation may increase the risk of wear debris access to the proximal tibia. In one study, hybrid cementing was associated with a high rate of tibial osteolysis and loosening.
Although polyethylene wear is the driving force in the development of periprosthetic osteolysis after total knee replacement, because of the complex geometry of knee implants, measurement of polyethylene wear in knee is difficult. As a result, the first radiographic sign of significant wear may in fact be osteolysis. The complex geometry of knee implants and the distal femur and proximal tibia can make recognition and quantitation of osteolysis difficult. Peri-prosthetic after total knee replacement occurs in the cancellous bone of the distal femur and proximal tibia. Not only do the implants obscure the bone, but since cancellous bone is less radiodense bone loss is less obvious. The posterior aspect of the femoral condyles and the medial femoral condyle under the medial collateral ligament are areas that appear to be prone to the development of osteolysis especially with cementless femoral components. Oblique radiographs are sometimes helpful in evaluating the posterior femoral condyles. Radiographs typically underestimate osteolysis. Both CT and MRI have be used to more accurately quantitate lesion extent.
Little data exists to help the surgeon guide management of distal femoral or proximal tibial osteolysis at revision surgery. Although not always the case, osteolysis in association with cemented components is usually associated with a loose implant. The decision to revise is based on the degree of bone loss and the patient’s symptoms. In contrast, severe osteolysis can develop after cementless knee replacement in association with osseo-integrated cementless components. Clinically, patients can remain asymptomatic despite extensive bone loss. Often however, osteolysis of the knee is associated with complaints of swelling or late instability. Wear particles can result in synovitis that results in an effusion. The synovitic process can effect knee stability especially with cruciate retaining implants as it can result in damage to the posterior cruciate ligament.
When there is osteolysis and the implants are wellfixed, the decision to operate is based on the degree of bone loss and patient symptoms. The decision to recommend revision surgery is more difficult in patients who are asymptomatic. In addition to the degree of bone loss, other factors to take into account include patient age and activity level, patient comorbities and the risk for the development of a pathologic fracture. No objective data exists to guide optimal timing for surgical intervention.
When the implants are stable, the surgeon has a choice to graft the osteolytic lesion and exchange the tibial insert or revise the component. Again, there is very little data available to direct treatment. Insert exchange with impaction grafting of lytic lesions can be successful provided the implant is otherwise well aligned and the knee can be made ligamentously stable with a new insert. It is important to remember that the posterior cruciate ligament can be damaged as part of the synovitic process. As a result, a standard tibial insert may not be sufficient to provide stability. Although most knee systems offer a more constrained tibial insert for their cruciate retaining designs, the actual impact these more constrained inserts have on articular stability varies significantly between designs. Knees the had early wear related failure likely have technical or implant related factors that contributed to the failure process. In such cases, revision surgery should be considered. In contrast, patients who functioned well for many years and then had a wear related failure are reasonable candidates for an insert exchange provided the implants are well fixed.
Management of bone defects is performed using a combination of allograft bone chips and structural grafts as well as metal augments. In general defects at the level of the distal femur or proximal tibia can be managed with metal augments. Larger defects usually require grafting. Contained defects can be treated with impaction grafting of allograft bone chips. This can be performed in the presence of well fixed components. Commercially available bone substitute putties may be helpful in containing the intra-articular communication with the defect once it has been packed with bone chips. Non-contained defects are managed with structural allografts. Femoral heads usually suffice for management of these larger defects, although a distal femoral or proximal tibial allograft may be necessary in some cases. Tibial and femoral extension stems should be used when grafting has been performed to help stress protect the graft. Less commonly, patients with severe bone loss and associated collateral ligament loss will require a hinge prosthesis. In these cases, the bone defects can usually be managed with the implant and not require grafting.
We have recently reviewed our experience with management of large osteolytic defects at the time of revision knee replacement. Twenty-eight knees underwent revision TKA requiring surgical management of major osteolytic defects. Three groups of osteolytic defects were identified based upon the degree of implant stability and the magnitude of bone loss. Outcome measures included the KSCRS, visual analog pain score, and radiographs. At a mean follow-up of 48 months, the average knee pain scores, range of motion, and KSCRS improved (p< .05). Eighty-six percent demonstrated clinical and functional improvement and were satisfied with the outcome. Radiographs for 24 revision TKA’s demonstrated component stability and incorporation of both cancellous and structural allografts. Revision TKA for major osteolytic defects may be effectively performed using a variety of bone grafting techniques. Both morselized and structural bone grafting, in combination with stemmed components was successful in managing revision TKA in the setting of major osteolysis. Significant improvement in clinical and radiographic outcomes may be anticipated using these surgical techniques.
Meniscectomy, induces osteoarthritis. Options for repair of a damaged meniscus are an allograft meniscus, an implant made of natural scaffold materials (the collagen meniscus implant; CMI) or an implant made of polymers.
Allograft menisci and the CMI are already clinically used for a considerably number of years. In this educational lecture the focus is on a comparison between the three implant types and the status of a tissue-engineered meniscus.
The allograft meniscus is already used for at least ten years. It is intended for the younger patient with a previous total meniscectomy, with moderate cartilage degeneration and with a good alignment of the knee. The clinical outcome is based on function and pain scores. In this lecture the functional scores, the survival rate and the histology of allograft menisci will be highlighted.
The CMI meniscus implant is intended for a different patient group. To enable implantation of the CMI the rim of the native meniscus should be intact. Patient series that should demonstrate the efficacy of this type of implant are still small and are mainly of the inventors of the implant. In general patients tolerated the implant well. Tissue ingrowth and remodelling into a fibro-cartilaginous tissue was found in animals and patients.
Polymers may be a good alternative for the allograft and CMI implant. Previously they were used to guide vascularized new repair tissue through an ingrowth channel to the avascular lesion. We developed a porous polymer meniscus scaffold with properties to allow tissue infiltration and regeneration of a neomeniscus. It was implanted in dog knees and compared with total meniscectomy. The tissue infiltration and redifferentiation in the scaffold, the stiffness of the scaffold, and the articular cartilage degeneration were evaluated.
Three months after implantation, the implant was completely filled with fibrovascular tissue. After 6 months, the central areas of the implant contained cartilage-like tissue with abundant collagen type II and proteoglycans in their matrix. The foreign-body reaction remained limited to a few giant cells in the implant. The compression modulus of the implant-tissue construct still differed significantly from that of the native meniscus, even at 6 months. Cartilage degeneration was observed both in the meniscectomy group and in the implant group.
The improved properties of these polymer implants resulted in a faster tissue infiltration and in phenotypical differentiation into tissue resembling that of the native meniscus. However, the material characteristics of the implant need to be improved to prevent degeneration of the articular cartilage.
To know how to succeed and survive for his or her whole life after the primary TKA by studying the causes of aseptic failure of the cruciate retaining type primary TKA. One hundred and seventy nine cases of revision of the TKA were analyzed concerning the causes of failure. The longest follow-up period was 25 years. All cases of the immediate postoperative and pre-revision weight bearing x-rays were reviewed. The operative findings of the revision surgery were compared with the pre-revision x-rays and physical findings.
The results of this study were:
The incidence of wear of the tibial polyethylene insert was predominant. The most severe disability before revision was instability and dislocation of the joint due to excessive eccentric wear of the posteromedial part of the tibial polyethylene insert. All cases showed full ROM after primary TKA. The causes of the failures could be classified as follows: Implant Design: Flat surfaced tibial polyethylene insert could be related with an eccentric wear and a resultant instability. Posterior pegs of the tibial base plate might be related with a stress fracture of the posteromedial part of tibial condyle, which ended up with an eventual fracture of the tibial base plate and dislocation of the tibial polyethylene insert. The metal backed patella could cause early wear of the patellar polyethylene insert. Bone Cutting: The most common cause of the failure related with the bone cutting was insufficient valgus of the femorotibial angle, which was related with a wear of the medial side of the tibial polyethylene insert. Less than 50 of valgus could be related with an early wear of the tibial polyethylene insert. Soft tissue balance: Most important factors were insufficient medial release and tight PCL, which caused early wear of the posteromedial portion of the tibial polyethylene especially in high flexion knees. Fixation: All cases of loosening occurred in cases of cementless TKA. The excessive body weight which is known to be one of the causes of early failure was not a significant factor in this series.
All aseptic failures occurred in high flexion knees. The causes of failures could be classified into four, the implant design, the bone cutting and the soft tissue balance and fixation. Long time survival could be achieved if those factors are perfect.
Three hundred and fifty-eight Tri Con 2 total knee replacements were done between 1987 and 1993. There were three versions of the femoral component, smooth for cement, porous coated and HA coated. Fifty-nine died or were lost to follow-up within two years leaving 229 cases with a follow-up of between 2 and 17 years. Eighteen were cemented, 162 porous coated and 51 HA coated. No porous or cemented femoral components were revised. Three (5.9) HA components were. One was revised at 2 years for unexplained pain. Revision did not help. In 2 cases the tibia loosened. The HA femoral component was tight. There was significant femoral osteolysis. It was possible to knock off the femoral component fairly easily. Virtually no HA remained on the components. There was significant 3-body wear of the polyethylene.
The conclusions are that the advantage of an HA coating is that well-fixed femoral component can be knocked off with a simple application of force. This can never be done with a well fixed porous component. The disadvantage is that HA fixation does not seal against osteolysis. The incidence of 3-body wear is possibly increased and HA coating may have a finite life expectancy.
We analysed the clinical and radiographic results after total knee arthroplasty in the valgus knee. Thirty six knees in 27 patients with a valgus alignment of more than 10 degrees of femorotibial angle underwent TKA. The average followup period was 7 years(range 1 to 14 years). Eighteen knees were implanted with a cruciate retaining prosthesis, 17 knees with a posterior stabilized prosthesis, and one knee with a constrained condylar prosthesis. In knees with a preoperative 15 degrees or greater femorotibial angle, the posterior stabilized prosthesis were necessary in 85%.
Medial parapatellar approach was used in 27 knees with a preoperative valgus 20 degrees or lesser femorotibial angle. With 20 to 29 degrees valgus, medial parapatellar approach was used in 5 knees and lateral parapatellar approach in 2 knees. With 30 degrees or greater valgus, lateral parapatellar approach was used in 2 knees.
The mean postoperative Hospital for Special Surgery knee scores were 89.5 points. Postoperative range of motion averaged 114.4 degrees. Postoperative alignment averaged 6.5 degree valgus. Radiolucent line or loosening was not seen in any knee. There were two deep infections in patients whose preoperative femorotibial angle was greater than valgus 20 degrees using lateral parapatellar approach.
Clinical and functional results after TKA in the valgus knee were similar to those in varus knee. But, prevention of deep infection in patients with marked valgus angle was important, especially using lateral parapatellar approach. A more constrained prosthesis was frequently used in more significant valgus deformity. In patients with severe valgus deformity needing lateral capsular release frequently, lateral parapatellar capsular approach was more reasonable than medial parapatellar approach to avoid medial and lateral capsular release simultaneously.
In this study, it was shown that the layered adsorbed film formation originated from the optimum composition of proteins in lubricants is effective to maintain low wear and low friction for PVA hydrogel artificial cartilage.
At present we conduct a clinical study on four bearing combinations in hip arthroplasty. Our main purpose is to assess changes in bone mineral density (BMD), function of the joint, and to monitor serum concentrations of prosthetic metals as well as plasma concentrations of a range of cytokines, chemokines, and related proteins during a ten-year follow-up. This is done in order to evaluate the potential role of these variables as predictors of dysfunction or loosening of the arthroplasty.
A total of 300 patients were randomly allocated to four bearing combinations. Four years after surgery the following number of patients were available for follow-up: Type A: Zirconia ceramic head, polyethylene cup insert in the Universal RingLoc metal backed shell (n=50); Type B: Cobalt-Chrome-Molybdenum head and cup insert in the Universal RingLoc metal backed shell (n=57); Type C: Zirconia ceramic head, polyethylene moulded on the Titanium shell of the Asian cup (n=55); Type D: Alumina head and cup insert in the Universal RingLoc metal backed shell (n=45). A BiMetric Titanium-Aluminium-Vanadium (Ti6Al4V) stem was used with all four combinations (n=207). All patients, but two with rheumatoid arthritis, had primary osteoarthritis or avascular necrosis of the femoral head. Five patients had astma and eight had diabetes.
At the time of surgery the groups were equal with regard to age, gender distribution, body height and weight, side of arthroplasty, and BMD in all seven Gruen zones. Harris Hip Score prior to arthroplasty was equally low in all groups (mean ± SD) (42 ± 17), and increased in all groups, with no significant differences between them (87 ± 10).
At follow-up there was a significant decrease in BMD in all Gruen zones ranging from −1.9 % in zone 4 in group C to −21.7% in zone 7 in group D. However, there were no significant differences between groups.
There were significantly higher blood concentrations of Chromium and Cobalt in group B patients compared to all other groups (p < 0.001).
Plasma concentrations of cytokines IL-1β, IL-6, IL-8, IL-10, TNF-α, TNF-R1, VEGF, OPG, GM-CSF, or TGF-β1 did not differ significantly between groups. Instead, elevated levels of IL-1β, IL-10 and TNF-R1 were found in patients with asthma. IL-6, TNF-α and VEGF were elevated in patients with rheumatoid arthritis or asthma. IL-8 and TGF-β1 were higher in patients with osteoarthritis, whereas GM-CSF was high in patients with asthma or diabetes.
This study was conducted to test the hypothesis that growth factors can reduce the suppressive effect of titanium particles on MSCs. Cultured human MSCs at passage 3 were challenged with prepared cpTi particles at a concentration of 500 particles/cell along with one of the following growth factors: TGF-beta(1) (10 ng/mL), FGF-2 (10 ng/mL), IGF-I (100 ng/mL), and BMP-6 (50 ng/mL). After various periods of time, the treatment effects on cellular proliferation, viability, and osteogenic differentiation were measured. All the four growth factors positively promoted cell proliferation and viability to a varying extent. FGF-2 most effectively enhanced cell proliferation, whereas IGF-I was the most effective growth factor for enhancing cell viability. FGF-2, IGF-I, and BMP-6 reversed the titanium-mediated suppression of osteogenic differentiation, BMP-6 being the most effective one. Various growth factors can mitigate the suppressive effects of titanium particles on MSCs and enhance cell proliferation, viability, and osteogenic differentiation.
Beta–tricalciumphosphate(β-TCP)coatinglayerisknown to be resorbed much faster than hydroxyapatite(HA), however, there has been few reports explaining the exact mechanism until now. Therefore, we investigated whether the resorption mechanisms of these two compounds are same, if not, what is the difference.
Eighty titanium discs with 12mm in diameter and 2mm in thickness were coated with HA(n=40) or β-TCP(n=40) by dip and spin coating method. In each group, the specimens were divided into 2 subgroups respectively; Dissolution (D, n=20) group and Osteoclast culture (C, n=20) group. The coated discs in D group were immersed in the cell culture media for 5 days, whereas, in C group, osteoclast-like cells (5×103 cells/500μ), which were isolated form human giant cell tumor, were seeded on the specimens and cultured for 5 days. Cultured cells were defined as osteoclast by the determination of osteoclast marker (tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase, TRAP). After immersion or osteoclast culture, the dissolution characteristics of coating surface were observed using light microscope (LM) and scanning electron microscope (SEM). And the area fraction of resorption lacunae formed by osteoclast was analyzed by image analysis to evaluate the activity of osteoclastic degradation.
After 5 days of dissolution, there were much more cracks and denuded areas in β-TCP coating compared to HA coating. In C group, the osteoclasts covering the coating layer were identified on LM and SEM images. Mean area fraction of resorption lacunae in HA-C group was 11.62%, which was significantly higher than that of 0.73% of β-TCP-C group (p=0.001).
We conclude that the resorption mechanism of HA and β-TCP coating layers was different each other in vitro study. The coated β-TCP was degraded mainly by dissolution and also tended to be separated from implant, on the other hand, the HA coating layer was resorbed by osteoclastic activity
Demineralized Bone Matrix (DBM) is currently used in various types of orthopaedic applications because of osteoconductive and osteoinductive properties. Fibrin glue is also used in cardiovascular and thoracic surgery due to its hemostatic, chemotactic and mitogenic properties. There is some possibility of being good biomaterial and biodegradable scaffold with DBM-fibrin glue mixture for bone void filler. After total hip replacement surgery, it takes long time to complete bone fusion. If patients have excess weight load after surgery, the artificial joint may not be adhered with patients’s bone.
That is why surgeons have to use any effective treatments for bone fusion for patient’s safety. In order to adapt to these surgical sites, DBMs are shaped in blocks or granules and preferable in porous forms. Combining these DBMs with fibrin glue provides a moldable and self-hardening composite biomaterial. This material will be applied to total hip replacement surgery for the effective fusion between bone and artificial joint. The aim of this work is to study the osteogenic properties of this composite material using in vivo and ex vivo. In radiological study, the DBM composite had been absorbed during one week since implantation surgery and after two weeks, some radio-opaque spots were observed in implantation sites. In histology study, Bone tissue had formed exotically in contact with the surface of the appeared well-mineralized, forming trabeculae between the granules, and had characteristics similar to those of cancellous bone. Bone growth in the tissue engineered filled with DBM and fibrin glue materials increased with implantation time.
In summary, these DBM and fibrin glue composites exhibited interesting biological and mechanical properties for filling large bone defect. These composites may be used in total hip replacement surgery for the effective filler between patient’s bone and artificial joint.
Bacterial infections related to orthopaedic implants is one of the serious types of complications. Recently, there has been a greater interest in antibacterial biomaterials. However, antibacterial evaluations of each material are inconsistant, so intercomparison of the antibacterial performance is difficult. This study focused on the Japanese Industrial Standards test (JIS Z2801), which is used for antibacterial evaluation of commodities. The study investigated a suitable evaluation method for in vitro antibacterial activity of biamaterials. In 2007, JIS Z2801 test was approved as international standard ISO 22196.
Hydroxyapatite (HA) powder containing 3 wt % of silver oxide (Ag) was sprayed on the surface of titanium disks with the thermal spraying method, using an acetylene torch. This coating has been proved to generate strong antibacterial activity in previous studies. The antibacterial activity was examined with the JIS Z 2801 test and modified JIS Z2801 test. The bacterial strains used in JIS Z2801 test were Escherichia coli (E.coli), Staphylococcus aureus (S.aureus). Bacterial culture medium was instilled onto the surface of the test disks (about 106 cells/ml) and covered with polystyrene films. After cultivation in 1/500 Nutrient Broth for 24 h at 35°C, the bacteria was washed out with the broth. The numbers of viable bacteria in the broth were counted with the agar plate culture method. Additionally, Modified JIS Z2801 test was performed. Modified points were added to the bacterial strain of biofilm-forming methicillin-resistant S.aureus (BF-MRSA), using Fetal Bovine Serum (FBS) as a culture medium, and cultivated at 37°C.
In the JIS Z2801 test, Antibacterial activity values of the HA-Ag disk were composed against E.coli 4.1 and S.aureus 5.0. In the modified JIS Z2801 test, antibacterial activity values against E.coli, S.aureus and BF-MRSA were 8.2, 5.5, and 7.1. When this value is greater than 2.0, it shows there is antibacterial activity. The titanium disk coated with HA-Ag showed antibacterial activity in both tests.
The JIS Z2801 test is designed to evaluate comodities in poor nutritional environment. However, the environment in the body is eutrophic. It is easy to make bacterial growth. For this reason, it is necessary to consider evaluating for biomaterials with suitable method considered in vivo. In this study, to examine the condition like that found in the body, we cultivated FBS at 37°C. In addition, the antibacterial activity against BF-MRSA was examined to consider the bacterial infection related to orthopaedic implants. The modified JIS Z2801 test showed that it is a suitable evaluation method for in vitro antibacterial activity of biomaterials.
Titanium alloys such as Ti-6Al-4V and Ti-6Al-7Nb have been widely used as orthopedic implants such as artificial hip joint, because of their high mechanical strengths and good biocompatibilities. Recently, new kinds of titanium-based alloys free from elements such as V and Al, which are suspicious for cytotoxicities, are being developed. Ti-15Zr-4Ta-4Nb (Ti-15-4-4) is one of such alloys and shows high mechanical strength and corrosion resistance which are comparable to those of the Ti-6Al-4V alloy. In the present study, chemical treatments for providing bone-bonding ability to this alloy were investigated. Apatite-forming ability in a simulated body fluid (SBF) was used as an indication of the bone-bonding ability.
Ti-15-4-4 alloy plates 10×10×1 mm3 in size were soaked in 5M-NaOH solution at 60 °C for 24 h, soaked in 100mM-CaCl2 solution at 40 °C for 24 h, heated at 600 °C for 1 h and then soaked in hot water at 80 °C for 24 h. Surface structural changes of the alloy with these treatments were analyzed by a field emission scanning electron microscope (FE-SEM) attached with an energy-dispersive X-ray spectrometer (EDX), Thin-film X-ray diffraction (TF-XRD) and Fourier transform confocal laser Raman spectroscopy (FT-Raman). Scratch resistance of surface layer of the alloy was measured by a thin-film scratch tester. Apatite-forming ability of the specimens was examined by soaking them in SBF for 3 days. Long-term stability of the apatite-forming ability was examined after keeping the specimens in an incubator with relative humidity of 95 % at 80 °C for 1 week.
A sodium hydrogen titanate layer about 500 nm in thickness was formed on the surface of the alloy by the NaOH treatment. This specimen formed some amounts of apatite in SBF within 3 days, but its scratch resistance was as low as less than 10 mN. When the NaOH-treated specimen was subsequently heat treated, the sodium hydrogen titanate transformed into sodium titanate to give scratch resistance as high as 92 mN, but lost its apatite-forming ability.
When the NaOH-treated specimen was soaked in CaCl2 solution, the sodium hydrogen titanate was isomorphously transformed into calcium hydrogen titanate. Thus treated specimen increased its apatite-forming ability, but its scratch resistance was still low. When the NaOH- and CaCl2-treated specimen was subsequently heat treated, the calcium hydrogen titanate transformed into calcium titanate to give scratch resistance as high as 169 mN. However, its apatite-forming ability was lost. Thus treated specimen was then soaked in hot water. As a result, its apatite-forming ability remarkably increased without decreasing scratch resistance. It showed high apatite-forming ability even after a long-term-stability test.
The NaOH-, CaCl2-, heat- and hot-water-treated Ti-15-4-4 alloy is believed to be promising materials for artificial joints, because of its high apatite-forming ability with long-term stability as well as high scratch resistance.
Kokubo and one of the present authors (T.N) have developed a new technique of bioactive coating using alkaline and heat treatment, which induces the formation of a thin HA layer on the surface of titanium after implantation in the body. This new coating technique is not associated with degradation or separation of the HA coating, because a bone-like apatite layer of 1 μm in width begins to form in the body tissue after implantation.
Chemically and thermally treated titanium possesses bone-bonding ability, which has been confirmed by detachment tests. Bone ingrowth into bioactive titanium continues to increase throughout the 26 weeks of implantation, whereas bone ingrowth into non-treated or HA plasma coating implants tends to decrease between 6 and 12 weeks. These findings suggest the long-term stability and osteoconduction of the bioactive layer of chemically and thermally treated titanium.
We carried out a series of 70 cementless primary total hip arthroplasties using this coating technique on a porous titanium surface, and followed up the patients for a mean period of 4.8 years. There were no instances of loosening or revision, or formation of a reactive line on the porous coating. Although radiography just after surgery showed a gap between the host bone and the socket in 70% of cases, all the gaps disappeared within a year, indicating the good osteoconduction provided by the coating. Alkaline-heat treatment of titanium to provide a HA coating has several advantages over plasma-spraying, including no degeneration or absorption of the HA coating, simplicity of the manufacturing process, and cost effectiveness. In addition, this method allows homogeneous deposition of bone-like apatite within a porous implant.
Although this was a relatively short-term study, treatment that creates a bioactive surface on titanium and titanium alloy implants has considerable promise for clinical application.
The osteoconductivity is the most desirable characteristic to achieve early fixation of the cementless-type artificial joints with bone. Apatite deposition on the surface of materials can induce the osteoconductivity in bony defect. In previous studies, various surface treatments have been proposed to provide titanium-based artificial joints with the osteoconductivity. The most popular surface treatment for commercial artificial joints is plasma-spray coating with apatite. Although the technique has been widely used for commercial artificial joints in the world, it remains some disadvantages attributed to high temperature during the process, such as fracture at the interface between metal and apatite, changes in the composition, crystallinity and structure of plasma-sprayed apatite. The chemical surface treatment with NaOH and H2O2 solution to provide spontaneous apatite-forming ability in the body could overcome the problems of plasma-spray process, since the treatments could be expected to not only continually express the apatite-forming ability in the body but also deposit the bone-like apatite having the similar crystal structure, crystallinity and composition of bone apatite. Therefore, surface treatments provided the spontaneous apatite-forming ability would be effective for titanium-based artificial joints with osteoconductivity.
Recently, our research group developed the extremely simple technique for providing the spontaneous apatite-forming ability to titanium by both spatial design and thermal oxidation, denoted as “GRAPE technology”. Pure titanium with machined micro-groove of less than 800 μm in depth and 1000 μm in width and thermally oxidized at 400°C in air induced apatite deposition in the internal space of micro-grooves during exposure to simulated body fluid. In this study, the application possibility of GRAPE technology was examined by using Ti-6Al-4V and Ti-15Zr-4Ta-4Nb. Apatite formed on the thermally oxidized Ti-15Zr-4Ta-4Nb at 500 and 600°C with micro-groove 500 μm wide and depth in the simulated body fluid for 7 days. In contrast, no apatite formation was observed on the thermally oxidized Ti-6Al-4V at 400, 500 and 600°C with micro-groove 500 μm wide and depth in the simulated body fluid for 7 days. Okazaki et al. reported that Ti-15Zr-4Ta-4Nb shows higher corrosion resistance, mechanical properties and cytocompatibility than Ti-6Al-4V. Hence, it is expected that the Ti-15Zr-4Ta-4Nb with GRAPE technology could be innovative cement-less artificial joints to achieve early fixation through its osteoconductivity and excellent performances.
Biocompatibility of Co-Cr alloy was significantly improved by forming rough TiO2 layer on the surface. The TiO2 layer was formed by coating the Co-Cr alloy with Ti through electron beam deposition followed by micro-arc oxidation (MAO) of the Ti. Biocompatibility of Co-Cr alloy was enhanced by coating with titanium, and it was improved further by micro-arc oxidation treatment. MAO process was dependent on the thickness of coated titanium layer and applied voltage. There were close relationships between the phase, morphology and thickness of TiO2 layer and the applied voltage. Biocompatibility of the specimens coated with Ti and MAO treated after Ti coating were evaluated by in vitro ALP activity tests.
Bacterial infection related to orthopaedic implants is a significant complication today. One of the ways to reduce the incidence of implant-associated infections is assumed to give antibacterial activity to surface of implant itself. We focused attention on Ag, because it has a broad antibacterial spectrum, strong antimicrobial activity and low toxicity. In the previous works, sputtering, electrochemically deposition and sol-gel coating of Ag-containing hydroxyapatite (HA) have been reported. However, since practical technique of HA coating widely used for medical and dental implants has been the “thermal spraying” technique over the last two decades, we aimed at developing the novel thermal spraying technology for Ag-HA coating with antibacterial activity. In this study, physical and chemical properties, in vitro antibacterial activity, inhibition activity of bacterial attachment, HA-forming ability, cytotoxicity and release of Ag ions of the thermal-sprayed Ag-HA coating were evaluated.
HA powder containing 3wt % of silver oxide (Ag2O) was sprayed on surface of titanium disks by the thermal spraying method using acetylene torch. SEM images showed a typical structure of the thermal-sprayed coating and the X-ray diffraction (XRD) pattern of the coating showed an amorphous structure. Ag residue in the coating was determined by the elementary analysis. The coating showed strong antibacterial activity and inhabitation activity of bacterial attachment to the methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) in fetal bovine serum (FBS). On the other hand, the coating showed fast HA-forming ability in simulated body fluid (SBF) and no cytotoxicity related to Ag contained in the coating. Therefore, it is expected that the thermal-sprayed Ag-HA coating provides antibacterial and bone-bonding ability on the surface of the implant itself. In addition, though the HA coating is generally liable to adhere bacteria, the thermal-sprayed Ag-HA coating overcomes this problem.
Pre-evaluation of release of Ag ions from the Ag-containing ceramic powders indicated that the releasing behavior of Ag ions in SBFs is dependent on the existing form of Ag in the Ag-containing material. It is assumed that most of Ag components in the Ag-HA coating are not retained as metallic Ag but as Ag2O in the amorphous layer. Time-course release tests of Ag ions from the coating in FBS showed a large release rate of Ag ions until 24 h after the immersion. It is expected that the Ag-HA coating could show strong antibacterial activity at the early post-operative stage. In the repeated release testing, the amount of released Ag ions was about 6500 ppb for the first release test, after which it gradually decreased. However, a significant release amount of Ag ions was observed even after the sixth repeat test. Therefore, it was assumed that the thermal-sprayed Ag-HA coating has a slow-release property of Ag ions in FBS.
Metal-on-metal bearing was re-introduced with the aim of eliminating polyethylene wear and resulting complications of osteolysis and aseptic loosening in total hip arthroplasty (THA). However, authors of recent studies have reported periprosthetic osteolysis and aseptic failure following second-generation metal-on-metal THA. The purpose of this study is to report the results at a minimum of five years following cementless total hip arthroplasty with a contemporary metal-on-metal articulation. Our study included findings of histologic examination on periprosthetic tissues from revised hips and wear and roughness analysis of retrieved implants.
A consecutive series of 158 cementless THAs that were performed in 154 patients using a contemporary metal-on-metal bearing were assessed at a mean of 6.5 years (5 to 8). Their mean age at surgery was 53 years (21 to 80). The patients were assessed clinically with use of the Harris hip score, and the hips were assessed radiographically. Histological analysis was performed on specimens retrieved from the revised hips, and wear and roughness measurements were made for the explanted prostheses.
The average Harris hip score improved from 45 points preoperatively to 92 points at the final follow-up examination. There was no aseptic loosening of the femoral or acetabular components. One hip was revised because of recurrent dislocation and one was managed with two-stage re-implantation for deep infection. Thirteen hips (8%) had osteolysis; 11 had osteolysis localized within the greater trochanter and two had both femoral and ace-tabular osteolysis. Of these, five patients who had a persistent pain and osteolysis underwent revision operation for the consideration of bearing exchange to a ceramic-on-ceramic or ceramic-on-polyethylene combination. All these revised hips showed extensive synovial-like tissue hypertrophy and perivascular infiltration of lymphocytes on histological examinations. Annual volumetric wear rate measured on one retrieved femoral head was 1.04mm3/yr, and roughness measured on three retrieved femoral heads was consistently very low between 8nm and 117nm. After the revision surgery, all the patients noticed disappearance of pain as well as radiographic evidence of healing of the osteolytic lesion.
Our mid-term follow-up of cementless THA using a contemporary metal-on-metal bearing revealed an unexpectedly high rate of periprosthetic osteolysis possibly in association with metal hypersensitivity. In patients with persistent hip pain and osteolysis after contemporary metal-on-metal THA, surgeons should consider an exchange of the articulation surface to a ceramic-on-ceramic or ceramic-on-polyethylene combination because they can be cured only after an elimination of the source of hypersensitivity reaction.
Metal on Metal coupling in total hip replacement has been widely used since many years. After the rebirth of resurfacing a new trend to use very large diameter metal-metal coupling with standard stem prostheses has been started. New prostheses, old and new problems. We analyze first failures with new large diameter metal on metal coupling.
The analysis focused on seven early failures of large diameter metal-metal prostheses (two resurfacing and five cementless prosthesis with XL head) over the first series of 350 cases (100 resurfacing and 250 cementless) in the first year. Synovial fluid aspiration have been performed in all failed patients searching for metal ions and bacterial proliferation. Moreover, prosthetic component positioning was also studied as a possible primum movens of these failures. Some failed patients underwent epicutaneous patch test for skin reaction to metal.
One resurface prosthesis failed as a result of an vascular necrosis and conseguent fracture of the femoral neck and revealed a moderate increment in metal ion concentration in blood and synovial fluid obtained at time of revision.
One resurface prosthesis failed as a result of an infected metallosis with a huge intraabdominal mass and revealed a huge increment in metal ion concentration in blood, addominal and synovial fluid. This patient underwent a lumbotomy to evacuate the abdominal retroperitoenal mass before prosthesis removal for a two step procedure.
Out of the five failures of metal on metal cementless prosthesis with XL head four were the result of aseptic loosening and one was the result of a low grade infection discovered at coltures after revision surgery. Three showed clear metallosis caused by wrong positioning (more than 50° of cup inclination). All of these three presented an articular noise and elevated blood and sinovial fluid metal ion concentration. The fourth patient with aseptic loosening had a good component positioning but demonstrated an epicutanous allergic reaction to Cobalt. Also one of the three patients with metallosis resulted allergic to Cobalt. The blood and sinovial metal ion values were always elevated but particularly high in patients with cup inclination over 50°.
Large head metal on metal prostheses demonstrated a higher percentage of early failure in our experience. They are very sensible to positioning. Blood and sinovial metal ion determination helps to promptly diagnose a bad metal on metal prosthetic functioning. A more accurate analysis about the different metals available on the market and their resistance to edge wear should not be delayed any further.
The purpose of this study is to identify clinical and radiographic results of 78 uncemented total hip arthroplasties using Metasul® metal on metal bearings with Wagner standard cup and proximal hydroxyapatite coated CLS stem.
Mean age was 39 years and average follow-up period was 11.7 years. Mean Harris hip score had improved from 51.4 points preoperatively to 95.2 points finally. There were 2 hips with progressive osteolysis around the acetabular cup. Of them, one hip was revised due to loosening of the cup, and the other was observed because of patient’s refusal to revise. In histopathologic findings on osteolytic area, a lot of macrophage phagocytizing metal debris and perivascular lymphocyte infiltration were found. Immunohistochemical analysis suggested delayed metal hypersensitivity. Serum cobalt levels in hips with osteolysis were not higher than those in hips without osteolysis.
Early osteolysis with sudden onset of groin pain in few hips remains a concern.
Little is published about the use of cementless conical stems in primary hip arthroplasty for congenital hip disease. A conical stem was designed in the 80’s by Prof. Wagner. The stem is made of a rough blasted titanium alloy with a cone angle of 5° and 8 sharp longitudinal “ribs” that cut into the inner cortex, designed to achieve rotational stability: The ribs depth of penetration ranges between 0.1 and 0.5 mm and is also very important to achieve osteo-integration. The CCD angle is 135°. The stem is straight and can be implanted in any degree of version thus being very useful for dysplastic arthritis with significant femoral neck anteversion.
Between 1993 and 1998 the senior author (RB) implanted 92 conical stems in 88 consecutive patients with dysplastic arthritis. The acetabular component was cementless and titanium with tridimensional porosity. The articulating surface was a second generation Metal-on-Metal.with a femoral head of 28 mm. According to the Hartofilakidis classification 63 patients had type A, 18 type B and 11 type C.
The average follow-up was 11.2 years (range 10.1–14.8)
Using the Harris Hip Scoring system we had 82 (89%) satisfactory results, with excellent correction of pre-op pain (42/44 Harris) and no case of anterior thigh pain; 88% of patients had no or slight limp at follow-up. No patient required revision of the stem, but one cup required revision for loosening (Type C class). We had one dislocation (1%) that was treated conservatively
Radiographically, all stems were osteo-integrated, 17% showed some resorption in femoral zone 1 and 7. In the same zones we observed 4 cases of real osteolysis without loosening. No radiolucent line was observed in other femoral zones. In the acetabular side we had 13 cases (14%) of radiolucency, but in only 1 case (1%) was it progressive.
A straight conical titanium femoral stem gave very satisfactory clinico-radiographical results in dysplastic arthritis at a mean of 11.2 years of follow-up.
Total hip replacement in the young active patient remains one of the major challenges in orthopaedics today. The use of ultra high molecular weight (UHMW) polyethylene acetabular liners is known to cause polyethylene wear related osteolysis, the major limiting factor in its use in the younger active patient. Modern alumina ceramic articulations have been developed in order to reduce wear and avoid polyethylene debris. This prospective randomized long-term study aims to compare the outcome between an alumina ceramic-on-ceramic (CC) articulation with a ceramic on UHMW polyethylene articulation (CP). In the younger active patient, is one option superior to the other with regard to patient satisfaction, osteolysis and implant longevity?
56 hips in 55 patients with mean age 42.2 (range 19–56) each received uncemented components (Wright Medical) and a 28mm alumina head with acetabular liner selected via sealed envelope randomization following anesthetic induction. Subsequent regular clinical and radiologic follow up measured patient outcome scores and noted any radiological changes.
26 CP hips and 30 CC hips were evaluated. One failure required revision in each group. Mean St Michael’s outcome score for each group with up to 10 years follow-up (median 8 years, range 1–10) was 22.8 and 22.9 respectively (p=0.057). Radiographs with a minimum 5 years post-operative follow-up were analyzed in 42 hips (23 CC and 19 CP). Radiolucency of all 3 acetabular zones was identified in one of the CP hips. There was no evidence of osteolysis or loosening identified in the remaining hips. The mean time of wear measurement for the CC group was 8.3 years (SD 1.3, Range 4.8–10.1 years) and for the CP group was 8.1 years (SD 0.9, Range 6.1–9.2 years)(p=0.471). Wear was identified in all but one of the CP replacements but only 12 of 23 CC articulations. The mean wear for the CC group was 0.14 mm (SD 0.16, Range 0–0.48 mm) and for the CP group was 0.89 mm (SD 0.6, Range 0–2.43 mm)(p< 0.001). Extrapolating the annual wear rate from these figures, the respective wear is 0.02mm for the CC group compared to 0.11mm per year for the CP group.
To our knowledge this is the first long term randomized trial comparing in vivo ceramic-on-ceramic with ceramic-on-conventional polyethylene hip articulations. Other than significantly greater wear in the polyethylene group there was no significant difference in long-term outcome scores between the two groups with up to 10 years of follow-up. The use of a ceramic-on-ceramic bearing is a safe and durable option in the young patient avoiding the concerns of active metal ions and osteolytic polyethylene debris. These patients remain under review.
Total Hip Arthroplasty (THA) has been more frequently performed for relatively young patients with osteonecrosis of the femoral head in Korea. Moreover, squatting and sitting with crossed legs are more common in Asian cultures than in Western cultures. Wear debris generated by conventional metal-on-PE articulations has been giving rise to extensive osteolysis. Due to these characteristics, higher incidence of pelvic osteolysis was observed after THA in Korea. As a result, interest in alternative bearings such as ceramic-on-ceramic bearing has been increased. Furthermore, the patients who require revision THA are still young in Korea. With this point of view, an application of ceramic-on-ceramic bearing throughout revision THA seems to be reasonable. The clinical and radiographical outcomes after revision THA with use of third generation ceramic-on-ceramic bearing in Korean patients were evaluated.
Total hip arthroplasty (THA) in patients with developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH) has been associated with increased rates of complications and revision. Hip instability and wear-induced osteolysis are among the more common and serious of these problems. The current investigation prospectively assessed the clinical results and the survivorship of patients with DDH treated by alumina ceramic-ceramic THA.
We investigated 164 consecutive hips in 147 patients with DDH. Twenty-five hips (15%) had prior surgery to improve acetabular coverage, 108 hips (66%) were classified as Crowe type I, 21 (13%) as type II, and 10 (6%) as type III. All patients had an uncemented titanium acetabular component with a flush mounted alumina ceramic-ceramic bearing and were treated between 1997 and 2006. The mean age at operation was 48.5 ± 12.2 years (range, 18–75 years). The preoperative Merle d’Aubigné score was 11.3 ± 1.6 (6–15). Ninety-four hips (57%) were replaced with the use of surgical navigation for acetabular component positioning. The mean cup diameter was 51.2 ± 3.9 mm (46–60 mm). Seventy-seven (47%) bearings were 28mm and 87 (53%) bearings were 32mm.
At a mean follow-up of 4.5 ± 2.3 years (2–10 years), the mean Merle d’Aubigné score was 17.5 ± 1.2 (14–18). There were no cases of osteolysis or dislocation. There was one reoperation of an early displaced cup. In addition, there was one calcar crack that was cerclaged, one intraoperative trochanteric fracture also repaired at surgery. No patient complained of squeaking. Ninety-four patients with 100 hips (61%) completed a questionnaire specifically concerning squeaking. None of these patients reported on squeaking either. The 10-year Kaplan Meier survivorship of the implants (revision of any component for any reason) was 99.1% (95% confidence interval 98.0–100%).
Results of ceramic-ceramic THA in young patients with low to middle graded DDH after two to ten year follow-up are promising with no radiographic signs of osteolysis or dislocation.
Expecting the low wear property and the longevity, since October 1998, we have been using the alumina on alumina bearing for the hip arthroplasty. Until July 2008, for dysplastic 1078 hips we have implanted the bearing couple. Among them, we evaluated 86 hips in 79 patients (male 3, female 76) with the primary arthroplasty, Spongiosa Metal II Total Hip System (GHE: ESKA implants, Lübeck, Germany/Biolox Forte®: Ceramtec AG, Plochingen, Germany), osteoarthritis secondary to developmental dysplasia, age 60 or below, and a minimum of five years follow-up. The preoperative diagnosis included the failed pelvic and/or femoral osteotomy, avascular necrosis after DDH, dislocation, and subdislocation. The average age at the surgery was 53 (27 to 60). The average of follow-up period was 6.3 (4.6 to 9.1) years. The implants have a macro-porous structure on the surface. To set the metal shell in the intended position, the sclerotic lesion was adequately resected by the chisels and then we used the acetabulum reamers. Otherwise the sclerotic lesion would prevent the reamer to go into the suitable direction. We reamed the acetabulum until the lamina interna to use the maximum size of the metal shell (i.e. to use the liner as thick as possible) and at the same time for the medialization of the hip center. To avoid impingement, the osteophyte was resected without hesitating. We added the adductor tenotomy for 19 hips, the extensive release of the flexor tendons (including the quadriceps origin, the sartroius origin, and the gluteus maximus insertion) for three hips, and the release of the extensor insertion (the gluteus maximus) for two hips, and the release of the flexor insertion (the iliopsoas) for two hips.
The hip score was improved in all patients. The average amount of the hip score was 59 before the surgery and was 90 at the final follow-up. A positive Trendelenburg sign was observed in 53 hips (62%) before the surgery and 12 hips (14%) at the final follow-up. We had no revision, no bearing failure (alumina fracture or excessive wear), no dislocation, and no squeaking in these patients. The average inclination angle of the cup was 41 (29 to 49) degrees. The average anteversion angle of the cup was 19 (13 to 27) degrees. No patient required the revision surgery. At the final follow-up, all implants were stable. In the acetabulum, the radio-lucent line was observed in two hips (2%) (zone I). In the femur the line was observed in 13 hips (15%). All lines existed in the proximal femur. There was no cystic osteolytic lesion. The prevalence of these periprosthetic reactions was less than those in the same type implant with the polyethylene on alumina bearing.
Some authors alerted that the alumina on alumina articulation should only be applied in when the optimized implant orientation is obtained so as to prevent the impingement and dislocation. Fortunately the alignment in this study was within the safe zone. However, we must always be very careful of the joint alignment, range of motion, and the muscle tension during the surgery to avoid the bearing failure, as setting an adequate alignment and obtaining a firm uncemented fixation of the cup is relatively difficult in dysplastic hips. From this view point, Spongiosa Metal II cup suits the use of the alumina on alumina bearing especially for dysplastic hips.
Previous studies suggested that the shallow Ultra High Molecular Weight Polyethylene (UHMWPE) acetabular socket liner or the liner with no head centre inset can significantly increase the risk of hip joint dislocation. Independent to the traditional neck impingement models, the purpose of this study was to investigate an additional dislocation force pushing the femoral head out of UHMWPE acetabular liner bearing under direct hip joint loading and the factors including the head centre inset affecting the magnitude of this force. The 3 D Finite Element Analysis (FEA) models were constructed by (30) 10 mm thick UHMWPE liners with six inner bearing diameters ranging from 22 mm to 44 mm and five head centre insets in each bearing size from 0 mm to 2 mm. A load of 2 446 N was applied through the corresponding CoCr femoral head to the rim of the liner. The DF was recorded as a function of head centre inset and head diameter. The results were verified by the physical tests of two 28 mm head bearing liners with 0 and 1.5 mm head centre insets respectively.
The results showed that the highest DF was 1 269N in 0 mm head centre inset and 22 mm head. The lowest DF was 171 N in 2 mm head centre inset and 44 mm head. The DF decreased as the head centre inset and head size increased. When head centre inset increased from 0 mm to 1 mm, the DF was reduced more than 50%. Two experimental data points were consistent with the trend of DF curve found in the FEA.
We concluded that the new intrinsic dislocating force DF can be induced by the rim directed joint loading force alone and can reach as high as 51% of the femoral loading force. This can be the addition to the dislocating moment generated by the neck impingement. A head inset above 1mm can effectively reduce DF to less than 25% of the joint force. Furthermore, the larger head diameter generates less DF. The DF is likely caused by the wedge effect between the deformed polyethylene bearing and the femoral head. The inset allows the femoral head to be separated from the spherical bearing surface, thus reducing the wedge effect. Our observation of the stabilizing effect trend of the head centre inset was consistent with reported clinical data. However, the increased height of the capture wall also reduces the range of motion. It is therefore necessary to minimize the inset height with the maximum benefit of the stabilize effect. This study suggested the larger femoral head has the advantage of reducing the DF and the stabilizing effect is more effective when combining with the inset wall. The result of this study should provide the guidance to improve acetabular poly liner design for better joint stability.
We suggested a new concept of buffered implant fixation. It is a cementless fixation using a buffer instead of the cement between the bone and the implant. We investigated the feasibility of the buffered implant fixation using a rat model. In our previous study, we measured the amount of bone around the implant to compare the buffered implant fixation with the cemented fixation. The results showed the difference in change of Bone Volume/Total Volume (BV/TV) with time between the buffered fixation and the cemented fixation. Now, in this study, we are comparing the mechanical interface strength between two fixations.
After micro CT scanning, the specimens were used for mechanical push-out test to measure the interface shear strength at the buffer-bone or cement-bone interface. The distal side of the femur was carefully removed to expose the whole distal region of the implant while the proximal side of femur was cut carefully with diamond saw (Metsaw, R& B Inc., Korea) until the proximal end of cement or buffer is exposed. The femur was embedded into a push-out jig with a plaster. The push-out jig was mounted in a material testing machine (KSU-10M, Kyungsung testing machine, Korea) and loaded at a rate of 0.01mm/s. The apparent interface strength was calculated by dividing the peak force by the surface area of the buffer or cement.
After 2 weeks, the apparent interface strength is 217.0 ± 280.0(average ± standard deviation) for buffer and 472.4 ± 381.1 for cement; after 4 weeks, 92.9 ± 67.6 and 268.1 ± 197.9; after 12 weeks, 441.9 ± 467.1 and 201.8 ± 132.3, respectively. The buffered fixation showed gain in strength with time while the cemented fixation showed reverse tendency but the interaction by ANOVA was not significant (p=0.125). Even though the excellence of buffer fixation was not clearly confirmed because of small sample size and high variance, the feasibility of the buffer fixation was shown.
However, further studies are necessary to improve the buffered implant fixation. To enhance the cell adhesion and biocompatibility, it is necessary to modify the surface of polyetheretherketone (PEEK) such as by plasma treatment or biological coating. Also, an animal test using a higher level animal such as dog or pig is necessary.
The primary fixation of cementless hip prostheses is related to the shape of the stem. When there is a complication of loading in several directions, the mechanical fixation of a hip stem is considered to provide good primary fixation. The purpose of this study was to evaluate whether the IMC stem with its characteristic fixation method, which was developed by a group at Kitasato University, contributes to primary fixation by finite element analysis.
Analysis was performed at a friction coefficient of 0.1 with automatic contact, under the restriction of the distal femoral end. The following three loading conditions were applied:
step loading of the joint resultant force in the region around the hip stem, loading in the rotational direction, simulating torsion, and loading of the femoral head equivalent to that during walking.
Micromotion of the IMC stem along the x-, y-, and z-axes direction was calculated by simulation, and the stress distributed on the stem and femur was determined.
Micromotion along the z-axis, which is a clinical problem in hip prosthesis stems, was lower in the IMC stem than in other stems reported. Micromotion of the stem along the z-axis was low, indicating a low risk of sinking. The interlocking mechanism, which is a characteristic of the IMC stem, functioned to suppress its micromotion, indicating that the locking method of this stem contributed to the stability. Since no stress concentration was detected, it was considered that there are no risks of breakage of the IMC stem and femur.
It was suggested that effective fixation of the finite element model of the IMC stem can be achieved because the micromotion and stress level are appropriate for primary fixation.
The operation technique and prosthetic materials for total hip replacement (THR) have continuously improved. Still, defining the end-point of the prosthetic stem insertion into the femur canal relies on the feeling of the orthopaedic surgeon. This consists of a sense of mechanical stability when exerting torque forces on the prosthesis as well as a feeling of the prosthesis being well fixed and not displaceable along the axis of the femur. Stability and survival of the implant is directly related to the long term fixation stability of the prosthesis stem. But, excessive press-fitting of a THR femoral component can cause intra-operative fractures.
In our centre custom made stem prostheses are commonly used to increase the optimal fit in the femoral canal. We report the first per-operative use of a non invasive vibration analysis technique for the mechanical characterization of the primary bone-prosthesis stability.
From in vitro studies a protocol has been derived for per-operative use. The prosthesis neck is attached to a shaker using a stinger provided with a clamping system. The excitation is realized through white noise in the range 0–12.5 kHz, introducing a power of approximately 0.5W into the femur-prosthesis system. The input force and the response acceleration are measured in the same point with an impedance head mounted between the shaker and the stinger. The Frequency Response Function (FRF) is measured and recorded by a Pimento vibration analyzer connected to a portable computer provided with the appropriate software. All equipment is installed in the surgical theatre but outside the so-called laminar flow area.
The surgeon inserts the implant in the femoral canal through repetitive controlled hammer blows. After each blow, the FRF of the implant-bone structure is measured directly on the prosthesis neck. The hammering is stopped when the FRF graph does not change noticeably anymore.
The amount of FRF change between insertion steps is quantified by the Pearson’s correlation coefficient R between successive FRFs. A correlation between the FRFs of successive stages of R=(0.99 +/− 0.01) over the range 0–10000 Hz is proposed as an endpoint criterion.
Non-cemented custom made stem insertion was studied in 30 patients. In 26/30 cases (86.7%), the correlation coefficient between the last two FRFs was > 0.99 when the surgeon stopped the insertion. In 4 cases, the surgeon decided to stop the insertion because of suspected bone fragility, the final correlation coefficient was lower.
In one case an abnormal change in the FRF graph triggered inspection of the femur bone. A small fracture was observed and insertion was stopped.
In a second case FRF graph showed an oscillating behaviour, while the stem was visibly not completely inserted. After withdrawal of the stem and readjustment of the femoral canal, the stem could be reinserted and the Pearson’s correlation index at end of insertion was 0.998.
The use of custom made stem prosthesis, made exactly to fit into the femoral canal increases the risk of excessive press fit and intra-operative fractures. Vibration analysis showed to be a useful tool to define end of the stem insertion.
Distance from central axis of the stem to inside wall of the femoral cortex (A) and distance from central axis of the stem to the surface of the stem (B) were measured. We defined B/A as cortex-stem ratio and mapped it on the surface of the stem like contour lines.
One of the most important characteristic of the developmental dysplastic hip (DDH) is high anteversion in femoral neck. Neck-shaft angle is also understood to be higher (i.e. coxa-valga) in DDH femora. From this understanding many DDH intended stems were designed having larger neck shaft angle.
According to the result of our prior study; reported in ISTA 2005 etc.; using computer 3-D virtual surgery of high fit-and-fill lateral flare stem into high anteversion patients, it was revealed that the geometry of proximal femur itself does not have big difference from normal femora but they are only rotated blow lessertrochanter.
It is very important to know what anteversion is, and where anteversion is located, to design a better stem and to decide more proper surgical procedures for DDH cases with high anteversion.
In the present study, the geometry of 57 femora was assessed in detail to reveal the geometry of anteversion and its location in the DDH femora.
Fifty seven CAT scan data with many causes were analyzed. Thirty-two DDH, 3 Rheumatic Arthritis (RA), 2 metastatic bone tumors, 4 avascular necrosis (AVN), 1 knee arthritis, 12 injuries, and 3 normal candidates were included. Whole femoral geometries were obtained from CAT scan DICOM data and transferred to CAD geometry data format. All the following landmarks were measured its direction by the angle from posterior condylar line. The assessed landmarks were
anteversion, lesser trochanter, linea aspera at the middle of the femur, and two more (upper 1/6, 2/6 level of aspera) linea aspera directions were assessed between ii) and iii).
All the directions were measured by the angle from the medial of the femur.
The direction of anteversion and lesser trochanter were well correlated, (R=0.55, Y=0.56X−35) i.e. femoral head and lesser trochanter were rotated together.
The direction of lesser trochanter and aspera in upper 1/6 section had no relation even they are located very close with only several cm distance, (R=−0.03, Y=−0.02X−88) i.e. however the lesser trochanter was rotated, the upper most aspera was located almost at the same direction (−87.5+/−7.58 degree).
The direction of aspera at upper 1/6 and middle femur were strongly correlated. (R=0.63, Y=0.81X-22) i.e. they stay at the same direction.
The results mean that the anteversion is a twist between normal proximal femur (from femoral head and lesser trochanter) and normal distal femur. The twist was located just blow lesser trochanter within several centimeter.
The anteversion has been understood as the abnormal mutual position between femoral neck and femoral shaft. In high anteversion hips the neck shaft angle was also believed to be higher, so several DDH oriented stems have higher neck shaft angle i.e. coxa-valga geometries. It has been believed that the location of the anteversion was around neck part. This study revealed that the deformity was located in the very narrow part just below lesser trochanter. It has been discussed that DDH oriented stems should have fit to different canal geometries, but understanding the biomechanics of abnormal anteversion and its treatment should be more important.
In almost all countries performing Total Hip Replacement (THR), dislocation is one of the major reasons for revision. Hence, in the last years the trend to larger bearings has been observed, following an improve in the bearing materials, the operation technique, and fixation techniques of stem and shell. Larger bearings allow for more range of motion and higher stability than conventional 28 mm bearing couples, leading to a better postoperative mobility. On the other hand, size limitations on the acetabular side are given by the anatomy of the human pelvic bone as well as the deformation and fracture behaviour of the used artificial materials. Therefore, the best solution to be achieved provides a maximum physiological outcome along with a minimised risk of intraoperative and in-vivo failures.
Investigating the wall thickness of the metal shell which is press-fitted in the human pelvic bone, the general trend towards a smaller wall thickness yielding an increased compliance can be observed with larger bearing diameters. This may lead to deformations of the metal shell making it difficult for the surgeon to properly introduce the insert. Hence, taking into account that a proper seating of the insert is absolutely necessary when using a ceramic insert in order to avoid point loads, operation time may strongly increase especially when minimal invasive surgery technique is used. With decreasing overall wall thickness of the acetabular components the volumetric stresses increase by definition. Therefore, an optimal component coupling between insert and metal shell is necessary in order to avoid point loads and resulting stress concentrations. With pre-assembled systems, this optimal coupling is reached by the force-controlled insertion of the insert in the metal shell without any prior deformation of the shell. This procedure enables to design acetabular components with a much lower overall wall thickness than conventional systems. As an example, in the case of the DELTA motion system, this overall wall thickness has been decreased to 5 mm allowing e.g. for a usage of a 36 mm bearing couple together with a 46 mm outer diameter of the metal shell. Additionally, the coating of the metal shell allows for direct bone ingrowth. Problems involved with larger bearing diameters may also arise from higher wear rates inducing possibly osteolysis and aseptic loosening. Investigations concerning the wear behaviour of large ceramic bearings have shown that there is no increase in the wear volume with increasing diameter.
Total hip arthroplasty (THA) often requires complex reconstruction for acetabular bone defect in patients with developmental dysplasia. We performed autogenous bulk structural bone grafting to deal with the lack of acetabular bone stock. The purpose of the present study was to assess the clinical and radiographic results after mean follow-up of 12 years.
Between April 1992 and December 1997 the single senior author performed 75 consecutive primary THA for patients with degenerative osteoarthritis. Acetabular bone grafting was performed for 27 joints. Of these, six patients (six hips) were lost to follow up. Left 20 patients (21 hips) included in the study. There were two male and 18 female with a mean age at the time of the operation of 54.5 years (40–66 years). The mean duration of follow-up was 12 years (8–15 years). The diagnosis for all hips at the time of operation was secondary osteoarthritis due to developmental dysplasia. The degree of subluxation as categorized according to the classification of Crowe et al was group I in 11 hips, group II in 6 hips, group III in 4 hips. All operations were performed through a posterolateral approach using the femoral head for the graft. The grafts were screwed to the superolateral aspect of the acetabular roof. We used the Bioceram implant (Kyocera, Kyoto, Japan) with a 26 mm alumina-ceramic head. Both acetabular and femoral components were fixed with cement using the double-thumb technique in all procedures. Harris hip score was used for clinical evaluation. Standard anteroposterior radiographs were used for radiographic evaluation. The presence of a radiolucent line at the cement-bone interface in the three zones of DeLee and Charnley was recorded. Loosening of the acetabular component was classified according to the criteria of Hodgkinson et al. The remodeling process of the grafted bone was analyzed according to the method described by Knight et al. The initial postoperative anteroposterior radiographs were measured to define the proportion of the socket covered by bone graft according to the method described by Inao and Matsuno.
The mean Harris hip score improved from 45.0 (24–60) before operation to 90.4 (77–100) at the final follow-up. At the final follow-up, 13 sockets showed the presence of a radiolucent line at the cement-bone interface and three sockets showed radiological evidence of loosening. According to the criteria of Hodgkinson et al, two sockets were type 3 and one were type 4. Bridging tarbeculation across the graft-host interface was seen in all cases. One case had the graft collapsed with migrated socket. The mean proportion of the socket covered by bone graft was 23.1% (9.8–42.3%). Three patients with loosed sockets had candidate for revision surgery, but no revision surgery was done because they had mild pain and did not demand the operation.
Autogenous bulk structural bone grafting for reconstruction of the acetablum presented favorable results during mean follow-up of 12 years in the condition that the proportion of coverage of graft was less than 50%.
Cemented acetabular components continue to be used in more than half of the total hip replacements performed in the United Kingdom. The implants are relatively inexpensive but the results rely heavily on precise surgical technique, with restoration of the centre of rotation of the hip and the creation of an equal cement mantle with good pressurisation and penetration of the cement into the bone.
The Opera all polyethylene acetabular component was designed with a malleable flange, which could be independently pressurised, a long posterior wall to promote stability and instrumentation which ensured that pressurisation could be maintained throughout the curing process.
We present for the first time, the medium-term results of 409 consecutive cemented flanged Opera acetabular components performed in 374 patients.
247 operations were performed via a trochanteric osteotomy and 162 via a posterior approach, using multiple key holes, cement pressurisation and Palacos-R cement. Autograft was used in 32 cases.
Cemented femoral components were used in all cases. There were 241 Charnley stems with 22mm heads and 168 polished triple tapered C-stems (146 with 22mm heads and 22 with 26mm heads).
The average age at the time of surgery was 68.2 years (32–87) and the average duration of follow-up was 89 months (60–130). 54 patients (56 hips) died during the follow-up period.
The acetabulum was assessed using the zones of DeLee and Charnley, and the Hodgkinson classification.
There was one temporary femoral nerve palsy, two dislocations and 3 non-fatal pulmonary emboli.
Both components were revised in two hips for deep sepsis, and in two hips only the femoral implant was revised, one for a fractured stem and one for aseptic loosening, with the original acetabular components remaining in situ.
Of the remaining original acetabular components 6% have shown progressive radiological demarcation, none have migrated, but in two hips there is evidence of rapid wear and the development of osteolysis.
Since 1993, we have been developing preoperative planning system based on CAT scan data. In early period it was used to decide cup diameter and orientation for Total Hip Arthroplasty (THA). It was done using hemisphere object locating proper position and orientation. According to our progress, we have started using it for custom stem designing, stem selection and stem size planning too since 1995. Since 2001, we have been using it for almost all THA cases. We also have started use it for any case we have question about 3D geometries. Since 2005 we started computer planed 2 staged THA after leg elongation for high riding hips and reported at ISTA 2007 too. Now our policy became that every tiny question we have, we shall analyze and plan preoperatively.
In our population, the incidence of the developmental dysplastic hips is higher. The necks often have bigger anteversion, and less acetabular coverage. So we often use screws for cup fixation. The screw direction allowed in thin shell thickness is limited and less bone coverage makes good cup fixation difficult. With highly defected cases and with revision cases the situation is more difficult.
In the present study, we have developed acetabular 3D preoperative planning method with screw direction, length, and for the cases with defect, cup supporter pre-shaping with models and prediction of the allograft volume.
For the less defect cases, geometries of cup with screw holes were requested to the maker and were provided for us. Screws were attached perpendicular to each screw hole. Screw geometries have marks at every 5mm to plan proper length. The cup was located as much as closer to the original acetabular edge, keeping in the limit to avoid dislocation. Small space above the cup was accepted if anterior and posterior cup edge could be supported by original bone. Then the cup was rotated until we can obtain proper screw fixation.
For the cases with severe defects, we use cup supporters and allografts. Cup supporters are designed to be bent and fit to the pelvis during the surgery. But to shape it a properly; for good coverage and strong support; is very difficult and takes long through the limited window with fatty gloves. And mean while we get more bleeding. The geometries were obtained by CAT scan of the devices. Then proper size was determined as cup size. Chemiwood model was made and proper size supporter was opened and bent preoperatively using the model. It was scanned again and compared to the pelvic geometry again.
Using cluster cups, no dangerous screw was found as long as normal cup orientation was decided and screws were less than 30mm. Posterior screws were often too short then rotated anterior and found to have good fixation. Pre-bending could reduce surgical time remarkably.
As long as we could know, no navigation system can control the cup rotation. But acetabular preoperative planning was very useful and could reduce operative invasion. It could be done easily without using navigation system.
One of the drawbacks of cemented total hip arthroplasty (THA) is aseptic loosening after long period, major reason for which is bioinertness of PMMA bone cement. To improve longevity of THA, interface bio-active bone cement technique combined with modern cementing technique has been used in our institute, and was evaluated clinically and radiologically.
The present study includes 44 cases of primary THA with an average age at operation of 64 years old (ranging 48 to 81). Mean postoperative follow up period was 4 (ranging 3.5 to 5) years.
Pre- and postoperative evaluation using Merle d’Aubigné score were 8.0 and 16.2 points, respectively. Postoperative cementing grade using Barrack’s classification was A or B. At final follow up, radiolucent line at bone-cement interface was not observed, except one case of rheumatoid arthritis patient at zone 3 described by Delee and Charnley in the acetabular side. Neither osteolysis nor loosening was observed in every case. No major complications, such as infection, dislocation, pulmonary embolization, were observed.
The present study revealed excellent short-term result was obtained by IBBC technique combined with modern cementing technique for primary THAs. Most important technical point required for IBBC is to obtain dry bony surface just before cementing. Compressive reamed bone and gauze packing was effective for complete hemostasis just before cementing for the acetabular side, and plugging the isthmus using bone chips was effective for reducing bleeding for the femoral side.
The use of polished femoral implants employing the taper-slip philosophy now dominates the cemented portion of the hip arthroplasty market in the United Kingdom. Despite this fact, there have been very few published or presented series reporting the medium to long-term results of double tapered implants and only one previously reported series looking at the results of the triple tapered stem.
We present the results of 500 consecutive polished triple tapered C-stem femoral components performed in 455 patients.
All operations were performed using a posterior appproach, with cemented all polyethylene acetabular components and the use of third generation femoral cementing techniques, restrictors, centralisers and Pala-cos-R cement.
There were 282 female patients (62%) and 173 males (38%). The average age at the time of surgery was 68.3 years (23 to 92), with an average duration of follow-up of 71 months (36 to 112). 47 patients (51 hips) died during the follow-up period at an average of 54 months (1–87).
There were 3 dislocations, 2 on one occasion and one twice, at an average of 4 years. There were 2 deep infections, one of which required revision, and 4 non-fatal pulmonary emboli. There were 3 undisplaced trochanteric cracks treated by cerclage wiring and 3 nerve palsies: 2 femoral (temporary) and one sciatic (permanent). There was only one case of significant heterotopic ossification (Brooker Class 4).
The stem was neutral in 89% of cases, varus in 7% and valgus in 4%. Subsidence within the cement mantle occurred in 79% of cases, with an average of 0.87mm. 9 stems subsided 2 to 4mm but all stopped at 2 years and there was no further subsidence thereafter.
One hip was revised for deep infection but none of the remaining implants demonstrated any progressive radiolucencies in any Gruen zones and none demonstrated any features suggestive of current or future loosening. There was no evidence of negative bone remodelling.
The data was collected prospectively and the study is ongoing.
Hip resurfacing has many advantages such as proximal bone conservation and easy revision including conversion to total hip arthroplasty. The major complication in the hip resurfacing is notching at the lateral cortical bone and fracture of the neck. In this research, we simulated the range of direction of reaming without causing notch.
One left femur model was used for the simulation. The femoral head was fitted by a sphere and the origin of Cartesian coordinate was set at the center of the sphere. The simulation was made by imposing a cylindrical cut to the femoral head in varying direction and location. The existence of notching was decided comparing the maximum distance from reaming axis to neck section contour and the radius of cylindrical cut. If the maximum distance is bigger than the radius of cut, the notching exists and vice versa. We simulated existence of notching by varying inclination(α) from 20 to 70 degrees, anteversion(β) from 0 to 30 degree and depth passing through the head center(d) from 0 to 5mm. The implant used for the simulation was Durom®, Zimmer©. We selected the implant size that is close to the fitted sphere of femoral head.
No notching was made for any direction when the depth d was less than 2mm. When the depth was 3mm, notching did not generate in the range of α from 43 degrees to 60 degrees and β from 0 to 25 degrees. When the range of depth was from 4mm to 5mm, notching did not generate in ranges of α from 41 degrees to 60 degrees and β from 0 to 29 degrees. The no-notching angle range had tendency increasing slightly when the depth was increased. The angle between the stem of the implant and the neck shaft axis without notching can be calculated from the angle α. When the depth was from 4mm to 5mm, the corresponding angle between stem of implant and the shaft axis was from 120 degrees to 139 degrees.
Variability in femoral head preparation and high cement pressures may be associated with failure to seat femoral components during hip resurfacing. Furthermore, excessive pressures may lead to over penetration of bone by cement with resulting necrosis of the underlying bone. We designed an experimental model to test the hypothesis that partial-length pressure-relief slots made longitudinally in the proximal bone of the femoral head, without extending to the head neck junction, would allow controlled leakage of cement during initial insertion of a femoral head resurfacing component, but would then become sealed during final insertion to prevent excessive loss of cement while still allowing accurate seating of the component.
Thirty-one resurfacing femoral components were cemented onto foam femoral head models. The clearance between foam model and implant was measured to determine the minimum space available for cement. Eleven components were inserted using hand pressure alone, 20 were hammered. Pressure relief slots were prepared in 10 femoral heads. The slots, 4mm deep grooves, were made in the proximal bone only, without extending to the head-neck junction. Cement pressure inside the component was measured during insertion. Implants were sectioned after implantation in order to determine whether they had been fully seated or not. The clinical relevance of the measures taken was tested by measuring the diameter of prepared femoral heads during 20 hip resurfacing operations in order to determine the extent of variability in intra-operative femoral head preparation.
Mean intraoperative clearance between bone and implant was −0.19mm (0.11 to −0.93mm). Mean clearance between foam model and implant was −0.30mm (0.35 to −0.94mm). Full seating was obtained in 22/31 components. Of those not fully seated, all had clearance less than −0.74mm. Full seating with a clearance of less than −0.35mm was only possible when pressure relief slots had been made in the femur. The use of a pressure relief slot longer than half the femoral head length allowed full seating in 9/9 cases, compared to 13/22 without. Cement pressure obtained with a hand pressure technique was less than half that observed with hammering (20.8vs56.0psi, p=0.0009) but was not associated with failure to seat the implant if a slot was used.
Variability of the actual diameter of the femoral head prepared may be associated with difficulty in fully seating resurfacing components. The same degree of variability in the space available for cement was observed in both intra-operative and test specimens. The use of a pressure-relief slot allows full seating of resurfacing implants with hand pressure alone, thereby halving cement pressure, in an experimental model, even when clearance between implant and bone is less than optimal.
In May 2006, the US FDA approved the first type of metal-on-metal hip resurfacing (MOMHR) for distribution in the US because of promising survivorship achieved in Europe for patients with a diagnosis of primary osteoarthritis. No long-term US survivorship data currently exists for the Birmingham Hip Resurfacing (BHR) implant. The purpose of this study was to demonstrate early efficacy with validated outcome measures and survivorship comparable to total hip arthroplasty (THA).
A cohort of 79 consecutive MOMHR patients was compared to a similar cohort of 71 THA patients, controlling for age, gender and comorbidities. Mean f/u was 14.1±5 mos (range 12–24 mos). The mean age for the MOMHR group was 50±9 yrs, and mean body mass index (BMI) was 29±5. The THA group had a mean age of 52±9 yrs and a mean BMI of 30±6. Outcomes were prospectively assessed with the SF-12 and WOMAC.
For both groups, pre-op pain and function scores were similar. At 1 yr f/u, MOMHR showed significantly more improvement (p< 0.05) in stiffness, pain and physical function compared to the THA. The overall complication rate was 7% in the MOMHR group and 9% in the THA group. There were no instances of displaced femoral neck fracture, component loosening, dislocation or chronic deep infection in any patient in the MOMHR cohort.
These early results are promising, but longer-term follow-up is needed to properly compare MOMHR to THA which remains the current gold standard.
Metal-on-metal hip resurfacing has been introduced recently, due to its potential advantages of biomechanics and biotribology. However, a number of problems have been identified from clinical retrievals, including significant elevation of wear when the implant is mal-positioned. Our hypothesis is that implant mal-position and micro-lateralisation can result in edge contact, leading to increases in wear. The aim of this study was to investigate the combined effect of cup position and micro-lateralisation on the contact mechanics of metal-on-metal hip resurfacing prosthesis, in particularly to identify conditions which resulted in edge contact.
Finite element (FE) method was used. A generic metal-on-metal hip resurfacing prosthesis was modelled. The bearing diameters of the femoral head and acetabular cup components were 54.49mm and 54.6mm respectively, with a diametral clearance between the head and the cup of 0.11mm. The resurfacing components were implanted into a hemi-pelvic hip joint bone model and all the materials in the FE model were assumed to be homogenous, isotropic and linear elastic (Udofia et al 2007). The FE models consisted of approximately 80,000 elements, which were meshed in I-DEAS (Version 11, EDS, USA) and solved using ABAQUS (Version 6.7-1, Dassault Systèmes). For this study, the femoral component was fixed with an inclination angle of 45° and an anteversion angle of 10°. The orientation of the acetabular cup was varied, using inclination angles of 35° and 65°, and anteversion angles between −10° to 30°. Contact at the bearing surface between the cup and femoral head was modelled using frictionless surface-based elements, simulating a fully lubricated situation, as coefficients of friction less than 0.1 would not have appreciable effects on the predicted contact mechanics. The femoral component was fixed into the femur (except the guide pin) using PMMA cement with an average thickness of approximately 1mm. The other contact interfaces in the FE model (cup/acetabulum, cement/bone and cement/femoral component) were all assumed to be rigidly bonded. The hip joint model was loaded through a fixed resultant hip joint contact force of 3200N, and was applied through medial, anterior muscle forces and subtrochanteric forces to simulate the mid-to-terminal stance phase (approximately 30% – 50%) of the gait cycle (Bergmann et al., 1993). Micro-lateralisation was modelled through displacing the femoral head laterally, up to 0.5mm, relative the centre of the cup.
Edge contact was detected once the inclination angle became greater than 65°. The effect of ante-version was to further shift the contact area towards the edge of the cup, nevertheless no edge contact was found for ante-version angles up to 25° and inclination angles below 55°. However, when the micro-lateralisation was introduced, edge contact was detected at a much smaller inclination angle. For example, even with a micro-lateralisation of 0.5 mm, edge contact occurred at an inclination angle of 45°. This study highlights the importance of surgical techniques on the contact mechanics and tribology of metal-on-metal hip resurfacing and potential outcome of these devices.
The exact alignment of the femoral component is crucial for the success of hip resurfacing arthroplasty. This prospective study was performed to find whether the imageless computer-assisted navigation surgery can improve the accuracy during hip resurfacing arthroplasty by comparing the alignment of the femoral component implanted with navigation system and conventional-mechanical guided system.
Forty patients were randomly allocated into 2 groups for resurfacing hip arthroplasty using Birmingham hip resurfacing system. In the conventional group, femoral component positioning was assisted by mechanical alignment guides. In the navigation group, it was assisted by an imageless computer-assisted surgical system of Vectorvision® (BrainLAB, Germany). We measured the difference between the preoperative plan of femoral component’s position and postoperative results on radiographs in the 2 groups
In the conventional group, a median difference of the stem alignment was 5.4° (range, 0.2°–10.9°) and a median difference of the stem anteversion was 2.6° (range, 0°–6.5°). In the navigated group, a median difference of the stem alignment was 2.3° (range, 0.2°–4.9°) and a median difference of the stem anteversion was 1° (range, 0°–3.6°). These differences between the 2 groups were statistically significant (P< 0.05).
In resurfacing arthroplasty with a hip navigation, the procedure showed a good performance and reliability. It is achieved with greater precision with a navigation system than a mechanical alignment system.
In hip joint simulator studies, wear measurement is usually performed gravimetrically. This procedure is reliable for metal-on-polyethylene or ceramic-on-polyethylene bearings, in which relatively high amounts of abrasive wear particles are produced. With modern hard-on-hard bearings, volumetric wear decreases significantly up to 100 to 200-fold. The gravimetric method reaches its detection limit with metal-on-metal bearings and even more so with ceramic-on-ceramic bearings. This study establishes a new method of determining wear in hard-on-hard bearings by measuring the amount of worn particles/ions in the serum of hip simulators.
A wear study on three resurfacing hip implants (BHR®, Smith& Nephew) was conducted using a hip joint simulator. Prior to the wear study, tests were performed to validate the detection power for high resolution-inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry (HR-ICP-MS). More importantly the system’s accuracy was compared to the gravimetric method, which is described in ISO 14243-2. The simulator was altered to run completely metal ion free. The ion concentration in the serum was measured every 100 000 cycles up to 1 500 000 cycles and subsequently in intervals of 500 000 cycles using HR-ICP-MS. The implants were neither removed from the simulator nor excessively cleaned during the course of the simulation. Serum was refreshed every 500 000 cycles. The serum samples were digested with purified nitric acid and hydrogen peroxide using a high pressure microwave autoclave in order to measure wear particles as well as dissolved ions. All steps were carried out under clean room conditions. Wear was calculated using the ion concentration and measured serum volume. Wear rates and transition from running-in to steady-state wear phases were calculated.
A detection power better than 0.028 μg/l for Co (cobalt), 0.017 μg/l for Cr (chromium) and 0.040 μg/l for Mo (molybdenum) was found for HR-ICP-MS. The validation of HR-ICP-MS showed good agreement between gravimetric data and measured ion concentrations. The tested implants showed similar wear behaviour. Implant wear resulted in high ion concentrations during the first 380 000 to 920 000 cycles. During this period, a mean wear rate of 6.96 mm3/10E6 cycles was determined. Subsequently, the wear rate significantly decreased to a mean wear rate of 0.37 mm3/10E6 cycles. Thus, a mean ratio between running-in and steady-state wear of 18.8 was found. The mean overall wear volume at the end of the simulation was 4.42 mm3.
This study showed that measuring the ion concentrations in the serum of hip simulators can be used to determine wear in metal-on-metal bearings. The main advantages of this new method are the ability to detect ultra-low wear rates and to precisely specify the duration of different wear phases. Because the implants do not have to be removed from the simulator and aggressive cleaning processes may be skipped, fluctuations in wear detection are extremely low. This in turn leads to a shorter duration of the simulation. Wear rates of the tested implants are low compared to polyethylene. Transferring the results to patient activity, wear would be the same during the first four to six months after implantation as in the next ten years. Minimizing the duration of running-in would be most effective in further reducing wear of metal-on-metal bearings.
The generation of particle debris from ultra high molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE) against metal hip joints has been shown to cause osteolysis leading to joint loosening in the medium term. This is known as late aseptic loosening since infection is absent
In an attempt to reduce the volume of wear debris, attention has moved to metal-on-metal prostheses as the total volume of wear debris is less. However, the size, shape and number of the particles are important as well as the total volume as these affect the biological response of the body leading to aseptic loosening.
The Durham Mk I Hip Joint Simulator was used to generate CoCrMo wear particles in a series of tests. Four simulator tests took place in succession, initially 50 mm Birmingham hip replacements were tested where both the head and the cup were as-cast CoCrMo alloy. A second test was conducted where the components were 38 mm and both head and cup were as-cast CoCrMo. A third test using 50 mm components was completed where both head and cup were double heat treated CoCrMo alloy and a final test took place where both components were 50 mm the head was as-cast and the cup was as-cast which had been pre-worn to 5 million cycles. Bovine serum with a concentration of 17 g/l of protein was used as a lubricant and particles were sampled every half million cycles. The volumetric wear was also obtained gravimetrically.
A double enzymatic protocol was used to cleave the proteins from the particles taking great care to minimise any effect on the particles. Finally the particles were suspended in distilled, de-ionised water to enable them to be analysed using a NanoSight LM10 particle analyser. This yielded the size distribution of the particles. This was then confirmed by placing an aliquot of the suspended particles onto a carbon coated copper grid and drying them under a lamp. These particles were then imaged in the TEM. Energy Dispersive X-ray analysis was also used to obtain the chemical composition of the particles.
The results indicated a strong correlation between the gravimetric wear and the number of particles. All the as-cast CoCrMo alloy tests showed a consistent particle modal average size. The double heat treated particles were shown to be smaller, with occasional large flake like particulates which were identified under the TEM. This particle data correlates extremely well with previous data from simple material testing pin on plate experiments.
Previous studies have used microscopy to investigate the size and morphology of the particulate debris
In the majority of cases, failure of conventional metal-on-ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE) artificial joints is due to wear particle induced osteolysis. Therefore, new materials have been introduced in an attempt to produce bearing surfaces that create lower, more biologically compatible wear. Polyetheretherketone (PEEK-OPTIMA) has been successfully used in a number of implant applications due to its combination of mechanical strength and biocompatibility.
Multi-directional pin-on-plate wear tests were performed on carbon fibre reinforced PEEK-OPTIMA (CFR-PEEK) against CoCrMo. PAN-based CFR-PEEK was tested against both low carbon and high carbon CoCrMo and Pitch-based CFR-PEEK was tested against high carbon CoCrMo only. The multi-directional motion of the pin-on-plate machine replicated the crossing of the wear paths that would be expected in vivo. For each test, four pin and plate samples were tested for two million cycles at a cycle frequency of 1 Hz under a 40 N load (which resulted in a contact stress of about 2 MPa). The lubricant used was bovine serum diluted with distilled water to a protein content of 15 gl-1. This was maintained at 37 °C. The wear was determined gravimetrically. Soak control specimens were used to account for any weight changes due to lubricant absorption.
The average steady state wear for the CFR-PEEK pins was found to be 0.144, 0.176 and 0.123 × 10-6 mm 3N-1m-1 for the CFR-PEEK PAN pins against low carbon CoCrMo, CFR-PEEK PAN pins against high carbon CoCrMo and CFR-PEEK Pitch-based pins against high carbon CoCrMo. A comparison of the results from the low and high carbon plates articulating against the PAN-based pins shows that the high carbon CoCrMo produced slightly higher wear than the low carbon CoCrMo. The protruding carbides on the high carbon CoCrMo plates may have caused this increase in wear. The lowest wearing material combination in this study was CFR-PEEK Pitch against high carbon CoCrMo. Published papers on the wear of UHMWPE against stainless steel [
Pitch and PAN-based CFR-PEEK against CoCrMo (low carbon or high carbon) provided low wear rates. On average, the Pitch-based material against high carbon CoCrMo provided the lowest wear in these tests. All the material combinations gave lower wear than found for UHMWPE-on-stainless steel tested under similar conditions. This gives confidence in the likelihood of this material combination performing well in orthopaedic applications.
The authors wish to thank INVIBIO Ltd for funding this research.
Aseptic loosening caused by UHMWPE wear debris induced osteolysis is a major cause of revision in total hip arthroplasty (THA)
Advantages include reduced wear and metal ion release compared with MOM. In addition, it is thought that there may be a reduced tendency for fracture of the ceramic component due to the softer metallic cup.
In this study a 5 million cycle wear test was carried out on the Mark II Durham Hip Wear Simulator. A set of six, 38mm diameter HIPed alumina heads and as-cast CoCr alloy cups were tested in bovine serum. Surface topography analysis was carried out at 0, 2, 3 and 5 million cycles. Additionally imaging of the bearing surfaces using ESEM and AFM was undertaken on the final bearing surface. Friction testing, using the Durham Hip Friction Simulator was carried out on one of the joints worn to 5 million cycles and the results were compared with theoretical calculations.
Wear of the ceramic heads was virtually undetectable using the conventional gravimetric methods. However, minor surface damage in the form of grain pull out and abrasive scratches was observed in the wear patch when the bearing surfaces were analysed using ESEM and AFM. The grains were not visible in the unworn sections of the head. The average surface roughness remained constant throughout the test. The CoCr cups showed a decrease in roughness between 0 and 2 million cycles, after which it remained relatively constant. This was consistent with the wear results in which a biphasic wear rate was found. The more frequently obtained wear results showed running in wear rate of 1.02±0.078 mm3/million cycles between 0–0.5 million cycles, followed by a steady state wear rate of 0.030±0.011 mm3/million cycles. These results are consistent with those of a recent study undertaken elsewhere
Friction testing produced a Stribeck curve which was indicative of full fluid film lubrication with a friction factor of 0.027±0.002 for 25% bovine serum (η=0.0014 Pa s-1). Other tests were also carried out using carboxy methyl cellulose fluid as the lubricant to investigate the effect of proteins. This showed that there was a small decrease in friction factor when proteins were absent from the lubricant. It is thought that the difference in friction factors is due to adsorption of the proteins onto the bearing surfaces, when lubricated in bovine serum. This introduces large proteins between the bearing surfaces, which penetrate the lubricant film, causing protein on protein interactions, in addition to the friction caused by shearing of the lubricant film.
The purpose of this study was to examine surface characteristics of 30 alumina and 24 zirconia ceramic femoral heads and to identify phase transformation in zirconia heads. We also studied penetration rate of alumina and zirconia heads into UHMWPE liner. The alumina heads had been implanted for a mean of 11.3 years (8.1 to 16.2) and zirconia heads for a mean of 9.8 years (7.5 to 15).
The mean surface roughness values of explanted alumina heads (Ra 40.12 nm and Rpm 578.34 nm) were similar to those for the explanted zirconia heads (Ra 36.12 nm and Rpm 607.34 nm). The mean value of monoclinic phase of two control non-implanted zirconia heads was 1% (0.8–1.5) and 1.2% (0.9–1.3), respectively. The mean value of monoclinic phase of 24 explanted zirconia heads was 7.3% (1% to 26%).
In the alumina head group, mean linear penetration rate of UHMWPE liner was 0.10 mm/yr (0.09 to 0.12) in hips with low Ra and Rpm values (13.22 nm and 85.91 nm, respectively). The mean linear penetration rate of UHMWPE liner was 0.13 mm/yr (0.17 to 0.23) in the hips with high Ra and Rpm values (198.72 nm and 1329 nm, respectively). This differences was significant (P=0.041)
In the zirconia head group, the mean linear penetration rate of UHMWPE liner was 0.09 mm/yr (0.07 to 0.14) in hips with low Ra and Rpm values (12.78 nm and 92.99 nm, respectively). The mean linear penetration rate of UHMWPE liner was 0.12 mm/yr (0.08 to 0.22) in hips with high Ra and Rpm values (199.21 nm and 1381 nm, respectively). This difference was significant (P=0.039).
The explanted zirconia heads which had a minimal phase transformation had similar surface roughness and a similar penetration rate of UHMWPE liner as the explanted alumina head.
Ceramic-on-ceramic bearings (ALX: pure alumina) have been used for human hip joints for almost 40 years. However an alumina matrix composite with zirconia (AMC) was introduced in year 2000 as a high-strength ceramic with almost double the fatigue resistance (AMC = 80.5%ALZ and 18vol% ZrO2). However we have not found any retrieval studies reported for this new ceramic bearing.
Wear maps were generated on three retrieved AMC femoral heads (28 and 36mm diameters) using x-ray diffraction, roughness and SEM imaging techniques. The wear study ran a physiologically appropriate, micro-separation test on 36mm ceramic balls and liners (AMC/ALZ). Wear rates were determined for the four combinations of balls and cups (ALX:AMC) with mapping of main-wear and stripe-wear zones, surface-roughness and analysis of debris morphology. In addition, the zirconia transformation to monoclinic phase was studied in AMC bearings
The retrieval study showed for the first time the wear phenomena occurring on three retrieved AMC femoral heads (at 1, 3, 6 years). Two had been paired with alumina liners and one with a polyethylene liner. Case-1 featured a 36mm ball in an UHMWPE socket, case-2 was an intact 28mm AMC ball and case-3 had a fractured ball from an IDE study. Laser interferometry and SEM were used to image ceramic wear and x-ray diffraction for analysis of transformation in the zirconia phase. Main-wear zones, stripe-wear zones, metal contamination and sites of implant impingement were also characterized. Surface roughness and in-vivo aging were quantified for both non-worn and worn areas. The SEM studies showed well-preserved articular surfaces, some with faint parallel scratches still evident. The latter likely represented the manufacturer’s original polishing marks. Multiple stripe-wear sites were identified with roughness 25–65nm (Sa) whereas polished main-wear zones averaged very low at 2–3nm. Metal impingements sites stained black with transfer of titanium increased roughness up to 140nm. Mildly worn areas of case-2 AMC ball averaged 10% transformation in the zirconia phase (tetragonal to monoclinic). In the stripe-wear zones, the monoclinic phase increased to 30%. The taper-bore and fracture surfaces in case-3 averaged 30% to 40% monoclinic, respectively. The stripe-wear zones and black metal contamination on these retrieved 28mm balls were correlated to multiple impingement sites on the rim of the alumina liners and titanium shells.
The laboratory model produced stripe wear on the ceramic balls and liners. The AlX/AlX controls produced the highest run-in and steady-state wear rates at 6.3 and 2mm3/Mc respectively). In contrast, the AMC/AMC combination produced the lowest wear rates at 0.5 and 0.1 mm3/Mc, respectively). With hybrid ball:cup combinations (AlX:AMC; AMC:AlX) the wear rates were similar and showed a 3-fold reduction compared to controls. In hybrid pairings, the AMC ceramic wore preferentially more than its AlX counterpart, regardless if present as a ball or cup implant. Thus the AMC ball contributed 66% to AMC/AlX total wear whereas the ALZ ball contributed only 33% of the total AlZ/AMC wear.
This study appears to be the first documentation of wear in retrieved AMC bearing surfaces. In general, the AMC surfaces worn in-vivo corresponded well to our in-vitro wear model. The stripe-wear zones in AMC femoral heads had rougher surfaces and higher monoclinic transformation than the main-wear zone. Overall the AMC ceramic appeared more resistant to stripe-wear effects created by the micro-separation and impingement phenomena.
Wear of the polyethylene liner in Total hip arthroplasty (THA) is associated to aseptic component loosening. With low wear bearing surfaces and metal backing in acetabular components the manual methods of measurements have not fared well. Computerized methods increased the ease and accuracy of wear measurement. The average clinician has no access to these methods. In this study we proposed to develop a method of manual wear measurement (PowerPoint – PP method) using a simple office PC and
quantify its accuracy and reproducibility compare the accuracy with Livermore and Dorr method and determine the accuracy in different degrees of wear.
The study population was divided into class 1 (C1), Class 2 (C2) and Class 3 (C3) group. C1 group had 20 patients who had undergone liner change for high wear. This class simulated a high wear situation. C2 group had 24 patients who were implanted with HXLP. This class simulated very low wear situation. 10 patients were included in C3 group. The same 6week postoperative radiograph was paired as a set of x rays for analysis. This mimics a zero wear situation.
PP method had more consistency with Livermore method for C1 group. For C2 and C3 groups all the three methods did not provide consistent results. The correlation coefficient values for wear measurement by PP method showed good correlation between observers in C1 and C2 wear (P values < 0.05). For C3 with true zero wear there was poor correlation between the observers (r −0.659, 0.028, 0.638). The paired T test P values for all classes and both observers were > 0.05. There was no statistically significant difference in the reading of the two observers. Pearson correlation coefficient for all methods showed good correlation for C1and C2 groups. All the methods had errors while measuring true zero in C3. The one way ANOVA analysis was done to identify the ability of the three methods differentiate between C2 and C3. The PP method had the ability (P value < 0.05) to differentiate between C1, C2 and C3. The Dorr’s and Livermore’s methods could only differentiate the C1 from C2andC3.
Computerized methods have certain limitations. Matthew Collier et al reported a mean linear wear rate of 0.4(0.04–0.86) and 0.27 (0.01–0.56) by computerized methods in radiographs with true zero wear. In C3 group the average wear rate by PP method was 0.22 ± 0.206 mm. In PP method ability to work at 400% magnifications, ability to correct for rotation on X axis, grouping function of PowerPoint program leads to less chances of errors. PP method has a good reproducibility for clinical use (r> 0.930). The ability of the PP method to differentiate between C2 and C3 should make it a preferred manual method of wear assessment.
The PP method has limitations. The least measurement is limited by diameter of the femoral head. It cannot be utilized for wear analysis in cup loosening or migration. It can be regarded as a supplement to the existing methods of manual wear measurements.
Wear in polyethylene liners appears to be exacerbated by 3rd-body abrasion effects with the CoCr ball combinations used for total hip replacements. This has implications for various wear modes encountered in patients. Yet clinical and laboratory studies have offered weak and sometimes contradictory wear relationships with respect to crosslinking, ball diameter and roughness, and 3rd-body wear effects. Our hip simulator model investigated the effect of severe wear challenges by 3rd-body cement particles, using large diameter CoCr and alumina balls, with highly-crosslinked polyethylene liners (HXPE) irradiated to 75kGy compared to contemporary controls (CXPE 35kGy).
The polyethylene liners were gamma-irradiated to 35/75kGy under N2 (CXPE/HXPE). We used 32 and 44mm CoCr balls (ENCORE, Austin, TX) and 44mm alumina-ceramic (Biolox-forte, CeramTecAG) as ‘scratch-resistant’ standard of comparison. We compared 5 bearings pairs with different roughness characteristics using both new and pre-worn polyethylene liners. A 12-station orbital hip simulator with a physiological load profile (0.2kN–3kN load, frequency 1Hz) with cups mounted in “Inverted- position”. Diluted bovine serum (Hyclone Inc., Logan, UT) was used as lubricant (20mg/ml protein, 400ml volume). In phase I, all cups were run in standard (‘clean’) lubricant for 1.5 million cycles (1.5Mc). In phase II, the liners were run in a PMMA slurry of serum (5mg/ml) for 2Mc. In phase III, implants were run ‘clean’ for 1.5Mc. Wear-rate was measured each 0.25Mc event, and surface roughness measured by SEM (XL-30FEG) and white light interferometry (Newview600, Zygo) every 0.5Mc.
In phase I, Wear withnew CXPE and HXPE liners averaged 182mm3/Mc and 30mm3/Mc. Thus the HXPE liners averaged a 6.0-fold wear reduction compared to controls. Compared to new liners, the pre-worn CXPE and HXPE liners showed 10% and 25%, greater wear respectively. Here it was noted that CoCr balls maintained similar roughness (Sa:8–12nm). And alumina balls showed small, gradual increase (Sa: 2 to 2.5nm). The HXPE maintained a superior finish to CXPE controls. Roughness revealed a gradual decrease with time, pre-worn CXPE from 0.28 to 0.15um and pre-worn HXPE from 0.18 to 0.04um (Sa). In contrast, new HXPE showed a dramatic smoothing (0.8 to 0.1um) 92.8% decreased in first 0.5Mc. These effects have not been previously quantified. In phase II with abrasive mode, the liner wear-rates increased dramatically by 6 and 80-fold for CXPE and HXPE, respectively. These data confirmed that HXPE was sensitive to ‘severe’ wear against CoCr and alumina balls. In phase III, the polyethylene roughness dropped by > 90% and wear decreased to phase-I values. The wear-ratio was now 2:1 for CXPE:HXPE as predicted by the ‘diameter’ and ‘crosslinking’ algorithms.
It was clear that surface roughness was not a confounding factorfor either the CoCr or alumina balls. It was the polyethylene surface roughness that appeared to influence wear rates. Our analysis showed that there was a transient due to patches of abrasive cement transferring onto CoCr ball surfaces. Overall the actual roughness of the CoCr balls did not change and was therefore not a factor in increased polyethylene wear.
The material properties of gamma irradiated Ultra High Molecular Weight (UHMW) polyethylene are known to degrade during exposure to air. Though gamma inert-sterilization has been developed to decrease free radicals, the rate of degeneration of UHMW polyethylene in vivo has not well known. This study aimed to compare the properties of gamma inert-irradiated highly-cross-linked UHMW polyethylene samples after exposure to air and the properties of gamma inert-irradiated highly-crosslinked UHMW polyethylene samples after exposure to liquid.
UHMW polyethylene samples were machined from heat-compressed sheet made of medical grade GUR 1050 (Ticona, Kelsterbach, Germany). Samples were rectangular, where the dimensions were 50mm in length, 5 mm in width and 2 mm in thickness. Samples were divided into four groups of 0, 60, 100 and 200 kGy irradiation in N2 gas. These samples were then exposed to air or Ringer’s solution for half a year. Dynamic vis-coelastic measurements and, Fourier Transform Infrared Spectrometry (FTIR) and Electron Spin Resonance (ESR) analyses were performed on samples immediately after inert-irradiation, after half-year-exposure to 25°C air (Air-exposure) and after half-year-exposure to 37°C Ringer’s solution (Liquid-exposure). Dynamic viscoelastic measurements were conducted over a temperature range of −150 to 350°C using a Dynamic Mechanical Spectrometer (Seiko Instruments, Osaka, Japan). FTIR analysis was conducted using a Perkin-Elmer Spectra BX (Norwalk, CT) with 100-μm thick slices. ESR analysis was also conducted using a JES-TE200 (Nippon-Denshi, Akishima, Japan).
Although the dynamic viscoelastic performance of 0 kGy irradiated storage sample was not different from that of original sample, the loss tangent value (tanδ, E”/E’) of 60, 100 and 200 kGy irradiated storage samples was different from that of original samples (Fig. 1). The difference of Liquid-exposure was larger than that of Air-exposure. Although a FTIR peak at 1718 cm-1 wave numbers was not observed in 0 kGy irradiated storage sample, obvious peak was observed in 100 and 200 kGy irradiated storage samples (Fig. 2). The peak of Liquid-exposure was larger than that of Air-exposure. The ESR analysis showed free radicals in storage samples.
The dynamic viscoelastic performance of 60, 100, 200 kGy irradiated storage sample was different from that of original sample, whereas the performance of 0 kGy irradiated storage sample was not different from that of original sample. The difference of Liquid-exposure was larger than that of Air-exposure. The storage modulus value of 60, 100, 200 kGy irradiated Liquid-exposure decreased and the reason for this was thought to be chain scission by oxidation for half-year exposure to Ringer’s solution. Obvious FTIR peak at 1718 cm-1 wave numbers was observed in 100 and 200 kGy irradiated storage samples. The peak of Liquid-exposure was larger than that of Air-exposure. This indicated that the oxidation of Liquid-exposure quickly progressed during half-year storage and the reason for this was thought to be chain scission by high liquid temperature. The results of the present study suggested that the properties of gamma irradiated UHMW polyethylene quickly degraded in vivo.
Audible squeaking following ceramic-on-ceramic total hip arthroplasty (THA) is a rare but troublesome problem. We retrospectively reviewed records of 1002 patients where a ceramic-on-ceramic THA had been done during the study period. Fifteen patients complained of squeaking, at any time following their arthroplasty. Fourteen of these 15 patients were evaluated clinically and radiologically. The demographics of these patients were compared to that of all the other patients who did not have squeaking following ceramic-on-ceramic THA. The radiographic data was compared to a control group matched for age, sex, body mass index (BMI), primary diagnosis, type of implant, date of surgery and length of follow-up.
There were 12 males and 2 females of a mean age of 44.5 years (range, 25–65 years). These 14 patients were found to have significantly higher BMI of 25.98 kg/m2 (range, 21.6–32.3 kg/m2) as compared to the other patients who had ceramic-on-ceramic THA (mean, 23.61 kg/m2; range, 15.8 –30.3 kg/m2) (p=0.005). The lateral opening angle was found to be significantly lower (mean, 34°; range 29°–40°) in these patients than the matched control group (mean, 38°; range 30°–41°) (p=0.016). Mean acetabular anteversion was 22° (range 9°–37°), which was not significantly different to that of the matched controls (mean 23°; range 2°–33°) (p=.957). Limb length shortening of more than 5mm was observed in 12 of the 14 (85.7%) patients as compared to only 4 of 14 (28.6%) patients in the matched control group. Two patients had intermittent squeaking while the other 12 had continuous squeaking. Flexion and sitting cross legged were identified as the movements which most commonly (11 of 12) resulted in squeaking. Mean Harris hip score (HHS) improved from 44 (range, 19–66) to 94 (range, 88–100) and most patients (13 of 14) were satisfied with the outcome of the surgery.
Thus the incidence of squeaking was found to be low (1.5%, 15 of 1002) in our series. We identified high BMI, decreased lateral opening angle and limb length shortening as factors associated with occurrence of squeaking. Proper patient selection, implant placement, and avoidance of limb length discrepancy are likely to further reduce the incidence of this complication of ceramic-on-ceramic THA.
We evaluated 3 cases of ceramic-on-ceramic THA in that the evidence of the impingement between the metal neck and the ceramic liner was found.
Between July 2007 and January 2008, impingement between the metal and the ceramic liner was found in 3 cases of ceramic-on-ceramic THA during re-operation. The re-operation was performed 3–6 years after the primary surgery because of ceramic head fracture, deep infection and cup loosening. All patients frequently sat on the floor in tailor fashion but did not have any sound in the hip after THA.
In all cases, V-shaped indented wear scar was found on the postero-superior aspect of the metal neck. Two ceramic liners could be retrieved. Both showed black staining in the postero-superior portion of the rim. The outer edge of the bearing surface of the retrieved acetabular liners was evaluated with SEM. The black stained area of the acetabular liner rim was found to be roughened. A micro-crack propagating into the deep portion of the ceramic liner was observed in one liner.
Our observations suggest that impingement between the ceramic liner and the metal neck can cause crack formation leading to ceramic liner failure in vivo.
Squeaking in ceramic on ceramic bearing total hip arthroplasty is well documented but its aetiology is poorly understood. In this study we have undertaken an acoustic analysis of the squeaking sound recorded from 31 ceramic on ceramic bearing hips. The frequencies of these sounds were compared with in vitro acoustic analysis of the component parts of the total hip implant. Analysis of the sounds produced by squeaking hip replacements and comparison of the frequencies of these sounds with the natural frequency of the component parts of the hip replacements indicates that the squeaking sound is due to a friction driven forced vibration resulting in resonance of one or both of the metal components of the implant. Finite element analysis of edge loading of the prostheses shows that there is a stiffness incompatibility between the acetabular shell and the liner.
The shell tends to deform, uncoupling the shell-liner taper system. As a result the liner tends to tilt out of the acetabular shell and slide against the acetabular shell adjacent to the applied load. The amount of sliding varied from 4–40μm. In vitro acoustic and finite element analysis of the component parts of a total hip replacement compared with in vivo acoustic analysis of squeaking hips indicate that either the acetabular shell or the femoral stem can act as an “oscillator’ in a forced vibration system and thus emit a squeak.
Under ideal conditions hard-on-hard bearings are assumed to be operating under conditions of fluid film lubrication with very low friction.14,15 However, if fluid film lubrication breaks down leading to dry sliding contact there will be a dramatic increase in friction. If this increased friction provides more energy to the system than it can dissipate, instabilities may develop in the form of friction induced vibrations and sound radiation16. Friction induced vibrations are a special case of forced vibration, where the frequency of the resulting vibration is determined by the natural frequency of the component parts. Running a moistened finger around the rim of a wine glass is an example of this. [Appendix].
The hypothesis of this study is that the squeaking sound that occurs in ceramic on ceramic hip replacement is the result of a forced vibration. This forced vibration can be broken down into a driving force and a resultant dynamic response17. The driving force is a frictional driving force and occurs when there is a loss of fluid film lubrication resulting in a high friction force14,15,18. The dynamic response is a vibration of a part of the device (the oscillator) at a frequency that is influenced by the natural frequency of the part16. By analyzing the frequencies of the sound produced by squeaking hip replacements and comparing them to the natural frequency of the component parts of a hip replacement this study aims to determine which part produces the sound.
We tested the following components: modular ceramic/titanium acetabular components, which included testing the titanium shell and the respective ceramic inserts both assembled according to the manufacturer’s instructions and unassembled; titanium femoral stems and ceramic femoral heads both assembled and unassembled. A range of sizes of each component was tested according to availability from our retrieval collection.
Sound files were captured and analyzed by the same method used in the in vitro analysis. Each recording was previewed in the spectral view mode which allows easy visual identification of the squeak in the sound recording. In addition all sound recordings were played, listening for the squeak. Once a squeak was identified a fast Fourier transform (FFT) was performed. We used FFT size 1024 with a Blackmann-Harris window which allowed us to easily pick out the major frequency components. All prominent frequency components were recorded at the beginning of the squeak and at several time points during the squeak if there was any change. A range was recorded for the fundamental frequency component. We were able to determine the frequency range of the recording device used by observing the frequency range of the background noise on the recording. We found that if a squeak was audible on the recording we had no difficulty determining its frequency regardless of the quality of the device used to make the recording or the amount of background noise.
The mean age of the patients was 54 years (23 to 79 years), mean height was 171cm (152 to 186cm) and mean weight was 79kg (52 to 111kg). There were 17 female and 14 male patients. There were nineteen ABGII stem and ABGII cup combinations, 10 accolade stem and trident cup, 1 Exeter stem and trident cup and 1 Osteonics Securfit stem with an Osteonics cup. Ethics committee approval was obtained for this project from our institution and from the referring institutions and informed consent was gained from the patients.
To-date neck-sparing stems have been disappointing in their ability to maintain the calcar. A new approach was undertaken to improve load transfer and to create a tissue-sparing stem that would be simple in design, reproducible in technique and provide for fine-tuning joint mechanics while maintaining compressive loads to the calcar.
A modular neck provides for fine-tuning joint mechanics.
Bone and Tissue sparring Restoration of joint mechanics Minimal blood loss Potential reduction in rehabilitation Ease of revision Simple surgical technique Options for bearing surface Selection of femoral head diameter Standard surgical approach to the hip
We are encouraged and believe there are advantages in the concept of neck sparing stems. Clinical/surgical evaluation is now underway and will be reported on in the future.
Architectural changes in occurring in the proximal femur (resorption) after total hip arthroplasty (due to stress shielding) continues to be a problem. In an attempt to reduce these bony changes the concept of short and femoral neck sparing stem designs have been advocated. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the early clinical and radiological results, especially stem fixation and bone remodeling of proximal femur after total hip arthroplasty.
A total of forty-five patients (fifty-four hips) were included in the study. There were twenty men and twenty-five women. The mean age at the time of operation was 53.9 years (range, twenty-six to seventy-five years). Clinical and radiological evaluation were performed at each follow-up. Bone densitometry was carried out on all patients one week after operation and at the final follow-up examination. The mean follow-up was 1.3 years (range, one to two years).
The mean preoperative Harris hip score was 45 points (range, 15 to 48 points), which improved to a mean of 96 points (range, 85 to 100 points) at the final follow-up. No patient complained of thigh pain at any stage. No acetabular or femoral osteolysis was observed and no hip required revision for aseptic loosening of either component. One hip (2%) required open reduction and fixation with a cable for calcar femorale fracture. Bone mineral densitometry revealed a minimal bone remodeling in the acetbulum and proximal femur.
The geometry of this ultra-short anatomic neck sparing cementless femoral stem has proved to provide effective initial stability even without the diaphyseal portion of the stem. We believe that femoral neck preservation and lateral flare of the stem provide an axial and torsional stability and more natural loading of the proximal femur.
This is a report on the first 100 THR patients treated with an off the shelf version of a novel “Lateral Flare” femoral component. A prior published report has documented the up to 19 year follow up of custom fabricated stems of an identical design concept as being successful in patients < 55 years of age.
HHS, radiographic measure of bone morphology, implant stability and densitometric measure of bone response after THR with an off the shelf version, “Revelation Lateral Flare”, femoral component, confirm excellent bone preservation and implant stability with this design concept. DEXA analysis of a 20 consecutive patient subset of these 100 patients, documented preservation of more than 95% of proximal femoral bone stock in Gruen zone 1 and 102% of total bone stock in Gruen zones 1–7. Implant stability measurement documented < 0.5mm of subsidence in spite of patients being permitted immediate post-operative full weight bearing activity.
These findings support reasonable optimism for expectation of successful long term results being achievable with the use of an off the shelf version of the “Lateral Flare” design concept, in young, high demand patients suffering with early onset osteoarthrosis of the hip.
18 years ago laboratory studies were started to develop a CT-based uncemented customised femoral stem in order to optimise the fixation and strain distribution to the proximal femur in uncemented femoral components. An individual design also aimed to optimise the biomechanics of the joint and to enable use of uncemented stems in femurs with abnormal shape and dimension. The developed prosthesis has now been in clinical use for 13 years. The aim of this paper is to present the preliminary results of a prospective clinical study of this prosthesis.
Design of hard-on-hard bearing couples has traditionally been characterized by the material of the bearing couple, clearance between the bearing surfaces, sphericity of the components, surface roughness, and the radii of the components. All of these factors play a role in the lambda ratio and fluid film thickness calculations. However, the fluid film for hard on hard bearings can be interrupted by issues like the presence of 3rd body particles, intermittent walking, jogging, and subluxation. Only recently have researcher begun to simulate some of these disruptions in the fluid film for hard on hard bearings.
Recent laboratory testing has looked at the effects of utilizing different materials and methodologies to evaluate hard-on-hard bearings. Ceramic-on-metal is a unique combination of components that is currently available. Several authors have shown that this combination can reduce the amount of metal wear generated during the test by a factor of 4–100. However, an occasional anomaly has shown up in some of these tests where a wear couple in a steady state wear mode will have a several-fold increase in wear for a short duration.
For bearing couples that have a metal component, ion analysis of the serum lubricant can be utilized to monitor the amount of wear. This technique can provide real-time data on the amount of wear seen in simulator testing without removing the specimens from the machine. Further, there are some designs of metal cups that cannot be removed from the simulator without causing damage to the component. Data from a ceramic-on-metal simulator test confirmed that the short-term anomaly in gravimetric wear correlated with an increase in metal ion levels.
Distraction testing evaluates the change in wear due to the unintended subluxation of the hip. This may occur during a standard walking gait if the hip is loose, during impingement, or during deep-knee bends, squatting, or rising from a chair. Distraction testing has various effects on wear depending on the material of the bearing couple. UHMWPE is insensitive to this additional mode of simulator testing. Metal-on-metal and ceramic-on-ceramic can increase in wear by up to an order of magnitude. The utilization of Biolox-delta rather than Biolox-forte can reduce the amount of wear seen during distraction testing. Diamond-on-diamond is insensitive to this wear mode and showed immeasurable wear.
Other issues during testing of hard-on-hard bearings are still being explored. It is well known that 3rd body particles will disrupt fluid films and can increase wear. But the results from adding particles is variable. Metal-on-metal tests can have one specimen with very little increase while another specimen has an order of magnitude increase. Deformation of the shell caused by insertion during surgery has been shown to occur. Currently, this deformation has not been able to be replicated in a simulator, therefore, its effects are unknown.
The design and laboratory testing of hard-on-hard bearings has improved significantly over the past decade. Further research is still needed to evaluate designs that may potentially increase resistance to failure modes other than standard walking gait cycles.
Our center has performed hip replacement arthroplasties since 1997. The purpose of this study was to assess the long term clinicoradiological results of a total hip replacement using the double tapered Mallory-Head system.
The results of a consecutive series of 81 total hip replacements in 75 patients were reviewed three to eleven years (average eight years) postoperatively. The diagnosis were avascular necrosis for 46 hips (57%), osteoarthritis for 12 hips (15%), RA for 9 hips (11%), and others. The clinical result was evaluated on the basis of the modified Harris hip score, modified Merle d’Aubigné-Postel score. A detailed radiographic analysis was also performed.
The average modified Harris hip score improved from 56 points to 92 points. The average modified Merle d’Aubigné-Postel score was 15 points at the latest follow up, and 55 hips(68%) were classified as the clinical grades of excellent or good results. Two acetabular components were revised because of loosening, and one was revised because of recurrent dislocation.
We concluded that the clinical and radiological evaluations of the total hip replacements, using the Mal-lory-Head system showed good results with mid-term follow-up.
This prospective study reports the midterm outcome of total hip arthroplasty performed in a consecutive series of patients using a tapered uncemented femoral component. From Nov. 2001 to Apr. 2006, total hip arthroplasties were performed in 138 patients (150hips). The clinical records and the routine serial radiographs of these patients were monitored closely over a 1-year period. Clinical evaluation was done by Harris hip score before surgery and at last follow-up. Radiological evaluation was done on plain radiographs. The average follow up period was 4.05 years. There was a significant improvement in functional outcome of these patients as measured by Harris hip score. There were no revisions for aseptic loosening of the femoral component in this series, accounting for an overall survivorship of 100%. The study confirms that the midterm outcome of this stem is excellent, with no revisions.
For successful long-term result of non-cemented total hip arthroplasty (THA), direct biological bond between bone and implant through bony ingrowth into the implant is essential. To facilitate strong bond between bone and implant, hydroxyapatite (HA) or hydroxyapatite and tricalcium phosphate (HA-TCP) coated implants have been developed. Early clinical results of HA coated implants were reported very satisfactorily. However, the long-term effects of HA or HA-TCP coating on implants were still controversial. We evaluated the effect of hydroxyapatite and tricalcium phosphate (HA-TCP) coating on fibermetal coated femoral stem. 37 cases using fibermetal coated femoral stem with additional HA-TCP coating and 38 cases using fibermetal coated femoral stem without additional HA-TCP coating were included with average follow-up for 127 months. The mean Harris hip score at final follow-up 91.2 in HA-TCP group and 90.5 in porous group. Engh’s score at final follow-up was 19.1 in HA-TCP group and 18.7 in porous group. Six acetabular components (8.0%, 3 cases in each group) were revised for excessive PE liner wear and liner dissociation from locking mechanism. One femoral stem without HA-TCP coating was considered as a loosening and failure. None of the remaining femoral components (98.7%) showed any signs of aseptic loosening. No significant differences between two groups were found in all parameters. A cement-less porous coated femoral stem provided good clinical function and survival in the medium term regardless of additional HA-TCP coating.
The aim of this study is to analyse the mid to long term results of cementless total hip arthroplasty (THA) performed in hemophilic coxarthrosis. Twenty-seven consecutive cementless THAs (23 patients) were performed at our institute for hemophilic coxarthrosis between June 1995 and June 2003. All these patients were followed up regularly for minimum 5 years and were included in this study. The average age at the time of surgery was 36 years (± 8.1) (range, 24–52 years). All the patients had hemophilia A. Twelve patients (52%) had more than 1 joint affected by hemophilic arthropathy. The mean follow-up period was 92 months (± 31.4) (range, 60–156 months). For clinical assessment we evaluated Harris hip score, range of motion, amount of transfusion and factor replacement, perioperative bleeding and the problems associated with the use of coagulation factors. For radiographic assessment, we evaluated the stability and fixation of components, various bone responses around the implants and complications such as loosening and osteolysis.
The average Harris hip score improved from 60.7 (± 19.3) (range, 30–89) before surgery to 95.9 (± 3) (range, 90–100) at the latest follow-up. The hip range of motion increased in all planes of motion after the operation. The mean factor VIII requirement per THA was 37 500 units (± 18 500) (range, 19 000–90 000 units). During surgery and post operative period mean 1.5 units (± 1.5) (range, 0–5 units) of packed cells and 0.5 units (± 1.4) (range, 0–5 units) of fresh frozen plasma was required. There was episode of re-bleeding in 4 cases. In one of them, severe osteolysis around pelvis and femoral stem was noted due to pseudotumor. Radiographically, except 1 loosened cup, the fixation was stable in all cases at the latest follow-up. Heterotopic ossification was noted in 2 hips. Osteolysis was noted in 4 femurs and 5 acetabulae. In 1 case of severe osteolysis around the stem, morsellised bone graft was performed at 144 months after the index operation. One case of pseudotumor was waiting for surgery. One loosened cup was revised to a cemented cup.
Unlike worrisome results of cemented THA, meticulously performed cementless THA for moderate or severe hemophilic arthropathy is safe and greatly effective in reducing pain, increasing the range of motion and improving the walking ability. However, special attention must be paid to the possible complications associated with re-bleeding such as pseudotumor around the hip. To obtain the best results multidisciplinary team comprising of pediatrician, hematologist, rehabilitation therapist and orthopaedic surgeon should be needed.
Dislocation is the most relevant early complication after primary total hip replacement (THR) in literature. Many factors have been advocated for dislocation, either surgeon-related either patient-related. Component positioning seems to be of major importance in determining dislocation. We evaluated 152 randomised THR with a CT study between 985 THR done at our Institute since november 2004 to november 2006.
152 randomised primary THR on a total of 985. The same prosthetic pattern (head size, stem, cup). Lateral approach with total capsulectomy and external rotator tendon resection. All 152 patients underwent a post operative standardized CT study assessing cup antiverion and inclination angles and stem antiversion angle. Dislocated patients where furthermore analysed for any detail concerning their procedure and follow-up. A safe zone was then deduced for safer positioning.
During the follow-up period dislocation occurred in 5 hips (only one in the randomised group) assessing our rate of dislocation at 0.5%. All dislocation were managed with closed reduction and an articulated hip brace. No open reduction or revision surgery were further needed. The mean cup abduction was 47° in the dislocated hips and 49° in the control group. Mean cup anteversion was 29° in both groups. The mean stem anteversion was 8.2° in the dislocated group and 3.1° in the control group. No statistical difference could be reached between dislocation and cup positioning. A correlation between hip dyspalsia (Crowe II) as primitive diagnosis and dislocation could be reached considering all the THR procedures.
In THR inappropriate cup and stem positioning is considered an important risk factor of postoperative dislocation. Accurate and reproducible measurement is mandatory for implant positioning evaluation. Conventional radiographs cannot provide accurate and reproducible measurement. CT can provide a precise measurement of prosthetic components. Several studies failed to demonstrate a correlation between component positioning and dislocation often because of small number of patients and many bias. We tried to reduce bias using the same prosthetic pattern and the same surgical approach. Notwithstanding we could not reach a statistical difference in term of prosthetic positioning between dislocated and control group. Perhaps the dislocated group was too small to have a statistical meaning. We could determine a Safe Zone of cup and stem positioning for our patients: cup anteversion between 24° and 33°, cup inclination between 42° and 50°, stem anteversion between −3° and 10°.
Dislocation is the main early complication after THR. Its etiology depends on many factors. Sometimes the cause can’t be identified. Orientation of prosthetic components may be responsable for dislocation but its truly correlation can be hard to be assessed. In this study we found no correlation between implant positioning and occurrence of dislocation, but we defined a tighter Safe Zone than previous reported, in which the risk of dislocation is nought. A correlation between hip dyspalsia (Crowe II) as primitive diagnosis and dislocation could be reached.
Failed internal fixation of hip fracture is a problem with varied aetiology. This becomes more complex when associated with infection. Total hip arthroplasty (THA) remains the only option to restore hip biomechanics when there is partial/complete head destruction associated with it.
A retrospective review was performed for 22 consecutive patients of THA following failed infected internal fixation between Sept. 2001 and Nov. 2007. There were 11 dynamic hip screw failures for intertrochanteric fractures, 6 failed osteotomies following proximal femoral fractures, and 5 failed screw fixations for transcervical fractures. The average age of the patients were 48.5years and average follow up period was 3.5 years (5months – 7.5years). All the patients have undergone two stage revision surgeries. The average Harris Hip Score improved from 35.5 to 82.8 at the latest follow up. None of the patients had recurrence of infection. One patient developed sciatic nerve palsy, recovered partially at 1 year following surgery. The results were comparable to primary arthroplasty in femoral neck fractures.
THA is a useful salvage procedure for failed infected internal fixation of hip fractures. Extreme care must be taken to avoid fracture and penetration of femoral shaft in such cases. Auto graft, allograft and special components like multihole cup, narrow stem should be available for reconstruction in difficult cases.
Dislocation remains a common complication following total hip arthroplasty, second only to aseptic loosening as a cause of revision. Factors thought to play a role in dislocation include cup and stem alignment, soft tissue tension, surgical approach, patient factors, and design features of the prosthesis, including femoral head size.
We analysed all consecutive total hip replacements at one institution over a 17 year period. Criteria for study inclusion were hips replaced due to primary osteoarthritis with no previous surgery, femoral head sizes of 28mm and 32mm only, and at least one year from date of surgery. 3682 hips fulfilled these criteria. All procedures were carried out using a posterolateral approach with enhanced posterior repair, and a standard method of intraoperative soft tissue balance assessment.
The rate of dislocation was 1.6%. 32mm femoral head size was associated with a statistically significant lower rate of dislocation. However, after controlling for different follow-up times between 28mm and 32mm heads, this difference was no longer observed. Older age at time of surgery and decreased cup anteversion were shown to be significantly associated with an increased risk of dislocation. Ceramic on ceramic bearing surface was significantly associated with a decreased risk of dislocation, after controlling for age, bearing wear and time from surgery. Cup inclination, gender, BMI, and preoperative hip score were not related to dislocation risk.
Our dislocation rate may reflect current dislocation rates of surgeons using the posterolateral approach with posterior capsule and external rotator repair. The risk factors identified and excluded in this study are likely to be relevant to all surgeons who utilise this approach in total hip arthroplasty.
Modified posterior approach preserving short external rotators would be able to contribute greatly to prevent dislocation after total hip arthroplasty. We modified the posterior approach to the hip by preserving the external rotator muscles in order to enhance joint stability after total hip arthroplasty in patients with osteonecrosis of the femoral head. The aim of the this study was to determine the influence of external rotator preserving posterior approach in primary total hip replacement on early dislocation and clinical outcome.
Three hundred sixty-four primary total hip replacements were divided into two groups based on how the external rotators were treated at surgery. External rotator preservation (Group 1, 165 hips) group was compared with reattachment (Group 2, 199 hips) group by evaluating the clinical and radiographic outcome at one year postoperative. Anteversion was significantly less in Group 1 as compared to Group 2 (P < 0.001). There was no significant difference in inclination between the groups (P > 0.05 in all comparisons). No dislocations were found in 165 hips with external rotator preservation whereas dislocations was noted in 11 (3.9%) in Groups 2, respectively. Group 1 had the higher mean Harris hip score (97.2±2.9 points) as compared with Group 2(94.9±3.4).
The results of this study showed that external rotators could play an important role in preserving joint stability after total hip arthroplasty in patients with osteonecrosis of the femoral head. It can be implied that this modified posterior approach would be able to contribute greatly to prevention of dislocation, and improve clinical outcome after total hip arthroplasty.
Dislocation remains a major early complication after total hip arthroplasty (THA), and range of motion (ROM) before impingement is important in joint stability. Factors contributing to dislocation include design specific factors such as head-neck ratio, surgeon-related factors such as component placement, and patient-related factors such as bony anatomy. To study the relative importance of these factors, we analysed the effects of patient anatomy, implant design, and component orientation on hip ROM.
Femoral and acetabular geometry were extracted from CT scans of 20 hips. CAD models of four different THA component designs were virtually implanted in the 3D-CT reconstructed anatomic models. The major design differences were in head-neck ratio and neck-stem angle. A previously reported contact detection model (D’Lima, J Orthop Research 2008) was used to measure restriction in hip ROM due to prosthetic or bony impingement. The following patient parameters were measured on plain AP radiographs: acetabular inclination, acetabular depth ratio, the arc-length between the tip of greater trochanter and ilium, and the arc-length between lesser trochanter and ischium. Multiple linear regression was used to determine correlation between radiographic parameters and hip ROM in flexion, extension, adduction, abduction, and external rotation.
Mean head size was 51 ± 2mm, mean anatomic acetabular inclination was 41° ± 2, and mean acetabular depth ratio was 460 ± 60. When the cup and stem were implanted for best fit to the anatomy, mean hip ROM was 125° ± 8 (flexion), 57° ± 17 (extension), 29° ± 13 (adduction), 69° ± 7 (abduction), and 42° ± 13 (external rotation). Implanting the cup in “optimal” surgical alignment of 45° abduction and 20° anteversion reduced mean hip flexion, extension and abduction and increased adduction. Subject-to-subject variation was substantially greater than variation between CAD designs (differences in head-neck ratio) or component orientation (between ideal and anatomic). Hip flexion correlated moderately with acetabular abduction angle and the angle of the flare of the iliac wing (R2 = 0.59, p = 0.03). Hip abduction correlated moderately with the angle of the flare of the iliac wing and the length of the arc from the tip of the greater trochanter to the ilium (R2 = 0.50, p = 0.05).
A universal cup position that permits optimal range of motion in all patients may not be valid. Since patient-related factors overshadowed implant design, cup position should be tailored to the individual patient. Preoperative radiographs can help predict postoperative hip ROM although not as accurately as 3D-CT reconstructions. These results may lead to enhancements in surgical navigation techniques.
The software is based on a spline-based multi-resolution 2D-3D image registration algorithm and a Markov random field theory based on similarity measurement. Based on a cone projection (imitating the path of the x-rays), the software is able to match the three-dimensional CT-based data set with the contours of the projected pelvis on the AP pelvic radiograph. This gives the possibility to correct the measured cup orientation (inclination and anteversion) by measuring it according to an anatomical defined coordinate system (anterior pelvic plane). The validation of the software consisted of accuracy, reproducibility and observer reliability measurements using cadaver and clinical data. For the cadaver validation 10 human pelves (20 hips) were used. From each pelvis 2 CT scans, one with and one without an inserted cup were acquired. The CT scan with the cup was used as the ground truth. With the cup inserted 4 AP pelvic radiographs with the pelvis in an unknown arbitrary position during acquisition were performed resulting in 80 measurements for accuracy. These measurements were performed by 2 observers at 2 different occasions resulting in a total of 320 measurements for reproducibility and observer reliability. The intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) was used for quantification of reproducibility and observer reliability and the Bland-Altman analysis was used to detect systemic errors. The clinical validation included 33 patients with a pre- and a postoperative CT and 49 patients with only a postoperative CT in addition to the postoperative radiographs. In the cases with only a postoperative CT, for the 2D-3D matching the postoperative CT after manual excision of the cup from the CT slice sticks was used. In all cases the postoperative CT was used as the ground truth. For each patient all the available postoperative radiographs were used resulting in 236 measurements of accuracy.
In the cadaver validation the cup orientation ranged from 34° – 57° for the inclination and from 1° – 24° for the anteversion measured on the CT. The accuracy showed a mean difference for the inclination of 0.9° ± 1.6° (−3.2° – 4.0°) and of 1.2 ± 2.4° (−5.3° – 5.6°) for the anteversion. The ICC for the reproducibility ranged from 0.96 to 0.99 and for the interobserver reliability from 0.95 to 0.98. No relevant systematic error was detected. In the clinical validation the cup orientation measured on the postoperative CT ranged for the inclination from 22° – 57° and for the anteversion from 7° – 35°. In the clinical setup the accuracy showed a mean difference for inclination of 1.8° ± 1.6° (−4.0° – 5.3°) and of −1.1° ± 2.9° (−5.9° – 5.7°) for the anteversion.
The 2D-3D matching technique showed a good accuracy and a very good reproducibility and observer reliability. This technique allows to measure the exact cup orientation out of an AP pelvic radiograph with the help of a preoperative CT and to correct the parameters for the individual pelvic position. Therefore this software is a powerful tool to measure accuracy of CT-based computer-assisted cup placement in a large clinical series.
Minimally invasive surgery (MIS) for total hip arthroplasty and hemiarthroplasty is performed through anterior or anterolateral approach from April 2006.
Appropriate stem insertion is often difficult by conventional approach.
Retractor for MIS stem insertion is used from February 2007 and initial stem position is measured.
Forty-four hemiarthroplasty and 20 total hip arthroplasty were performed from April 2006 until December 2007 with mean age of 79.7.
Retractor for MIS stem insertion has been used for 36 hips from February 2007.
Stem was cemented for more than 13mm at femoral isthmus.
Stem position was measured in rentogenographs of hip after operation about adduction or abduction, extension or flexion, and anteversion of stem in proximal femur.
The average abduction/adduction was 1.75 degree abduction in conventional method and 1.38 degree abduction from February 2007.
The average extension/flexion was 1.10 degree flexion in conventional method and 0.25 degree flexion from February 2007.
The average anteversion was 30.3 degree in conventional method and 28.4 degree from February 2007.
Two cases in conventional method and one case from February 2007 complicated femoral fracture during operation.
In conventional method, cement cap in one case was undersized and proximal major trochanteric fracture was happened in one case.
Ectopic ossification at medial gluteal muscle in one case was observed and one case was dislocated among conventionally operated cases during follow-up period.
Care of femoral exposure though gluteal muscles is needed in anterior and anterolateral MIS. More exact and safe stem insertion procedure is available by using retractor for MIS of the hip.
Typical navigation system to insert hip implants in the accurate position consists of a 3D position measurement device and a computer. These navigation systems are classified into two categories according to the method of identifying the anterior pelvic plane that works as the reference of the orientation of the acetabulum cup. The preparation process for imageless navigation system is very easy because it uses three anatomical bony markers to define the anterior pelvic plane. When these anatomical bony markers are hard to locate, especially at the pubic symphysis due to the thick soft tissue, the accurate direction of the cup cannot be secured. The aim of this study is to estimate the soft tissue thickness without using the patient’s specific data such as the A-mode ultrasound image or C-arm image.
In our previous study, it was pointed out that the thickness of the hypodermic fat obtained through an ultrasound image could be estimated using the patient’s BMI and the displacement created by a specific force. Considering the probe shape, the soft-tissue thickness estimation formula is expressed as follows:
k: constant for the shape of the probe end
Only two kinds of the probe end shapes (flat-ended probe and spherical-ended probe) were considered, and the change in the k value corresponding to the radius was calculated using the FE model of the soft tissue for each subject. The finite-element model was constructed as axisymmetric.
The simulation result of the initially assumed variables and the measured result were compared, and the optimization method was used to minimize the error: The RMS difference between the result of the experiment and that of the analysis was taken as the objective function. With the FE analysis for the two kinds of probe shapes with one subject, we determined the shape variable (k).
From the formula composed by a model with data from 28 people, the average error was 3 mm equivalent to the angle error of less than 1°. Therefore, the use of the method suggested in this study will help to improve the acetabulum cup navigation in THA, when we use only the surface points on the soft tissue. In addition, it seems that the soft-tissue thickness estimation formula suggested in this study may be generally used.
The anterior pelvic plane (APP) through the bilateral anterior superior iliac spines (ASIS) and pubic tuberosities is often used as a pelvic reference in measuring orientation of the acetabular cup in total hip arthroplasty. Apophyses such as ASIS are, however, anatomically variable among patients and APP does not always represent the functional pelvic tilt in the sagittal plane in each patient. Therefore, malposition of the cup and recurrent dislocation may occur even though the cup is placed in a safe zone when measured against APP. We analyzed dynamic pelvic tilt angle in the sagittal plane using a motion analysis system after THA and we found a case of recurrent dislocation due to an unusual APP tilt.
A 77-year-old woman underwent primary THA 3 years ago and cup re-implantation was done with the use of a 10-degree elevated liner and the head diameter was increased from 26mm to 28 mm after two anterior dislocations. However, posterior dislocation occurred 11 times after this. A second revision was performed with a 36 mm head and cup anteversion was optimized against APP. Further posterior dislocations occurred twice again. To probe the cause of recurrent dislocation, we performed motion analysis using a 6-camera VICON system and the markers were registered to the bone and implant models based on the postoperative CT images. This system visually represents four-dimensional dynamic motions that include the time sequential transitions of components and their posture. The cup had been placed in 6 degrees of radiographic anteversion against APP, and in −13 degrees of radiographic retroversion in supine (FPP), because the pelvic flexion angle in supine was 17.6 degrees. Furthermore, when standing, the pelvic flexion angle increased 10 degrees.
Malposition of the acetabular cup in THA is the most common cause of dislocation. To avoid errors in cup placement, computer navigation systems have been introduced and most of the navigation systems refer APP to establish cup orientation. There are two drawbacks in using APP as the reference. One is that apophyses such as ASIS develop variably in each patient with a resulting variability in APP tilt in the sagittal plane in supine. The other is significant changes in pelvis tilt during various activities of daily living such as standing, walking, and sitting. Therefore, even if cup orientation is acceptable when referencing APP, it can be mal-oriented in a functional position of the pelvis as in this case, which showed proper anteversion against APP but retroversion in supine, standing and sitting.
In conclusion, we found that there exists a case in which APP is not a suitable pelvic reference in determining orientation of the cup.
Goals of femoral revision arthroplasty are to achieve stability of the femoral component, to restore biomechanical function of the hip joint and to restore the femoral bone stock. In order to accomplish such an ideal revision arthroplasty, several points should be reminded before and during the revision arthroplasty such as exposure, removal of the failed component, restoration of bone loss, placement of the new component and hip stability. Appropriate options of femoral components for revision depend on the degree of femoral bone loss. When the bone loss is minimum, a standard length component can be used like in primary total hip arthroplasty (THA). When it is moderate or severe, special components and techniques would be necessary.
Loss of bone stock is the most difficult problem in femoral revision surgery. It increases a risk of complications during operation such as fracture or perforation, and also results in difficulty to achieve stability of the component. Even when the bone defect is moderate or severe, immediate fixation of the femoral component should be mainly supported by native bone. Additionally, in the remaining bone loss, bone tissue is grafted as much as possible.
Survival rate of revision arthroplasty is low comparing with that of primary THA. In addition to the present revision, a possible next operation in the future should be considered when we plan revision surgery.
Cemented femoral revision has a disadvantage of removal of the prosthesis when it is failed. Removal of cemented component has a high possibility of complications including perforation and fracture. During revision arthroplasty of a cemented femoral component using a modern cement technique, removal of the cement mantle is difficult, time-consuming and hazardous. The cement mass distal to the tip of the femoral component is the most difficult to be removed since it is often well fixed. The removal procedure has a high risk of causing femoral perforation or fracture. Furthermore, in re-revision, the cement fixation will be often beyond the isthmus and into distal bone defect. And revised cemented femoral components would be more difficult to be removed. On the contrary, loosened uncemented components will be removed relatively easily.
Uncemented stem has the advantage of bone stock restoration. Simultaneous bone graft induces restoration of bone stock. Restored bone tissue will support the component, and this improvement of the bone stock would be beneficial when it is failed again in the future.
According to these principles, we prefer uncemented femoral revisions rather than cemented revisions. This paper will show the clinical results of femoral revisions in our department mainly using an uncemented femoral component.
In this report, porous tantalum was used to achieve abductor tendon reattachment to structural allograft of the proximal femur in salvage reconstruction of a failed total hip arthroplasty.
In each case, a porous tantalum segment with trapezoidal cross section was fixed to a dovetail joint of complementary geometry cut into the lateral greater trochanter. Fixation of the porous tantalum to the allograft was supplemented with polymethylmethacrylate cement. Residual abductors were mobilized from the surrounding soft tissues and secured against the porous tantalum segment with a short greater trochanteric reattachment device and cables.
Patients were followed up at 73 and 80 months. Harris Hip Scores of 74 and 80 respectively were found. Both were unlimited community ambulators without support, had negative Trendelenberg signs, and were satisfied with the clinical outcomes.
This preliminary experience suggests that porous tantalum has potential application in cases of severe proximal femoral bone loss involving abductor deficiency.
Extensive bone deficiencies in proximal femur remains a significant challenge in hip surgery. In such a situation, one alternative is to use a proximal femoral allograft-prosthesis composite (APC) to restore the mechanical integrity and bone stock. The current study was performed to analyze the results of APC in the treatment of femoral bone deficiency.
From January 1996 to June 2006, 12 patients who received 15 APC (3 of them received repeated APC), were followed for a mean of 4.2 years (range 2.0 to 9.8 years) by one surgeon. 5 were males and 7 were females and the mean age of the patients was 60.9 years (range 32 to 84 years). 6 patients were diagnosed with septic loosening, 5 were with aseptic loosening, 4 were with re-revision arthroplasty, and 1 was with limb salvage procedure due to malignancy and all were treated with fresh-frozen allograft. The surgical technique was used to cement the femoral component into the allograft but not into the host bone except 1 case.
The average Harris hip score improved from 21.8, preoperatively, to 83.2, the latest follow-up, and the all stems showed good stability except 3 cases of aseptic loosening. These 3 cases went through a repeated operation with another APC after mean 83.7 months (51,92,108 months) and their results showed good stability. 11 APC had a good junctional union. One case was showed junctional nonunion that needed onlay graft at 3.3 years after APC. There were no infections (or septic loosening), dislocations and allogragt fractures (except one great trochanter avulsion fracture, neither clinical symptoms nor went a surgical treatment).
This study demonstrated that the use of APC for extensive proximal femoral bone deficiencies showed a clinically, functionally and radiologically good results. Therefore it is considered as a good options.
At the revision surgery of the cemented Total hip arthroplasty (THA), complete removal of an old cement mantle of the femur without loosening is very difficult. It can be associated with complications, such as femoral fracture, perforation and femoral bone loss. Cement-within-cement technique (CWCT) of femoral revision is very useful and advantageous without those complications for special cases.
We reviewed the experiential radiological outcomes using CWCT for the cemented femoral revision.
Between 1999 and 2006, we performed seventeen of revision THA using CWCT in 17 patients.
There were four men and 13 women, with an average age of 75 years (range 68 to 87), with an average follow up of 39 months (range 12 to 87).
The reasons for revision surgery were eleven for cup loosening, 5 for recurrent dislocation and one technical failure of stem insertion intra-operatively.
An original Charnley stem (Depuy, Leeds, England) was implanted in six cases, an Exeter femoral component (Stryker Benoist Girard, Herouville, Saint-Clair, France) was in 10 and another stem in one.
Posterolateral approach without trochanteric osteotmy was performing for all patients. After the femoral component was removed, the cement mantle was examined in detail, to confirm cement-bone interface and cement fracture.
The cement mantle was washed with a pulsatile lavage to clean and to be dried.
If necessary, the surface of the cement mantle was reamed. A double mix of Simplex P cement (Stryker Limerick, Limerick, Ireland) in liquid phase was inserted within the cement mantle by a cement gun with a thin nozzle(Stryker Instruments Kalamazoo, US). Thereafter suction and pressuriser were used, and a femoral component was inserted.
The results of this study were that the intra-operative complication was two fractures of the greater trochanter at the stem removed and was one shaft perforation at a new original Charnley stem inserted. The stem position was one valgus and 3 varus stem position of more than 2 degrees.
Radiographic outcomes showed no stem loosening, no radiolucent line at the bone-cement interface, nor any osteolysis in the patients at final follow-up.
We conclude that this cement-within-cement technique is good radiographic outcomes up to 87 months and this technique should be used with the thinner femoral component than the previous.
To evaluate the radiographic mid-to long-term result of femoral revision hip arthroplasty using impacted cancellous allograft combined with cemented, collarless, polished and tapered stem.
Among 27 patients with impacted cancellous allograft with a cemented stem, 28 hips from 26 consecutive patients were analyzed retrospectively. The average patient age was 59 years. The follow-up period ranged 36 months to 10 years, 3 months (mean, 76.6 months). Radiographic parameters analyzed in this study included subsidence of the stem in the cement, subsidence of the cement mantle in the femur, bone remodeling of the femur, radiolucent line, and osteolysis.
Radiographic analysis showed very stable stem initially. 27 stems showed minimal subsidence (less than 0.005m) and 1 stem showed moderate subsidence (about 0.008m) in the cement. But there was no mechanical failure and subsidence at the composite-femur interface. Evidence of cortical and trabecular remodeling were observed in all cases. No radiolucent line or osteolysis were found in the follow-up period. There were 4 proximal femoral cracks and 1 distal femoral splitting during operation.
The result of cemented stem revision with the use of impacted cancellous allograft was good mid-to long-term. And femoral bone stock deficiency may be reconstructed successfully.
It is still unclear whether it is best, when revision surgery is required for replacement of an acetabular component, to treat femoral focal osteolysis with bone-grafting or instead to leave it untreated because the defect is too small and uncontained; the concern is to prevent bone graft from escaping into the hip joint. We hypothesized that progression of osteolysis can halted if the cause of particulate generation is removed and the femoral component is well osseointegrated. We prospectively followed 21 patients (24 hips) who underwent acetabular revision and curetting of proximal femoral osteolysis. These patients were followed for the minimum 3 years (mean, 4.3 years; range, 3–7.4 years).
At the time of the latest follow-up examination, all hips were judged to be stable and to have well-fixed acetabular cups and femoral stems. No hips had significant progression of the osteolytic defect through the follow-up period and none demonstrated any new osteolytic lesion.
Provided that a femoral component is bone ingrown with osseointegration sufficient to provide long-term stability, that the osteolytic defect is in the proximal aspect of the femur, and that the defect is uncontained, simple curettage is an effective alternative to additional bone-grafting.
The new technology using femoral heads with sleeves allows conservative procedures for revision hip arthroplasty. The implantation of classical ceramic heads on a previously used femoral taper is not recommanded. When there is no loosening of the femoral implant, the use of sleeves is a good solution for using an alumine on alumine couple, specially in young and active patients.
In 13 patients the revision was performed for a loosening and a wear of the PHE cup with osteolysis (4 zyrcon and 9 chrome-cobalt heads). The mean age was 49 years for the metal on metal revisions (36 to 75) and 54 years for the prosthesis using a polyethylen socket.
Cementless cups were implanted using XLW delta alumina inserts. The 32 mm delta alumina sleeved heads were adjusted on the existing femoral 12–14 tapers. Patients were evaluated preoperatively and followed-up with clinical and radiological examinations.
Concerning the metal on metal revisions, the aseptic loosening of the socket was combined with high rates of cobalt and chromium serum levels. Mean delay before revision was 4 years (2 to 11). Unipolar acetabular revisions were only decided after a carefull inspection of the remaining stems to detect any taper alteration or impingement lesions.
Postoperative cobalt and chromium serum levels significantly decreased postoperatively.
Concerning the metal on PHE and the zyrcon on PHE revisions, the mean delay before revison was 11 years (4 to 21).
At this short follow up, we did not notice any parasitic impingement due to the additional sleeve or any ceramic fracture or squeaking. The radiographic results did not demonstrate acetabular loosening, osteolysis, or femoral abnormalities.
A seventy-one-years old, female, has been treated by hemodialysis from 1977 due to renal failure. In April 19, 1985, she had Charnley Low Friction Arthroplasty for right hip joint. She often felt mild pain on the joint from 2000. Radiograph showed central migration of the socket and huge cystic bone defect of the acetabulum surrounded by thin cortical bone like an egg-shell form. Tear drop (acetabular floor) was diminished due to massive bone destruction or severe osteolysis. CT showed that the diameter of the cavity was approximately 10 cm. In March 1, 2002, the socket was upside down and moving freely in the cavity. The patient could not weight-bear on right lower extremity but walk without two crutches. Hemiarthroplasty for her left hip joint (contra-lateral side) was done in June 26, 2006, due to femoral neck fracture. Because of continuous right hip joint pain and walking disturbance, she underwent revision surgery in May 20, 2008. At the surgery, the cavity was empty except for the socket and fibrous tissue. Impaction grafting by using morselized allograft including porous and solid hydroxyapatite granules (100 g and 40 g each) was done after the socket and the tissue were extracted. A custom made all polyethylene socket (73 × 68 mm in diameter) was fixed by polymethylmetacrylate bone cement. Postoperative course was uneventful. She can walk with one crutch and ride on/off a vehicles without help four months postoperatively.
It is often difficult to reconstruct acetabulum with large bone defect in revision total hip arthroplasty. Especially, almost of support rings with hook cannot be applied in the case that the tear drop is destructive or absorbed. Impaction bone grafting is commonly used for reconstruction of bone defect in revision surgery. However, the extremely thick graft for large bone defect is at risk of collapsing lead to implant migration. The socket used in the case was custom made jumbo type to reduce the thickness of impaction grafting. It seems to be one of resolution to use the custom made jumbo socket for the case with large defect of acetabulum in revision total hip Arthroplasty.
Though over ten-year follow-up results of impaction bone grafting for acetabular reconstruction from European countries are available in literatures, clinical reports from Asian countries are rare. The purpose of the present study is to assess mid-term clinical and radiographic follow-up results at least three years after acetabular reconstruction with impaction bone grafting technique by single surgeon in Japanese cohort.
The senior author performed 24 acetabular revisions with impaction bone grafting technique in 24 patients from February 2001 to June 2005. The average age of the patients at the revision was 67.5 years (36–82 years). The average follow-up period was 5 years and 5 months (3–7.3 years). The reasons for the operation were aseptic loosening of sockets in 17 hips and migration of bipolar heads in seven. The acetabular bone defects were classified as cavitary in 3 hips and as combined segmental-cavitary in 21 hips according to AAOS classification. For clinical assessment, Merle d’Aubigné and Postel hip score was assessed. Peri-operative complications were recorded. For radiological assessment, antero-posterior hip radiograph was analyzed pre-operatively, and post-operatively at one month, 6 months and every 6 months thereafter. Clear lines more than 2 mm around the sockets using DeLee and Charnley zone classification, and migration of the sockets were assessed. Hodgikinson’s type 3 (complete demarcation line) and type 4 (migration more than 5 mm or change of the angle more than 5 degrees) were classified as “loosening”. Kaplan-Meier survival analysis was performed with radiographic loosening and any re-operation (including recommendation for the re-operation) for the sockets as the end point, respectively.
The mean Merle d’Aubigné and Postel hip score improved from 11.5 points before operation to 15.7 points at the final follow-up. Though, intra-operative blow-out fracture of the acetabular floor was detected in 3 hips, re-containment had been achieved by adding metal mesh or bone graft. Clear lines at cement-bone interface were detected at zone 3 in 2 hips. Migration more than 5 mm was detected in 2 hips of type III defect at 2 years and 6 months. Re-revision was recommended for one migrated hip at 3 years and 6 months after the operation, and the other hip was stable with no clinical symptom without progressive migration at the final follow-up of 5 years. The Kaplan-Meier survival analysis, with loosening and re-operation as the end point, predicted a rate of survival of the socket of 91.7% and 95.2% at 5 years, respectively.
In conclusion, acetabular reconstruction with impaction bone grafting is attractive, but technical demanding procedure. The survival rate of the present series was compatible with the results of previous literatures. However, careful follow-up is essential, especially for the cases with massive bone defect.
Management of severe acetabular bone loss at the time of revision total hip replacements (THR) remains has been one of the greater challenges for hip surgeon. Recently, many methods of acetabular reconstruction have been described and various materials are used for supplement of the bone stock deficiency in acetabular revision THR. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the midterm results of the using support ring with bone allografts in acetabular revision THR.
From 1990 to 2005, forty-six acetabular revisions using supporting ring with bone allografts were performed at our institution. All patients were followed up for a minimum of three years with a mean follow-up of 7.5 years. Pre-operative radiological acetabular bone defects were assessed and classified by author’s classification (Itoman’s classification). Radiological analysis involved a general qualitative evaluation. The position of the acetabular reinforcement ring was measured on radiograms, taken immediately after revision surgery and again at the time of last follow-up. Using a MEM template, cranio-central migration and cup inclination angle were measured. Kaplan-Meier survivorship analysis was performed. The end point was revision because of mechanical loosening of the acetabular implant. We used thirty-six Ganz rings, six Müller rings, three Kerboull T-plate and two Burch-Schneider anti-protrusion cages. The acetabular bone defects were classified as: 10 hips Type B (central defect), 9 hips Type C (cranial defect), 27 hips Type D (cranial-central defect). Migration of acetabular component was defined as a change of >
5mm in the cranial or central direction of the cup or a change in the cup inclination angle of >
5° at the time of last follow-up. All the Eleven acetabular components which had defined as loose were Type D. One acetabular component was revised because of mechanical loosening, four were revised because of infection, and one was broken polyethylene liner. Kaplan-Meier survivorship of these reconstructions was 96.2 % at 10 years. Allograft reconstruction of acetabular bone defect in revision total hip replacement is beneficial procedure. The remaining pelvic bone is usually in poor condition, therefore, it is necessary to ensure primary fixation with the reinforcement ring with bone allografts.
Long-term stability of total hip arthroplasty (THA) depends on the integration between osseous tissue and the biomaterial implant. Integrity of the osseous tissue requires the contribution of mesenchymal stem cells and their continuous differentiation into an osteoblastic phenotype.
Some studies, like Wang ML et al., show that chronic exposure to titanium and zirconium oxide wear debris may contribute to decreased bone formation at the bone/implant interface by reducing the population of viable human mesenchymal stem cells (hMSCs) and compromising their differentiation into functional osteoblasts.
On the basis of our good experience in the use of Exeter technique in revision surgery of THA, two years ago we started to utilize bone grafts mixed with growth factors in order to improve grafts incorporation and implant fixation. At the moment we are studying the use of hMSCs during hip revision surgery, employing polyethylene cup to reduce the possible titanium and zirconium oxide debris. hMSCs are obtained with MarrowsStim Concentration Kit (Biomet Biologics Europe) by 60 ml of patient’s bone marrow.
Clinical outcomes and quality of life are evaluated on the basis of Harris Hip Score, Womac score and SF-36 score, while bone graft incorporation features are assessed with post operative computed tomography (CT) examination and further CT controls at two, four and eight months after surgery.
Anterior approaches have been suggested for THP revision in order to reduce dislocation rate. However, the exposure is considered to be more strenuous. The goal of the study was to evaluate if anterior approach in lateral position may improve the exposure.
From 2005 to 2007, 47 patients underwent THP revision, 34 times on the acetabular side, 2 times on the femoral side and 11 patients had a bipolar revision. Mean age was 64 years and mean BMI was 23. Patients were positioned on the lateral side and had an antero-lateral approach. During the femoral procedure, the leg was placed in a sterile bag stuck on the lateral side in order to optimize the exposure by positioning the femur in adduction and posterior translation.
Acetabular and femoral exposures were achieved correctly in all the cases allowing to perform all the revisions using this technique and no additional approach was needed in any patient. Antero-posterior femorotomies were performed in 7 patients for stem replacement and cement extraction, without any specific complication. Early post-operative anterior dislocations occurred in 2 patients who underwent monopolar cup revision. Dislocation was explained by an excessive anteversion of the remaining stems. 2 patients had an incomplete and transitory sciatic deficiency due to excessive posterior translation of the femoral head in the sciatic notch.
Using this technique, THP revision seems to be achievable even in complicated cases requiring stem revision and femorotomy. Dislocation rate was low; however a larger cohort is needed to confirm these preliminary results.
We evaluated the effects on infection control and clinical feasibility of a prosthesis with antibiotic-loaded acrylic cement(PROSTALAC) which was designed for treatment of infected total hip arthroplasty.
Thirty patients underwent two-staged exchange arthroplasty using the PROSTALAC for treatment of the infected total hip arthroplasty were analysed from March 1995 to February 2007. For shaping of the stem spacer, cement containing antibiotics were appropriately coated on stem spacer and push and pull movement was carried out within the medullary cavity of proximal femur until cement hardened. Also, for prevent of post surgical dislocation, a specially designed polyethylene liner was used. Postoperatively, antibiotics were administered for at least 6 weeks according to the results of erythrocyte sedimentation rate and C-reactive protein assessment.
Infection cure rated 83.3% (20 cases) and C-reactive protein normalized in an average of 5.6weeks (2wks~26wks) but ESR showed very variable score. Partial weight bearing with crutch was possible after 2 weeks postoperatively and lower-limb shortening averaged to 1.43 cm (0.5~3) with a mean bending range of 63.6 degrees (40~90). There were neither dislocations nor fractures during patient mobilization and 5 cases, especially in old age showed satisfactory results even without second staged revision. Recurred infection after PROSTALAC insertion occurred in 5 cases (15%).
Appropriate techniques of PROSTALAC insertion for stability allows us to adjust the reimplantation timing to the course of infection control.
Infection has been one of the serious complications after total hip arthroplasty. It forces physical and mental stress to the patients. We have routinely applied two-stage revision for infected replaced hip joint. Cement spacer mold technique has been used for the purpose since 2002. The purpose of this study is to analysis of peri-operative status and functional outcome of the patients underwent the two-stage revision procedure.
Nine joints of the eight patients were included in the study. Seven patients were female and one was male and its average age was 64 years (55–81 years). After removal of implant, antibiotic-loaded cement spacer prosthesis which was made by the cement spacer mold (Biomet, Warsaw, USA), was inserted. The leg length, range of motion of the hip, walking ability and complications between first and second-stage operation were analyzed. The change of leg length after first stage operation compared with prior operation was ranged from −18 mm to +13 mm with an average of 20 mm. Average range of hip flexion was 70°(40–90°). Patients could walk with crutches after first-stage operation. Complications after first stage operation were found in two cases; fracture of femoral cement spacer prosthesis and dislocation of the femoral spacer. There was no case of recurrence of infection.
Clinical assessment of two-stage revision for infected replaced hip joint with cement spacer mold showed favorable functional outcome and a few complications after first-stage operation. It also showed satisfactory short-term outcome after second-stage operation.
Periprosthetic infection with extensive bone loss is a complex situation. The appropriate management of large bone defects has not been established. Without reconstruction amputation/disarticulation is the likely outcome.
Aim of the study was to Analyse preliminary results of direct exchange endoprosthetic reconstruction for periprosthetic infection associated with segmental bone defects.
Study of patients with periprosthetic infection and severe osteolysis treated by direct exchange tumour prostheses between June, 2005 and May, 2008 (4 – Distal femoral & 2 – Total femoral Replacements). Microbiological evidence of infection was confirmed with regular monitoring of radiograph, crp, esr and wcc. Community based antibiotic therapy was provided by infectious disease team based in our institution.
The mean age and follow up were 74.2 years and 26.5 months respectively. Mean duration of antibiotics was 6 weeks intravenous(community based) and 3.5 months oral. 1 patient required intervention by plastic surgeons at index procedure. Radiographs at 6, 12 & 24 months showed no changes from immediate post-op. CRP, ESR and WBC count were within normal limits at the end of antibiotic therapy. One patient required prolonged pain relief with poor mobility due to instability in the opposite knee. One patient had infection recurrence. Knee range of movements averaged full extension to 95 degrees. The mean oxford knee scores pre and post operatively were 58 and 39.4 respectively.
We conclude that salvage endoprosthetic reconstruction has provided effective pain relief, stability and improved mobility in our experience. It has provided an oppourtunity to avoid amputation. Multidisciplinary support from plastic surgeons and specialist microbiologists is essential.
To obtain correct soft tissue balance during TKA is an important operative technique for successful clinical outcome. The soft tissue balancing has been assessed by the tibiofemoral joint gap in full extension, and at 90°. Since recent advancements in the design of femoral components, tibial articular surface and operative techniques have enabled a prosthetic deep knee flexion, the joint gap measurement in such a condition became necessary. Also it should be noted that the joint gap directly reflects on the clinical outcomes such as range of motion, laxity and instability.
In recent years, many in-vivo kinematic measurement methods were developed, which measure the 3D position and orientation from the 2D X-ray image. Among them a pattern-matching method is representative, which is the method by comparing the contour shape from the X-ray image with a predicted contour to seek the 3D position and orientation.
The objective of this study is to measure the range of motion of knee prostheses from their X-ray fluoroscopic images by using the pattern-matching method.
We analyzed 7 knee prostheses of 7 female patients, age of 59 to 77 years, height of 149.5 to 159 cm, weight of 43 kg to 72 kg. Their knee prostheses were all NRG-PS type (Striker Co., USA) with various sizes. During the fluoroscopy measurement, the patient was lying supine on a bed with her both legs free. First the patients were asked to make flexion-extension with their prosthetic knees by themselves and their fluoroscopic images were recorded for analysis. Next the following motions were done passively. Starting with 0°, the knee angle was gradually increased and fixed at 30°, 60°, 90° and up to 120° respectively. At each flexion angle, the knee was internally rotated as possible as the maximum limit of the patient capacity and then externally rotated in the same way. Similarly, the knee was made varusly and then valgusly at each flexion angle respectively.
The results of kinematic analyses were arranged by the tibial orientations relative to the femur. The range of flexion-extension angles were from 113.9° (SD=8.3°) to 5.2° (SD=8.2°). At maximum flexion for each patient, the orientation in terms of internal-external rotation and varus-valgus was measured and averaged; they were internally rotated by 6.0° (SD=0.6°) and varusly inclined by 1.2° (SD=1.0°). At full extension (minimum flexion), they were externally rotated by 4.3° (SD=1.9°) and varusly inclined by 0.1° (SD=0.7°) respectively. The maximum value of internal-external rotation range was recorded at 89.4° (SD=2.4°) of knee flexion and they were from 5.4° (SD=1.3°) of internal rotation to 12.9° (SD=6.0) of external rotation. The varus-valgus motion was small, from 1.7° (SD=1.6°) of varus to 0.1° (SD=2.2°) of valgus through the whole range of knee flexion.
Important findings were that the range of varus-valgus was smallest for the prosthesis with the thickest insert, and the knee whose collateral ligaments were loose tended to incline varusly.
Intraoperative measurement of tightening torque In vivo data of the maximal torque which was applied by an experienced surgeon was measured using a torquemeter. Total 11 cases of periprosthetic femoral fractures from 11 patients were participated with their agreement. A two-side Dall-Miles cable tightener (Stryker Co., USA) was used. To measure the torque of Dall-Miles tightener applied by a surgeon, a torquemeter (Torque driver 80FTD2-N-S, TOHNICHI, JAPAN) was connected to the Dall-Miles tightener through a square groove. The groove was machined with 1cm × 1cm × 1cm in dimension on the proximal end of the rotational shaft of the Dall-Miles tightener.
Laboratory measurement of torque and tension To reveal the relationship between the torque of Dall-Miles cable tensioner and the tension of the cable, mechanical tests were done. A two-side Dall-Miles cable tightener were mounted to INSTRON (INSTRON, Norwood, MA, USA) using a customized fixation jig. One cable of 2 mm in diameter was connected to the upper head of INSTRON, and another to the lower headA preload was slowly applied to the cables up to 10 N so that the initially loose interaction among a tightener, two cables, and two loading heads of INSTRON became tight. Once the preloading finished, tightening torque and cable tension were simultaneously measured. The tightening torque was increased in increment of 1 N-m; accordingly, at each torque the tension hung to Dall-Miles cable was measured by reading loadcell data of INSTRON.
Numerical expression of torque-tension relationship Based on the data of tightening torque and cable tension measured from mechanical tests, the relationship between the torque (T) and tension (P) of Dall-Midles cable fixation system was numerically expressed. Total range of measured tightening torques and cable tensions was linearized. The linear expression was “T=106.8 × P”. Based on this numerical relationship, the amount of cable tension applied to the cable was calculated as 606.6±58 N.
This study reports the comparison of the clinical use of a new tourniquet system for total knee arthroplasty that can determine its pressure in synchrony with systolic blood pressure (SBP) with the conventional that keeps the initial setting pressure. We prospectively applied the additional pressure of 100 mmHg based on the SBP recorded prior to skin incision to consecutive 72 procedures (conventional; initial 36, new; following 36). Six knees with the conventional and none of 5 with the new showed oozing blood in surgical field after sharp rise in SBP. According to statistically no difference of the perioperative blood loss without any tourniquet-related postoperative complications in both groups, the new system seemed to be much practical device especially for controlling a bloodless surgical field.
Hyaluronic acid (Hyalunan, HA), β-1,4-linked D-glucuronic acid and β-1,3 N-acetyl-D-glucosamine polysaccharide, is a nonsulfated glycosaminoglycan(GAG) conserved in the extracellular matrix (ECM). Due to its biocompatibility, biodegradable properties, HA is widely applied for tissue engineering. However, HA also has defects for tissue engineering such as mechanical properties, difficulty of handling. Thus, it is various modified by chemical reaction to produce HA derivative. HA plays an important role in tissue morphogenesis, proliferation and cell differentiation. Ascorbic acid (AA) has an effect on collagen synthesis and bone mineralization. Ascorbate levels also have a significant effect on osteoblast proliferation and alkaline phosphatase (ALP) expression. However AA is weak to heat and light, thus it is easily degradable. Consequently, we conjugated HA with AA in order to make it more stable and effective. In this study, we prepared HA-AA conjugate and evaluated activity of products in pre-osteoblast.
To produce more effective conjugation, we synthesised HA derivative, HA-N-hydroxysuccinimide, an activated ester of the glucuronic acid moiety. This HA-active ester intermediate is a precursor for drug-polymer conjugates. The degree of substitution was calculated by NMR analysis. The modified HA was dialysed and lyophilised. The yield of conjugation is calculated by Gel Permeation Chromatography (GPC). After the process, HA was conjugated with AA once again as previously mentioned. In this study, the resultant HA-AA conjugate was tested on MC3T3-E1, murine pre-osteoblast cells. We examined cellular viability (cytotoxicity), proliferation and gene expression. The expression of Type 1 collagen was examined by RT-PCR and western blot. Osteocalcin (OCN), osteopontin (OPN) and bone sialoprotein (BSP), bone proliferation and differentiation marker were detected by RT-PCR. Alkaline phosphatase assay was also performed. For confirmation on bone mineralization, alizarin red staining and von Kossa staining was performed.
In conclusion, the in vitro data demonstrate that HA-AA conjugate has an important role in bone formation, as it can increase proliferation and osteogenic differentiation of MC3T3-E1 cells. These observations further support the use of in vivo system for tissue engineering applications.
Physical environments play important roles for maturation of mechanical functions of tissue. In this study, effects of relative tribological movement on the expression of tribological function of regenerated synovial membrane were investigated. Fibroin sponge derived from silk was used as a three-dimension scaffold for the synovial membrane regeneration. Synovial cells were isolated from human synovial membrane, and were seeded onto the fibroin sponge. Magnetic stirring system (named Stirring Chamber) was used for culturing with relative slip motion where the cell-seeded side of the scaffold had been rubbed by a glass culture dish for 24 hours/day.
Histological view of regenerated tissue of the dynamically cultured group (D group) showed extracellular-matrix-like eosinophilic meshwork structure formed continuously on the meshwork structure of the fibroin sponge. The newly formed tissue showed expression of collagen type I, especially on the surface of fibroin sponge. These structures were not seen in the statically incubated group (S group). Each group didn’t show expression of collagen type II.
Frictional force was measured by using leaf spring method under the conditions of the sliding velocity: 0.8 mm/s, the loading time prior to sliding: 1 minute, and the applied load during the experiment: 0.029 N. The counterface for regenerated synovium was a flat stainless steel of which roughness was 0.06 μm Ra. All frictional experiments were performed in the saline solution and at room temperature (25°C). The friction coefficient of tissues cultured statically was 0.6–0.8, and that of tissues cultured with sliding motion was 0.2–0.4 at one week culturing, 0.3–0.5 at two weeks culturing.
Our previous experiment showed that combination of fibroin-sponge scaffold and Stirring-chamber culturing system improved the tribological performance of regenerated cartilage tissue. The present study suggests that this combination have also a possibility for synovial cells to form functional lubricious membrane which can be used as anti-adhesion membrane for knee, ligament, and/or other surgical procedures. However, the deterioration of lubrication properties in the 2 weeks dynamically cultured group would indicate that the too long continuous tribological movement does not provide an optimal condition. More fine tribological loading history should be designed.
While novel surgical technologies offer potential for improved outcomes, the new techniques they require create concerns regarding the acquisition of new skills and clinical outcomes during the initial period of relative inexperience. The purpose of this study was to compare short-term clinical outcomes of medial unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) performed with a conventional technique versus a novel tactile-guided robotic technique.
Eighty-one medial UKA’s were performed by a single surgeon for isolated medial compartment osteoarthritis, 45 with a standard minimally invasive technique using an implant system with which the surgeon had significant prior experience. The other 36 were performed using a new haptic-guided technique with which the surgeon had no prior experience. Knee society scores (KSS) were collected preoperatively and at three, six, and twelve week follow-ups. Marmor ratings were also determined for each follow-up.
There was no significant difference in terms of average KSS, change in KSS, or Marmor rating between the two groups at any of the three follow-ups. At twelve weeks, for example, the average increase in the combined KSS was 83.6 in the conventional group and 79.7 in the haptic-guided group (p = 0.66). Furthermore, there were no significant differences in the measures that comprise these scores, such as range of motion, pain, and use of assist devices (p > 0.05).
Clinical results of an initial series of UKA’s using a new haptic-guided surgical technique are comparable to those using established techniques, thus alleviating concerns regarding the acquisition of a new skill set and inferior outcomes at the beginning of the learning curve.
In this study, it was shown that the layered adsorbed film formation originated from the optimum composition of proteins in lubricants is effective to maintain low wear and low friction for PVA hydrogel artificial cartilage.
Spontaneous osteonecrosis of the knee (SONK) is a distinct clinical condition occurring in patients without any associated risk factors. There is controversy as to the best method of treatment, and the available literature would suggest that patients with SONK have a worse outcome. We evaluated the clinical and radiographic outcomes of unicompartmental knee arthroplasty using Oxford prosthesis in patients with spontaneous osteonecrosis
Between September 2002 and March 2008, 20 knees (18 patients) with SONK were treated with Oxford unicompartmental knee arthroplasty. There were fifteen women and three men with a mean age of 61.1 years old. The mean follow up was 37 months. The clinical assessment was performed using the American knee society score rating system. The preoperative radiography and MRI were analyzed according to size and stage of the osteonecrotic lesion and the osteoarthritic changes. Postoperatively, new osteonecrotic lesion, loosening of implant, subsidence, arthritic changes of other compartment were recorded.
The mean preoperative knee score and the knee function score were 52.5 and 56.0 points, respectively. The knee score was improved to 89.2 points (p < 0.05) and the knee function score was also improved to 85.2 points (p < 0.05) at last follow up. There were no implant failures. There was no new necrotic lesion in the lateral compartment, loosening, subsidence and arthritic change.
The Oxford Unicompartmental knee arthroplasty for spontaneous osteonecrosis of the knee provided satisfactory clinical and radiological results in a short to medium term. However, a longer term follow up will be needed.
Renewed interest in UKA necessitates further investigation into the ramifications of conversion to TKA due to either implant failure or progressive joint disease. The purpose of this study was to compare the depth of tibial resection at UKA and the resulting implications for conversion to TKA using two different UKA techniques and implant designs.
A radiographic review of 42 UKA’s from a single surgeon was performed. Sixteen cases utilized a standard all-polyethylene tibial onlay UKA marketed as a minimally invasive resurfacing implant. The other 26 employed a novel robotically assisted technique and a tibial inlay implant design. Measurement techniques were developed to determine the depth of medial tibial plateau resection at initial UKA as well as potential tibial cuts and implant components required at conversion.
Average depth of bony medial plateau resection was significantly greater in the standard technique onlay design group (8.5 ± 2.26 mm) compared to the robotically assisted inlay group (4.4 ± 0.93 mm) (p< .0001). At conversion to a standard TKA, the proposed tibial osteotomy would require medial augmentation/revision components in 75% of the onlay group as compared to 4% of the robotically assisted inlay group (p< .0001).
Robotically assisted UKA using a tibial inlay design appears to be a truly resurfacing procedure with respect to the tibia, resulting in significantly less tibial bone resection at UKA as well as simpler conversion to TKA when compared to conventional onlay techniques.
The introduction of mobile bearings for unicompartimental knee implants resulted in heightened interest in this implant design in the field of orthopaedics. This study aims to determine the effect of the mobile and fixed design concepts on the wear progression in unicompartmental knee implants using a knee simulator.
An unicompartmental knee implant design, which is available in a fixed and mobile version, was tested using a knee simulator. For the wear test, the medial and lateral compartments were implemented in the simulator. To account for the physiologically higher medial load compared to the lateral compartment, a medially-biased load distribution was implemented. The wear test was performed force controlled according to ISO 14243. Wear was measured gravimetrically separately for the medial and lateral compartments. To evaluate implant kinematics, AP-translation and IE-rotation were measured during the simulation.
Gravimetric wear was higher medially than laterally for both designs. The mean wear rate of the medial mobile compartment was found to be 10.70 mg/10E6 cycles, whereas a mean wear rate of 6.05 mg/10E6cycles was found for the medial compartment of the fixed design. Lateral wear rates, which were about 50% lower than medial wear rates, were found to be 5.38 mg/10E6 cycles in the mobile design and 3.23 mg/10E6 cycles in the lateral design. Wear of the mobile design was higher compared to the fixed design, both medially and laterally. Surprisingly the kinematics of both designs were very similar. A low AP-translation of 2.7 mm in the mobile and 2.4 mm in the fixed designs was documented. High IE-rotations of 6.5° and 6.7° for the mobile and the fixed design, respectively, were observed.
In bicondylar bearing knee designs, reduced wear has been reported for mobile polyethylene inlays. This study showed that the wear behaviour of unicompartmental knee implants differs from bicondylar implants and that the introduction of the mobile concept may lead to increased wear.
There is evidence that positioning of the talar component too posteriorly may cause pain and limit dorsiflexion of the foot (probably because the posterior aspects of the deltoid ligament are over-tensioned), thereby the intrinsic forces are also increased which may cause unacceptable high shear forces at the bone-implant interface and/or component instability. In all but one of the seven revised talar components (out of the author’s first 400 cases), the component was positioned too posteriorly.
There is a potential risk for dislocation of the meniscal component either laterally or medially as long as no appropriate alignment and/or ligament balancing have been achieved during surgery. The author encountered this problem only in two of the first twenty cases; thereafter, no such complications occurred probably because of better understanding alignment and balancing the ankle.
A potential concern in uncemented resurfacing prostheses is the use of screws that may create stress shielding. The HINTEGRA® ankle, however, uses oval holes on the tibial side so that some settling of the component during osteointegration is possible. As screw fixation is located eccentric to the load transfer area, the potential for stress shielding is in addition minimized.
The AOFAS Hindfoot Score improved from 42.1 (14–61) points preoperatively to 78.6 (44–100) points at follow-up. 205 ankles (60.5%) were completely pain free. The average range of motion was clinically 32.2° (range, 15° to 55°), and under fluoroscopy (that is, true ankle motion) 30.4° (range, 7° to 62°). Four ankles were revised to TAA (component loosening, 3; pain, 1), and 2 ankles (component loosening and recurrent misalignment, 1; pain, 1) were revised to ankle arthrodesis. Overall survivorship at 6 years was 98.2%, being 97.9% for the talar component and 98.8% for the tibial component.
Four ankles (1.2%) were successfully revised, and the obtained result at latest follow-up did not differ from those ankles without complications. Whereas, 2 ankles (0.6%) were revised to ankle arthrodesis.
In another series of 37 patients (37 ankles: STAR, 26 ankles; HINTEGRA, 3 ankles; AGILITY, 3 ankles, Büchel-Pappas, 2 ankles; MOBILITY, 2 ankles; SALTO, 1 ankle) with failed total ankle arthroplasty, revision arthroplasty was performed with the HINTEGRA® ankle. All but one surgery were successful. At a mean follow-up of 3.6 (1.2–6.4) years, 29 patients (78.4%) were satisfied with the obtained result. The AOFAS Hindfoot Score improved from 39.2 (23–58) points pre-operatively to 72.8 (54–95) points. All but on implants were radiographically stable; in one case, the tibial component showed, at one year, still a radioluscency which may be considered as loosening. As the patient is completely pain free, no revision surgery was done.
In another series of 29 patients (30 ankles), a painful ankle fusion was taken down and ankle arthroplasty was performed with the HINTEGRA® ankle. All surgeries were successful. At a mean follow-up of 3.4 (2–7.6) years, 24 patients (80%) were satisfied with the obtained result. The AOFAS Hindfoot Score improved from 34.1 (18–47) points preoperatively to 69.4 (48–90) points. The obtained motion for dorsi-/plantar flexion was clinically 23.5° (10°–40°) [52.6% of contra lateral ankle), and radiographically (“true ankle motion”) 24.5°(8°–24°) [54.4% of contra lateral ankle].
The author’s overall experience: more than 750 replacements with the HINTEGRA® ankle in the last 8 years. The learning curve was rather long as some adjustments had to be performed, and there was need of some time to understand “ligament balancing” in ankle replacement in more detail. However, since then, an extremely high satisfaction rate was obtained, and most patients are doing very well. The revision rate has also turned down to < 2% despite, with increased experience, more complex cases may have been considered for ankle replacement.
The purpose of this study was to review the total ankle arthroplasties performed in consecutive series of 78 ankles and to determine the short-term results in cases with over 12 months follow-up. Preoperative diagnoses were post-traumatic osteoarthritis in 40 ankles (51.3%), primary osteoarthritis in 32 ankles (41.0%), and systemic arthritis in six ankles (7.7%). HINTEGRA® (Newdeal SA, Lyon, France) total ankle system was used in all cases
Fifty-five total ankle arthroplasties including four revision cases, followed up for over 12 months (range, 13~49 months) were included in this study. Ankles were divided into three groups according to the coronal plane deformity in preoperative standing ankle AP radiograph; Varus (≥10°; 20 ankles (39.2%)), neutral (< 10° varus or valgus; 25 ankles (49%)), and valgus (≥10° valgus; 6 ankles (11.8%)). Various additional surgeries were performed simultaneously with the arthroplasty to correct the deformities; deltoid ligament release (25 cases), posterior tibialis tendon lengthening (2 cases), peroneus longus tendon transfer to brevis (5 cases), lateral ankle reconstruction with modified Broström procedure (4 cases), lateral closed-wedge calcaneal osteotomy (3 cases), percutaneous heel cord lengthening (19 cases), and gastrocnemius recession (1 case). In one patient with severe valgus deformity, staged total ankle arthroplasty was conducted after primary triple arthrodesis.
Preoperative and postoperative visual analogue scale (VAS), American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) score, range of motion (ROM), as well as patient’s satisfaction and willingness to receive the operation again were evaluated The results were compared among the three groups. Serial radiographs were reviewed for any radiological changes.
AOFAS score has improved from 54.3 ± 11.4 pre-operatively to 79.2 ± 11.4 at last follow-up. VAS has decreased from 6.8 ± 1.6 to 3.2 ± 1.6. Mean improvement in ROM was 15.6 ± 16.2 degrees. Forty-eight cases (873%) were satisfied with excellent or good results and 49 cases (89.1 %) were willing to receive the operation again. No significant differences in the postoperative VAS (p=0.14), AOFAS score (p=0.79), and ROM (p=0.06) were found among the three groups. Hetero-topic ossifications were observed in 12 cases (23.5%) and periosteal reactions proximal to medial malleolus occurred in four cases (7.8%).
Perioperative complications include one intraoperative medial malleolus fracture which was successfully managed with two cannulated-screws, and one medial malleolar stress fracture at six weeks after surgery which has healed spontaneously. One case with osteolysis around tibial screws was managed with bone graft. One case with deep fungal infection was converted to arthrodesis after infection control. Four ankles had to be revised including three cases of polyethylene bearing change due to dislocation, and one case of tibial component and bearing change due to loosening. The patient with revised tibial component was converted to arthrodesis due to recurred loosening. The Kaplan-Meier cumulative survival rate was 90.9% at 12 months and 87.8% at 49 months postoperatively.
The short term clinical results of HINTEGRA ankles showed favorable results. No significant differences were observed among different groups of coronal plane deformities when adequate additional surgeries were performed simultaneously. Long term follow-up study is required.
Recently with the introduction of operations using various instrument of total ankle arthroplasty, we are showing quite satisfactory short term results on the treatment of resolved pain of ankle joint. However, there have been reports of high probability of complication from total ankle arthroplasty to other arthroplasty applied to other joints. Therefore in order to make the results of ankle arthroplasty superior, it is necessary to reduce these complications. We try to analyze complications that occur often and come up with the best results.
There were 45 cases of 42 patients of HINTEGRA® (Newdeal SA, Lyon, France) model from November 2004 to August 2006. Follow up averaged 33.5 months, the average age of patients was 61.1 years, with 14 males and 28 females. We evaluated the complications and analyzed the causes of failures. There was a total 15 cases of complications; 5 cases of medical impingement syndrome, 3 cases of varus malposition, 2 cases of delayed healing of wound, 1 case of peroneal nerve problem, medial malleolar fracture, postoperative deep infection and gouty arthritis pain and Achilles tendinitis.
Our conclusion is that total ankle arthroplasty had more complication rate than other joint arthroplasty, so we need a more meticulous preoperative and perioperative care.
The results of total ankle arthroplasty using metal (first generation) and ceramic (second) prostheses were not good for loosening sinking. Then, we have replaced on 159 ankles in 146 cases using beads-formed alumina ceramic prostheses (third) from 1991 to 2006. The follow-up periods were ranged from 2 to 17 years (average 6.5 years). Revision was performed for 13 cases (arthrodesis, 3; re-replacement by artificial talus. 10). Overall satisfactory result of new prostheses for OA was 88%, RA was 74%. Results of OA were better than RA. Furthermore, we have re-replaced using ceramic talar whole body for 10 revision cases. These results until present have been good. It is convinced that total arthroplasty with talar whole body can be indicated for cases with severe deformity and revision.
There is no data concerning morphological dimensions of distal femur, proximal tibia and patella in Indian population. The objective was to analyse the anthropometric data in Indian knees and to co-relate them with existing knee arthroplasty systems.
MRI scans of 25 patients (15 males & 10 females) who underwent bilateral knee scans for ligamental injuries were collected. Patients with arthritis, bone loss, varus/valgus deformity of > 15 degrees and those with immature skeleton were excluded.
The mean age was 32 yrs (18–53 yrs). Three surgeons independently measured medio-lateral (ML), antero-posterior(AP) dimensions & aspect ratio(AR) of distal femur, proximal tibia and unresected patellar thickness(PT) on three occasions one week apart to account for intra & inter-observer variability. The resultant data of 50 knees was analysed using SPSS v14.0 and compared with five prosthesis knee systems (PFC sigma, NexGen, Scorpio, IB-II & Gender specific knee). The mean ML & AP for proximal tibia was 73.3±5.3 & 47.8±4.3 mm. The mean ML & AP (lateral condyle) for distal femur was 74.3±5.9 & 65.4±5.0 mm. The mean PT was 24.7 & 21.8 mm in males & females respectively. The ML & AP showed a statistically significant positive correlation with the height of the person (ML r=0.55; AP r=0.50 & p=0.01). The tibial and femoral AR showed higher ratio for smaller knees & smaller ratio for larger knees i.e. decline in AR for increasing AP dimension. None of the prosthesis designs mimicked this decrease in AR and NexGen prosthesis infact showed an increase in AR. Gender differences in the morphological data were shown by variable tibial AR.
Most of the available TKR prosthesis designs differ from actual knee morphometry of Indian population. These data provides the basis for designing optimal prosthesis for people of Indian/Asian origin in UK and overseas.
Femoral component sizing can play a critical role in the clinical outcome and success of a TKR prosthesis. In particular, achieving the correct AP dimension for the femur is important to ensure correct balancing and to maintain flexion/extension spacing and the ML width dictates bone coverage which, if insufficient, can cause complications or affect long-term outcomes.
There has been some discussion in the literature about the optimal femoral component shape and size with reports of differences in anatomy between male and female patients or those of larger or smaller stature. The majority of these publications have been conducted on normal anatomy with un-cut bone, reporting on the epicondylar width of the femur which is difficult to relate back to the dimensions of a prosthesis. Some studies have measured resected bone, however, the prosthesis and instruments used to make the cuts dictate the amount of bone removed anteriorly and posteriorly which, in turn affect the footprint of exposed bone that is measured.
Data was gathered to assess whether a generic prosthesis with a standard AP/ML sizing ratio could be used to cover the range of femoral sizes dictated by a Caucasian population of 26 male and 26 female patients. MRI scans were obtained for these patients, all between 20 and 45 years of age and diagnosed with a meniscal tear. A theoretical size range for a prosthesis was determined from an analysis of literature data and a review of currently available devices. This consisted of 8 femoral sizes ranging from 50 – 74.5 mm in AP dimension with a constant AP/ML ratio of 0.9. Each MRI scan was viewed in the sagital plane and the maximum AP dimension was measured. This was sized to the closest available femoral component using the criteria of matching the existing articulating geometry as closely as possible. A ‘virtual’ distal condyle cut was made on the scan relating to the component size and the ML dimension of the resected bone was taken. The measured ML data was then compared to the implant dimension for each subject and component overhang/underhang was determined.
An appropriate femoral component match was found in all cases with a mean AP dimensional undersize of 1.71 mm across all patients (range: 0.16 – 3.77 mm). The mean ML femoral component overhang was 0.34 mm for the male population, 1.52 mm for the female population and 0.89 mm for all 52 patients. These values were all considered to be well within an acceptable range and not be significant in terms of clinical outcome. No patient was too large for the largest component, however no patient in the population that was assessed matched the smallest of the 8 components.
This simple dimensional assessment has shown that using a prosthesis with a standard AP/ML ratio, it is possible to accommodate a mixed gender population. The data reported here suggests that the anatomical differences between men and women femora is not hugely significant and can be covered with a common implant provided a sufficient size range is used.
Finsbury Orthopaedics would like to acknowledge Dr. Pinskerova for providing the MRI scans.
The aim of this study was to evaluate passive kinematics of a mobile-bearing, ultracongruent (UC) total knee design compared with a mobile-bearing, posterior stabilised (PS) design intraoperatively using navigation system.
Thirty-four knees of 24 patients which had undergone total knee arthroplasty with UC prosthesis (E-motion®, Aesculap, Tuttlingen, Germany) for primary osteoarthritis and fifteen knees of 14 patients with PS prosthesis (E-motion®) were included in this study. Thirty-one female and seven male patients were included and the mean age was 70.4 years. Patients were followed up for 7.26 months (6 to 12 months). Intraoperative kinematics including valgus/varus rotation, internal/external rotation, and anterior/posterior translation was assessed from 10° to 120° of passive flexion before and after total knee replacement using a surgical navigation system (Orthopilot®, Aesculap). The range of motion (ROM) was measured preoperatively and at the final follow up.
The tibiofemoral alignment in 10° flexion changed from varus 5.85° to valgus 0.38° in UC group and changed from varus 7.45° to valgus 1.08° in PS group (p> 0.05), the magnitude of varus rotation during flexion was 0.01° in UC group and 4.08° in PS group (p< 0.05). PS knee showed the tendency to slight varus alignment during flexion but UC knee showed the tendency toward valgus alignment fter midflexion. The mean internal rotation during flexion was 10.3° in UC group and 13.2° in PS group (p> 0.05). The translation of the femur was 4.99mm posteriorly in UC group and 3.24mm posteriorly in PS group at 120° flexion (p> 0.05). The maximum flexion angle at the final follow up was 123° in UC group and 118° in PS group (p> 0.05). Total knee arthroplasty with high flexion PS prosthesis showed good ROM and satisfactory early clinical results.
UC total knee design showed less varus rotation during flexion, more valgus pattern in higher flexion angle than PS design, similar internal rotation angle and pattern, and similar posterior translation at 120° flexion with PS design.
Numerous fluoroscopic studies of total knee arthroplasty (TKA) kinematics have shown that many contemporary TKA designs exhibit abnormal tibiofemoral translations during activities like gait and stair climbing. One reason for these abnormal motions is the absence of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) in the vast majority of knees with TKA. The purpose of this study was to analyze knee kinematics during gait and stair activities in patients with a new design of TKA, incorporating a lateral compartment which is fully congruent in extension, but lax in flexion approximating the function of the anterior cruciate ligament. Our goal was to determine if such ACL-substitution results in more normal weight-bearing kinematics during gait and stair activities.
Thirteen ACL-substituting TKAs (AS knees) in 8 patients were observed using fluoroscopy during treadmill gait (1 m/s) and stair stepping. Model-image registration was used to determine the 3D knee kinematics. These kinematics were compared with those from 5 knees with posterior cruciate preserving TKA (PCL Group) and 7 knees with ACL-intact bi-unicondylar arthroplasties (bi-UNI Group). AS Group subjects were 12±6 months post-op. Control groups (PCL Group/bi-UNI Group) subjects were 72±6/15±6 months post-op.
During gait, the AS knees showed 1.6±0.4mm medial condyle posterior translation from heel strike to the middle of stance phase and 2.6±0.3mm posterior translation during swing phase. A similar pattern was observed in the bi-UNI knees. The lateral condyle translated posteriorly 2.1±0.2mm from heel strike to terminal stance phase, similar to the PCL knees and the bi-UNI knees. The center of rotation was predominantly lateral (19% lateral) from heel strike to mid-stance and then moved medially (16% medial) in swing phase. AS knees showed 3.4°±2.4°of internal tibial rotation from mid-stance to terminal stance, similar to the bi-UNI knees. During the stair activity, medial/lateral condylar AP translation in the AS Group was 1.6±0.1mm/2.0±0.3mm from extension to flexion, similar to the bi-UNI knees. The AS knees showed 5.9°±2.4° of internal tibial rotation from 20° to 80° during stair activity, similar to the bi-UNI knees.
Substitution of the ACL by a lateral compartment which is conforming in extension may provide more natural stability and function with knee arthroplasty. Medial condylar translations and axial rotations were similar to those observed in ACL-intact bi-unicondylar knees. Gait kinematics were similar to those reported for healthy natural knees [Koo S and Andriacchi TP, J Biomechancs, 2008]. The long-term success of TKA depends not only on kinematic factors, such as those reported here, but also on polyethylene wear and patellar complications. A longer-term clinical study will be required to determine if ACL-substituting TKA represents an overall functional and clinical improvement compared to more traditional designs.
For wear testing of knee implants, ISO 14243 is the most used testing protocol. In force control, this standard requires linear motion restraints for simulation of ligaments. The aim of this study was to investigate if a nonlinear, physiological motion restraint would influence the wear behaviour of the implants.
A wear study was performed on a highly conforming knee implant design. Three implants were tested forced controlled according to ISO 14243-1 on an AMTI knee simulator. Linear motions restrain of 30 N/mm for AP-translation and 0.6 Nm/° for IE-rotation were applied as required per ISO 14243-1. A second wear test was performed on the same implant design. Based on the data given by Kanamori et al. and Fukubayashi et al., a physiological, nonlinear ligament constraint model (sectioned ACL) was adopted and implemented in the simulation. The implants were pre-soaked and a soak controls was used. Wear was measured gravimetrically.
A mean gravimetric wear rate of 2.85 mg/10E6 cycles was found for the implants which were tested using a linear motion restraint as required per ISO 14243-1. Simulating a physiological, nonlinear motion restraint resulted in a 60% increase in gravimetric wear (mean gravimetric wear rate: 4.75 mg/10E6 cycles). As expected, the kinematics of the implants differed between wear tests. The mean AP-translation increased from 2.89 mm (linear motion restraint) to 4.82 mm (physiological motion restraint). A similar behaviour was observed for the IE-rotation. The IE-rotation increased from 4.09° (linear motion restraint) to 5.94° (physiological motion restraint).
The reaction of the ligaments is not linear in the human knee joint. This study showed that wear and kinematics change when simulating physiological ligament reactions. Wear increased by 60%, an effect which can likely be credited to fundamental differences in kinematics. The ACL is commonly sacrificed during surgery. Thus, more attention should be paid to ligament simulation when performing wear tests on knee implants.
Recently mobile-bearing total knee arthroplasty (TKA) has become more popular. However, the advantages of mobile bearing (MB) PS TKA still remain unclear especially from a kinematic point of view. The objective of this study was to investigate the difference and advantage in kinematics of mobile baring PS TKA compared with fixed bearing (FB) PS TKA. Femorotibial nearest positions for 20 subjects (20 knees), 10 knees implanted with NexGen Legacy flex with mobile bearing PS TKA, and 10 knees implanted with NexGen Legacy flex with fixed bearing PS TKA were analyzed using the sagittal plane fluoroscopic images. All the knees were implanted by a single surgeon. All the subjects performed weight bearing deep knee bending motion. The average range of motion between femoral component and tibial component was 119±18 in MB and 122±10 in FB. The axial rotation of the femoral component was 11.8±6.2 in MB and 11.8±4.9 in FB. There was no significant difference both in range of motion and axial rotation between BM and FB. The kinematic pathway pattern was externally rotated due to a lateral pivot pattern in both MB and FB. In four subjects, more than 12°axial rotation was observed in knees implanted with FB TKA which allows only 12°axial rotation.
The data in this study demonstrates that there was no significant difference in kinematics of weight bearing deep knee bending motion. The advantage of MB is allowance of axial rotation which restricted until 12 °in FB NexGen Legacy flex PS TKA.
Radiologically, the humeral offset, the lateral gleno-humeral offset (coracoid base to the greater tuberosity), height of center of instant rotation and the acromio-humeral distance were significantly increased. No intra-or postoperative complications encountered.
Reverse total shoulder arthroplasty (R-TSA) converts the glenohumeral joint into a ball-and-socket articulation by implanting a metal glenosphere on the glenoid and a concave polyethylene articulation in the humerus. This design increases the stability of the shoulder and is indicated for the treatment of end-stage shoulder arthropathy with significant rotator cuff deficiency. To minimise the risk of loosening, the glenosphere is often medialised (to keep the center of rotation within glenoid bone). Since bone grafting under the glenosphere is recommended as an alternate method to medialisation, we studied the effect of glenosphere placement on the biomechanical efficiency of the deltoid.
A musculoskeletal model of the shoulder was constructed using BodySIM (LifeModeler, Inc, San Clemente, CA). The model simulated active dynamic glenohumeral and scapulothoracic abduction in a shoulder implanted with an R-TSA. Muscle forces and gleno-humeral contact forces were computed during shoulder abduction. The following conditions were simulated:
R-TSA with the center of rotation unchanged; medialisation of center of rotation by 16 mm; medialisation reduced to 10 mm with a 6-mm bone graft; and inferior placement of R-TSA by 4 mm to preserve soft-tissue tension and prevent scapular notching.
We validated our model by comparing peak glenohumeral contact forces (85% body weight) with previously reported in vivo measurements (Bergmann, J Biomech 2007). Inferior placement of the glenosphere component increased the mechanical advantage of deltoid muscle at 90° abduction by 25%. Medialisation of the glenosphere had little effect on deltoid forces. Reducing the medialisation (to 10 mm, by simulating the effect of a bone graft under the glenosphere) also did not change the mechanical advantage relative to full medialisation (16 mm).
One disadvantage of R-TSA is that a center of shoulder rotation outside (lateral) to the glenoid increases the tendency for glenosphere loosening. Unfortunately, medialisation of the glenosphere reduces the tension on the deltoid, increases the incidence of prosthetic impingement resulting in scapular notching, and produces a shoulder contour that is cosmetically undesirable. To counter these disadvantages, reduced medialisation is proposed by bone grafting under the glenosphere and placing the glenosphere inferiorly. Our model indicates that the major mechanical advantage of the R-TSA is provided by the inferior placement of the glenosphere, which increases the moment arm of the deltoid muscle. On the other hand, the extent of glenosphere medialisation had an insignificant effect. These results support the use of reduced medialisation and bone grafting in the presence of other advantages, such as reduced notching and maintenance of infraspinatus tension and improved shoulder contour.
Synthesis and hemi-prosthesis give well known radiological results for acute proximal complex humeral fractures in elderly population. We wanted to expose the radiological outcome of the reverse concept in this indication.
From 1993 to 2007, forty one DELTA III were implanted for thirty two three-part and four-part displacements and nine fracture-dislocations, in 3 males for 38 females, with an average age of seventy five years. The results were estimated with AP and LAMY profile X-rays.
Because of nine deceases and two moving, thirty cases were reviewed with a mean follow-up of 6.5 years, range 1 to 14. The radiographs showed: two 2-mm thick borders on the glenoid at four and eight years with a scapular notch at 11 years and an aseptic loosening of the base plate at 12 years with a broken polar inferior screw. The patient underwent an easy surgical revision because of a fair bone stock. There was no wear of the polyethylene. According to the NEROT classification, seventeen inferior scapular notches were observed with a mean occurrence time of 4.7 years. The seven type-1 notches appeared at a mean of 2 years and the five type-2 notches at a mean of 4.3 years. We observed three type-3 notches which reached the inferior screw at 5,6 and 7 years, and two type-4 notches which extended beyond the inferior screw at 6 and 7 years follow-up, respectively. There seem to be two distinct patters of notches: mechanical, stable proximal humeral bone loss because of an impingement between the humeral component and the inferior scapular pillar and biological, progressive in size, evolving over time with proximal humeral bone loss because of polyethylene disease; the longer the follow-up, the more severe the notch. Fourteen inferior spurs, stable after emergence, were reported with a mean occurrence time of 2.5 years range 1 to 6 years. One joint ossification occurred at 6 months and was stable at 6 year follow-up. The humeral results consisted in four medial (5,6,7 and 10 years) proximal bone looses and two bone-cement interface medial borders on the two thirds of the height of the stem at 5 year follow-up. In these six cases, there was a notch associated. We reported one case of septic humeral loosening at 2 year follow-up.
For acute proximal humeral complex fractures in elderly population, when re-fixation of the tubercles on the classical orthopaedics devices is impossible, the use of a DELTA III prosthesis shows, with a mean follow-up of 6.5 years, worrying images in 70% of the cases. These images are on the glenoid in 70% of the cases, appeared before seven years in 86% and are progressive in 50% of the cases. But, we have only one re-intervention for an aseptic loosening of the base plate at a twelve year evolution. New developments in design and bearing surfaces and a more long term results will probably provide more durable utilization of the reverse concept in this indication.
Improper rotation of the femoral and tibial components in total knee arthroplasty may leads to various patellofemoral(PF) complications. As for the femoral component, alignment it to the epicondylar axis of the femur has been a widely used method. The tibial component traditionally has been aligned to the medial 1/3 of the tibial tuberosity. However, there is no consensus concerning how to determine the tibial component rotation. The purpose of the current study is to evaluate the influence rotational alignment of tibial component upon PF joint. We divided the cases to two groups. Group A: 41cases 50knees (OA 34cases, RA16cases). The average age was 69.5(35~84). Group B: 30cases 30knees (OA 25 cases, RA 5cases). The average age was 72.6(59~86). In group A, the anteropostrior (AP) axis was defined as the line connecting the medial 1/3 of tibial tuberosity and the center of PCL attachment. In group B, the line connecting the medial edge of patellar tendon attachment and the center of PCL attachment was defined as AP axis. We measured the PF alignment on postoperative X-rays. Tangential radiographs were used to measure the amount of patellar tilt (tilting angle: TA), subluxation and patellar lateral shift (LS).
Group A showed that tilting angle 14±4°, lateral shift 0.3±0. These values of group B were 12±5°,0.2±0.1, respectively.
In rotation of tibial component, Insall reported that the landmark in front of tibia was medial 1/3 tibial tuberosity. Akagi et,, al reported that the landmark was midial edge of patellar tendon attachment. This study indicated that the latter had better alignment in patellofemoral joint.
Previous studies report the neurological complication rate for shoulder arthroplasty to be 4.3% to 5.0%, However, these studies were limited to total shoulder arthroplasty (TSA) and did not include hemiarthroplasty (HA) or reverse prosthesis arthroplasty (RPA). Our hypotheses were that the neurological complication incidence after shoulder arthroplasty would vary by type of procedure performed and that the overall incidence would be higher than previously reported in the literature.
We retrospectively reviewed the charts of 307 consecutive patients who had a total of 349 SA by the same surgeon between June 1995 and August 2007. Only patients with over six months follow up were included. The charts were reviewed for any sensory or motor disturbance postoperatively. Those who had EMG confirmation of nerve injury (NI) were placed into the surgical complication group, with a second group composed of patients with neurological symptoms (NS) who did not require electromyography (Dr Ji or Matt---how many in the NI group did not have EMG?). These two groups were statistically compared to those patients without neurological injury using standard statistics software. There were 113 HA, 191 TSA and 45 RPA with over 6 month follow up, and there were 10 (10/349; 2.9%)neurological injuries (NI) There was no significant difference in the incidence between the groups (HA: N=3/113, 2.7%; TSA: N=5/191, 2.6%; RPA:N=2/45, 4.4%). There were an additional 34 neurological symptoms (NS) after shoulder arthroplasy, and if included with the NI then the total rate of neurological complaints after shoulder arthroplasty was 12.6% (44/349). If the NI and NS are combined, multivariate analysis showed that there was a statistically significant association between the development of neurological symptoms and revision surgery.
The rate of neurological complications after shoulder arthroplasty was independent of the type of procedure. The incidence of neurological complaints after shoulder arthroplasty is higher than previously reported.
To make rectangular flexion and extension gap is an important goal in total knee arthroplasty (TKA). The purpose of this study was to determine the AP and rotational position of the femora component to obtain rectangular flexion with reference to the anatomical landmarks.
One hundred and twenty seven varus osteoarthritic knees (87 patients) undergoing TKA from June 2004 to March 2006 were included (72 women and 15 men, mean age 74.4 years). All operations were performed with Vanguard PS, Biomet (Warsaw, IN U.S.A.). The position of femoral component was determined using a modified Ranawat block (Equiflex™) to obtain the rectangular flexion gap equal to extension gap. This instrument uses the balanced soft tissue sleeve in extension as a guide to create a balanced flexion gap. The flexion gap asymmetry after TKA was evaluated as the angle between the posterior condylar axis (PCA) and the tibial cutting line (TCL) by axial radiography of the distal femur. (
The asymmetry of the flexion gap was 1.6±2.4° with slight laxity in the lateral side. The average amount of external rotation of the femoral component relative PCA was on 6.2 ±2.5°. The thickness of resected bone from the posterior lateral and medial condyles were 4.7 ± 2.1 mm and 8.6 ±2.1 mm respectively.
The results of this study have shown that, for a well-balanced flexion gap, femoral component should be excessively rotated by 3 degrees compared to current recommendation (Parallel to SEA) As for the AP position, the average amount of medial bone resection is equal to the implant thickness (9 mm). This information is useful for the modification of measured resection technique to obtain rectangular flexion gap.
The aim of this study was to evaluate the rotational axis of the tibia and the association of its axis to tibial coronal alignment after TKR.
TKRs were performed using navigated mobile bearing system (40 knees), conventional mobile bearing (48 knees) and conventional fixed bearing (40 knees) and preoperative and postoperative CT scans were assessed using 3D image reconstruction-analysis program. The tibial AP axis which was defined as the line connecting the middle of the PCL and the medial edge of the patellar tendon attachment was measured relative to the AP axis of distal femur preoperatively and postoperatively, as well as the coronal angle of the tibia and posterior slope. The tibial coronal alignments in navigation, postoperative plain radiograph and CT were compared.
The AP axis of the tibia was in 2.10° internally rotated position relative to the AP axis of the femur preoperatively and 3.54° postoperatively (range, 19.5° internal rotation to 16.8° external rotation). The coronal angle of the tibia was 0.46° varus on plain radiograph, 0.72° varus on CT, 0.37° valgus in navigation (p=0.005). Posterior slope was 2.53° on plain radiograph and 0.67° in navigation (p< 0.001). There was no correlation between postoperative rotational position of the tibia relative to the femur and the difference in the tibial coronal angle between navigation data and CT.
The proposed anteroposterior axis of the tibia centered between 0 to 5 degrees internally rotated position relative to the femur but showed wide range of deviation. The rotation angle of the tibial cutting in navigated TKR did not influence on the postoperative measurement discrepancy between navigation and CT.
A new type of knee prosthesis capable of making deep knee flexion has been long awaited for Asian and Muslim people. Our research group has developed such a prosthesis and designated it as CFK (Complete Flexion Knee). In order to assess the performance of CFK, we have set up various kinds of simulation/experimental projects, such as a cadaveric study, a mathematical model analysis, a photoelastic analysis and FEM analysis.
For carrying out the above-mentioned projects, we faced the most fundamental problem; the information about the muscles’ forces and the forces acting on the joints is limited to that for ambulatory activities but not for squatting or sedentary sitting.
The objective of this study is to introduce the force acting on the knee joint and the lower limbs’ muscle forces at deep knee flexion. A 2D mathematical model was used. The model was composed with three segments: upper leg, lower leg, and foot. The muscle groups incorporated into our model were gluteal muscles, quadriceps including rectus femoris and the vasti, hamstrings, and calf muscles including gastrocnemius and soleus. And thigh-calf contact was assumed to take place at 130° of knee flexion. Three equations were introduced from the moment equilibrium condition about each joint. Since the number of unknowns was six, being surplus to the number of equations, several muscles were grouped into one basing upon the EMG data.
Double leg ascending motions from deep squatting with heel rising were studied for 10 healthy male subjects age of 24±2 years, height of 172±5.8 cm, weight of 66.5±8.7 Kg. The data of ground reaction force and angle of each joint during the motion were collected using a force plate and video recording system respectively. The length of each segment for each subject was directly measured. The mass of each segment and center of gravity was determined by referring to the literature.
The results demonstrated that both the normal force acting on the knee joint and the quadriceps force became maximum when knee flexion angle became 130°(the angle at which the thigh-calf contact diminished), then decreased according as the knees extended. Both of their maximum value were proportional to the subject’s body weight and about seven times larger than that. Therefore it was justified that the joint force and quadriceps force were normalized by dividing them by the body weight. Ascending speeds did not affect the values of joint and quadriceps forces unless the motion was jumping.
One third of the world population have a life style to sit sedentary on a floor. Thus far the patients who had undergone TKA surgery loose deep flexion of the knee and various designs of artificial knee joint capable of deep knee flexion have been proposed. Among them, Bi-surface knee prosthesis (Kyocera Inc., Japan) is of special interest because of its unique design with a ball-and-socket joint. Although some patients attained a sedentary sitting with this prosthesis, the X-ray studies revealed that the femoral condyles and tibial insert tended to separate at about 150° of knee flexion, indicating a risk of subluxation when standing up.
Thus we have developed CFK (Complete Flexion Knee, Japan Medical Material Co., Japan) by further improving Bi-surface knee to enable the patient to make knee flexion as much as 180°. Our CFK has a ball-and-socket joint and whose socket part is jutted to form a tibial post. Since the ball and the cam become into a single sphere and the ball-socket and post-cam joints form a spherical bearing, CFK can provide high stability and mobility at the same time.
Besides its kinematic performance, CFK has to be assessed with its strength and durability. Since the durability of an artificial knee joint is attributed to wear of the polyethylene insert, it is essential to focus on determining the stress on it. Although the FEM analyses have been most extensive for stress analysis, whose results greatly depend upon the way how to create the meshes. The stress values introduced from the FEM are the Von Misses stresses; while wear is mainly attributed to the shear stresses. For these reasons, we employed a photoelasticity for determining the magnitude and distributions of stresses on the insert.
The models of Bi-surface, CFK and a conventional posterior stabilizer knee, Scorpio NRG (Stryker Co., USA) were used for the experiments. Epoxy resins (Araldite AER 250, 2400, Ciba Geigy Co., Japan) were selected to fabricate the tibial insert models. Special equipment was used to apply 2 kg force on the model by setting knee flexion angle at 0°, 30°, 60°, 90° and 120° respectively. After that the stressed model was sliced along the anterio-posterior direction and photoelastic fringes in each slice were observed. The results demonstrated that while knee angle was smaller than 90°, shear stress on the lateral slice became higher in the order, NRG, CFK, and Bi-surface, indicating NRG has high conformity in the condylar surface. After knee angle bacame larger than 90°, shear stress on the mid-posterior slice became higher in the order, CFK, Bi-surface and NRG. We may conclude that CFK has optimal configuration at deep knee flexion not only for kinematic but also for load bearing viewpoints.
Recently, it has been reported that the posterior stabilised implant clinically used for the total knee replacement (TKR) may have a risk of failures caused by pressure and stress concentrated on the tibial post. Malalignment of the implant or variable loading applied to the implant are one of the major causes of the failure in posteriori stabilised TKR. The purpose of this study is to biomechanically analyse the effect of implant malalignment on the failure risk of the implant in posteriori stabilised TKR by estimating von-Mises stress on the implant.
Finite element models of a knee joint and a posteriori stabilised implant were developed from 1mm slices of CT images and 3D CAD software, respectively. The posterior stabilised implant consists of a femoral component, a tibial post, and a tibial tray. The finite element models of TKR for the neutral alignment case as well as the different malalignment cases (3° and 5° of valgus and varus angulations, 2° and 4° of anterior and posterior tilts, and 3° of external rotation) were developed. Then, the von-Mises stress, which is which was chosen as the fracture risk parameter, acting on the implant were analysed by using CAE software. Loading condition at the 40% of one whole gait cycle such as 2000N of compressive load, 25N of anterior-posterior load, and 6.5Nm of torque was applied to the TKR models.
The maximum von-Mises stresses were concentrated on the anterior region of the tibial post regardless of the oblique loadings. In the rotationally additional loading (3° of external rotation), excessive stresses occurred in the anterior medial and posterior lateral areas. The maximum stress was 18.3MPa in neutral position. The maximum stress increased by 10% in anterior tilt 2°, 15% in anterior tilt 4°, 25% in posterior tilt 2°, 54% in posterior tilt 4°, 116% in varus 3°, 262% in varus 5°, 318% in valgus 3°, 389% in valgus 5°, 6% in external rotation 3° compared with that in the neutral position case. In addition, 32.0MPa of maximum stress occurred on the posterior lateral area of the base component in rotationally additional loading.
The results showed that the implant malalignment could accelerate the stress concentration on the anterior region of the tibial post as in the result of clinical study. In the case of additional rotation, high stress concentration on the anterior medial and posterior lateral areas as well as on the tibial base surface could generate wear or fracture of tibial post. From the additional rotation case, we can expect that higher conformity implant will generate higher stress concentrations than lower conformity implant even though we did not compare the effect of conformity ratio on the stress concentration in the tibial polyethylene component. This study showed that careful consideration of the implant malalignment would be necessary to improve the clinical outcome in the posteriori stabilised TKR.
In the anatomical studies for Caucasian, it has been reported that the center of plateau tends to be located central or lateral from the tibial canal axis. However, in the three dimensional analysis of author, the center of plateau was located on average 4.4 mm medial from the point of tibial canal axis passing through the plateau. The purpose of this study is to examine the placement of the tibial component in relation to the anatomical axis of the tibia in total knee arthroplasties for Korean patients and to identify this mismatch affecting the measurement of postoperative mechanical axis.
Measurements were performed on the pre- and postoperative radiographs of 60 osteoarthritic knees with varus deformity replaced between October 2005 and May 2008 using PFC. The inclusion criteria was the cases with the accurate coronal alignment of component, in which α angle ranged from 94 to 96° and β angle ranged from 89 to 91°. The mean age was 66.6 years (range, 54 to 79), and the body mass index was 27.0 kg/m2 (range, 20.7 to 37.7). Radiological measurements were performed using an orthoreontgenogram. Preoperatively, 30 patients with varus deformity lesser than vaurs 10° were classified to group A and 30 patients greater than vaurs 10° were classified to group B. Post-operatively, the distance between the midline of the tibial stem and anatomical axis (medial offset) was measured at the level of tibial resection. These distances were compared between the group A and B. The postoperative mechanical axes were compared between the group A and B. The intra- and inter-observer reliabilities were assessed. In this study, intraclass correlation coefficient values of all measurements were greater than 0.8.
The mean preoperative mechanical axes were varus 7.4±2.3° in group A and varus 16.9±4.0° in group B (p=0.000). The mean medial offsets were 2.5±1.9mm (range, −3.6 to 5.9) in group A and 3.9±2.7mm (range, −1.1 to 10.2) in group B (p=0.021). The tibial stems were located medial to anatomical axis in 22 knees (73.3%) of group A and 26 knees (86.7%) of group B. The mean postoperative mechanical axis were varus 1.3± 1.2° (range, varus 3.6 to valugs 1.6°) in group A and varus 2.5± 2.0° (range, varus 5.9 to valugs 2.1°) in group B (p=0.004).
In this study of TKA, the tibial component in relation to anatomical axis tends to be located medial. The postoperative mechanical axis remained more varus in spite of the accurate coronal alignment of the component as the preoperative varus deformity was more severe. This study suggests that the radiographic measurement of postoperative mechanical axis using a line passing the component center has the limitation.
The Birmingham Knee Replacement (BKR, Jointmedica, UK) is a newly designed knee replacement which combines a high conformity during the complete ROM with the principles of rotating platform and high-flexion TKA. The main objective of this study was to analyze the mechanical performance of the BKR during its full ROM (0°–155°) and investigate whether its high conformity could be maintained during high-flexion. In addition, the BKR polyethylene loading computed in this study was compared with other mobile bearings.
The current study therefore indicates that the BKR benefits from its high conformity during the full ROM. Hence, the BKR demonstrated relatively low polyethylene stresses. The quadriceps efficiency during deep knee flexion may be lower in case of the BKR since the femoral rollback was negligible at these flexion angles. Whether this phenomenon is of any clinical relevance is unknown.
We have developed a new type of knee prosthesis which is capable to make 180° knee flexion, and have designated it as Complete flexion knee (CFK). Since the kinematics and kinetics of knee prosthesis vary depending not only on its articulating surface shapes but also on the stiffness of soft tissues, its performance should be assessed under various kinds of lower limb activities.
The objective of this study is to perform simulation analysis of various lower limb activities to evaluate the performance of CFK using the 2D and the 3D mathematical models. Kinematic analyses using X-ray picture or stress analyses using FEM are extensive however, kinematic analyses can not introduce stresses and FEM can not introduce kinematics. Mathematical model analyses can introduce vital information about kinematics and kinetics at the same time.
First, we carried out an in-vitro experiment using cadaver knee under the condition of passive knee flexion-extension. After that, we performed a simulation using the same parameter variables as the in-vitro experiment in order to assess the validity of our 2D and 3D models by comparing the results about the joint contact forces and kinematics with those from the experiment.
In the in-vitro experiment, the femoral bone of a cadaver knee was fixed on a jig. In order to secure the tibiofemoral contact, each muscle was pulled with constant force respectively. Then the tibia was carried through from 40° to 140° of knee flexion. The contact forces between the femur and the tibia were measured by a load sensor. During the process, fluoroscopic images were taken, and then 3D positions/orientations of the tibia relative to the femur were introduced from the images using the pattern matching method.
Our 2D and 3D models of total knee arthroplastic joint included the tibio-femoral and patello-femoral compartments, incorporating major muscles, patella tendon and primary ligaments. The patella tendon and primary ligaments were represented with non-linear springs, whose mechanical properties were determined from the literature. In our 2D model, “thigh and calf” contact was taken into account at deep knee flexion.
Using our 3D model, the simulation was performed up to 100° of knee flexion. After that we had to alternate the model from the 3D to the 2D because the patella stacked into the femoral intercondylar, the thigh-calf contact occurred and the 3D model did not introduce the converged solution.
Over all, both the experimental and simulation results were in good agreement with each other. The results from the simulation showed that the contact points were located unusually anteriorly. The post-cam contact occurred at 44° of knee flexion, indicating that the tibia was strongly pulled to the posterior. As for the contact resultant force, large differences between simulation and experiment were found. This may be because the soft tissues of the cadaver were not intact, while we determined their properties from the literature in the simulation.
Patellofemoral complications are among the important reasons for revision knee arthroplasty. Femoral component malposition has been implicated in patellofemoral maltracking, which is associated with anterior knee pain, subluxation, fracture, wear, and aseptic loosening. Rotating-platform mobile bearings compensate for malrotation between the tibial and femoral components. It has been suggested that rotating bearings may also reduce the patellofemoral maltracking resulting from femoral component malposition.
We constructed a dynamic musculoskeletal model of weight-bearing knee flexion in a knee implanted with posterior cruciate-retaining arthroplasty components (LifeMOD/KneeSIM, LifeModeler Inc). The model was validated using tibiofemoral and patellofemoral kinematics and forces measured in cadaver knees on an Oxford knee rig. Knee kinematics and patellofemoral forces were measured after simulating axial malrotation of the femoral component (±3° of the transepicondylar reference line). Differences in patellofemoral kinematics and forces between the fixed- and rotating-bearing conditions were analysed.
Rotational malalignment of the femoral component affected tibial rotation near full extension and tibial adduction at higher flexion angles. In the fixed-bearing conditions, external rotation of the femoral component increased patellofemoral lateral tilt, patellofemoral lateral shift, and patellofemoral lateral shear forces. Up to 6° of bearing rotation relative to the tibia was noted in the rotating-bearing condition. However, the rotating bearing had minimal effect in reducing the patellofemoral maltracking or shear induced by femoral component rotation.
The rotating bearing does not appear to be forgiving of malalignment of the extensor mechanism resulting from femoral component malrotation. The rotating bearing may correct tibiofemoral axial malrotation near full extension but not at higher knee flexion angles. These results support the value of improving existing methodologies for accurate femoral component alignment in knee arthroplasty.
Application of computer assisted navigation (CAN) has been documented to improve the accuracy of limb alignment and implant positioning. However, a recent study reported that a great deal of disparities occurred between the radiographic and navigational measurements calling the basic argument for application of CAN to TKA into question. In the authors’ practice using CAN for TKA, we have observed consistent disparities between the preoperative radiographic assessments and intraoperative navigational assessments of limb alignment in the coronal plane. A large disparity between radiographic and navigational assessments of limb alignment would be presenting a challenging question whether or not the surgeon can rely on the information provided by the CAN system. We developed a novel method to measure the coronal limb alignment and have found that the radiographic measurements with the novel method remarkably reduce the disparities between the radiographic and navigational assessments of the coronal limb alignment. This study was conducted to document the existence of the disparities between the radiographic and navigational assessments of the limb alignment and the value of our novel method to perform preoperative radiographic measurements of limb alignment.
In 107 TKAs performed using a CAN system (Ortho-pilot: B. Braun-Aesculap, Tuttlingen, Germany), radiographic assessments of coronal limb alignment were assessed using preoperative and postoperative whole limb radiographs taken with weight bearing with two different methods: a standard method, angle between the femoral mechanical axis (the line connecting hip center and the top pint of the femoral intercondylar notch) and a tibial mechanical axis (the line connecting the mid-point between the medial and lateral tibial eminences and the mid-point of the talus dome) and a novel method, the angle between the weight loading line (the line connecting the hip center and the mid-point of the talus dome) and the tibial mechanical axis. A negative value was given to a varus alignment and a positive value to the valgus alignment. During surgery, the coronal limb alignment was measured by the navigation system two different time-points: after registration and after implantation of prostheses. The disparity between the radiographic and navigational assessments was calculated with subtracting the radiographic assessments by the navigational assessments.
The disparity between the radiographic and navigational assessments was significantly smaller with the novel method than with the standard method. The mean difference between the radiographic and navigational assessments of preoperative limb alignment was −6.5o (range: −19 ~ 1) with the standard method and −0.9o (range: −8o to 4o) with the novel method. The mean difference between the radiographic and navigational assessments of the postoperative limb alignment was −1.96 (range: −11 ~ 3) with the standard method and −1.3 (range: −6 ~3).
This study documents that a wide range of disparities occurs between the radiographic and navigational assessments of limb alignment and the amount of disparity occurs in preoperative assessments. Our findings indicate that our novel method to perform the radiographic assessments of limb alignment can be a useful tool to interpret the information intraoperatively given by the navigation system.
We hypothesized that navigation can help provide a well-balanced knee, through real-time feedback of alignment accuracies and gap sizes in flexion and extension. The purpose of this study was to evaluate in vivo stabilities of mediolateral laxity in full extension and anteroposterior laxities in 90° of flexion after navigation-assisted total knee arthroplasty, and to determine the nature of the correlations between these and range of motion (ROM).
Forty-two total knee arthroplasties performed using a navigation system with a minimum two-year follow-up were included. The following were measured at final follow-ups; mediolateral laxities at extension and anteroposterior laxities at 90 degrees of flexion (using stress radiographs and a Telos arthrometer), modified HSS scores (excluding laxity and range of motion), and range of motion (ROM).
At final follow-up the mean modified HSS score was 82% of total points and mean postoperative ROM was 128.1 ± 10.4°. Mean medial laxity was 3.5 ± 1.4°, mean lateral laxity 4.4 ± 2.2°, and mean anteroposterior laxity 7.1 ± 4.1 mm. We found no significant correlation between mediolateral laxity and postoperative ROM. However, a significant correlation was found between postoperative ROM and anteroposterior laxity.
In the present study, the use of a navigation system in total knee arthroplasty was found to improve in vivo stability and produce promising short-term clinical results.
Computer assisted surgical techniques in total knee arthroplasty have demonstrated increased accuracy of alignment and decreased risk of outliers. Some studies have also demonstrated improved early functional results and pain scores in comparison to traditional surgical methods. Studies have also shown a slightly increased surgical time for computer assisted surgery. A learning curve for computer assisted surgery is recognized, and there may be different outcomes for cases performed initially during the learning phase. This study reports on a single surgeon’s experience with the initial 261 computer assisted total knee arthroplasties.
A single experienced, fellowship trained surgeon performed computer assisted total knee arthroplasty utilizing either the BrainLab or Ci intraoperative navigation system and either the LCS Complete Mobile Bearing Knee System (DePuy) or Sigma PFC Rotating Platform (DePuy). Preoperative and postoperative data was recorded prospectively (DePuy Captureware) of the initial 261 consecutive cases at minimum of one year follow-up. SAS 9.1 was used to perform univariate and multivariate analyses of four groups of patients: patients 1–77, patients 78–135, patients 136–211 and patients 212–261. Multivariate analyses were performed to control for body mass index, age, sex, implant type, pre-operative range of motion, preoperative function and preoperative pain scores.
Multivariate analysis of these four groups demonstrated that there was no statistically significant difference in the improvement of postoperative function (p=0.29) and pain scores (p=0.28) among the patients in the four groups at minimum one year follow-up. There was a statistically significant difference in improvement of postoperative extension (p=0.0022) and flexion (p=0.0139) scores with subsequent surgeries, however the range of improvement for the groups was not clinically significant (extension ranging from 1.97 to 5.92 degrees gained in the four groups, and flexion loss of 0.67 degrees to gain of 6.18 degrees in the four groups). The number of patients requiring a hospitalization greater than two days decreased with each subsequent group which was clinically significant (p=0.021, p=0.001, p< 0.0001 for the second, third and fourth groups, respectively).
For an experienced reconstructive surgeon incorporating computer assisted surgery into his total knee arthroplasty practice, there is no significant learning curve in regards to intermediate term outcomes. Patients undergoing computer assisted total knee arthroplasty have similar intermediate outcomes whether performed earlier in that surgeon’s experience or later. Patients did initially have shorter hospitalization stays in subsequent groups. However, at an intermediate follow-up period of one year, there is no significant difference in patients’ postoperative improvement in function, pain score, knee flexion and knee extension.
Computer navigation in total joint arthroplasty has been shown to be effective in improving the radiographic outcome in patients undergoing both hip and knee arthroplasty. However, critics have argued that the required capital equipment and added time to perform the procedure is cost prohibitive. To test this hypothesis, we compared our hospital discharge experience with computer navigation to national standards published by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality for the years 2004 and 2005
In the AHRQ database the average length of stay for DRG 209 in 2004 and 2005 respectively, in the Midwest region was 4.6 days and 4.3 days, with a mean charge of $27,403 and $27,948, with only 40% and 45%, of patients discharged to home with or without home health care. In 2004 and 2005, the senior author performed 125 and 117 Medicare primary hip and knee replacements, respectively, with computer navigation with a mean length of stay of 2.9 days and 2.8 days, with charges of $22,134 and $24,612, and 63% and 71% discharged to home.
On a pure charge basis, the senior author experience a decreased overall charge compared to published data. Even if the entire cost of the navigation system in our system $204,000 was spread equally over only the Medicare patients over the two year period, the additional $842/case still results in a case charge below published data.
Based on the senior author’s experience with hospitalization cost, length of stay and discharge disposition, computer navigation in total joint replacement is not associated with an increased cost/case and may result in dramatically lower indirect costs due to shorter length of stay and increased number of discharges to home compared to published regional Medicare discharge data.
Despite the well-documented improvement in coronal alignment achieved by computer assisted navigation, varying results have been reported for sagittal alignment. Current navigation systems rely on a sagittal femoral mechanical axis identified by the navigation system, but little information is available on the relationship between the sagittal mechanical axis and anatomical axes for intra-operative or postoperative radiographic assessments. We asked whether deviations exist between sagittal femoral mechanical axis and anatomical axes and attempted to identify predictors of the deviations found.
In 100 consecutive patients (200 knees) undergoing TKA, angles between two anatomical axes (the anterior cortical line and mid-medullary line) and two sagittal mechanical axes identified by current navigation systems were measured as proxies of the deviations between them on true lateral radiographs of the whole femur. Correlation analyses and multivariate regression were carried out to identify predictors of deviations.
Significant deviations existed with wide ranges between the anatomical axes and the sagittal mechanical axes. Degree of femoral bowing and femoral length were found to be predictors of deviations between sagittal femoral mechanical axes and anatomical axes.
This study suggests that surgeons applying navigation technology to TKA need to consider deviations between the sagittal femoral mechanical axes and anatomical axes when they intend to place a femoral component at a target sagittal orientation with respect to an anatomical reference.
Literature has shown that the outcomes of UKA are significantly improved by correct component alignment. With the desire to minimize the surgical exposure and the limitations of manual instrumentation, this goal has proven difficult to achieve consistently. This study evaluates the accuracy of a new technique that replaces manual instrumentation with a robotically guided cutting instrument designed to implement a three-dimensional pre-operative plan.
Forty-three UKAs were implanted using a robotically guided system that creates virtual boundaries defining the depth and volume of bone resection for a specific implant. The boundaries were based on a three-dimensional pre-operative plan. Post-operative lateral and AP radiographs were evaluated for four different aspects of component to host bone alignment for the tibia and four for the femur. Ten patients also underwent a post-operative CT to compare the resultant versus the planned three-dimensional component placements.
Radiographically, we identified an outlier as any specific measurement outside a particular range set by an independent clinical advisory board of orthopedic surgeons. Of the 344 radiographic measurements, only 4 (1%) were identified as outliers, with none of these deemed clinically significant. On average, the components were placed in 0.6° less varus (SD = 1.9°) and 0.1° less posterior slope (SD = 1.8°) compared with the pre-operative plan, with RMS errors of 1.9° in the coronal plane and 1.7° in the sagittal plane.
Robotically assisted implementation of a pre-operative plan for UKA is accurate and precise with very few outliers. This is particularly impressive as these patients were from the inaugural series of patients undergoing a technologically innovative procedure. This technology has great potential to improve accuracy and enhance safety for surgeons with procedures that are less forgiving and technically difficult.
There are several techniques in minimally invasive total hip arthroplasty. One of the possible advantages of these techniques is early functional recovery. The purpose of the study was to evaluate possible differences in functional recovery patterns after three different techniques of minimally invasive total hip arthroplasty.
Computer navigation for total knee arthroplasty (TKA) has been increasingly used because it improves the accuracy of implant placement. However, some clinical cases have reported complications caused from pin holes during the computer navigated surgery. The objective of this study is to analyse the femoral fracture risk cause by the pin hole in the computer navigated TKA by using finite element analysis.
Three dimensional finite element model of the human femur was developed from CT images. A parametric investigation was conducted to analyse the femoral fracture risk for the following parameters: hole sizes (3, 4, and 5 mm) and hole position (70, 100, and 130 mm above the distal end). Four different penetrations (unicortical, bicortical, half-bicortical, and transcortical) methods in tubular bone were considered in each model, where the half-bicortical penetration was defined that the pin hole was located between the holes of bicortical and transcortical penetrations. The finite element model was rigidly fixed to a distance of 25 mm above the distal end. The vertical load of 1500 N and the torsional load of 12 Nm were applied to the femoral head. The maximum von-Mises stress, which was chosen as the fracture risk factor, was then investigated around pin hole.
The maximum von-Mises stress around the pin hole was the highest in the transcortical penetration for different hole sizes: 7.8~8.5, 15.7~16.2, 15.5~16.8, and 25.5~45.3 MPa under the vertical load, and 9.6~10.5, 9.7~11.0, 8.8~10.2, and 14.2~33.8 MPa under the torsional load in unicortical, bicortical, half-bicortical, and transcortical penetrations, respectively. For the different hole position, the maximum von-Mises stress around the pin hole was: 6.0~7.8, 15.7~24.7, 16.3~19.6, and 12.2~22.4 MPa under the vertical load, and 9.6~10.7, 9.7~11.5, 8.7~9.8, and 12.2~16.6 MPa under the torsional load in unicortical, bicortical, half-bicortical, and transcortical penetrations, respectively.
For the pin hole size, the maximum stress increased only in the transcortical penetration regardless of the loads as the pin hole size increased. However, there was little meaningful difference between the hole positions for each penetration method. The results of this study suggested that it would be beneficial to avoid using the transcortical penetration and large size of pin with respect to reduction of femoral fracture risk since the high stress may cause the femoral fracture.
Hi-flex insert was developed in part for the needs of Asian and Islamic people’s life style, because of the traditional floor sitting style in a daily life. We studied about the short term results of Genesis2 with Hi-flex insert in Japanese life style for 57knees in 39patients that were passed more than 2 years post-operation between 2004 and 2006. The mean age at implantation was 72.1. From the patients reviewed the mean pre-operative Japanese Orthopaedic Association score was 51, compared to 81 at last follow up. The mean pre-operative flexion was 113, compared to 124 at last follow up. Almost all patients had changed their life style basically from Japanese (floor sitting) to Western (chair sitting) before operation because of their knee problems. But 30% of the patients sometimes wanted to sit on the floor traditionally before the operation, and 83% of these patients can sit also after the operation. Japanese traditional life styles with the knee flexed deeply can be achieved by Genesis2 with Hi-flex insert satisfactorily limited to the patients who could do also before the operation. But when the patients sit on the floor, the complicated stress to the implants and insert were unknown. At the present time, we must advice to the patients who can sit on the floor about the motion that can reduce the stress to the implants and insert.
The aims of this study were to assess the clinical outcomes especially range of motion of the knee after total knee arthroplasty with sigma RP-F versus LCS RP.
110 knees underwent total knee arthroplasty with LCS, and 59 knees with PFC sigma RP-F. We performed a prospective clinical trial. At the time of the one-year follow-up, we compared the clinical outcomes of two groups. In LCS group, LCS AP glide type group was excluded. Range of motion, the knee score, functional score and HSS score etc. were assessed.
91 knees were available. The mean active non-weight-bearing range of motion at one year was 124 (95% confidence interval) in the fifty-six knees that underwent a LCS and 127 (95% confidence interval) in the thirty-six knees that underwent a PFC sigma RP-F (p=0.55). There were no significant differences in the knee score (the mean 94.12 in LCS, 93.54 in RP-F, p=050), functional score(the mean 62.58 in LCS, 65.14 in RP-F, p=0.91) and HSS score (the mean 87.73 in LCS, 87.85 in RP-F, p=0.50).
Although PFC sigma RP-F has the design that is advantageous in knee flexion, we found no significant differences between the groups with regard to range of motion or clinical outcomes.
Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA) has been widely performed and successful clinical outcomes have been achieved for the patients with knee osteoarthritis which is generally known to cause ADL problem. Clinical and radiographic evaluations are commonly used when evaluating postoperative outcomes, among which kinetic analysis and gait analysis are considered essential to investigate the more detailed effect of the treatment. There is a controversy whether performing TKA on both knees simultaneously is appropriate in treating patients with bilateral knee osteoarthritis, in terms of the speed and effectiveness of gait recovery. In this study, we reviewed the significance of performing simultaneous bilateral TKA, by the results of preoperative and postoperative gait analysis.
We compared the short term follow-up clinical and radiological results after PCL substituting (PS) Medial Pivot Knee and Nexgen® LPS total knee arthroplasty (TKA).
Seventy knees in 48 patients after TKA with PS ADVANCE® Medial Pivot Knee (Group I) and sixty seven knees in 45 patients after TKA with Nexgen® LPS (Group II) were evaluated retrospectively from March 2004 to May 2006. The mean follow up period was 31 months (range: 24–43 months) in group I and 32 month (range: 24–46 months) in group II. All the knees were operated by one surgeon. The evaluations included the preoperative and postoperative range of motion (ROM), Knee society score (KSS), tibiofemoral angle, and postoperative complications.
In group I, ROM increased from preoperative mean flexion contracture of 6.3° and further flexion of 116° to postoperative mean flexion contracture 1.9° and further flexion 121°, KS knee score increased from 46 to 87, KS function score increased from 37 to 83, and tibiofemoral angle changed from preoperative varus 4.0° to postoperative valgus 5.5°. In group II, ROM increased from preoperative mean flexion contracture of 13° and further flexion of 118° to postoperative mean flexion contracture 0.9° and further flexion 123°, KS knee score increased from 50 to 87, KS function score increased from 48 to 83, and tibiofemoral angle changed from preoperative varus 4.1° to postoperative valgus 5.3°. The complications were two periprosthetic patellar fracture and one failure of tibial component in group I, and one early failure of femoral component and one arthrofibrosis in group II. There was no statistical difference in radiological and clinical results between the two groups.
Minimum 2-year follow-up result of PS Medial Pivot Knee TKA was comparable to that of Nexgen® LPS TKA and longer term follow-up would be necessary.
In a previous study, we found that pre-TKA patients were severely disabled in high-flexion activities but perceived these disabilities as being no more important than pain relief and the restoration of daily routine activities. This study was conducted to investigate functional disabilities and patient satisfaction in Korean patients after TKA.
Of 387 patients who had undergone TKA with a follow-up longer than 12 months, 270 (69.7%) completed a questionnaire designed to evaluate functional disabilities, perceived importance and patient satisfaction.
The top 5 severe functional disabilities were difficulties in kneeling, squatting, sitting with legs crossed, sexual activity, and recreational activities. The top 5 in order of perceived importance were difficulties in walking, using a bathtub, working, climbing stairs, and recreation activities. Severities of functional disabilities were not found to be correlated with perceived importance. The patients (8.5%) dissatisfied with their replaced knees had more severe functional disabilities than the satisfied for most activities. The dissatisfied patients tended to perceive functional disabilities in high-flexion activities to be more important than the satisfied.
This study indicates that despite severe disabilities in high-flexion activities, most Korean patients after TKA would not consider high-flexion disability to be more important than other daily routine activities. Moreover, postoperative high-flexion disabilities would not adversely influence satisfaction for most patients. Nevertheless, such disabilities are likely to cause dissatisfaction among those that are not prepared to modify their traditional life-styles.
MISTKA resulted earlier recovery of ROM, muscle power and shorter incision. But bleeding after operation did not decrease compared with conventional TKA. We compared MISTKA results between several approach mini arthrotomy, mini midvastus and mini subvastus. There were no difference in these series. We thought extramedullary femoral guide may be less invasive than intramedullary femoral guide system.
34 cases were performed by minisubvastus approach. 17 cases were using intramedullary method. 17 cases were using extramedullary method. We compared JOA score, ROM, muscle power, blood examination, X ray, and operation time. Total protein(TP), albumin(alb), prealbumin(prealb), hemoglobin(Hb), total lymphocyte content(TLC) and CRP were examined.
There was no difference in JOA score, ROM and recovery of muscle power. But there were statistically difference in prealbumine at 1 week after operation and TLC at 2 week after operation.
Extramedullary group showed earlier recovery than intramedullary group.
MIS TKA does not discuss about approach but also system of bone cut. Navigation system is very good method but it is very expensive and takes more time at operation. Extramedullary system we developed is simple and low technology method and useful for MISTKA.
We have analyzed the long-term clinical and radiological results of 169 total knee replacements(TKRs) for rheumatoid arthritis over 10 years. The average follow up period was 12.8(10–17.6) years.
The flexion contracture was improved from average 25.0 to 2.9 degrees. But the angle of great flexion had decreased from average 128.0 to 114.7 degrees. At the final follow up, the American Knee Society knee score was 87.5 and function score 76.5 in average. The revision arthroplasty was performed in 20 cases, but only 4 cases were done before 10 years after the primary TKRs. The survival rate of the implant was 97.9% at 10 years and 85.3% at 14 years in Kaplan-Meier survivorship analysis. But just after 10 years, problems such as osteolysis and periprosthetic fractures started to occur increasingly. 10-year follow up results is just the 10-year results only, not the long-term or final results of TKRs for rheumatoid arthritis.
Between the year 1987 to 2005, 45 primary knee replacements were performed for 30 patients affecting ankylosing knee joint. 23 patients were having flexion fused deformities with 38 knee arthroplasty, ten of them were having flexion fused deformities over than 60 degrees. 18 cases were performed ipslateral THR & TKR. 2 AS patients undergone THR, TKR and total ankle replacement on the same anesthesia.
The other 7 patients were having extension ankylosing deformities with 9 primary TKR performed. All patients were post infection deformities with the exception of one Rheumatoid Arthritis and one hemophiliac patient with bilateral extension ankylosing deformities of the knee joint.
Exposure of the knee joint and separation of the fused bones, providing a mobile joint space plays a crucial procedure for the next step of surgery for both flexion and extension ankylosing deformities. The following 2 points are important: First separate the fused bone between the femoral condyles and the patella, pay attention to the thickness of the patella button allowing sufficient bone stock with thickness and strength for patella replacement. Separate the fused bone between the femoral and tibial condyles allowing motion and space, pay attention that: the resection plane is 90 degrees perpendicular to the tibial axis and as proximal to the tibial plateau fused with the femoral condyles as possible. release and protect the blood supply and nerve of the posterior resection area avoiding damage to the nerve endings and the blood vessels. Soft tissue balancing is important, it is difficult to achieve the same flexion and extension gap. Usually the extension gap is narrow than flexion gap with flexion ankylosing deformities, on the contrary the flexion gap is narrow than extension gap with extension ankylosing deformities. Post operative rehabilitation and traction can gradually improve for the patients who less than 20 degrees flexion contracture deformities. For extension ankylosing deformities, post-operative rehabilitation can achieve better results even though the intra-operative ROM is less than 90 degrees but if the patient is stable in extension position.
The purpose of this study was to evaluate a high flex porous tantalum metal monoblock component system implanted through a MIS technique.
A fellowship trained surgeon proficient in MIS surgery performed 109 consecutive TKAs in 95 patients. Patients were implanted with a tantalum monoblock tibia and a fiber-metal cruciate-retaining high flex femur through a MIS midvastus approach. Ninety uncemented porous tantulum monoblock patellae and 19 cemented all polyethylene patellae were implanted.
Knee Society scores and Knee Society radiographic scores were calculated in all patients. Follow-up for a minimum of 2 years was performed in 109 knees. The average follow up was 39 months. Sixty-six percent of the patients were female and 34% male. The average age was 66 years. The average preoperative Knee Society Knee score was 36. The average preop Knee Society Functional Score was 46. Osteoarthritis was the primary diagnosis in 104 knees. Rheumatoid arthritis and Hemophilia was the diagnosis in two knees each.
The average Knee Society Knee Score improved to 89. The average Knee Society Function score improved to 86. 106 of the knees were rated good or excellent and three knees were rated poor. Two patellar revisions were performed for loose components and one for patellar misalignment. One patella fracture occurred that required ORIF. One femoral component was revised for loosening. There were nonprogressive radiographic lucencies demonstrated on 4 tibial components. One tibial component was rated loose. There were radiographic lucencies on 5 femoral components, all nonprogressive. There were two uncemented tantalum patellar components with stable radiolucencies.
Early results in 109 consecutive porous tantalum metal tibial and high flex cruciate-retaining femoral components implanted through an MIS midvastus approach have a high rate of success at a minimum followup of two years.
Binary Surface type knee prosthesis (bisurface knee) has successfully been utilized in total knee arthroplasty (TKA) in order to improve flexional motion, especially, deep flexion. Binary surface means that the knee prosthesis has two different bearing structures, that is, normal condylar surfaces and ball-socket structure. The ball and the socket are placed between the condylar surfaces of the femoral component and the tibial insert, respectively. Two different designs of bisurface knee have been proposed so far and only one model called KU has been utilized in clinical applications. The other model called CFK is still under development and characterized to have a post-cam structure to stabilize the knee motion. These bisurface knees are expected to attain deep flexional motion and therefore, it is important to understand their safety and durability at high flexion angles. In the present study, the finite element analysis (FEA) is conducted to characterize the mechanics of the bisurface knees under deep knee flexion. Risk assessment of the bisurface knees are then performed based on the FEA results.
Detailed 3D-FEA models are constructed using CAD data and deep knee flexion corresponding to a squatting motion is reproduced by using spring models and proper boundary conditions. The spring models attached to the tibial component are used to express the mechanical effects of soft tissues. Internal rotational motion is also considered with the flexional motion. The femoral and the tibial components are assumed to be rigid and the tibial insert made of UHMWPE is an elastic-plastic solid having a nonlinear constitutive relation determined from experiments. The femoral component is rotated continuously from 0° to 135° to express the flexional motion and the tibial component is also rotated to express internal rotation.
The equivalent stress of the condylar surface of the new CFK model is almost equivalent to that of the KU model during flexion from 0° to 90°, however, the stress values are different at the angles higher than 90°. At higher angles of flexion than 90°, the bearing surface of the KU consists of the condylar and the socket surfaces, while the bearing surface of the CFK consists of the socket surface only. Therefore, the CFK exhibits higher stress than the KU at these high angles. The ball-socket bearing system enables these bisurface knees to be adapted to deep flexional motion. The CFK is trying to achieve higher flexion angles than the KU by employing the modified ball-socket bearing structure, however, higher stress concentration on the socket surface of the CFK may hasten degradation of the tibial insert. It is also found that the stress concentration on the socket surfaces increase with increase of the internal rotation angle and therefore, the risk of damage of the tibial insert becomes higher with internal rotation.
In summary, 3D dynamic FEA is utilized to make a risk assessment of the bisurface knees and the computational results suggest that the design of the ball-socket structure is one of the most important factors to determine the safety and durability of the knees.
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effect of decreasing tibial slope on extention gap during posterior stabilized total knee arthroplasty. 110 posterior stabilized total knee arthroplasties were studied for 2 groups;
having flexion contractures(n=35), having no flexion contracture(n=75).
In each group, we measured the decrease of tibial slope and frequency of additional distal femoral resecions that were done due to insufficient extension gap in comparison with flexion gap during posterior stabilized total knee arthroplasty. We also compared frequencies of additional distal femoral resections between 2 parts having more and less slope decrease in each groups.
In each group, tibial slope decrease were 8.7 degrees, 7.4 degrees(p=0.145) and frequencies of additional resection were 51.4%, 24%(p=0.005) in average. In 2 parts having more and less slope decrease in each group, frequencies of additional resection were 44.4% vs 58.8%(p=0.505), 13.2% vs 35.1%(p=0.032). Results suggested that more decrease of tibial slope reduced frequency of additional distal femoral resection during posterior stabilized total knee arthroplasty in group having no flexion contracture.
Decreasing tibial slope can be considered as a factor influencing on extension gap during posterior stabilized total knee arthroplasty. The estimation of predictable tibia slope decrease through preoperative radiologic findings can be beneficial in performing succeful posterior stabilized total knee arthroplasty.
The range of motion (ROM) after total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is one of the most important factors for patient satisfaction, especially in Asian countries. To enhance the knee flexion angle, “high-flexion” designs have been introduced in total knee prostheses. One of such design was a new design of femoral prosthesis, which increased the posterior cut on the bone by 2 mm and thickened the posterior condyle, allowing the posterior condylar radius to continue further. There were several reports on postoperative ROM of such “high-flexion” posterior-stabilized (PS) total knee prosthesis. However, there was no report on the postoperative ROM of “high-flexion” cruciate ligament retaining (CR) total knee prosthesis. The purpose of this study was to compare the ROM associated with standard and high-flexion posterior CR total knee prostheses.
One hundred and fifty-one consecutive patients (176 knees) had CR total knee prosthesis. 89 knees had standard CR TKA (NexGen CR, Zimmer, Warsaw, IL), and 87 knees had high-flexion CR knee prostheses (NexGen CR-Flex, Zimmer, Warsaw, IL). Differences in the age, diagnosis, preoperative Knee Society Score (KSS), and preoperative ROM of the knee between two groups were not significant. At one year postoperatively, the patients were assessed clinically and radiographically.
The mean postoperative KSS knee score was 96.2 points for the standard CR prosthesis group and 96.7 points for the high-flexion CR prosthesis group (p=0.464). The mean postoperative KSS function score was 83.4 points for the standard CR prosthesis group and 84.8 points for the high-flexion CR prosthesis group (p=0.446). The mean postoperative ROM was 110.8 degrees in the standard CR prosthesis group, and 114.0 degrees in high-flexion prosthesis group (p=0.236). No knee had aseptic loosening, revision, or osteolysis.
Previous report showed that “high-flexion” PS design did not increase postoperative ROM compared to standard design. However, there was no report on the postoperative ROM of “high-flexion” CR total knee prosthesis. We found no significant differences between the standard CR group and “high-flexion” CR group with regard to ROM or clinical and radiographic parameters. However, in the cases which achieved high flexion, “high-flexion” design, which chamfered posterior femoral edge, can reduce the possibility of deformation from posterior contacts under lord. Therefore, the results of the current study suggested that “high-flexion” CR design is not the design that increase ROM significantly, but might be the safe design even when the knee achieved deep flexion.
The purpose of this study was to compare the clinical and radiological results of the PFC flex mobile bearing design with those of the LPS flex fixed bearing design in high-flex total knee arthroplasty.
Between January 2005 and November 2006, forty-six patients who received PFC flex mobile bearing prosthesis in one knee and LPS flex fixed bearing prosthesis in the contralateral knee followed up for a minimum 2 years were evaluated. Clinical results were assessed using the ROM, HSS score, the Knee rating systems of the knee society, WOMAC score and SF-36. Radiological results were evaluated tibio-femoral angle and loosening or osteolysis of components. We subdivided preoperative less 90 degree and more 90 degree in each group.
Mean ROM range of last follow up was increased to 131.1 degree in LPS group and 130.1 degree in PFC group. But there was no significant difference between the two groups. HSS score, knee pain and function score, WOMAC score, SF-36 score didn’t differ significantly between two groups. But descending stairs, rising from sitting, bending to the floor more improved significantly in LPS group. T-F angle was changed from preoperative 8.2 degree varus to a postoperative 4.8 degree valgus. No knee had aseptic loosening or osteolysis.
Postoperative ROM was increase significantly in both groups. We found no significant differences between the two groups with regard to clinical and radiological parameters excepts descending stairs, rising from sitting, bending to the floor in WOMAC score. There was no aseptic loosening or osteolysis but needed long term observation about these concerns.
The aim of this study was to report a 3 year follow up of vitamin E add polyethylene in total knee arthroplasty. UHMWPE powder (GUR1050) was mixed with 0.3% of vitamin E before consolidation by direct compression molding. The vitamin E added UHMWPE was applied to the articular surface and patella in 65 patients (mean age, 69.6 years). Joint fluid concentrations of tocopherol and matrix metalloproteinase 9 were measured in vitamin E added UHMWPE cases one year after surgery, and were compared to those of conventional UHMWPE cases and osteoarthritis patients. Concentrations of α-tocopherol and γ-tocopherol were measured by using HPLC with ultraviolet-visible wavelength detection. Concentrations of matrix metalloproteinase 9 were detected by using enzyme immunoassay.
The Average Knee Society score were 91.7(clinical) and 76.7(functional). There were three failures (1 supracondylar fracture, and 2 skin necrosis). The average concentrations of α-tocopherol were 281.8μg/dL (10 cases) in the vitamin E group, 371.8μg/dL (15 cases) in the conventional group, and 317.8μg/dL (46 cases) in the osteoarthritis group. There were no significant differences among three groups. The average concentrations of γ-tocopherol were 43.4μg/dL in the vitamin E group, 52.3μg/dL in the conventional group, and 49.8μg/dL in the osteoarthritis group. There were no significant differences among three groups. The average concentrations of matrix metalloproteinase 9 were 83.2 ng/mL in the vitamin E group, 78.4 ng/mL in the conventional group, and 17.4 ng/mL in the osteoarthritis group. There was no significant difference between the vitamin E group and the conventional group. However, The matrix metalloproteinase 9 concentrations of the osteoarthritis group were significantly lower than others.
No cases exhibited measurable polyethylene wear or osteolysis and also no abnormal values relating to vitamin E on joint fluid examinations. At three year follow-up, vitamin E added polyethylene demonstrated the safe use for the human body.
This research was done in the Asan Medical Center in Seoul. We performed a prospective study to assess clinical outcomes, complications and survival of prostheses in a consecutive series of 278 knees receiving NexGen legacy posterior stabilised (LPS) – Flex total knee replacement (TKR) between May 2003 and February 2005. The mean follow-up period was 3.8 years (3.0 to 4.8), and 259 knees (93.2%) were followed for an adequate interval. Annual follow-ups showed improvement in the Knee Society scores (paired t-test, P< 0.05). At the latest follow-up, the mean maximal flexion was 135° (110° to 150°). Two knees showed radiolucency but revision was not required as there were no significant symptoms. Revision was required in one case due to prosthetic infection, but no prosthesis-related revisions were required. There were no complications such as patellofemoral pain, wound healing problems, dislocation or instability during deep flexion postoperatively. The estimated survival rate at 4 years with revision for any reason and prosthesis-related problems were 99.6% and 100% respectively (life-table method). This relatively large TKR study indicates that LPS-Flex system provides excellent medium-term outcomes and seems to warrant ongoing evaluation to confirm the long-term durability and functioning of the implant afterward.
Clinical experience has shown the needs for high flexion. The aim of this study was to evaluate the clinical and radiological results of a fixed bearing high flexion posterior stabilized (PS) total knee arthroplasty (TKA).
Between July 2001 and December 2005, 422 TKAs in 288 patients were performed with high flexion PS prosthesis and 378 knees of 258 patients had been followed up for 2 to 6.5 years (mean: 3 years 11 months). We evaluated range of motion (ROM), Knee rating system of the Hospital for Special Surgery (HSS) and Knee Society (KS) score, and radiological results.
The mean flexion improved from 110.1 degrees to 126.7 degrees at the latest follow-up. 333 knees (88 %) showed more than 120 degrees of flexion, 105 knees (28 %) more than 140 degrees of flexion. The mean KS clinical score improved from 39 to 93 points (p< 0.01) and KS function score, from 40 to 85.4 points (p< 0.01). The mean HSS score improved from 41.2 to 86.3 points (p< 0.01). In 28 knees, radiolucent line of 1–2 mm in width was observed at zone 1 without symptoms. Aseptic loosening in 4 knees, Mid-flexion instability in 2 knees, superficial infection in 3 knees and deep infection in 3 knees were observed.
Total knee arthroplasty with high flexion PS prosthesis showed good ROM and satisfactory early clinical results. Complication rate was similar to those of other series. Close observation and serial radiological evaluation are needed for long term results.
Carbon fibre reinforced polyetheretherketone (CFR-PEEK) has been introduced recently as an alternative material to be used in joint prostheses. During injection moulding of the CFR-PEEK the carbon fibres tend to become orientated in the direction of the plastic flow. The direction of these fibres may affect the wear produced by these materials.
Reciprocation only and reciprocation plus rotation (multi-directional) pin-on-plate wear tests were performed on PAN-based CFR-PEEK against itself. The plates were manufactured with the carbon fibres mainly orientated either longitudinally (in the direction of reciprocation motion) or mainly transversally (perpendicular to the direction of motion) to determine the effect of carbon fibre orientation on the wear of these materials. For each test, four pin and plate samples were tested (two reciprocation only and two reciprocation plus rotation) for three and a half million cycles at a cycle frequency of 1 Hz under a 40 N load (which resulted in a contact stress of about 2 MPa). The lubricant used was bovine serum diluted with de-ionised water to a protein content of 17 gl-1. This was maintained at 37 °C. The wear was determined gravimetrically. Soak control specimens were used to account for any weight changes due to lubricant absorption.
The average steady-state wear for the CFR-PEEK samples that underwent reciprocation motion only was found to be 5.41 and 18.7 × 10-8 mm3N-1m-1 for the longitudinal carbon fibres and the transverse fibres respectively. For the multi-directional tests, the average steady-state wear was 5.88 and 19.9 × 10-7 mm3N-1m-1 for the longitudinal and transverse fibres respectively. It is clear from these results that for both reciprocation motion only and reciprocation plus rotation the wear was considerably lower with the fibres orientated in the longitudinal direction than the transverse direction. Also, these tests show that reciprocation only gives approximately an order of magnitude lower wear than multi-directional motion.
It can be concluded that the wear rate of CFR-PEEK is lower when the sliding motion occurs in the same direction as the carbon fibre orientation. Also, in these pin-on-plate tests, the wear produced using reciprocation motion only was an order of magnitude lower than that for the tests using multi-directional motion.
The authors wish to thank INVIBIO Ltd for funding this research.
We evaluated the minimum 3 year follow-up clinical and radiological results after Nexgen® LPS-flex total knee arthroplasty (TKA).
Two hundred eighteen knees in 166 patients, who could be followed up more than 3 years after Nexgen® LPS-flex TKA from October 2001 to February 2005, were evaluated retrospectively. The average age was 64.2 years. Twenty-two patients were male and 144 patients were female. The mean follow-up period was 51 months (range 36–73 months). The evaluations included the preoperative and postoperative range of motion (ROM), Knee Society (KS) Score, tibiofemoral angle and postoperative complications.
The ROM increased from preoperative mean flexion contracture of 8.7° and further flexion of 117.3° to postoperative mean flexion contracture of 1.8° and further flexion of 131.3°. The KS knee score and function score improved from 52 and 38 before surgery to 87 and 82 after surgery, respectively. The tibiofemoral angle changed from preoperative varus 5.7° to postoperative valgus 5.4°. The complications were 30 knees (13.8%, 27 patients) of early loosening of the femoral component on X-ray, 2 instabilities, 2 periprosthetic fractures and 1 failure of extensor mechanism. Early loosening (30 knees) was found at mean 24 months after operation. Among these cases, 23 knees were able to squat, 5 knees to flex over 130°, 1 knee upto 115° and 1 knee upto 95°. Seven knees (3.2%, 6 patients) were revised at mean 49 months after index operation.
The results after Nexgen® LPS-flex TKA were satisfactory in terms of ROM, but relatively high incidence of early loosening of the femoral components occurred, which might be associated with passive-maximal flexion activity, such as squatting or kneeling.
Polymerized material such as Ultra High Molecular Weight Polyethylene (UHMWPE) is commonly used as a bearing cushion with titanium alloy, austenistic stainless steel, ceramic and cobalt chrome alloy to be used for the tibial and femoral components in knee replacement application. As a biomaterial product these substances must comprise a wear resistance capacity.
This study was conducted to observe the wear product and wear factor of the die drawn GUR 1120 UHMWPE that was rubbed against nitrogen based-ion implantation of cobalt chrome alloy (irradiated at 100 Kev for 90 min) and employment of bovine serum in various concentration as lubricant.
The wear mechanism was tested with the application of bovine calf serum pre-conditioned similar to synovial fluids in human knee. The experiment was tested with a Pin on Plate Unidirectional Reciprocating Movement with various lubricant protein concentrations applied. The ‘A’ lubricant is a serum with protein concentration of 19.3 g/L and the ‘B’ lubricant is a serum with protein concentration of 30 g/L; these lubricants were then compared after the reciprocating movement test with constant load of 180 N force, 116.5 mm/s constant friction velocity and 25 mm average gait length with total of 35 km distance covered.
This study showed that protein concentration augmentation would decrease the wear factor up to 300%. This value was derived after increasing the protein concentration of the lubricant (from 19.3 g/L to 30 g/L) which then altered the wear factor from 5.12×10-7 mm3/Nm to 1.71×10-7 m3/Nm respectively.
Current total disc prostheses are 2- or 3-pieces devices, including 1 or 2 bearing surfaces, and providing 3 or 5 degrees of freedom but with no, or very little, resistance. The ESP® is a one-piece deformable implant made of silicon and polycarbonate polyurethane elastomer securely fixed to titanium endplates. It allows limited rotation and translation with elastic return. This cushion without fixed rotation center achieves 6 degrees of freedom including shock absorption. An earlier attempt to use elastomers (Acroflex®) failed clinically due to the polymer. This highlights the need for accurate in-vitro fatigue testing and clinical evaluations.
In-vitro fatigue testing with more than 40 millions cycles were performed on different samples for compression, flexion-extension bending, lateral bending, torsion and shear. A prospective trial was initiated in 2004 for L3L4, L4L5 and L5S1 levels. Total disc replacements have been performed in 153 lumbar levels through extra-peritoneal mini-invasive anterior approach.
After in-vitro testing, microscopic examination showed that the polymer core remained unchanged without evidence of cracking or other degradation. Gravimetric analysis revealed insignificant changes in weight. The geometrical characteristics and the cohesion of the implants remained stable. After 3 years clinical experience, there was no device related complication, except one early revision for a post-traumatic implant migration. VAS and ODI scores improvements were equivalent to other published series.
In-vitro fatigue testing and short term results of the innovative ESP® prosthesis demonstrate the reliability of the concept. The results are equivalent to other series with conventional implants.
The combination of Ultra High Molecular Weight Polyethylene (UHMWPE) as tibial substitute components paired with cobalt chrome alloy as femoral substitute components are the most common materials widely used in knee replacement applications. Wear mechanism effect on UHMWPE material is one of the leading factors that cause failure of this application.
In this study, the effects of loading in creating wear product and the influence of wear mechanism to alter material wear factor of the UHMWPE was investigated after Pin on Plate Unidirectional Reciprocating Movement Wear Test. This study use a die drawn GUR 1120 UHMWPE pin paired with nitrogen based-ion implantation of cobalt chrome alloy and utilize 25% bovine serum plus 75% distilled water as lubricant.
The materials were paired in a Pin on Plate Wear Test with sliding unidirectional reciprocating movement and subsequently loaded with 353 N and 462 N of force resulted in 9MPa and 12MPa contact pressure with constant friction velocity of 116.5 mm/s.
After the test, there was significant difference of wear product and wear factor subsequent to the loading process with a total of 35 km distance covered and 25 mm average gait length. From the 353 N loaded forces there was 1,075 mm3 of wear product volume created and 4.4 × 10-8 average wear factor observed, while in the 462 N force application there had been no wear product volume and wear factor resulted during the observation. The result of this study demonstrated that greater load produce lesser wear product and wear factor of the die drawn UHMWPE.
Suggestions for improved wear performance of total knee replacements have included replacement of standard CoCr femoral components with ceramic. Yttria-stabilized zirconia (y-TZP) was introduced as high-strength and high toughness ceramic as an alternative to alumina ceramic. Since the introduction of zirconia in 1985, the clinical outcomes and successes for hip joint have been controversial. Y-TZP ceramics have been studied both experimentally and clinically. Magnesia-stabilized zirconia (Mg-PSZ) also appears promising for total knee replacements (TKR).
Mg-ZrO2 and CoCr femoral condyles were compared in the VanguardTM knee configuration (Biomet Inc, IN). Molded tibial inserts (GUR1050) were gamma-irradiation sterilization to 3.2-Mrad under argon. Knee simulation was conducted on a 6 station simulator (Shore Western Manufacturing, Monrovia, CA). Motion included 20 degrees of flexion/extension, 5 degrees of internal/external rotation and 5 mm of AP-translation. All knee components were subjected to 6 million cycles of normal walking (2.9 kN max, freq 1.4 Hz). Lubricant was 50% alfa-calf serum diluted to 20 mg/ml protein and using EDTA additive. Test duration was 6 million cycles (6-Mc), and wear was measured by weight-loss techniques.
For wear trending of CoCr/PE and MGZ/PE, linear wear trends were apparent from 1 to 6 Mc test duration. The control implants (CoCr/PE) showed excellent linear trending (regression coeff r> 0.99) with wears rate averaging 6.3 mm3/Mc. These data showed good control of experimental variance (< 10%). The ZrO2/PE combination showed good linear trending (r > 0.86) with wear rate averaging only 0.8 mm3/Mc. This set also showed good control of experimental variance (< 15%. The MGZ/PE wear was 8-fold reduced from that of CoCr/PE.
The laboratory knee wear simulation appeared very supportive of femoral condyles of Mg-stabilized zirconia. Such implants may provide excellent performance for active patients who may risk high wear rates over many years of use.
Many reports show good results following procedures, such as intervertebral body fusion using cage or total disc replacement, that restore adequate disc height. However, there have been no references regarding the range of normal lumbar disc height in Korean adults which can be used as a standard for the implant size. The purpose of our study is to measure the lumbar disc height on radiographs in normal Korean. 132 subjects (age range 20 to 40 years) who had no previous history of low back pain and no significant finding on physical examination were enrolled. Plain lateral lumbar spine radiograph in supine position were taken. Intervertebral disc heights were measured at anterior, middle and posterior portion of each lumbar disc. The average magnification rate was 115%, and the disc heights were corrected by the magnification rate in each segment.
Lumbar disc height showed cranio-caudal pattern in both male and female groups. L4–5 disc heights were highest at anterior, middle and posterior portion in male. L4–5 disc heights were highest at middle and posterior portion in female. L5-S1 disc height was highest at anterior portion in female, but there was no statistically significant difference between L4–5 and L5-S1 disc height at anterior portion. There was no significant difference in disc height between male and female except anterior portion of L1–2 and L2–3 disc. Statistically significant decrease in disc height was not presented in overweight person at all measured site in male and female except posterior portion of L1–2 disc in male.
This research is meaningful in that it is an attempt to provide a reference value of lumbar disc height in Korean adults, and the measured values may also be useful in manufacturing Korean modeled artificial lumbar disc prosthesis or surgical instruments for lumbar interbody fusion.
Spinal fusion has been used as the gold standard to treat some spinal disorders such as degenerative disc or disc herniation of the cervical spine. However, some clinical complications have been reported caused by high stiffness of spinal fusion. Recently, total disc arthroplasty using motion preservation devices such as artificial discs (ADs) have been proposed as an alternative treatment technique. In current study, we analysed biomechanical influences including inter-segmental motion, facet joint forces, and ligament stresses of two different clinical available ADs and compared with those of intact cervical spine in various loading conditions using finite element analysis.
A three dimensional finite element model was developed for C2-C7 spinal motion segment based on CT images and previous anatomical literatures. The finite element models for two different types of ADs, semi-constraint (Prodisc-C®, Synthes, U.S.A) and un-constraint (Mobi-C®, LDR Spine, U.S.A), were developed. Each AD was inserted at C6–C7 segments. Superior and inferior plates of ADs were fixed on inferior plane of C6 and superior plane of C7 vertebrae, respectively. Based on the conventional surgical techniques, anterior longitudinal ligaments and some parts of intervertebral disc in C6–C7 motion segment were removed to insert ADs. Inferior plane of C7 vertebra was constrained in all directions and 1Nm of flexion, extension, lateral bending and torsion were applied on superior plane of C2 vertebra with 50N of compressive load along follower load direction.
Rotation angle in flexion of C5–C6 segment in cases of semi-constraint and un-constraint AD was 3.3° and 3.7°, respectively. Both values were greater than that in case of the intact cervical spine by 18% and 32%, respectively. Rotation angle in extension, lateral bending and torsion were greater than intact model by 45%, 26% and 43% for the case of semi-constraint AD and 55%, 35%, 100% for the case of un-constraint one, respectively. In extension, facet joint forces were about two times higher than intact model in cases of semi-constraint and un-constraint AD. Also in flexion, on average, ligament stresses in cases of semi-constraint and un-constraint AD were higher than intact model by 66% and 116%, respectively.
The results of this study showed that ADs were useful to generate inter-segmental motion at surgical level. And the un-constraint type of AD had higher mobility than semi-constraint one. However, high mobility of ADs would lead not only higher facet joint forces but also ligament stresses than intact cervical spine. Therefore, more careful care must be taken to choose surgical method of total disc arthroplasty.
All patients underwent anterior cervical discectomy followed by anterior cervical plating or implantation of the Bryan artificial disc prosthesis, done by one surgeon. Clinical evaluation included the visual analogue scale (VAS), and neck disability index (NDI). Radiographic evaluation included static and dynamic flexion-extension radiographs in an upright position using the computer software (Infinitt PiviewSTAR 5051) program. Range of motion/disc space angle and inter vertebral height were measured at the operative site and adjacent levels. Functional spinal unit (FSU) and overall sagittal alignment (C2–C7) were also measured pre-operatively, postoperatively and at final follow-up. ROM was calculated for all 3 areas and data collected were compared from pre operative to last follow-up as well as between the two groups. Radiographic assessment for adjacent level changes was also done. Radiologic change was analyzed using chi square test (95% confidence interval). Other data were analyzed using the mixed model. (SAS enterprise guide 4.1 version)
Cervical arthroplasty is usually performed for the treatment of soft disc herniation, but not for spondylotic radiculopathy. To our knowledge, there has no study to investigate the clinical and radiological results of cervical arthroplasty for spondylotic radiculopathy. We therefore performed the current study to evaluate clinical and radiological results of cervical arthroplasty for spondylotic radiculopathy with severe narrowing of the intervertebral disc space.
Eight patients, who underwent anterior decompression, overdistraction, and implantation of artificial cervical disc for primary, single-level spondylotic radiculopathy with severe narrowing of the disc space (decrease more than 50% of adjacent disc spaces) were included in this study. Four were male and 4 were female with mean age of 49.5 years. The operation level was 7 C5–6 and 1 C6–7. Five Prodisc-C and 3 Prestige LP prostheses were implanted. The clinical and radiological evaluations were performed with minimum one year follow-up (range, 12 – 19 months) after surgery.
VAS of the neck and arm pain improved (79.6 vs. 19.4 points, p < 0.01; 82.5 vs. 22.7 points, p < 0.01) at last follow-up, respectively. According to Odom’s criteria, satisfactory clinical outcome was achieved in 63% (5 out of 8, 3 excellent and 2 good) while fair result was achieved in 37% of the patients (3 out of 8). The disc space (3.0mm vs. 6.4mm, p < 0.01) and range of motion (1.4 vs. 6.3 degrees, p = 0.009) at the operated level increased, respectively. Overall sagittal alignment of the cervical spine was increased after surgery (5.2 vs. 11.3 degrees, p < 0.05). In 5 patients, segmental angle of the operated level was increased (0.2 vs. 5.3 degrees, p = 0.003) after surgery with maintained facet joint articulation overlap. However, in 3 patients, segmental angle of operated level became kyphotic from neutral (0 vs. −10.0 degrees, p = 0.295) with decreased facet joint articulation overlap.
In conclusions, cervical arthroplasty provided favorable clinical and radiological outcomes in most of the patients with spondylotic radiculopathy and severe narrowing of the disc space at minimum one year follow-up after surgery. However, in some of the patients, postoperative segmental kyphosis developed and clinical outcomes were not satisfactory.
Anterior decompression and fusion has been standard treatment for cervical disc herniation and myelopathy with disc degeneration. Since cervical total disc replacement (TDR) has been introduced with early favorable results and ideal mechanism, it has gained its popularity recently. But varying degrees of heterotopic ossification (HO) around the operated segment have been noted in the literatures. The theoretical advantages of TDR are the maintenance of intervertebral motion and prevention of adjacent segment degeneration. It is questionable that if HO occurs after TDR, mobility of operated segments would be restricted then clinical outcome worse. Purpose of this study is to determine prevalence of HO and to investigate that the presence of HO would limit motion and subsequently negatively affect clinical outcome following cervical TDR.
We analyzed 29 patients (30 levels) who were treated with cervical TDR by 2 spine specialists using 4 types of prostheses (Mobi-C: 13 levels, ProDisc: 10, Bryan: 5, Prestige LP: 2) consecutively from July 2004 to June 2007. Postoperative mean follow-up period was 21.4 (12–36) months. We assessed presence of HO and segmental ROM radiographically and clinical outcome by VAS, ODI after 1.5, 3, 6 months, and every year postoperatively in principle. All subjects were divided by 3, which were group A (no HO, McAfee class 0), group B (class I and II), and group C (class III and IV), then compared with each other.
HO was detected on 14 levels (46.7%) in the 30 levels after at mean of 8.2 (4–18) months after operation. There were 15 levels(53.3%) of group A (no HO, class 0), 7 levels of group B (class I HO:3, II: 4), and 7 levels of group C (class III: 3, IV: 4). Segmental flexion-extension ROM of group A was 10.1 (5.6–16.2)°, group B is 8.3 (3.5–14.4)°, and group C is 3.1 (0.0–6.6)° (p< 0.001, multiple comparison test with post hoc Bonferroni correction). And no difference in the clinical outcomes, VAS and ODI, was found compared with each other among group A, B, and C (p> 0.05).
Nonetheless, longer term follow-up should be performed to investigate whether clinical outcomes would be changed and occur adjacent level degeneration as time goes on. In addition, further study for prevention of HO may be needed as in HO of other joint replacement surgery not to lose superior mechanism to fusion treatment.
Wound complication including superficial infection is a concern after total knee arthroplasties (TKA) in diabetics. However, influence of glycoregulation before TKA has not been investigated in relationship to wound healing. Our hypothesis was that glycated hemoglobin (HbA1C), since it reflects long-term regulation of blood glucose, might be associated with incidence of wound complications after TKA in diabetic patients.
We retrospectively reviewed 167 TKAs performed in 115 patients with diabetes mellitus between January 2001 and March 2007. All patients were diagnosed as type II DM and osteoarthritis. A wound complication was defined as a hematoma, bulla, drainage or superficial infection. Stepwise multivariate logistic regression was used to identify which variables had a significant effect on the risk of wound complications. Variables considered were age, gender, body mass index, histories of previous knee surgery, comorbidities, duration of diabetes, the methods of diabetes treatment, complications of diabetes, preoperative HbA1c level, operation time, antibiotics-impregnated cement use, the amount of blood transfusion, and postoperative blood glucose level.
The overall incidence of wound complications was 6.6% (n=11) including superficial infection in 1.8% (n=3), hematoma or bullae in 3.6% (n=6), and drainage in 1.8% (n=3). There were seven cases (4.2%) of deep infection. A multivariate logistic regression revealed that independent risk factors for the development of wound complications were preoperative HbA1C ≥ 8% (odds ratio 6.074, 95% confidence interval 1.119–32.971) and operation time (odds ratio 1.013, 95% confidence interval 1.000–1.026).
Poorly controlled hyperglycemia before surgery may increase the incidence of wound complications among diabetic patients receiving total knee arthroplasties. The correlation of glycemic control and wound complications may assist in the preoperative evaluation and selection of time for surgery.
Infection is one of major problems in Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA) or Bipolar Head Prosthesis (BHP). We have used Calcium Phosphate Paste (CPP) for treatment of infected TKA and BHP, and followed up for minimum one year. CPP is a mixture of alpha Tri-Calcium Phosphate, Tetra-Calcium Phosphate, Calcium Hydrogen Phosphate and Hydroxyapatite. CPP harden in 10 minutes and its stiffness increases to maximum in 3 days.
Infected TKA were diagnosed in four osteoarthritis and four rheumatoid arthritis knees, and BHP infection were observed in two femoral neck fracture cases from 2001 to 2007. Two were male and eight were female, average age were 67.3 years old ranged 39 to 80. Follow-up period were one to 7 years. Six cases were MRSA infection, three MSSA, one was unidentified but diagnosed with clinical data. In TKA cases, CPP (10–12g) with vancomycin hydrochloride or tobramycin were filled on the back side of PMMA articulated surface spacers, and in BHP cases, CPP with antibiotics were filled in acetabulum. In all TKA cases, infection ceased in 2 to 4 month and revision TKA ware performed. One recurrence of infection was observed during follow up in BHP infection, and nine patients can walk with/without a cane. No venous thromboembolism were observed.
The purpose of this study was to elucidate the hemostatic effects of tranexamic acid (TA) in patients undergoing total knee arthroplasty (TKA) performed with different three methods.
The subjects were 89 patients (10 males, 79 females; mean age at surgery 74 years old) who underwent TKA for osteoarthritic knees in our department between April 2006 and October 2007. A cemented prosthesis (NexGen LPS flex, Zimmer) was used in all cases. The subjects were divided into three groups; Group A (n=39), in whom intravenous administration of TA (1 000 mg) 15 minutes before tourniquet release and a drain-clamping method [DC; joint filled with 50 ml of fluid that contained TA (1 000 mg, 10 ml) and 40 ml of physiological saline just after surgery] were performed, as reported by Prof. Otani (Keio Univ., Tokyo, Japan) in 2005; Group B (n=20), who had the same protocol as Group A, except that the DC Joint was filled with a total of 50 ml physiological saline alone; and group C (n=30), who received DC alone with 50 ml of physiological saline and no intravenous administration of TA. The parameters evaluated were the amounts of intra-operative bleeding, bleeding after 24 hours, total bleeding (intra- and post-operative), and changes in Hb levels between before surgery and 1 week after surgery. Statistical analyses were performed using a Mann-Whitney U-test, with P-values greater than 0.05 considered to be significant.
No differences were observed in the amount of bleeding during the TKA among the groups. In contrast, bleeding at 24 hours after surgery and total amounts of bleeding were significantly lower in Group A (281 and 695ml, respectively) as compared to Group B (337 and 868 ml, respectively) and Group C (650 and 1043 ml, respectively) (p< 0.01). In addition, Hb levels at 1 week after surgery were reduced by 1.8 g/dl in Group A, as compared to 2.3 and 3.0 g/dl in Groups B and C, respectively, demonstrating a significantly lower amount of reduction in Group A (p< 0.01).
The effect of TA for reducing blood loss in TKA is widely recognized. In the present study, concomitant use of an intravenous administration and infiltration into the joint (via DC) significantly reduced blood loss during and after TKA. Furthermore, allogenic blood transfusion could be avoided in all patients (Group A) who underwent that protocol. In our study, even when given intra-operatively, such as intravenous administration and infiltration, there were no complications. Nevertheless, when used during the post-operative course, careful attention should be paid to prevent such problems. In order to reduce blood loss during and after TKA, it is important to elucidate the optimal conditions, volume, and timing of administration of TA in future studies.
To investigate the amount and the factors of changes of the thickness of tibial polyethylene insert in revisional TKA compared to original thickness of primary TKA. We analyzed one hundred and twenty cases of wear, loosening and instability were included in this study. Infection cases were excluded. The period between the primary TKA and revision TKA was 88.5 months in average (range 1 to 17 year 3 months). The amount of increase of the tibial polyethylene thickness according to the main cause of failure and the wear site was analyzed.
The results of this study were: 1: The increased thickness was 6.7 mm in average. 2: The amount of increase in case of wear of anterior portion only was 2.3 mm, which was below the average. 3: The loosening cases showed 8.2 mm increase in average which was significantly greater than the average. 4: The cases of greater wear of medial side than lateral side showed 8.5 mm increase of the thickness which was significantly greater than the average. 5: The cases of only medial side wear showed 5.5 mm increase of the thickness, which was below the average. 6: The cases of the other causes such as patellar component wear, generalized wear, wear of posterior portion only, early wear less than 5 years after primary TKA because of flat polyethylene surface showed comparable amount of wear to the average.
The thickness of tibial polyethylene insert in revisional TKA compare to original thickness of primary TKA showed that it increased 6.7mm in average and was variable according to the cause of failure.
The author developed a novel technique was for intra-operatively creating an antibiotic spacer for two-stage treatment of infected total knee replacements. An intra-operative mold is made from the removed components and that mold used to create antibiotic spacers with surface contours similar to those of the original total knee replacement. The spacers restore leg length and knee stability. This allows limited function during the interval before reimplantation of the new total knee replacement.
The clinical results of 22 consecutive patients using this technique with minimum of 2 years follow-up appears to be at least equal or better than the previous reports.
It is a cost effective and convenient technique for creating a suitably shaped and sized cement spacer for two-stage revision total knee replacement after infection.
To analyze the mechanism of failure and basic cause in cases of early failure which were required revision within 5 years index TKA. Between 1991 and 2006, 167 revisions TKA of aseptic failure were performed. Revision diagnosis or reason for failure were categorized as wear of tibial polyethylene insert, failure of tibial base plate, early imbalance between medial and lateral soft tension, tight or loose PCL and posterior capsule. The percentages of each failure category were calculated as a percentage of the overall number of revision TKA and a percentage of the early failures. A descriptive statistics were calculated for the time in situ for each failure category.
Early failure within 5 years following index TKA occurred in 33 out of 167 TKA(20.0%). Average time in situ was 38.53 months(3.21 years). Wear of the tibial polyethylene insert occurred in 12 out of 33 cases(36.4%). All cases showed tight PCL. Loosening was the second leading cause occurring in 9 cases(27.2%). Pure instability with tight MCL occurred in 3 knees. Catastrophic early wear within one year after index surgery occurred in 18 knees. The cause of failure were flat surfaced poly in 11, fracture of metal tray 2, dislocation of the thick poly insert 1 and early poly wear due to unknown cause 4.
There were multiple factors of the early failure, which could be divided into design failure and surgical skill failure. However, they worked together in most of the cases.
We analyzed the causes of 113 revision total knee arthroplasties in 84 patients between December 1996 and June 2008. Patient history, medical record and radiographs were reviewed to detect the main cause of failure of primary total knee arthroplasty. The causes of revision total knee arthroplasty were as follows: 44 infections (38.9 %), 34 loosenings (30.1%), 22 polyethylene wears or breakages (19.5%), 5 stiffness (4.4%), 4 polyethylene dislocations (3.5%), 2 patellar dislocations (1.8%), 1 patellar component failure and 1 instability (0.9%, each). The mean interval from the index operation to the revision surgery was 59 months (1 month-20 years).
Infection was the most common causes of revision TKA and followed by loosening, wear or breakage of polyethylene, stiff knee, dislocation of polyethylene and so on.
The use of stem provides consistent component alignment with immediate stable fixation and protects grafted bone by reducing stress on metaphyseal area in revision total knee arthroplasty. One of major concern with use of stems involves stem tip pain in cementless diaphyseal engaging stem. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the effect of stem design and method of fixation on stem tip pain in revision total knee arthroplasty by finite element analysis.
3D finite element model of normal tibia was reconstructed from CT scan images of 26 year old male and the CAD model of revision total knee arthroplasty was developed using commercial software(CATIA®, Dassault system, USA, version 8.20). The tibia component models were assembled based on conventional surgical procedure. The design changes of stem such as the length, diameter and slot were performed and methods of fixation including press fit and coefficient of friction was considered. The contact pressure and von-Mises stress around the stem and the micromotion at the interface were evaluated for a 2000 N of external load by finite element analysis to investigate the effect of stem design and methods of fixation on stem tip pain. The longer length and larger diameter press fit stem significantly increase the contact pressure & stress at the end of stem. The distal slot reduces the contact pressure & stress at the end of stem. Less displacement between tibial component and bone was noted in the increased coefficient of friction.
It would be better to avoid using press fit stem with extended length and larger diameter in revision total knee arthroplasty. More flexibility of stem tip would be favorable because of less concentration of stress. Stem fixation with higher coefficient of friction would be recommended for less displacement of tibial component. Stem with shorter length enough to engage proximal diaphysis, closer diameter of proximal canal and minimal press fit could be accepted to reduce stem tip pain if patient’s surgical anatomy such as bone loss and quality is tolerable in revision total knee arthroplasty.
Uncontained peripheral bone defect in posteromedial tibial plateau is not an infrequent problem even in primary total knee arthroplasty, especially in Korean patients some of those have large angular deformities preoperatively.
We reviewed the clinical and radiological results of primary total knee replacements of 33 osteoarthritic knees in 28 patients with the use of metal block augmentation for uncontained peripheral tibial bone defects more than 5 millimeters in depth and more than a quarter of medial tibial plateau in width. Those defects were encountered in 75 knees (9.6%) during 779 primary total knee arthroplasties performed by single surgeon between January 2002 and December 2004 at our institution. Modular metal block augmentation was reserved for 42 knees, while the other knees were managed with bone-grafting or cement-filling techniques. Clinical and radiological follow-up more than 12 months were available from 33(78.6%) of 42 knees.
At a mean of 32.2 months (range:12~75 months), 31 knees (93.9%) except two cases of failure were evaluated as good or excellent. The average pre-operative American Knee Society Knee and Function scores were 32.5 and 38.6 respectively, which increased to 82.9 and 79.8 respectively at the latest follow-up. There were no radiolucent lines (RLLs) beneath the metallic block or tibial tray, which were progressive or more than 2 millimeters on radiographs, in those knees. Revisions were required for one delayed infection and another aseptic loosening of tibial component.
Non-progressive RLLs less than 2 millimeters at the cement-bone interface beneath the metallic block were noted in 10 (32.3%) of 31 knees. The RLLs appeared in 5 (41.7%) of 12 knees with metallic block augmentation alone and 5 (26.3%) of 19 knees which had been treated with the use of additional intramedullary stem augmentation, although this difference was not statistically significant. Since these radiolucent lines were not progressive or symptomatic at all, their clinical meanings or long-term consequences are not determined yet. All knees managed with the additional intramedullary stem augmentation revealed to have radiopaque lines adjacent to the stem on follow-up radiographs. The sclerotic halo around the tip of stem could be interpreted as evidence of the stem’s function in load sharing and might reflect secure fixation of tibial tray to bony interface.
We concluded that the use of modular metal block augmentation devices for peripheral tibial defects measuring more than 5 millimeters could provide a simple, rapid and dependable technique that provides predictable results. The observation that all knees managed with additional intramedullary stem augmentation would have sclerotic halo adjacent to the stem on follow-up radiographs may reflect an intramedullary stem is an important adjunct to bone defect management.
Although the clinical manifestation of ONFH is well summarized as forms of various stages, its etiology, natural history or epidemiology has not been clearly elucidated yet. With this study, we wanted to find out the estimated annual incidence, epidemiologic characteristics and the effect of known risk factors of ONFH. Therefore we can understand the disease better to provide optimal management to the patients.
Among 133 189 patients who diagnosed as osteonecrosis of femoral head (ONFH) in database of national health insurance system in Korea from 2002 to 2006, three hundreds an eighty-two samples were randomly extracted with 5% error range in 95% confidence interval. With a structured worksheet, medical records and radiographs of each sample were reviewed at corresponding clinic or hospital by authors and trained orthopedic surgeons. With these data, we calculated the prevalence and associated risk factors.
The mean number of annual requests was 23 466. Among 382 samples, two hundreds and seventy-four were confirmed to have ONFH. Diagnostic accuracy was 71.7 %. Diagnosis was more accurate when the patient was male or hospitalized. After the logistic regression analysis, calculated diagnostic accuracy during 2002 and 2006 was 60.3% (51 823/85 987). The annual predicted number of cases of ONFH during this period was 14 103. It corresponds to 28.91 patients per 100 000 populations. Alcohol abuse was noted in 45% and 22% was related to use of steroid. 37% showed bilateral involvement. Bone graft procedures in any kind was the most frequently performed joint preserving procedure.
With this, the first epidemiologic study for ONFH in Korea, we estimated nationwide annual prevalence of ONFH as 28.91 per 100,000 populations during 2002 and 2006. There is an absolute male predominance. Alcohol abuse is the most frequent risk factors. We believe that this result can serve as a baseline data for understanding the epidemiology, clinical characteristics and treatment of ONFH.
The treatment algorithms for femoral neck fractures in elderly keep changing constantly and are still controversial because of increasing stress on improving the quality of life in elderly population and associated osteoporosis. Orthopedic surgeons have almost agreed to the advantages of arthroplasty over fixation in improving the outcome in elderly population, but differences still persist as to type of arthroplasty. Options include unipolar, bipolar or total hip arthroplasty. The objective of present study is to compare the outcome of bipolar and total hip arthroplasty in fracture neck femur in Indian elderly population.
A retrospective analysis was performed for comparing the quality of life index in 60 patients over the age of 55 years who underwent bipolar hemiarthroplasty (30 patients) or total hip arthroplasty (30 patients). The follow up period ranged from 3 months to 3 years. Patients were interviewed by an independent observer by questionnaires based on Harris Hip score and Hospital for special surgery score and were examined clinically. The results were analyzed using unpaired
Though the average period of stay for total hip arthroplasty group was significantly longer but it did not affect the quality of life after 3 months. Patients undergoing total hip replacement were found to be doing significantly better with regards to muscle power, range of motion and function as assessed by unpaired
Total hip replacement provides a better quality of life to elderly patient with femoral neck fractures compared with bipolar hemiarthroplasty in Indian population.
Surgical site infection related to orthopaedic implants is one of the serious complications. In the previous works, we developed a novel thermal spraying technology combined silver with hydroxyapatite (HA) in order to resolve such problems, and reported the property and antibacterial effect of them in vitro. However, no previous reports have investigated in vivo. Therefore, we monitored serum silver level in rats to clarify in vivo kinetics of silver released from the coating.
HA loaded with 3 wt % of silver oxide (HA-Ag) and plain HA powder were sprayed on surface of titanium disks (20 mm diameter × 1 mm thick) by the flame spraying, which is a kind of thermal spraying method with acetylene torch. All these test pieces were obtained from Japan Medical Materials Corporation (JMM, Osaka, Japan). Both samples were implanted singly into the back subcutaneous pockets of male Sprague-Dawley rats (150–200 g). Rats were housed individually and given ad libitum access to food and water. After 24 h, 48 h, 7 d, 14 d and 28 d, the rats were sacrificed, and then the blood was drawn from common iliac vein. All procedures were operated under anesthesia. These blood samples were spun down and serum silver levels were measured by an inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry.
The average serum silver level in HA-Ag group had increased to more than 40 ppb until 48 h after implantation, and then decreased rapidly to normal level. There were significant differences (p < 0.05) between HA-Ag and HA group, at each measurement period.
This is the first report to elucidate the serum silver level in rats implanted HA-Ag coatings. To date, reported coating technologies have included direct-loading antibacterial agents or heavy metals including silver with prosthesis base. The combine technology HA with silver would be effective in not only antibacterial but also osteoconductive respect. Our experimental results highlight the following 2 features: the serum silver levels peaked relatively early, and the levels reduced immediately to normal level after the peak. Therefore, we speculate that the released silver would not be accumulated generally, which not contribute long-term toxicity, and the coating would be suitable for prevention of early surgical site infections.
This study provides novel and important information on in vivo release- property for HA-Ag coating, and suggests this coating is effective against not late but rather early infection related to orthopaedic implants.
Personalized three-dimensional (3D) femoral geometry is a great aid in the surgical planning. X-ray image is still essential to diagnose and plan surgery in total hip replacement due to its lower cost and lower dose of radiation than computer tomography (CT). The purpose of the current study is to improve 3D reconstruction process using conventional X-ray images incorporating the anatomical parameters for building up the femoral model.
For 3D reconstruction, the personalized femoral appearance and parameters were firstly prepared from X-ray images and the referential CT model with anatomical parameters was modified as follows: the axial scaling, shearing transformation and radial scaling. In this study, the reconstruction algorithm was applied to X-ray images obtained from the 28 years old male.
The current study showed that this 3D reconstruction technique is clinically useful and feasible because this method was based on anatomical parameters and used for whole femur. This result can provide the basic model of individual femur for using finite element method of hip or knee joint, and designing the customized hip and knee implant. In addition, this result can be applied to the visualized 3D model with more effective parameters of individual femur in the surgery navigation system.
The fixation of titanium or titanium alloy implants is related to their surface composition and topography. Osteoconductive calcium phosphate coatings promote bone healing and apposition, leading to the rapid biological fixation of implants. It’s no doubt that the addition of certain biologically active protein with biomaterial will improve the bioactivity of the material. Previously, we examined the biocompatibility of basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) incorporation with titanium implants. Now we investigate the effect of fibronectin (FN) incorporation with thin calcium phosphate film deposited on titanium by electron-beam evaporation since fibronectin is actively involved in cell adhesion, spreading, would healing, cytoskeletal reorganization, and bone tissue formation. A FN-apatite composite layer was formed on the surface of titanium by biomimetic process. The coating process was carried out by immersing thin calcium phosphate film coated Ti in Dulbecco’s Phosphate buffered saline containing FN (20 ug/ml). The surfaces of samples were examined with FESEM, Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy and X-ray diffraction. The quantity of FN taken up and the kinetics of protein release were monitored by BCA method and Elisa. The fibronectin was immobilized in the newly formed apatite layer. The adhesion of osteoblast cells to the FN-apatite composite layer was to show the biocompatibility of implants, and FN-apatite composite layer could enhance osseintegration of implants in vivo.
This research was supported by a grant (code #: 08K1501-01220) from Center for Nanostructured Materials Technology under 21st Century Frontier R& D Program of the Ministry of Education, Science and Technology, Korea.
Much attention has recently been paid to bioabsorbable polymeric materials, such as poly(L-lactic acid) (PLLA), in the field of orthopedics and oral surgery. For example, PLLA has extensively been used as resorbable bone fixation devices. Recently, hydroxyapatite (HA) micro-particles filled PLLA has also been developed to improve the bioactivity, elastic modulus and absorption rate of biomedical PLLA devices. Porous structures of PLLA and HA/PLLA composites have also been developed to improve osseous conduction so that these biomaterials can be used as scaffolds in tissue engineering for rejenerative medicine. Such porous materials may also be utilized as artificial bones in orthopedics. Thus, demand for porous PLLA and HA/PLLA is rapidly increasing, however, the relationships between their mechanical behavior and properties and their microstructure have not been well understood yet.
In the present study, porous structures of PLLA and HA/PLLA with continuous pores are developed by using a solid-liquid phase separation technique and a subsequent solvent sublimation process. Size of pores and porosity are varied by changing the concentration of the solutions. Compression and shear tests are performed to evaluate the elastic moduli and strengths. Field emission scanning electron microscopy (FE-SEM) of the deformation behavior at the critical transformation points from linear elastic to nonlinear deformation is conducted to characterize the mechanism of such microscopic deformation at the critical point. Microscopic deformation and failure behavior of such porous structures are then characterized on the basis of FE-SEM results, and then correlated with the macroscopic mechanical properties. Structural modification is also tried to improve the mechanical properties to extend the applicability of the porous biomaterials.
To evaluate the effectiveness of core decompression using the tantalum trabecular metal system for treatment of an early stage osteonecrosis of femoral head in minimum 1 year to maximum 5 years follow-up.
From January 2003 to August 2007, 36 patients in 46 cases underwent core decompression using the tantalum trabecular metal system. The ARCO classification system was used. Retrospective analysis was done. The conversion to total hip arthroplasty due to aggravating hip pain was defined as a clinical failure.
With the higher stage of ARCO classification and more lateral location of lesion, the conversions to total hip arthroplasty would be increased. The better outcome was noted with lower stage of ARCO classification and more medial location of the lesion.
The higher stage of ARCO classification and more lateral position of lesion, the failure rate of the tantalum trabecular metal system increases. The most important thing is to detect early stage of osteonecrosis of femoral head. The tantalum trabecular metal system is considered as a useful treatment of osteonecrosis of femoral head with lower stage of ARCO classification and medial location of lesion.
Alumina and zirconia have been extensively used for orthopedic implants, such as hip and knee joint replacements. In 1982, Dr Hironobu Oonishi and Kyocera Corp. put the world’s first ceramic knee component, KOM, to practical use. This ceramic knee component shows excellent clinical results for long-time use. Now, the ceramic material of the knee component is changed from the alumina to the zirconia, and over 5000 ceramic components have been used in Japan so far.
The 3 mol% yttria stabilized polycrystalline zirconia (3Y-TZP) has been used as surgical grade zirconia. The 3Y-TZP possesses higher fracture strength and toughness as compared to monolithic alumina. However, it is generally known that spontaneous transformation may also occur at relatively low temperatures in hydrothermal environment as in the case of human body for the 3Y-TZP. Therefore, there is a concern of the degradation of mechanical and wear properties as a consequence of the transformation (low temperature degradation).
Our previous studies confirmed that low temperature degradation can be prevented by optimizing sintering temperature and adopting a Hot Isostatic Press process. In this study, we evaluated the effects of surface nature of ceramic material and heat treatment. Since grinding and polishing of the ceramic implants (e.g. femoral heads) might induce phase transformation, residual stress and microcracks, it is needed to examine the validity of the manufacturing process.
At first, the 3Y-TZP samples with grinded (#400) and mirror polished surfaces were prepared and exposed in saturated vapor in an autoclave at 121°C for 150 h (aging test). Some of the samples were subjected to a heat treatment and then to aging test. Before and after aging test, change in crystal structure was evaluated by X-ray diffraction. Then, for evaluation of the aging effects for microscopic area of the ceramic, a Vickers indentation was introduced on the surface before the aging test. Changes in crystal structure and residual stress were evaluated by a Raman spectroscopic technique.
In the results of the aging test, it was found that the degree of the increase in monoclinic fraction of both grinded and polished surfaces was lower in the samples with heat treatment than in those without heat treatment. These results indicate that the phase stability of the 3Y-TZP was improved by the heat treatment after machining.
Around the indentation, circular-like deformation zone and cracks extending from the four corners of the indentation were observed. After the aging test, the transformed area gradually spread towards neighborhood regions depending on the aging time. Besides, a distinct progress of phase transformation at around the crack was also observed. On the other hand, in the samples subjected to the heat treatment, no transformed area was observed around the indentation. These results suggest that low temperature degradation could be prevented by the heat treatment after the machining.
The residual stress fields induced in phase-transformed areas increased during aging test, and heat treatment after the machining was also able to prevent phase transformation even if surface damages, such as indentation or machining, were introduced on the samples.
We report the review of performance and problems of Metasul Hip System with metallic sliding face during mean time of 11 years or longer.
Ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE) has been successfully used as a bearing material in total joint arthroplasty. However, longevity of these implants has been compromised by wear and fatigue damage of the polyethylene. The addition of vitamin E to the polyethylene is a process recently introduced in the market to stabilize free radicals produced during radiation crosslinking. The objective of the present study is to investigate the effect of the addition of vitamin E on the wear characteristics of UHMWPE. Sequentially cross-linked and annealed UHMWPE material (X3™, Stryker Orthopaedics, Mahwah, NJ) was used as a control.
Trident™ acetabular cups (Stryker Orthopaedics, Mahwah, NJ) with inner diameters of 36 mm and 44 mm and a wall thickness of 3.8 mm were tested on a 12 station MTS hip joint simulator. The simulator used a physiologic loading pattern with a maximum load of 2450N. The test was conducted under standard clean conditions with alpha calf fraction serum diluted to a protein concentration of 20 g/l for a total of three million cycles. All cups ran against CoCr femoral heads, and gravimetric measurements were taken every half-million cycles.
Results show that sequentially crosslinked components, size 3 6mm, had an average volume loss of 9.4 ± 2.5 mm3, while vitamin E components of the same size had an average of 16.5 ± 3.1 mm3. This represents a 75% increase for vitamin E components that is statistically significant (p = 0.039). Size 44 mm sequentially crosslinked components had an average volume loss of 6.8 ± 3.7 mm3, while vitamin E components had an average of 19.7 ± 3.2 mm3. This denotes a statistically significant increase of 192% for material with vitamin E (p = 0.011). Linear regression analysis yielded wear rates of 4.1 ± 0.9 mm3/mc and 6.1 ± 1.3 mm3/mc for size 36 mm sequentially crosslinked and vitamin E components, respectively, which represents a non-significant increase of 49% for vitamin E components. Size 44 mm sequentially crosslinked components had a wear rate of 3.8 ± 1.3mm3/mc, while vitamin E components had a wear rate of 8.1 ± 0.7 mm3/mc. This represents a statistically significant increase of 117% in wear rate for vitamin E components (p = 0.013).
The results of this testing indicate that the addition of vitamin E degrades wear performance relative to sequentially crosslinked material. Research shows that the introduction of Vitamin E affects the ability to create crosslinks during irradiation by reacting with some of the free radicals. Oral et al have shown that the crosslink density decreases when Vitamin E is blended into UHMWPE. Their research has also shown that a decrease in crosslink density causes an increase in wear rate. The results of the current testing show that the addition of vitamin E to polyethylene reduces the wear resistance of highly crosslinked polyethylene.
The osseointegration of implants is related to the early interactions between osteoblastic cells and titanium surfaces. The behavior of osteoblast cells was compared on four different titanium surfaces in vitro and in vivo: machined, blasted, plasma spray and micro-arc oxidation.
X-ray diffraction and scanning electron microscope investigations were performed in order to assess the structure and morphology. Biologic and morphologic responses to the osteoblast cell lines (Saos-2) were then examined, using Promega proliferation assay, alkaline phosphatase activity, vβ3 integrin expression and cytoskeleton staining (Rhodamine-Phallodine). The analysis of gene expression for osteocalcin and collagen I was done through RT-PCR. In addition, differential histologic evaluation and interfacial strength at the bone-implant interfaces were then evaluated in the distal femur of four beagle dogs.
In conclusion, micro-arc oxidation of titanium appears to exhibit more favorable osteoblast adhesion and stronger interfacial strength than the compared groups in vitro and in vivo as well.
The purpose of this study is to analyze clinical and radiological results of total hip arthroplasty using the 3rd generation ceramic on ceramic articular surface.
Between July 1999 and May 2005, 339 hips of 250 patients had primary cementless total hip arthroplasty with the 3rd generation ceramic on ceramic bearing implants. And 325 hips of 236 patients were followed up over 3 years. Male were 168 patients(237 hips) and female were 68 patients(88 hips). The mean age at the time of operation was 47.3(range, 25~76) years old and the mean follow up period was 62.4(range, 36~107.6) months. The preoperative diagnoses were osteonecrosis of the femoral head (ONFH) in 250 hips, secondary osteoarthritis in 55 hips(dysplasia in 35, infection sequalae in 12, LCP in 2, CDH in 2), hemophilic arthropathy in 9 hips, ankylosing spondylitis in 7 hips etc.
We used Bicontact system(Aesculap, Germany) in 65 hips, Secur-FitTM(Stryker Howmedica Osteonics, USA) in 206 hips, Trilogy ABTM (Zimmer, USA) in 54 hips. Clinically, Harris Hip Score, thigh pain, squeaking and other complications were evaluated. Radiologically, the serial radiographs were analyzed.
Clinically, the Harris hip score was improved from preoperative 66.0(19~91) to 96.2(58~100) at the last follow-up. Radiologically, there was no loosening of implants and visible wear and osteolysis. Heterotopic ossifications were noted in 5 cases. In complications, there was dislocation in one case, periprosthetic fracture in 2 cases and thigh pain in 9 cases. Intermittent squeaking sound has occurred in 8 cases(2.5%). Among these, one case of loud squeaking which happened after fall down had revision surgery. There was no infection and fracture of ceramic implant.
Our midterm results of THA with the 3rd generation ceramic bearing system were very satisfactory and demonstrated that the 3rd generation ceramic bearings remain as an excellent bearing choice because of their superior wear characteristics. However, the results of this study suggests that the squeaking would be one of strong potential risk factors for failure of ceramic on ceramic total hip arthroplasty and we must be very cautious to prevent squeaking.
Bipolar hip arthroplasty was introduced to alleviate the problems of hip pain, acetabular protrusion and femoral stem loosening associated with unipolar prosthesis. Earlier generation bipolar endoprosthesis used to cause varus fixation of outer head which led to the unacceptably high incidence of dislocation, component disassembly and fractures of the polyethylene bearing insert. Second generation endoprosthesis with a self centering mechanism were introduced to overcome these problems. This new design incorporates a polar offset by setting the center of rotation of the inner head proximal to the center of rotation of the outer head, which generates a valgus producing moment at the outer cup. There is a controversy whether this mechanism works in vivo, more so in indigenous prosthesis.
A retrospective observational study was done on 37 subjects, which included 21 males and 16 females. The first radiograph was taken with the patient standing and bearing full weight over the endoprosthetic leg and abducting the contra lateral limb as much as possible. The second radiograph was taken with the patient standing neutral and bearing weight on both the legs. Abduction and adduction views were then taken in supine position. The radiographs were analyzed using the method similar to that of Drinker and Murray. The adductive motion from abduction to neutral position is within the range of inner bearing oscillation. Modified Harris Hip Score was used to evaluate the patients clinically. Results were analyzed using Wilcoxon Matched-Pairs Signed-Ranks Test, Students t-test and Karl Pearson correlation statistics.
The mean outer head alignment changed from 42.46 degrees ±13.62 (range 10 to 72 degrees) to 31.93 degrees ± 10.59 (range 8 to 50 degrees) in moving from abduction to neutral position in weight bearing position. The analysis showed that 68.66% of the total motion occurred at the outer bearing in weight bearing position whereas 73.86% of the total motion occurred at the outer bearing in supine position. The difference between distribution of motion between supine and weight bearing position was not found to be statistically different using Wilcoxon Matched-Pairs Signed-Ranks Test (p = 0.3164) and unpaired students t test (p = 0.35). No correlation was found between weight of the patient and time of follow up with outer head alignment and differential distribution of motion.
Self centering mechanism of bipolar endoprosthesis works in vivo under physiological loads and aligns the cup in neutral or valgus position till an average follow up of 10 months. Though the motion occurs at both the bearing surfaces outer bearing motion clearly predominated in both weight bearing as well as supine position.
Femoral off-set is the perpendicular distance between femur longitudinal axle and the femoral head’s rotation’s centre. Femoral off-set influences following yardsticks: stability of the joint, range of movement (ROM), muscular forcibleness, solicitations on the femoral component and acetabular component’s usury. From numerous radiographies studies, is shown as off-set is not an indefeasible measure, but an average with a range of variability. Offset is one of the most important yardsticks to consider during the pre-operating planning since, as is broadly documented, it has a positive effect on the functionality of the prosthesis; difficulty remains to individualize the optimal offset value in patient with bilateral coxofemural pathology or carriers of opposite side total hip prosthesis. Modular necks act indipendently in three spatial variables allowing to reach 27 points in the space, disposing of heads with three lenghts the real disponibility become of 81 points.
Usually we estimate the sizes and the orientation of the components manually and through a radiographic intra-operative control in order to choose the best match head-neck.
If we make a minimum mistake in cup position, the use of modular necks allow to correct this failure to obtain the most correct anatomic position producing negligible debris and the reduction of the mechanic stress.
Basing on our experience we think that the possibility to change length and version independently and sequentially is the unique technique avaible to correct the implant’s orientation, even if in our series we have choose neutral neck in most cases. To obtain better functional outcome we are studing a device based on gait analysis and superficial electromyography to calculate pre and post operative off-set. The data that we have achieved are still too few to be able to produce results; if there is possible, presenting them in future editions.
One to five years follow up with a mean of 2.8 years. Two-thirds were female and one- third male. Age ranged from 39 to 87 with a mean of 73. Majority was treated for OA. A c.c. head (28mm or 32mm) and poly bearing in a cementless cup were used for all patients. Selection of neck position was recorded for all patients.
Elderly femoral neck fractures are often treated with cemented stems according to the reason that bone quality of the patients is not good enough to obtain the initial stability for supporting press fit cementless stem. Some elderly patients also have medullary expanding so called stovepipe canals which make initial stability of press fit stems difficult. Stems with lateral flare have some mechanical advantages to obtain proximal fixation compare to the straight stems without lateral flare. Concerning to initial stability, their vertical loads can be supported not only by proximal medial cortex but also by proximal lateral cortex. The stems also have rotational stability because of the proximal high fit and fill. As lateral flare is a transverse extension in axial section, the stem occupies the proximal canal widely. So it provides strong rotational stability. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the outcome of press fit cementless stem with lateral flare for elderly femoral neck fractures with poor bone quality and with medullary expanding.
We performed a retrospective review of the clinical records and radiograghs of consecutive 42 patients (42 hips) of femoral neck fracture operated with cement-less stems with lateral flare in 2005 and 2006. In this period, all displaced femoral neck fractures were operated using cementless stems with lateral flare (Revelation Hip System, DJO, USA) in our hospital. We could follow 24 patients for over one year. 12 of 24 patients had so called stovepipe canals according to Canal Flare Index< 3.0 (Noble et al). Minimum follow up duration was one year. The mean age of the patients at the time of operation was 78.2 years. The mean duration of follow-up was one year and three month. At the time of final follow-up, stem subsidence, stem fixation, spot welds and demarcation line at distal part of stem are assessed on radiograph. And operation time, blood loss at operation and complaint of thigh pain through all the follow up period are also investigated on clinical record.
There was no stem subsidence over 2mm and demarcation line in two cases. All stems were assessed bone-grown fixation. We could find at least one spot welds in all patients around porous coated part of the stem. The mean operation time was 60.1 min. and mean blood loss was 240.5 ml. There was no patient who complaints of thigh pain after operation.
Cementless stems with lateral flare were seemed to obtain good initial stem fixation for elderly femoral neck fracture patients even they have poor bone quality and medullary expanding.
The cemented and cementless implant fixations are popular in orthopaedic arthroplasty. However, these implant fixations have some problems such as cement failure, wear debris, stress shielding, revision and so on. To overcome these problems, we are developing a new concept of buffered implant fixation which uses a bone-friendly buffer between the implant and the bone. In this study, we performed a finite element analysis to evaluate the buffered implant fixation in comparison with cemented and cementless implant fixations in mechanical aspects. In addition, we investigated the effect of buffer taper angle to the stress distribution in the buffered implant fixation.
Three-dimensional FEA of the cemented, cementless and buffered fixation were performed using the ABAQUS program. In these FEA, the ‘standardized femur’, which is the composite femur model supplied by Pacific Research Lab., was used as the bone model and the CPT stem and the Versys Fibermetal Midcoat stem were modeled for the cemented fixation and the cementless fixation, respectively. These three-dimensional models were meshed using the tetrahedral elements with 4 nodes (C3D4) and the additional contact definitions. The buffered implant fixation is similar with the polished cemented fixation except the material between the implant and the bone. The polyetheretherketone (PEEK) was selected as the buffer material. Also, several taper angles of buffer were simulated to change the stress distributions in the buffered fixation. The external load three times of mean body weight (74.3 kg) was cyclically loaded at the femoral head with the angle of 20° in adduction and 6° in flexion while the distal end of femur was fixed.
In the buffered implant fixation, the taper-locked effects were observed. The buffered fixation had greater cyclic compression for the bone compared to the cemented fixation. Also, the failure probability of the buffer in the buffered fixation was less than that of the cement in the cemented fixation. The risk factors in the buffer were 0.148 for the tension and 0.176 for the compression while, the risk factors of cement in the polished cemented implant fixation were over than 1. Moreover, the buffered fixation had widely distributed compression compared to the cementless fixation and the stress distribution could be modified easily to change the taper angle of buffer. The FEA results showed that the buffered implant fixation would provide an appropriate mechanical environment.
Combined anteversion (CA) is defined as the sum of the anteversions of acetabular and femoral components. In this study, we determined the appropriate CA in a variety of femoral versions using a total hip arthroplasty model. In addition, we also examined the usefulness of a changeable neck to improve range of hip motion in these cases.
Using a THA model, the range of motion (ROM) was tested in various CA values obtained by changing the anteversion of a cup in six increments after setting the femoral anteversion to 20° or 60° anteversion and 20° retroversion. The angle of the changeable neck was changed in 11 increments of 5°. To evaluate stability, the range of internal rotation at 90° flexion, the external rotation at 0° extension, and the range flexion was measured when any impingement occurred prior to dislocation. We defined the required ROM that met 40° internal rotation, 30° external rotation, and 110° flexion.
In normal 20° anteversion group, the required ROM was achieved with CA between 30° and 50° without using any changeable necks. In excessive anteversion 60° group, the range of external rotation was less than 10° even when the acetabular component was set 10° retroverted, because of the bone impingement between the greater trochanter and the posterior acetabulum. When 25° retroverted changeable neck was used, ROM improved to 30° external rotation and satisfied the required ROM. In 20° retroversion group, the internal rotation angle was 31° even when the acetabular component was opened 35° anteverted, because of anterior neck-liner impingement. When 25° anteverted changeable neck was used, ROM improved to 39° internal rotation and 130° flexion.
In cases with normal anteversions, the required ROM can be achived by adjusting CA. In cases with excessive anteversion or retroversion, there was a limitation of the CA adjustment. The use of changeable necks allows for further improvement of ROM by compensating femoral anteversions.
To investigate the effect of bilateral total hip replacement for patients with ankylosed hip joints caused by late ankylosing spondylitis (AS) and to discuss its related pre- and post-operation rehabilitation problems.
Data of 20 patients with ankylosed hip joints caused by late AS undergone total hip replacement (40 hips) were reviewed. Among the total 14 patients (28 hips) undergone bilateral total hip replacement, other 6 patients (12 hips) undergone twice operations. We used Harris score, assessment of the joint pain, range of motion to make sure the curative effect of the operative strategy.
The mean duration of follow-up was 3. 8 years, all hip joints function was improved, and the flexion deformity of the involved hips were disappeared. The range of hip flexion were 75°–105°(average 86. 2°), and the range of hip extension were 5°–15°(average 8. 7°), the average Harris score was from 32.8 pre-operation improved to 88.2 post-operation, the patients experienced no pain on their hips, the pain of the knee and the lower back complained before the treatment were obviously relieved.
Bilateral total hip replacement is an effective treatment for ankylosed hip joint caused by late ankylosing spondylitis, early rehabilitation intervention is useful for the functional recovery of the joints
Bipolar Hemiarthroplasty Using Non-cemented Femoral Stem in Non-traumatic Osteonecrosis of the Femoral Head Nine to Nineteen years Follow-up
The purpose of this study is to evaluate the clinical and radiographic results of 20 patients(27 hips) who underwent primary bipolar hemiarthroplasty with non-cemented femoral stem and biarticular cup from January 1989 to April 1999 who were followed for more than nine years. Average follow up was 13.4 years(range: 9~19 years). The type of non-cemented femoral stem was Harris-Galante type in ten hips, Multilock porous coated stem in seven hips, and Multilock porous and tricalcium phosphate coated stem in ten hips. The etiology of osteonecrosis of the femoral head was idiopathic in eleven hips, alcohol abuse in twelve hips and steroid administration in four hips. According to Ficat’s grading system, all twenty-seven hips were in stage. Clinically, we evaluated the Harris Hip scores. We also evaluated the radiographic measurements around the femoral stems and the bipolar cups.
The average Harris Hip score improved from 57.2 points to 89 points; and 2(7.4%)hips were associated with thigh pain and 5(18.5%) hips with groin pain. Around the femoral stem there was progressive radiolucent line more than 1mm in width in 1(3.7%) hip, and osteolysis was present in 9(33.3%) hips. On evaluation of radiographs for stability of fixation, we found that 21 hips(77.8%) showed osseous ingrowth, 5 hips(18.5%) showed stable fibrous ingrowth and one hip(3.7%) showed unstable fixation. The osteolysis around the acetabulum was found in 9 hips(33.3%). Two hips showed evidence of migration of the bipolar cup. Five hips(18.5%) showed acetabular cartilage erosion more than 1mm. Seven hips(25.9%) required conversion to total hip arthroplasties, and in two hips, femoral stems were revised. The causes of failure of bipolar cup was central migration in 2 hips, and dissociation of femoral head, extensive osteolysis, and unknown groin pain after trauma in one each. Two bipolar cups were converted to acetabular cup at revision of the femoral stem. The overall failure rate of the primary operation was 26%. The survivorship of non-cemented femoral stem was 92.6% and 74% in bipolar cup at minimum 9 years follow up.
The current study demonstrated favorable results after bipolar hemiarthroplasties with non-cemented femoral stems. However, the osteolysis around the femoral stems and the acetabular cup emerged as main causes of need for surgical revision.
The rate of failure of primary THA in patients with osteonecrosis of the femoral head is higher than that in patients who undergo THA because of other diagnoses. We examined the results of cementless THA performed with second-generation in a consecutive series of young patients with osteonecrosis of the femoral head.
Sixty-five consecutive primary THAs with insertion of a femoral stem with a circumferential proximal porous coating (HG Multilock prosthesis) and a cementless acetabular component (Harris-Galante II) were performed in 52 patients with osteonecrosis of the femoral head. These patients were followed prospectively and evaluated at a minimum of 10 years after surgery. Four patients (4 hips) died and three patients (3 hips) were lost to follow-up monitoring. The remaining 45 patients (58 hips) had a mean of 11.1 years (range, 10 to 13.4 years) of clinical and radiographic follow-up.
One stem (1.7%) was revised because of aseptic loosening. Eighteen cups (31%) were revised because of excessive polyethylene wear and osteolysis. One hip (1.7%) underwent revision of both acetabular and femoral component because of excessive polyethylene wear and osteolysis. The mean Harrsi Hip Score improved from 49 points before surgery to 92.8 points after surgery in patients who did not undergo reoperation. Osteolysis around the acetabular component was present in 22 hips (37.9%). Femoral osteolysis was seen in 9 hips (15.5%), and there was no osteolysis below the lesser trochanter in any hip.
Circumferentially porous-coated second-generation femoral prostheses provide excellent fixation in young patients with osteonecrosis of the femoral head. However, a high rate of polyethylene wear and osteolysis in these high-risk patients remains a challenging problem.
In the case of a complete dislocated hip or a severe deformity of the proximal femur, total hip arthroplasty (THA) can still be combined with a proximal femoral osteotomy for shortening femur or correcting the deformity if needed. Subtrochanteric femoral shortening and a corrective osteotomy are considered to be an integral part of THA for such cases. A precise osteotomy is mandatory to achieve good results. Although, the freehand excision of V-shaped subtrochanteric osteotomy used to be performed frequently, this procedure was also subject to some pitfalls, such as poor coaptation of the osteotomy surface. A new device was thus developed to perform a V-shaped osteotomy in an identical central axis between the distal and proximal femur. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the efficacy of the device by comparing the perioperative results with those of a free-hand subtrochanteric osteotomy.
From 1999 to 2002, THA combined with a double-chevron subtrochanteric osteotomy was performed by free hand (free hand group). From 2003 to 2007, THA combined with a double-chevron subtrochanteric osteotomy was performed using a new device (device group). The free hand group included 27 hips in 21 patients. The mean age of the patients (23 females and 3 males) at the time of the operation was 58 years. Fourteen were completely dislocated hips and 13 followed various proximal femoral osteotomies. The device group included 102 hips in 79 patients. The mean age of thepatients (70 females and 9 males) at the time of the operation was 62 years. Seventy two were completely dislocated hips and 26 followed various proximal femoral osteotomies. Four parameters were used to evaluate the efficacy of the device:
operation time, total blood loss, C-reactive protein at postoperative 1 day and early complications at the osteotomy site.
The mean operation time, total blood loss, and C-reactive protein in the device group all significantly decreased in comparison to the free hand group. The decreases ranged from; 132 to 96 minutes (p< 0.01), 1346 to 999 g (p< 0.01), 4.9 to 3.0 mg/dl (p< 0.05), respectively. Two types of complications were observed at the osteotomy site. Pseudoarthrosis at the osteotomy site was observed one case in each group and both of these cases underwent a stem revision (4% in the freehand group and 1% in the device group). A femoral shaft split was observed in 3 cases in the freehand group (11%) and 3 cases in the device group (3%) and all 6 cases were treated conservatively. There were no instances of nerve palsy, infections, or thromboembolic events resulting from these procedures.
The above described new device allowed for the easy and accurate performance of a subtrochanteric V-shaped osteotomy with THA for either a completely dislocated hip or a severely deformed proximal femur.
Treating Crowe type 3 or 4 of hips tends to be technically difficult when performing total hip arthroplasty (THA) due to the severely dysplastic acetabulum and proximal femur in addition to a high dislocation of the hip. Since the socket is limited to being placed at the original hip center, a femoral shortening osteotomy is often required in order to prevent neurovascular problems. This osteotomy will need the stability of the femoral stem with both the proximal and the distal femoral bones. We used the modular S-ROM stem, which has a valuable proximal structure and a distal flute structure to stabilize the stem with the proximal and distal femoral fragments. The purpose of this study was to report the clinical and radiographic results of the primary THA with a shortening osteotomy while also using the S-ROM prosthesis.
Between 1994 and 2004, primary THA using the S-ROM prosthesis was performed on 7 hips in 6 cases (1 male, 5 females). Crowe type 3 or 4 was observed in one and 6 hips, respectively. The mean age at operation was 56 years old (range 51~60). The mean follow-up period was 41 months (range 24~56 months). Four hips had previously undergone a subtrochanteric valgus osteotomy. All hips underwent a step-cut femoral osteotomy at the proximal metaphysis for the shortening and/or correction of angulations with on-lay chip bone grafts. All of the used stems were straight type. The clinical outcome was evaluated using the clinical scoring system of hip joints established by the Japanese Orthopaedic Association (JOA). According to a 100 point scale, pain was determined to be 40, ROM was 20, gait was 20 and ADL was 20.
No hips had undergone any revision surgery as of the most recent follow-up. Union was achieved at the osteotomy site in all hips. Neither osteolysis nor a loosening of the implant was radiographically observed. The mean JOA score before THA and at the last follow-up was 41 (31–48) and 81 (62–91) points, respectively. The mean postoperative days to start full weight bearing was 53 days (range 49~70). In two cases (28%), a procedure using circular wiring was performed to treat a crack in the proximal femur.
The S-ROM prosthesis was thus found to be useful for primary THA with a shortening metaphyseal femoral osteotomy for hips in patients with Crowe type 3 or 4 developmental dysplasia.
This study was undertaken to assess the feasibility of a new subtrochanteric osteotomy technique for total hip arthroplasty (THA) in cases with a high dislocated hip secondary to the sequelae of a septic hip in childhood. Eighteen patients (20 hips), aged 25 to 65 years (average 47.3 years), underwent THA using a cement-less conical stem (Cone prosthesis®; Protek AG, Berne, Switzerland) with a new subtrochanteric osteotomy technique and were followed for an average of 23.6 months. All patients were graded as type III (high dislocation) according to the Hartofilakidis classification, and according to the Crowe classification 3 cases were of type III and 17 were of type IV.
The procedure was performed through a posterolateral approach and a provisional osteotomy was usually performed at the inferior half of the lesser trochanter. All acetabular component was inserted at the true acetabular and the acetabular cup was inserted in 5 cases and only a liner was inserted after cementing in 15 cases. The stem size and the amount of stem insertion was decided according to the preoperative planning and soft tissue tension. After final reduction, the greater trochanter was re-attached to the proximal femur with the hip in the abducted position. Cables or a grip system (Dall Miles®, Stryker Orthopaedics Inc., Mahwah, NJ, USA) were used for fixation, and if possible, additional screws were inserted.
Postoperatively, range of motion exercises were encouraged after 2 to 3 weeks of bed rest and non-weight bearing crutch ambulation followed. Weight bearing was permitted only after obtaining radiological confirmation of bone union, but then active exercises were strongly encouraged to stretch abductors. Mean duration of surgery was 180.6 minutes, and mean perioperative blood loss was 1424.1ml. There were no intra-operative complications. Post-operative dislocation occurred in 2 cases and partial femoral nerve palsy developed in 1 case. Mean Harris Hip Score improved from 42.4 to 84.2. Mean lateral opening angle of acetabular cup and liner was 34.7 0 and mean anteversion was 20.8 0. All femoral components were implanted in neutral to 5 degrees of valgus, and mean leg lengthening was 36.5mm. The mean time to greater trochanter union was 3.72 months.
Primary THA in highly dislocated hips due to the sequelae of septic hip in childhood using the described subtrochanteric osteotomy and a cone prosthesis was found to be safe and effective at restoring leg length and trochanteric rotation. But more follow-up is required to more comprehensively establish the long-term results of the described procedure.
In situ fixation of mild slips of the slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE) is a safe and reliable method of treatment. Hardware failure and fractures are reported at the time of pin retrieval. Difficulty in removing these pins is well reported. Major problems can be expected when arthroplasty is necessary years later, if the pins are still inside the proximal femur. Hence we have come up with a novel technique to remove these pins during Primary Total hip arthroplasty.
The hip is exposed through posterior approach, dislocated and the neck is then cut at the usual site. It is then segmented in both sagittal and coronal planes into approximately eight to ten pieces and removed piecemeal. The pins are thus exposed, cleared of any bony debris and hammered retrograde.
By using our simple and novel technique to remove these pins we feel it avoids unnecessary trauma to the outer cortex of femur and also reduces the operating time significantly.
A special surgical technique and consideration is necessary in the total hip arthroplasty for dysplastic osteoarthritis after Kalamchi and MacEwen Type III or IV deformity (so called “Perthes-like-deformity”). There have been few reports concerning the total hip arthroplasty for “Perthes-like-deformity”. We evaluated the clinical and radiological outcome of 52 uncemented hip arthroplasties for the lesion.
We have performed 106 hips of uncemented total hip arthroplasty for dysplastic osteoarthritis after Kalamchi and MacEwen Type III or IV deformity. Among them, 52 hips of 47 patients (11 males and 41 females) were evaluated with minimum of three years follow-up. The average age at the surgery was 52 (28 to 65). The average follow-up period was 4.8 (3 to 8.1) years. Against the developmental dysplasia or dislocation, 29 hips of 26 patients had been treated by casting or surgery in infancy. Thirteen hips of 11 patients had no previous treatment before the arthroplasty. Spongiosa metal cup (GHE: ESKA implants, Lübeck, Germany) was used for 33 hips of 28 patients and Zweymüller type cup (Allo-classic cup: Zimmer Inc., Warsaw, IN, Bicon cup: Smith & Nephew Orthopedics AG, Rotkreuz, Switzerland) for 19 hips of 19 patients. Spongiosa Metal stem (GHE: ESKA implants) was used for 23 hips of 19 patients and Zweymüller type stem (Alloclassic stem: Zimmer Inc., SL stem: Smith & Nephew Orthopedics AG) for 29 hips of 28 patients. The average operative time was 108 (53 to 233) minutes. The average blood loss during the surgery was 731(150 to 1749) milliliters. The adductor tendon release was added in 28 hips of 26 patients against the severe contracture. The patients were evaluated clinically (pre-surgical history, hip score, leg length discrepancy, Trendelenburg sign, and gait function) and radiologically (ATD before the surgery, alignment, and stability of implants). Average ATD before the surgery was −2.2 (−28 to 17) millimeters. The average leg length discrepancy was 1.9 (0 to 7) centimeters before the surgery and was improved to 0.1 (0 to 1) centimeters after the surgery. The average hip score was 54 (23 to 80) before the surgery and was improved to 90 (69 to 100) after the surgery. At the final follow-up, Trendelenburg sign was positive in 14 hips of 14 patients (26.9%) and the limping was not obvious in 38 hips of 33 patients (73.1%). All implants were stable at the final follow-up.
“Perthes-like-deformity” often has the severe deformity. It has a shortening or an absence of the neck and an excessive antetorsion of the femur. When it has the coxa magna, the acetabulum is shallow, has the narrow anteroposterior diameter, and has the thin wall like the osteophyte. It is frequently accompanied by shortening of leg and contracture, as the lesion arises from the development disorders. Thus, the total hip arthroplasty, especially uncemented one, is complicated. However, the satisfactory result can be obtained by careful consideration and surgical procedure such as a provision against the bleeding and the soft tissue release.
Considerable numbers of authors have reported the change in periprothetic bone mineral density (BMD) after hip arthroplasty. However, there have been few reports concerning the BMD in the lumbar vertebra, especially for dysplastic hips.
Since 1998, we have been measuring the BMD mineral density for 2016 patients by DXA (Dual-energy X-Ray Absorptionmetry method). Among them, we evaluated the BMD in 66 postmenopausal patients with the single side primary arthroplasty, with five years or more follow-up, and also aged 60 or more. We used a DXA densitometer (DPX-IQ, GE Healthcare, Madison, WI, USA). The diagnosis at the surgery was dysplastic osteoarthritis in all patients. The average age at the surgery was 66 (60–81). All patients were female. No patients had the systematic diseases which contributed to the secondary osteoporosis. No patients had received the pharmacotherapy for osteoporosis in the whole therapeutic process. The bed rest was seven from two days after the surgery (different by the operation date). The average follow-up was 7.0 (five to ten) years.
The average BMD in the lumbar vertebra before the surgery was 0.996 (0.612 to 1.712) g/cm2. The BMD was 0.971 (0.637 to 1.402) at six month postoperatively, 0.972 (0.552 to 1.740) at one year, 1.004 (0.573 to 1.733) at two years, 1.032 (0.633 to 1.670) at three years, 1.035(0.724 to 1.688) at four years, 1.031 (0.564 to 1.679) at five years, 1.027 (0.734 to 1.647) at six years, 1.042 (0.589 to 1.389) at seven years. At the final follow-up, the BMD was 1.054 (0.589 to 1.647). In 53 patients (80%), the density at the final follow-up increased in comparison to that before the surgery. In 27 patients (41%), the density once decreased six month postoperatively. The density increased at 3 years (t=−1.919, p=0.030), four years (t=−2.523, p=0.015), five years (t=−2.381, p=0.021), seven years (t=−2.822, p=0,007), and at the final-follow-up (−4.076, p= 0.000) in comparison to that before the surgery. The activity of the patients was evaluated by the hip score. The average score was 54.5 (21 to 76) before the surgery. The average score was 88.0 (66 to 100) and increased at the final follow-up in comparison to that before the surgery (t=−13.04, p 0.000).
Some authors (eg. Bergström I, 2008, Espar I, 2008, etc.) have pointed out that the appropriate activity may increase the bone density. Presumed from the literatures, the increase of activity after the arthroplasty may have increased the BMD, though the direct correlation was not obvious between the BMD and the amount of hip score (at the final follow-up: r=0.005, p=0.972) in this study.
The use of polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) in orthopaedic reconstructive surgery can increase the possibility of cardiovascular dysfunction remains a debate. This study was undertaken to determine if cemented hemiarthroplasty is safe in treatment of femoral neck fracture in patients with ischemic heart disease. Between March 1999 and February 2004, we performed cemented hemiarthroplasties for displaced femoral neck fractures on 158 consecutive patients. This retrospective study consisted of 44 patients with ischemic heart disease(group 1) and 58 patients of age matched control(group 2). We compared the mortality rate, the incidence of deep vein thrombosis (DVT), pulmonary embolism, cerebrovascular disease, dislocation, deep infection, the amount of postoperative blood loss, and the grade of cementation by Barrack in radiograph between two groups.
No difference was found in perioperative mortality rate, deep infection rate, the incidence of DVT or pulmonary embolism, the newly developed heart ischemic event or brain hemorrhagic lesion between the two groups. But there were more incidence of dislocation related to weakness by past brain ischemic lesion and the newly developed brain ischemia in patients of group 1 than group 2(p < 0.05). More importantly, six patients in group 1 had transient symptoms of dyspnea, signs of hypotension, and bradycardia during two days postoperatively, which is suspicious of embolic phenomenon, even though it was not confirmed.
More closer and careful observations for the occurrence of dislocation related to previous brain ischemia, or newly developed brain ischemic lesion or embolic phenomenon and appropriate thromboprophylaxis are necessary in patients with ischemic heart disease after a cemented hemiarthroplasty for the treatment of femoral neck fracture.
88.5% of the patients had retained the original prosthesis. Survival rate for the cup component was 95%, and for the stem component was 85%.
There was no ceramic head fracture in Germany. We thought that beating with the hammer when we install the ceramic head to the taper was one problem. Stem loosening was seen in undersized stem component. On the other hand, survival rate for the cup component was 95% in Japan and Germany. This was good result in comparison with other reports about long term survival.
Twenty-Six total hip arthroplasties were performed in Crowe grade 3 or 4 hip dysplasia using subtrochanteric shortening osteotomy with 2-kinds of femoral stem(Primary monoblock and modular femoral stem). The average age was 46.2 years, and the average follow-up was 4.1 years. Acetabular reconstruction with structural autograft was used in 13 hips. Radiologically, hip centers were nearly normalized by vertical height of 10.6mm elevation and horizontal lengths of 1.7mm compared with uninvolved sites. Three of four osteotomy nonunions were managed with bone graft and other one wating for surgery. One acetabular revision was performed for migration. One postoperative dislocation was managed successfully with closed reduction and abduction brace. One patient (> 7cm) showed postoperative neurologic complications was noted. Harris hip score was improved from 35.6 to 81.7. A cementless modular distal fluted femoral stem is a useful device in these patients.
Resurfacing hip implants differ in macro- and microstructure. Manufacturing related parameters like clearance or carbon content influence the wear behaviour of these metal-on-metal bearings. The aim of this study was to analyse the main macro- and micro-structural differences of commercially available resurfacing hip implants.
Ten different commercially available resurfacing hip implant designs were included in this investigation:
- BHR® (Smith&
Nephew/MMT) - Durom® (Zimmer) - Conserve Plus® (Wright Medical) - Cormet® (Corin) - Icon® (IO) - ReCap® (Biomet) - Adept® (Finsbury) - ASR® (DePuy) - BS® (Eska) - Accis® (Implantcast).
The heads and cups were measured in a coordinate measuring machine and radial clearance as well as sphericity deviation were calculated. Surface roughness measurements were carried out. The microstructures of the heads and cups were inspected using SEM and element analysis was performed using EDX to identify carbides and the alloy composition.
The mean radial clearance was found to be 85.53 μm. The range was from 49.47 μm (DePuy, ASR®) to 120.93 μm (Biomet, ReCap®). All implants showed a sphericity deviation of less than 10 μm. The highest sphericity deviation was found to be 7.3 μm (Corin Cormet® head), while the lowest was 0.8 μm (Smith& Nephew BHR® head). On average, the heads tended to have a higher sphericity deviation (4.1 μm, SD: 2.3 μm) compared to the cups (2.7 μm, SD: 1.4 μm). SEM revealed that most manufacturers use a high carbon alloy casting manufacturing process combined with heat treatment after casting (Corin Cormet® and Wright Conserve®: head and cup; DePuy ASR®: cup; Eska BS®: head).
Commercially available resurfacing hip implants differ in design and manufacturing parameters, including macro- and microstructure, which are critical in achieving low wear and ion release. This study was designed to aid in the understanding of clinical observations. Also, specific information is now available for surgeons choosing an implant designs.
The ultimate goal for treatment of osteonecrosis of femoral head (ONFH) is preserving the femoral head. We have tried to manage the patient who received failed joint preserving procedures with resurfacing arthroplasty if they fit the indicati385on. In this brief review, we wanted to clarify the role and technical concern of resurfacing arthroplasty as a salvage procedure after failed joint preserving operations for ONFH.
Among 556 hips underwent resurfacing arthroplasty from September 1998 to October 2007, sixteen resurfacing arthroplasties (13 patients) were performed after failed joint preserving procedures for ONFH. Mean age at the operation was 39 years old. Seven vascularized fibular grafts, 3 multiple drillings, 3 core decompressions and 3 combined procedures were performed as initial operations. Mean duration from the index operation and resurfacing was 95 months. Mean follow up was 14 months. The patients were clinically evaluated with the Harris hip score, hip or thigh pain, and range of motion. As a radiological evaluation, we measured positions of the acetabular cup and femoral stem, radiographic changes at the neck and complications. The Harris hip score increased from 69.2 preoperatively to 89.5 at the final visit. Hip range of motions other than sagittal directions significantly improved after the operation. No patient complained of limb length discrepancy. One patient complained of unexplained hip pain, and another patient had trochanteric pain. Other than those two cases, all patients regained their pre-morbid activity level uneventfully. Radiologically, eleven femoral stems in anteroposteior and lateral radiographs were exactly aligned along the previous operative tracts. However, there were no clinical complications related to the position of femoral component. The only case that the acetabular cup was implanted in high inclination (60 degrees) experienced sustained unexplained hip pain. There was no another complications.
Our experience suggests that even for the case of failed hip preserving procedures in ONFH, resurfacing arthroplasty can play a successful role as a salvage operation. Furthermore, this can be an excellent alternative between joint preserving procedures and conventional THA.
We are now seeing the third generation of cross-linked polyethylene along with work on alternative hard on hard bearings trying to reduce the generation of wear debris.
Issues have been raised from squeaking to high trace elements and strength characteristics of current materials.
Ideally, the surfaces for articulating bearing surfaces will be made from materials having high strength, high wear, and corrosion resistance, a high resistance to creep, and low frictional moments. This paper will review characteristics of a novel new approach for a bearing material.
Studies have demonstrated the advantages of the fullfluid film layer of lubrication in-terms of enhanced wear performance.
An acetabular “buffer” bearing was developed that features a pliable bearing surface formulated, biocompatible polycarbonate urethane (PCU). A review of design objectives and testing will be highlighted in this paper.
34 components have been implanted reaching two years post-op. Two devices have been removed both for non-related implant issues. Retrieval analysis did not show any appreciable wear or damage to the bearing material.
Ceramic heads and highly cross-linked polyethylene (HXLPE) as bearing surface materials have been introduced to reduce the production of polyethylene wear particles. The present study hypothesized that the wear rate of HXLPE could be further reduced when combined with a ceramic head. The purpose of this study was to compare the in vivo wear of Longevity HXLPE against cobalt-chromium and zirconia heads after a minimum 5-year follow-up.
A prospective cohort study was performed in 102 cementless total hip arthroplasties (THAs) with the Longevity HXLPE socket (Zimmer) between June 2000 and October 2001. Same prostheses were used in all cases both acetabular cups (Trilogy; Zimmer) and femoral stems (Versys Fiber Metal Taper; Zimmer). 26-mm zirconia heads (NGK) or 26-mm cobalt-chromium heads (Zimmer) were randomly used in 51 hips each. A minimum 5-year follow-up was completed for 47 hips with zirconia heads and 46 hips with cobalt-chromium heads. Two-dimensional linear wear of Longevity HXLPE was measured using computer-assisted methods (PolyWare) on annual x-rays, and total head penetration rates and steady state wear rates were calculated. In addition, periprosthetic osteolysis was evaluated.
At a mean 6-year follow-up, the total head penetration rates were 0.034±0.016 mm/year (zirconia) and 0.031±0.015 mm/year (cobalt-chromium). The steady state wear rates were −0.01 mm/year (zirconia) and −0.01 mm/year (cobalt-chromium). No significant difference was seen between the two groups (p=0.4 and p=0.91). Osteolysis was not observed around prostheses in any hips.
In conclusion, no advantage was seen for the zirconia head compared with the cobalt-chromium head in this time period.
We developed a modified posterior approach that preserved the short external rotator muscles to prevent dislocation after THA or BHA. The present study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of short external rotator preserving posterior(ERP) approach for bipolar hemiarthroplasty in treatment of femoral neck fractures in patients with neurologic disorders. Between March 2004 and February 2006, we performed 187 cementless bipolar hemiarthroplasties for displaced femoral neck fractures on 36 patients with neurologic disorders, who were operated on by ERP approach (Group 1) and 151 patients without neurologic deficits, who were operated on by conventional posterolateral approach (Group 2). We compared operation time, the amount of postoperative blood loss, the early postoperative complication rates, the dislocation rate within 1 year, and duration of hospital stay between two groups.
The amount of postoperative blood loss was significantly decreased in group 1(p < 0.01). There were no significant differences in mean operation time and early postoperative complication rate including wound problem, deep vein thrombosis or infection and duration of hospital stay. There was no dislocation after operation in group 1, but seven patient (4.6%) had dislocation in group 2. Nine patients (25.0%) died within postoperative 1 year in group 1 and twenty six patients (17.2%) died in group 2.
Cementless bipolar hemiarthroplasty through ERP approach provides a favorable outcome for treatment of displaced femoral neck fracture in patients with neurologic disorders who is considered as high risk of dislocation. Also, it decreases the postoperative blood loss and the needs of postoperative abduction brace.
Direct anterior approach (DAA) in supine position is one of the successful minimally invasive surgery (MIS) approaches, but it may need special traction table and stem selection is limited. DAA in lateral position is easier, and full porous cylindrical stem is easily inserted in this approach. The purpose of this presentation is to report this technique and result. 55 patients with osteoarthrosis (Crowe group1 to 3) were undergone THA with DAA in lateral position and followed for a minimum of 7months. Approach and cup settlement is the same as usual DAA in supine position. After liner placement, proximal femur is pushed up anterolaterally with the hip hyperextension, external rotation and adduction, which make excellent view of femoral neck cut surface. Because the leg is shortened, neurovascular relaxation is achieved. PCL retractor of TKA instrument is used to keep tensor fascia femoris muscle laterally over greater trochanter. No other special instrument is needed in stem insertion. Hip scores improved from 37.8 preoperatively to 87.8 postoperatively. Mean incision length was 9cm and mean operation time was 85minutes including routine intra-operative X-ray check. Neither auto blood donation nor cell saver was used. Blood transfusion was not needed. Stem position with over 2 degree varus were in 5 cases (9%) and over 2 degree valgus were in 3 cases (5%). There were no dislocation, loosening, infection, or femoral nerve injury.
In supine position, hip motion in sagittal plane has limitation. DAA in lateral position afford more extension with easily controlled external rotation and adduction which is the key to insert stem easily. DAA in lateral position is easy and tolerable MIS.
To compare the early result of minimum incision surgery (MIS) to standard incision procedures with use of lateral flare hip replacement (Revelation Hip System, DJO, USA). 38 primary total hip arthroplasty of 36 patients were performed using lateral flare hip system. Lateral flare hip has symmetric contact to medial and lateral cortical bone at high proximal part and it provides definite endpoint of stem insertion. From this point of view, we can say that this system is suitable for MIS. Among the 38 hips, 21 hips were performed by MIS (less than 10cm) and 17 hips were performed by Standard incision. MIS were performed from November 2004 to December 2005. And Standard incisions were performed from June 2004 to December 2005. Two surgeons performed all operations (NW and YT). The main surgeon decided whether MIS was applicable or not for each patient. Anterolateral intra gluteal approach (modified Dall) was applied for all surgeries. The same rehabilitation program was applied on both groups postoperatively. The average follow-up period of MIS patients was 28.6 months and 34.7 months in standard incision. We investigated the early result of these patients.
There was a relationship between patients’ height and the length of skin incision (p< 0.05). No significant difference between two groups was proved in CRP, CPK and D-Dimmer (CRP: 13.9/11.9mg/dl, CPK: 405.5/380.5mg/dl, D-Dimmer: 6.1/5.3mg/dl). Both intraoperative blood loss and operation time were less in MIS group (blood loss 530.9ml vs. 772.8ml, operation time 99min vs. 115.4min) (p< 0.05). The days until the patient was able to do active straight leg raising were 17.3 in MIS group and 22.4 in standard incision group and hospital stay days were 26.7 vs. 29.2. But no significant differences were proved in hospitalization. On roentgenografic findings, the inclination of acetabular cup was 42.0 degree in the MIS group versus 41.2 in the standard incision group and no significant difference was found. In Radiographic findings, one stable fibrous fixation was observed in each group. The other cases were bone ingrowth fixation. Japanese orthopedics association (JOA) hip score was not significant different in each group at the final follow up (88.1 in MIS group and 85.9 in Standard group). Also as the result at the term of 6, 12, 18 and 24 months after operation, JOA hip scores was not significant difference in each group. There were no revision cases in this study until the final follow up.
In the present study, intra-operative hemorrhage and operation time were significantly less in MIS group. It was supposed that at the patient selection, each surgeon decided the candidate of MIS due to patient’s hip condition. But in another situation, no significant difference was found for example in serum CRP, CPK and D-Dimmer levels. Clinical and radiological outcomes were not significantly different between MIS and Standard group in this study.
The two-incision technique uses strategically located incisions to insert the prosthesis components in to specific intermuscular or internervous planes in an effort to minimize damage to these tissues. Even though there are many reports about safety and benefits of bilateral simultaneous total hip arthroplasty (THA), none of them has reported about either one-incision or two-incision bilateral simultaneous minimally invasive (MI) THA. This study aimed to assess the feasibility of bilateral simultaneous MI two-incision THA in terms of clinical, radiological and functional outcomes.
Sixty two patients, in the age of 24 to 69 years were operated for bilateral simultaneous THA using modified two-incision technique and followed for average 41 months. In the technique of two-incision THA described by Mears, they used modification of Smith Peterson approach for insertion of acetabular component and femoral component is inserted through a small incision situated between greater trochanter and iliac crest, centered directly in line with the femoral shaft. We modified this technique and used part of Watson Jones approach for insertion of acetabular component with patient in lateral position. The posterior incision for insertion of femoral component is through intermuscular interval between gluteus medius and piriformis.
The average Harris Hip score improved from 41.8 (range 10 to 59) preoperatively to 95.3 (range 73 to 100) postoperatively (P < 0.05). WOMAC score improved from median of 66.2 (range 31 to 96) preoperatively to 5.0 (range 0 to 19) postoperatively (P < 0.05). Forty-nine (79.03%) patients were pain-free at the time of first follow up (6 weeks after surgery) and remained pain-free till the last follow up, while remaining 13 (20.97%) had only slight pain. Out of those 13, 3 patients complained of occasional mild pain at last follow up. Fifty (80.64%) patients were walking without limp, while remaining 12 (19.35%) had only slight limp at 6 months. Out of those 12, 2 patients had persistent limp at final follow up. Fifty-eight (93.53%) patients were walking without support, 56 (90.32%) were able to walk unlimited distance and 55 (88.70%) were able to climb stairs without using a railing. Walking with walker was started on average 3.7 days (range 1 to14 days) and walking with crutches was started on average 10.3 days (range 1 to 49 days) postoperatively. Patients were able to walk without support on an average 48 days (range 14 to 120 days) and use stairs without support and without any discomfort on an average of 50 days (range 5 to 150 days). The average lateral opening angle of acetabulum was 40 ° and anteversion was 12 °. All femoral components were implanted in neutral to 5 ° valgus position. None of the femoral component showed subsidence of more than 3 mm. The filling of the femoral canal by the prosthesis was excellent in all cases. Post-operative periprosthetic fracture occurred in 2 patients and delayed infection occurred in 1 patient.
In conclusion, bilateral simultaneous two-incision minimally invasive THA gives satisfactory clinical and radiological results in comparison with conventional THA. It is safe in experienced hands, without any additional risk of complications. It provides excellent functional outcome and patient satisfaction.
The anterior pelvic plane has been introduced as a concept of the reference plane to image free navigation-assisted cup placement of total hip arthroplasty. With the neutral pelvis, the anteversion relative to the conventional coordinate system is equal to the that of relation to the anatomical coordinate system. This is the rationale of image free navigation system. But, currently, two major concerns about image-free navigation assisted total hip arthroplasty are tilting of anatomic coordinate system and the cutaneous palpation procedure. Therefore, it was the goal of this study to provide both the bone anterior pelvic plane (Bone_APP) and the overlying soft tissue plane (Soft_APP) simultaneously, and to find possible correlations of biometrical parameters and effect of ante-version were an additional motivation of this study. 23 Korean adult patients underwent image-free navigation-assisted total hip arthroplasty. The tilting of Bone_APP, soft tissue thickness on ASIS, pubis, and then tilting of Soft_APP, and anteversion of cup were measured with reconstructed CT and 3D workstation system.
The average age was 66.1 years, the average height was 162.5cm at a weight of 59.2 kg. The average body mass index was 22.3. And the average lumbar lordosis was measured as 30.4 degrees. The soft tissue on the level of the pubis was 17.6 mm thicker than that on the level of ASIS in average. In all cases, Soft_APP was positive, that is from 3.5 to 16.5 degrees of backward rotation. We also found a high-intersubject variability in the Bone_APP from 13.4 of forward rotatation to 23 degrees of backward rotation. Overall, there are no correlation between biometrical parameters and difference of navigated data to others measured on CT. Averaged navigated data was 22.4 degrees. The average anatomic, operative, and planar anteversion were 29.2, 27.2 and 21.3 degrees respectively. The value of anteversion measured on the transverse plane and sagittal plane shows higher than navigated anteversion in paired comparison. This could be comprehended that the navigation system had under-estimated the anteversion than that of transverse and sagittal plane, This means navigation assessed pelvic plane as back ward tilting rather than forward tilting intraoperatively.
None of cases showed the Bone_APP was parallel to conventional coordinate system. Comparing the variable bone APP tilt, all of cases showed an backward tilted soft tissue plane. There were no correlation between bone APP and biometrical parameters. Overall, navigated data were less than anatomic and operative anteversion. Rather than anatomic coordinate system (Bone-APP), backward tilting due to overlying soft tissue (Soft-APP) might to make the navigated data have the tendency to under-estimated the anteversion of cup measured with CT. In conclusion, anterior pelvic plane does not satisfactory reliability with should be easily identified during operation. Image-free navigation system would take into account variations of individuals including both bone tilt and soft tissue plane.
Aseptic loosening and osteolysis may cause significant periprosthetic femoral bone destruction, often necessitating bypass of the deficient proximal femur to obtain stable fixation in the distal diaphysis. The purpose of the present study was to report our results of femoral component revision using a distally locked revision femoral stem for the treatment of the severe proximal femoral bone loss.
We evaluated 21 hips in 20 patients who underwent revision hip arthroplasty associated with Paprosky grade-IIIB or IV femoral deficiencies. Three hips were associated with a Vancouver type-B3 periprosthetic femoral fracture. The mean age at the time of revision was 70.8 (51–82) years old with 5 men and 15 women. The mean duration of follow-up was 5.1 years. The femoral implant used for the revision was the Cannulok Revision Prosthesis in 16 hips and the Huckstep interlocking stem in five. Gaps between the stem and the host bone were filled and impacted with bone chips and morselized bone prior to stem insertion.
One femoral implants were resected because of deep infection Subsidence was absent and stable fixation was achieved in all patients. Non-progressive radiolucent lines in zones 1 and 7 according to Gruen’s classification were detected in five cases. Cortical hypertrophy around the interlocking screws were seen in ten cases. No disadvantages or complications of the interlocking screws were observed. All the fractures have united within three to five months. Intraoperative fractures in the diaphyseal area occurred in five hips in which trochanteric osteotomy was used.
A diaphyseal fixation of the femoral stem with distal interlocking screws appears to provide primary axial and rotational stability of the prosthesis and early mobilization. This implant may provide a satisfactory alternative for the management of revision hip surgery in the presence of a loose femoral component with massive bone loss. Longer-term follow-up data from this study will be needed to confirm these outcomes.
The precise orientation of the acetabular component is one of the important factors in total hip arthroplasty (THA). Computed tomography (CT) provides image data for accurate measurements of the orientation of the acetabular component. However, in many studies in the literature, the orientation of the acetabular component after THA has been expressed as a combination of inclination angle (IA) and version angle (VA) measured on radiographs. For measuring VA, an anteroposterior (AP) radiograph of the hip joint, or a cross-table lateral radiograph has been used. The accuracy of these radiological measurements was not thoroughly studied. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the accuracy of measurements on radiographs comparing to those on CT.
Aseptic loosening and osteolysis may cause significant periprosthetic femoral bone destruction, often necessitating bypass of the deficient proximal femur to obtain stable fixation in the distal diaphysis. The purpose of the present study was to report our results of femoral component revision using a distally locked revision femoral stem for the treatment of the severe proximal femoral bone loss.
We evaluated 21 hips in 20 patients who underwent revision hip arthroplasty associated with Paprosky grade-IIIB or IV femoral deficiencies. Three hips were associated with a Vancouver type-B3 periprosthetic femoral fracture. The mean age at the time of revision was 70.8 (51–82) years old with 5 men and 15 women. The mean duration of follow-up was 5.1 years. The femoral implant used for the revision was the Cannulok Revision Prosthesis in 16 hips and the Huckstep interlocking stem in five. Gaps between the stem and the host bone were filled and impacted with bone chips and morselized bone prior to stem insertion.
One femoral implants were resected because of deep infection Subsidence was absent and stable fixation was achieved in all patients. Non-progressive radiolucent lines in zones 1 and 7 according to Gruen’s classification were detected in five cases. Cortical hypertrophy around the interlocking screws were seen in ten cases. No disadvantages or complications of the interlocking screws were observed. All the fractures have united within three to five months. Intraoperative fractures in the diaphyseal area occurred in five hips in which trochanteric osteotomy was used.
A diaphyseal fixation of the femoral stem with distal interlocking screws appears to provide primary axial and rotational stability of the prosthesis and early mobilization. This implant may provide a satisfactory alternative for the management of revision hip surgery in the presence of a loose femoral component with massive bone loss. Longer-term follow-up data from this study will be needed to confirm these outcomes.
Total hip arthroplasty (THA) is a commonly performed surgical procedure for various arthritic conditions that affect the hip joint, and it has proven to be highly effective for the relief of pain and improvement in the quality of life. Despite many recent advances in THA, dislocation continues to be a frequent complication, and the incidence of dislocation ranges from 1% to 5% in primary THAs. The literature abounds with options for the treatment of recurrent dislocation after THA. However, to the best of our knowledge, successful treatment with open reduction of a chronic proximal dislocation after THA has not been reported previously in the literature.
We report an unusual case of a chronic prosthetic dislocation that was caused by the buttonholing of a prosthetic femoral head by anterior soft tissue, which impeded reduction. A surprisingly good functional result was achieved by an open reduction and revision operation on a 56-year-old man, who had a chronic dislocation of a total hip prosthesis. 5 years after the surgery, the patient has no clinical or radiographic evidence of recurrence of dislocation of THA. We believe that a chronic irreducible dislocation may hamper operations by adhesion and scar tissues. Especially soft tissue buttonholing makes it impossible to perform a closed reduction. We restored a much higher level of function by a single operation in a short time, and made the patient to be able to ambulate with fast recovery from the surgery. Equal limb lengths were restored and no neurologic compromise occurred.
Visualization of the femoral medullar canal is troublesome in revision surgery. To obtain better visual field of the canal and assist cement extraction and following reconstructive procedures, flexible endoscope was applied in femoral revision. Mean age and time to revision of fifteen cemented totally replaced hips were 69.3 (42–83) and 14.9 (3–25) years, respectively. Preoperative status of the revision regarding type of stem loosening was classified as possible in four cases, probable in two, and definite in five classified by Harris et al. No marked finding of loosening was in four. That of bone defect was type I in four cases, Type II in three, and Type III in three by Gustilo. Five cases showed no marked loss of the defect. Extraction of cement mantle was performed under flexible endoscopic inspection. Impaction bone grafting was performed in eight cases. Time for cement removal in association with type of loosening and bone defect were evaluated as well as analysis of periprosthetic complications.
Retained cement mantle was extractable in all cases under good exposure and with maintenance of efficient working space. Interfacial granulation and fibrous tissues between bone and cement were easily removed. Endoscopic time for cement removal was 41.7 ± 10.3 minutes in average. It was 51.8 ± 6.2 minutes in no loosening. 41.3 ± 11.1 minutes in possible loosening, 38.5 ± 9.2 minutes in probable loosening, and 35.4 ± 8.3 minutes in definite loosening, which depended on the status of fixation between bone and cement. Type of bone defect also influenced the time. It was 52.4 ± 5.6 minutes in the cases of no marked bone loss, 43.8 ± 3.5 minutes in Gustilo type I, 28.3 ± 3.5 minutes in Type II, and 34.7 ± 2.5 minutes in Type III. The procedure was effective to prepare suitable bone bed for reconstruction, which allowed proper stem settlement and facilitated recovery of bone stock in the cases of impaction bone grafting. Intra-operative blood loss was 377 ml (212 – 1430) and total amount of blood loss including post surgical drainage was 593 ml (316 – 1680). Type of loosening and bone defect did not affect both whole and intra-operative bleeding volume. However, three occult fractures happened, in which two revealed minor cement leakage and one required additional osteosynthesis with extensive approach.
The data indicated that flexible medullo-endoscope could provide good visual field with maintenance of working space, potentially contributing to less invasive femoral revision surgery, if it would be combined with refined device for cement extraction to improve accuracy of the procedure.
Modular femoral stem provides significant flexibility in total hip revision arthroplasty. There have been few clinical studies that have dealt with modular stem. We have evaluated the clinical and radiographic performance of 59 patients with distal fix modular Link MP stem. The average follow-up period was 6.4 years. The average Harris hip score was improved from 47 to 87.6. Of 19 patients with trochanteric osteotomy, greater trochanter was displaced in four patients. Re-revision was done to five patients. Three were for subsidence, one of them showed dissociation of the coupling part and the other two were for a nonunion of osteotomy site. There was no statistical relation (p=0.40) between stem subsidence and bone deficiency; the subsidence may have been too small for the canal. As a result of last follow-up, survival rate was 91.5 %(CI 95%, 89–101), but there was no case of recurrent dislocation or femoral stem fracture.
Non-cemented tapered wedge femoral stems have gained popularity given their excellent long-term clinical success rates. However, there is sparse literature reporting the incidence of early postoperative periprosthetic femur fractures in patients with this stem design. The aim of this study is to report this incidence and to identify factors which may increase the risk of such fractures.
The charts of all patients who were implanted with a single design of a tapered wedge femoral stem at a single institution were retrospectively reviewed to identify any early periprosthetic femur fractures, defined as occurring within the first year of surgery. Demographic, operative, and radiographic details were analyzed for potential risk factors that may predispose to periprosthetic fractures, and compared to a cohort of patients with the same implant that was matched for age, sex, and pre-operative diagnosis and did not have a periprosthetic fracture.
Six fractures were identified in 2220 stems implanted over a five year period, for an incidence of 0.3%. The average time to fracture was nine weeks post-operatively. Five fractures were Vancouver Type B2, and the other was Vancouver Type A. Three stems were radiographically undersized, and two failed to achieve a proximal wedge fit because of distal fixation. When compared to the matched cohort, there was no statistical significance with regard to body-mass index, morphological cortical index, or canal-bone ratio. However the fracture cohort did have a statistically lower canal-calcar ratio (p < 0.05) and statistically higher canal-flare index (p < 0.05).
Early postoperative periprosthetic femur fracture around a tapered wedge stem is a rare but potentially devastating complication. Risk factors which may predispose to fracture are a proximal-distal mismatch in femoral geometry and an undersized implant.
Two-stage reimplantation is currently the most widely accepted method of treatment for a periprosthetic hip infection. However, it remains controversial whether the treatment protocol may be equally effective in the eradication of resistant microorganisms. We compared the results of two-stage reimplantation performed for periprosthetic hip infection caused by resistant microorganisms with those performed for periprosthetic hip infection caused by non-resistant microorganisms.
We reviewed a consecutive series of 32 patients (32 hips) who had a culture-proven deep infection at the site of hip arthroplasty and were treated by a two-stage reimplantation protocol. Based on the antibiotic sensitivities of the infecting microorganisms, the patients were divided into two groups. Resistant microorganism group consisted of 20 patients who had an infection with antibiotic-resistant bacterial strains (methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus in 11 and methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus epidermidis in 9). Non-resistant microorganism group consisted of 12 patients who had an infection with antibiotic-sensitive bacterial strains. The treatment was considered a failure if the patient had a persistent infection after the first-stage procedure or a recurrence of infection after reimplantation. The mean duration of follow-up after the index procedure was 45 months (24 to 123).
Among the entire series of the 32 patients, the second-stage reimplantation was able to be performed in 29 patients (91%) and the remaining three went on to a permanent resection of the hip because of persistent infections. After the two-stage reimplantation, four patients had a recurrence of infection (relapse of infection with the same microorganism in three and reinfection with different resistant microorganism in one). Thus, overall treatment failure rate was 22% and all these failures occurred among patients with resistant microorganisms. Treatment failure rate of 35% in resistant microorganism group was significantly higher than that of 0% in the non-resistant microorganism group (p = 0.029). None of the variables evaluated in this study was found to be significantly associated with the treatment failure in the resistant microorganism group.
Current two-stage reimplantation protocol showed a high rate of treatment failure in our patients who had periprosthetic hip infection caused by methicillin-resistant bacterial strains. Further study is needed to develop optimal treatment strategy for this difficult-to-treat condition.
This study was to analyze the minimum ten years clinical and radiological results of revision total hip arthroplasties using allogenic impaction bone graft and cemented cup in acetabular bone deficiency.
Fifty two revision total hip arthroplasties that had been performed in forty nine patients between March 1992 and June 1997 and had followed more than minimum ten years were included in this study. The clinical and radiological results were evaluated by Harris hip score and roentgenography including anterior-posterior view of pelvis and lateral view of operated hip.
The mean Harris hip score was 47 points preoperatively, 81 points at three years, 84 points at seven years, and 82 points at ten years after revision. In radiological evaluation, osseous union between grafted bone and host bone was seen within four months in 47 hips, a complete grafted bone-cement radiolucent line of two millimeter or more in at least one zone was seen in 5 hips at two years, 7 hips at seven years, and 2 hip at 10 years follow-up.
We recommend the technique using allogenic impaction bone graft and cemented cup to reconstruct the acetabular cavitary defect in revision total hip arthroplasties.
We apply a hydrocolloid-gel sheet (C-12, Karayaheive, Alcare, Tokyo, Japan) for the hip arthroplasty. The sheet is a kind of wound dressing film made of the Hevea sap. The Hevea sap has been widely applied for the stoma or cosmetics (e.g. facial mask, UV protection moisturizer, hair lotion). We use it since October 2004. It applies the moist wound healing mechanism without preventing the self-wound-healing. The surgical exudate is kept under the sheet to apply the moist wound healing mechanism. The sheet had been improved originally as a wound dressing material. Because of its very strong adhesiveness, we use it also as an alternative to the epidermal suture. In our method, we do not use any epidermal suture or staples. We use an anterolateral approach making an arcate incision. After the subcutaneous tissue was sutured just like as in the case of using the epidermal sutures or staples, the sheet was attached to the skin. Both the sheet and the overlaying gauze were not changed until the removals on the tenth day after surgery.
We have applied this wound closure method for 814 primary surgeries. Among them, we evaluated 56 hips in 49 patients (three males and 46 females) (including seven patients of the simultaneous bilateral surgery) with minimum of two years follow-up. The average age at the surgery was 61 (40 to 77). The diagnosis at the surgery was dysplastic osteoarthritis for 50 hips in 45 patients, primary osteoarthritis for five patients in three hips, and rheumatoid arthritis for one hip. The uncemented implants were used for all patients. In all patients, a good wound healing was obtained. The wound dehiscence occurred in two patients, however the wound healed later by attaching the hydrocolloid-gel sheet again. The hyperplastic scar was observed in one hip.
Though Orientals have less ability of wound healing than Caucasian, a satisfactory wound healing was achieved without any epidermal suture. Comparing the conventional skin closure methods, the hydrocolloid gel sheet brought about less pain; as no removal of staples was necessary, less time and labor, less medical waste, and better wound healing. As the disadvantage, some sensitive patients might mind the smell of the exudate under the gel sheet. The wound closure method using the hydrocolloid-gel sheet was very useful for the hip arthroplasty.
The use of tapered titanium femoral stems has gained in popularity for primary total hip arthroplasty. One of the basic stem designs is a fully grit blast square tapered stem with distal fixation (Zweymuller-type). Another stem design (Muller-type), a proximally porous coated flat wedge stem with proximal fixation is associated with a low but significant perioperative femoral fracture risk. Both of these implant types are inserted with a broach-only technique. We theorize that the Zweymuller-type implant can be inserted safely with pneumatic broaching with a very low fracture risk even when broached by rotating residents with no prior experience.
We prospectively reviewed 300 consecutive hip arthroplasty cases using Zweymuller-type stems from eight different manufacturers implanted using the Woodpecker TM pneumatic broaching system. The series included both THA and hemiarthroplasty cases with a wide range of cortical/canal indexes. Patient age ranged from 14 to 98 (avg. 68). Half of the hip stems were inserted through a posterolateral modified Kocher-Gibson approach, and half through an anterolateral Hardinge approach. Approximately 25 rotating residents who were initially unfamiliar with this broaching technique and stem implant type performed the majority of the procedures. We routinely obtained an intra-operative AP pelvis x-ray to confirm trial implant size, alignment, and adjust the leg lengths.
The overall technique/implant-related perioperative complication rate was 2% (6/300). These included intra-operative femoral fractures(2), post-operative femoral fractures (1), dislocations(3), and deep infections(2). There were no cases of nerve palsy or leg length inequality > 1cm. Rates of post-op blood transfusions and venous thromboembolism were not reviewed for the purposes of this study. Only one of the complications (one deep infection) required exchange of the original femoral component. There was no significant difference in complication rates between type of surgical approach, brand of square tapered stem manufacturer, or experience of the operating surgeon.
We conclude that hip arthroplasty using pneumatically broached, square tapered, cementless distal fixation (Zweymuller-type) hip stems has a low learning curve and can be implanted safely even in very osteoporotic bone. This technique/implant gives the surgeon control of stem anteversion for stability and leg length inequality correction. The incidence of certain perioperative complications can be reduced by using Zweymuller-type stems using pneumatic broaching regardless of approach, implant manufacturer, or surgeon experience. These patients will continue to be followed clinically for implant survivorship.
Proximally-coated non-cemented tapered femoral stems have demonstrated excellent long-term clinical results. However, there is sparse literature reporting the incidence of failure of osteointegration in patients with this stem design. The aim of this study is to report this incidence and identify factors which may increase its risk.
206 elective primary total hip arthroplasties were performed consecutively with a single stem design over a three-year period. All patients were evaluated clinically and radiographically. Radiographic parameters were analyzed for any potential risk factors that may predispose to failure of osteointegration.
Three of 206 hips failed to osteointegrate and subsequently underwent revision surgery, for an incidence of 1.5%. The average time to revision was 1.2 years. The presenting complaint was persistent pain and radiographs revealed a progressive linear lucency at the proximal implant-bone interface in all three patients. Each patient had been implanted with a large-sized stem that had achieved a diaphyseal fit radiographically. This cohort had a statistically lower canal-flare index (p < 0.05) when compared to the rest of the study group. At the time of surgery, all stems were found to be loose and were easily removed.
Failure of osteointegration in this type of stem is an uncommon but serious complication that may necessitate revision surgery. Risk factors predisposing to a failure to osteointegrate are a mismatch between the patient’s proximal femoral geometry and the stem, specifically a large stem in a Dorr type C femur, leading to a diaphyseal rather than a metaphyseal wedge.
Venous thromboembolism (VTE) is a frequent, life-threatening postoperative complication of orthopaedic surgery. Preoperative autologous blood donation has been advocated to reduce the risk of transfusion reactions and to limit potential infectious risk associated with donor blood. Experimental data suggest that autologous leukocytes might lead to immunomodulation similar to the effect attributed to allogenic leukocytes, but autologous whole blood (WB) is often still being used in Japan. We investigated the incidence rate of VTE and plasma D-dimer levels of the autologous WB transfusion and compared the findings with autologous red cell concentrates (RCC) and fresh frozen plasma (FFP) with regard to the cases of lower extremity arthroplasty.
The subjects of this study were 138 patients with lower extremity arthroplasty who were scheduled to receive surgery. The operations included 72 total hip arthroplasties (THA) and 66 total knee arthroplasties (TKA). Postoperatively, plasma D-dimer levels were measured latex agglutination turbidimetric immunoassay. Ultrasonography and contrast-enhanced helical computed tomography was used for diagnosing VTE.
There was no statistically significant difference in the post-surgery incidence rate of VTE between the autologous WB group (THA:20.0%, TKA: 27.9%) and autologous RCC/FFP group (THA: 11.9%, TKA: 30.4%). On the first post-surgery day, the plasma D-dimer levels were significantly higher in autologous WB group (THA: 8.1±9.5 μg/ml, TKA: 12.1±15.9 μg/ml) compared to the autologous RCC/FFP group (THA: 4.2±2.9 μg/ml, TKA:8.0±6.6 μg/ml). However, the plasma D-dimer levels were almost the same in both groups on the 14th day from the surgery. The results of this study suggest that donation and transfusion of autologous WB do not negatively influence the post operative VTE compared with autologous RCC/FFP. However, we must cautiously assess the plasma D-dimer levels of the autologous WB group on the first post-surgery day because of the high propensity of showing false positive rate compared to the RCC/FFP group.
In the last months of 2007 we started to retrospectively review 60 patients who had undergone Girdlestone resection arthroplasty of the hip between 1994 to 2006.
The most frequent indications for this procedure were sepsis around prosthesis, aseptic loosening, pseudoartrhosis after femoral neck fractures or medical compromised patients who had an high risk of hip reimplantation procedure. The evaluation of patient’s satisfaction ranges a lot in literature and no valid guidelines have been publicated.
All our patients were submitted to limb shortening measurement and functional evaluation according to SF-36 score and Harris Hip Score. There were 20 men and 40 women with an average age of 70 years old (range 96-43 years old on operation time), the mean follow up was 133 months (range 14–167 months). Some patients were lost at the follow-up, the main reason was death for related and unrelated causes (overall mortality of 30%).
The aim of this study was to analyze patient’s satisfaction and functional outcomes after Girdlestone arthroplasty which appears in our experience, despite the limits, a valid surgical option in order to improve hip function, decrease or cancel pain and control infections when implantation or reimplantation is not possible.
Segmental bone defects with complex fractures or chronic infections comprise a very special subset of patients. Modular endoprosthetic reconstruction is an operative solution. Without reconstruction amputation/disarticulation is the likely outcome.
Aim of the study was to analyse preliminary results of modular endoprosthetic reconstruction in nonneoplastic limb salvage.
11 patients(9 – distal femoral replacement, 2 – total femoral replacement) underwent salvage reconstruction between January 2005 and March 2008 for chronic periprosthetic infections(6 – single stage revision; 2 – two stage revision) and complex periprosthetic fractures(3) with segmental bone defects. Microbiological and haematological evidence of infection was confirmed in the infection group and treated with concomitant community based antibiotic therapy as per guidance from specialist team.
The mean age and follow up were 74.2 years and 27.5 months respectively. No intraoperative complications identified. Average post operative mobilisation was with frame at 5 days, 2 sticks at 2 weeks. 1 patient required plastic surgical intervention at index operation. 1 patient had recurrence of infection.
Radiographs at 6, 12 & 24 months showed no changes from immediate post-op. Microbiological and haematological evidence of infection eradication was considered as successful treatment. Knee range of movements averaged full extension to 95 degrees. Oxford knee scores showed maximal improvement in the single stage revision group.
We conclude that salvage endoprosthetic reconstruction has provided an oppourtunity to avoid amputation. A significant improvement in overall range of motion, knee scores, pain relief and stability was achieved in this highly complex subset of patients. Multidisciplinary support from plastic surgeons and specialist microbiologists is essential.
The introduction of porous tantalum metal (Trabecular Metal; Zimmer, Warsaw, IN) for acetabular component fixation in total hip arthroplasty has shown optimum fixation qualities and “gap filling” effect. Recently, trabecular metal was introduced in tibial component for total knee prosthesis, however its effect on the bone mineral density (BMD) was not reported. The purpose of this study was to compare the BMD of proximal part of the tibia between trabecular metal and another cemented tibial component.
31 knees receiving trabecular metal tibial component and 33 knees receiving cemented tibial component (PFC Sigma RP, Depuy, Warsaw, IN) had dual energy x-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) scans at preoperatively and 3 weeks, 3, 6, 12, 18, 24 months post-operatively. To assess peri-prosthetic BMD, three regions of interest (ROI) were measured for each case. They were medial aspect (ROI 1), center aspect (ROI 2) and lateral aspect (ROI 3) of tibia. Average follow up period was 1.8 (range: 1.5 to 2) years. In both groups, BMD in tibia decrease postoperatively. Comparing postoperative decrease of BMD in lateral aspect of tibia (ROI 3) between both groups, it was significantly less in trabecular metal component (−0.09 g/cm2 +/−0.27) than cemented tibial component (−0.31 g/cm2 +/− 0.21) (p=0.0007).
We conclude that trabecular metal tibial component showed a favorable effect on BMD of proximal part of the tibia after total knee arthroplsaty.
Knee prostheses have widely been used for severely damaged knee with osteoarthritis or articular rheumatism. PS type knee prosthesis is one of typical artificial knee joint systems and characterized by possessing the post-cam structure to stabilize the motion of the knee at large flexion angles. Post is a projection placed on the surface of UHMWPE tibial insert, and severe fracture and wear of the post are sometimes reported. It is therefore very important to understand the stress state of the post under real flexion motions in order to prevent such damages. It is also well known that the contact and bearing surfaces of a human knee is subjected to very high force especially during deep knee flexional motion such as squatting, and it is naturally expected that the tibial insert of a knee prosthesis deforms plastically under such high force condition.
In this study, three dimensional dynamic finite element analysis of two types of PS knee prosthesis clinically used worldwide, Stryker’s Scorpio Superflex and NRG, are performed to characterize the plastic deformation behavior due to stress concentration generated in their tibial inserts under deep knee flexion motions. The new system NRG is recognized as a modified version of Superflex. Especially, the shape of the post is tried to be improved in order to reduce stress concentration and mobility. Continuous repeated flexional motion such as flexion-extension-flexion motion is considered in the analysis. Internal rotation of the tibial component and insert with flexional motion is also considered. It is found that severe stress concentration is generated in the post for both models and also in the condylar surfaces, and the stress concentration in Superflex is much higher and wider in NRG. Plastic deformation is therefore observed at these stress concentration points. The relationship between residual stress and plastic deformation in the tibial inserts is then discussed based on the analytical results.
Posterior-cruciate ligament retaining (CR) total knee arthroplasty (TKA) designs have long been used with excellent clinical success, but have shown kinematics that are significantly different from the natural knee. Recently, variations on traditional CR designs have been introduced. The purpose of this study was to compare deep-flexion knee kinematics in patients with two types of CR-TKA: one group received a traditional non-conforming symmetric articular configuration, and one group received a design incorporating a lateral compartment which is fully congruent in extension, but lax in flexion – approximating the function of the anterior cruciate ligament.
In vivo kinematics were analysed using 3D model registration and plain radiographs of kneeling and squatting activities in 20 TKAs in 18 patients with a minimum follow-up of 12 months. Two surgeons worked together placing all components. Ten knees received a traditional CR-TKA (CR Group), and 10 knees received an ACL-substituting TKA (AS Group). CR Group subjects averaged 66.1±7.4 years and were 12.3±0.5 months post-op. AS Group subjects averaged 68.0±5.4 years and were 12.4±0.7 months post-op. True lateral radiographs were taken in 4 positions:
with the patient in a weight-bearing, single-leg stance, kneeling at 90°, kneeling at maximal flexion, and squatting.
Two-way repeated measure ANOVA was conducted to determine if there were effects of design or flexion angle on the AP tibiofemoral contact position. Medial and lateral sides were analyzed separately. The level of significance was set at p< 0.05.
There was no significant difference in the average post-operative Knee Society Clinical/Functional Scores between CR Group (96±2/88±11) and AS Group (94±2/92±9). Clinical ROM was recorded using a handheld goniometer. The clinical pre-operative passive ROM was 113 °±15° (80°–135°) for CR Group and 116°±20° (65°–140°) for AS Group (p=0.75). The clinical post-operative passive ROM was 117°±11° (100°–130°) for CR Group and 127°±13° (115°–160°) for AS Group (p=0.07). During squatting, the implant flexion angle was greater for AS Group (119°±15°: 101°–157°) compared to CR Group (104°±10°: 94°–123°, p=0.02). Tibial external rotation at maximum kneeling and squatting activities were significantly larger in AS Group knees (10.2°±4.8°/9.0°±3.9° versus 16.6°±4.1°/15.8°±4.1°, p=0.00/p=0.00). Average tibiofemoral contact position of the lateral condyle during squatting activity was significantly posterior in AS Group compared to CR Group (−11.2±5.6mm vs. −6.2±3.0mm, p=0.02).
Substitution of the ACL by a lateral compartment which is conforming in extension may provide more natural stability and function with knee arthroplasty. In this comparison of two small groups, knees with the ACL-substituting design exhibited femoral AP translation and rotation closer to the natural knee than did knees receiving a traditional symmetric CR prosthesis. The long-term success of TKA depends not only on kinematics factors, such as those reported here, but also on polyethylene wear and patellar complication. A longer-term clinical study will be required to determine if high flexion activity will lead to increase polyethylene wear or patellar complications.
Posterior stabilized (PS) type knee prosthesis characterized by Post-Cam structure as stabilizer has successfully been used in TKA worldwide, while failure and fracture problems of tibial insert made from polymeric material (UHMNWPE) are still important issues from clinical and mechanical points of view. It is therefore needed to understand the mechanical conditions of the tibial insert under different kinds of TKA motions. The aim of this study is to characterize the mechanical condition of tibial insert under contact between femoral component and tibia insert during flexional motion using dynamic 3-D finite element (FE) method. 3-D FE models of two different kinds of PS type prostheses clinically used were developed and stress analyses were performed from full extension to 135 degree knee flexion. Effects of the different Post-Cam structures on the stress states were investigated, and a guideline towards risk assessment of PS type prosthesis was discussed.
Three-D FE models of Stryker’s PS type knee prostheses, Scorpio Superflex and NRG, were developed base on their CAD data. The tibial post of Scorpio Superflex type knee prosthesis shapes angular, while NRG shapes round. Four nodes tetrahedral elements were used to construct the FE models. Nonlinear spring models were attached to the front and back of the tibial component to express the effect of soft tissues on the movement of real TKA knees. Vertical load and horizontal load were applied to the femoral and tibial components, respectively, to express a deep knee bending (squatting) motion. Flexion motion was introduced by rotation the femoral component from full extension to 135 degree. Internal rotation of 5, 10, 15 degrees were also introduced by rotating the tibial component simultaneously with the flexional motion.
Maximum Mises equivalent stress during knee flexion with 5, 10 and 15 degrees internal rotation of the tibial component of Superflex were much higher than that of NRG, especially at the flexion angle of 120 degree. NRG exhibited stress concentrations on both the Post and condylar surfaces and stress levels were much lower that that of Superflex. The maximum stress in NRG was found to be reduced to about half of Superflex. Mises equivalent stress distribution also showed that flexion with internal rotation generated higher stress concentrations on the condylar surfaces of both prostheses.
The analytical results well demonstrated that the design modification of the tibial insert of NRG effectively reduced the stress concentration with rotated tibial component. The lower stress level in NRG corresponds to the lower reaction force and hence lower resistance to flexional motion than Superflex. This implies that the round post is more suitable for deep flexion than the angular post.
The wear phenomenon of ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE) in knee and hip prostheses is one of the major restriction factors on the longevity of theses implants. Despite quite a number of studies on the wear of UHMWPE, the wear mechanism is not clear yet. In order to minimize the wear of UHMWPE and to improve the longevity of artificial joints, it is necessary to clarify the factors influencing the wear mechanism of UHMWPE. Especially for the artificial knee joint with anatomical design, the contact stresses in the UHMWPE tibial insert are generally higher than the yield stress of the material during normal gait. In addition, the predominant types of wear on reported simulator-tested and retrieved UHMWPE tibial inserts are delamination and pitting. These facts suggest that the fatigue fracture that causes micro-cracks both on and below the surface of the UHMWPE tibial insert and the generation of wear particles as fatigue type are closely related to the repeated plastic deformation. On the metallic femoral components of the retrieved knee prostheses with anatomical design, a number of microscopic scratches caused by various factors were observed. It is thought that microscopic surface asperities caused by this surface damage contribute to increasing and/or accelerating wear of the UHMWPE tibial insert. The primary objective of this study was to investigate the factors influencing the wear mechanism of UHMWPE tibial insert in knee prosthesis.
In this study, macroscopic and microscopic elasto-plastic contact analyses of the UHMWPE tibial insert based on macroscopic and microscopic geometrical measurements from retrieved knee prosthesis were performed using finite element method (FEM) in order to investigate the mechanical state, plastic deformation behavior in the UHMWPE tibial insert and microscopic wear of the polyethylene caused by microscopic surface asperity. For this purpose, the determinative method of the contact position between the femoral component and the UHMWPE tibial insert for the retrieved knee prosthesis was developed. The three-dimensional FEM model of the retrieved knee prosthesis with worn contact surfaces was produced. Three-dimensional microscopic surface profile measurements of damaged surface of a retrieved metallic femoral component by using a laser microscope and reproduction of the femoral component surface by using 3D CAD software were performed in order to produce the 3D FEM models of the microscopic asperity based on actual measurement data.
The analytical findings of this study suggest that maximum plastic strain below the surface is closely related to subsurface crack initiation and delamination of the retrieved UHMWPE tibial insert. The worn surface whose macroscopic geometrical congruity had been improved due to wear after joint replacement showed lower contact stress at the macroscopic level. The aspect ratio, shape ratio and indentation depth of the microscopic asperity have a significant effect on increasing and/or accelerating wear on the UHMWPE. Higher aspect ratios, shape ratios and indentation depths cause higher contact stresses and plastic strains in the UHMWPE. These are therefore significant factors influencing the wear mechanism of UHMWPE.
Comprehensive anthropometric information is essential to avoid patella-related complications after TKA. We compared the anthropometric patellar dimensions of Korean and Western patients. In particular, we determined whether the reestablishment of original patellar thickness, residual bony thickness, and pre- to postoperative deviations between the median ridge position and the component center position influence the clinical and radiographic outcomes of TKAs. We measured anthropometric patellar dimensions in 752 osteoarthritic knees treated with TKA in 466 Korean patients and compared them with those of Western patients reported in the literature. We investigated the effects of postoperative overall thickness deviations, residual bony thickness after bone resection, and postoperative deviations of component center positions from median ridge positions versus clinical and radiographic outcomes evaluated 1 year after surgery. Korean patients undergoing TKA had thinner and smaller patellae than Western patients. We found no associations between pre- to postoperative overall thickness differences and clinical and radiographic outcomes and no differences between knees with a residual bony thickness of 12 mm or more and knees with a residual thickness of less than 12 mm, with the exception of WOMAC pain scores. We found no associations between postoperative deviations of component center position and clinical or radiographic outcomes. Our findings indicate bone resection for patellar resurfacing can be flexible without jeopardizing clinical outcome.
From 1985 metal-on-metal (MOM) designs of resurfacing (RSA) and total hip arthroplasties (THR) have been available over a large diameter range (28–60mm). In-vitro studies indicated satisfactory low wear performance for all designs and diameters tested (wear = 0.1 to 7 mm3). While reports from many centers have been encouraging, some have reported adverse effects. We reviewed clinical and metal ion studies in large diameter retrievals and compared these to 28mm MOM cases. Patients with the latter THR ranged 36–76 years of age and were followed 9–11 years. Main finding in our revisions was osteolysis and pain. The 28mm ball was represented 86% of cases; 71% balls had stripe wear. For liners, 25% had circumferential stripe wear and impingement was evident in 64% cases. Seven cemented stems were recovered with impingement marks; 26 stems were undamaged and therefore not revised. Using the concept of ‘damage modes’ from McKellop, normal wear mode #1 was evident in only 14% of 28mm retrievals whereas incidence of ‘abnormal’ modes #2-4 approached 30% each. Thus the 28mm MOM appeared susceptible to impingement risks with CoCr liners. Summarizing MOM retrievals, damage modes 2–4 were most likely implicated in revisions. The performance of such ‘small diameter’ THRs will be contrasted to our large diameter THR and RSA experience. The questions to be reviewed include, how much of the reported MOM adversity was predictable and how much risk was due to
wear of small diameter MOM, adverse cup positioning and hip instability, cup-stem impingement issues or design conformity issues?
Correct rotational alignment of the femoral prosthesis in total knee arthroplasty is important for correct patella tracking, patellofemoral joint contact forces, varus-valgus positioning in flexion, and the avoidance of anterior femoral notching. But achieving correct femoral rotation can be difficult, and there are reports of highly variable rotational alignment with the use of fixed surgical landmarks to determine femoral rotation. Minimal invasive technics makes it more difficult to identify these surgical landmarks. Computer assisted surgery may increase the accuracy of coronal and sagittal positioning but probably does not increase the accuracy of rotational positioning. We used preoperative MRI to aid us in determining femoral rotation preoperatively and used that information to implant our femoral components and evaluated the results.
We measured the angular difference between the surgical epicondylar axis and the posterior condylar axis of twenty patients preoperatively using MRI images and then used that angle to implant the femoral component. For a second group of twenty patients, computer assisted balanced flexion gap technic (Aesculap. Orthopilot system) was used to determine the rotational alignment of femoral components. CT scans were taken postoperatively and the accuracy of the rotational alignment was analyzed for both groups.
The ranges of error were as follows;
Preoperative MRI Group, 8degrees (3 degrees IR to 5 degrees ER). Gap technic group, 21degrees (11 degrees IR to 10 degrees ER).
If an error of more than 5 degrees from neutral alignment is defined as an outlier, 2 in the pre-operative group and 6 in the GAP method group would fall in the outlier zone.
In conclusion, using preoperative MRI to determine the femoral rotational alignment and then using that information to implant the femoral component could aid in avoiding errors in rotation positioning of the femoral prosthesis. It is a simple and effective method to avoid rotational positioning errors with no learning curve.
Previously orientation of rotation of the femoral component has been set by equal resection of the posterior condyle (Hungerford 1985, Laskin 1989). The anteroposterior axis of the distal femur that was defined by a line through the deepest part of the patellar groove anteriorly and the center of the intercondylar notch posteriorly, was an easy and reliable landmark of the rotational alignment of the femoral component (Whiteside, Arima).
The posterior condylar line (PC line) that connects the posterior condyle of the femur is widely used as a landmark for the cutting of the posterior condyle. Also, 3°external rotation off the posterior femoral condyle has been commonly used as a intraoperative landmark (Laskin1995).
The anatomical and functional axis of the femur has been studied so far (Poilvache.Yoshioka1987). Transepicondylar axis (TEA) as the origin of collateral ligament is valuable axis for the parallel cut of the posterior condyle (Berger, Miller). TEA was found to be a reliable landmark to proper rotation of the femoral component, measuring the angle between the axis and the posterior condylar line to orient the femoral component is very important.
However, intra-operative manual palpation of the TEA was not reproducible because most prominent point was covered with soft tissue (Jenny). It is sometimes difficult to identify the sulcus of the medial epicondyle accurately with palpation even during surgery ().
Therefore, it is crucial to measure and evaluate the TEA as the preoperative planning. The posterior condylar line (PC line) that connects the posterior condyle of the femur is also used for the landmark of the cutting of the posterior condyle. The methods of examining the angle between TEA and PC line are computed tomography (CT) and kneeling view that was simple radiographic technique by Takai et al. Posterior condyle of deformed side makes inaccurate decision of the angle for TEA and PC line because thickness of cartilage and bone are different between medial and lateral condyle. PCA is not applicable in MIS-TKA because it is very difficult to visualize the posterior condyle in the lateral side by the medial approach.
Alternative landmark of the angle between TEA and anterior trochlear line of lateral and medial femoral condyles for the determination of rotational positioning of the femoral component may be considered. We have improved the simple radiographic view of evaluating the TEA and PC line but also anterior trochlear line for the assessment of rotational alignment of the distal femur in TKA. The purpose of this study was to measure these angles and to evaluate the reliabilities in compared with 3D-CT.
Subjects and methods Our new radiograph we describe is the antero-posterior view of looked-up distal femur. The patient lies on the supine position and flexes the knee about 130 degrees as much as possible. X-ray is applied to the knee at the right angle to the front of the skin from 20 degrees bottom (Figure 1).
We pointed out the location of the anterior surface of the condyles, medial epicondyle and lateral epicondyle. We marked the medial and lateral epicondyle of anterior surface of condyles, and posterior condyles as the indivisual reference points in these views. We defined the anterior intercondylar line (trochlear line) as the most axial projections of the medial and lateral femoral condyles. We defined PC line as a line connecting the surfaces of the subarticular cortex of the medial and lateral posterior femoral condyles likewise. We used to obtain clinical TEA that was defined by drawing the most prominent points of the medial and lateral epicondyles. We measured the external rotational angle between PC line and clinical TEA (condylar twist angle), and the internal rotational angle between clinical TEA and trochlear line (Figure 2).
Reproducibility of our radiographic technique We examined the reproducibility of our new radiographical technique by 20 healthy volunteers. They included ? males and ? females and the average age of the patients was # years (# ~ # years). No knees in volunteers showed remarkable deformities. We photographed at the flexion angle from 110 to 140 degrees every 10 degrees, at the incident angle of 20 and 30 degrees.
The anterior trochlear line, PC line and clinical TEA were drawn on the images and measured condylar twist angle and the internal rotation angle between clinical TEA and trochlear line. The differences of their measurements were quantified using paired t-test.
Comparison with our view and reconstruction images of 3-dimensional helical CT system The CT images of 35 knee joints in 28 patients had been taken at full extension of the knee using 512 × 512 pixel matrix, in addition of plain X-ray. From the data of CT images, two different images were acquired such as the composition images and the reconstruction images of 3D.
The composition images were obtained by putting a photograph with slices of every 2 mm on top of one another. The CT slices (Shimazu Co Ltd, Kyoto, Japan) obtained from the proximal edge of the patella to the joint line of the knee. We added anterior surface of condyles, medial epicondyle, lateral epicondyle and posterior condyles on tracing paper every slice in the same place. Then we drawn trochlear line, PC line and clinical TEA, and measured the external rotation angle between PC line and clinical TEA (condylar twist angle) and the internal rotation angle between clinical TEA and trochlear line.
The reconstruction images were obtained by the distal femoral view looked-up from distal aspect and reconstructed with 3-dimensional helical CT system. We have drawn trochlear line, PC line, clinical TEA, and measured the external rotation angle between PC line and clinical TEA (condylar twist angle), and the internal rotation angle between clinical TEA and trochlear line from three methods mentioned above and had compared them. The differences of their measurements were compared with three groups.
This study involved 122 knees in 82 patients including 22 males and 80 females with osteoarthritis of the knee. The average age of the patients was 67.3 years from 37 to 89 years. We classified by Kellgren and Lawrence classification (K-L grade). They consisted of grade 1; 12 knees, grade 2; 37 knees, grade 3; 34 knees, and grade 4; 39 knees. Tibiofemoral angle (TFA) on long-leg radiography at the standing position were ranged from 164°to 197°; mean, 180.2°±6.7°. We examined the correlation between condylar twist angle and gender, TFA, height and weight.
Informed consent
The varus angle was negatively correlated with the CTA (R=−0.30) and positively correlated with the internal rotation angle of trochlear-TEA (R=0.376) (Figure 3).
The external rotation angle between PC line and clinical TEA was 5.3°±2.4° at our view, and 5.5°±2.3° at reconstruction images from 3-dimensional helical CT system. The difference of condylar twist angle between plain X-ray and 3D-CT was shown in Figure 4.
The internal rotation angle between clinical TEA and anterior trochlear line was 5.3°±2.4° at our view, °and 5.7°±2.3° at reconstruction images from 3-dimentional helical CT system. The difference of the internal rotation angle between clinical TEA and anterior trochlear line between plain X-ray and 3D-CT was shown in Figure 5.
Regarding the reproducibility about the flexion angle of the knee and the incident angle, correlation coefficients were ? for the flexion angle of the knee, ? for the incident angle. All cases were within 5° variations of the external rotation angle between PC line and clinical TEA, and 4° variations of the internal rotation angle between clinical TEA and trochlear line, respectively. The case of at 110° flexion and 30° incident angle, however, tends to be more variable than the other cases due to unclear PC line (SD 3.3°; range 3–16°).
Intra-operative palpation of the trans-epicondylar axis involved a mean of 5° intra- and inter-observer variations (Jenny 2004). Some authors reported that CTA was 3.6° ± 2.02, 3.58° in male and 3.62° in female during TKA (Poilvache), however, in CT study
Arima reported that CTA was 5.7°± 1.7, in cadaver study 4.4° in male and 6.4° in female. In our study, there was significant difference in gender of CTA.
There has been only a few reports regarding the angle between the TEA and anterior trochlear line of the lateral and medial femoral condyles (trochleo-epicondylar angle). The line between the most anterior projections of the lateral and medial femoral condyle was called as trochlear line, was measured (Poilvache 1996), trochleo-epicondylar (surgical) angle was 4.95° ± 2.15, 4.4° in male, 5.38° in female during TKA. The mean value of the trochleo-epicondylar angle in CT view was 8.0°± 1.76 of internal rotation in all subjects, 8.8° in male, 7.3° in female, there was significant gender difference (Won). Our developed view is the first method of showing the trochleoepicondylar angle in plain radiography. Our results demonstrated trochleo-epicondylar angle using clinical epicondylar axis was 5.6° ± 2.85 of internal rotation in all subjects, 5.27° in male, 5.77° in female, there was no significant gender difference.
Line drawing of posterior condylar line between medial and lateral condyle in osteoarthritic knee sometimes make error of the angle measurement because thickness of cartilage and wear of subchondral bone is not equal in the both side of the condyle. Our view is the first method that is able to examine both the CTA and trochleo-epicondylar angle simultaneously, simple, need not to use special instrument, and reveal reproducible.
A minimally invasive operative method in TKA is reported to be effective and recommended in primary OA. However, the reference guide of the angle between PCA and TEA is sometimes difficult to set properly with the full contact of both condyles in the limited view of the non-open side, especially MIS TKA.
In contrast, it is easy to set the guide or template properly for the trochlear line angle during the surgery because the anterior trochlear is completely visible. Surgeons should not use only one method of femoral rotational alignment and make appropriate adjustment in TKA (Olcott 2000). Then, we focused on the angle between the anterior trochlear line and TEA,
And we developed the simple method of the radiographic view that is able to evaluate the trochlear line and clinical epicondylar axis as the preoperative surgical planning.
From our data, the trochlear line angle with a landmark of the anterior femoral condyle by our radiographic view was reproducible. Our method may be a possible one for determining the rotational alignment of the femoral component in total knee arthroplasty.
Regarding the study of variability of these angles in several kinds of flexion angle of the knee and
Discussion and conclusion: We improved the simple radiographic view in order to evaluate the TEA and PC line, and also the anterior trochlear line, for assessing the rotational alignment of the distal femur in total knee arthroplasty (TKA). We are able to measure and evaluate both angles and do double-checking the condylar twist angle and trochlear line angle. Our new radiographic technique is easy to measure the condylar twist angle, and the angle between AT line and clinical TEA (trochleo-epicondylar angle), simple and reliable, and may be an alternative method for the assessment of TEA of the femur in TKA as preoperative planning.
We report the results of Oxford unicompartmental knee arthroplasty after short term follow up. Twenty nine knees from 26 patients who had undergone Oxford unicompartmental knee arthroplasty from March 2002 to February 2006 were reviewed. There were 1 male(1 knee) and 25 females(28 knees) and average age was 65.9 years. The preoperative diagnosis was 22 cases of medial osteoarthritis and 7 cases of osteonecrosis of medial femoral condyle.
The postoperative knee society pain and function score, Lysholm score and HSS(Hospital for Special Surgery) score were improved compared with preoperative scores. The AP tibiofemoral angle was improved from varus 2.8° preoperatively to valgus 6.6°. Three cases of medial tibial condyle fracture were occurred and 1 case of overhang of tibial component was observed. Three cases were revised due to component loosening.
Even though high incidence of complication and loosening were observed, the clinical results of Oxford unicompartmental knee arthroplasty were improved in short term follow up. We thought that thorough preparations should be done prior to surgery and there was room for the improvement of femoral component design for the stability against rotational torque such as two pegs on the femoral component.
Clinical outcomes of UKA procedures are sensitive to malalignment of the components, and thus show significant variability in the literature. This study evaluates the early clinical results of a new surgical procedure designed to significantly increase the accuracy and precision of the alignment of the components, and thus increase post-operative functional outcomes.
A new UKA technique has been developed, which combines tactile guided robotic technology with image guided surgery. Three-dimensional planning of the implant positioning is followed by precise resection of the bony surfaces. 223 patients have received a UKA from three clinical sites using this new technology. To date, 14 patients are 1 year and 84 patients are 6 months postoperative. Clinical data from all patients are included in an IRB approved registry.
From 223 UKAs, there have been no revisions and 6 reoperations; 2 for infection, 1 for arthrofibrotic band release, 1 for quad tendon arthrotomy separation, 1 for a femoral fracture at the navigation pin site and 1 for unexplained medial pain. Data for patients one year postoperative showed significant improvements, compared to pre-operative values, in range of motion (p< 0.02), Knee Society Scores (p< 0.0001) and WOMAC scores (p< 0.01), particularly pain (p< 0.01) and stiffness (p< 0.01).
This initial series of robotically guided UKA implantations provided significant improvement in the postoperative function of patients in every functional measurement with no revisions to date. The introduction of new procedures and technologies in medicine is routinely fraught with issues associated with learning curves and unanticipated pitfalls. Because the explicit objectives of this novel technology are to optimize surgical procedures to provide more safe and more reliable outcomes, these favorable results provide the potential for significant improvements in orthopedic surgery.
Successful clinical outcomes following unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) depend on accurate component alignment, which can be difficult to achieve using manual instrumentation. A new technology has been developed using haptic robotics that replaces traditional UKA instrumentation. This study compares the accuracy of UKA component placement with traditional jig-based instrumentation versus robotic guidance.
Forty-four UKAs performed using standard manual instrumentation were compared to 33 performed with a robotically guided implantation system without instrumentation. Each was performed using a minimally invasive surgical approach. The two groups were identical in terms of age (p=0.74), gender (p=0.65) and BMI (p=0.72). The coronal and sagittal alignment of the tibial components were measured on pre- and post-operative AP and lateral radiographs. Postoperative tibial component alignment was compared to the pre-operative plan.
For both techniques, the surgical objective was to match the natural tibial posterior slope. The RMS error of the tibial slope was 3.5° manually compared to 1.4° robotically. In addition, the variance using manual instruments was 2.8 times greater than the robotically guided implantations (p< 0.0001). In the coronal plane, the goal of the manual technique was to implant the tibial component perpendicular to the anatomic tibial axis, while the robotic implantations attempted to match the natural varus of the medial compartment. The average error was 3.3 ± 1.8° more varus using manual instruments compared to 0.1 ± 2.4° when implanted robotically (p< 0.0001).
Tibial component alignment in UKA is significantly more accurate and less variable using robotic guidance compared to manual, jig-based instrumentation. By enhancing component alignment, this novel technique provides a potential method for improving outcomes in UKA patients.
Unicompartmental arthroplasty of the knee (UKA) is technically challenging because the prosthetic devices must function in concert with a mostly normal joint. Malalignment is common, leading to patient dissatisfaction and early failures. However, UKA remains attractive as a temporizing treatment in early disease. Until now, resurfacing UKAs were performed with free-hand techniques. This study is only the second report investigating the use of a tactile guidance system (TGS—essentially, a robotically assisted surgery) for the performance of UKA.
Methods. The first 20 patients who underwent resurfacing using a Mako Surgical Inc. TGS system by a single surgeon were studied. Surgical goals were to place the components to replicate closely the patient’s native bony architecture. The surgical plan was completed on a workstation, and then executed with the TGS system through a mini-arthrotomy. Stelkast, Inc resurfacing components were implanted with methymethacrylate. Intraoperative measurements of component position were obtained. Pre- and postoperative radiographs were also measured for alignment correction, change in angulation of the joint line relative to the femoral and tibial anatomic axes, femoral component alignment relative to the femoral anatomic axis, and change in tibial slope.
Intraoperative measurements showed an average femoral component position of 0.89+3.36 degrees of varus relative to the mechanical axis, with 62.5% being varus and 37.5% being valgus. The average femoral component flexion was 11.1+2.11 degrees, with no outliers (less than 5 degrees; greater than 15 degrees). The tibial component position was 4.60+1.76 degrees of varus, with all components in varus as desired. There was an average of 5.00+2.37 degrees of slope, with 25% outliers (less than 3 or greater than 7 degrees).
Postoperative measurements showed an overall limb alignment correction of 4.29+2.60 degrees, femoral joint line change of only 0.43+0.49 degrees, and an overall component alignment relative to the anatomic axis of 4.54+3.77 degrees of valgus. On the tibial side, the joint line varus was corrected by 3.00+2.04 degrees and the slope was changed by 4.29+3.24 degrees, including 19% outliers (less than 3 degrees, more than 7 degrees). However, 33% of the outliers were outliers preoperatively as well. Interestingly, the bone level after resection on the tibial side averaged 5.36+3.00 degrees of varus, suggesting that component placement must be carefully watched.
Potential benefits of an inlay design of UKA compared to onlay components include less post-operative pain and quicker recovery due to a lower volume of bone removed, in particular preservation of the densely innervated periosteum and medial tibial plateau periphery. This study assesses the clinical consequences of removing less tibial bone in UKA.
Seventy-nine UKA patients from a single surgeon were included in this study, 45 patients receiving a standard onlay UKA and 34 receiving an inlay UKA implanted using a robotically guided system. A radiographic technique was developed to measure the depth of resection of tibial bone stock relative to the initial medial joint line. All patients received the same pain management and rehabilitation protocol and the length of hospital stay was measured.
The average depth of medial tibial plateau resection was significantly less with inlay tibial components (3.7 ± 0.8mm) relative to onlay tibial components (6.5 ± 0.8mm, p< 0.0001). While the average length of hospital stay was the same for both onlay (LOS = 1.0 ± 0.2days) and inlay (LOS = 0.9 ± 0.5days) UKA procedures, a significantly higher percentage of inlay patients went home the day of surgery (18% vs. 2%, p< 0.0001).
The depth of medial tibial plateau resection with a typical fixed bearing onlay UKA design is twice as much as an inlay tibial UKA. This has significant consequences for potentially using only primary components at future conversion to total TKA. Likely due to the less invasive (from a host bone perspective) nature of inlay UKA, a significantly higher percentage of these patients are able to be treated as outpatients.
Achieving precise component alignment of total knee arthroplasty produces good clinical outcome. However, the cutting errors between planed and final bone resection planes during the procedure of total knee arthroplasty were less evaluated. The aim of this study was to evaluate the cutting errors during total knee arthroplasty using the navigation system.
In a prospective series of 60 total knee replacements with image-free navigation system, the planed resection plane and final resection plane in frontal and sagittal planes were evaluated. The cutting errors standard deviations ranged from 1.01° to 1.21° in final frontal femoral and tibia plane and 1.23° in final sagittal femoral and tibia plane. The cutting errors showed only significant difference in the sagittal plane of femoral resection and only 9 cuts (4%) 3 of all plane and the maximal error was 4 in only 2 cases (0.8%).
Our results support to use the navigation system to adjust the cutting block and correct the cutting errors. This would lead to a more precise cut and result in better leg alignment and component orientation than the conventional TKR technique.
Achieving the correct amount of femoral component rotation has become the basic objective of surgical techniques in total knee arthroplasty and this can be done either with a measured resection technique or indirectly by flexion/extension gap equalization technique. We demonstrated the variabilities of the reference axes (PCA, WSL, TEA) when soft tissue tension was managed intraoperatively by navigation system. The mean angle of transepicondylar line, Whiteside’s line, posterior condylar line from the proximal tibia resection plane were 1.29 ± 3.67 (mean ± SD; range 7 to 10.5), 3.90 ± 4.17 (mean ± SD; range 3 to 15.5), −4.03 ± 2.71 (mean ± SD; range 9.5 to 1.0) respectively. Coefficient of variation(CV(%); std/mean × 100) were 283, 106, 67 respectively. Out of the 3 reference axes widely used for femoral component rotation, angles from proximal tibia resection plane to posterior condylar line showed the least range of variance.
The minimal invasive total knee arthroplasty has demonstrated shorter hospital stays, less postoperative blood loss, and less pain associated with these techniques but concerns are raised about inaccurate implant alignment due to limited visibility. The combination of computer assisted arthroplasty and MIS could aid in the improvement of the accuracy of implantation.
This prospective randomized study presents the initial results of the first 25 cases of two different imageless computer-assisted arthroplasty, the Orthopilot(B. Braun-Aesculap, Tuttlingen, Germany) and the Ci navigation system(DePuy, Munich, Germany). The same surgeon performed all TKA procedures using the minimidvastus approach. Coronal and sagittal alignments of the femoral and tibial components were determined using postoperative full length radiographs.
Comparison of the 2 groups demonstrated no difference in postoperative limb alignment, femoral and tibial coronal alignment, and sagittal tibial alignment. The sagittal alignment between the 2 groups showed different results. The Orthopilot group showed a tendency toward flexion of the femoral components, and the Ci navigation group showed a tendency toward extension of the femoral components. The tourniquet time was longer by an average of 16minutes in the Ci navigation group. One complication of femoral fracture through the pin site occurred in the Orthopilot group. Combined CAS and MIS has he advantage in improving the accuracy of component alignment but caution is needed for improving sagittal femoral component alignment.
Computer based navigation system improved the accuracy of limb and component alignment and decreased the incidence of outliers. The majority of previous studies were based on the infrared navigation system. We evaluate the availability and accuracy of the electromagnectic(EM) navigation system in total knee arthroplasty
From July 2006 to January 2007, 40 patients (50 TKAs) with osteoarthritis were participated in this study. AxiEM(Medtronics) was used and Nexgen CR(26 cases), and Nexgen CR flex(24 cases) were used. We analyzed the failure mode of navigation (7 cases), operation time and radiologic results (limb and component alignment)
Total registration time was 4 minutes 45 seconds in average (Range: 3 minutes 45 seconds – 6 minutes 55 seconds). Failures in clinical applications resulted from non-recognition of EM tracker or paddle by metallic interference in 4 cases and from informational changes during surgery by fixation loss or loosening of the tracker in 3 cases. Radiologically, the mechanical axis changed from −11.2±7.21 (Range: −25.8~3.1) to 1.0±1.25(Range: −2.1~4.0) and 1 case of outlier occurred (valgus 4°). Component alignment is measured as followed: 89.3±1.6° of Theta angle, 89.9±1.5° of Beta angle, 1.8±2.5° of Gamma angle, 86.1±2.9 of Delta angle°. There were no complications related to the EM navigation.
The EM navigation system helped to achieve accurate alignment of component and lower leg axis without any complications. It had several advantages such as relatively less invasiveness in fitting small instruments, not disturbing operation field, no interrupted line of sight, portable use, and applicability to any implant. However, metallic interference may be still problematic.
The EM navigation had advantages; less invasiveness, no disturbing operation field, no interrupted line of sight, portable use and applicability to any implants. But metallic interference may be still problematic.
Patient satisfaction is becoming increasingly important as a crucial outcome measure for total knee arthroplasty (TKA). We aimed to determine how well commonly-used clinical outcome scales correlate with patient satisfaction after TKA. In particular, we sought to determine whether patient satisfactions correlate better with absolute postoperative scores or preoperative to 12-month postoperative changes. Patient satisfaction was evaluated using four grades (enthusiastic, satisfied, noncommittal, and disappointed) for 438 replaced knees that were followed for longer than one year. Outcomes scales used AKS, WOMAC and SF-36 scores. Correlation analyses were performed to investigate the relation between patient satisfaction and the 2 different aspects of the outcome scales: postoperative scores evaluated at latest follow-ups and pre- to postoperative changes. The WOMAC function score was most strongly correlated with satisfaction (correlation Coefficient = 0.45). Absolute postoperative scores were better correlated with satisfaction than the pre- to postoperative changes for all scales. This study demonstrates that patient satisfaction correlates better with patient-derived and disease specific scales (WOMAC) than physician-driven (AKS) or generic (SF-36) measures. The present study also shows that absolute postoperative status is more important pre- to postoperative change when determining patient satisfaction.
A randomized, prospective stress arthrometric study was done on 60 knees in 60 patients, using a Telos arthrometer to determine the changes of varus-valgus laxity with time and to evaluate the relationship between laxity and retention of posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) using mobile bearing prostheses.
Thirty knees had PCL -retaining (PCLR) with an average 75 months follow-up (range; 60–106 months) and 30 had PCL-sacrificing (PCLS) prostheses with an average 78 months (range; 60–109 months). In all patients, the preoperative diagnosis was osteoarthritis. The coronal conformity of the PCLR and PCLS designs was similar. All of the TKA procedures were judged clinically successful (Hospital for Special Surgery scores: PCLR 92 ±4 points, PCLS 92 ±3 points). The patients had no clinical complications. Varus-valgus laxity was measured with the knee in extension at 6 months, 1 year, 2 year and 5 year after surgery. The intrasubject error was less than 1 degree.
Laxity with PCLR at 6 months, 1, 2 and 5 years was 3.7, 4.0, 4.1, 4.2 degrees with varus, 3.5, 3.5, 3.5, 3.6 degrees with valgus laxity. Laxity with PCLS was 4.3, 4.3, 4.3, 4.4 degrees with varus, 3.7, 3.4, 3.5, 3.6 degrees with valgus laxity. The changes of the varus and valgus laxity had no significant differences in both PCLR and PCLS groups using a repeated measure ANOVA methods (p> 0.05).
The coronal laxity has proved to be no changes with time for the patients who have clinical good results. The changes of the varus-valgus laxity for long timehad no significant differences in both PCLR and PCLS groups. Therefore, we conclude that the PCL doesn’t affect coronal stability in Extension and that the characteristics of the component geometry may act as a resistance factor. We surgeons should have a new understanding of the importance to obtain the balanced coronal laxity for successful mobile-bearing TKA for long period.
The objective of this study was to compare the results between MCL complete detachment and medial epicondylar osteotomy for severe varus deformity in TKA. We reviewed 8 cases of MCL complete detachment (group I) and 11 cases of medial epicondylar osteotomy (group II) for severe varus deformity (from February 2001 to December 2006). In MCL complete detachment, we performed the reattachment of MCL and putting on the brace. Clinical outcome measures included Knee Society score (KSS), Function scrore (FS), and range of motion (ROM). Radiological outcomes were medial instability as determined by valgus stress radiograph, alignment by whole extremity radiograph. Group I had 4 neutral and 4 varus alignment and group II had 9 neutral, 1 varus and 1 valgus alignment. There were no significant differences in clinical results between both two groups, for KSS (95.1 vs 91.1), FS (82.5 vs 88.2), and ROM (0.6–115° vs 0–118.8°). However, there were significant differences in medial instability compared normal side. Group I had the differences of 4.1 degree at postoperative 3 months and 2.1 degree at final follow-up. Group II had 0.9 degree at postoperative 3 months and 0.4 degree at final follow-up. Medial epicondylar osteotomy for severe varus deformity in TKA could be useful technique for medial stability of the knee regardless of the alignment.
We previously reported no clinical differences in short-term results in 26 patients that underwent fixed-bearing (FB) total knee arthroplasty in one knee followed by a rotating-platform (RP) version of the same implant in the contralateral knee at a later date. This study presents intermediate-term results in this unique cohort and uses optimised MRI for detection of particle disease in both knees.
Patients from the original series were asked to complete questionnaires regarding both knees. In addition, both knees were evaluated with optimised MRI, which has been shown to be useful in evaluating early particle disease and osteolysis before its appearance on radiographs.
Nine patients have been enrolled to date. At an average follow-up of 8.3 years for the FB side and 6.5 years for the RP side, no significant differences were found with respect to knee preference, pain, or overall satisfaction. Seven patients underwent MRI studies of both knees. Two FB knees demonstrated a massive intracapsular burden of particle disease (average 3066 mm3) with reactive synovitis, compared to no obvious particle disease in any RP knees. Osteolysis was seen around the femur in one FB knee and around the patella in two FB knees, compared to only around a single patella in the RP side.
RP knees continue to demonstrate excellent patient satisfaction that is comparable to clinical results of the FB design; however, FB knees demonstrate higher rates of particle disease and early osteolysis on MRI. This is the first study to demonstrate in vivo advantages of RP over FB designs. It is unclear whether this is due to the slightly longer follow-up period for the FB knees or a decreased wear rate in the RP design; these differences may become apparent with longitudinal follow-up.
This study was conducted to investigate the correlation between intra-operative Flexion Balance (IFB) and post-operative Flexion instability in Posterior-Stabilized Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA).
Eighty-three knees (4 males and 79 females, average 74 y/o) with primary TKA (Zimmer NexGen LPS flex fixed-bearing) for varus osteoarthritis in our hospital between January 2006 and December 2007, were included in this study. After bone-cutting independently and balancing manually, Extension Balance (EB) and IFB were measured with seesaw type tensor. Post-operative Flexion Balance (PFB) was evaluated as post-operative instability with Kanekasu’s Epicondylar view at the least more than 6 months postoperatively. Varus inclination (lateral joint opening) was indicated as plus. In addition, pre-operative standing FTA (femorotibial angle), the change of FB (CFB=PFB-IFB) and True Correction Angle (TCA=FTA-174-EB), we had defined, were calculated. The TCA was hypothesized to mean the extent of medial soft tissue release. With these data, the correlation between IFB and PFB, CFB and TCA were analyzed. Of these, furthermore, in the well-balanced knees (IFB ≥ ±2°), same analyses were done. Statistical analysis was performed with StatView software.
Each data (n=83) in all subjects was as follows (Mean ± SD, degrees.); EB: 2.74 ±2.74, IFB: 1.61 ±3.67, PFB: 1.73 ±2.66, CFB: 0.01 ±4.25, FTA: 185.3 ±6.7, TCA: 8.65 ±6.52, respectively. Though there was no correlation between IFB and PFB (r=−0.09, p=0.57), CFB was correlated with TCA (r=0.40, p< 0.01).
Each data in the well-balanced knees (n=43) was as follows, EB: 3.09 ±2.71, IFB: 0.70 ±1.30, PFB: 1.22 ±2.52, CFB: 0.57 ±2.3, FTA: 185.5 ±6.5, TCA: 8.42 ±6.09, respectively. There was a correlation between IFB and PFB (r=0.41, p< 0.01), however, FBC was not correlated with TCA (r=−0.26, p=0.10).
Same rectangular balance has been thought to be one the most important factors to obtain the good postoperative stability in TKA. For correcting alignment of lower extremity, medial or posteromedial release are generally needed to perform mainly in extended knee. Even if well-balanced EB was achieved, IFB does not necessarily prove to be well, rather than sparse. This might be because intra-operative balance was not measured under physiological condition, especially after wide posteromedial release. Soft tissues released for balancing would be repaired and shortened over time, so it seems to be natural that intra-operative balance would change. We have reported that EB was correlated with post-operative instability in the previous congress (ISTA 2006). However, it remains unknown as for FB. Our study demonstrated that CFB increased in accordance with the extent of soft tissue release (TCA), and that IFB was correlated with PFB only in the well balanced knees. This means that the measurement of IFB was not useful for predicting PFB in the imbalanced knees. That’s why we should achieve adequate balance & gap during operation and should recognize that FB was influenced by various factors, not only soft tissues but also rotation and inclination of components. In the future, how to measure IFB, including tensor and measurement condition, should be considered and established to predict knee balancing for good clinical results.
This study was conducted to investigate the cases which were obliged to receive revision surgery within the first 5 years after primary Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA).
The subjects of this study were 15 patients (5 males & 10 females, mean age at revision 72 years) who had undertaken revision surgery within 5 years since 1996. Intervals between primary and revision TKA averaged 29.8 months. Prosthesis used for primary TKA was as follows; 11 Zimmer NexGen LPS-flex fixed bearing, 2 mobile bearing, 2 CR type.
Revised components, cause of revision, JOA score as clinical results and FTA as radiographic evaluation were examined.
Revised parts were as follows;
All components: 2, Both Femoral and Tibial components: 4, only Femoral component: 2, only Tibial component: 5, only patella component: 1, only articular surface: 1.
Stemmed Femoral components were used in 6 out of 8 knees, stemmed Tibial components in 9 out of 11 knees.
The causes of revision were as follows;
infection: 1, loosening: 7, inadequate component position: 4, instability: 2, pain: 1.
JOA scores improved from 45 points to 78 points, and FTA proved to be 176 deg., postoperatively.
Primary TKA remains one of the most successful orthopedic procedures. Survivorship was generally reported over 15 years in the previous article. However, there are some cases in which revision TKA is necessary by some causes. There seems to be various types of causes for revisions, such as loosening, inadequate position, abrasion of components and others. Though loosening of components due to traumatic cause was inevitable, other causes, such as inadequate position of component, imbalanced soft tissues and infection, which depend on our technique, should be cared during and after surgery. From our study, except for 7 (2 trauma, 5 unknown) out of 15 knees, almost half of revision TKA (8 knees) might be due to technical demand. As for surgical techniques, in the case of poor bony quality, we routinely use stemmed components and should try not to impact strongly on setting component to prevent from sinking. In the case of non-traumatic cause, 3 out of 12, though the position of tibial component was acceptable, tibial component sunk because of bony weakness and/or imbalanced soft tissues resulting pain.
Adequate position and balance of components should be achieved during primary TKA. In our department, we are trying to revise and routinely use stemmed components as soon as possible, when loosening of component is confirmed. Metal augmentation, if necessary, is mainly used for bone defect to do early rehabilitation.
We concluded that adequate position of components and soft tissue balance was very important at the time of primary TKA. Clinical results of revision TKA were almost equal to those of primary TKA, however, long term follow-up will be needed.
562 osteoarthritic knees rated as stage 1or more according to Kellgren’s osteoarthritic knee classification were selected randomly and analyzed radiologically. Eighty cases with the height of 155 cm-160 cm, for which a large number of male and female cases are available (34 male cases, 46 female cases) were extracted for analysis. The values measured were significantly larger in male than in female in any region. In order to clarify differences in morphology between the sexes, the ratio between the values measured of various regions was computed. As a result, the value(AP/ML ratio) obtained by dividing the length of medial femoral condyle in anterior-posterior direction and the depth of medial femoral condyle in proximal-distal direction by the width of femur at articular level was 0.87±0.03, 0.56±0.03 in female against 0.81±0.04, 0.52±0.03 in male, respectively. A statistically negative correlation was found between femoral width and AP/ML ratio. The value (AP/ML ratio) obtained by dividing the length of medial tibia condyle in anterior-posterior direction by the width of tibia at articular level was 0.61±0.05 in female against 0.59±0.04 in male. A statistically negative correlation was found between femoral width and AP/ML ratio. That is, the larger the medial-lateral width of the tibia becomes, the smaller becomes the AP/ML ratio. When the differences between the sexes were studied, the values measured of various regions were significantly larger in males than in females even in the group of the same height. Moreover, The AP/ML ratio of the current components does not follow the negative correlation between the width and AP/ML ratio. It was concluded that the size variation of the currently available components should be reconsidered.
Achieving deep flexion of knee after total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is particularly desirable in some Asian and Middle Eastern who have daily or religious customs typically use full knee flexion. After TKA, some patients complained about anterior knee pain during deep knee flexion. We evaluated the efficacy of arthroscopic fat pad resection in a series of patients suffering from anterior knee pain associated with high flexion achievement after TKA.
The efficacy of fat pad resection via arthroscopy for treating anterior knee pain associated with high flexion angle (average = 133.1°) was evaluated in eight knees of eight patients among 207 knees performed between 1996 and 1999. The mean age of patients was 71.1 years when the primary TKA was performed. All implatants were posterior stabilized type (IB-II, Nexgen PS and LPS). The symptom of anterior knee pain during deep knee flexion developed within one year after TKA in all cases. In addition to pain in eight knees, two patients have crepitation as the knee was flexed and extended and three patients had hydrarthrosis. Impingement and fibrosis of fat pad were confirmed, and fibrous structures were removed by arthroscopy.
Before arthroscopy, the symptom obviously subsided after injection of local anesthesia into infrapatellar fat pad. Patellar clunk syndrome is also soft tissue impingement and suprapatellar fibrous nodule becomes entrapped intercondylar notch on the femoral component during knee flexion. On this point, these cases does not cause by patellar clunk syndrome. After fat pad resection, the symptom disappeared, and keeps symptom-free after a mean follow-up of six years five months in all cases. Any complications following fat pad resection, such as patella baja and necrosis, were not experienced.
Those cases achieving higher flexion angle tended to experience severe pain and shorter time interval between TKA and arthroscopic surgery, suggesting impingement of the infrapatellar fat pad is closely related to deep flexion after TKA. These results demonstrate that the anterior knee pain due to repetitive infrapatellar fat pad impingement is one of the complications during deep knee flexion after TKA, and the arthroscopic fat pad resection is useful to relief the anterior knee pain. Because of our experience with patients encountering anterior knee pain, we have begun to remove 70 to 80% of the fat pad during the primary TKA procedure since 1999, and until today, none developed anterior knee pain thought to be associated with fat pad impingement, patellar baja nor patellar necrosis. We suggest that fat pad resection is necessary to prevent the anterior knee pain due to fat pad impingement during deep flexion in TKA.
Constrained condylar knee (CCK) prosthesis offers an implant option for complex revision total knee arthroplasties in which stable varus-valgus constraint as well as rotational control is needed for severe bone defect and ligament insufficiency. The aim of this study was to evaluate the clinical and radiological outcome of CCK prosthesis in revision TKA.
Fify-one revision TKAs performed using CCK prosthesis between Jan. 1998 and Feb. 2006 were performed. The mean follow-up period was 5 years and 3 months (2 to 9 years) and the interval between initial and revision TKA was 8 years (4 months to 21 years). The mean age was 67 years. Range of motion (ROM), knee society (KS) score, hospital for special surgery (HSS) score, complication rate and failure rate was evaluated. The tibiofemoral angle and radiolucent line was also evaluated on plain radiograph.
The mean ROM improved from 81.9° to 102°. The mean KS score improved from 49.3° to 79.7°, and KS function score from 50.3 to 71.0 (P< .001). The mean HSS score improved from 50.7 to 78.7 (P< .001). Tibiofemoral angle improved from valgus 3.1° to valgus 5.6° (P< .001). Radiolucent line more than 2mm was observed around 4 femoral and 4 tibial components. Complications including 1 skin necrosis, 1 tibial tubercle nonunion, 2 infections, 3 periprosthetic fractures and 5 arthrofibrosis were observed. Overall rating was excellent or good in 88% at the last follow up.
Revision TKA using CCK prosthesis showed comparable results with other reports in average 5 years follow-up.
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the clinical and radiological results of the minimal invasive treatment of the supracondylar periprosthetic fracture after total knee arthroplasty using locking condylar plate.
From January 2001 to June 2007, the 9 cases of the periprosthetic supracondylar femoral fracture were included in this study. The average age of the cases was 67 years old (range: 62–73 years old). The average duration of follow-up was 2year 1 months (range: 12–48 months). The implants of the index operation were posterior cruciate substitution implants without stem. According to the classification of Orthopedic Trauma Association, all cases were classified as 33A. All cases were treated using locking condylar plate. The fracture was extended into undersurface of the anterior flange of the femoral component. Locking condylar plate was fixed by the minimal invasive percutaneous technique. The average time of bone union was 5.4 months (range: 4–7 months) without additional bone graft. The average range of motion was 95 degrees and HSS (Hospital for Special surgery) score was 75 points in last follow-up. Femorotibial angle at the last follow-up was average valgus 5 degree.
Minimal invasive percutaneous fixation using locking condylar plate was useful to treat the periprosthetic femoral fracture which was alternative method to retrograde femoral nail.
Arthrodesis is used most commonly as a salvage procedure for failed total knee arthroplasty (TKA). For successful arthrodesis, a stable fusion technique and acceptable limb mechanical alignment are needed. Although the use of intramedullary alignment rods might be helpful in terms of achieving an acceptable limb mechanical axis, fat embolism and intramedullary dissemination of an infection or reactivation of latent infection might occur in failed TKA cases. However, computer-assisted surgery allows precise cuts to be made without breaching medullary cavities. Here, the authors describe a case of knee arthrodesis performed by computer navigation and the Ilizarov method in a patient with a past history of infection. A 45-year-old man visited our hospital with failed total knee arthroplasy. Fortunately, even though infection was treated by debridement with component retention, mild heating was present over the knee, but ESR(erythrocyte sedimentation rate) and CRP(C-reactive protein) were within normal ranges. X-ray showed subsidence of the femoral component and a radiolucent line around the femoral component. Arthrodesis was planned for this patient due to disabling pain, a long-lasting severe functional deficit, failure of the primary TKA for ankylosed knee, and the patient’s poor economic status and his strong desire for arthrodesis. The computer navigation surgery system and the Ilizarov method were used for two reasons. The first reason was that the patient had a past history of infection. At pre-operative evaluation, even though ESR and CRP levels were within normal range, we could not completely rule out the possibility of latent infection due to suspicious findings such as long lasting disabling knee pain, mild heating over the knee, severe osteolytic radiographic changes around the femoral component. In that situation, inserting an IM rod to achieve acceptable mechanical alignment might have reactivated and disseminated a possible latent infection to the femoral or tibial medullary canals. The second reason was that we wanted to reduce the possibility of fat embolism by using computer navigation without instrumentation within the medullary canal. A CT-free, wireless computer navigation system was applied, with trackers fixed to the femur and tibia and no requirement for the use of an IM rod with component retention. Navigated femoral and tibial bone resections were then performed using Stryker software. The femoral resection was conducted at 0° of flexion to the sagittal axis, and the tibial resection at 7 ° of flexion to the sagittal axis. Arthrodesis was held in proper axial and rotational alignment with bone surfaces compressed together. Finally, knee arthrodesis was completed using the Ilizarov method. Based on our experience of the described case, we believe that arthrodesis for failed TKR, especially failure secondary to intraarticular infection, can be considered as another indication for computer navigation.
To assess the clinical comparison of closed suction drainage group and non drainage group after simultaneous total knee atrhroplasty. We analyzed the thigh circumference, ecchymosis, wound infection, transfusion amount, knee score and range of motion in 140cases (70patients) done with PFC or PFC-sigma model between 1998 and 2005. 100 cases of them(group )were inserted hemovac and the others (group )were not inserted hemovac. The average thigh circumference in group was 43.8cm (preoperative), and 47.3cm(postoperative), in group was 43.2cm (preoperative) and 47.9cm (postoperative). The knees that had no drains had a higher incidence of ecchymosis. However, the final result of knee score and range of motion of knee joint were not affected significantly by nonuse of closed suction drainage. There were no infection sign in both groups.
The clinical comparison of closed suction drainage group and non drainage group after simultaneous bilateral total knee arthroplasty was not significantly different in wound healing, clinical and rehabilitation course. The use of suction drainage must be carefully selected after primary total knee arthroplasty.
A 55-year-old woman who was diagnosed as RA (stage, class ) in 1995 had undergone right total elbow arthroplasty (TEA) in October 2006. We implanted her prosthesis FINE ELBOW® (Nakashima Medical, Japan). Prosthesis of the humerus side is made of Co-Cr-Mo, and the ulna side is of polyethylene. Radius side is metal back system which inserts a polyethylene joint part in metal holder made by Co-Cr-Mo. All components were fixed by cement. She complained her right elbow uncomfortable gradually from January 2008. X-ray radiograph showed loosening of the ulnar component.
So we performed revision surgery using ulnar revision sack in May 2008. This ulnar component had only a product made in polyethylene and we inserted the component of the product made in the polyethylene in a metal sack. The operation was successed and now she does housework.
We think that strength is not worthy of the ulnar component made by polyethylene in TEA for the patient with terrible joint destruction and high daily activity patient of rheumatoid arthritis.
“Karayahesive” is a viscoelastic film made of Karaya gum. The Karaya gum includes some polysaccarides and is exted from Karaya gum tree (Sterculia urens). It applies “Moist Wound Healing Mechanism” which has been proposed by plastic surgeons. According to this mechanism, the spontaneous wound cure can be promoted by preventing wound becoming dry, keeping a wet environment around wound, and reducing the inhibitors against wound healing. It was originally developed as a wound dressing material to use after the ordinal skin closure. We remarked its strong adhesiveness, as a modification, we use it as an alternate for epidermal suture. Since June 2006, we have been using it for 183 knees. Among them, in this study, we evaluated 158 knees in 183 (18 male, 165 female) patients with minimum of two months follow-up. The diagnosis at the surgery was osteoarthritis for 137 knees, rheumatoid arthritis for 20 knees, and aseptic necrosis of the femoral condyle for one knee. The average age at the surgery was 70.8 (40 to 84). The average of follow-up was 8.5 (two to 21) months. In all knees we used a parapatellar medial approach. Without any epidermal suture, the wound was closed by attaching Karayahesive. Before attaching Karayahesive, we made the ordinal subcutaneous suture just like as the conventional skin closure. We wipe off the blood to dry the skin. Without any epidermal suture, we attached Karayahesive to reduce the wound tension. After attaching it, we made the ordinal gauze dressing and compression bandage. No dressing change was necessary until the removal. Karayahesive was removed two weeks after the surgery, together with clot and overlaying dressings. After the removal, most patients require no additional dressing and could go into bathtub on the same day. The excellent primary wound healing was obtained in 152 knees. In six knees, the wound disrupted. However, re-attach of “Karayahesive” provided early healing of the disrupted wound successfully. Comparing the ordinal epidermal suture, the patients complained less pain at the removal and irritation after the surgery, and Karayahesive provided better wound healing. It saved time and labor as no epidermal suture and no dressing change were necessary. It saved cost of the medical waste. On the other hand, it was difficult to observe the wound; as it was concealed by clot. We had to be very careful not to miss early symptom of the infection. In conclusion, for the knee arthroplasty Karayahesive was not only very useful wound closure material but also the excellent alternate for the epidermal suture.
There was used cement in first generation total ankle arthroplasty, but first generation of ankle arthroplasty was abandoned because of aseptic loosening of component. For the treatment of aseptic loosening of ankle arthroplasty, there had been many methods. One of methods of revisional ankle arthroplasty is the ankle arthodesis. The authors report a case of revisional ankle arthroplasty using allograft with hybrid external fixation.
45 year old male had surgery of cemented total ankle arthroplasty on his right ankle 20 years ago. He went to our clinics because of motionless and pain of his right ankle. He got the mild pain on his right ankle after 5 years surgery. His pain was managed by oral NSAIDS for 15 years. The pain was aggravated recently. There were osteophytes on posterior aspect of ankle joint and radiolucency around the implant, subtalar arthrosis at the radiograph. There was also sclerosis around the ankle joint.
The authors decided revisional surgery. At the operative findings, we can see the loosening of talar and tibial component and large posterior osteophyte bridging between remained talus and tibial bone. There were no infection signs. After remove the implant, there was big space remained. For the regaining the limb length, we used femoral head allograft. The graft was fixed with 6.5 mm cannulated screws and addition fixed with ilizarov external fixation. Also additional auto bone graft from the osteophytes was applied. Compression over the ilizarov external fixation was done at the end of the operation. Weight bearing was allowed immediate after surgery. Ilizarov ring was removed 6 weeks after surgery. At the 3 months after surgery, bony union was obtained on radiographs.
AOFAS score was improved from 30 to 70 6 mo after surgery. There was no pain on his right ankle. Patient satisfied with arthrodesis with allograft at final follow-up.
Primary total knee arthroplasty is associated with considerable blood loss, and allergenic blood transfusions are frequently necessary. Because of the cost and risks of allogenic blood transfusions, the autologous drainage blood reinfusion technique has been developed as an alternative. A number of studies have compared reinfusion techniques with standard suction drainage, but few reports compared with no drain use. We analyzed early results after primary total knee arthroplasty using autologous drainage blood reinfusion and no drain.
We selected 30 patients who underwent primary total knee arthroplasty using no drain between November 2005 and March 2006 and matched for age and gender with 30 patients who underwent primary total knee arthroplasty using autologous drainage blood reinfusion technique between January 2003 and October 2005. All operations were done under pneumatic tourniquet and meticulous hemostasis was performed after deflation of the tourniquet. We have retrospectively reviewed the preoperative data (age, gender, body mass index, diagnosis, history of the knee surgery, infection and anticoagulant therapy, and medical cormorbidities) and the postoperative data (hemoglobin, hematocrit and platelet during hospitalization, the amount of allogenic blood transfusion and narcotics, complications, rehabilitation process, and clinical scores).
All preoperative and postoperative variables except the postoperative second and seventh days hemoglobin and 2nd day hematocrit showed no significant differences between two groups. The hemoglobin and hematocrit also showed no significant differences at the postoperative fourteenth day.
The autologous drainage blood reinfusion method in primary total knee arthroplasty does not have significant clinical benefit over no-drain method with regards to allogenic blood transfusions, narcotics uses, the incidence of complications and rehabilitation processes.
To date nine cases treated by cementless total ankle arthroplasty for avascular necrosis of the talar body have been described in the English literature. However, these reports show high complication rates including collapse of the talar component, and as a result cementless total ankle replacement is not recommended for the treatment of avascular necrosis of the talar body. The authors report two cases of ankle osteoarthritis with avascular necrosis of the talar body that were treated by cementless mobile bearing total ankle arthroplasty, because preoperative magnetic resonance images and radionuclide bone scanning showed revascularization of the talus. Recent follow-up plain radiographs of ankles showed no loosening or subsidence. The authors conclude that cementless total ankle arthroplasty for the treatment of avascular necrosis of the talar body is likely to be successful if necrotic bone has healed by creeping substitution and has enough strength to support an implant.
The total disc replacement (TDR) devices are gaining popularity because of their capability of allowing joint motion at the index level. Studies have shown that motion preservation can reduce the likelihood of further degeneration at the adjacent level with better surgical outcome. Current lumbar TDR devices require an anterior approach for implantation. However, it is known that its clinical outcome may depend on implant insertion and placement during surgery. Only limited number of biomechanical studies regarding the effect of placement orientation on the clinical outcome is currently available. The purpose of this study was to investigate effects of various surgical placement of a lumbar TDR on the kinematics and load-sharing characteristics using finite element method (FEM).
A previously-validated 3-D nonlinear FE model of the intact lumbar motion segment (L3-S1) based on computer tomography (CT) images of a cadaveric specimen (male, age 56, no pathologies) was used as the baseline FE model. Then, implantation of ProDisc-L (Spine Solutions, Inc., Synthes, Paoli, PA, USA) was simulated into the L4–L5 disc space through anterior approach with removal of the nucleus, anterior longitudinal ligament, and the anterior part of the annulus. The location of lumbar TDR was varied in the sagittal and the coronal planes. In the sagittal plane, the implants were placed anteriorly at 3-mm (S-3), 5-mm (S-5), and 7-mm (S-7) offset from the posterior margin of the endplate. In the coronal plane, the devices were shifted from the baseline position laterally to the right by 1-mm (C-1), 2-mm (C-2), and 3-mm (C-3) from the mid-sagittal line along the lower endplate. All of the models were subject to 150N compressive pre-load and flexion/extension moments of 10Nm at the superior endplate L4, while the inferior endplate of L5 was fully constrained. Changes in motion (ROM) and facet loads at the index and adjacent levels were assessed at different implant position.
Results showed that deviation from the central placement (from S-3 to S-7 and from C-1 to C-3) decreases ROM while increasing facet load at the index level. The effect was more pronounced in the sagittal plane than in the coronal plane:10% decrease in ROM and 1% increase in facet load in the sagittal plane vs. no significant change in the coronal plane. As expected, changes were more evident during extension than in flexion. While the kinematics of the spine was restored to the pre-operative stage at the index level (L4-5), the ROM decreased at the adjacent level (L5-S1) in a compensating manner. The overloading of the facet seemed to indicate mal-alignment of the implant can further trigger facet degeneration, which may require unwanted revision or additional surgical treatment.
The purpose of this study is to compare the two prosthesis which were used for total ankle arthroplasty. From Sept. 2003 to Jun 2007, 13 patients and 14 ankles that could be follow up more than 2 years. Semiconstrained type (Group I, 7cases) and Unconstrained type (Group II, 7cases) were used for total ankle arthroplasty. Mean age was 63.2 year-old, 12 ankles are men and 2 ankles were women. Mean follow up periods were 31.1 months. The criteria to compare the clinical result were postoperative range of motion (ROM), AOFAS foot score and residual bone stock of medial malleolus.
Postoperative ROM of group I was 37.5±7.1 degree and of group II was 51.4±8.9. Postoperative AOFAS score of group I was 76.1±13.8 and of group II was 86.0±5.7. Residual bone stock in medial malleolus of group I was 6.1mm±0.7 and of group II was 11.5mm±0.9. Total number of complication in our study was 9 cases. 3 cases were a malleolar fracture, two occurred at intra-operation, the other at follow-up period. Re-operation was done in 6 cases, 3 cases were calcaneal corrective osteotomy, 2 cases were resection of a heterotopic bone and one case was pedicular flap operation for skin problem.
In our hospital, mobile bearing type prosthesis showed good result than a semiconstrained type in respect of ROM improvement and of residual bone stock in medial malleolus. AOFAS score between two groups showed no definite difference. But small number of patients and short term follow up period is a defect in our study, afterward more population and long term follow up period are needed.
To evaluate this design, a finite element model (Solidworks, Cosmos, Concord, MA) was employed on a 12° lordosed, 18mm distraction height device under a compressive load of 2745N. This represents the least stable condition as the lordosis angle and height are at the maximum values clinically appropriate. Static and dynamic mechanical testing were performed. Static testing consisted of applying at compressive load at 25mm/min (858 Mini Bionix, MTS, Eden Prairie, MN) until failure of the device or a maximum load of 7000N was sustained. Maximum load, device stiffness and overall deformation were extracted from the load versus deflection data.
Dynamic testing (ELF 3300, Bose, Minnetonka, MN) involved sinusoidal loading from −50N to −300N at a rate of 60Hz. This load represents the approximate mass of the torso. The device was cycled for 5 million cycles with load and displacement data acquired at 250,000 cycle intervals at a rate of 500Hz. Net deflection was computed at 250,000 cycle intervals while compressive stiffness was computed at 500,000 cycle intervals. Non-linear regression analyses were performed for both deflection and stiffness versus cycle number in order to elucidate the behavior of the device.
These results confirm that this novel design can enhance the likelihood for osseointegration by maintaining the micromotion levels below the reported critical value of 75μm.[
Even though spinal fusion has been used as one of the common surgical techniques for degenerative lumbar pathologies, high stiffness in the fusion segment could generate clinical complications in the adjacent spinal segment. To avoid these limitations of fusion, the artificial discs have recently used to preserve the motion of the treated segment in lumbar spine surgery. However, there have been lacks of biomechanical information of the artificial discs to explain current clinical controversies such as long-term results of implant wear and excessive facet contact forces. In this study, we investigated the biomechanical performance for three artificial discs in the lumbar spinal segments by finite element analysis.
A three-dimensional finite element model of five spinal motion segments, from L1 to S, in intact lumbar spine was reconstructed from CT images. Finite element models of three artificial discs, semi-constrained and metal on polyethylene core type (ProDisc® II, Spine Solutions Inc., USA; Type I), semi-constrained and metal on metal type (MaverickTM, Medtronic Sofamor Danek Inc., USA; Type II), and un-constrained and metal on polyethylene core type (SB ChariteTM III, Dupuy Spine Inc., Switzerland; Type III) were developed. Each artificial disc was inserted at L4–L5 segment, respectively. Upper and lower plates of artificial discs were attached on the L4 and L5 vertebrae. Some parts of ligaments and intervertebral disc in L4–L5 motion segment were removed to insert artificial discs. Nonlinear contact conditions were applied on facet joints in lumbar spine model and artificial discs. Bottom of sacrum was fixed on the ground and 5Nm of flexion and extension moments were applied on the superior plate of L1 with 400N of compressive load along follower load direction.
In extension, all three artificial disc models showed higher rotation ratio at the surgical levels, but lower rotations at the adjacent levels than those in the intact model. There was no big difference of the intersegmental rotations among the artificial disc models. For the comparison of the peak von-Mises stresses on the polyethylene core in flexion, 52.3 MPa in type I implant was higher than 20.1 MPa in Type III implant while the peak von-Mises stresses were similar, 25.3 MPa and 26.5 MPa in Type I and III, respectively in extension. The facet contact forces at the surgical level for the artificial disc models showed 140 to 160 N in extension whereas the facet contact force in the intact model was 60 N.
From the results of this study, we could investigate the biomechanical characteristics of three different artificial disc models. The relative rotation at the surgical level would be increases at the early outcome after total disk replacement. The semi-constrained type artificial disc could generate higher wear risk of the implant than unconstrained type. Also all types of artificial disc model have higher risk of facet joint arthrosis, and especially in the semi-constrained and metal on metal type. The results of the present study suggested that more careful care must be taken to choose surgical technique of total disc replacement surgery.
A total number of 428 patients underwent surgical procedure due to different acquired spinal disorders. Conservative approaches were tried where it was indicated. When there was no improvement with conservative treatment then surgical procedures were adopted
It was a prospective study which was done in both Govt. and private hospitals irrespective of age & sex. Total period was from August 2002 to February, 2008. Age of the patients ranged between from 8–65 years. In this series male was more dominant than female. In this series main causes were traumatic, infective, degenerative & neoplastic disorders. Prolapsed Lumber Inter-vertibral Disc 202, prolapse cervical disc 15, unstable spinal injuries 86, Pott’s paraplegia 68, degenerative disc disease 18, spondilolisthesis 12 and neoplastic both primary & secondary were 9 cases. Fenestration & disectomy done in PLID and decompression and stabilization done in unstable spinal injuries. Instrumentation done as adjuvant to achieve early biological union of bone. In Pott’s disease when conservative treatment failed to improve, decompression and stabilization was done by thoracotomy specially in at thoraco-lumber tuberculosis. Clowards operation done in cervical disc prolapse & spinal canal stenosis. Laminectomy done in lumber spinal canal stenosis. In spondilolisthesis, laminectomy followed by stabilization done by bilateral pedicular screw fixation with or without inter-body bony fusion.
Excellent and satisfactory results were achieved in incomplete unstable injuries. No neurological improvement detected in complete injuries. Maximum Pott’s paraplegia regained their neurological function and bowel bladder dysfunction except one who recovered her one limb function full but other limb become spastic. In PLID maximum patients improved immediately after surgery. Few patients required physiotherapy after surgery and improved later on. In Spondilolisthesis patients became symptoms free after decompression and in situ fusion by instrumentation.
In complete spinal injuries no improvements were detected. Breaking of pedicular screws observed in two cases. Mal-position of screws in 5 cases observed in traumatic spinal injuries. Post operative discitis developed in 2 cases after PLID operation 2 cases required surgery second time due to recurrent PLID.
Proper selection of cases is very important in spinal disorders. In incomplete spinal injuries satisfactory results can be achieved in maximum cases but in complete spinal injuries no neurological development are achieved but for early mobilization surgery is helpful. Maximum spinal disorders can be managed conservatively but surgical intervention should be done in earliest possible time when indicated.
The treatment of rotator cuff arthropathy due to irreparable massive rotator cuff tear is still challenging. We performed reverse total shoulder arthroplasties for 2 cases of cuff tear arthropathy. The short term follow-up after the surgery reveal excellent results by ASES and UCLA score. However, these results still require long term follow-up and the study about implant design for the shoulder anatomy of the Koreans.
Intra-medullarly nail techniques for fracture fixation has gained Universal acceptance over the past 50 years. Closed interlocking nail fixation is the procedure of choice for femoral shaft fracture specially in poly trauma. Unlocked Nail can be considered when a non comminuted fracture occurs through the narrowest part of the medullarly canal. Unlocked Nail does not resist axial and rotational deformation of the fracture. Interlocking fixation controls bending and rotational deformation but allows nearly full axial load transfer by bone. Interlocking nails can be used in almost all long bones.
A total of 67 cases were stabilized by intra-medullarly interlocking nails. It was a prospective study done in SSMC & Private hospital from the period of January 2004 to February 2008. Total period of follow up was about 4 years. Both male & female were included in this series. Fresh, delayed fracture & Non Union all were included. Maximum cases were closed fracture but few were fresh but open fracture. Simple unstable fracture comminuted segmental fracture, implant failure was the selection criteria. Fracture, tibia femur and humerus were selected for this study. Both closed and open techniques were applied in this series without any support from C-arm.
In maximum cases bony union was achieved in expected time. In few cases healing process was delayed due to extensive soft tissue damage during the occurrence of fracture and non-cooperation of patients during post operative period. Excellent results were achieved in fresh cases. Over all result of this series is very satisfactory.
Breaking of screws was in 2 cases, bending of nail was in one case due to early weight bearing. Revision of surgery done in 2 cases.
Intra Modularly interlocking nail fixation is very simple device for unstable comminuted and segmental fracture shaft of long bones. If C-arm is available in that case procedure becomes more simple and easy. But without C-arm sometimes surgery becomes very lengthy and in that case expected results may not be achieved.
Modern metal-on-metal bearings were reintroduced on the market by Prof. B.G. Weber in 1988. Since this date, more than 500,000 bearings have been implanted world-wide with excellent clinical results.
The goals of this presentation are to review critically the long-term published clinical results for metal-on-metal bearings (small and large diameter) and to investigate the current concerns (ions release, allergic reactions, pseudo-tumours…) about metal-on-metal bearings. Based on this review, the benefice-risk ratio of metal-on-metal bearings will be discussed.
FDA approval of metal-on-metal (MOM: 28, 32mm) bearings has provided 10 years of clinical experiences in USA. However there has been no detailed mapping of wear phenomena in retrieval cases. We present an analysis of 28 cases, MOM retrievals with 1 to 10 years follow-up, radiographic reviews and metal ion studies. Ball diameters ranged from 28mm to 42mm. Two balls were the early design with skirts. Main indicators for revision were the progressive radiographic changes indicative of osteolysis, with associated hip pain. Approximately 54% of patients were males and ages ranged from 36 to 76 years of age. Only 7 femoral stems were recovered but all had impingement marks. Only three cases lacked any evidence of stripe wear and these were in very elderly patients. Approximately 85% of these cases showed some evidence of stripe wear and multiple stripes were clearly visible on 50% of the femoral balls. The medial ball stripes were twice as common as lateral. Stripe wear was identified in 25% of CoCr liners.
In the hip simulator studies generally show ‘run-in’ wear rates of 1–7mm3 per million cycles (Mc). We noted that above the 5mm3/Mc threshold, the serum generally appeared black. In contrast, the ‘steady-state’ wear rates of 0.1–1.6 mm3/Mc showed the true potential of MOM bearings. However there were often examples of higher wear (7–20 mm3/Mc), which gave confounding trends in published studies. Our studies of metal ions in the simulator lubricant provided a very accurate representation of MOM wear.
There are many limitations in comparing in-vitro to in-vivo wear performance. Our retrieval data are biased to cases that failed due to hip pain, had radiographic signs of progressive osteolysis and some showed high levels of metal ions. There was also the bias of having predominantly a CoCr sandwich design (polyethylene adaptor). Use of the small ball added the well-known risks of impingement, subluxation and dislocation with rigid cups. Using the ‘damage modes’ from McKellop, we found only normal Mode-1 wear to be rare in these cases, whereas Modes# 2–4 had an incidence approaching 30% each. Signs of impingement were evident in 85% of our cases. Thus summarizing these MOM wear phenomena in retrieved 28mm sandwich cups, the evidence implicated impingement and 3rd-body wear modes (#2–4) as the clinical risk for adverse wear effects at 10 years follow-up. The in-vitro wear studies have not yet simulated such adverse clinical effects.
In a personal series of over 560 hip resurfacing operations performed since 1995, 35 hips have required revision operations.
Only one has been for infection, a single stage revision was performed at 33 months following primary implantation, and the revised hip is still functioning well over 7 years later.
There have been five femoral neck fractures, all became symptomatic within 100 days of surgery. The first four were revised to cemented stems with large modular heads, the fifth was revised to an uncemented stem with large head. The first of these patients developed aseptic loosening at the bone/cement interface, and was revised at 18 months to a cemented Exeter stem with ceramic head and uncemented socket with plastic liner. At 8 years, the hip continues to function well clinically with no radiological signs of loosening.
The remaining four patients have all had satisfactory results at a mean follow up of 69.3 months (range 52 – 96 months)
Ten hips have required revision operations for femoral head loosening or collapse. The mean time after initial surgery was 54.6 months (range 23 – 107 months). In every case, the original socket was preserved and a stem with large modular head was used. The first two were using cemented stem and are still functioning well at 52 and 69 months. The next was with a Trifit uncemented stem, and remains satisfactory at 36 months. The remaining five have all been revised with a Plus Orthopaedics Zweymuller stem. The mean follow up is 13.8 months (range 5 – 33 months) and all are currently satisfactory.
There have been 18 sockets which required revision operations for loosening. The three earliest of these underwent revision surgery at 16, 17 and 27 months, and probably represent sockets which were inadequately seated at the time of implantation and failed to osseointegrate. This is evident on the initial post op radiographs in two patients. The third patient had unexplained discomfort in the hip from the outset, and eventually the hip was explored; at operation the socket was found to be loose after the hip had been opened and the head excised. Only one other patient required the head to be removed; the bone loss in the socket around the loose acetabular socket required revision with a larger socket than would allow the head to be preserved.
There was a cluster of five sockets which were revised between 50 and 57 months, the remaining five sockets were revised between 78 and 98 months. The timing of these failures suggests different modes of failure.
One patient had a revision with a dysplasia socket but no graft and 12 months later had clinical and radiological signs of loosening, but the symptoms settled before surgery was performed.
One patient developed a post operative infection and the implants were removed.
The remaining patients have a mean follow up of 36.5 months (range 8 – 61 months), with no signs of failure of the revised socket or the original femoral component.
Combined techniques of fracture mechanics and confocal Raman microprobe spectroscopy were applied to characterize, after increasing periods of environmental exposure, bulk and surface toughness values in an advanced alumina/zirconia composite. This material is used in joint prostheses (BIOLOX® delta femoral heads, manufactured by CeramTec AG). Besides conventional fracture mechanics characterizations, including different types of fracture toughness test, Raman and fluorescence microprobe spectroscopy provided a microscopic insight into the effect of environmentally assisted processes of zirconia phase transformation at the surface on the fracture toughness of the material. We have found that the tetragonal-to-monoclinic polymorphic transformation occurs in the studied composite material as a consequence of an environmentally assisted process, although severe exposures are needed for to obtain a substantial increase of the monoclinic content. Such severe exposures in vitro correspond to exposures in human body of several lifetimes. The effect of an exposure of 10 h in autoclave (in vitro accelerated test) was carefully examined, because this span of time corresponds:
to the period of time recommended for testing in vitro by ISO standard; and, to approximately the lifetime expected for a prosthesis in vivo.
The main experimental outcomes of confocal Raman spectroscopy and fracture mechanics assessments can be summarized as follows:
the crack-tip toughness level measured in the as-received material was comprehensive of a tangible contribution by transformation toughening, thus showing that phase transformation in the zirconia dispersoids plays a positive role in the toughening behavior of the material; after the material was environmentally aged in vitro for periods of the order of hundreds of hours, its surface toughness was reduced by about one-third; but, even in the case of such a severe exposure, the surface toughness of the composite was at least the same as that of monolithic alumina; the observed decrease of fracture toughness by about one-third was limited to the very surface of the material (i.e., to a layer of the order of the tens of microns) and did not affect the bulk fracture behavior of the composite.
It appears that concerns arising from the brittleness of alumina-based materials and, thus, from their vulnerability to fracture due to unexpected load situation, can be successfully counteracted by properly adding a dispersion of zirconia particles to the alumina matrix. Such an addition enables the obtainment of a composite material, whose fracture resistance is greatly enhanced by a crack-shielding effect due to phase-transformation processes occurring in the zirconia dispersoids.
Traditional total hip arthroplasty (THA) using metal-on-polyethylene bearings has been established as a reliable procedure but wear and wear debris-associated osteolysis are among the most frequent reasons for revision. Ceramic-ceramic bearings represent an alternative for THA with improved wear characteristics and low biological reactivity of wear particles. We investigated the clinical outcome of alumina ceramic-ceramic THA in a series of more than 400 THAs.
A total 418 alumina ceramic-ceramic THAs performed in 360 patients treated between 1997 and 2007 were studied prospectively. All patients had an uncemented titanium acetabular component with a flush mounted alumina ceramic-ceramic bearing (Wright Medical Technology, Inc. and Ceramtec AG). The mean age at operation was 51.7 ± 12.3 years (range, 18 – 79 years). 47 cases (11%) had previous hip surgery. The indication for surgery included primary osteoarthritis or impingement (58%), developmental dysplasia of the hip (32%), osteonecrosis of the femoral head (5%), post-traumatic osteoarthrosis (2%), and other indications (3%). In 202 (48%) a minimally invasive approach, the superior capsulotomy, was used with the help of the surgical navigation for acetabular component placement.
There were no cases of osteolysis or wear. We found 7 (1.1%) implant revisions: 1 acute cup displacement, 1 acetabular liner fracture, 1 case with failure of osseointegration of the cup, and 4 trochanteric wafer nonunions. A dislocation of the hip was found in 2 (0.5%) cases. The 10-year Kaplan Meier survivorship of the implants (revision of any component for any reason) was 98.4% (95% confidence interval 97.1–100%).
The results of alumina ceramic-ceramic THA after one to ten years are promising, especially considering the young age and high incidence of previous surgery in this patient population. The data are especially encouraging since no hip has demonstrated osteolysis. In particular, we are not aware of any other bearing that has shown an absence of lysis and 10 years follow-up. Since many of these patients are quite young, we await further assessment at 15 and 20 years.
To analyze the long term results of a third generation ceramic on ceramic bearing in cementless total hip arthroplasty (THA), we reviewed the clinical and radiological results of 100 consecutive THAs performed in 86 patients (68 females, 80 hips; 18 males, 20 hips) between 1996 and 1998. The average age at operation was 55 years with a range of 26 to 73 years. The diagnoses were osteoarthritis in 83 hips, osteonecrosis in 10 hips and rheumatoid arthritis in 7 hips. The articulation was composed of a hemispherical titanium porous bead-coated cup (AnCA), a Biolox Forte alumina ceramic cup liner and a ball with a diameter of 28-mm. The modular ceramic liner was fixed directly to the metal cup without polyethylene sandwich or metal rim. A press-fit technique of 1 mm under-reaming without screws was used for cup fixation. The ceramic head was fixed to a 12/14 taper cone of a modular neck which allowed changes in neck-shaft angle, anteversion, and offset. All operations were performed via a posterolateral approach under general anesthesia. To measure the cup orientation, an ellipse was fitted to the acetabular component rim on the early postoperative AP radiographs using computer software. The average cup inclination and anteversion in the radiographic definition were 41 (range 28 to 63) and 17 (range 3 to 34) degrees, respectively. 22 cups were outside the Lewinnek safe zone. All patients were radiographically evaluated in term of implant stability at two years using Engh’s criteria. All of the acetabular components radiologically were judged to be bone-ingrown stable at two years except one cup. 98 stems were judged to be bone-ingrown stable and the remaining two stems were judged to be fibrous stable at two years. After two years, all patients except for two were followed up clinically and radiologically for at least 10 years or until revision or death. One unstable cup was revised at 2.5 years. This case had a previous Chiari’s pelvic osteotomy and insufficient press-fit of the cup was assumed to have led to loosening. One of the two fibrous stable stems was revised at six years due to aseptic loosening. One rheumatoid arthritis hip with stable bone ingrown fixation developed late infection at six years and was revised. One stable cup showed chipping of the acetabular liner at 8 years and required revision. The orientation of this cup was 55 degrees of inclination and 17 degrees of anteversion and the high inclination was thought to be related to the ceramic liner chipping. The remaining hips showed no osteolysis or loosening at the final follow-up. There were no squeaking hips. The 10-year survivorships with the endpoint of mechanical loosening or revision were 96.7% and 95.6%, respectively. We conclude that the third generation ceramic on ceramic hip bearing without polyethylene sandwich provided long term stability and eliminated periprosthetic osteolysis.
Vitamin E stabilized highly crosslinked UHMWPE (E-Poly™) was developed to improve upon the properties of first generation highly crosslinked UHMWPE’s. The post-crosslinking processing for E-Poly™ maximizes the strength of the material while at the same time stabilizing residual free radicals that remain after irradiation. E-Poly™ is crosslinked with 100 kGy gamma irradiation prior to infusion of vitamin E. The infusion process involves diffusing vitamin E into the crosslinked material at temperatures beneath the melt temperature.
Small punch testing (ASTM F2183-02) was completed to evaluate strength of E-Poly™ compared to gamma-inert sterilized UHMWPE. The results showed that the E-Poly™ material had equivalent or better properties before and after accelerated aging than the gamma-inert sterilized UHMWPE (96–105 N vs. 75–88 N unaged; 100–115 N vs. 42–56 N 2-week aged).
Environmental stress crack testing evaluated the resistance to oxidation while the material was subjected to fatigue testing. A constant stress beam was tested for 5 weeks at 80C. Failure was defined as the appearance of cracks or fracture of the specimen. All 4 specimens of gamma sterilized components showed evidence of cracking prior to the completion of the test. 2 of 4 sequentially crosslinked and annealed specimens fractured prior to completion. None of the E-Poly™ specimens showed cracks during testing. An examination of the amount of oxidation induced during this testing showed that the addition of fatigue loading increased the oxidation index for UHWMPE’s that had unstabilized free radicals. The surface oxidation index for gamma sterilized UHWMPE increased from ~0.3 to 1.1 and for sequentially crosslinked UHMWPE from ~0.3 to 0.7; the oxidation index for E-Poly™ was negligible for all test condition.
Hip simulator testing (ISO 14242-1) showed that the volumetric wear rates for E-Poly™ were 95–99 % less than that of ArCom. For 28mm head diameters the rates were 53.3 mm3/Mc for ArCom and 0.24 mm3/Mc for E-Poly™. Wear particle morphology analysis showed that the E-Poly™ wear particles were similar to ArCom. Qualitatively, there appeared to be fewer E-Poly™ particles.
Knee simulator testing (ISO14243-1) was performed on both cruciate retaining and posterior stabilized Vanguard® knees. The E-Poly™ tibial bearing, CR and PS, showed 86% less wear than direct compression molded UHMWPE, the current gold standard. Fatigue testing of the PS post before and after accelerated aging (ASTM F2003) loaded to 1300lbs showed no degradation or failure of the post following 3 million cycles.
Vitamin E stabilized highly crosslinked UHMWPE has demonstrated excellent material properties, wear properties, and resistance to oxidation. These properties have been optimized through the combination of cross-linking, processing below the melt temperature subsequent to crosslinking, and the stabilization effect of vitamin E. These properties provide rational support to the utilization of vitamin E stabilized highly crosslinked UHMWPE for hip and knee applications.
One of important issues of concern in total hip arthroplasty (THA) is osteolysis due to wear debris of ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene (PE), and it often leads to aseptic loosening. Reduction of PE wear debris is essential to prevent osteolysis, and different bearing interfaces as well as improvement of the bearing material itself have been attempted. Alumina ceramics as the bearing material for THA was introduced in Europe and Japan in the 1970s in aim to reduce the PE wear debris. The clinical results have proved the superiority of ceramic on PE couples to metal on PE couples in wear resistance. PE materials cross-liked by irradiation have also demonstrated a significant low wear by in vitro studies. Several types of highly cross-linked polyethylene (CLPE), with the irradiation dose of 50 to 105 kGy, have been developed and extensively used since 1998. In this study, the in vivo wear and oxidation of CLPE acetabular cup combined with ceramic femoral head were evaluated using retrieved cups.
Eight retrieved CLPE acetabular cups (Aeonian; Kyocera Corp., Kyoto, Japan, currently Japan Medical Materials Corp., Osaka, Japan) with clinical use for 3–80 months (mean 34 months) were examined. All cups were used against alumina or zirconia ceramic femoral heads. The linear wear of the retrieved CLPE cups was measured using a three-dimensional coordinate measurement machine. The worn surfaces of retrieved CLPE cups were observed by a scanning electron microscope (SEM). Oxidative degradation of the retrieved CLPE cups was expressed in terms of an oxidation index which was calculated from microscopic Fourier transformed infrared spectroscopy analysis, according to ASTM F2102.
The linear wear rate of retrieved CLPE cups was in 0.006–0.08 mm/year range, which was similar to the results reported by the previous radiographic study. In the worn surface of the CLPE cup retrieved after clinical use shorter than 39 months, machine marks were observed. In contrast, those retrieved after clinical use of 70 and 80 months were smooth. Oxidation indices of retrieved CLPE cups were: 0.12–0.37 in worn surface and 0.13–0.34 in unworn surface, respectively. There was no difference in the oxidation indices between the worn surface and unworn surface.
The retrieved CLPE acetabular cups in this study showed low and stable wear rates. The results showed a notable reduction in wear of the CLPE cups compared to that of conventional PE cups in the previous studies. And also, the oxidation indices of the retrieved CLPE cups were the same level as conventional PE cups. These findings from this retrieval study showed that there is neither progressive wear in the clinical use for 3–80 months, material failures due to wear, delamination nor cracks. The lower wear rate and smooth surface of the CLPE acetabular cup suggest the possibility of reduced wear debris from those cups articulated against the ceramic femoral head. We expect that the CLPE acetabular cup has favorable wear properties in long-term clinical use.
Alumina ceramic-ceramic bearings have the benefit of very low wear and studies showing the complete absence of osteolysis during the first decade of close study. However, good results depend on several critical factors including surgical exposure, surgical technique, component placement, and choice of component design. The following abstract discusses our experience with several of these factors.
Initially, there were concerns that the use of ceramic-ceramic bearings would lead to a higher incidence of hip dislocation since the bearings have fewer femoral head-length choices and the absence of lipped-liners. In our prospective study of 418 hips the incidence of hip dislocation at 1 to 10 year followup is 0.5% (2/418). This experience suggests that the use of alumina ceramic-ceramic bearings is not associated with an increased incidence of dislocation.
More recently, concerns about squeaking of alumina ceramic-ceramic bearings have been reported, particularly from centers in the United States. To investigate this issue, we reviewed information on 1275 consecutive revision THAs and 1039 consecutive primary ceramic-ceramic THA that had been performed at two institutions between 1996 and 2007. To identify the influence of the implant design on the incidence of squeaking we divided the primary hips into three groups with group 1: flush mounted ceramic liner; group 2a: recessed ceramic liner mated with a stem made of TiAlV; and group 2b: recessed ceramic liner mated with a stem made of a beta titanium alloy comprised of 12% molybdenum, 6% Zirconium, and 2% Iron.
Analysis of the 1275 revision hips revealed 5 alumina ceramic-ceramic hips in patients who complained of squeaking or grinding. All 5 hips were designs that included a ceramic liner that was recessed inside of an elevated metal rim. All 5 hips also demonstrated metallosis at the time of revision.
In primary THA, Group 2b had statistically significantly more squeaking (9 of 118) than group 2a (10 of 321) which had statistically significantly more squeaking than group 1 (6 of 700). In addition, the severity of squeaking between the groups was qualitatively different. Patients in Group 2b who complained of squeaking would often experience squeaking frequently throughout the day and could be demonstrated in the physician’s office. By contrast, patients in Group 1 who noted squeaking stated that the hip squeaked once a day to once a year. No patient in Group 1 complained of frequent squeaking or could demonstrate squeaking in the physicians’ office. Further, joint fluid analysis from a patient in Group 2b who complained of squeaking revealed metal from both the femoral (Molybdenum) and acetabular (Aluminum) components.
As reported in another abstract at this meeting, 10 year survivorship of flush-mounted alumina ceramic-ceramic THA is 98.4% (95% confidence interval 97.1–100%) and no patient in that prospective clinical studies demonstrated radiographic evidence of osteolysis or wear.
These experiences demonstrate that THA using alumina ceramic-ceramic is extremely reliable with low revision and dislocation rates and an absence of osteolysis. Significant squeaking is not associated with flush-mounted alumina ceramic liners and is clearly associated with elevated metal rims and metallosis. Finally, squeaking is statistically significantly associated with femoral components made of a beta titanium alloy consisting of Titanium, Molybdenum, Aluminum, and Iron.
Current CoC hip bearing ranges are typically from 28mm to 36mm diameter, but to improve stability and range of motion, a novel large diameter hip bearing is introduced, with bearing diameter from 32mm to 48mm. To minimise acetabular bone loss, a low profile acetabular component is required and achieved with a ceramic wall thickness of 3.5mm and metal shell thickness of 1.5mm at the acetabular rim. This paper presents some of the testing required to develop this novel design.
Finite element (FE) modelling was performed to simulate the standard 46kN burst loading of the acetabular cup for 5 different geometries of ceramic liner and metal (titanium) shell. By smoothing the facets on the back of the ceramic and thinning the metal shell, the stresses in the ceramic were reduced by 20% and failure was not predicted for the burst test. Reducing the thickness of the metal shell increased the stresses in the metal, but these were kept below the yield strength of the material. When assembled, the hoop stresses in the titanium shell caused a greater volume of the ceramic to be in compression and the strength of the assembled cup was therefore increased.
To assess the effect of fatigue loading on the ceramic/titanium taper-lock, cups were loaded at 45° to the horizontal for 10,000 cycles in Ringer’s solution at 37°C. The load required to push the ceramic from the metal shell were recorded after the test and compared to the push out load of unloaded specimens. There was no significant decrease in the push-out load (mean 2kN) indicating that the taper lock retains its strength during fatigue loading.
The new CoC acetabular cup design is assembled under controlled conditions before packaging. To demonstrate the effectiveness of this, the new device was compared to a commercially available intraoperatively assembled Ti/ceramic device which had a metal shell thickness of 5mm. The cups were placed in reamed cavities of polyurethane foam and the rims impacted with increasing impact energy until the ceramic came loose from the metal shell. An average impact energy of 4J (1kg dropped from 400mm) was necessary to separate the ceramic from the metal liner of the new design compared to 2J for the commercially available design. The thicker titanium wall thickness and intraoperative assembly method of the commercially available design limited the amount of shell deformation/hoop stress generated, and therefore limited the ‘grip’ of the Ti/ceramic interface. The thinner titanium shell (1.5mm) and controlled assembly load of the new design allowed greater shell deformation/hoop stress which produced a two-fold improvement in interface strength. Further effects of assembly in vivo, in particular the effects of periprosthetic or lavage fluids, remain to be investigated. In any case, incomplete ceramic liner seating has been reported in 16% of procedures in vivo (Lang-down, JBJS Br 2007) and the preassembled design therefore represents a notable and necessary improvement to current technology.
Computers arrived late in orthopaedic surgery. While the rest of the world already happily integrated computers into daily life, business and production, orthopaedic surgeons remained sceptical and denied any need for help from modern technology. It was in the mid-eighties though, that a young veterinary surgeon from California, specializing in total hip replacement in dogs, was contemplating the problems that he encountered during surgery. This veterinary surgeon, the late Hap Paul, was one of the founding members of the custom – implant society, from which evolved ISTA. He struggled with wrong positioning of implants and broken bones, and wondered why implants that were manufactured with highest technology finally were placed into the bone with crude instruments reminiscent of those found in a carpenters workshop. With the help of IBM and engineers from the University of California he created a system which he called ROBODOC®, and it became the first computer based system helping the surgeon during an orthopaedic procedure. The technological effort was huge, as many parts of the system and of the procedure using advance robotic tools had to be invented from scratch. There was nothing there they could copy, and the system they invented – an active robot performing a critical part of surgery – represented a very ambitious step forward. Some compare the development of ROBODOC® with the technological history of the Concorde: very sophisticated technology, very early and very advanced, somewhat expensive and with an aura of vision and adventure
Of course this was not the only and ultimate solution of bringing computers into surgery. Other researchers took a step backwards: they invented systems that helped the surgeon to navigate hand held instruments and implants within the surgical field, so-called navigation systems. These were initially used by neurosurgeons to navigate probes within the brain. As neurosurgeons were closely related to and depending on CT-scan, the logic step was to use the CT- datasets, match them with real world (the process of registration) and create a virtual 3D space that is congruent to the real 3D space. Using CT provided orthopaedic surgeons increase visibility with less required exposure
With the help of optical systems (other options are mechanical or magnetic systems) instruments can be tracked outside and inside the surgical object and allow precise navigation within the surgical field. However, preparation of tissue and/or placement of implants were still done with manual tools. Very early application of this navigation technology was spine surgery in the mid-nineties, where utmost precision was needed during the placement of pedicle screws. Further applications were knee replacement, hip replacement and numerous applications in trauma surgery. Also the source of data was further developed: from the very precise but costly CT-scan to simple radiographs taken during surgery to so-called image free surgery, where data are retrieved directly from the surgical object and approximations are created to direct the placement of implants. Navigation systems, in contrast to the original robotic system, presented two major advantages: they were much cheaper, and they allowed the surgeon to use his standard instruments and, most important, to play a more active part in the surgery, “to stay in the loop” (Tony DiGioia).
Today there are thousands of navigations systems in routine use all over the world. Published results show benefits, but also limits. Surgery using navagation has become more precise and results more reproducible, yet there are still outliers which mainly stem from technical problems, but which are hard to detect and cause significant inaccuracy. Therefore the era of the robots is not over: robotic technology is currently revisited by numerous groups, and technically more advanced robots are developed and currently under testing. Robotic technology has continued to make inroads into the market with demonstrated capacity to assist the surgeon to reduce intraoperative complications, eliminate outliers, and achieve improved surgical outcomes consistently. Different types of robots (active, semi active and passive robots, such as systems which provide for constrained motion in the surgical field) are successfully moving into the operating theatre. ROBODOC®, the forefather of all computer-assisted orthopaedic systems, is still around and actively applied during surgery, with published good results and high reliability.
The history of ROBODOC® is a master piece of technological history. After initial successful human surgeries, embedded in the feasibility study required by the FDA, the next step was more difficult: the randomized study for FDA approval to prove the efficacy almost killed the company and with it the technology. In early optimistic statements the inventors foresaw major benefits, but overlooked the difficulties to prove these in the postoperative outcome. Disadvantages of the system, like longer OR times and higher blood loss, at least prevalent in the in the early trials of the FDA study, were obvious while the “clear” benefits in outcome were not so obvious. Thus marketing abroad became a major option, and Europe became the prime target. The attempt was successful, and rapidly 30 systems were busy all over Europe. This development was brought to a halt by a couple of unsubstantiated lawsuits in Germany and unprecedented negative press campaign accompanying this effort. The lawsuits were sponsored by the illusion to finally sue an American company and gain millions from that lawsuit. This process started in the early days of this century, and so far, in spite of numerous sentences proclaimed, not one court has condemned the technology or found any wrong doing in applying it. In parallel with the declining European market, the Asian market was developed, and surgeons there benefited from the experiences in Europe and the consecutive improvements of the system. Currently TKR and THR are routinely performed using the ROBODOC® system in Japan, Korea and India.
This process let to recovery of the company, which tells us that technological progress also in medicine is inherently coupled to economic success. Although the first system applied in CAOS, Robodoc still is the most advanced system in technological terms. This is finally also accepted by the very critical USFDA, which had problems with the approval for such a long time because the system represents an autonomous robotic system working on patients.
Initial problems like bulkiness, software bugs and invasiveness have been overcome. Work is underway even now to make the system more flexible covering a wider range of surgical procedures like uni and multi compartmental knee, hip resurfacing and acetabular cup in THR and further expanding the functionality of the system supporting not just orthopedic procedures but Neurosurgical procedures as well.
Many of these developments are in the final stages of testing. In the meantime the CAOS community, i.e. the surgeons and engineers primarily working in application and development of the existing systems, more and more become convinced that computer assisted surgery undoubtedly is heading towards the integration of robotic systems into surgery: this is where ROBODOC® came from.
Proximal femoral osteotomy was a common procedure prior to modern total hip replacement. It is seldom done now as the results were unpredictable, complications common and morbidity substantial. Eventually almost all required a total hip replacement.
In carrying out a total hip replacement after inter-trochanteric osteotomy there may be a problem with hardware removal which is sometimes best done as an interval procedure as the hardware may have been in place for decades and the appropriate screw driver not available, necessitating the use of a crown drill to remove the screws. After a varus inter trochanteric osteotomy the tip of the greater trochanter may overlie the medullary canal necessitating re-osteotomy. Most sub-trochanteric osteotomies will require re osteotomy.
A review has been carried out with the author’s personal cases. There were fourteen previous varus osteotomies two being non-unions. There was one non-union of a re-osteotomy and 17% continued to have a severe limp. Harris scores were acceptable in all. There were 20 valgus osteotomies. Limp was mild in 20% and severe in 3.5%. The Harris Hip Score was acceptable in 95%. There were eleven subtrochanteric osteotomies. There was one non-union of a re-osteotomy. Limp was mild in 27.3% and severe in 27.3%. The Harris Hip Scores were acceptable in all.
The results in terms of limp are disappointing. The de-functioned glutei may never recover in the same way a long standing rotator cuff muscles may undergo fatty degeneration. The patient should be warned of this possibility pre-operatively.
Hip-spine relationships should be better investigated in THP as lumbo-sacral orientation in the sagittal plane plays a critical role in the function of the hip joints. Lateral X-rays showing spine and hips together in standing, sitting or squatting positions characterize the adaptations of the sagittal balance and the functionnal interactions between hips and spine.
Acetabular cup implantation has to be planned for frontal inclination, axial anteversion, and sagittal orientation. The later refers to the sacro-acetabular angle, key-point in the spine – hip relationships, and that is redefined by the surgeon at the time of implantation.
Usual standard CT-sections are biased for evaluating acetabular anteversion. The conventional CT procedure does not refer to the pelvic bony frame and. the measured anteversion is a projected angle on a transverse plane, depending on the pelvic adaptation in lying position. This measured angle is often considered as anatomical anteversion, leading to some confusion. Therefore this angle is only a “functional” supine anteversion, reflecting the anterior opening angle of the acetabulum in a specific position. According to the sagittal orientation of the pelvis, the true functional acetabular orientation can virtually be assessed in various postures from adjusted CT-scan sections.
The EOS™ low irradiation 2D-3D X-ray scanner is an innovative technology already used for global evaluation of the spine. This technology allows simultaneously “full body” frontal and lateral X-rays with the patient in standing, sitting or squatting positions; a tridimensionnal patient specific bone recontruction can be performed and the cup anteversion can be directly assessed according to the position.
We investigated the lumbo-pelvic parameters influencing the tridimensionnal orientation of the acetabulum. We compared the data obtained for real postural situations using the EOS™ system and the measures from plane X Rays and classical CT scan cuts replicating standing, and sitting positions.368 patients with cementless THP were involved in a prospective follow-up protocol. Sacral slope and pelvic tilt, incidence angle, acetabular frontal and sagittal inclination were evaluated on AP and lateral standard XRays. Functionnal anteversion of the cup has been measured using a previously described protocol with CTscan cuts oriented according to standing and sitting sacral slope. The mean difference between CTscan and EOS™ system was 4,4° with comparable accuracy and reproductibility.
Sacral slope decrease in sitting position was linked to anteversion increase (38,8° SD 5,4°). Sacral slope increase in standing position was linked to lower ante-version (31,7° SD 5,6°). The anatomical acetabular anteversion, the frontal inclination, and the sagittal inclination were functional parameter which significantly varied between the standing, sitting, and lying positions. We noticed that the acetabular parameters in lying position highly correlated to the one in standing position, while poorly correlated with the one in sitting position. The difference between the lying and the sitting positions was about 10°, 25°, and 15° for the cup anteversion (CA) and the frontal and sagittal inclinations (FI,SI) respectively. The poor correlation between the lying and sitting positions suggests that the usual CT scan protocol is biased and not fully appropriate for investigating the cases of posterior THP dislocation and subluxation, which happen in sitting position. On the contrary, a strong correlation was observed between lying and standing measurements with all the acetabular parameters (CA,FI, SI), suggesting that the classical CT assessment of the cup anteversion remains an interesting source of information in case of anterior THP
Each patient is characterized by a morphological parameter, the incidence angle. High incidence angle is linked to low acetabular anteversion, increasing the instability risk and anterior impingement in sitting and squatting position; higher anteversion angles are observed in low incidence angle patients, leading to more internal rotation of the hip in any position.
Lumbo-sacral orientation in the sagittal plane influences the tridimensionnal orientation of the acetabulum, especially for anteversion. Aging of the hip-spine complex is linked to progressive pelvic posterior extension. Impingement phenomenons, orientation of stripe wear zones and some instability situations can be interpreted according to those data.
This study points out the opportunity to adjust the CT scan sections to the sacral slope in functional position for properly investigating the orientation of the acetabular cup, mainly in case of posterior dislocation.
In addition, the mobility of the lumbo-sacral junction could be a crucial parameter in the mechanical functioning and the stability of a THP due to its impact on sacral slope and pelvic tilt. Therefore we also recommend doing dynamic lateral radiographs of the lumbo sacral junction in standing and sitting position for planning a THP implantation in order to detect stiff lumbosacral junction or sagittal pelvic malposition.
The study is to evaluate mid-term follow-up clinical results and navigation prediction of the first 106 TKAs, which was performed based on the soft tissue balancing technique using the OrthoPilot navigation system (B.Braun Aesculap, Tuttlingen, Germany).
All the 106 cases were diagnosed as osteoarthritis with varus deformity. After anatomical and kinematic registration, the mechanical axis was restored to neutral (±2°) at full extension with step by step meticulous medial soft tissue release and osteophyte removal. Proximal tibial bone cutting was performed under real-time navigation system control. Flexion and extension gaps were measured at full extension and at 90° of flexion using a tensioning device (V-STAT tensor, Zimmer) and a special torque wrench set at 50lb/inch before femoral bone cutting. The flexion and extension gap was evaluated and it’s difference was classified into 3 kinds; balanced, tight flexion gap and tight extension gap. Sixty-one (57.5%) knees were classified as having a ‘balanced gap’ (meaning that flexion and extension gaps were within 2 mm), 20 (18.9%) knees as having a ‘tight flexion gap’ (an extension gap at least 3mm more that the corresponding flexion gap), and 25 (23.6%) knees as having a ‘tight extension gap’ (a flexion gap at least 3mm more that the corresponding extension gap). Depending extension/flexion, and medial/lateral gap difference, the level of distal femoral cut and the rotation of femoral component was determined. Following the final bone cuts and completion of soft tissue release, assessment of the flexion and extension gap was repeated. Balanced flexion and extension gap (difference between flexion and extension gap ≤ 3mm) was confirmed in 99 cases (94%). A mobile bearing prosthesis (e motion FP, B.Braun Aesculap) was used.
One patient (bilateral TKAs) died of unrelated causes at postoperative 2 year. One knee was revised due to infection. One hundred three cases were followed up at least more than 4 years, 53 months in average. Overall survival rate is 97%. Average preoperative HHS scores and range of motion (ROM) were 65.4 points (range, 33~82) and 126.8 degrees (80~140). At the last follow-up, HHS score and ROM were 95.0 points (78~100) and 131.4 degrees (110~140). Statistically significant improvement in HHS score and ROM were observed (p< 0.05). The mean mechanical axis was 179.44±1.83° (175~184°) with 8 cases of outliers (more than ±3° of optimum). There was no radiolucency, osteolysis, subsidence, or loosening at the last follow-up.
In conclusion, navigation is an excellent predictor for achieving balanced soft tissue & flexion-extension gap in primary total knee arthroplasty. Navigated TKAs using soft tissue balancing technique showed excellent clinical results and is effective methods achieving accurate mechanical axis and reducing prosthetic alignment outlier.
The goals of knee arthroplasty are to relieve pain, to provide motion while maintaining stability, and to correct deformity. According to advantages of minimally invasive surgical procedure (MIS) are to facilitate the patient’s recovery, less pain, earlier mobilization, shorter hospital stay, and quicker rehabilitation. The surgeon takes responsibility between each other and makes the decision, makes the cuts, checks accuracy of surgery even he/she uses jigs or not.
From April 2005 to February 2008, more than 50 unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) were performed at our medical center with free hand technique.
We conclude this free hand technique of MIS UKA, the small incision, short operative time, less blood loss, quick recovery, accurate alignment, and reduced fat or thrombo-embolism risk were impressed, also the extra advantage is preservation of patellar-femoral joint.
Dislocation after THA is the most common complication in modern THA, The reported failure rate of reoperation for recurrent instability is higher than any other indication for revision surgery.
Treatment of dislocation after THA
Non-operative treatment
The first episode of dislocation after THA is usually treated by close reduction with or without brace treatment. There is no agreement about the role and effectiveness of bracing. Generally, bracing is indicated in the following circumstances:
First dislocation Early laxity No component malposition Patients with poor general condition
The main management issues are about managing recurrent instability. Treatment choice is often complex and management begins by identifying the cause of instability.
Causes to consider:
Component issue Impingement Soft tissue imbalance Laxtiy Abductor weakness Trochanteric non-uion
Surgical Treatment
The decision to use operative treatment to stabilize the hip joint is complex and the surgeon must take into consideration:
How many times the hip dislocated Interveral between dislocation How long after THA the dislocation occur Can the problem be solved by an operation Operative risks
Treatment choices depends on the underlying mechanism of dislocation:
Correction of malposition Correction of soft tissue laxity Release contractures Addressing problems of impingement Using a large femoral head Constrained liners
The stemmed tibial implant has enabled the salvage of challenging situations of bone loss in primary knee arthroplasty. This ease of use has unfortunately led to the adoption of stemmed implants in situations where this may not be warranted. In general uncontained defects of less than 5 mm may be dealt with using cement fill techniques. Defect of less than 10mm require bone grafting techniques and those above 10 mm require stems and wedges. In the third category however long term results suggest that good results are only attainable in 65% of cases whether grafts or wedges are used. The use of intramedullary guides in this setting is re-addressed to allow the accurate placement of cuts enabling the use of pegged (or non-stemmed) implants. In addition with the advent of navigation this may be a special situation where non-stemmed implants may be selected over stemmed implants.
Navigation systems are able to measure very accurately the movement of bones, and consequently the knee laxity, which is a movement of the tibia under the femur. These systems might help measuring the knee laxity during the implantation of a total (TKR) or a unicompartmental (UKR) knee replacement.
20 patients operated on for TKR (13 cases) or UKR (7 cases) because of primary varus osteoarthritis have been analyzed. Pre-operative examination involved varus and valgus stress X-rays at 0 and 90° of knee flexion. The intra-operative medial and lateral laxity was measured with the navigation system at the beginning of the procedure and after prosthetic implantation. Varus and valgus stress X-rays were repeated after 6 weeks. X-ray and navigated measurements before and after knee replacement were compared with a paired Wilcoxon test at a 0.05 level of significance.
The mean pre-operative medial laxity in extension was 2.3° (SD 2.3°). The mean pre-operative lateral laxity in extension was 5.6° (SD 5.1°). The mean pre-operative medial laxity in flexion was 2.2° (SD 1.9°). The mean pre-operative lateral laxity in flexion was 6.7° (SD 6.0°). The mean intra-operative medial laxity in extension at the beginning of the procedure was 3.6° (SD 1.7°). The mean intra-operative lateral laxity in extension at the beginning of the procedure was 3.0° (SD 1.3°). The mean intra-operative medial laxity in flexion at the beginning of the procedure was 1.9° (SD 2.6°). The mean intra-operative lateral laxity in flexion at the beginning of the procedure was 3.5° (SD 2.7°). The mean intra-operative medial laxity in extension after implantation was 2.1° (SD 0.9°). The mean intra-operative lateral laxity in extension after implantation was 1.9° (SD 1.1°). The mean intra-operative medial laxity in flexion after implantation was 1.9° (SD 2.5°). The mean intra-operative lateral laxity in flexion after implantation was 3.0° (SD 2.8°). The mean post-operative medial laxity in extension was 2.4° (SD 1.1°). The mean post-operative lateral laxity in extension was 2.0° (SD 1.7°). The mean post-operative medial laxity in flexion was 4.4° (SD 3.3°). The mean post-operative lateral laxity in flexion was 4.7° (SD 3.2°).
There was a significant difference between navigated and radiographic measurements for the pre-operative medial laxity in extension (mean = 1.4° – p = 0.005), the pre-operative lateral laxity in extension (mean = 2.6° – p = 0.01), the pre-operative lateral laxity in flexion (mean = 3.3° – p = 0.005). There was no significant difference between navigated and radiographic measurements for the pre-operative medial laxity in flexion (mean = 0.3° – p = 0.63). There was a significant difference between navigated and radiographic measurements for the postoperative medial laxity in flexion (mean = 2.5° – p = 0.004). There was no significant difference between navigated and radiographic measurements for the postoperative medial laxity in extension (mean = 0.3° – p = 0.30), the post-operative lateral laxity in extension (mean = 0.2° – p = 0.76), the post-operative lateral laxity in flexion (mean = 1.7° – p = 0.06). These differences were less than 2 degrees in most of the cases, and then considered as clinically irrelevant.
The navigation system used allowed measuring the medial and lateral laxity before and after TKR. This measurement was significantly different from the radiographic measurement by stress X-rays for pre-operative laxity, but not statistically different from the radiographic measurement by stress X-rays for post-operative laxity. The differences were mostly considered as clinically irrelevant. The navigated measurement of the knee laxity can be considered as accurate. The navigated measurement is valuable information for balancing the knee during TKR. The reproducibility of this balancing might be improved due to a more objective assessment.
The objective of this study was to evaluate the kinematics of a high-flexion, posterior-stabilized total knee arthroplasty (TKA) in weight-bearing, deep knee bending motion. Fifteen patients implanted with the Legacy Posterior Stabilized Flex (8; mobile bearing and 7; fixed bearing), 18 patients with Scorpio NRG, and 8 patients with PFC sigma RP-F were examined during a deep knee bending motion using fluoroscopy. Femorotibial motion was determined using a 2-dimensional to 3-dimensional registration technique, which used computer-assisted design models to reproduce the position of metallic implants from single-view fluoroscopic images. The average flex-ion ranges of motion between the metallic implants were 120° with Legacy Flex, 125° with NRG and 121° with RP-F. The average rotation of the femoral component was 11° external rotation (ER) with Legacy Flex, 12° with NRG and 11° with RP-F. The mean kinematic pathways were early rollback, lateral pivot with ER, and bicondylar rollback with Legacy Flex, medial pivot with ER and bicondylar rollback with NRG and central pivot with ER and bicondylar rollback with RP-F. The in vivo kinematics was different due to the prosthesis designs to obtain weight-bearing deep knee bending motion.
The high-flex total knee arthroplasty system was introduced to enhance knee flexion and to facilitate tibiofemoral articulation at high-flexion by the design modification of an increased thickness of the posterior wall of the femoral component by 2 mm compared with the standard total knee prosthesis. However, several clinical studies on the effectiveness of designs intended to provided high flexion following total knee arthroplasty have produced conflicting results. We performed a prospective, randomized study to compare the ranges of motion of the high-flex and standard total knee replacements in patients who were managed with simultaneous bilateral total knee arthroplasty.
This study comprised of three independent groups of patients.
The first group: Fifty patients (mean age, 68 years old) received a standard NexGen LPS prosthesis in one knee and a NexGen LPS-Flex prosthesis in the contralateral knee. Two patients were men, and 48 were women. At a mean of 2.1 years postoperatively, the patients were assessed clinically and radiographically with use of the knee-rating systems of the KS and HSS. The second group: Fifty-four patients (mean age 69.7 years) received a NexGen CR prosthesis in one knee and a NexGen CR-Flex prosthesis in the contralateral knee. Five patients were men, and 49 were women. The minimum follow-up was 3 years (mean, 3.1 years). At each follow-up, the WOMAC score and range of knee motion were evaluated and patients were assessed clinically and radiographically with use of the knee-rating systems of the KS and HSS. The third group: Two hundred and fifty patients (mean age, 71.6 years) received a NexGen CR-Flex knee prosthesis in one knee and a NexGen LPS-Flex knee prosthesis in the contrallateral knee. Ten patients were men and 240 were women. At each follow-up (mean follow-up, 2.3 years) the patients were assessed clinically and radiographically with use of the knee-rating systems of the KS and HSS. The first group: The mean postoperative HSS knee score was 90 points for the knees treated with the NexGen LPS prosthesis and 89.4 points for those treated with the NexGen LPS-Flex prosthesis. At the time of the final follow-up, the knees with the NexGen LPS prosthesis had a mean range of motion of 135.8° (range, 105° to 150°) and those with a NexGen LPS-Flex prosthesis had a mean range of motion of 138.6° (range, 105° to 150°). No knee had aseptic loosening, revision, or osteolysis. The second group: The mean postoperative KS and HSS knee scores were 93.7 and 89 points, respectively in the knees with a NexGen CR prosthesis and those were 93.9 and 90 points, respectively in the knees with a NexGen CR-Flex prosthesis. The mean postoperative WOMAC score was 22 points. Postoperatively, the mean non-weight and weight bearing ranges of motion were 131° (range, 90° to 150°) and 115° (range, 75° to 145°), respectively in the knee with a NexGen CR prosthesis and those were 133° (range, 90° to 150°) and 118 (range, 75° to 145°), in the knees with a NexGen CR-Flex prosthesis. Patients satisfaction and radiographic results were similar in both groups. No knee had aseptic loosening, revision, or osteolysis. The third group: The mean postoperative KS and HSS knee scores were 95 and 90 points, respectively in the knees with a NexGen CR-Flex prosthesis and those were 95 and 91 points, respectively in the knees with a NexGen LPS-Flex prosthesis. Postoperatively, the mean non-weight and weight bearing ranges of motion were 133° (range, 90° to 145°) and 118° (range, 75° to 135°), respectively in the knees with a NexGen CR-Flex prosthesis and those were 135° (range, 85° to 140°) and 122° (range, 70° to 135°), respectively in the knees with a NexGen LPS-Flex prosthesis. No knee had aseptic loosening, revision, or osteolysis.
After a minimum follow-up of two years, we found no significant differences among the first, second and the third groups with regard to range of knee motion, or clinical and radiographic results.
Soft tissue balancing remains the most subjective and most artistic of current techniques in total knee arthroplasty. The flexion gap is traditionally measured at approximately 45 degree of hip flexion and 90 degree of knee flexion on the operation table. Despite of aiming equal joint gaps or tensions in flexion and extension, influence of the thigh weight on the flexion gap has not been documented. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to examine the flexion gaps in the 90–90 degree flexed position and the traditional 45–90 degree flexed position of hip-knee joints.
Thirty patients with osteoarthritic knee underwent total knee arthroplasty. After the PCL sacrifice, soft tissue releases, and bone cuts. Biomechanical properties of the soft tissue were obtained during the surgery, using the specially designed system. The system consists of two electric load cells in the tensioning device, digital output indicators, and an XY plotter. Load displacement curves were obtained in extension and in flexion. 160N was applied to open the joint gaps in the traditional 45–90 degree flexed position and the 90–90 degree flexed position of hip-knee joints. The flexion gap in the 90–90 degree flexed position of hip-knee joints was 2.1±1.2mm wider than that in the traditional 45–90 degree flexed position of hip-knee joints. The flexion gap had significant difference between the two different hip flexion angles (p< 0.001). Interestingly, the stiffness of curves obtained from the lateral in flexion is 1/3 lower than the other three.
In the traditional 45–90 degree flexed position of hip-knee joints on the operation table, the flexion gap is approximately 45 degree to the gravitation and influenced by the thigh weight. To avoid the influence of the thigh weight and obtain equal joint gaps or tensions in flexion and extension, the flexion gap should be checked in the 90–90 degree flexed position of hip-knee joints.
Extension and flexion gaps on the sagittal plane, and medial and lateral gaps on the coronal plane have to be well balanced. However, it is very difficult to match these four. It is still very questionable whether we can adjust these materials precisely and constantly or not.
Restoration of proper alignment is one of the principle goals of TKA. Various methods are popular, including intramedullary (IM) and extramedullary (EM) mechanical guides, and recently computer assisted navigation (CAS). In addition, minimally invasive surgery has added an extra level of complexity to achieving satisfactory alignment. The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of approach (standard arthrotomy vs MIS) and alignment technique (Mechanical vs CAS) upon component alignment in TKA.
Methods. Three consecutive cohorts of patients were included: Group I--Standard arthrotomy with Mechanical guides; Group II-MIS approach with Mechanical guides; Group III-MIS approach with CAS. A single surgeon performed the Standard Mechanical cohort, and a second surgeon performed all surgeries in the other two cohorts. For the mechanical groups, IM femoral and EM tibial guides were used. For CAS, the Orthosoft system was used. All components were NexGen (Zimmer) Postoperative x-rays were used to measure component alignment relative to the IM axes, including femoral valgus and flexion, and tibial varus and slope, and patellar tilt. In addition, joint line position was measured. Students’ t-test was used to determine level of significance.
Results. For Groups I, II and III, there were 41, 38 and 39 patients, respectively. For femoral alignment in the coronal plane, results were 4.83+4.29 degrees, 3.82+2.72 degrees, and 3.36+2.49 degrees, respectively. Femoral flexion was 2.93+2.82 degrees, 3.18+2.93 degrees, and 2.46+2.79 degrees, respectively. Tibial alignment was 0.44+3.98 degrees of varus, 1.00+2.83 degrees of valgus, and 0.95+2.58 degrees of varus, respectively. Slope was 6.78+3.23 degrees, 3.23+3.21 degrees, and 3.93+2.85 degrees, respectively. Patellar tilt was 2.15+3.51 degrees lateral, 1.73+2.67 degres lateral, and 1.03+2.28 degrees lateral, respectively. The joint line was raised 1.18+3.54 mm and 0.05+4.92 mm in Groups I and III, respectively, and lowered 0.33+4.78 mm in Group II. There were no statistically significant differences in any measurement between any groups.
Discussion. Satisfactory alignment can be achieved with either mechanical guides or navigation systems. MIS approaches do not worsen alignment with either alignment methodology. Whether having fewer outliers translates into improved clinical outcomes remains to be seen. More importantly, CAS provides an intraoperative tool that may allow more accurate reproduction of a customized plan for an individual, rather than simply attempting to achieve the “mean” for a population. Again, the value of achieving such a goal is unknown since the threshold for improvement with off-the-shelf knee components may have already been maximised.
Several reports suggest that the clinical transepicondyle axis which is known as the transverse flexion axis of knee rotation most consistently recreates a balanced flexion space and normal patella-femoral tracking. However the problem is that it is difficult to find the exact location of both femoral epicondyles intraoperatively. We suggest a method to determine femoral external rotation which parallel to the T-E axis using the femoral extramedullary(EM) system.
By definition, T-E axis is the line across each epicondyle and knee center, which is perpendicular to the mechanical axis of the femur in the coronal plane. Mechanical coronal plane perpendicular to mechanical sagittal plane is represented by the plane made of three points; femoral head center, lateral femoral epicondyle and knee center. T-E axis is parallel to the coronal plane, therefore if we position the distal femoral block parallel to the mechanical coronal plane, the position of distal femoral block should be parallel to the T-E axis. If the EM system is in its correct position sagittally and coronally, the T-E axis can be traced automatically.
Determination of femoral external rotation which parallel to the transepicondylar axis using the EM system could be one of the useful method to determine the external rotation of the femoral component and it will also imrove the patello-femoral tracking.
Revision total knee replacement (TKR) is a challenging procedure, especially because most of the standard bony and ligamentous landmarks used during primary TKR are lost due to the index implantation. However, as for primary TKR, restoration of the joint line, adequate limb axis correction and ligamentous stability are considered critical for the short- and long- term outcome of revision TKR. There is no available data about the range of tolerable leg alignment after revision TKR. However, it is logical to assume that the same range than after primary TKR might be accepted, that is ± 3° off the neutral alignment. One might also assume that the conventional instruments, which rely on visual or anatomical alignments or intra- or extra-medullary rods, are associated with significant higher variation of the leg axis correction, especially in cases with significant bone loss which prevents to control the exact location of the usual, relevant landmarks. Navigation system might address this issue.
We used an image-free system (ORTHOPILOT TM, AESCULAP, FRG) for routine implantation of primary TKR. The standard software was used for revision TKR. Registration of anatomic and cinematic data was performed with the index implant left in place. The components were then removed. New bone cuts as necessary were performed under the control of the navigation system. The size of the implants and their thickness was chosen after simulation of the residual laxities, and ligament balance was adapted to the simulation results. The system did not allow navigation for intra-medullary stem extensions and any bone filling which may have been required. This technique was used for 54 patients. The accuracy of implantation was assessed by measuring following angles on the post-operative long-leg radiographs: mechanical femoro-tibial angle (normal = 0°, varus deformation was described with a positive angle); coronal orientation of the femoral component in comparison to the mechanical femoral axis (normal = 90°, varus deformation was described with an angle < 90°); coronal orientation of the tibial component in comparison to the mechanical tibial axis (normal = 90°, varus deformation was described with an angle < 90°); sagittal orientation of the tibial component in comparison to the proximal posterior tibial cortex (normal = 90°, flexion deformation was described with angle < 90°).
Individual analysis was performed as follows: one point was given for each fulfilled item, giving a maximal accuracy note of 4 points. Prosthesis implantation was considered as satisfactory when the accuracy note was 4 (all fulfilled items). The rate of globally satisfactory implanted prostheses and the rate of prostheses implanted within the desired range for each criterion were recorded.
Limb alignment was restored in 88%. The coronal orientation of the femoral component was acceptable in 92% of the cases. The coronal orientation of the tibial component was acceptable in 89% of the cases. The sagittal orientation of the tibial component was acceptable in 87% of the cases. Overall, 78% of the implants were oriented satisfactorily for the four criteria.
The navigation system enables reaching the implantation objectives for implant position and ligament balance in the large majority of cases, with a rate similar to that obtained for primary TKA. The navigation system is a useful aid for these often difficult operations, where the visual information is often misleading.
In designing artificial joints the main criteria are to reduce the wear-rate of the material and the reaction of the body to the wear particles produced. These can be achieved by using harder materials (metals, ceramics) or by reducing the chances of producing a wear particle by the choice of material and design. This paper will look at combinations of PEEK-OPTIMA against different counterfaces with the aim of reducing the wear-rate of artificial hips and knees.
Pin-on-Plate Studies Twenty-six different sets of experiments combining PEEK-OPTIMA in different formulations and against different counterfaces were conducted to evaluate the lowest wear combination.
The lowest wear-rate combination was CFR-PEEK PAN against low carbon CoCrMo alloy (K=0.144×10-6 mm3/Nm) which is only about 1/8th of the wear of UHMWPE against stainless-steel (1.1×10-6 mm3/Nm). Gamma radiation sterilisation did not seem to affect the PEEK wear-rate.
Hip Simulator Studies A 25 million cycle wear study has been conducted on the Durham Hip Simulator using 54 mm diameter alumina heads against CFR-PEEK thin-walled acetabular cups (MITCH). Five joints were in active stations and one acted as a loaded control. Wear was measured gravimetrically.
Particles were analysed using a NanoSight LM10 instrument at 0.5, 10 and 25 million cycles. Also an Atomic Force Microscope (AFM) was used to look at particles above 2μm which is the limit of the NanoSight instrument.
The wear-rate was linear over the whole 25 million cycle test at 1.16 mm3/ million cycles (range 0.811–1.392 mm3/million cycles). As the test progressed, the number of particles reduced and the dominant particle size increased from about 40nm to circa 200 nm. The AFM showed some particles as large as 3μm to exist also. No fluid film lubrication was observed to be generated in these joints so the low wear-rate was due to the inherent low-wear properties of the material combination.
Knee Simulator Studies CFR-PEEK was moulded into the interpositional bearings for experimental lateral and medial unicompartmental knee designs and tested for 5 million cycles using 5 pairs of active joints and one pair of loaded controls in the Durham Knee Simulator. Wear was measured gravimetrically.
Whilst the CFR-PEEK components gave a total wear-rate (both medial and lateral) of 2.72 mm3/million cycles, UHMWPE inserts in a similar application
The patho-anatomy of a valgus knee could be divide into two categories as bony hypolasia and/or deficiency and soft tissue imbalance. The soft tissue in the lateral side of the knee (Including illio-tial band, lateral collateral ligament, poplitious tendon, posterior-lateral ligament, and hamstrings etc) is contracted with or without medial soft tissue attenuation.
There are many reasons explain why dealing with a valgus knee is much more difficult than dealing with a varus knee. The most important three factors are:
There is much less room or space to release a LCL, The MCL could be attenuated, A fixed valgus deformity is always associated with bone deficiency or hypoplasia.
However, it is arbitrary, and in many times, it is wrong to take it for granted that a valgus knee is always associated with a tight LCL. In this article, the author mainly introduce the rationale and clinical application of a LCL tension based classification and treatment algorithm of a valgus knee. The details of how to judge if the LCL is tight, loose or normally tensioned; Is the valgus knee purely or associated with an extra-articular deformity will also be discussed.
Femoral deformity
Type F1 Valgus in Extension only
F1a Intra-articular deformity, LCL is loose when the knee extends, while LCL maintains normal tension when the knee flexes.
F1b Extra-articular deformity which is close to knee joint(supra-condylar deformity), LCL remains normal length and tension through all the range of motion.
Type F2 Valgus in both extension and flexion
Intra-articular deformity, LCL is tight through all the range of motion, hypoplasia or bone deficiency in both distal and posterior lateral femoral condyle.
Tibial deformity
Type T1 Intra-articular deformity, lateral tibial plateau deficiency
Type T2 Extra-articular deformity, tibial metaphyseal orshaft deformity.
Treatment algorithm of a valgus knee
Type F1a
This type valgus knee is the easiest to deal with. The LCL length is well maintained, and LCL is loose when knee extends. What is tight and restrains the deformity as a fixed valgus one is: ITB and posterior-lateral capsule instead of LCL and poplitous tendon. The deformity is corrected simply by releasing ITB & posterior-lateral capsule and bony graft or using a metal block to augment the deficient or hypoplastic lateral distal femoral condyle. At the same time, the loose LCL is properly tensioned by bone graft of metal augmentation. Since both ITB & posterior capsule are secondary stabilizers, the LCL and poplitous tendon is properly tensioned, the knee is pretty stable.
Type F1b
This type of valgus deformity actually comes from juxta supera-condylar area, the deformity is very close to the joint, or in other words, close to the collateral ligament frame, this type deformity is also regard as a type of valgus knee. According to severity of the deformity, patient’s age, and surgeon’s preference, the following methods are commonly used.
Since a F1b valgus knee is actually a normal knee combined with a supera-condylar deformity, it is understandable to correct deformity by an supera-condylar osteotomy. The osteotomy can be done in one stage or two stage style. Theoretically, a supera-condylar osteotomy is done in the most deformed region, and is done within cancellous bone, bone union can be predictably expected. But if a total knee and osteotomy is performed in one stage, the operator could encounter the following difficulties:
Conventional instruments can not guarantee correct bone cut because a supera-condylar deformity deviates intramedullary guiding rod; the canal in distal femoral metaphyseal part is quite expended, it is difficult to achieve solid fixation either by a stem extension or retrograde intramedullary nailing. Total knee replacement, supera-condylar osteotomy and intramedullary could severely damage blood supply to osteotomy line leading to nonunion. The author prefer a two stage TKA and osteotomy for a F1b valgus knee. In one stage TKA and osteotomy, the author will use frontal epicondyle axis instead of intra-medullary rod to guide distal femoral cut.
TypeF2
This type knee is consistently valgus no matter the knee extends of flexes, indicating both distal distal and posterior part of lateral femoral condyle is deficient of dysplastic and LCL is contracted. Lateral soft tissue, including LCL and some times popolitous tendon, is inevitable in managing type F2 valgus knee. If soft tissue releasing alone can’t balance medial and lateral part of the knee, a bidirectional sliding osteotomy can be done to shift proximal insertion of LCL both distally and posteriorly, releasing the LCL.
Type T deformity
Type T deformity is sparse, Type T1 is typically seen in a rheumatoid arthritis, and Type T2 is usually iatrogenic(over corrected high tibia osteotomy) or after malunion of a tibia metapyseal or proximal shaft fracture. It is possible try to augament the lateral tibial plateau deficiency and release the lateral soft tissue for a Type T1 valgus knee. But for a Type T2 knee, a correctional osteotomy concomitant to a total knee is usually needed.
Concerns about reduced strength, fatigue resistance, and oxidative stability of highly crosslinked UHMWPE have limited the acceptance of these materials for TKR. It was hypothesized that a new crosslinked UHMWPE stabilized with vitamin E would substantially improve wear performance and resistance to oxidative degradation without compromising mechanical properties. The purpose of this study was to comprehensively test this hypothesis in vitro.
GUR1020 was machined from isostatic molded bar-stock, crosslinked with 100 kGy, and then doped with vitamin E. This material was compared to direct molded GUR1050 UHMWPE. Both materials were gamma irradiation sterilized as for clinical use. Small punch testing, crack growth rate fatigue testing and oxidation index measurements were performed on each material before and after accelerated aging. Knee simulator testing evaluated wear of each material for 5-million walking cycles. CR knees were tested on a 6-station AMTI knee simulator; PS knees were tested on two 4-station Instron-Stan-more knee simulators. Statistical differences in all metrics were evaluated for significance with ANOVA (p < 0.05).
After 4-week accelerated aging, the control material showed elevated oxidation, loss of small punch mechanical properties and decreased fatigue crack growth resistance. In contrast, the vitamin E stabilized material had minimal changes in these properties. Further, the vitamin E stabilized material exhibited 85% reduction in wear for both the CR and PS designs.
Highly crosslinked UHMWPE stabilized with vitamin E appears to be promising for use as a bearing surface in TKA.
‘Tribology’ is derived from the Greek word “tribos” and means the “science of rubbing”. Friction, lubrication, and wear mechanism in the common English language means the precise field of interest of tribology. Wear of PE insert has often been reported in TKA to be primary causes of complications and failure.
As a friction, the wear that occurs in TKA is system properties rather than intrinsic material properties and is therefore affected by multiple variables such as design, material properties, duration and alignment. The contact area on each condyles varies from about 150 mm2 for moderate to high-conformity knees in flexion, down to 30 mm2 for low-conformity. The corresponding maximum compressive pressure in activity is 10 to 50 MPa, which favor fatigue and deformation of UHMWPE (yield stress: 15MPa). In contrast, fully conforming mobile bearing knees have contact area of at least 300 mm2 on each condyles, giving maximum pressure of only 5 MPa. There are several mechanisms whereby small PE particles are released in TKA. Some of these mechanisms are fatigue processes requiring numerous cycles of sliding. Multidirectional sliding is more damaging than sliding in same direction. The wear mechanisms in TKA are as follows:
Adhesive wear Abrasive wear (2-body, 3-body) Third body wear Corrosion wear Fatigue wear (delamination): the most destructive of all wear mechanism
There have been a number of published studies on the in vivo wear measured on retrieved total knee bearings. These studies indicated more clinical wear on the medial side. Patterns of wear varied greatly among individual knees; a majority showed very similar extents of wear on the medial and lateral sides, however there were cases with significantly more wear on one condylar articulation than the other. Evidence of edge loading was common and seen most frequently in the central zone of the medial condylar area.
Instability is one of the leading causes of clinical faiure after total knee arthroplasty. Instability can be categorized according to four type: extension instabiity, flexion instability, genu recurvatum and global instabi;ity. Basically flexion and extenion gap should be equal. And also medial and lateral gap should be equal balance. we should know basic concepts, the effect of the ligament or capsular structure release. And also surgeon should understand of the nine gap- balancing permutaiion that can occur during revision TKA. After bony mechnical and rotational alignment correction, flexion gap correction first then adjust extension gap methode will be easier to adjust ligament balancing. Joint line elevation should be avoid if possible because this can lead to mid-flexion instability, decreased range of motion soft tissue impingement or anterior knee pain associated with patella infera.
Varus/valgus constrained components should be considered only in the presence of adequate inherent or to stabilize the knee until a ligament repair or reconstruction heal. In a situation of severe varus/valgus, or gobal instability where the knee cannot be stabilized other than through the implant, use of a rotating hinge or linked component is advocated.
The result of the revision TKRA relies upon the causes of failure, method of operation and surgical skill of the surgeon. For the success of the revision, surgeon should do his best from surgical planning to rehabilitation program. I have experienced more than 100 cases of revision TKRA and here I would like to share my surgical techniques of revision surgery in aseptic failure of the primary TKRA. An approach, implant selection, bony reconstruction and fixation methods used are just the same with the principles of other surgeons.
I will describe my surgical tips in removal of the implant, preservation of the joint line and morselized bone graft application.
For removal of implants, I used microsaw instead of Gigli saw. This is because microsaw has advantages of preserving the bone by easy approach to notch and posterior condylar area and less contamination risk.
After partial separation of bone and implant interface by microsaw, I would not remove the implant immediately. Instead I will tap medial and lateral condylar portion alternately with mallet repeatedly until I can see the movement of the prosthesis, and then I will gently remove the prosthesis. By this maneuver, the prosthesis is easily removed with less bony defect.
Before removal of femoral prosthesis, for joint line preservation, I will mark 5–6 cm proximal to the joint line on the femoral metaphyseal area with drill bit. In most revision cases, as the height of femoral prosthesis is maintained, this mark can be good landmark for the joint line insert of the trial prosthesis later at that level, thus the joint line can be preserved.
I also have special tips in morselized cancellous graft. After impaction of morselized bone, the bony fragments are easily dispersed and to prevent this phenomenon, some surgeons apply temporary cement coating over the bone. However, when using cement, the cement can intervene between bony fragment resulting in delay or failure of incorporation. Another disadvantage of cement coating is that the surface may be irregular and interfere with tight fitting of the prosthesis. My methods is by using haematoma to coat on the morselized bone followed by inserting the trial prosthesis in situ, and with knee deflate the torniquette. In most of the revision operation, 2 torniquette times is needed. It means that I deflate the torniquette a little earlier than 1st torniquette time. I do not irrigate for 10 ~ 15 min. After inflation of torniquette, gently remove the trial prosthesis and you can see beautiful shape of morselized graft which is well aggregated with haematoma. In this state, we do not need cement precoating on the morselized graft until the real prosthesis is implanted.
A new hinge knee system (LEGION HINGE, Smith & Nephew, Memphis, TN) was designed to treat gross knee instability resulting from loss of collateral ligament function, femoral and/or tibial bone loss, or from comminuted fractures of the proximal tibia or distal femur. The knee system is offered with an insert that guides the motion of the implant for kinematic improvement. The purpose of this study was to evaluate kinematic and wear performance of this novel hinge knee replacement system.
The kinematics and kinetics of the Guided Motion (GM) hinge knee were assessed for a deep knee bend using a numerical lower leg simulator. Measurements of A/P translation and I/E rotation were compared to 3D MRI data of healthy weight bearing knees and measurements of M/L patella shear forces were compared to a standard primary knee implant. Three GM knee systems were tested for wear performance. All metal components were fabricated from cobalt chrome except for the Ti-6Al-4V insert locking screw. All plastic components were fabricated from UHMWPE. Wear testing was conducted on an AMTI 6-station force controlled knee simulator for approximately 5 million cycles under ISO 14243-1 load/motion profiles and soft tissue constraints. Simulation results showed that up to 130° of flexion the anterior/posteror (A/P) translation and internal/external (I/E) rotation followed a similar path over the flexion range compared to the MRI data. The magnitude of A/P translation at 130° was 9.5 mm for the GM design compared to 15.7 mm for the MRI data. The magnitude of I/E rotation at 130° was 18° for the GM design compared to 20.8° for the MRI data. The GM design showed a maximum M/L patella shear force of 456.8 N compared to 1152.4 N for a standard primary knee design over the flexion range. All constructs successfully completed wear testing and were fully functional with no issues for binding of the mating parts. All polyethylene components showed only burnishing on the articulating surfaces. The volumetric wear rate of polyethylene components was 17.54±1.24 mm3/Mcycle. The volumetric wear rate of the metal components (excluding femoral and tibial tray) was 0.045±0.01 mm3/Mcycle.
Testing showed the GM design has A/P and I/E kinematics that are similar to those seen in a normal healthy knee and good patella tracking as evidenced by the low M/L patella shear forces. The wear rate of the polyethylene parts was within the range of wear rates published in the literature for primary knee designs (up to 35.8 mm3/Mcycle). The low metal wear rate indicates that fretting and corrosion of the components was minimal.
We conclude the GM design more closely replicates the kinematics of the natural knee without compromising the wear characteristics. This could lead to better outcomes for the patient population that requires a hinge knee implant.
Modern Total Hip Replacement (THR) is in general one of the most successful surgical treatments although the functional requirements of modern patients are more and more demanding. Challenges arise from an extended life-span, a higher activity level requiring more sophisticated artificial materials, and a larger required range-of-motion (ROM) caused by the younger patients’ eagerness to continue a sporty lifestyle. The design criteria for modern THR resulting from these patient demands also depend on the anatomical conditions as well as the socio-cultural circumstances of the patients.
Asian people require in general a higher ROM due to their habit to squat during daily activities which is not common in western societies. The outcome of a THR regarding the ROM is influenced by the size of the bearing couple, the design of the acetabular component, the head-to-neck ratio, and the implantation angles. In the case of a wrongly designed or a misaligned component, e. g. a verticalised socket, subluxations and impingement might occur leading to edge-loading between the ball head and the insert. This leads in all material couplings to problems: in hard-soft couplings (ceramic or metal ball head and polyethylene insert) to strongly increased polyethylene wear, in hard-hard bearings (metal-on-metal or ceramic-on-ceramic) to point loading followed by stripe wear and, in the case of a metal-on-metal coupling, a much higher metal ion level in the blood. Therefore, an appropriate choice of the prosthesis design together with the necessary surgeon’s diligence is necessary to avoid this kind of complication.
Other important design challenges come from possible anatomical differences between different ethnical groups. It has been shown that the “asian knee” has a different mean thickness in anterior-posterior as well as medio-lateral direction compared to caucasian. As another example, an extensive study of mexican people has shown a significantly different femur geometry concerning the height of the Trochanter major compared to the cross section of the femoral axis and the neck axis. For asian people it is widely accepted that the mean femoral size is smaller. The nonobservance of these geometrical factors in implant design may again lead to higher wear rates or subluxation and impingement followed by dislocation.
Major orthopaedic surgeries such as total hip and total knee replacements are considered a major risk factor for venous thromboembolism (VTE). Without prophylaxis, DVT occurs in 10–40% of general surgical or medical patients and 40–60% of patients following major orthopaedic surgery. There has, however, been a perception that VTE is less common in Asia than in Western countries. New evidence has emerged recently that contradicts this perception. Results from multinational epidemiological studies (SMART, AIDA, ENDORSE) clearly showed that the rate of venographic and symptomatic thrombosis after major joint replacement in Asian patients is similar to that previously reported in patients in Western countries. However, thromboprophylaxis is not routinely used in Asia, even in situations considered high risk in Western countries. The ENDORSE study reported that less than 20% of at-risk surgical patients in Asia received prophylaxis compared with over 80% in Western countries. This leaves the majority of patients at risk of developing VTE and VTE-related conditions, which continues after hospital discharge. Current guidelines recommend the use of thromboprophylaxis for at least 10 days and up to 35 days in patients undergoing total joint replacement. Available anticoagulants are effective at preventing VTE but are associated with various limitations, such as parenteral administration as in the case of UFH and LMWH. A narrow therapeutic window, unpredictable pharmacology, frequent coagulation monitoring and dose-adjustment as in the case of vitamin K antagonists (VKAs). Several new, oral anticoagulants are in advanced clinical development, including the direct thrombin inhibitor, dabigatran, and the direct Factor Xa inhibitors, rivaroxaban and apixaban.
Rivaroxaban, an oral, direct FXa inhibitor has shown in large phase III trials to be both superior to enoxaparin a low molecular weight heparin for VTE prophylaxis in patients undergoing MOS, and to also have a good safety profile. RECORD, a pivotal clinical trial program investigating rivaroxaban for the prevention of VTE after THR and TKR surgery, consists of four multinational, randomized, double-blind, double-dummy phase III studies (RECORD1,2,3 and 4) comparing rivaroxaban 10 mg once-daily with enoxaparin 40 mg once-daily or 30 mg twice-daily. The RECORD program has consistently shown superiority of rivaroxaban to enoxaparin at preventing VTE after major orthopaedic surgery. Results from the RECORD 2 study confirmed the benefit of extended thromboprophylaxis after THR. Rivaroxaban was more effective than enoxaparin at reducing the incidence of VTE and all course mortality in patients undergoing THR, with a relative risk reduction (RRR) of 70% in total VTE (RECORD 1). In the TKR populations, rivaroxaban was superior to both once-daily (RECORD 3) and twice-daily (RECORD 4) enoxaparin, with a RRR of 49% and 31.4%, respectively. It also significantly reduced the incidence of symptomatic VTE in TKR patients (RECORD 3). Rivaroxaban groups had low and similar bleeding rates to enoxaparin across the RECORD program. Thus, with its superior efficacy and a good safety profile, oral, once-daily fixed dosing with rivaroxaban could transform the future of VTE prevention after major orthopaedic surgery and improve the quality and reliability of patients care.
We analyzed the radiographic results of patients treated surgically for flatfoot deformity and who underwent medial cuneiform opening wedge osteotomy as part of the operative procedure. The aim of this study was to confirm the utility of the cuneiform osteotomy as part of the correction of hindfoot and ankle deformity. All patients requiring operative management of flatfoot deformity between January 2002 and December 2007 were prospectively entered in a database. We selected all patients who underwent medial cuneiform opening wedge osteotomy. We measured standardized and validated radiographic parameters on pre and post-operative weight bearing radiographs of the foot. All radiographs were assessed using the digital imaging software package (Siemens). The following measurements were used: lateral talus-1st metatarsal angle; medial cuneiform to floor distance (mm), talar declination angle, calcaneal-talar angle, calcaneal pitch angle, 1st metatarsal declination angle, talonavicular coverage angle, and anteroposterior talus-1st metatarsal angle. Other variables including concomitant surgical procedures, healing of the osteotomy, malunion, and adjacent joint arthritis were also noted. There were 86 patients with a mean age of 36 years (range 9–80). 15 patients had bilateral surgery. The aetiology of the deformity was flexible flat-foot in 48, rupture of the posterior tibial tendon in 41, rigid flatfoot deformity with a fixed forefoot supination deformity in 7, and fixed forefoot varus with metatarsus elevatus in 5. In addition to an opening wedge medial cuneiform osteotomy, a lateral column lengthening calcaneus osteotomy was performed in 80, a gastrocnemius recession in 76, a supramalleolar osteotomy in 2, a triple arthrodesis in 4, a subtalar arthroerisis in 13, excision of an accessory navicular in 6, a tendon transfer in 15 and medial-slide calcaneal osteotomy in 8 patients. The mean lateral talus-1st metatarsal angle improved from 23° to 1°; the mean medial cuneiform to floor distance improved from 20mm to 34mm; the mean talar declination angle improved from 39° to 27°; the mean calcaneal-talar angle improved from 64° to 55°; the calcaneal pitch angle improved from 14° to 23°; the mean 1st metatarsal declination angle improved from 17° to 26°; the mean talonavicular coverage angle improved from 45° to 18°; and the mean anteroposterior talus-1st metatarsal angle improved from 19° to 0° Radiographical analysis confirms that the medial cuneiform opening wedge osteotomy is a reliable and valuable surgical tool in the correction of the forefoot which is associated with flatfoot deformity and that arthrodesis of the 1st metatarsocuneiform joint may not be required to obtain correction of the elevated 1st metatarsal.
Surgical treatment is considered for treatment of plantar fasciitis in the 10% of patients who do not improve with large range of non-operative measures. The aim of this study is to describe a surgical technique that maintains normal foot mechanics by preserving the integrity of plantar fascia and to demonstrate its effectiveness in the treatment of severe plantar fasciitis unresponsive to no-operative treatment.
The study is a retrospective-prospective analysis of patients who underwent surgery for plantar fasciitis unresponsive to at least 6 month of non-operative measures. The surgical technique involves excision of the heel spur if present, drilling of the calcaneus and a split of the plantar fascia in line with its fibres taking great care not to detach it from its calcaneal attachment. The clinical outcome was assessed prospectively using the Foot and Ankle Ability Measure which is a self-reported questionnaire used to assess the effectiveness of treatment in ankle and foot disorders.
Between 1993 and 2007, 52 patients (56 feet) had surgery for plantar fasciitis. There were 35 females and 17 males and the average age at surgery was 51. Retrospective data was available on all patients. No patients had prior surgery for their symptoms. Of 52 patients treated, 34 were able to be contacted at an average of 46 months after surgery. The average FAAM score was 93 (maximum of 100, 95%CI, 89, 97) and 80% of patients reported a normal or nearly normal overall level of function with no reports of a severely abnormal level of function. Two patients reported no change in symptoms after the surgery. All other patients reported they were satisfied with the outcome of surgery. No patient reported recurrence of symptoms or further surgery for plantar fasciitis. The early postoperative complications were superficial cellulitis (2 patients), wound breakdown (3 patients) and deep vein thrombosis (1 patient). The only long term complication was hypoaesthesia around the surgical scar (8 patients) with no adverse impact on the final outcome.
Plantar fascia release or division has been associated with altered foot biomechanics which may be responsible for forefoot fractures and medial and lateral column foot pain sometimes described after this procedure. Our surgical technique avoids these problems by preserving the integrity of plantar fascia and at the same time is very effective in relieving the symptoms of chronic and severe plantar fasciitis.
The aim is to review the functional results of reconstruction of neglected Achilles Tendon Ruptures, in which the gap between the ruptured ends was a minimum of 6 cm. All ruptures had a gap of 6–8cm, intraoperatively, between the ruptured ends when the foot was put into plantigrade.
There are 9 patients in our case series, who presented with neglected Achilles Tendon ruptures over a six year period. All reconstructions were done by a single surgeon. All patients had a a reconstruction done using 2 strips of gastrocnemius aponeurosis turned down to bridge the gap, with the foot in plantigrade and augmented with flexor hallucis longus. The flexor hallucis longus was threaded through the distal stump and tenodesed and myodesed to the reconstructed Achilles tendon.
All patients were put in a non-weight bearing cast for 6 weeks followed by partial weight bearing, physiotherapy and strengthening exercises. There were no complications in our series. Six patients were available for assessment. At minimum of 2 years, AOFAS Score is 94.2, Ankle Hindfoot Visual Score of 0 in 5 and 5/10 in:
The SF 36 ranged from 75 to 96 for the various functions and patients rated the results from good to exellent with expectations of the surgery being met in most patients.
Reconstruction of Neglected Achilles Tendon Ruptures with a large gap are challenging. Methods proposed include transfers of various tendons, free grafts, allografts and synthetic materials. The gastrocnemius turn down flap with flexor hallucis longus augmentation can bridge a gap of 6–8cm with the foot in plantigrade. Rehabilitation can start after 6 weeks casting. The results show that most patients have achieved a good functional outcome and are satisfied to happy with the surgical outcome.
A consensus for the best treatment for acute Achilles tendon ruptures has not yet been reached. Non-operative functional treatment using ankle foot orthosis has shown a reduction in re-rupture rate. This study aims to compare operative, cast immobilisation and functional treatment with cam- walker for acute Achilles tendon ruptures.
A retrospective review of medical records of patients with acute Achilles tendon rupture between 1999–2770 was carried out. Open repairs were carried out in the surgical group. In the cam- walker group, patients were immobilised in equines backslab for 2 weeks and then transferred to cam- walker with 3 heel-wedges giving plantar flexion of 20–30 degrees. One wedge was removed weekly after 4 weeks. After 6 weeks, patients removed the cam-walker at night. After 10 weeks, they mobilised in a shoe with a raise. After 12 weeks, the cam-walker was removed. There were 56 patients reviewed of whom 20 were treated operatively, 23 were treated non- operatively in a cast and 13 were treated functionally in a cam-walker. The average age of operative group was 39 years with average post operative immobilisation in a cast of 7.4 weeks. 15% had major complications with 2 DVTs and 1 re-rupture and 45% minor complications with 4 wound infections, 3 sural nerve damage and 2 patients complained of pain. The average age of non-operative group in a cast was 46 years with average immobilisation of 8 weeks. 12% had minor complications with 2 DVTs, 1 re-rupture and 12% healing complications with 1 non- healing and 2 delayed healing.
The average age of functional group treated with cam- walker was 44.5 years. They were immobilised in a cast for 2.5 weeks and cam-walker for 9 weeks. There were 35% major complications with 3 DVTs and no re-ruptures. 2 DVTs were treated and 1 DVT spontaneously resolved.
Metz et al. (2007) conducted a similar study and found that 34% of surgically treated patients suffered from complications other than rerupture. The main advantage they found with conservative treatment is the elimination of wound complications and intra-operative sural nerve damage. This retrospective review shows that surgical treatment provides a lower re-rupture rate but higher complication rate. A prospective study is currently underway to look at re-rupture rates and functional outcome after non-operative functional treatment with cam-walker.
Acute peroneal tendon tears present as a relatively sudden onset of lateral ankle or hindfoot pain, frequently in conjunction with a traumatic episode or injury. Underlying or causative factors, including recurrent ankle sprains, hindfoot varus leading to ankle instability, or dislocating peroneal tendons may be associated and can often lead to peroneal tendon tears being overlooked as a cause of persistent lateral ankle or foot pain. Some apparently acute peroneal tendon tears may represent an acute manifestation of an underlying chronic or subclinical abnormality.
The spectrum of peroneal tendinopathies includes tenosynovitis, tendinosis, subluxation or dislocation, stenosing tenosynovitis, disorders of the os peroneum, and conditions related to accessory peroneal tendons, as well as acute and chronic tendon tears. These abnormalities of the peroneal tendons may coexist, and one may lead to another, as evidenced by the significant incidence of tears in the presence of dislocating peronei and ankle instability.
Suspicion of the possibility of peroneal tendon injury, coupled with careful clinical examination and appropriate investigation, allows the clinician to identify the extent of damage and to implement a successful management plan. Because peroneal tears signify a mechanical abnormality, this management often entails surgical intervention.
Compression staples are a popular form of fixation for osteotomy and arthrodesis. “Mechanical Compression” or “Shape Memory” designs are commercially available. We performed a biomechanical study to assess suitability for their intended functions.
Compression was measured using a load cell mounted within a simulated arthrodesis site. Two designs of mechanical compression and shape memory staples were tested and compared. The effect of altering the length of the staple limb was also assessed.
Both designs of mechanical compression staple had divergence of their fixation limbs causing inconsistent compression or even distraction. The shape memory staples all achieved a consistent compressive force at the fusion site. Staple limb length did not appear to alter the compression force generated.
The limbs of Mechanical Compression Staples splay open with a fulcrum at the intersection bridge. As a result, there is distraction of the far cortex and compression of the proximate cortex. Shape memory staples compress both the near and far cortices leading to stability and compression forces across the arthrodesis site.
The classification and staging of charcot arthropathy assists us in decision making and appropriate management of these patients. Clinical presentation and diagnosis will be discussed as well as management techniques for the different stages of arthropathy. Neuropathic ulcer management, including new ideas, will be briefly covered.
Scapho-lunate Dissociation is an uncommon carpal instability, but produces significant functional loss and early post-traumatic arthritis. Traditional soft tissue reconstructions have a mixed history of success, and are associated with significant loss of range of motion making sport difficult. This study reports use of modified Brunelli reconstruction that allows return to professional contact sport
The Brunelli reconstruction tethers proximally from the lunate attachment of the FCR graft. The modification anchors the tendon graft from the lunate to the capitate across the stretched mid-carpal capsule, and ensures better correction of the DISI deformity and good range of motion.
A cohort of 8 AFL level footballers was treated with this reconstruction, and retrospectively reviewed.
The modified Brunelli reconstruction was used in all cases. Interestingly, 3 of the 8 cases were delayed by over 12 months, and had already suffered loss of cartilage over the scaphoid proximal pole dorsally. The same operation was performed despite this relative contra-indication. This was protected by a specific translation manouvre to lift the dorsal scaphoid away from the dorsal ridge of the radius whilst the wires holding the reduction were in situ.
All players returned to professional level Australian Rules Football. Follow up examination revealed excellent maintenance of dorsiflexion and good retention of palmar flexion post reconstruction. No players complained of arthritic pain, and no further procedures were performed.
This procedure is an excellent alternative to partial carpal fusion which is promoted in the literature as the only reliable treatment option for symptomatic scapho-lunate instability.
The unresolved ankle sprain is one of the most common referrals to a specialist orthopaedic foot & ankle surgeon.
These injuries occur in sports people as well as workers, and frequently cause prolonged sporting inactivity or time off work.
The unresolved ankle sprain can be defined as that injury which does not resolve with appropriate conservative treatment within six weeks. The pathology causing an ankle sprain to be unresolved can involve soft tissue or bony structures.
Thorough clinical and radiological assessment is necessary to secure the diagnosis, institute effective surgical treatment and counsel the patient accurately with regards to prognosis for the injury.
This paper discusses the differential diagnosis & surgery in order to resolve prolonged disability after the common ankle sprain.
I will discuss a personal approach to managing this condition at each stage of presentation, considering how appropriate each alternative treatment may be, and describing in detail what happens to such patients in my practice.
As specialist hand surgeons, we pride ourselves on a diagnostic suspicion whenever we are met with an appropriate history or likely injury mechanism. We are able to assess the patient individually, their plain radiographs, MRI arthrograms and arthroscopic findings. The challenge in providing a service for this injury, is to extend that knowledge (or make it readily accessible) to a wider group of generalists in Orthopaedic Surgery, Trauma Surgery and Emergency Medicine.
I will describe my method of assessment with preferred imaging techniques.
I will illustrate some of the pitfalls in decision making with a series of case examples, and explain my personal approach.
Acute repair Reconstruction Salvage
I will describe my preferred techniques, which procedures I no longer perform (and why) and rehabilitation programmes in detail for these categories.
Injuries to the tarsometatarsal joint complex are uncommonly recognised. Many treatment modalities have been advocated. In recent years anatomic reduction and temporary rigid fixation with trans -articular screws has become popular.
This is a study conducted over a period of at least two years. It reviews the management and subsequent outcome of a series of consecutive patients with an average age of 40.1 who suffered tarsometatarsal injury, or Lisfranc fracture.
Anatomic or near anatomic reduction was achieved using temporary bridging plate fixation of the TMT joints and occasionally also with second metatarsal base medial cuneiform screw fixation.
Two years post surgery a good or excellent functional result was generally achieved; however midfoot stiffness was a common problem.
There are numerous causes of cavovarus feet, the most common of which are the hereditary motor and sensory peripheral neuropathies. Regardless of the underlying aetiology, cavovarus feet are caused by muscle imbalance. Often the imbalance is between a relatively strong tibialis posterior acting against a weaker peroneus brevis, and a relatively weak tibialis anterior being over powered by peroneus longus. Intrinsic muscle weakness and gastro-soleal tightness is common.
After the failure of non-operative management, flexible deformity can be corrected with a combination of tendon transfers and osteotomies. Frequently surgical management of cavovarus feet involves a combination of calcaneal and first metatarsal osteotomies, peroneus longus to brevis transfer, transfer of tibialis posterior through the interosseous membrane to the dorsum of the foot, tendo-Achilles and plantar fascia lengthening and correction of toe deformities.
The post-operative recovery is slow, but most patients achieve good functional results and report improvements in their activities of daily living.
I routinely request MRI with contrast before bone graft surgery so that I can give the patient an idea of the likely success of that surgery beforehand.
This enforced restriction means that all my bone grafts now come from the distal radius. There is good evidence to support the use of graft from this site – especially in the younger male. As a result, I developed the technique of employing vascularised grafts for all my scaphoid non-unions. Not necessarily because I thought they were any better, but because they were straightforward to perform, offered no disadvantages, and may actually offer an advantage.
I favour the palmar grafts described by Mathoulin because of the biomechanics of the humpback deformity. Scaphoid waist non unions need a palmar wedge to restore their length and shape. Using a corticocancellous palmar wedge graft from the distal radius provides this.
Proximal pole non unions do demand a different approach (both surgically and in decision making). The Zaidemberg dorsal graft is usually more appropriate for these cases, but I recommend developing skills in both techniques to use the right graft for the right indication.
I will illustrate the surgical and rehabilitation techniques I employ in some detail, and discuss the results of these treatments in my personal series.
I will illustrate and justify the salvage techniques I consider in scaphoid non union.
Complex carpal injuries can be difficult to assess and manage. They usually occur following high energy injuries to the wrist.
Imaging in the form of traction views and a CT scan can help understand the detail of the fracture dislocation pattern.
Perilunate dislocations and perilunate fracture dislocations are commonly managed with a dorsal approach to provide an anatomic reduction. A volar approach can be used is median nerve entrapment and allows a surgical repair of the volar aspect of the lunotriquetral ligament.
Perilunate dislocations are often classified into greater and lesser arc injuries. The greater arc injuries include fractures which go through the radial styloid, scaphoid, capitate or triquetrum. Lesser arc injuries are through the scapholunate ligament and lunotriquetral ligament. It is common for there to be a combination of greater and lesser arc injuries.
We have also identified a complex injury which is a lunate intra-arc injury. This is a fracture through the lunate. With this translunate perilunate dislocation it is important to stabilise the lunate prior to stabilising the remainder of the carpus.
The authors have reviewed a series of complex injuries and developed a classification system based on the above findings. In complex cases where reconstruction is difficult then salvage procedures can be performed. SLAC wrist procedure, proximal row carpectomy and full wrist fusion can be performed particularly in highly comminuted cases or cases with a delayed presentation.
This study has developed a unifying theory of carpal motion based on computer derived isometric constraints which guides the movement of particular bones. This extends the previously reported concept of rules based animation which proposes that resultant motion is a net interplay of bone shape, isometric constraints, bone interaction, and applied load
The positional relationship between bones of the proximal row and the radius at extremes of motion was assessed to identify isometric constraints, based on a computer derived analysis rather than by observation of carpal bone motion or ligamentous anatomy. Using 3-D surface rendering software, models were created from the CT scan data of 10 normal wrists taken in extremes of radial and ulna deviation as well as flexion and extension.
Virtual lines were identified between specific points of the lunate and radius which corresponded to an isometric constraint through range. Similar pairs of points were found at the trapezium and scaphoid and dorsally at the scapho-lunate joint. There was a clear discrepancy (p < .05) between those areas (typically either volar or dorsal depending on the bones) which remain isometric and those which did not and this corresponded to previous documented anatomical structures. Variability in the pattern of isometric lines correlated with variation in scaphoid motion, thus providing a correlation with previous carpal motion observations. The Carpus can be seen to function as a stable central column (lunate/capitate/hamate/trapezoid/trapezium), with a supporting lateral column (scaphoid). This functions more as a “crossed four bar linkage” than the traditionally described “slider crank”. On the medial side of the central column, the triquetrum acts principally as an ulna translation restraint. The “trapezoid” shaped trapezoid places the trapezium anterior to the transverse plane of the radius and ulna, and thus rotates the principal axis of the central column to correspond to that used in the “Dart Thrower Motion”.
This model provides a unifying theory for understanding normal and abnormal wrist motion based on isometric constraints and more broadly rules based motion. The characterisation of isometric constraints within the proximal carpal row has allowed the quantitative analysis of carpal dynamics, which has as its core, a stable central carpal column – with a lateral column stabiliser, and medial column translation restraint key to safe administration of anaesthetic in the upright position.
Following a laboratory rat study where iliac crest was removed, the femoral vessels were placed as a pedicle through the centre of the graft which was wrapped in silastic sheeting and transplanted to the subcutaneous abdominal wall, which showed in all cases bone revascularisation and viability within three weeks. A human study followed in two patients with chronic complex scaphoid non unions where iliac crest was placed in the anterior interosseous pedicle in the proximal forearm. The pedicle was ligated proximally. Four months later, the graft was dissected on its pedicle distally to the scaphoid. In both cases, the scaphoid united and in both cases the bone was viable at biopsy. Rather than this tedious two stage procedure, Russe and Fisk grafts are routinely pedicled with the superficial radial vessels flowing retrograde at scaphoid bone grafting.
At the same time of our rat study, Zaidemberg published his dorso-radial radius vascularised pedicled bone graft on the “irrigating artery”. The details were scant as they were at the oral presentation three years later. The irrigating artery was subsequently beautifully demonstrated in Zancolli’s Atlas of Hand Surgery and this and other dorsal pedicled bone grafts of the radius have been well described by Bishop and colleagues at the Mayo Clinic. The technique of 1-2 SRA (Zaidemberg) pedicled bone grafting is described in detail together with the indications for prefabrication and vascularised pedicled bone grafting and the necessary pre operative imaging information to plan and select the correct procedure.
A new technique of trapeziometacarpal suspension arthroplasty is described.
Suspension arthroplasty as a treatment for trape-ziometacarpal arthritis has been studied extensively in the literature, but only using relatively weak forms of tendon-bone fixation. Interference screw fixation for tendon grafts has been proven in other areas of the body such as the knee and shoulder. Our technique involves trapeziectomy and suspension arthroplasty using one half of the flexor carpi radialis tendon, left attached distally. A short segment (approximately 2 cm) is harvested and passed through a 4 mm drill hole in the proximal thumb metacarpal. This is accurately positioned using an initial K-wire and then a cannulated drill. Fixation is achieved with a 4 mm Bio-tenodesis screw (Arthrex) and enhanced using a 4/0 Fibrewire (Arthrex) Krackow suture weave. Due to the strength of fixation, no supplemental fixation is required and immobilisation is only used in the initial postoperative period. There is no need for additional support in the form of tendon interposition.
Although these are preliminary results, this technique shows promise for an improvement in outcome for the surgical treatment of thumb carpometacarpal arthritis, compared to current methods
Ulnar styloid fractures may contribute to negative outcomes after distal radius fractures due to its association with distal radioulnar (DRUJ)instability and injuries of the triangular fibrocartilaginous (TFCC) complex. This study assesses clinical outcomes of untreated ulnar styloid fractures after internal fixation of distal radius fractures.
Patients undergoing operative fixation for distal radius fractures from January 2004 to June 2006 were divided into those with and without ulnar styloid fractures. The two groups were compared in terms of wrist range of motion, ulnar sided wrist pain, extensor carpi ulnaris (ECU) tendinitis, TFCC grind test, and DASH scores.
Thirty-one males and 23 females aged 50.9 years(18–88 yrs, SD 16.5) were assessed. At 24 months, the presence of ulnar styloid fractures had no impact on ulnar-sided wrist pain (p=0.331), TFCC grind test(p=0.917) and distal radioulnar joint instability (p=0.957). There was a tendency towards ECU tendinitis (23.8% vs 6.1%, p= 0.058) in patients with ulnar styloid fractures. There was no significant difference in the range of motion and overall DASH scores (8.0 vs 5.9, p=0.474).
No association was found between ulnar styloid fractures and DRUJ instability in this study. Ulnar styloid fractures behave like avulsion injuries. In the absence of DRUJ instability, conservative management of ulnar styloid fractures during operative treatment of distal radius fractures do not compromise clinical outcome.
A retrospective review was conducted to evaluate the long term results of surgically excised wrist ganglia over a six year period between January 1998 and March 2005.
The study involved patients who had undergone ganglion surgery around the wrist joint who were contacted by telephone and on whom a follow-up questionnaire was performed. The study included 117 patients with a mean follow up period of 4.2 years (range 1.5 – 8.7 years). There were 40 (34%) dorsal and 77 (66%) volar ganglia. The recurrence rate for surgically excised dorsal ganglia was 32.5% and for volar ganglia was 46.8%. Recurrence occurred in 58% of patients who had previously had their ganglion aspirated. The overall risk of developing a moderate to severely tender scar was 19% and an unsightly scar 9%. In those patients with recurrence of their ganglia, this was 33% and 8% respectively. Despite 49 patients experiencing recurrence, 24 were still satisfied with their treatment and 30 patients would still choose surgical treatment again knowing the risk of recurrence
This study questions the effectiveness of surgery in the treatment of wrist ganglia in that recurrence rates are similar to rates seen in studies merely observing or aspirating ganglia. Not only does one have to question the surgical risks that are undertaken but also the demands on healthcare resources.
The effect of cup geometry in uncemented Total Hip Arthroplasty has not been investigated. We reviewed the radiological and clinical results of 527 primary total hip arthroplasties. We assessed the bone ingrowth potential of two geometric variations of an uncemented cup and compared hydroxyappetite and porous coated shells.
Patients undergoing primary hip arthroplasty between 1997 and 2004 were prospectively entered into an arthroplasty database. Patients were reviewed at 1,2,4,5,8 and 10 years post surgery. Three acetabular shell types were used. These included hemispherical cups with porous or hydroxyapatite coating, and cups with peripheral expansion with porous coating. Radiographs with minimum 1-year follow-up were examined in 542 cases, using digital templating software. Radiographs were assessed for signs of bone in-growth, lucent lines, migration and polyethylene wear. Survivorship analysis was performed using Kaplan-Meier analysis with 95% confidence intervals. Radiological findings and cup type were analysed using Fishers exact test.
Radiological evidence of bone ingrowth was seen in 82% of hemispherical cups, compared with 59% of peripherally expanded cups, which was significant (p,0.05). Bone ingrowth was not affected by the presence of HA coating. The most common diagnoses were osteoarthritis (67%) and avascular necrosis (12%). The mean age was 56 years. Survivorship with revision or impending revision for aseptic loosening was 95.6% at 7 years (95%CI 1.0134-0.8987). The 3 revisions and 1 impending revision for loosening were in patients with avascular necrosis (3) or previous acetabular and femoral osteotomies for DDH (1), with a mean age of 44 years.
Hemispherical shells have improved radiographic outcome in comparison with peripherally expanded components. At 7 years, clinical results are similar for both components.
The aim of the study was to develop a simple and effective method of determining acetabular component ante-version at the time of surgical implantation. A technique using a laser beam was developed, and put into practice.
Ante-version and closure of the component determine the three-dimensional position. Ante-version is particularly difficult to judge because of lack of perspective from the surgeons position. Using a standard industrial laser, a protractor and a tripod, a beam is projected across the operative field, allowing the acetabular impactor handle to be lined up, at predetermined angle. The patient needs to be positioned accurately preoperatively, and secured in a stable fashion to the operating table. The operating table needs to be parallel to the floor.
We have found this technique easy-to-use. It is less invasive than the computer navigation techniques requiring skeletal fixation, but it does not provide as much information. It is simple, inexpensive, easily transportable. As far as anteversion measurement is concerned, because of the longer distance of projection it provides a greater degree of confidence in alignment, than the standard short jigs which attach to the handle of the acetabular impactor.
Femoral bone preservation is an important consideration in total hip replacement for those patients expected to outlive the success of their primary procedure. A clinical study was initiated to assess the performance of a new, ultra-short, cementless femoral implant that is sited in the region of the femoral neck.
This two-centre study, conducted in Australia and Germany, was approved by the ethics committees and regulatory authorities in both countries. Patients aged between 25 and 65 with non-inflammatory arthritis were included subject to review against the detailed study selection criteria and the provision of written informed consent.
Patients were assessed pre-operatively using the Harris Hip Score and Oxford Hip Score. These scores were repeated and standard radiographs taken at 3, 6, 12 and 24 months follow-up. Radiostereometric analysis (RSA) was employed to monitor the in-vivo femoral implant stability. The Oxford Hip was additionally collected at 36 and 48 months.
Forty-one patients, 23 males and 18 females, received the SILENT™ femoral implant in primary total hip replacement surgery between January and November 2003. The mean age was 50.4 years (range 26–65) with an average BMI of 26.6 (Range 19–37). The diagnoses included osteoarthritis (68%), AVN (15%), DDH (7%), post-infection osteoarthritis (5%) and others (5%).
The average Harris Hip Score increased from 54.3 (Range 26–80) pre-operatively to 95.0 (Range 46–100) at 24 months. This improvement was supported by the patient’s view with the mean Oxford Hip Score data changing from a pre-operative level of 38.9 (Range 19–52) to a 4-year average of 13.2 (Range 12–27).
The radiographic performance is also positive with only one patient having evidence of a radiolucent line on the latest x-rays at 24 months however this is non-progressive and has been present since 6 months post-op. RSA data shows the mean values for the translations of the implant and distal tip in any of the three axes to be low out to 2 years follow-up indicating a high degree of stability in this critical post-operative period.
No revisions of the SILENT™ implant have been undertaken to date.
Early prosthetic stability is acknowledged as a critical success criterion for any new femoral implant being introduced into clinical practice. This has been demonstrated for a new, ultra-short, femoral implant thereby presenting a new solution for patients who could benefit from healthy bone preservation at the time of primary surgery.
There are several different ways of preparing the femoral canal prior to cementing a hip prosthesis. This study investigated the mechanical strength of the cement-bone interface of four different types of preparation determined by the maximum tensile force required to separate a cemented prosthesis from its cancellous bone origin.
Forty-eight fresh-frozen ox femora were prepared for hip arthroplasty, In a four-way comparison, groups of eleven femora were prepared by irrigation using
syringe injected normal saline; hydrogen-peroxide soaked gauze; pulse-lavage brushing; and pulse-lavage brushing and hydrogen-peroxide soaked gauze combination.
Specimens were secured to a Material-test System (MTS), and the femoral implant pulled from the femur uni-axially at a rate of 5mm/min. The ‘pull-out strength’ was defined as the maximum tension recorded by the MTS during separation. Cement interdigitation was also inspected for each technique by microscopy of eight bone-implant transverse sections taken from prepared specimens.
Following an analysis of variance and pair-wise Fisher comparison, the average pull-out strength of the cemented prosthesis was significantly higher (P< 0.001) using pulse-lavage brushing (mean 8049.2 N), and pulse-lavage brushing in combination with hydrogen-peroxide soaked gauze (mean 8489.1 N), than with normal saline irrigation (mean 947.1 N) or hydrogen-peroxide soaked gauze preparation (mean 1832.6 N). Prosthesis pull-out strength following pulse-lavage brushing in combination with hydrogen-peroxide soaked gauze was not significantly different (P> 0.05) than preparing with pulse-lavage brushing alone. Low and high power microscopy of specimen transverse sections revealed the greatest levels of cement penetration in specimens prepared using pulse-lavage brushing.
This study demonstrated that one of the most effective preparations of the femoral canal for optimal mechanical fixation between cement and cancellous bone is pulse- lavage brushing. The use of hydrogen-peroxide soaked gauze in femoral canal preparation, either alone or in combination with pulse-lavage brushing, may not significantly improve prosthesis fixation.
Published data has shown that only 45% of acetabular components were in an acceptable position, where positioning was determined clinically by the surgeon intra-operatively. The aim of this study is to assess the accuracy of cup orientation, using computer tomography (CT), when the TAL is used as the intra-operative guide.
In this prospective study, the TAL was used as the anatomical reference for positioning the cup. The TAL was graded 1 to 4 based on visibility of the ligament. The version and abduction angles were estimated clinically and recorded by the surgeon after insertion of the cup. Post-operatively the true orientation of the cup was measured using CT. Statistical analyses were carried out to calculate the difference between the intra-operative estimation of cup orientation and the true cup position as measured by CT. Ethical approval was granted and informed consent was obtained for all the patients.
Forty-eight hips have been studied to date. The TAL was easily identifiable in the majority of cases. Overall, the cup version was under-estimated by the surgeon when the TAL was utilized as the anatomical landmark. The true mean acetabular component version was 26.5 degrees [range from 11 to 41 degrees]. The true mean abduction angle was 43.6 degrees [range from 35 to 55 degrees]. The mean difference between surgeon estimation and CT measurement for cup version was 4 degrees of underestimation [range from 14 degrees of underestimation to 11 degrees of overestimation]. The mean difference for abduction angle was 0.1 degrees [range from 14 degrees of underestimation to 10 degrees of overestimation]. When using TAL as an intra-operative guide, 64% of acetabular components were within the target range of 15 to 30 degrees of anteversion, as measured by CT, compared to 45% in previously published study (Wines, A & McNicol, D, J. Arthroplasty, 2006).
TAL improves the accuracy of acetabular component version, when utilized as an anatomical landmark during cup insertion in primary total hip arthroplasty. It is reliable and easily identifiable in the majority of cases.
Infection in orthopaedic surgery has a large impact on outcome. This study audits the use of a microbial sealant and the infection rate of a single surgeon’s practice over four institutions in an 18 month period. The aim is to demonstrate a reduction in infection rate with its use.
A consecutive series of operative cases using a microbial sealant was compared with a similar number of cases prior to its introduction. A microbial sealant (n-butyl compare cup placement using imageless navigation to a historical control group cyanoacrylate) is used to bond to skin pre-operatively therefore immobilizing bacteria. This would reduce intra-operative wound contamination from skin flora. The criteria for surgical site infection was taken from the guideline for prevention of surgical site infection (1999) form the National Centre for Infectious Diseases.
Over an 18 month period 624 consecutive operative cases where a microbial sealant was used was reviewed. This was compared with a similar cohort of cases prior to the introduction of the microbial sealant. The case load included hip and knee arthroplasty, osteotomies of the knee, knee ligament reconstruction and surgery for neck of femur fractures.
Three deep and two superficial wound infections were found in the sealant group use compared with four deep and three superficial infections in the non sealant group use. The numbers available did not allow statistical evaluation over a trend of infection reduction is noted.
A microbial sealant is intended to be applied on skin after standard surgical skin preparation. The results obtained in this single surgeon’s surgical case audit demonstrate a tendency for infection reduction, however a larger series is required for statistical significance.
In perfroming hip resurfacing arthroplasty, concern has been expressed as to the proximity of the femoral neurovascular bundle during the anterior capsulotomy and the risk of damage during this maneuver. We therefore aimed to identify the proximity of the femoral nerve, artery and vein during an anterior capsulotomy done during a hip resurfacing procedure using the posterior approach.
A standard posterior approach was performed in 5 fresh frozen cadavic limbs. An anterior incision was then used to measure the distance of the femoral neurovascular structures to the anterior capsule. Measurements from the most posterior aspect of the vessels and nerves to the most anterior aspect of the anterior capsule were taken prior to hip dislocation. The femoral head was then dislocated, and measurements were made with the hip in both flexion and extension. In a separate group of eleven patients that underwent routine MR imaging of the hip, measurements were taken to assess the proximity of the anterior joint capsule to the femoral neurovascular bundle, by a specialist musculoskeletal radiologist who had no prior knowledge of the results obtained during the cadaveric dissection
All 5 cadaveric limbs were utilised. 3 were male and 2 were female. The average age was 72.4 years (range 56–84). The patients whom underwent routine MR imaging incorporated 6 males and 5 females with a mean age of 43.7 years (age range 18–64 years). There was no significant difference between the mean distances to the nerve (p=0.21), artery (p=0.21) or vein (p=0.65) between the MR and cadaveric groups. Prior to dislocation the femoral artery and vein were closest to the anterior capsule (mean distance of 21mm) and the femoral nerve was the furthest away (mean distance 25mm). Following dislocation there was a significant increase (25mm to 31mm) in mean distance to the femoral nerve when the superior capsule was cut with the hip in a flexed position (p=0.01) and to the femoral artery in flexion (increase mean distance from 21mm to 35mm) (p< 0.0001) and in extension(increase mean distance from 21mm to 31mm) (p=0.005). When the inferior capsule was cut, there was a significant increase (25mm to 31mm) in mean distance to the femoral nerve and femoral artery when the hip was dislocated and the capsule cut with the hip in flexion (increase mean distance from 21mm to 27mm) (p=0.019) and in extension(increase mean distance from 21mm to 28mm) (p=0.015).
This study suggests that the neurovascular structures are relatively well protected during an anterior capsulotomy performed during hip resurfacing. The procedure may be safer if the capsulotomy is performed with the hip dislocated and the hip in a flexed position while cutting the antero-superior aspect and in an extended position while cutting the antero-inferior aspect.
The aim of the study was to examine the stress and strain relationships in proximal femurs, using finite element analysis techniques. We looked at normal, osteoporotic and osteoarthritic models, to detect any differences, and specifically, in relation to neutral or valgus alignments of the femoral components in a cemented prosthetic femoral head resurfacing situation. A CAD model of a third-generation composite femur was virtually operated upon to implant the femoral component. The femoral component, geometry was of a 54 mm Birmingham hip resurfacing. A 1 mm cement mantle was allowed for. Finite element model is were generated with 10 node tetrahedral elements. The material properties of both cortical and cancellous bone were assigned according to standard parameters.
Our analysis of the stress and strain in the resurfaced femoral head under the implant showed significant reductions in the stress and strain compared to the intact femur and this was the case for all stem-bone interface conditions. This region of high stress and strain was not seen in the model with the stem was overreamed and there was no bone contact with the stem. The stress and strain levels were generally higher when osteoporotic bone was modelled. The peak maximum tensile stress and strain in the cortical bone at the superolateral femoral neck was 4% to 24% greater in the resurfaced femur for all by the conditions with valgus implant positioning experiencing high at peak stresses and strain then neutral alignment. Maximum tensile stress in the cement at the had- implant rim junction was not greatly different for the different bone conditions except for osteoporosis where the stress was almost 50% greater than the other bone conditions. Generally the highest tensile stresses occurred anteroinferiorly and were greater in the neutral alignment than in the valgus alignment. The superolateral offset associated with a valgus orientation, rather than the valgus orientation itself maybe what reduces the stress and strain in the neck leading to a lower incidence of fracture. Stresses were lower than 8 MPa, the fatigue strength of cement, for all the valgus models except osteoporosis. All neutral models contained some locations where the tensile stress exceeded 8 MPa.
The postoperative stress and strain in the femoral head and neck maybe increased in comparison to the intact femur. Under the component there may be significant reduction in stress and strain, causing resorbtion. The biomechanical reason why a more valgus orientation protects against femoral neck fracture is more complex, sends in some critical locations stress and strain has reduced but in others it is increased. Further study is being planned.
Ion levels in the serum and urine of patients with metal-on-metal hip resurfacing implants can provide a means to monitor bearing wear. This presentation will discuss the current results, now out to 5 years for the Conserve Plus resurfacing. In particular, the effect of bilateral implantation on ion levels was examined
Forty-eight patients were studied. Forty-three of these cases were initially implanted with a unilateral resurfacing. Nine of these cases subsequently were implanted with a resurfacing implant on the contra-lateral side 4 to 48 months following the first implantation (staged implantations). Five cases had bilateral resurfacings done simultaneously. All surgeries were done in one institution by a single surgeon. Serum and urine samples were collected pre-operatively, and at 4 months, 12 months and annually thereafter. The samples were analysed for cobalt and chromium using atomic absorption spectrometry with a detection limit of 0.3 to 0.03ng/ml respectively. The data were compared between the groups and also correlated with UCLA activity scores, cup angle, BMI and component size.
All patients showed a rise in ions following implantation. The simultaneous bilateral levels were higher at all time periods compared with the staged bilaterals monitored at the same time point for the second hip, for example cobalt serum at 12 month uni = 2.24, simultaneous bilat = 2.53, staged bilat = 2.05ng/ml, and at 4 years uni = 1.20, simultaneous bilat = 2.93, staged bilat = 2.27ng/ml. There was no correlation between ion levels and UCLA activity score, gender, component size or cup angle (but only 4 hips had cups > 55 degrees).
Bilateral metal-on-metal hip resurfacings performed simultaneously resulted in higher levels of metal ions, particularly chromium, compared to staged implantations monitored at the same time periods. With the exception of a small number of outliers, the levels in this group of hip resurfacings were within the range of metal levels reported for other metal-on-metal total hips.
Geometric and material changes in the femoral neck following hip resurfacing have been linked to femoral neck fractures.
This study developed a unique method to determine the level of influence of the implant stem on the structural changes in the femoral neck following surgery.
A 3D femur model was generated using CT-images. The finite-element model was meshed using 10-noded tetrahedral elements. An ASR hip-resurfacing component (Depuy International, Leeds) was implanted into the femur in load sensitive position. A strain-adaptive bone-remodelling algorithm was used to determine the bone-remodelling behaviour of the femur over a minimum of 2-year period.
Following the analysis, the material properties and stresses in the neck region were mapped onto a cubic mesh, which simulated a CT stack. Moments of inertia, bending moments and shear was calculated for each slice along the neck of femur. These were compared to the pre-operative model.
Bone mineral density changes in the neck region were observed following implantation due to the changes in moments of inertia, bending moments and shear loading.
A method to determine the effect of implantation on the geometric and densitychanges in the femoral neck following resurfacing was developed. This methodology has shown that implant stem geometry affects the load transfer to the femur and the adaptive behaviour of the femoral neck. This will influence the structural integrity of the femoral neck and the long-term clinical outcome of the hip resurfacing component.
Femoral neck fracture is a common short-term hip resurfacing failure mode, but later term fractures are starting to be reported. The fracture pattern may indicate whether etiology is primarily mechanical or biological
Central 3mm thick coronal slices were cut from each of 50 cemented and 2 cementless fractured femoral components (27 males, 25 females). Fracture patterns were grouped as: “edge to edge”, “inside head”, “outside” and “edge to outside”1. Sections were decalcified and processed for routine histology to examine viability and remodelling. Bone viability was judged on the presence of osteocyte nuclei. Components were judged to be unseated if the cement mantle was more than twice the manufacturers recommended thickness. Histological and clinical data were correlated with fracture pattern.
Overall average time to fracture was 6 months (1–85 months). There were 25 “edge to edge”, 12 “inside head”, 4 “outside” and 11 “edge to outside” fractures, which occurred after a median of 2.0, 13, 1.5, and 2.0 months respectively. The majority of the heads were viable, and the fractures occurred through a region of healing bone involving one or both edges. Fifteen heads with a substantial proximal avascular segment fractured at the interface between necrotic and viable bone, typically inside the component. Eleven implants (21%) were considered unseated. All 4 “outside” fractures were found to be unseated. All “inside head” fractures were seated, but 83% (10/12) of them were found to be avascular. The latest failure (85 months) occurred in association with wear-induced osteolysis. Both cementless components fractured early with an “edge to outside” pattern and were found to be substantially avascular.
Avascular heads failed from one month to four years, usually inside the component. Viable heads tended to fracture early through an area of healing bone at or below the rim. Most fractures were technical failure-sand might be avoided with better patient selection and surgical technique.
Irradiating allograft bone may compromise the mechanical stability of the prosthesis-bone construct, potentially having adverse effects on the outcome of femoral impaction grafting at revision hip replacement. This in vitro study aimed to determine the effect of irradiation of allograft bone used in femoral impaction grafting on initial prosthesis stability.
Morsellised ovine femoral head bone was irradiated at 0 kGy (control), 15 kGy and 60 kGy. For each group, six ovine femurs were implanted with a cemented polished double taper stem following femoral impaction bone grafting. Dynamic hip joint loading was applied to the femoral head using a servo-hydraulic materials testing machine. The primary outcome was stem micromotion. Tri-axial micromotion of the stem relative to the bone at two sites was measured using linear variable differential transformers and non-contact laser motion transducers. Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS.
Compared to the control and 15 kGy groups, specimens in the 60 kGy group demonstrated statistically significant greater micromotion in the axial, antero-posterior and medio-lateral axes. A multi-factorial post-hoc power analysis based on the overall effect of group size indicated a power of 0.7. There was no difference in micromotion between the control and 15 kGy groups. The average micromotion in the axial axes was 63μm in the control and 59μm in the 15 kGy group.
The results of this study suggest that a maximum irradiation dose of 15 kGy may not affect initial prosthesis stability following femoral impaction grafting in this model and provide the basis for us to now proceed to in-vivo studies examining the effect of irradiated bone on implant stability over time.
There is evidence that recommends the retention of a well-fixed cement mantle at the time of revision hip arthroplasty. The cement-cement interface has been proven to have a greater shear strength than a new bone-cement interface after removing the old cement mantle.
This study reviewed a series of acetabular revision procedures with a minimum 2 year follow-up where the original cement mantle was left intact. From 1988 to 2004, 61 consecutive cement-in-cement revisions of the acetabular component were performed at our institution. Outcome was based on functional assessment using the Oxford, Charnley, and Harris scoring systems as well as radiographic analysis using the DeLee and Charnley criteria.
In total 61 procedures were performed in 59 patients (40 female and 19 male), whose mean age at surgery was 75 years (range 40 to 99 years). 47 hips (77%) were performed for recurrent dislocation, 12 for polyethylene wear associated with other reasons for revision (aseptic stem loosening in 8, stem fracture in 2, femoral periprosthetic fracture in 1, subluxation in 1), 1 for unexplained pain, and 1 for disarticulation (intraprosthetic dislocation) of a constrained liner. No case was lost to follow-up. There was a significant improvement in the functional scores from the pre-operative status with the patients maintaining a low level of pain. There was one re-revision for aseptic cup loosening at 7 years, with 1 further case of radiological loosening identified at the latest review. There were 6 further cases of dislocation 4 of which were treated with further in-cement revisions. All other cases showed well-fixed components on radiographic analysis and no evidence of failure at the most recent follow up.
The cement-in-cement revision technique can be used in selected cases of acetabular revision surgery, providing satisfactory functional outcomes backed up by good radiographic results. Blood loss and surgical time are also significantly decreased.
Computed tomography (CT) provides a sensitive and accurate measure of periacetabular osteolytic lesion volume, however, there may remain a role for plain radiographs in monitoring osteolysis. This study aimed to compare CT and plain radiographs for determining the progression in size of osteolytic lesions around cementless acetabular components.
A high-resolution multi-slice CT scanner with metal artefact suppression was used to determine the volume and progression of osteolysis around 19 cementless Harris Galante-1 and PCA acetabular components. The mean duration since arthroplasty was 14 years (range 10–15 years) at initial CT. Repeat scans of the hip were undertaken over a five year period to determine the progression in size of osteolytic lesions over time. A second blinded observer manually measured the area of osteolytic lesions off anteroposterior pelvis radiographs and oblique radiographs of the acetabulum that were taken at the same time as the CT scan.
All 19 hips had CT detected osteolysis. Osteolysis was detected on one or both of the anteroposterior pelvis or oblique radiographs from at least one time point in eight of 19 hips (42%). Osteolysis was detected on 31 of 76 anteroposterior pelvis radiographs (41%) and on 22 of 75 oblique radiographs (29%) (p=0.140). Osteolysis was more likely to be detected on plain radiographs if the lesion volume was greater than 10cm3 in size compared to those 5–10cm3 and less than 5cm3 in size (p=0.009). In 10 of 19 hips (55%), CT determined that osteolytic lesions progressed in size by more than 1cm3/yr. The mean volume of osteolysis progression was 3.2cm3/yr (range 1.1–7.5cm3/yr). Progression in size of osteolytic lesions was significantly associated with hips with larger osteolytic lesions at the initial CT (p=0.0004). Radiographic measurements detected progression of osteolytic lesions in 5 of the 10 hips (50%) that progressed. No correlation was found between progression in size of osteolytic lesions as measured by CT and progression in size of osteolytic lesions as measured off the anteroposterior pelvis (r2 = 0.16, p=0.37), oblique (r2=0.37, p=0.15) and combined anteroposterior pelvis and oblique radiographs (r2=0.34, p=0.17).
Periacetabular osteolytic lesions are more likely to be detected on plain radiographs if they are more than 10cm3 in size. Plain radiographs may therefore provide some monitoring value as lesions more than 10cm3 are more likely to be progressive. However, plain radiographs should not be relied upon to monitor the progression of these lesions.
Dislocations remain a significant problem, especially after revision hip surgery. Revision of components, particularly in elderly patients with co-morbidities, can be fraught with complications. The surgeon’s options are sometimes restricted, particularly when the acetabular and femoral components are well fixed. Increased head lengths are often utilized to increase tissue tension, and thus improve stability.
As a niche solution we have designed a low cost modular femoral neck extender. They are manufactured from medical grade Cobalt-Chrome, conforming to ISO 200, CE mark and EN46001 standards. Available in 3 incremental lengths and with different connecting Morse tapers, increases in effective neck lengths of up to 49 mm can be achieved. When both the original acetabular and femoral components are well orientated, the resultant increased tissue tension imparts stability to the hip.
We present a series of 5 patients where we have used a femoral neck extender to achieve stability of a total hip replacement. 4 patients had had multiple previous dislocations. 1 patient was unstable at the time of revision surgery because of a high hip centre. The average age of the patients was 72 years, and the number of previous dislocations averaged 4. The average follow-up after surgery was 22 months. No patients have redislocated their hips.
We present our novel femoral neck extenders as an elegant and cost effective solution to convert an unstable hip to a stable hip, especially when the patient has well fixed and orientated components not in themselves requiring revision.
The purpose of our study was to evaluate the initial results of this new technique of acetabular revision.
Osseointegration and cup stability were assessed by our musculoskeletal radiologist with radiographs at 2 years following surgery, and patients’ clinical outcomes were reviewed. We retrospectively reviewed the clinical records and radiographs of all patients who underwent acetabular revision between 2003 to 2005. Patient’s clinical outcomes and records were extracted from Orthowave and Statwave software. Radiographs were digitised and evaluated by our radiologist on E-film workstation.
Between January 2003 to May 2005, 62 consecutives patients with 65 acetabulum revisions (3 bilateral) were performed by a single surgeon. All acetabular shells were revised to revision tantalum shells with ancillary screws fixation. Fenestrated tantalum augments and wedges of different sizes and shapes were used to address bone defect in our series. 30.7% were Paprosky grade 3 and worse, 21.5% were Paprosky grade 2C. Radiologic review showed none of the cups had a change of 3° or more for cup inclination. There was no migration of the cups of 2 mm or greater both in the vertical direction and horizontal direction from our reference lines during the 2 year period. There were no new radiolucencies in any cases, and all the 9 cups with radiolucent lines post op either filled up or remain unchanged. Postoperative review mean HHS was 79.09 ± 16.16 (Range 33–100). There were 3 cases (4.6%) of dislocation. There were 9 fractures (13.9%) in our series.
In our series of 65 revisions, the porous tantalum revision system has performed well, despite being used to reconstruct fairly significant defects (Paprosky 2C and worse) in 52.3% of our cases. The clinical improvement, stability of the cup at 2 years, and acceptable complication rates would suggest that this porous tantalum system can be an alternative to a more traditional acetabular reconstruction.
Dislocation remains a common complication following total hip arthroplasty, second only to aseptic loosening as a cause of revision. Factors thought to play a role in dislocation include cup and stem alignment, soft tissue tension, surgical approach, patient factors, and design features of the prosthesis, including femoral head size.
We analysed all consecutive total hip replacements at one institution over a 17 year period. Criteria for study inclusion were hips replaced due to primary osteoarthritis with no previous surgery, femoral head sizes of 28mm and 32mm only, and at least one year from date of surgery. 3682 hips fulfilled these criteria. All procedures were carried out using a posterolateral approach with enhanced posterior repair, and a standard method of intraoperative soft tissue balance assessment.
The rate of dislocation was 1.6%. 32mm femoral head size was associated with a statistically significant lower rate of dislocation. However, after controlling for different follow-up times between 28mm and 32mm heads, this difference was no longer observed. Older age at time of surgery and decreased cup anteversion were shown to be significantly associated with an increased risk of dislocation. Ceramic on ceramic bearing surface was significantly associated with a decreased risk of dislocation, after controlling for age, bearing wear and time from surgery. Cup inclination, gender, BMI, and preoperative hip score were not related to dislocation risk.
Our dislocation rate may reflect current dislocation rates of surgeons using the posterolateral approach with posterior capsule and external rotator repair. The risk factors identified and excluded in this study are likely to be relevant to all surgeons who utilise this approach in total hip arthroplasty.
Ceramic head and metal liner hip replacements (COM) have shown reduced wear in comparison to metal-on-metal (MOM) bearings. The aim of this study was to further assess the performance by a wear simulator study under standard and adverse conditions, including the wear of a metal head against a ceramic liner.
Components were Biolox Delta and CoCrMo alloy. Hip simulator testing applied a simplified walking cycle to anatomically mounted prostheses. The lubricant was 25% calf-serum and wear was measured gravimetrically. In hip simulator testing with edge loading a standard cycle was adapted so the head sub-luxed in the swing phase forcing the head onto the edge of the cup at heel strike, this was applied to ceramic on metal and metal on ceramic material combinations.
Under standard conditions the total overall mean wear rate of the MOM THR (1.01±0.38mm3/Mc) was significantly higher in comparison to the COM and COC (< 0.015mm3/Mc). The overall mean wear rate for the MOC bearings (0.71±0.30mm3/Mc) was significantly higher than the wear rate for the COM bearings (0.09±0.025mm3/Mc). The contact of the head against the rim of the cup caused deep stripe wear on the metallic heads of the MOC bearings. This region on the head is exposed to high stress conditions and susceptible to damage in edge contact, the effect of this is increased when the cup is a harder material than the head. The wear of a metal-on-metal (MOM) couple under similar conditions was almost two-fold greater than the MOC couple (1.58mm3/Mc, Williams et al., 2006) providing further evidence of the reduced wear with COM in comparison to MOM.
Reduced wear from COM bearings will address some concerns associated with MOM THRs regarding reports of elevated ion levels clinically. These studies have provided valuable data demonstrating reduced wear with COM bearings. COM bearings are undergoing clinical trials, early data suggests reduced metal ion release in patients compared to metal-on-metal
Whole blood metal ion levels remain a concern in those patients undergoing total hip replacement with metal bearing surfaces. The determination of baseline reference levels are essential if useful information can be gleaned from in vivo studies of functioning implants. We set out to prospectively determine chromium and cobalt metal ion concentrations in patients undergoing total hip replacement to determine reference levels of these metal ions.
100 patients with normal renal function, no occupational or environmental exposure to cobalt and chromium, and an absence of implanted metals were recruited into the study. Metal ion levels were determined using two different assay methods. Both ICP-MS (Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectroscopy) and GFAAS (Graphite Furnace Atomic Adsorption Spectroscopy) are well recognized analytical techniques for the quantification of trace elements. Levels were correlated with gender, age and place of residence.
There was considerable variability in whole blood metal ion levels, with the ICPMS being more sensitive and consistent than the GFAAS method. Direct comparison of concentration levels determined by the two methods revealed no significant correlation. There was no correlation with age, gender and place of residence
Our findings would favour the use of the ICP-MS to determine reference levels and as a baseline for metal ion surveillance pre-operatively in patients undergoing metal-on-metal total hip replacements. We also determined that changes in whole blood metal ion levels are more significant than actual levels in patients who have undergone total hip replacement.
A randomised prospective study of 4 bearing surfaces in hip replacements is being conducted. The primary objective is to identify the best long term bearing surface clinically and radiographically, and metal ion levels have been measured in all cases.
Patieents have been randomised to the 4 bearing surfaces viz. Ceramic on XLinked Poly, Ceramic on Ceramic, Metal on Metal and Ceramic on Metal. Pre operative blood samples and follow up blood samples for metal ion analysis using the ICPMS method have been taken in all patients. As at February 2008 187 patients have been recruited, and metal ion levels at 1 year are available in 52 patients.
Metal ion levels are not increased with Ceramic on XLinked Poly or Ceramic on Ceramic bearings. At 1 year follow up the metal ion levels in Ceramic on Metal bearings is half that of Metal on Metal bearings using the mean levels, and one third using the madian levels. Of note is that the chromium levels in Ceramic on Metal bearings is the least elevated.
Due to laboratory evidence that Ceramic on Metal bearings have the best surface wear characteristics with no head stripe wear, and laboratory and clinical evidence of lower metal ion blood levels, Ceramic on Metal hip replacements could be a bearing surface of the future.
Severe and recalcitrant Greater Trochanteric Pain Syndrome (GTPS), previously known as Trochanteric bursitis, has been associated with torn gluteal tendons. The aim of this study was to assess the physical, functional and quality of life outcomes of combined bursectomy and gluteal tendon reconstructive surgery.
24 patients underwent combined bursectomy and gluteal tendon reconstruction under one surgeon. They were contacted by mail, email, and telephone. 16 were available for examination, two had revision surgery, one had interview only, one moved interstate, one declined and three were lost to follow up. An independent standardised assessment was undertaken. Hip muscle strength was measured by hand-held dynamometry. Trendelenburg sign was measured according to Hard-castle’s protocol and by observing gait. Functional and quality of life measures were assessed via the Harris Hip Score and the Oswestry Disability scale. Pain and satisfaction was measured via a 10cm visual analogue scale.
All patients were female. The mean time from surgery was 18.9 months +/− 8.50. 10 had right sided surgery. The two patients who had revision surgery are not included in this data. Strength of hip abduction was weaker on the ipsilateral side (p< =.05). External rotation appeared to be weaker, however this was not statistically significant. Hardcastle’s single leg standing Trendelenburg sign was shorter on the ipsilateral side (16.3secs +/− 12.3 vs 22.1secs +/− 10.1, p< =.05). Five patients had an ipsilateral Trendelenburg gait, two had a contralateral Trendelen-burg gait. The mean recalled preoperative pain score was 67.73 +/− 31.51 out of 100. The mean post operative score was 14.44 +/− 16.1 (p< =.0005). Patient satisfaction with the results of surgery was rated at 80.7 +/−17.69, out of 100. With regard to function, the mean post operative Harris hip score was 70.9 +/− 25.73 out of 91, and the Oswestry disability score was 15.5 +/− 11.39, out of 100 where a low score indicates better outcome.
Combined bursectomy and gluteal tendon reconstruction appears to be an effective procedure for the relief of pain in patients with recalcitrant GTPS in most patients. High patient satisfaction levels suggest that function and quality of life are improved following surgery. A prospective longitudinal study has commenced to verify these results.
The purpose of the present investigation was to evaluate muscle damage one year after anterior minimally invasive THA by MRI and to compare these findings with MRI investigations performed in asymptomatic patients one year after THA using a conventional direct lateral approach.
Institutional review board approved this study and patients gave signed informed consent. The minimally invasive group consisted of a consecutive series of 25 patients 1 year after anterior minimally invasive THA. The historic control group consisted of a consecutive series of 25 asymptomatic patients (no pain, no limb, full abduction strength) 1 year after conventional THA. Excluded were patients having prior hip surgery or suffering lumbar spine pathology. Tendon defects and degenerations within the insertion of the Gluteus medius and minimus muscles as well as fatty atrophy within these muscles were recorded according to the protocol of Pfirrmann et al. A Mann-Whitney U Test, two sided t-test and Chi-square test were used for appropriate comparison of quantitative and qualitative variables, respectively.
In terms of gender, age, BMI and side no significant differences were shown between the two groups. When compared to the conventional group, tendon defects, diameter changes and signal alterations of the Gluteus medius and minimus insertion were significantly less frequent in the minimally invasive group (p= 0.001–0.03). Fatty atrophy within the gluteus minimus and gluteus medius musculature was significantly less in the minimally-invasive group (p=0.001–0.04).
In terms of structural damage to muscles and tendons of the hip abductors, the anterior minimally invasive approach proves to be less invasive than the direct lateral approach.
The aim of this study was to compare a single-incision minimally invasive posterior approach with a standard posterior approach in a double-blind prospective randomised controlled trial.
A pilot study was carried out to assess the efficacy of the minimally invasive (MI) approach. The protocol described in the CONSORT statement was used as a template for the study design. 100 Primary total hip replacements meeting the inclusion criteria were randomised in theatre to either the MI approach (using a small incision with preservation of piriformis and distal aspect of quadratus femoris) or the standard posterior approach. Hips meeting the inclusion criteria were randomised in theatre using sealed identical opaque envelopes. Patients were blinded to allocation and all patients remained in the group they were allocated to. Pre and post-operative care programmes were identical. Patients were scored by a blinded research physiotherapist pre-operatively, at Day 2, 2 weeks, 6 weeks and 3 months post operation. The primary outcome measure was function, assessed using the Oxford hip score, SF-12 questionnaire, Iowa score, 6-minute walk test and the number of walking aids required after 2 and 6 weeks post operatively. Secondary outcomes were complication rates, patient satisfaction, difficulty of the procedure as perceived by the surgeon, soft tissue trauma (CRP and blood loss) and radiographic analysis.
50 patients were recruited to each group. There was no difference in demographics Mean incision length was 12.8cm and 19.1cm respectively. There was no statistically significant difference in operation time, post-op functional recovery (ILOA score) or length of stay. Pain (VAS) was similar post-operatively, and at 6 and 12 weeks. There was no significant difference in 10 metre walking speed or 6 minute walking distance at 2, 6 or 12 weeks; nor was there a difference in Oxford hip score, patient satisfaction with surgery (VAS), or SF-12 score at 6 or 12 weeks. Blood loss, fall in haematocrit, transfusion rate and CRP rise were similar. There was no significant difference in cementation of the stem (Barrack) or cup position (Dorr). There was one death from PE in the MIS group and one deep infection in the standard group. There was one dislocation in the standard group. The only statistical difference between the groups was less dependence on walking aids at 2 and 6 weeks in the MIS group; there was no difference at 12 weeks.
MIS surgery is safe, and may allow earlier independent mobility after THR. However, the claims of significantly reduced pain, less morbidity, better function and improved patient satisfaction appear to be unfounded.
Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction has become a standard procedure with a documented good and excellent outcome of 70–90%. It has been demonstrated by previous research that all patients following surgery demonstrate a strength deficit of almost 20%. However it is not known whether these strength deficits have an influence on postoperative functionality.
52 consecutive patients (38 males and 14 females) were selected (mean age 27.9 years). All subjects were tested prior and 12 month following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Muscle strength was assessed using a Biodex dynamometer. Isometric strength was examined at 30 and 60 degrees of flexion. Isokinetic testing was performed at 180 degrees/sec and peak torque and symmetry indices were analysed.
No correlations were found between the Cinncinnati Score and isokinetic peak torque for extension. A moderate significant (p=0.001–0.007) correlation (r=0.200.45) was found for peak flexion torque in ACL reconstructed patients. In ACL deficient patients symmetry indices (r=0.36–0.43, p=0.001–0.004) were moderately related to functionality for both flexion and extension.
Quadriceps muscle strength does not seem to be an important predictor of knee function after ACL reconstruction. Flexors seem to be important to protect the graft from overload. In ACLD knees functionality is related to high symmetry indices suggesting similar strength is necessary to perceive knee function as near normal. This is possibly a normal neuromuscular adaptation caused by contralateral quadriceps avoidance.
There is significant disagreement among surgeons regarding optimal placement of the femoral tunnel for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Placement of the femoral tunnel via a transtibial approach usually will not allow consistent overlap between the tunnel and the anterior cruciate ligament footprint. This remains true in recent publications in spite of the fact that the tunnel center lay totally outside the femoral footprint.
We have performed radiographic studies (Feller et al, 1993), cadaveric studies (Kaseta et al 2008) and currently postoperative studies showing that femoral tunnel creation is much more anatomic with an independent drilling technique. We have performed postoperative high resolution MRI exams of both knees using a protocol that reliably shows the anterior cruciate ligament footprint on the normal knee and the tunnel on the surgical knees. The centers are approximately 2mm. apart for independent techniques and 9mm. apart of the transtibially created tunnels.
We are now using dual angle fluoroscopy and high resolution MRI mapping to evaluate the in vivo kinematics of knees following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with independent or transtibial techniques.
It has been suggested that excessive tibial rotation during pivoting tasks is not controlled by single bundle ACL reconstruction (ACLR). This may be partly explained by graft orientation in the coronal plane. The purpose of this study was to assess tibial rotation after ACLR with an obliquely placed hamstring graft.
18 patients were evaluated. All patients had undergone a primary ACLR for an isolated ACL injury within 6 months of injury. All had a 4 strand graft, either semi-tendinosus alone (ST) or semitendinosus and gracilis (STGR) – 9 in each group, each with 2 females and 7 males. Follow-up was at least 2 years postoperatively and all patients had made a good functional recovery and returned to their pre-injury sporting activities. Evaluation consisted of IKDC 2000, instrumented laxity testing, and 3D motion analysis to record tibial rotation when subjects descended stairs and pivoted 90 degrees on landing using a similar protocol to one which has previously been reported.
All patients had made an excellent recovery (mean IKDC score 100 for both groups) and there were no significant differences between the ST and STGR subjects for any of the background variables including anterior knee laxity. There were no differences in the maximal tibial rotational angle between the operated (mean: 20°, range: 10°– 27°) and non operated limb (mean: 21°, range: 6°– 42°). There was no significant difference between the graft types (ST: 20°, STGR: 21°). Females had greater tibial rotation on both the operated and non-operated sides compared to males.
Contrary to previous reports, we found restoration of normal tibial rotation during the pivoting task after a single bundle ACLR. The lack of difference between the ST and STGR groups suggests that this restoration of normal tibial rotation is due to static rather than dynamic restraints. We suggest that it probably reflects the more horizontal graft orientation in the coronal plane for patients in the current study compared to that reported in previous studies.
Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction has become a standard procedure with a documented good and excellent outcome of 70–90%. Important variables of outcome after surgery consist of objective and subjective variables. It is important to examine the relationship between commonly used knee rating systems and functional tests to assess whether there is a correlation between rating systems and functional performance. The purpose of this study was to determine if a correlation exists between four commonly used knee rating systems (Lysholm, Tegner, IKDC, Noyes) and commonly performed dunctional tests: single and timed hop, vertical jump and isometric, isokinetic and eccentric muscle strength.
44 consecutive patients (31 males and 13 females) were selected (mean age 27.9 years). All subjects were tested prior and 12 month following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. The subjects completed the above knee rating scores. The patients were then evaluated performing the following tests: single leg hop for distance, timed hop and vertical jump. Muscle strength was assessed using a Biodex dynamometer. Isometric strength was examined at 30 and 60 degrees of flex-ion. Isokinetic testing (concentric and eccentric) was performed at 120 and 180 degrees/sec. Their results of functional testing were expressed as percentage of the contralateral non involved limb.
A positive correlation was found between single leg hop, Lysholm (r=0.53, p< 0.05). IKDC (r=0.30, p< 00002) and Noyes score (r=0.45, p< 0.01). A positive correlation was found between vertical jump, Lysholm (r=0.21, p< 0002), IKDC (r=0.31, p< 0.0001) and Noyes score (r=0.31, p< 0.0001). There was no correlation between timed hop and knee scores. A negative correlation (r=0.25–0.46) was noted between eccentric peak extension torque at 120 degrees/sec and 180 degrees/sec (r=0.230.26). However it only reached significance (p< 0.04) between IKDC and eccentric torque at 120 degrees/sec and 180 degrees/sec (p< 0.01). In addition there was a moderate negative correlation (r=0.26, p< 0.0004)) between Lysholm score and eccentric peak torque at 180 degrees/sec. No correlations were found for isokinetic and isometric torque for the knee flexors.
Knee rating systems seem to reflect functional capabilities and subjective satisfaction of patients prior and post ACL reconstruction. Isokinetic strength does not seem to be an important predictor of knee function.
The maximum duration of patient follow-up in any of the papers was 10 years. All papers presented results of at least 2 years follow up. In all papers, standardized outcome measures produced results equivalent to those obtained using traditional ACL reconstruction techniques. Complications were detailed in all papers, with each reporting the absence of synovitis in patients for whom the LARS had been used.
Acute dislocation of the patella is a common injury in adolescents and adults and occurs most commonly during sports participation. The injury is most commonly an indirect injury occurring with a pivoting away from the involved knee. Risk factors include young age, generalized laxity, patella alta, patellar subluxation, and trochlea or patellae dysplasia.
The essential lesion of the lateral patellar dislocation is a tear of the medial patellofemoral ligament coursing from the medial patella to the medial epicondyle. The medial patellofemoral ligament is superficial to synovium and the femoral attachment lies posterior to the medial synovial reflexion and is not seen at arthroscopy. The retinaculum becomes confluent with the medial patellofemoral ligament distally. There are frequently bone fragments detached from the medial patella and lateral femoral condyle at the lateral margin and just anterior to the terminal sulcus. Patellar subluxation with an increased TT-TG distance is common.
Studies applied to an entire group of dislocations have not shown acute surgery to be of great benefit. Conservative treatment is usually recommended. I made an exception in the case of large patellar chondral injuries with significant subluxation. Removal of loose bodies, lateral retinacular release and medial patellofemoral ligament repair or reconstructon with a hamstring graft are then recommended.
In cases of recurrent dislocation I recommend an Elmslie-Trillat procedure in addition when there is significant subluxation and closed physes.
Multi-ligament knee injuries require complex surgery. Hinged external fixators propose to control the tibio-femoral relationship, protect reconstructions and allow early mobilisation. However, a uniaxial hinge may be too simplistic for such a complex joint. We investigated the influence of an external fixation device on ligament strains and joint contact forces.
Six fresh frozen cadaveric lower limbs (41–56 years old) were obtained. Displacement transducers (Microstrain, USA) were attached to mid-substance lateral (LCL) and medial collateral (MCL) ligaments, and the anterior and posterior cruciate (PCL) ligaments through minimal soft tissue incisions. Joint pressures were measured by transducers (Tekscan) introduced in the medial and lateral compartments through small sub-meniscal arthrotomies. Flouroscopic imaging was used to construct the hinged fixator centred over the epicondylar axis. Ligament tensile strains and joint contact forces were determined through a passive arc of 20 to 110 degrees of flexion and extension, with and without the external fixator (ExFix™, EBI Biomet Australia).
The application of the external fixation device resulted in minimal change in the mean peak percentage strain of the PCL, MCL and ACL ligaments, while the LCL peak percentage strain decreased. Generally the peak percentage strain for each ligament occurred at or near the same flexion angle in both the un-instrumented and instrumented case within each limb, but the peak percentage strain flexion angles varied significantly across limbs. Peak joint contact forces increased significantly (p < 0.05) in the lateral compartment after attachment of the external fixation device. There was no difference seen in the medial compartment joint contact forces.
This study shows that a uniaxial hinged external fixator can be used in a multi-ligament reconstructed knee to maintain joint congruence and allow early postoperative rang of motion without compromising the results of reconstructions or repairs.
There are many procedures described to address recurrent patellar instability. This study evaluated the clinical and radiological outcome of a cohort of patients who had been treated using an algorithm based on plain radiography and CT findings to select the appropriate surgical procedure.
64 knees in 49 consecutive skeletally mature patients were treated by one surgeon over 4.8 years. They underwent either tibial tuberosity transfer and lateral release (TTT/LR) or lateral release alone (LR) based on their patellar height and tibial tuberosity trochlear groove (TTTG) distance. Of the knees that were reviewed, 33 underwent TTT/LR and 13 LR. 46 knees in 35 patients were evaluated clinically (42 in 32) or by phone (4 in 3) at a minimum of 1 year. Evaluation included the Kujala and IKDC (subjective and objective) scores and 31 knees underwent repeat radiological examination.
There had been one or more further episodes of instability in 6/46 knees (13%). Only one knee had more than one further episode of instability. The rate of further instability was 8% in the LR group and 15% in the TTT/LR group. The mean overall subjective IKDC score was 80 (LR: 85, TTT/LR: 79). The mean overall objective IKDC scores were 79% A and 21% B (LR: 67% A, 33% B; TTT/LR: 83% A, 17% B). The mean overall Kujala score was 88 (LR:86, TTT/LR: 88). Three patients developed a clinically significant haemarthrosis (LR: 2, TTT/LR: 1), one of whom required an arthroscopic washout. The mean postoperative TTTG distance in the TTT/LR group was 8.5mm compared to the mean preoperative value of 16.2mm (p < 0001). However, there was also a mean reduction in the TTTG distance in the non operated knees of 2.6mm, suggesting a clinically relevant measurement error for this variable.
The algorithm resulted in satisfactory outcomes for most patients. However, changes have subsequently been made in an attempt to further improve outcomes. These include using medial patellar glide to assess the requirement for a lateral release, measuring the TTTG distance with the knee extended, lowering the threshold for distal TTT, raising the threshold for medial TTT, and adding medial patellofemoral ligament reconstruction to the surgical options.
Recurrent patellar dislocation is a relatively common disorder in young patients. Historically, treatment options have been based on the underlying disorder predisposing the patient to the dislocation. This has resulted in various soft tissue reefing procedures, patella tendon realignment procedures and boney realignment procedures.
Further research has shown that the medial patellofemoral ligament (MPFL) is the primary restraint to lateral patella subluxation and dislocation. Many authors have published their successful treatment of recurrent patella dislocation by reconstruction of the medial patellofemoral ligament. The most widely used is autologous semitendinosis tendon grafts, as well as synthetic materials, and MPFL reconstructions may be combined with boney procedures. Varieties of fixation techniques have been described involving both the patella and femoral sides.
We present a technique of MPFL reconstruction using the autologous ipsilateral quadriceps tendon. Our technique avoids the morbidity associated with semitendinosis graft harvesting and the drill holes in, and potential resulting fracture of, the patella. The technique is also simple and is associated with decreased procedure costs.
We present the technique and a series of 6 patients (7 knees) with follow up ranging from 8 months to 9 years. The average age of patients at the time of surgery 16–28 years (mean = 20years). There have been no redis-locations. The median Kujala patellofemoral knee score at follow up was 97 out of 100 (Range 69–100). The results compare very favourably to published results using other techniques.
Our technique of reconstructing the MPFL is reliable, produces good results using an objective knee score, and is cost effective.
Medial instability of the patella is most often an iatrogenic condition following surgery for patellofemoral pain or instability. Most often the instability is associated with a previous extensive lateral retinacular release for anterior knee pain without instability.
The symptoms usually involve pain and a sense of medial subluxation at unpredictable times. The clinical diagnosis is based on increased medial laxity of the patella and apprehension with medial translation. A positive gravity subluxation test is often present.
If symptomatic treatment, bracing, and other conservative measures fail, surgery may be helpful. Repair of the vastus lateralis tendon near the proximal patella is usually necessary. The lateral retinaculum should also be reconstituted. At times this can be done with direct repair of the retinacular edges. More frequently the scar tissue filling the defect must be imbricated.
Medial retinacular release has also been reported to be a successful intervention.
Understanding of mechanical factors influencing knee joint loading is crucial for insight into OA progression and development of prevention and treatment strategies. High tibial osteotomy (HTO) changes knee alignment. Forces and moments should also be altered and reduce loading on one compartment.
15 subjects undergoing high tibial osteotomy were enrolled in the study. Markers were placed on prominent anatomical landmarks to indicate 12 body segments. Three dimensional positions of each marker were calculated using fourteen cameras (Eagle 8 mm, Motion Analysis Corp.) recording at 100Hz and a motion analysis system (EvaRT4.6, Motion Analysis Corp.). Three-dimensional external moments and inter-segmental joint forces were calculated using inverse dynamics in the Kintrak™ software. Kinematic and kinetic data from
Mathematical models of patients and surgeons can be built using joint registry data. These models can then be used in a computer simulation yielding results comparable to what has been reported in the literature. The outcome of Oxford UKA is primarily determined by the skill of the surgeon in selecting suitable patients rather than operative experience. Attempts to expand indications for new procedures should be moderated by concerns that the favorable results from pioneering centers may be due to the judgment and experience of the developers as much as their technical skill in performing the procedure.
Currently long term survivorship is highly predictable for total knee replacements. However, they still do not have the functional outcome of a normal knee, particularly in younger people. Using our results published in 1999 we compared the functional outcomes with a modern design implant.
415 patients having an LPS Flex Mobile implant were performed by one surgeon and were assessed using the SF36 functional outcome questionnaire. Patients were looked at pre-operatively, three months post-operatively and 12 months post-operatively. The results were compared with the previously reported study and there were shown to be some exciting changes in respect to functional outcome, particularly in the younger age group, and at the same time not incurring any increased complications. Comparing the 2 studies in 1999 and this study and using the ABS survey where population norms were calculated we showed that the results in the older patients were maintained with no additional compllcations. In 1999 the younger patients performed poorly however in this new study the younger patients returned to the age matched expected norms for the broader community.
Total knee replacements still do not provide normal function in a knee, however, recent changes to design concepts have permitted improved functional outcome for patients particularly in the younger age group.
There is suggestion our National Joint Replacement Registry (ANJRR) does not recognize ‘the surgical learning curve’ for new prostheses. Prostheses introduced post-Registry have the learning curve revisions captured. Prostheses introduced pre-Registry will not and will be advantaged. This paper presents the evidence for this and makes suggestions to correct this issue. A literature search was made for surgery learning curve references. The Swedish Knee Arthroplasty Register was reviewed for learning curve references. The ANJRR reports were examined for evidence of learning curve revisions inclusion in cumulative revision rate curves using Unicompartmental Arthroplasty data. An Internet search reveals 212 references on ‘surgery learning curve’. Some discuss the particular issue of minimally invasive surgery (MIS). The 2004 Swedish Knee Arthroplasty Register (SKAR) report mentions the trend towards increased revision rates when Unicompartmental Arthroplasty was inserted with MIS. The 2006 SKAR report discussed this issue further suggesting the method may initiate a new learning process which can be shortened if the surgeons are offered training before they start using the method. In 2004 the Australian National Joint Replacement Registry report showed that a new Unicompartmental Arthroplasty (Preservation) had a high early revision rate. This prosthesis was launched in 2002 as a minimally invasive product. That report data was used by several prostheses companies and surgeons to widely highlight the prosthesis “poor performance”. The 2007ANJRR report shows that Preservation now has the lowest 2 to 4 year revision rate of all Unicompartmental prostheses. If the surgery learning curve was excluded the prosthesis would not have been disadvantaged in its early data reports. The evidence is that the learning curve exists and disadvantages new prostheses in ANJRR reporting. This now discourages prosthesis companies from launching new products here. Solutions recommend are:
The ANJRR accept and support the issue of “the learning curve” and the adverse impact this has on post ANJRR prosthesis revision rate data &
graphs compared with pre ANJRR prostheses. The first 2 years results of the new prostheses be monitored and discussed with vendors and early evaluators but not reported. The first 2 years of revisions be “quarantined” from subsequent ANJRR reporting so that pre and post ANJRR prostheses are on an “level playing field.”
We have conducted a prospective, observational clinical trial of 34 patients with dual compartment osteoarthritis of the knee treated with a 2/3 Knee.
Exclusion criteria included obesity, inflammatory arthritis and a fixed flexion deformity > 10 degrees.
Subjective outcome measures included Oxford Knee Scores (OKS) and EQ-5D Scores. RSA beads were implanted at surgery to detect loosening, micro-motion and prosthesis wear. Gait analysis was conducted at 1 year post op in a subgroup of patients.
The patients have recorded Significant improvement in their Oxford Knee Scores at 6 months (mean reduction all patients: 17.3, resurfaced 20).
Early RSA results have not detected Significant migration to indicate early loosening. Gait analysis has shown that patients return to approximate normal rather than pre-operative gait.
It is essential that patients undergo primary patella resurfacing to prevent crepitus and associated anterior knee pain.
A study comparing clinical outcomes of 2/3 Knee vs TKA is underway at our institution.
Obesity is considered a risk factor to a successful outcome in total knee arthroplasty. The prevalence of obesity is causing concern as risks associated with obesity are well documented and the incidence of obesity is increasing in the Australian population. Previous studies have not reached a consensus on the relationship of BMI and short term outcomes of total knee arthroplasty.
The aims of this study were to evaluate the relationship between BMI and the degree of flexion achieved at discharge and to determine the influence of BMI on pre and postoperaive range of motion, duration of surgery, analgesia requirements and duration of stay.
Obesity is defined as a body mass index (BMI) of greater than 30 KG/m2. 120 consecutive patients were recruited from patients presenting for total knee arthroplasty (TKA) to two hospitals. They were classified into one of four groups based on their BMI. All patients were assessed pre and postoperatively by the surgical team. Data was collected on type of implant used, duration of surgery, type of anaesthetic, analgesia requirements and length of stay. Knee society scores were collected pre and postoperatively. Three to six month follow-up was conducted by the surgical team to record flexion, ROM and KSS. Statistical analysis was performed using statistical software.
120 patients were available for the study with 61 (50.8%) being classified as obese and 6 patients classified as morbidly obese. (BMI > 40). The average preoperative flexion results were 112.1 degrees (BMI 18.5 to 14.9), 114.0 degrees (BMI 25 to 29.9), 107.0 degrees (BMI 30 and above), while the postoperative flexion prior to discharge was 85 (BMI 18.5 to 24.9), 90.3 (BMI 25 29.9) and 88.3 (BMI 30 or above). The obese patients had a lower ROM preoperatively but there was no Significant difference at discharge. Patients with a BMI of 25–29.9 used the least amount of analgesia and had the fastest surgery time. They also spent the least amount of time in hospital. (6.3 days) Patients classified as clinically obese (BMI 30 and above) recorded the lowest KSS. As BMI increases the postoperative functional knee score decreases but there is no Significant difference at discharge and 3–6 months postoperatively.
The increasing prevalence of obesity in the Western world suggests that a Significant proportion of surgical patients will be in the obese or morbidly obese catergory. This studty suggests that BMI alone does not influence the short term outcomes of TKA. The poorer long term outcomes in TKA may be related to other factors. Further research may be appropriate.
Within the female population, ethnicity was shown to have a Significant influence on the outcome of TKA as inferior results were reported by both Hispanic and African-American patients when compared to Caucasians. This effect is particularly marked in African-American women whose Knee Society Scores were 13% lower at follow-up compared to Caucasians. The differences in the perception of pain noted by the various ethnic groups proved to be a principal factor for outcomes following TKA among women. This study demonstrates that the ethnicity must be considered in assessing outcomes. Within the female population TKA appears to be less successful in Hispanic and African-American patients.
The number of total knee arthroplasties (TKA) performed each year continues to rise and now outnumbers total hip arthroplasty (THA). Obesity is more predominant amongst TKA patients compared to THA. As such we conducted a review to determine if a relationship existed between obesity and acute prosthetic infection following primary TKA.
A review of 1214 consecutive primary TKA was performed from January 1998 to December 2005 with no exclusions. Pre-operative Body Mass Index (BMI), patient demographics, co-morbidities, and operative data were recorded. Patients were separated into obese (BMI => 30 kg/m2) and non-obese groups (BMI < 30 kg/m2) groups and compared for incidence of acute prosthetic infection in the first 12 months following surgery. The prevalence of obesity in patients who underwent primary (TKA) was 59% (n=715) and more females were obese (63%) than males (48%). The number of patients with multiple co-morbidities was similar for the 2 groups.
Median age was 70 yrs in obese patients and 74 yrs in non-obese patients, (p=< 0.001). Median operative time for obese patients was 105 minutes, compared to non-obese patients 100 minutes, (p=0.02).
The prosthetic infection rate was 1.5% (n=18). The rate was more than double in obese patients (2.0%) compared to non-obese patients, (0.8%), (p=0.16). Of the total, 206 patients had diabetes mellitus (DM) and the incidence of prosthetic infection in this group was 4.9%, compared to patients without DM, 0.8%, (p=< 0.001). However there were no cases of prosthetic infection in diabetic patients with a BMI < 30 kg/m2. Patients with combined DM and obesity had a significantly higher prosthetic infection rate 6.4%, compared to patients who only had one of these conditions or neither; DM only 0%, obesity only 0.7%, neither condition 0.9%, (p=< 0.001).
A post operative drain was used in 1109 patients. The prosthetic infection rate was 3 times higher in patients without a drain 3.8%, compared to patients with a drain, 1.3%. When analyzed together it was the obese group without a postoperative drain, who had the highest infection rate, 6%. This compared to: obese with a drain 1.7%, non-obese with a drain 0.7% and non-obese without a drain 1.8%, (p=0.027).
Obesity was a risk factor for the development of acute prosthetic infection in diabetic patients who underwent primary TKA at our institution. Using a post-operative drain reduced the risk of acute prosthetic infection in our obese patient group.
Australia is a society with a diverse mix of people, cultures and languages. Patients presenting at our institution in 2006 who underwent TKA originated from 39 countries and 14 different languages were represented. Little is reported on the outcomes for non-English speaking patients undergoing Orthopaedic surgery. We conducted a prospective study to determine if outcomes were comparable for English and non-English patients undergoing TKA. A prospective observational study of 278 consecutive, primary TKA was undertaken from January to December 2006. Pre-operative Body Mass Index (BMI), patient demographics, co-morbidities, operative data, complications, length of stay and discharge destination were recorded. Functional status was measured preoperatively and 12 months post TKA using the International Knee Society Score (IKS). An interpreter was used for non-English speaking patients for Surgeon assessment and consent, pre-admission assessment and during the in-patient stay. A total of 41 patients (15%) were non-English speaking and of these 38 were female. No patient was lost to follow-up and 94% of patients completed the IKS evaluation at 12 months. The median age, ASA scores and number of co-morbidities were comparable between English and non-English speaking patients presenting for TKA. Median BMI was higher in the non-English speaking group 33.2 kg/m2 compared to English speaking 30.9 kg/m2, (p=0.010). There were no differences in the length of stay, discharge destination or complication rates between the 2 groups. Median preoperative IKS scores were poorer in non-English speaking patients (61) compared to English speaking patients (72), (p=0.002). At 12 months the difference in IKS scores between the 2 groups was even greater. The median score for non-English speaking patients was (116), compared to (142) in English speaking patients. Of the total IKS evaluation, poorer ratings for pain was the predominant cause for the lower scores in non-English speaking patients compared to English speaking patients, p=0.016. Active flexion was also slightly poorer at 12 months in non-English speaking patients 102° compared to English speaking patients 110°, (p=0.075). As there were significant differences in BMI and gender between English speaking and non-English speaking patients, we analyzed English speaking patients separately for differences in outcomes according to BMI and gender. We found no difference in the IKS scores based on these variables.
Although non-English speaking patients undergoing TKA achieved comparable outcomes in the acute phase following surgery, this did not equate to achieving the same functional result at 12 months, compared to English speaking patients. Pain was the predominant cause for poorer results. Further exploration of patient expectations and pain management is required for non-English speaking patients.
Marrow stimulation techniques such as drilling or microfracture are first-line treatment options for symptomatic cartilage defects. Common knowledge holds that these treatments do not compromise subsequent cartilage repair procedures with autologous chondrocyte implantation (ACI). We present our experience with ACI after prior marrow stimulation. This study reviewed prospectively collected data for the first 321 consecutive patients treated at our institution with ACI for full-thickness cartilage defects that have reached more than 2 years of follow-up. Patients were grouped based on whether they had undergone prior treatment with a marrow stimulation technique. Outcomes were classified as complete failure if more than 25% of a grafted defect area had to be removed in later procedures due to persistent symptoms. This includes treatment with revision ACI, allograft transplantation, partial or total knee replacement. 522 defects in 321 patients (325 joints) were treated with ACI. Patient average age was 35 (13–60), there were 185 men and 136 women, with a follow-up of 2–12 Years. On average, there were 1.7 lesions per patient (range, 1–5) with a transplant area of 4.8 cm2 per lesion and 8.1 cm2 per knee. 111 of these joints had previously undergone surgery that penetrated the subchondral bone: microfracture (n=25), abrasion chondroplasty (n=33), and drilling (n=53). 214 joints had no prior treatment that affected the subchondral bone and served as control. Within the marrow stimulation group, there were 27 (24%) failures compared with 17 (8%) failures in the control group. In our review of 321 patients, defects that had prior treatment affecting the subchondral bone failed at a rate 3 times that of non-treated defects. These data demonstrate that marrow stimulation techniques have a strong negative effect on subsequent cartilage repair, and should be used judiciously in larger cartilage defects that could require future treatment with ACI.
Gait analysis is an important tool to measure function following total knee replacement. It is currently unknown whether there is a correlation between subjective and objective outcome variables. The purpose of this study was to analyse relationships between subjective outcome scores and kinematic and kinetic data.
25 consecutive patients (15 males, 10 females) were selected (mean age 68 years, BMI 31.8). All subjects were tested a minimum of 24 months following total knee replacement. SF12, Oxford knee score, knee society and KOOS scores were collected. Muscle strength was assessed using a Biodex dynamometer and symmetry indices were analysed. A timed up and go test and KT2000 measurements were performed.
Strong correlations (r=0.52–0.74) were found between scoring systems (SF 12, Oxford knee score, knee society score, KOOS score) and the timed up and go test. Moderate correlations (r=0.27–0.35) were found between knee scores and KT2000 measurements. Only weak correlations (r=0.09–0.12) were found between knee scores and strength. None of the correlations reached statistical significance. Post hoc contrasts demonstrated adequate power (0.95) of the study.
The finding of this study suggests that outcome scores and objective and functional tests following total knee arthroplasty measure different variables of outcome. Whilst objective tests and gait analysis provide an understanding of joint mechanics after surgery and can be used to calculate resultant forces and moments, patient perceived outcomes have no Significant correlation to knee biomechanics. This may be related to factors such as pain relief, improved quality of life and the ability to perform activities of daily life. In contrast modern implants may provide a satisfactory outcome resulting in high patient satisfaction. The results of this study underline the importance of using subjective patient outcome measures to follow up total knee replacement patients.
Traditionally, the results of autologous chondrocyte implantation (ACI) in the patellofemoral joint have been considered inferior to those in the weightbearing femoral condyles. This study investigated the clinical effectiveness of patellofemoral ACI in a large, single-surgeon cohort.
This study reviewed prospectively collected data of patients treated with ACI for defects of the trochlea and/ or patella with a minimum follow-up of 2 years. Clinical outcomes were evaluated by SF-36; WOMAC, Knee Society Score, modified Cincinnati Score and a patient satisfaction survey.
130 patients reached a minimum follow-up of 2 years (2–9 years, average 56.5 months) after treatment involving the patellofemoral articulation. There were 77 men (59%) and 53 women (41%), the average age at the time of implantation was 37.5 years (15–57 years). The treatment groups included
isolated patella (n = 14); isolated trochlea (n = 15); patella plus trochlea (n = 5); weight-bearing condyle plus patella (n = 19); weightbearing condyle plus trochlea (n = 52); weightbearing condyle plus patella plus trochlea (n = 25).
The average surface area of patellar and trochlear defects was 4.7 cm2 (n = 63) and 5.8 cm2 (n = 98), respectively. The average resurfacing per knee was 11 cm2. There were 16 failures (12%) that could be attributed to a patellar or trochlear defect. 80% of patients rated their outcome as good or excellent, 18% rated their outcome as fair, and 2% rated outcome as poor.
ACI of the patellofemoral articulation provided a Significant improvement in quality of life as measured by functional scores and patient satisfaction survey. The failure rate was comparable to ACI used in other locations, such as the weightbearing femoral condyles.
The goal of this study was to evaluate the outcomes from arthroscopic “all inside” meniscal repairs using the FasT-Fix suture system, performed at the Gold Coast and Allamanda Private Hospitals during 2006–2007
40 consecutive meniscal repairs in 36 patients were performed both in isolation and in conjunction with ACL reconstruction. All repairs were performed by the senior author (PG), using an arthroscopic all inside technique with the Fastfix suture anchor system. Patients were assessed at a minimum 6 months follow up, including assessment with the IKDC subjective form.
36 patients underwent a total of 40 meniscal repairs. The average age of the patients was 23.4 years (range 14–42). There were 65% male (26 patients) and 35% female (14 pts). 67.5% (27 menisci) were medial and 32.5% (13 menisci) were lateral repairs. 4 patients underwent bilateral repairs (1 involving 2 different operative dates). 55% (22/40 pts) were right knees and 45% (18/40 pts) were left knees. The average number of FasT-Fix meniscal anchors used was 3.8 (range 1–10). 62.5% (25 pts) underwent concurrent anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction. 37.5% (15 pts) were isolated meniscal injuries. 55% (22 pts) had associated chondral surface abnormalities. No Significant complications occurred, including no nerve injuries, infections, or post-operative stiffness. 3 patients underwent subsequent re-operation to resect failed repairs, leaving 37 menisci successfully repaired (92.5%). 5 patients 12.5% described some persistent pain post operation. The average IKDC subjective score for those patients with intact repairs was 91 (62–100).
Meniscal repair using an arthroscopic all inside technique provides a safe, reliable and reproducible method of repairing torn menisci, without the need for a further ‘safety incision’ to retrieve and tie sutures. The outcomes from this study indicate that patients demonstrate similar functional results, and low failure rates, similar to other published meniscal repair methods, including the gold standard of inside-out repair.
The purpose of the current study was to compare mid-term outcomes of posterior cruciate retaining(CR) versus posterior cruciate substituting (PS)procedures, using the Genesis II total knee arthroplasty (TKA) system(Smith and Nephew, Memphis TN). Ninety nine CR and 93 PS TKA’s were analysed in this prospective, randomised, clinical trial. Surgeries were performed at seven medical centres by participating surgeons. Clinical outcomes (Knee Society Score, Range of Motion, WOMAC, SF 12 : and radiographic findings), in addition to postoperative complications, were evaluated with a minimum follow-up of five years. Following data analysis, there were no Significant differences in patient demographics or pre-operative clinical measures between the two groups. At the latest follow-up interval, no Significant differences were found between the CR and PS groups with regard to functional assessment, patient satisfaction or post-operative complications. However the PS group did display statistically Significant improvements in range of motion when compared with the CR group. The results of this investigation would suggest that while comparable in regards to supporting good clinical outcomes, the PS Genesis II design does appear to support significantly improved post-operative range of motion when compared with the CR design
We have an aggressive approach to meniscal repair, including repairing tears other than those classically suited to repair. Elite athletes represent the subgroup of patients who place the most demand on the menisci and as a result, place maximum stress on any meniscal repair. Here we present the medium to long-term outcome of meniscal repair (inside-out) in the elite athlete.
42 elite athletes underwent 45 meniscal repairs between January 1990 and July 1997 were identified from a prospective database. All repairs were performed using an arthroscopically assisted inside-out technique. All patients returned a completed questionnaire (Lysholm and IKDC) to determine their current function and any symptoms or interventions that we were unaware of. 67% medial and 33% lateral menisci were repaired (3 patients had both medial and lateral menisci repaired). 83.3% of these repairs were associated with simultaneous ACL reconstruction. The average time from injury to surgery was 11 months (range 0–45 months). Follow-up time was a mean of 8.5 years (range 5.4 to 12.6 years).
In general, function was good with an average Lysholm and subjective IKDC scores of 89.6 and 85.4 respectively. 81% of patients returned to their main sport and most to a similar level at a mean time of 10.4 months post-repair. We identified 11 definite failures, 10 medial and 1 lateral meniscus that ultimately required arthroscopic excision, this represents a 24% failure rate. We identified one further patient who had possible failed repairs, giving a worse case failure rate of 26.7% at a mean of 42 months post surgery. However, 7 of these failures were associated with a further injury, and 2 of the 7 failures ruptured their ACL reconstruction. Therefore the repairs had healed and were torn with reinjury. In this series medial meniscal repairs were Significantly more likely to fail than lateral meniscal repairs, with a failure rate of 36.4% and 5.6% respectively (p< 0.05).
This series reflects an aggressive approach to meniscal repair with repair of tears in a high demand elite group of patients. Despite this, on a worst case analysis 73% were intact at a mean of 8.5 years post repair. We conclude that meniscal repair and healing is possible and that most patients can return to preinjury level of activity.
The AMMFL is an anatomical variant of the attachment of the anterior horn of the medial meniscus to the posterolateral wall of the intercondylar notch. It is distinct from the meniscofemoral ligaments of Wrisberg and Humphrey. This large series prospectively documented its incidence and any associated meniscal or chondral pathology. The study period was from September 2006 until December 2007.
All patients that underwent arthroscopy of the knee for meniscal, chondral or ligamentous pathology including arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction were included. The procedures were performed by the two senior authors, according to their standard protocols at one of two hospitals.
All the findings from the arthroscopies were prospectively recorded in a standardized datasheet. This recorded all meniscal, chondral and miscellaneous pathology including the presence or absence of an AMMFL. This data was entered into a database including all patients.
The results of 401 arthroscopic procedures were recorded during the study period. Of these patients, 14 were found to have AMMFLs, resulting in an incidence of 3.49%, higher than previously reported. (
The associated pathology was most commonly a radial tear of the medial meniscus, found in six patients. One had a bucket handle tear of the medial meniscus. There were three lateral meniscus tears, two of which were associated with an ACL rupture. Two patients had an ACL rupture as the only other pathology at arthroscopy. One patient was found to have a ruptured AMMFL as her only pathology.
This anatomical variant is more common in this Australian sample than has been described in the literature, and there seems to be a relationship between the presence of the AMMFL and a particular pattern of medial meniscus tear, suggesting an influence of this anatomical variant on meniscal pathology.
The posterior compartments of the knee are not routinely visualised during arthroscopy. However, considerable pathology can occur here and be overlooked. The purpose of this study was to assess both the use of posterior knee joint inspection and the use of posterior portals. The operative technique of posterior portal placement is described.
A retrospective audit of all knee arthroscopies performed by a single surgeon from August 2004 to March 2006 was carried out.
108 arthroscopies were performed and posterior portals were used in 20 patients. The posterior portal was used predominately for instrumentation rather than visualisation. The main indication for use of a posterior portal was for meniscal preparation during meniscal repair. Loose bodies were removed from the posterior compartment in six cases. A posterior portal was used to inspect the PCL stump for debridement and possible PCL reconstruction in one patient. There were no specific complications attributable to portal placement.
Posterior portals were utilised in over fifteen percent of cases. These portals are easy to create and are particularly useful in meniscal repair and loose body removal. Specific complications of posterior knee portals have been
Early mobilisation in the first 24 hours post TKR is a cheap and effective way to reduce the incidence of post-operative DVT.
Cemented total knee arthroplasty has excellent long term survivorship however deficiencies of the cement mantle can compromise results. Minimising mantle deficiencies and increasing mantle size, may improve implant fixation and survivorship. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of pressurized carbon dioxide lavage in an attempt to increase cement penetration into bone.
Two consecutive series of TKAs where performed by the senior surgeon. During the first series standard cementing techniques where utilised prior to prosthesis implantation. The bone surfaces were cleaned with pulsatile lavage and then dried prior to cementation (n=69). During the second series a jet of high pressure carbon dioxide was also delivered to the bone surfaces via a hand held device (CarboJet, Kinamed Inc, Global Orthopaedic Technology)(n=50). A single investigator reviewed standardised post operative radiographs with respect to, depth of cement mantle around the prosthesis, and the presence of mantle defects.
The cement mantle around the tibial and femoral prosthesis was divided into multiple zones, similar to that applied by the Knee Society. The depth of cement penetration was then measured for each zone in 0.5 mm increments using a 115% rule. Depths were averaged and then analysed using students’ T test. Cement penetration was greater with the use of pressurized carbon dioxide lavage. The greatest difference was seen in zones 1 and 4 beneath the Tibial prosthesis. A Significant difference was noted between groups.
The size of the cement mantle can be increased with the use of pressurized carbon dioxide lavage. It is postulated that the bone interstices are cleared of fat and fluid more effectively than with fluid lavage alone. This may lead to an improved outcome for cemented total knee arthroplasty.
Kneeling and squatting are the most common “high-demand” activities actually performed on a routine basis by patients after TKR After TKR, patients rarely participate in particularly demanding competitive sports, however, individualized exercise and fitness activities are common. As these activities vary extensively, surgeons are advised to ask individual patients which activities they enjoy for recreation and exercise to enable specific advice to be provided concerning possible impact on the durability of the prosthesis.
Particulate wear debris from the UHMWPE component of implant prostheses typically causes inflammatory cascades leading to bone resorption and prosthesis loosening. Aseptic loosening is the leading cause of joint replacement failure. Green et al. have shown that the most biologically active polyethylene wear particles are in size range 0.3–10 micrometer, determined by filtration and Scanning Electron Microscopy.
A new methodology based on radioisotope tracing is investigated which promises aseptic loosening is the leading cause of joint replacement failureto be more sensitive and may allow the characterization of wear debris shedding on the nanometer-scale. A constant force knee simulator has been designed and constructed at the University of New South Wales, to generate reproducible wear patterns. Atomic Force Microscopy is used to measure the wear particle dimensions.
The constant axial force can be adjusted over a range of 0–1000 N, and flexion angles of 24°, 38°, 51° and 66° can be set. The UHMWPE wear surface is articulated at a rate of 1 cycle per second. It has been found that the simulator operates reliably over up to 2×10^6 cycles at various loads and flexion angles, and that wear debris can successfully be removed from the lubricant. For a walking cycle simulation, a wear rate of the order of 86 mg/10^6 cycles was measured using distilled water as lubricant.
The debris particulates generated from the simulation have been characterized with Atomic Force Microscopy. In the nanometer range two characteristic types, clumps and fibrils, may be distinguished.
A constant force knee simulator has been shown to operate reliably over up to 2×10^6 cycles at various loads and flexion angles, and that wear debris particulates can be obtained. It has also been shown that atomic force microscopy is well suited to characterize nanometre size UHMWPE particles. In parallel, the wear debris generated from the experiments is being tested for their bioirritant characteristics on osteoblast cells (in the TORU laboratory at the John Curtin School of Medical Research at ANU).
Accurate placement of unicompartmental knee arthroplasty components is thought to be essential for the long-term survival and efficacy of the prosthesis. Computer navigation is being explored as a means of improving the accuracy of component position. There are few published studies comparing conventional and computer-navigated techniques using the same prosthesis.
Twenty-two Allegretto [Zimmer] medial unicompartmental knee prostheses were placed in 18 patients using the AxiEM [Medtronic] computer-navigated system. The immediate post-operative AP and lateral radiographs were analysed and compared with an equivalent cohort of 30 prostheses in 29 patients with medial unicompartmental arthritis in whom the Allegretto was placed without the aid of computer navigation. All operations were performed by the senior author in a rural Queensland hospital.
No cases were lost to follow-up. The data was not normally distributed. The mean, SD and variance of the data sets was calculated and significance tested with a 2-tailed Mann-Whitney U-test. Computer navigated tibial components were implanted with a mean of 2 degrees of varus compared with 1 degree of valgus with conventional navigation [p = 0.027]. Our target was 0–4 degrees of varus. Eighteen of the 20 computer-navigated cases, 90% fell within the recommended range [0–4 degrees of varus] compared with only 40%, 12 of the 30 conventionally-implanted cases. This is demonstrated by the greater range and variance of the conventional navigation data set. Posterior slope for the computer navigated components was 1 degree compared with 3 degrees for conventional navigation [0.010]; only 1 computed navigated component [5%] was implanted with anterior slope compared with 4 cases for conventional navigation [13%]. Measurements of femoral component flexion and position with respect to the tibial component were not significantly different but demonstrated greater variance for the conventionally navigated data set.
Accurate component positioning improves efficacy and prosthesis survival for patients who meet the indications for unicompartmental surgery. However proponents acknowledge the weaknesses of conventional jigs for unicompartmental prostheses. In this study computer navigation has been shown to improve the accuracy of component placement.
A technical goal in total knee arthroplasty is the production of a neutral coronal plane mechanical axis. Errors may produce large mechanical axis deviations precipitating early implant failure. This study sought to test if measured distal femoral resection produced more accurate and consistent coronal alignment than arbitrarily set distal femoral resection.
Data from a cohort of 255 consecutive unselected primary total knee arthroplasties undertaken by the senior author (PM) was collected prospectively and independently assessed. In the first 167 cases distal femoral resection was arbitrarily set to 5 degrees of valgus. In the remaining 88 cases the distal femoral resection angle was determined on a preoperative long leg standing AP radiograph. Postoperative coronal alignment was measured on long leg standing AP radiograph in all cases.
The measured distal femoral valgus angle was between 4 and 7 degrees. An equal number measured either 5 or 6 degrees and accounted for 85% of the total number. Statistically insignificant improvements in mean axis and standard deviation were observed in the measured group: mean axis deviation −0.31 vs −0.51: p=0.17 (independent samples t test) and standard deviation 0.91 vs 1.09: p=0.055 (Levene test).
Acceptable coronal alignment in total knee arthroplasty can reliably be obtained with conventional instrumentation. Improvement in standard deviation with measured distal femoral valgus angle approaches statistical significance.
Malalignment of knee arthroplasty components can lead to abnormal wear, premature loosening and patellofemoral problems. Computer assisted surgery has been developed to improve surgeons ability to achieve correct alignment and thereby improve outcomes. This project compares the accuracy of computer assisted total knee arthroplasty with a conventional jig-assisted technique.
A total of 150 patients were recruited. Selection criteria included patients presenting with degenerative or inflammatory joint disease who were candidates for total knee arthroplasty. Patients having revision procedures were excluded as were patients who previously had a corrective osteotomy. Ethics approval was obtained and patients consented for the study. Patients were randomly allocated to either the computer navigated or jig alignment groups via the sealed envelope system. Demographic patient data and intraoperative data were collected. Quality of life and function assessments made using the WOMAC and Knee Society Scores. The component position was assessed using the Perth CT protocol.
One hundred and fifty patients were recruited from Dec 2005 to July 2007. Five patients were excluded due to machine malfunction and two others were excluded due to insufficient data collected leaving 143 patients for the study. There was no difference in blood loss, post operative hemoglobin or patient length of hospital stay. There was no difference in the Knee Society knee or function scores at 12 weeks or the knee flexion range either at discharge or at 3 months follow up. There was a significant correlation in duration of surgery (p< 0.05) with the navigated cases taking an average 23 minutes longer. Both the conventional jig alignment and computer navigated techniques produced accurate results in all CT measurements except for the tibial slope where the navigated group (4.8+/−1.6) was closer to the elected posterior slope of 3.5+/− 1.5 than the jig system (6.4+/−2). Statistically significant differences in favour of the navigated group were also found for both femoral component rotation and tibial coronal alignment but the outliers beyond the accepted ideal alignment of 0+/−3 degrees for each parameter were minimal and equivalent for the two groups.
Computer navigation in knee replacement surgery is gaining popularity to improve component alignment and consequently the outcome of total knee arthroplasty. This study has shown only marginal benefits in alignment of the navigated group but this needs to be considered against the increased surgical time despite familiarity with the hardware.
Computer navigation was introduced in Australia in 2000, initially with the use of pre-operative computer scans and then later with image free systems. In 2003 the AOA – NJRR began collecting data for knee replacement performed with computer navigation.
Meta analysis of the literature has shown better coronal and sagittal plane alignment in total knee arthroplasty performed with computer navigation as opposed to standard instrumented knee replacement. At present, however, there is no data on improved outcomes or reduced revision rates. Information was requested from the AOA – NJRR on the use of computer navigation for both uni-compartmental and total knee replacements. This included numbers of navigated knees done per year as well as revision rates and reasons for revisions of knees performed by computer navigation surgery.
Since data collection began there has been 2,651 computer assisted total knee replacements performed which is 4.1% of the total number of knee replacements in this time period. There has been a steady increase in the last three years in the use of computer navigation. There has been an increased number of computer navigated knees performed in the private hospital sector as opposed to the public hospitals and there is a state by state variation in the uptake of navigation. The revision rate per 100 observed ‘component’ years at three years is 2.8 for non computer assisted and 2.5 computer assisted surgery. This is not statistically significant. There is no difference in the early complication rate leading to revision.
The use of computer navigation could be expected to reduce the long term revision rates of knee arthroplasty due to better alignment and potentially less wear. In the short term there is no significant revision rate between the two methods of performing TKR particularly with regard to infection or fracture
Cognitive dysfunction has been well documented following total knee replacement. Possible causes that have been postulated include cerebral emboli, post-operative complications and pain. The aim of this study is to compare cognitive decline in patients undergoing conventional total knee replacement (TKR), navigated total knee replacement and total hip replacement (THR).
We prospectively analysed 75 patients undergoing lower limb arthroplasty. Group 1 consisted of 25 conventional TKR’s, group 2 consisted of 25 navigated TKR’s and group 3 consisted of 25 THR’s. Cognitive function was assessed by 11 validated neuropsychological tests preoperatively, at 1 week post-operatively and at 6 months post-operatively. Testing was carried out by a clinical psychologist.
At day 6 post-operatively 55% of group 1, 83% of group 2 and 61% of group 3 patients had a significant cognitive decline. Group 2 had a significantly greater cognitive decline at day 6 compared to the other 2 groups. At 6 months significant cognitive decline was found in all 3 groups to 21%, 16% and 34% respectively. Group 2 demonstrated the greatest improvement in cognition from day 6 to 6 months post-operatively
Significant cognitive decline occurs in two-thirds (66%) of all patients undergoing lower limb arthroplasty at day 6 and remains significant in a quarter (25%) of patients at 6 months. There was no significant difference in cognitive decline in patients undergoing hip and knee arthroplasty.
Between 6 and 12 weeks full length weight bearing radiographs were taken when patients could achieve full extension. Coronal alignments of the tibial and femoral components were calculated relative to the mechanical axis. The goal for both femoral and tibial component alignment was within 30 of 900 to the mechanical axis. The results were verified by an independent observer. Analysis of sequential tourniquet times, complication rates and component alignment were used as measure of the learning curve for the technique.
Component position was acceptable for all implants. The mean coronal tibial alignment was 90.35 degrees (range 88 to 92 degrees) and the mean coronal femoral alignment 90.10 degrees (range 88 to 93 degrees) to the mechanical axis. Tourniquet time averaged 90 minutes (range 60 to 118 minutes). There was no significant reduction in tourniquet time with increasing familiarity with the technique. Our results demonstrate that CAS combined with MIS for TKA maintains the accuracy of component alignment despite the minimally invasive approach. These initial results demonstrate no significant learning curve associated with the technique.
To better understand the functional effects of pathologies, a system to capture accurate real-time 3D imaging of functional activities, without the limitations of RSA, is desirable. To address this problem, a new registration algorithm was developed to automatically determine the 3D kinematics of the knee using commonly available imaging modalities.
To evaluate this new registration algorithm, three cadaveric knees were implanted with 1mm tantalum beads to act as gold standard fiducial markers. The knees were flexed between 0 and 90° and fluoroscopy data was captured at a rate of 25 frames/sec and a resolution of 0.5 mm/pixel (Axiom Artis MP). “Pin-cushion” distortion and beam spreading were accounted for. CT data was captured using a Toshiba Aquillon 16 using bone and soft tissue algorithms. For every frame of the fluoroscopy data, the 3D femur and tibia data was individually registered to the fluoroscopy images using the new algorithm. This position data was then used to generate a kinematic 3D model. Similar fluoroscopy-to-CT registration techniques have been proposed for stationary image-guided surgery applications. The majority of these techniques use fluoroscopy images projected onto at least two different planes (with some systems using as many as 18 planes). Other techniques have been proposed that use a single-plane but require stochastic optimization procedures that perform in the order of 500 iterations to find the optimal 3-D registration. The reported average target registration errors (TREs) of these systems range from 0.5–1.2 mm. The newly developed registration technique requires only a single-plane fluoroscopy image and uses a novel gradient-descent optimization strategy that converges to the optimal 3-D position within 20–30 iterations. Preliminary results demonstrate that the performance of the new registration algorithm is able to align the bones of the knee with an average TRE of 0.57 mm. Up to 7 degrees of concurrent axial rotation was observed during flexion of the knees to 90°. The new registration algorithm developed for the project is capable of automatically determining the 3D kinematics of a knee joint using only single-plane fluoroscopy data. The new algorithm requires approximately one-tenth the number of iterations to find the optimal registration position when compared with existing single-plane techniques. Once it is established in vivo that this image registration technique has the accuracy of RSA, this method will permit real-time kinematic studies without tantalum beads. This will enable prospective longitudinal and controlled studies of reconstruction surgery, and conservative management of joint pathologies.
I have watched and peripherally participated in the development of navigated knee replacement over the last 5 years.
After a CT analysis of a number of my cases I became aware of the deficiencies of my instrumented approach.
What I desired was a method that would allow avoidance of rodding the femur. And a way of more accurately reproducing posterior slope.
I am currently using the Articular Surface Mounted system by Stryker with the Triathlon knee system.
I am presenting this as a technique that we are currently evaluating.
in a simulator which reproduced the manual intraoperative manipulation of the knee during unloaded passive range of motion (PROM), and in a functional activity simulator which recreated a loaded squatting maneuver.
Standard 14cm midvastus medial arthrotomies were performed on each knee, and the PROM and squatting simulations were repeated. A laser scanner was used in conjunction with CT models to recreate the three-dimensional position of the knee and allow calculation of medial and lateral femoral rollback and tibial rotation.
The Parliament makes the law, the court interprets the law and the judge or jury make the decisions. The adversarial system in Australia is a battle between two advocates who elicit information which is consistent with the version of facts being advanced in his/her case and likely to persuade the court (judge or jury). Deciding on fault is the courts decision. In criminal cases the standard of proof is “beyond reasonable doubt” in civil cases the standard is “on the balance of probabilities”
You may be called to court to present the details regarding your patient or as an expert witness. The court needs you because the two parties have failed to agree regarding any of the following; the presence of a clinical problem, the probable cause of the alleged injury, the degree of pain, suffering, loss of performance and expected permanent impairment.
The surgeons dilemma is that the patients details are confidential but the discussions in court can become public knowledge.
A medical expert is recognized to possess knowledge or experience which is beyond that of the ordinary members of the lay community (or jury). Your evidence is therefore related to a matter that is not ‘common knowledge’.
The lawyers are in their comfort zone, you are a fish out of water. The court is their theatre yours is in the hospital. The court needs your evidence.
Don’t try to help to see that justice is done. Use simple and concise language, stick to the facts and your field of knowledge (what you know, heard or saw). Don’t do the advocates job nor try to help or take sides. Don’t be intimidated to answer yes or no when you know that neither is correct. Don’t embellish, dramatize, show off, guess, be evasive, use complicated medical terminology or volunteer opinions.
If you believe that the proceedings are ‘way off the mark’ you can appeal to the judge to allow you to make a statement to clarify an issue.
Current evidence suggests that in Australia more than 80% of individuals are not receiving treatment for osteoporosis following an initial osteoporotic fracture. The earliest opportunity to identify many individuals with osteoporosis is following their first osteoporotic fracture, which is usually less severe than subsequent fractures. As these fractures are usually treated by orthopaedic surgeons it was decided to survey Australian orthopaedic surgeons to determine their understanding, attitudes and involvement in the management of osteoporosis.
Eighty five per cent of the respondents do not prescribe any pharmacological treatment for osteoporosis management. Most commonly (36%) there was a preference for surgery rather than drug prescription. Twenty four percent had access to a specific osteoporosis team for treating osteoporosis. No experience with treating osteoporosis (23%) and no formal education in osteoporosis (16%) were other common reasons. Very few orthopaedic surgeons felt it was their responsibility to treat osteoporosis, however 52% were interested in attending a course on osteoporosis.
The findings are contrasted with those of an international study conducted by the Bone and Joint Decade and the International Osteoporosis Foundation, using the same questionnaire.
This paper discussed the challenges to provide advanced surgical training in orthopaedics, the inter-relationship between trainers, trainees, the AOA and the College. It looks at the factors that are involved in each level of training, some of the new initiatives that are being undertaken and the medicolegal issues regarding training of the modern generation of Orthopaedic trainees. It also discusses the pitfalls in process, that are present for all those involved in the training.
Despite tendencies for Claims against medical practitioners around Australia to fall, litigation continues to be a burden on individual practitioners and the system.
Unlike Claims frequency, Claims costs are not falling and indemnity insurance remains a significant practice cost.
Data is presented to illustrate some trends in litigation and illustrative cases are also presented to outline some of the difficulties in defending Claims.
Particular emphasis on the degree of difficulty is made in respect of Epidural Abscess.
Surgeons acquire knowledge from a variety of sources that include textbooks, journals, the attendance at scientific meetings and workshops, from the internet, from continuing medical education (CME) programs and from informal corridor discussions with colleagues.
Surgeons also rely heavily on the information that is provided by the manufacturers and distributors of implantable surgical devices. Advertisements in journals and on the internet are frequently published for surgical products where there are claims by manufacturers of clinical and scientific fact. Also it is the case that the pictorial (photographic) content of these advertisements can be of a nature that might lead the reasonable observer into error. Patients and their Surgeons, both as consumers, will frequently rely heavily on the available information when exercising choice. In the event it is particularly important that manufacturers avoid the publication of promotional information that might be misleading or deceptive, as consumers can be greatly influenced by marketing material and by the representations made.
Though the manufacturers of drugs have frequently been accused of misleading consumers, the claims made by surgical device manufacturers have escaped any more than minor criticism. The author discusses the question of what might or might not be misleading or deceptive conduct. Evidence is presented to support the view that there is a very fine line that separates puffery from conduct where there is a real or not too remote chance that might lead another into error.
The Australian law of misrepresentation is complicated and includes two sources of law. These are the general law which is an amalgam of general law and equity rules and the Trade Practices Act s52 which is mirrored in the Fair Trading Acts of each State and Territory. The author reviews this law as it effects the medical devices industry.
It is evident that there are lessons to be learned that include the need for greater diligence by surgical implant manufacturers when substantiating their claims and greater vigilance among members of the medical profession, and other consumers, when exposed to promotional material.
Dean Acheson, US Secretary of State, commenting on the American loyalty security program
The NSW Government has introduced mandatory reporting into the NSW Medical Practice Act 1992 and the Health Care Complaints Act 1994. The QLD Government has called for “new laws to force doctors to report cases of harm by all colleagues”. Speculation has arisen as to whether or not mandatory reporting will become national under the proposed COAG/IGA legislation (and regulation) should it be introduced. A draft National Code of Conduct has been issued by the Federal Department of Health covering all doctors. Changes to this code could facilitate mandatory reporting. What are the justifications for mandatory reporting are they valid? What evidence exists that mandatory reporting is effective? What are the likely outcomes of a mandatory reporting system? Are there adverse and unintended consequences? Why is mandatory reporting not universally adopted? 10. What should an independent profession’s approach be to mandatory reporting?
Mandatory reporting uses as its justification certain high profile cases of alleged breaches of health care standards by doctors. However close examination of these cases may lead to the conclusion that reporting was sufficient to justify earlier intervention i.e. that cases were not a result of a lack of reporting, rather a lack of decision making and following routine procedures by a tardy administration. The recently released Garling Report needs close examination. It must be emphasised that in some of these high profile cases against doctors, judicial proceedings are still in progress and final verdicts remain to be determined.
Mandatory reporting is being introduced on top of a plethora of ethical codes, codes of conduct, regulation and legislation. The Australian medical profession is one of the most highly regulated groups in Australia. Are we making it impossible for our doctors to undertake their professional responsibilities?
Mandatory reporting as a public safeguard needs greater examination as to its efficacy and justification. Systems that produce poor outcomes reduce public confidence and are counter-productive.
Differentially loaded radiostereometric analysis (DLRSA) uses RSA whilst simultaneously applying load to the bones under investigation. This technique allows measurement of interfragmentary translations and rotations under measured amounts of weight bearing. The aim of this paper was to measure the mechanical stiffness of distal femoral fractures during healing.
Six patients with a 33A2, 33A3, 33B2 and 33C2 fracture were treated with open reduction, internal fixation using a long bridging plate. All patients had a DLRSA examination at 6, 12, 18 and 26 weeks postoperatively. Each DLRSA examination consisted of RSA radiographs taken without load (pre-load), under different increments of load, and finally, without load (post-load). The direction and magnitude of the interfragmentary displacements in six degrees of freedom were recorded at each examination.
DLRSA examinations were able to monitor the inter-fragmentary displacements of the distal femoral fragment relative to the femoral shaft. The interfragmentary displacement recorded, progressively increased as more load was applied in all patients, at all follow-up time points. The two dimensional (2D) translations under maximum tolerated load, progressively decreased over time in three patients. The 2D translations recorded under 60 kg of load at 26 weeks for these patients was 0.18, 0.21 and 0.27mm. The 2D translations of two patients did not decrease progressively between 6 and 18 weeks but did decrease at 26 weeks to 0.47 and 0.75mm. One patient recorded 2D translations of 4.11, 3.48 and 4.53mm under 30kg at 12, 18 and 26 weeks respectively. In the majority of examinations, post-load radiographs enabled the interfragmentary displacements under load to be identified as elastic in nature.
The DLRSA stiffness data confirmed that at 26 weeks three patients had united; two were delayed but improving; and one was a clear non-union without progression. DLRSA examinations may be used as a clinical research tool. to monitor in vivo the stiffness of healing femoral fractures fixed with “relative stability”.
Distraction osteogenesis (DO) is useful for bone lengthening and deformity correction. Unfortunately, this often requires prolonged use of an external fixator with concomitant morbidities. This study investigates whether low-magnitude, high-intensity vibrations (Dynamic Motion Therapy, DMT) can accelerate maturation of regenerate bone in DO, thus reducing the duration of external fixation. 28 NZ White Rabbits underwent a right mid-tibial osteotomy with application of an Orthofix M-103 fixator (Orthofix, Busselengo, Italy). Distraction commenced on day 3 at 0.5 mm every 12 hours for 12 days. All animals were sacrificed on day 45. Animals were randomly assigned into 4 groups:
control group; DMT only during distraction period; DMT only during consolidation period; DMT during distraction and consolidation periods.
DMT was applied with the Juvent platform (Juvent, Somerset, NJ) for 10 minutes/day. X-ray and CT scans were taken prior to mechanical testing. All specimens were processed for histology. X-rays and CT scans showed evidence of cortical remodelling and re-establishment of the medullary canal in animals treated with DMT (groups 2, 3 and 4). This was most pronounced in animals treated during the distraction and consolidation phases (group 4). Regenerate bone in the control group (group 1) was more disorganised, with a delayed union evident in 1 animal. Group 1 achieved peak torque and stiffness values of 70% and 50% of the contralateral (unoperated) tibia respectively. No significant difference was seen in peak torque and stiffness between groups 2, 3, and 4, however each was significantly higher than group 1 (P< 0.05). H& E staining revealed less porosity in the newly formed cortical bone and a more defined medullary canal in animals treated with DMT than in the control group. Low-magnitude, high-intensity vibrations appear to accelerate cortical remodelling and reestablishment of a medullary canal. Regenerate bone in animals treated with DMT was also mechanically superior. The timing of DMT therapy did not appear to be important. Further studies are required to determine the optimal timing and duration of DMT therapy.
Tissue engineering is a rapidly expanding field of research. Bone and cartilage engineering are being undertaken in an attempt to treat osteoarthritis and repair bone defects. In spite of extensive research little successful clinical application of this work has been seen. There are however many advances in the field that one day may have therapeutic interest. One particular area of interest is the potential for using osteophyte tissue in repairing osteoarthritic defects. Osteophytes represent an attempt by the body to regenerate bone and cartilage. They present an obvious source of cells for tissue engineering. Research ay QUT has shown that cells within the osteophytes are a better source of bone and cartilage regeneration in the laboratory than matched patient’s bone marrow stem cells.
Osteoarthritis remains the ultimate challenge for orthopaedic tissue engineering. Understanding the chemical and mechanical signals occurring in osteoarthritis presents opportunities for targeted drug delivery and potential slowing of disease. We have identified changes within the MMP profile of cells at the osteochondral junction. Subchondral sclerosis appears to be associated with changes in the nature of chondrocytes deep within the cartilage layer. This transformation of chondrocytes into osteoblast-like tissue in many ways mimics the changes seen in the growth plate once maturity is reached. Understanding the parallels between these processes may help answer some of the mechanisms of the development of osteoarthritis.
This talk will discuss the above topics as well as other areas of interest to an orthopaedic surgeon working within a group of 10 cell biologists.
Osteoarthritis (OA) is a major public health problem. Plain radiography, which mainly depicts joint-space narrowing and osteophytes, is useful for defining OA, but has weak associations with symptoms, limited sensitivity to change, as well as poor prediction of cartilage loss and the need for joint replacement. MRI, with standard techniques such as fat-saturated, T1-weighted, spoiled gradient echo sequences and T2-weighted, proton-density-weighted fast-spin echo sequences, has been utilized to directly assess knee structural alterations, such as cartilage volume, cartilage defects, subchondral bone changes and meniscal lesions. MRI factors (cartilage defects, bone marrow lesions, meniscal pathology and bone area) as well as clinical risk factors (age, sex, obesity, smoking and muscle strength) can identify subjects at risk of faster cartilage loss. We hypothesize that a combination of genetic factors interacting with environmental factors might establish a cascade of joint changes from subchondral bone expansion to other structural changes, and ultimately, but not inevitably, lead to OA. MRI has, therefore, been invaluable in improving our understanding of early changes in the knee joint.
Patients with spinal cord injuries have been seen to have increased healing of attendant fractures. While the benefits are obvious, this excessive bone growth also causes unwanted side effects, such as decreased movement around joints, joint fusion and renal tract calculi. However, the cause for this phenomenon remains unclear.
This paper evaluates two groups with spinal column fractures – those with neurological compromise (n=10) and those without (n=15), and compares them with a control group with isolated long bone fractures (n=12). Serum was taken from these patients at five specific time intervals post injury (1 day, 5 days, 10 days, 42 days (6 weeks) and 84 days(12 weeks)). These samples were then analysed for levels of Transforming Growth Factor-Beta (TGF-.) using the ELISA technique. This cytokine has been shown to stimulate bone formation after both topical and systemic administration.
Results show TGF-.; levels of 142.79±29.51 ng/ml in the neurology group at 84 days post injury. This is higher than any of the other time points within this group (.0.009 vs. all other time points, ANOVA). Furthermore, this level is also higher than the levels recorded in the no neurology (103.51±36.81 ng/ml) and long bone (102.28±47.58 ng/ml) groups at 84 days post injury (p=0.009 and p=0.04 respectively, ANOVA).
In conclusion, the results of this work, carried out for the first time in humans, offers strong evidence of the causative role of TGF-.; in the increased bone turnover and attendant complications seen in patients with acute spinal cord injuries.
DDH These methods have been applied to examine systematic variations in the shape and dimensions of the dysplastic femur through reference to data from 171 dysplastic and 84 skeletally normal patients. Of the 171 dysplastic femora, 74 (43%) were graded as Crowe I, 82 (48%) as Crowe stages II or III, and 15 (9%) as Crowe IV. The change in femoral morphology was quantified as a function of the grade of deformity in comparison with normal controls. The principal sources of deformity were also identified. FAI We examined the hypothesis that the femur of patients with femoro-acetbular impingement has multiple morphologic characteristics leading to reduced range of motion. Sixty-six cadaveric femora (30 male and 36 female, average age: 76 years) were selected from a large osteologic collection. Thirteen femora were morphologically normal and 53 were abnormal. Standard morphologic parameters were calculated and normalized with respect to the femoral head diameter. Additional parameters were determined to quantify the head/neck relationship. These included the I angle, the. angle, the anterior offset ratio (OSR), the anterior head-neck ratio, the posterior ‘slip’ of the femoral head, the neck shaft angle and the femoral neck anteversion.
We have found that heparanase (HPSE) stimulates human osteoblast cell growth. This study explored the mechanism of HPSE in the stimulation of osteoblasts from osteoporotic and healthy subjects. We further hypothesized that the structure of chromatin is modified by HPSE via activating phosphorylation of histone H3.
Osteoblast primary cell cultures originating from osteoporotic and healthy human subjects (n=8/group) were developed and exposed to exogenous HPSE at a series of concentrations. The mineralized nodules were stained using Alizarin red-S, a dye-binding ~2 mole of Ca2+/mol in solution, and then calcium mineral content was quantified by measuring the amount of AR-S bound to mineralized nodules in the cultures. A RT-qPCR array assay was used to detect osteogenic gene expression on osteoblasts after treatment with HPSE. A flow cytometry approach was used for the detection of histone H3 modification.
Heparanase significantly increased the calcium content of osteoblasts cultures from healthy and osteoporotic subjects at day 14, but the effect on osteoporotic cells was much greater. Osteoblasts exposed to heparanase at concentrations of 6, 3, 1, and 0.1μg/mL yielded 257, 222, 145, and 134% increase in the calcium content in osteoporotic subjects; and 160, 152, 121 and 106% increase in healthy subjects. A number of osteogenic genes were dramatically up-regulated by the exogenous HPSE. In the osteoporotic subjects, BMPs, COLs, GDF10, COMP (skeletal development and bone mineral metabolism), ENAM (bone mineralization) and ALPL (ossification) were significantly up-regulated. Genes involved in cell growth, IGF1, IGF2, VEGF, CSF2, CSF3 and growth factors’ receptors such as FGFR1, FGFR2, EGFR, TGFBR1, and cell adhesion molecules, CTSK, VCAM, BGN and CD36 were also up-regulated. In the healthy subjects, FGF, CSF2, BMP2, ALPL, and ECM protease (MMP9) were up-regulated, while ENAM and FGFR2 were down-regulated. In addition, HPSE modified the structure of chromatin by increasing positive events of histone H3 phosphorylation (91%) compared to control cultures (2.4%) from osteoporotic subjects, and 39% vs. 23% in healthy subjects. HPSE markedly promotes mineralization of osteoblasts in osteoporotic and healthy subjects.
HPSE up-regulates osteogenic gene expression, correlates with markers of bone formation, activates histone H3 phosphorylation, and seems to be playing a role in bone remodeling at steps preceding BMP, VEGF and ALPL’s during osteoblast cell growth.
Patient- specific orthopaedic models are currently used in computer navigation. They provide realistic 3-D geometries for assessment of device placement (e.g. tibial trays, hip implants). Models are generated at time of operation by the surgeon. But patient-specific models have other uses. We envisage a future in which realistic 3-D patient models are routinely used for predicting the outcome of surgical procedures and new devices and for general patient health monitoring.
We are currently developing accurate 3-D models directly from CT scan post-operation. They are being used in investigations of the progress of bone remodeling. Such work can provide valuable feedback on the outcome of new procedures and how bone remodels under load. Such models would eventually include other tissue such as muscles and skin.
But there are a number of research and development challenges associated with the creation of patient-specific models. They include
minimal use of radiation for data collection; need for an automated method of generating patient specific models as clinicians (not engineers) should be able to create computer models easily and quickly; need for improvements in computational efficiency. An ultimate goal would be to run simulations on computer hardware that is available to the clinician; How to deal with missing data. We need techniques for supplementing patient data with data from a “model library”; Research to provide techniques for dealing with multiple organs (muscles, skin and bone altogether).
We are working to meet these challenges. They include the use of generic data to supplement patient data, efficient ways of morphing models to fit the patient, and multi-scale modeling strategies. Work in progress at the Auckland Bio-engineering Institute will be presented in this talk.
Calcium and vitamin D are both of key importance for bone health, and their effects on bone appear to begin even in utero and continue throughout life. The dietary requirements for both calcium and vitamin D are different at different stages of the lifespan. Importantly, in Australia the bulk of vitamin D comes from manufacture of vitamin D in the skin from ultraviolet light exposure i.e. from sun exposure, as the amount of vitamin D in foods is low. Vitamin D deficiency is common at all stages of life and some groups are at particularly high risk. Adequate calcium intake and maintaining adequate vitamin D levels are important in childhood for maximising peak bone mass, but the effect of calcium supplementation on bone mineral density is small. The role of vitamin D supplementation in childhood outside of treating rickets is unclear, though there is potential for a clinically significant effect. Calcium and vitamin D supplements have been investigated for the primary prevention of osteoporotic fracture in the elderly. Calcium and vitamin D is effective at reducing non-vertebral and vertebral fractures in the institutionalised elderly but community-based studies show conflicting results. There is no evidence that calcium, vitamin D or the combination of calcium and vitamin D alone prevent fractures in those who have already sustained a low trauma fracture (secondary prevention) but calcium and vitamin D are both important adjunctive treatments in established osteoporosis i.e. in combination with other pharmacotherapies.
Traditionally autologous bone graft is the standard treatment for non-union of fractures. More recently osteo-inductive agents with or without allograft have been utilised. A trial of Autologous Mesenchymal Precursor Cells has been completed at the Royal Melbourne Hospital to investigate their potential for the treatment of nonunion of long bone fractures.
With the approval of the ethics committee at the Royal Melbourne Hospital a human safety trial was commenced for the treatment of fracture non-union. Bone marrow cells were harvested from patients approximately six weeks before surgery and cultured in a laboratory. The cells were expanded in a culture medium. At the time of definitive surgery the stem cells were implanted on a hydroxy apatite/tricalcium phosphate matrix to the non-union site. Any further fixation that was required at the time of the union was performed by the treating surgeon. Investigations were performed at regular intervals to assess for union and for any reaction to the stem cells and growth medium.
The trial has been completed and eleven patients have been entered into the study. There were eight patients with non-union of femoral fractures and four patients with tibial non-unions (one patient with ipsilateral injuries to both bones). The average age was 41.9 years and the mean time to surgery from the initial injury was 15.2 months. Eight patients have united at a mean time of 24 weeks. One is well on the way to union and of the remaining two patients one is listed as uncertain and one a declared non union. The patient who has failed to unite is currently awaiting further surgery. One patient withdrew from the trial after ceasing smoking and finally uniting prior to stem cell implantation. There has been one adverse event with possible infection at a screw site though this was thought not to be related to stem cell therapy.
This is a phase one safety trial of a new development for the treatment of a nonunion of long bone fractures. The results are promising with the regards to achieving bone union without any significant complications. This paves the way for a trial involving allogeneic stem cells.
The morbidity associated with tendinopathy is a costly burden on our health system. Recent investigations in our laboratory have shown that alterations in mechanical stress cause significant changes in tendon expression of key matrix molecules and proteolytic enzymes including the aggrecanase molecules, (e.g. ADAMTS-5). Here, we investigate the biomechanical consequences of such altered tensile stress in tail tendons from mice with and without deletion of the ADAMTS-5 gene. Tail tendons from 12 week old C57BL6 wild type and ADAMTS-5 knock-out mice were immediately snap frozen (ex vivo), or cultured stress deprived for 120 hours in DMEM/10% FCS (eight tendons per group). Material properties including maximum stress, strain and elastic modulus were determined for each tendon in uniaxial tension to failure at a constant strain rate of 1.0 mm/second (10% strain/second) on an Instron 8874 servo-hydraulic testing apparatus. Significant differences between groups were determined with Kruskal-Wallis one-way analysis of variance, followed by Mann-Whitney U test with Benjamini-Hochberg post-hoc corrections for multiple comparisons. Stress deprivation for 120 hours led to a significant increase in maximum stress for both the wild type (~150% increase, p = 0.0008) and ADAMTS-5 deficient (~100%, p = 0.0033) mice when compared to ex vivo tendon. Stress deprivation led to a 100% increase in elastic modulus compared to ex vivo for the wild type tendons (p = 0.0033) but failed to increase this parameter in the ADAMTS-5 deficient mice. When the effect of stress deprivation of the ADAMTS-5 deficient mice was directly compared to the wild type stress deprived tendons, a 35% decrease in elastic modulus was found (p = 0.021). We have shown for the first time that deletion of an aggrecanase molecule significantly decreases the material properties of tendon. Alterations in the expression of the aggrecanase molecules may play a role in the development and progression of tendinopathy through their ability to modulate the metabolism of aggrecan [
The response of articular cartilage in joint dislocation is not well documented. We have previously demonstrated that the rate of chondrocyte apoptosis increased with duration of joint dislocation with a significant increase after 1 hour. The purpose of our study was to determine if early joint reduction reduced the rate of chondrocyte apoptosis.
Southern Health animal ethics approval was obtained. 36 Sprague-Dawley rats underwent surgical dislocation of the left hip and the hip was reduced after 1, 2 or 4 hours. The rats were then killed at 1 or 8 weeks. Histological assessment of the femoral heads was performed with H+E and TUNEL stain to determine if the apoptotic index (proportion of apoptotic cells present per high magnification field (X 400)) alter after joint reduction in the short to medium term.
The mean apoptotic index in the non traumatized right hip was 0.044 ± 0.031 (control). After joint reduction of 1 week the mean apoptotic indices were 0.069 ± 0.023 (1 hr), 0.064 ± 0.031 (2 hr) and 0.138 ± 0.060 (4 hrs). After joint reduction of 8 weeks the mean apoptotic indices were 0.062 ± 0.028 (1 hr), 0.108 ± 0.109 (2 hrs) and 0.135 ± 0.035 (4 hrs).
Our results suggests that joint reduction within 1 hour prevents worsening of apoptotic index and that there is a population of delayed apoptosis if the joint is left dislocated for 2 hours. The apoptotic index does not recover after 8 weeks.
Manufacturing of autologous chondrocytes presents unique challenges, and robust and reliable release assays are required to ensure product quality. We have discovered markers that correctly identify chondrocytes and predict potency. Novel qPCR assays developed with these markers for our Matrix-induced Autologous Chondrocyte Implant product (MACI® implant) are described. An identity assay must distinguish chondrocytes from potentially contaminating cell types, such as synovial fibroblasts. Microarray analysis of more than 47,000 transcripts led to the discovery of two markers, currently aliased “Cart1” and “Synov1”, that have been characterized as the two most differentially expressed mRNAs between chondrocyte and synovial fibroblast cultures. A potency assay must identify cells that have the potential to form hyaline-like cartilage. We examined expression of critical components of hyaline cartilage during the chondrocyte manufacturing process and in re-differentiation assays. From these studies a gene, which we call “Hyaline1”, was identified as a candidate potency marker. Using an assay measuring the ratio of Cart1:Synov1, a large population study of chondrocyte and synovial fibroblast cultures examined the assay’s suitability for identity classification with our proposed Cart1:Synov1 acceptance boundary. In this study, assay specificity and sensitivity were both observed to be 100%. The utility of the assay was further demonstrated in mixing experiments, where a majority of chondrocytes (in mixtures with synovial fibroblasts) was required to pass the assay acceptance. These results indicate that the assay is useful for determination of both culture identity and culture homogeneity, and thus represents a significant improvement over previous identity assays. The potency assay is also a real-time quantitative RT-PCR assay that measures levels of Hyaline1. Characterization of MACI® implants indicated that Hyaline1 is stable in long-term culture of chondrocytes but not fibroblasts on ACI-Maix membrane, and is overexpressed in chondrocytes compared fibroblasts that had been recovered from MACI® implants and tested in various redifferentiation assays. These data suggest that Hyaline1 is predictive of the chondrogenic potential of cells used to manufacture MACI® implants. After comparing may cell strains, a threshold level which indicates product potency was established. The identification of genetic markers that unambiguously identify cultured chondrocytes has been a long-standing challenge. Another challenge has been the ability to predict re-differentiation capacity of cultured chondrocytes. Modern techniques like whole genome microarray analysis have enabled us to develop novel identity and potency assays for quality control of MACI® implants.
The use of MRI scanning has been described after open reduction of the hip in DDH to check hip position but has not previously been reported after open reduction with femoral osteotomy and the use of metalwork. We performed a prospective study utilising MRI to document the adequacy of reduction.
An MRI scan was performed on the second postoperative day in order to confirm the satisfactory reduction of the hip following surgery. Previously a CT scan was performed.
10 consecutive cases were scanned and all gave diagnostic information of satisfactory reduction. Sedation was not required. The mean scanning time was 3 minute 45 seconds and the total time in the MRI suite ranged from 7 to 10 minutes.
Satisfactory images, the lack of need of sedation, comparable time and cost to CT scanning and most importantly the lack of exposure of the child to ionising radiation make MRI a most appealing method of imaging. We therefore recommend it as the investigation of choice in this patient group.
Demographic data reviewed included gender, MP at time of primary surgery, GMFCS level, age at time of surgery, type of adductor release procedure performed, and experience of surgeon.
Outcome variables assessed were type of subsequent failure, time of failure after primary procedure, and length of follow-up.
Three hundred and thirty children underwent hip adductor surgery. The number of children per GMFCS Level was 33 Level II, 55 level III, 103 level IV, and 139 level V. The average age at time of primary surgery was 4.19 years, mean MP at time of primary surgery 43.16%, and mean length of post-operative follow-up was 7.10 years.
Eighty two children had adductor longus and gracilis lengthening alone, 97 also had an iliopsoas release, 97 had psoas tenotomy and phenolisation of the obturator nerve, and 54 had a psoas tenotomy and neurectomy of the anterior branch of the obturator nerve (in addition to longus & gracilis lengthening).
At time of audit 106 children did not require further surgery (‘surgery success’ of 32%). Thirty one were in children of GMFCS level II (94%), 27 level III (49%), 28 level IV (27%), and 20 level V (14%).
A Cox proportional hazards survivorship analysis was constructed to chart the time course of progression to further surgery over time to reveal statistically significant ‘surgery success’ rates according to GMFCS. Differences in the success rates according to GMFCS become more apparent beyond 3 years post-surgery.
The most important determinant for predicting the success of hip adductor surgery in preventing hip displacement is GMFCS at the time of primary surgery. Current treatment strategies need to be re-evaluated with the context of undertaking long-term post-operative follow up, particularly for children GMFCS levels VI and V.
This study evaluates outcomes of hip adductor surgery in children with cerebral palsy in preventing hip displacement. This review is from the perspective of an extended follow-up (beyond 3 years in contrast to currently available literature) and the Gross Motor Function Classification System (GMFCS).
A retrospective audit was performed of children with cerebral palsy aged 2 to 10 years who had primary adductor surgery at the Royal Children’s Hospital Melbourne between January 1994 and December 2004. These children had hip migration percentages (MP) greater than 30% and been followed up for a minimum 12 months post-operatively.
The mean SNIP value for the idiopathic and neuromuscular groups was 70cmH2O and 44cmH2O respectively. This was significantly different (P=0.006). The mean cobb angle for idiopathic pattern was 58°. For the neuromuscular group it was 73°. There was no correlation between SNIP value and curve severity in either the idiopathic or neuromuscular group.
SNIP value does not correlate with cobb angle severity. SNIP can differentiate idiopathic from neuromuscular scoliosis. Low SNIP values are found in neuromuscular scoliosis. Its role in non neuromuscular scoliosis does not appear to be significant.
As an example, the average weight of children aged 12 to 14 years was 13kgs more than the median value of children in this age group.
There was a clear increase in incidence of this condition over the last twenty years which corresponds with increasing obesity rates in the community.
There was a higher incidence in the indigenous population as compared with the non-indigenous population.
Out of the 236 patients enrolled, 5 cases were complicated by avascular necrosis. The overall complication rate was low.
Rate of progression to contralateral slip was low as was the rate of prophylactic pinning.
We have shown that SCFE is associated with obesity in Australia when compared with general population data. Obesity is also more common in the Aboriginal population and we postulate that this explains the higher incidence of SCFE in this group. In keeping with increasing rates of obesity amongst Australian adolescents, the increasing incidence of this condition further highlights the importance of public health initiatives to tackle obesity in the community.
Instrumented spinal arthrodesis is a common procedure to correct scoliosis. The long-term consequences of these retained implants is unclear. Concern of possible toxic effects of raised metal ion levels have been reported in arthroplasty literature. We investigated serum metal ion levels in patients having instrumented spinal arthrodesis for scoliosis correction.
The study included patients who underwent posterior spinal arthrodesis using Isola stainless steel instrumentation for scoliosis between 1998 and 2002. Patients having post-operative complications, instrumentation removed, revision surgery or additional in situ metal implants were excluded. Participants completed a questionnaire to evaluate exogenous chromium exposure.
Serum levels of chromium, molybdenum, iron and ferritin were measured in venous blood samples. Participants with elevated serum chromium levels underwent further erythrocyte chromium analysis. Comparisons were made with two control groups;
“non-instrumented” individuals with scoliosis and “normal” unaffected volunteers. All control group participants underwent serum and erythrocyte analysis (as above).
Thirty “instrumented” patients (Group 1, 26 females and 4 males), 10 “non instrumented” patients with scoliosis (Group 2) and 10 unaffected volunteers (Group 3) were included in the study. Mean age at surgery was 13.8 years (range 6.6 to 13.2), mean time from surgery 5.7 years (range 3.4 to 8.1). Elevated serum chromium levels were demonstrated in 11/30 (37%) Group 1 participants. In the control groups, elevated serum chromium levels were demonstrated in 0/10 (0%) in Group 2 and 2/10 (20 %) in Group 3. There was a statistically significant (p=0.001) elevation in serum chromium levels between scoliosis participants with retained spinal implants, and those without.
There was no significant correlation found between Groups 1, 2 and 3 for serum molybdenum, iron and ferritin levels. Erythrocyte chromium measurements from all participants (n=31, 100%) were considered within the normal range.
At a multivariant level, the results of a stepwise censored regression (n=50) indicated the significant predictors of serum chromium to be spinal implants (p=0.001), gender (male versus female, p=0.04) and iron grading (low, normal or high, p=0.05).
Time since surgery was found not to have a significant correlation with chromium levels (p=0.147).
Raised serum chromium levels were detected in 37% of patients after instrumented spinal arthrodesis for scoliosis correction. This new finding has relatively unknown health implications but potential genotoxic, dysmorphic and carcinogenic sequelae; this is especially concerning with most scoliosis patients being adolescent females with their reproductive years ahead.
The trampoline is a popular source of recreational and competitive sport. However, little is documented about the dangers associated with its use particularly in the paediatric population.
We reviewed paediatric patients referred to our service from April to September 2005 inclusively, having been injured on a trampoline. This unit services a catchment area of approximately 400,000 patients.
Eighty-eight patients were assessed (mean age: 8 years 6 months). There were 33 males and 55 females. Most injuries (53/88) occurred while bouncing on the trampoline, while 34 were secondary to falls off the trampoline. The injured child was supervised in only 40% cases. In 31 cases, the injury was attributable to the presence of others on the trampoline. Thirty-six children required surgery. Fracturesof the upper extremities occurred in 70% of cases.
Injuries related to the recreational use of trampolines are an important and significant cause of paediatric injury. These results strongly suggest that there is a clear need for guidelines.
This study is to evaluate the effectiveness and outcome of our protocol: Russell traction followed by gentle manipulative reduction with a single screw fixation & spica cast immobilization.
Twenty-three patients with thirty hips of slipped capital femoral epiphysis were treated in our department, KK Women’s and Children’s Hospital, Singapore between 1997 and 2005. Except one patient lost of follow-up, twenty-four SCFEs with more than 2 years follow-up were reviewed. In this series, there were 13 boys & 5 girls, mean age 12 year old ranging from 10 to 14 years. Among them 7 were Chinese, 6 Malays & 5 Indians. There were 12 unilateral cases (8 on the left & 4 right, 67%) & 6 bilateral cases (33%), including 2 patients found contralateral SCFE subsequently 1 year postoperatively. Acute-on-chronic SCFE were 16 & chronic SCFE 8. 16 were Grate I & 8 Grate II. Russell traction was on preoperatively with an average of 6 days. Gentle manipulative reduction under general anesthesia was performed in 20 SCFEs (12 GI & 8 GII) and 17 of them were successful. Fixation with a single screw was used for all cases except one hip with 2 screws.
Average follow-up was 38.5 months. Good results achieved. All patient were symptom free with good function. No complications of AVN, chondrolysis, screw loosening and reslipping of the affective hips.
Our protocol of management for SCFE has been largely successful in term of manipulative reduction and fixation.
This is a safe, simple and effective management.
We report the frequency of door-opening (“theatre traffic”) in orthopaedic operations at three metropolitan hospitals with different theatre policies. Published studies have correlated “theatre traffic” with airborne bacteria levels, which have been associated with raised wound infection rates.
Hospital A had one scoliosis operation and two hip replacements, Hospital B had one knee revision and one knee replacement. Hospital C had one scoliosis operation. A second scoliosis operation was performed at Hospital C after “theatre traffic” education and door signage discouraging entry.
One pair of surgeons performed the scoliosis operations and a different pair did the hips and knees.
Hospital A is private and Hospitals B and C are public.
The scoliosis operation in Hospital A (private) had an average door opening rate of 0.45/min compared to the same operation in Hospital C (public) with an average door opening rate of 1.0/min. The two hip replacements in Hospital A (private) had an average rate of 0.43/min and 0.51/min while the knee revision and knee replacement in Hospital B (public) had average rates of 0.91/min and 0.77/min respectively.
Of concern is the total number of door openings that result from this rate of “theatre traffic”. In the Hospital C (public) operation the total number of door openings equalled 140 over the course of the scoliosis operation. In Hospital B the total number of door openings for the knee revision was 169 and the knee replacement was 72. In contrast, for Hospital A (private) the total number of door openings for the scoliosis operation was 73 and the two hip replacements equalled 30 and 36.
The second study at Hospital C after staff education revealed a 35% decrease to 0.65/min.
There was a difference in “theatre traffic” between private and public hospitals for the same or similar operations. Staff education and door signage dramatically reduced “theatre traffic” in Hospital C. Surgeons and theatre staff need to be aware of “theatre traffic” and its influence on infection rates.
However the complication rates have been noticeably higher for the Inverse shoulder arthroplasties with 2/44 (5%) not being completed at surgery and 5/44 (11%) requiring surgical revision subsequently. This experience mirrors that of other publications which will be summarised.
Instability for persistent subluxation or dislocation of the SCJ has been treated with interposition with Graft-Jacket +/− medial clavicle resection (2) or a sterno-mastoid tendon stabilisation (2).
We prospectively compared hemiarthroplasty (HA) and total shoulder replacement (TSR) in cuff intact osteoarthritis. The 2 years postoperative review, which has been presented previously, showed an advantage of TSR over HA. This study reviewed the longer term outcome in the same patients at a minimum of 10 years to assess the longer term durability of the glenoid components. Patients with Osteoarthritis and an intact rotator cuff were intraoperatively randomisation to HA or TSR using the Global™ Shoulder Arthroplasty system after glenoid exposure. Post-operative mobilisation for the two groups was identical, and up until two years, patients were assessed using the UCLA and Constant Score, as well as analog pain scales and functional questionnaire. At the 10 year review patients were assessed using a similar range of subjective evaluations by telephone, or reviewed in the clinic as was possible
Thirty-three shoulders in thirty-two patients were entered into the trial (14 HA and 19 TSR). At six months and one year, function scores and motion were similar, but the TSR group had less pain than the HA patients (p < 0.05) and this became more apparent at two years postoperatively (p< 0.02). Apart from those who died, no patients were lost to follow-up. At the two year mark postoperatively one patient in the HA group had undergone revision to TSR due to severe pain secondary to glenoid erosion, and three further HA were subsequently revised (2 at 3 years, and one at 4 years). Two shoulders in the TSR group have been revised (at 5 years and 7 years). At 10 years from the initial arthroplasty, 5 of the 14 HA and 6 of the 19 TSR had died. 10 of the 14 HA (71%) and 17 of the 19 TSR (89%) remained in situ at the time of death or at the 10 year review. Overall outcomes in each group were similar with respect to pain, function, daily activities. Based on this longer term review, our recommendation remains that TSR has advantages over HA with respect to pain and function at two years, and there has not been a reversal of the outcomes on prolonged follow-up. Revision from HA to TSR is made difficult due to glenoid erosion. Overall 89% of TSR remain insitu at death or 10 year, whereas 71% of HA were intact at the same times. The contention that HA will avoid later arthroplasty complications and, in particular, an unacceptable rate of late glenoid failure is not supported by this longer term review.
There has been concern over the safety of the upright position for shoulder surgery from anaesthetists uncomfortable with the risk of reduced cerebral blood flow (CBF). Because there are no studies documenting what happens to CBF during upright surgery we aimed to measure CBF through an indirect and non-invasive method using recently available Ultrasound monitoring equipment.
This study randomised patients into awake (interscalene block alone) and GA with block, and indirectly measured the CBF by using a validated Doppler technique on carotid flow both before and during the shoulder procedure. Non-invasive and invasive measurements of mean arterial pressure were made throughout the procedure, together with doppler measurement of carotid flow following preoperative measurement of carotid contribution to cerebral flow in the radiology department by an experienced sonographer. All measurements recorded in real time and charted independently.
This study has shown that CBF in both groups were consistent with the expected values, and CBF remained proportionate in supine to upright. CBF values in the block alone group were generally lower than the GA group. In the GA group the MAP dropped lower, requiring use of adrenergic drugs to bring the pressure up. Despite the significant drop in MAP, the CBF was still high. This could signify cerebral autoregulation is a significant factor in the upright position.
We have shown the feasibility of use of DOppler to indirectly measure CBF during upright surgery. Despite the predicted drop in MAP in this position with GA, we could NOT show a concurrent drop in CBF, demonstrating that much more complex factors regulate the CBF in these patients. Clearly, monitoring is the key to safe administration of anaesthetic in the upright position.
Patient outcomes are affected by tear characteristics, patient factors and surgical experience.
Little information is reported in literature on the affect on outcome in the presence of delamination tearing found at surgery.
This prospective study compares outcome of miniopen rotator cuff repairs with and without delamination.
The Western Ontario Rotator Cuff score (WORC) was used as the measurement tool to assess outcome. Scores were recorded pre-operatively and at 6 months, 12 months and 2 years post-operatively.
Tear size and presence of delamination were recorded at the time of surgery. Incidence of delamination was 72%. The average age of patients was 58.6 years. There was no age difference in the incidence of delamination. Incidence of delamination was 72% in patients under 60 years (n=123) and 71% in patients over 60 years (106). 72% (of 62) female shoulders showed delamination and 71.5% (of 168) male shoulders showed delamination. Tears of less than 3cm had a 64% incidence of delamination. Tears greater than 3cm had 76% incidence of delamination. No difference in pre-operative WORC scores between delaminated group versus non-laminated group. Pre-operative WORC scores showed both delaminated and non-laminated tears had 40% of maximum score. Analysis at 2 years showed no difference in outcome of non-laminated tears (84% of maximum score) compared with delaminated tears (84% of maximum score). Size at time of repair did not affect outcome. Outcome showed slightly better results for delaminated tears in the older age group. Workers compensation patients achieved poorer outcomes than non workers compensation patients but there was no difference for delaminated versus non-laminated tears.
There is no significant difference in outcome of repair when comparing workers compensation, size of tear or sex.
Increasing age was a positive predictor for outcome at 6 and 12 months.
It remains to be seen whether arthroscopic techniques can achieve similar results.
Frozen Shoulder (FS) is a debilitating musculoskeletal condition with an uncertain aetiology and poorly understood pathogenic mechanism. This study aimed to investigate the pathology of FS. We hypothesised that an altered expression of cytokines may disrupt the normal tissue remodeling process, leading to FS, which would be apparent histologically.
Patients undergoing arthroscopic treatment of FS were prospectively recruited, along with control patients being treated for subacromial impingement. Synovial biopsies were taken from all subjects. Synovial RNA levels were analysed using quantitative Polymerase Chain Reaction (qPCR). Inflammatory cytokines and growth factors thought to play a role in the pathogenesis of FS were assessed. These included metalloproteases (MMP, ADAMTS) involved in tissue remodeling and fibrosis, inflammatory cytokines such as interleukins (IL), and growth factors such as colony stimulating factors (MCSF, GMCSF, CSF1R). Samples underwent histological analysis, to assess inflammation and fibrosis.
Thirteen patients with FS and ten control patients with subacromial impingement were recruited. Arthroscopic inspection revealed greater levels of synovitis (2.63+ vs 0.40+, p< 0.01) and papillary proliferation (50% vs 10%, p=0.02) in FS patients compared with the control group, confirming the initial clinical diagnosis of FS. Histological analysis of the synovium revealed samples from the FS group were more likely to demonstrate a fibrotic, focally nodular collagen morphology (53.8% vs 10%, p=0.03). There were similar levels of chronic inflammatory cells present in those with FS and control patients (53.8% vs 30%, p=0.25). There was no evidence of acute inflammation in any of the samples. Immunohistochemical staining revealed a high level of AGEs present in the synovium and smooth muscle tissue in all samples. There was no observed difference between diabetic and non-diabetic samples. Cytogenetic analysis using qPCR revealed fibrogenic factors MMP3 (p=0.068), and ADAMTS4 (p=0.083) to be elevated in FS cases, as were inflammatory cytokines IL6 (p=0.062) and IL8 (p=0.075)
We have quantified the level of inflammatory cytokines and growth factors in FS, demonstrating that these factors are elevated in FS. This indicates that altered levels of inflammatory cytokines may be associated with the pathogenesis of inflammation evolving into fibrosis, the characteristic feature of FS. We have also shown the histology of this fibrosis to be different to that observed in normal synovium.
Results: We found there is no significant difference between left (anterior: mean 2.92 mm, SD 1.15; posterior: mean 5.10 mm, SD 1.75; inferior: mean 3.08 mm, SD 1.00) and right (anterior: mean 3.07 mm, SD 1.14; posterior: mean 4.87 mm, SD 1.61; inferior: mean 2.91 mm, SD 0.99) shoulder in healthy players (P > 0.05). The comparison between the healthy shoulders (anterior: mean 3.00 mm, SD 1.15; posterior: mean 4.99 mm, SD 1.68; inferior: mean 3.00 mm, SD 1.00) from healthy players and the normal uninjured shoulder (anterior: mean 4.16 mm, SD 1.70; posterior: mean 6.16 mm, SD 3.04; inferior: mean 3.42 mm, SD 1.18) from injured players identified that players with unstable shoulders have a significantly higher shoulder translation in their normal shoulder than healthy players (P < 0.05).
Conclusion: This is the first study looking at laxity and the risk of shoulder dislocations in sportsmen involved in a high contact sport. These results support the hypothesis that rugby players with “lax” shoulders are more likely to sustain a dislocation or subluxation injury to one of these lax shoulders in their sport. We believe pre-season screening and targeted training may play a role in identifying those at risk and may decrease the incidence of dislocations.
Prosthetic radial head replacement is usually performed for trauma or post traumatic reconstruction. Therefore pain caused by a loose prosthesis might be incorrectly attributed to other causes. We lack reliable guidelines for diagnosing a loose radial head prosthesis that is symptomatic. Experience in Hip Arthroplasty has identified thigh pain as originating from the bone-prosthesis interface in the femoral canal, as opposed to the acetabulum or hip joint itself. The authors have recognized a similar phenomenon with radial head prostheses that has not yet been reported in the literature. Pain from a loose stem within the proximal radius may present as forearm pain.
The medical records and radiographs of 14 consecutive cases (13 patients) with proximal radial forearm pain associated with a loose radial head prosthesis were reviewed retrospectively. From August 1999 to December 2006, 9 consecutive patients (10 cases) required revision surgery for painful aseptic loosening of a primary metal prosthetic radial head implant. One of the 9 patients required re-revision with a longer stem. A further 4 patients with symptomatic aseptic loosening have not yet been revised. The indication for revision surgery was painful loosening of the prosthesis within the canal of the proximal radius in 7 patients (8 cases) and pain with no evidence of loosening in 2 patients (2 cases). Various prosthetic designs had been used in the primary operations.
In 12 of 14 cases the loosening was evident radiographically, but in 2 the only indication of a loose prosthesis (confirmed surgically) was proximal forearm pain. Revision or prosthetic removal eliminated the pain in 7 of 10 cases and decreased it in 1 Most of the patients who had relief of their forearm pain could tell in the first few days that the pain was gone following revision or removal of the loose radial head prosthetic component. One patient with moderate pain had an arthritic elbow and had no significant lasting relief from surgery. One patient was lost to follow-up. Follow-up averaged 27 months (range 1 to 66 months). Three of the 4 patients who had not yet undergone revision, were still awaiting revision and one did not want further surgery.
In conclusion, the presence of radial sided proximal forearm pain in a patient with a radial head prosthesis is a strong indicator of symptomatic aseptic loosening. If the prosthesis has a textured surface for bone ingrowth, and was inserted without cement, we now consider this symptom to be diagnostic even in the absence of radiographic signs of loosening.
Rotator cuff repair failure may to some extent be attributed to tendon-bone gap formation at the repair sight caused by insufficient suture tightening. We measured the footprint contact properties over time of single row and trans-osseous equivalent repairs. We also investigated the effect of suture retightening on the repair.
Rotator cuff tears (RCT) were created in the supra-spinatus tendon of 6 cadaveric shoulders. An electronic pressure sensor (Tekscan) was placed between the tendon and bone to measure the footprint pressure. The OPUS AutoCuff System was used to consecutively repair the RCT using a single row repair (SR-R) and two trans-osseous equivalent repair (TOE-R) techniques;
two parallel sutures (TOE-P) and cross over suture pattern (TOE-C). Sutures were tightened, then retightened in each group.
Peak initial contact force, were recorded on suture tightening (peak force) and equilibrium contact properties after 300 seconds relaxation (equilibrium force). Data were analysed using pairwise ANOVA.
All techniques demonstrated a similar trend in the contact properties over the test period with an initial peak in contact force on tightening of the sutures, followed by a rapid drop in contact pressure immediately after suture tightening, and finally tending towards equilibrium contact force at 300 seconds.
The TOE-C group demonstrated the highest mean ‘peak force’ and the highest ‘equilibrium force’ after 300 seconds relaxation. The TOE-P ‘peak force’ and ‘equilibrium force’ were −15% and −3% that of TOE-C, while the SRR was −45% and −25% that of TOE-C.
Retightening the sutures a second time had little effect on the SSR contact properties, while retightening the TOE repairs increased the equilibrium contact force by 30% although this was not significant.
Significant relaxation occurs especially within the first 30s, compromising the contact properties.
TOE-R’s exhibit better contact properties than SRR. Retightening the TOE-R’s tended towards a higher final equilibrium contact force. SRR repair contact properties were unaffected by a second tightening.
TOE-R’s should be re-tightened before the suture is locked
The benefit of open stabilization for recurrent shoulder instability is well known, however there have been recent reports of postoperative dysfunction of the subscapularis tendon following open shoulder surgery (Habermeyer et al, Scheibel et al). We present our findings in patients who have undergone an open anterior stabilization using a subscapularis split approach.
We reviewed 48 patients (49 shoulders), who were treated by the senior author (SB) from 2003–2005. They all underwent an open anterior stabilization of shoulder through a deltopectoral approach, with a subscapularis split technique, without any lateral tendon detachment. The minimum follow-up was 2 years, with average 34 months. Thirty-eight shoulders underwent an isolated anterior stabilization (1 bilateral) and 11 patients had additional procedures (8 bone grafts, 1 SLAP repair, 1 cuff repair, 1 anterior and posterior repair). There were 41 male and 7 female patients, and the mean age was 23.9 years (range 15–47 years). All patients were involved in sports and 45 had presented with recurrent dislocations. Patients were followed up using the Oxford instability score and the Rowe score questionnaires. All had a clinical examination for range of movement, stability, subscapularis muscle function, or signs of dysfunction. All had a MRI to assess the quality of the subscapularis muscle and tendon.
Mean postoperative Oxford instability score was 22.5 and the Rowe score was 69.38. Two patients had redislocated following re-injury. There was no evidence clinically of subscapularis dysfunction and the muscle and tendon were normal on all MRI scans. External rotation was reduced by a mean of 15.6 degrees. There was no significant loss of flexion or abduction. 81% of patients returned to their previous level of sport.
With a subscapularis split technique for anterior shoulder stabilization there is no significant postoperative dysfunction or damage to the subscapularis muscle, and most patients return to their previous level of sport.
The cervical spine exhibits the greatest range of motion amongst the spinal segments due to its tri-planar components of movement. As a result, measurement of movements has proved difficult. A variety of methods have been used in an attempt to measure these movements but none have provided satisfactory triplanar data.
This paper uses the Zebris ultrasonic 3-D motion analysis system to measure flexion, extension, range of lateral bending and range of axial rotation in five similar male and five similar female subjects with no history of neck injuries. The subjects were tested unrestrained and in soft and hard collars, as well as in Philadelphia, Miami J and Minerva orthoses.
Results show that the Minerva is the most stable construct for restriction of movement in all planes in both groups (p< 0.001 vs. all groups (p=0.01 vs. Philadelphia in female extension), ANOVA). In the male group, the standard hard collar provides the second best resistance to flexion, lateral bending and axial rotation. The female group showed no one orthosis in second place overall. Looking at these results allows ranking of the measured orthoses in order of their three-dimensional stability. Furthermore, they validate the Zebris as a reliable and safe method of measurement of the complex movements of the cervical spine with low intersubject variability.
In conclusion, this paper, for the first time presents reproducible data incorporating the composite triplanar movements of the cervical spine thus allowing comparative analysis of the three-dimensional construct stability of the studied orthoses. In addition, these results validate the use of the Zebris system for measurement of cervical spine motion.
A recurrent fracture rate after vertebroplasty and balloon kyphoplasty is as high as 20%. Biomechanically, it has not been proven that refracture rate is due to the cement stiffness alone. This finite-element study investigated effects of cement-stiffness, bone-quality, cement-volume and height-restoration in treatment of vertebral compression fractures using balloon kyphoplasty.
A finite-element model of the lumbar spine was generated from CT-scans. The model comprised of two functional spinal-units, consisting of L2-L4 vertebral bodies, intervertebral-discs, and spinal ligaments. Cement volumes modelled were in the order of 15% and 30% of total vertebral body (VB) volume. Spinal fracture was modelled as being reduced and height of VB was restored. Kyphoplasty was performed. Three different bone qualities were modelled: healthy, osteopenic, osteoporotic. A compressive load was applied to the proximal endplate of L2. An anterior shift of the centre-of-gravity of upper body was simulated by increasing the moment arm of the applied load.
All results of the analysis were compared back to an intact spinal model of the same region under the same loading regime. All parameters affected the mechanical behaviour of the spine model, although changing the bone quality from normal to osteoporotic resulted in the least change. The cement stiffness was initially modelled with an elastic modulus between 0.5GPa and 2GPa. The results showed small differences relative to intact case in the lower modulus cement. A much higher cement stiffness of 8GPa resulted in larger changes in the stresses. The most significant parameter in this study was found to be the changed load path as a result of partial height restoration. This induced a moment in the construct and increased the stresses and strains in the anterior compartments of each vertebra as well as marked in the adjacent (upper and lower) vertebrae. The factor of safety calculation showed the centre of the L3 vertebra to be the most failure prone in all cases, with the osteoporotic bone models showing higher fracture tendencies.
This study indicates that healthier bone has a better chance of survival. Cement properties with lower cement elastic moduli induce stresses/strains which are more similar to the intact model. The best way to reduce the likelihood of failure is to restore the vertebral height.
This study aims to explore the trend in spine fusion surgery in Australia over the past 10 years and to explore the possible influence of health insurance status (private versus public) on the rate of surgery.
Data pertaining to the rate of lumbar spine fusion from 1997 to 2006 were collected. Data on publicly performed procedures in NSW were obtained from Inpatient Statistics Collection of NSW Health, and data on privately performed procedures were obtained from Medicare Australia Statistics. Population data was obtained from the Australian Bureau of Statistics. Data on total hip and total knee arthroplasties performed were collected to provide a comparator. Health insurance coverage was also investigated to control for insurance status, this data was obtained from the Private Health Insurance Administration Council.
There has been a slowly declining trend in the number of publicly performed spinal fusion procedures over the past 10 years, falling by 63% from 1997 to 2006 in NSW. In comparison, privately performed spinal fusion procedures have increased by 166% over the same 10 year period. Compared to spine fusion, the rates of total hip and total knee replacement procedures in the public sector of NSW have fallen by smaller proportions (58.9%% and 42.1%, respectively) over the same 10 year period. The increase in privately performed joint replacements has been less than that seen for spine fusion, with increases of 120% and 74%% for knee arthroplasties and hip arthroplasties, respectively.
In 2006, spine fusion surgery was 10.8 times more likely to be done in the private sector than in the public sector, compared to corresponding figures of 4.2 times and 3.0 times for knee replacement and hip replacement, respectively.
Our study has demonstrated that there is a disproportionately high rate of spine fusion procedures performed in the private sector. Possible explanations for this difference include: over servicing in the private sector, under servicing in the public sector, differences in medical referral patterns, surgeon and patient preferences, and financial incentives.
Stress fractures of the pars interarticularis of the lumbar spine in professional fast bowlers have become commonplace in recent times. Should conservative measures in their treatment fail, surgery can give good results. Postoperative rehabilitation is of the utmost importance following surgery and a suggested programme is outlined.
Post operatively, exercises and rehabilitation should proceed at a rate that is proportional to graft incorporation at the surgical site. Our rehabilitation programme has been fine tuned over several years giving much clearer guidance regarding that bowlers’ progress.
We have rehabilitated 12 fast bowlers subsequent to Bucks repair of the pars interarticularis stress fracture in the lumbar spine. We have identified 7 stages in this process to rehabilitate the bowler to the highest level. We emphasise that the process of rehabilitation involves a team approach, the most important members being surgeon, physiotherapist, bowling coach and trainer.
Surgery to the fast bowler with a stress fracture of the pars interarticularis can give good results. However it is necessary to have a multidisciplinary rehabilitation programme that proceeds in a stepwise manner to enable a return to full sport.
Introduction: Studies suggest pedicle screw constructs are more effective than hybrid or hook constructs for AIS correction. This study assessed the efficacy of three methods of spinal instrumentation in patients treated at the WCH.
Structural curve correction was 63.6°, 60.2° and 58.5° for each group respectively. Compensatory curve correction favoured the hybrid and screw groups.
Thoracic kyphosis correction was 20.7° (most improved), 19.9°, and 15.5° for the screw, hook, and hybrid groups respectively.
Coronal alignment favoured the screw construct group.
Comparison of operative time revealed no significant difference, and complication rates were similar in nature and incidence for all three groups.
Traditional management of spinal metastases has been for the most part palliative. In this decade however there has been a gradual shift towards extirpative treatment of spinal secondary malignancy in certain circumstances. The techniques of en bloc vertebral resection have gained more widespread acceptance improving the chances of successful wide or marginal resection of both primary and secondary tumours of the spine. Those metastatic lesions which are solitary and associated with a long period of latency from treatment of the primary lesion have a greater likelihood of improved survival with en bloc resection. Although technically demanding, these same techniques coupled with advances in spinal implantation may allow complete excision of extended primary malignancy of the spine previously considered unresectable. This presentation examines the indications for en bloc resection of secondary and extended primary malignancy of the spine. A case for early referral of solitary metastatic spinal lesions is presented in the hope of adding extirpative surgical techniques to the traditional armamentarium of theoncologist.
Stress fractures of the pars interarticularis of the lumbar spine in professional fast bowlers have become commonplace in modern times with a recently reported prevalence of 16.1%. We report 25 years of experience in the management of this patient group.
Between 1982 and 2007, we diagnosed pars defects in 21 professional cricketers. 8 were managed conservatively by a combination of rest, supervised rehabilitation, bowling action analysis and re-training to a ‘safe’ action. Surgery was considered in those players who did not respond to these conservative measures and this group essentially compromised of the fast bowlers. Surgery was by Buck’s direct repair of the pars lesion.
This treatment regime has given very good results enabling all of these players to return to professional sport with an average follow-up of over 5 years. Two of the surgical group have over 10 years follow-up and 4 have played to international level subsequent to their surgery.
We recommend treatment of this group of sportsmen in a unit consisting of a specialist physiotherapist, a bowling coach and a spinal surgeon. Should conservative measures fail, we recommend Buck’s repair as the operation of choice.
Median hospital length of stay was 12 days. Inpatient mortality reached 5.5% whilst mortality at 6 and 12 months post-injury was 17.1% and 22.6% respectively. Upon discharge 16.1% returned to the community and 60.5% required rehabilitation. At 6 months 48.0% were residing at home and 30.5% at an institutional setting. Institutionalisation decreased to 27.7% at 12 months, approaching pre-injury levels. Mean physical SF-12 scores remained well below population norms at 12 months (36.4 vs 48.9). Younger patients demonstrated significantly different results with reference to presentation, management and outcomes. Several factors were highlighted as predictors of mortality and/or functional recovery.
We aimed to examine the influence of nursing home residency on mortality after sustaining an acute hip fracture in patients presenting to a metropolitan trauma centre. A prospective study of all adults aged 65 years and over who presented to a single tertiary referral hospital for management of a fracture of the proximal femur between July 2003 and September 2006. Residential status was obtained at admission. Patients were followed up to September 2007. Relative risk values for mortality were calculated comparing nursing home residents with non-nursing home residents. Survival analysis was performed.
Relative risk of death was higher in nursing home patients compared to non-nursing home patients. This was particularly so in the first 30 days (RR 1.9). Survival analysis showed that 25% of patients in the nursing home group died by 96 days post-injury, compared with 435 days post-injury in the non-nursing home group. The age-adjusted hazard ratio for death in nursing home patients was 1.5 (95% CI: 1.1–2.1), however the effect of nursing home status decreased over the first 12–24 months.
Nursing home residence confers an increased risk of death following hip fractures, especially in the immediate post-injury period. However, the relative risk of death decreased over time. This study provides some indication of the mortality risk in an easily definable population, without requiring an alternative assessment of comorbidities.
The treatment of those fractures varies from conservative treatment, posterior plate fixation, anterior plating as well as percutaneous and open Sacroiliac (SI) joint screws.
However, screw pull-outs and loss of fixation in those methods are well described In the Alfred Hospital, Melbourne (Australia) a Level 1 Trauma Center a series of 14 patients were treated from 10/2006 to date with a multiaxial spinal system.
A pedicel screw from a multiaxial spinal system (Xia, Stryker or Pangea, Synthes) is placed percutaneously in the posterior iliac crest on both sides and the reduction is performed with the screws attached to the screw handles and with Image Intensifier.
After the reduction the multiaxial screwheads are bent and transfixed with a bar which is tunneled epifacial.
All patients underwent a multislice pelvic and lumbar spine CT and these patients were assessed clinically for neurovascular symptoms and stability. The follow-up included clinical assessment and CT imaging.
The follow up time was one to 18 month. The patients were assessed clinically and with CT imaging. No complications or loss of fixation have been observed in this patient group in this short follow up time.
The construct provides initial stability and allows mobilization of the patient. It can be used in cases with sacral comminution and may offer advantages over posterior plate fixation, by reducing complications with prominent metalware.
Traditional fixation with a DHS or Gamma Nail has seen instances of excessive fracture collapse, screw cut out, re-operation, and loss of independence for the patient. The Gotfried PerCutaneous Compression Plate (PCCP) is a novel solution reducing the morbidity of fixing intertrochanteric fractures. Claimed advantages include relative preservation of the lateral femoral cortex, achieving better fracture stability, less collapse, and a percutaneous technique.
This is a pilot study of the introduction of the PCCP. At the time of abstract submission, 42 cases have been undertaken in Ballarat. The study assesses the safety and learning curve issues. Outcomes include length of stay, morbidity, and return to independence. A comparison to a historical cohort is made.
Of the first 42 cases, no operative complications occurred. The operations were no longer than traditional fixation methods, and no “learning curve” errors occurred. One patient with severe osteoarthritis of the hip preoperatively still required a hip replacement, which was performed 3 months later without difficulty. Two patients died within a week post-operatively. The PCCP provided an eloquent low morbidity solution to even extremely displaced fractures, allowing comfortable nursing and a high proportion of patients maintained their previous level of independence.
The PCCP is a better way of fixing intertrochanteric fractures. It prevents excessive collapse, maintains femoral shaft offset, has less surgical morbidity, and consequently has minimized the loss of independence often seen with the fractures.
Pelvic fractures in multi-trauma patients are an indicator of severe trauma and often require advanced wound management of pelvic, abdominal or extremity injuries. Poor wound management may result infected pelvic hardware, necessitating revision surgery. We propose that TNP is a safe method of wound management and report our experience.
In 2006 91 multi-trauma patients required pelvic/ace-tabular fixation at The Alfred, either internal or external. Of those, 23 needed TNP for wound care of pelvic, abdominal or extremity injuries. Indications for TNP included Morel-Lavelle lesions, concomitant bladder disruption with anterior wounds, severe edema preventing any wound closure, extremity open fractures/degloving/fasciotomies and post-op infections.
The average age of the group was 33, the average injury severity score was 36, 5 were female, 18 were male. There was one pelvic wound infection that resolved with TNP and local wound care. Two unsalvageable limbs (one transhumeral, one transfemoral) required amputation after TNP, all others were either closed primarily or with a flap and skin graft. There was one death in the group from unrelated causes. Pelvic scores, SF-12, visual analog pain scores and sexual dysfunction rates are being gathered and will be reported.
Topical negative pressure is a safe and effective method of managing complex wounds in multi-trauma patients with pelvic injuries.
Successful treatment of bone fractures requires a balance between stability, to restore functional anatomy and allow early mobilisation (and thus avoid dystrophy). The healing occurs through complex interactions of inducing, enabling and inhibitory factors. The mechanical environment (e.g. stress and strain) in/around the fracture site regulates tissue changes throughout the healing process, including the formation of a fibro-cartilaginous callus and its progressive replacement by bone. The mechanical and biological environment is controlled substantially by the selection of the fracture stabilisation method achieving either absolute stability (mostly achieved with compression plating technique) or relative stability allowing a limited amount of dynamic fracture displacement across the fracture gap. A number of treatments may be used to accomplish these conditions, ranging from splinting with a plaster cast, external fixator or an intramedullary nail to rigid internal fixation using plates affixed to the bone fragments. Fixation methods are presently selected on the basis of general guidelines, but nevertheless the optimal stability/instability remains unclear and relies heavily on the surgeon’s experience. With the recently more and more widely used locking plates the question of the optimal fixation technique and applied stability to the fracture zone especially in simple fractures have raised again.
To fill this knowledge gap, an interdisciplinary approach with in vitro and in vivo experiments seems to be essential. Analysing clinical situations and the healing course with mathematical modelling and computational simulations can further aid to understand the healing conditions in respect to stability.
This presentation will give an overview on the role of the mechanical environment in fracture healing, and demonstrating clinical examples that highlight the relevance of this research.
Differentially loaded radiostereometric analysis (DLRSA) uses RSA whilst simultaneously applying load to the bones under investigation. This technique allows measurement of interfragmentary translations and rotations under measured weight bearing and joint movement. We have recently introduced this technique to monitor tibial plateau fracture healing. This paper presents our preliminary results.
Twelve patients with a 41 B2, B3, C2, or C3 fracture were followed for a minimum of three months. RSA beads were inserted in the largest osteochondral fragment and the adjacent metaphysis. Knee flexion was restricted to 60° for 6 weeks. After partial weight bearing (20kg) between 2 and 6 weeks, patients progressed to full weight bearing. Follow up included clinical and radiological examinations and patient reported outcome scores (Lysholm, KOOS). DLRSA examinations included RSA radiographs in 60° flexion and under measured weight bearing. Significant interfragmentary displacement was defined as translations greater than 0.5mm and/or rotations greater than 1.5°.
There was no loss to follow-up. Longitudinal RSA follow-up: Follow-up RSA radiographs were compared to postoperative examinations. Osteochondral fragment depression was less than 0.5mm in seven patients and between 2 and 4mm in the remaining five patients. Significant interfragmentary displacement after three months was recorded in three patients. DLRSA flexion results: Under 60° of flexion, translations over 0.5mm were recorded in five patients (one postoperatively; one at 2 weeks; two at 6 weeks; and one postoperatively, at 2 weeks and at 3 months). Rotations over 1.5° were recorded in six patients (one postoperatively; two at 2 weeks; one at 6 weeks; one at 2 weeks, 3 months and 4.5 months; and one postoperatively, at 2 weeks, 3 months and 6 months). DLRSA weight bearing results: Under partial weight bearing at two weeks, two patients recorded significant translations, one involving a significant rotation. Under weight bearing as tolerated, three patients recorded significant translations (one at 6 weeks; and two at 18 weeks) and four patients recorded significant rotations (one at 6 weeks; one at 18 weeks; and two at 12 and 18 weeks). Patient Reported Outcomes: Both the Lysholm and KOOS scores improved between 6 weeks and 3 months. DLRSA provides new insight and perspective in tibial plateau fractures. Some fractures take more than three months to heal. Our current rehabilitation protocol was safe in most patients, however significant interfragmentary displacement was encountered in 17% at the 2 week followup, raising questions about the quality of the initial stability.
Since the early nineties clinical experience were gained with locking plates to stabilize long bone fractures. Firstly with a Point Contact Fixator, a device making the step from a conventional plate to an internal fixator, than with pure precontured internal fixators for the periaticular regions or nowadays with plates giving the option for the placement of locking or conventional cortical screws and are so called Locked Compression Plate (LCP). Almost every new development for extraarticular fracture stabilization reflects this development.
Despite today’s broad, worldwide acceptance of the fixation technique, someone should be very clear about the benefits and the underlying concept to avoid failures, complications and unnecessary costs. Clear clinical benefits have been proven in complex fractures of the metaphysis and joints, furthermore the fixation of highly osteoporotic and/or periprosthetic fractures became more reliable. Also the technique of minimally invasive plating – the so-called biological plating –, where the fracture zone is only bridged and therefore the fracture often is not exposed any more, was facilitated with the new internal fixators. However, the process should not be overused, particularly in cases of insufficient surgical experience, because the technical demanding minimally invasive procedures can have detrimental effects on the fracture alignment and therefore on the later outcome. Not to forget the extended use of intraoperative x-ray exposure to control the reduction and implant fixation.
Applying locking plates, the surgeon should never forget that bone healing requires still prerequisites in respect to stability and, of course, of other biological stimuli. This reflects the ongoing discussion, how a simple long bone fracture, should be optimal stabilized with an internal fixator, the amount of bone/implant fixations contacts and the timing for necessary further operations in present of delayed healing. The opportunity to combine both stabilization options – conventional screw and locking screw placement – within one implant needs a clear understanding of the underlying fixation issues and requires a clear teaching concept to avoid unfavorable combination of the different screws.
In this lecture a broad, critical overview about the worldwide impact of locking plates in long bone fracture treatment will be given including proven advantages as well as discussing detected disadvantages using literature evidence and clinical examples.
Methods: 24 sheep (Merino wethers, mean age 5.6years, mean weight 39.1kg) underwent the trauma model 2 with a severe soft tissue damage and a multifragmentary, distal femur fracture as well as initial stabilisation with an external fixator. After five days of soft tissue recovery, the animals were definitively operated with an internal fixator (LCP) randomised either by a minimally invasive or open approach. The sheep were sacrificed after 4 and 8 weeks (two groups), mechanical testing performed and statistically analysed with ANOVA test.
Results: After 4 weeks, torsional rigidity is significantly higher in the MIPO group (30.1r10.6(SD)%) of fractured to intact bones, p< 0.05) compared to ORIF group (9.8r12.4(SD)%), while ultimate torque also shows increased values for MIPO technique (p=0.11). After 8 weeks, the differences in mechanical properties levelled out, but still higher values for the MIPO group (p=0.36/p=0.26).
Conclusion: In the early stage of fracture healing, minimally invasive plate osteosynthesis shows advanced healing pattern compared to open fixation technique. This advantage seems to level out over time.
Fractures of the proximal humerus account for 4–5% of all fractures with 80% requiring no surgical treatment. However, the management of the other 20% remains controversial. Multiple surgical modalities have been examined with no consensus as to which if any is the most effective.
This study followed a series of 27 patients who had PHILOS plate fixation of their proximal humeral fractures. All patients were followed up clinically and radiologically for at least one year to a mean of 27.6+/−7.8 months.
We reviewed 27 patients with a mean age of 62.2 years (16 patients were aged at least 60 years). The patients were classified as per the AO system into type A (n=11), type B (n=12) and type C (n=3) fractures. The mean DASH score was 51.8. The mean SF-36 scores for physical and social functions were 68.7 and 88.0 respectively. The mean Constant score was 50.5%.
These results how that the PHILOS plate offers good functional outcomes across a spectrum of fracture severities and in an older population group. Its use should be considered where appropriate in the management of displaced proximal humeral fractures.
Despite various forms of operative treatment, outcomes have been variable after displaced multi-fragment proximal humeral fractures. A significant number of fixation failures and avascular necrosis of humeral head occurs (up to 77 percent). Biomechanical studies on the locking proximal humeral plate indicate the locked screw-plate combination is a more stable construct than conventional implants. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the clinical and radiological outcome in patients who have undergone operative treatment using this implant.
Twenty-three patients with displaced proximal humeral fractures underwent surgery using this implant. The mean age was 63.6 years (range, 40–85). Nineteen patients were female and 4 were male. The mean follow-up duration was 22.2 months (range, 5–38). All patients had a fracture configuration that required operative treatment. Three patients were lost to follow-up leaving 20 patients available for review. Patients were assessed clinically using the Constant score, pain scale and satisfaction scale. General health was assessed using the SF-12 survey. Radiographs were assessed looking at the initial reduction to determine whether an anatomical reduction with calcar support correlated with a better outcome.
The mean constant score was 62 (32.5–85). The mean age and sex-adjusted constant score was 83 percent (46–117). The mean pain score was 26mm (100mm scale), and the mean satisfaction score was 84 percent. Patients that were 60 years or younger had a lower age and sex adjusted constant scores (78, range 58–109 percent) than those over 60 years (87, range 46–117 percent) despite a better absolute score (63 vs. 61). The Physical Component Score of the SF-12 was better in the younger age group than it was in the older group (43 vs. 38) although the Mental Component Score was lower (45 vs. 54). Overall satisfaction was also lower in those 60-years and younger (79 compared with 86 percent). This may be explained by higher social demands on younger patients. Only 3 patients sustained the injury as result of high-energy trauma. These patients were significantly younger (50, range 40–56) than the low energy trauma group (65, range 46–85). Patients that sustained high-energy trauma had a better clinical outcome with a mean constant score of 74.3 compared with 59.6 for the low energy trauma group.
Nine patients did not have adequate medical (calcar) support with the initial reduction. Four of these patients developed complications. Two patients developed AVN requiring a hemi-arthroplasty. One patient had a valgus collapse of the head fragment and screw penetration requiring removal. One patient had a non-union requiring bone grafting and re-plating.
The proximal humeral locking plate provides a good clinical outcome. The results of this study correlate with the limited data available on these implants in the literature. A clinical benefit over alternative procedures is yet to be elucidated by a randomised clinical trial. An anatomical reduction with calcar support appears to result in a lower complication rate.
Rates of operative fixation for clavicle fractures have been increasing over recent years, but non-operative treatment remains the most common treatment. However, the reported results of case series of non-operatively and operatively treated clavicle fractures show considerable variation, making comparison difficult.
Non-operative treatment leads to unsatisfactory results in approximately 3 – 10% of cases, sometimes requiring delayed surgical intervention. Recent studies exploring predictors of poor results after non-operative treatment have shown that fracture displacement is a significant predictor of poor outcome. However, fracture comminution, angulation, shortening, smoking, age, and fracture type and location are not consistently associated with worse outcomes. This has lead to increased interest in surgical fixation for displaced fractures.
Prior to the large randomised trial by the Canadian Orthopaedic Trauma Society (COTS), controlled trials comparing surgery to non-operative treatment provided no significant support for surgical fixation. The COTS study provides some evidence for plating displaced mid-shaft fractures, however, partly due to methodological issues, recent reviews of the topic have concluded that additional, more rigorous studies are required to confirm the findings of the COTS trial.
Intramedullary fixation is also popular, but it does not have the weight of evidence of plate fixation.
To assess patient following operative fixation of clavicle fractures. In the literature, the incidence of paraesthesia following operative fixation of clavicle fractures is reported to be between 7–29%. This problem can be bothersome to patients and the degree of disability is poorly documented.
All clavicle fractures (67) treated operatively at the Alfred Hospital between 01/06/2003 and 01/06/2006 were included in the study. Patients were asked to complete paper based questionnaires assessing satisfaction, presence of numbness and degree of disability following clavicle operation. Additionally, they were followed up clinically to assess the area of numbness and scarring.
The response rate was 65% (43/67). Most of the patients were satisfied with the operation and only 15% reported significant problems with the wound. Majority of patients returned to pre-morbid activities and employment. The degree of paraesthesia varied among respondents and it was associated with the type of incision used. There was little difference in patient satisfaction with regard to various surgical devices utilised.
It is important to address wound complications such as scarring and paraesthesia when discussing operative treatments for patients with clavicle fractures. The results suggest that wound related problems can be frequent and a significant percentage of operatively managed patient experience long term numbness. It is possibly an under appreciated problem. Additionally our results suggest that vertical incisions achieve a more favourable outcome compared to horizontal incisions.
The management of distal radius fractures has evolved with the availability of locking plates to control the fracture fragments from the volar surface. This study compares volar locking plates (VLP) with any other available treatment including K-wires, screws, non-locking plates, external fixateurs or any combination of these.
Patients with distal radius fractures requiring surgical intervention were invited to participate and were randomised to the VLP group or the other surgical treatment group. Outcome was assessed on radiology(radial length, angle, inclination and articular step), function (range of motion and grip strength) and the Disability of Arm Shoulder and Hand (DASH) score. The final assessment was at one year. Complications were recorded. The target was one hundred and sixty patients. Comparisons of sub groups based on fracture classification are made, including intra-articular and extra-articular fractures.
By August 2008, one hundred patients will have completed their one year follow up assessment. Initial results show no significant difference between the groups.
New fixation techniques for common fractures require objective assessment under normal conditions of use. This prospective study compares locked plate fixation with techniques available before its introduction. It aims to examine a range of fracture severities to determine which fracture types are appropriate for this fixation technique.
Distal clavicle fractures associated with coracoclavicular ligament disruption are potentially unstable
Inadequate distal fragment size and Displacement and instability consequent to ligament disruption.
We hypothesize that a contour-matched locking plate coupled with a coracoclavicular ligament repair device would provide a potentially safe and minimally invasive method for adequate fixation.
Between 2006 and 2008, 5 patients were surgically treated for non-comminuted distal clavicular fractures associated with coracoclavicular ligament disruption. The surgical technique consisted of
neutralization of muscular forces on the proximal fragment by using a minimally invasive ligament repair device (TightRope™, Arthrex, FL), and Internal fixation using a contour-matched locking plate (Distal radial locking plate, Synthes).
Technical tips to optimize this new procedure are presented. Outcome measures consisted of
Constant shoulder score Radiographic union.
The retrospective follow-up period varied from 8 weeks to 24 months. A statistically significant improvement in the Constant score was observed in every patient. All patients progressed to satisfactory bony union. Plate removal was not necessary in any patient. Potential complications include screw penetration of the acromioclavicular joint, acromioclavicular ligament disruption, and distal fragment comminution.
A contour-matched locking plate coupled with a coracoclavicular ligament repair device is a new lesser invasive and safe anatomical approach for achieving fixation adequacy in a highly unstable but non-comminuted distal clavicular fracture subgroup. We recommend strict adherence to the guidelines presented (technical tips) to achieve an optimal result.
Non-operative treatment of lateral clavicle fractures presents a difficult problem. A high incidence of non-union, residual pain and shoulder girdle instability has been reported. A variety of fixation techniques have been described but the complication rates of these procedures can be high. This retrospective review describes the use of distal radius locking plates for fixation of lateral unstable clavicle fractures.
From January 2006 until December 2007 23 patients (17 males, 5 females; mean age 31 yrs (12–70) presented to our service. 2 patients sustained type 1, 16 patients type 2, 2 patients type 4 and 3 patients type 5 fractures (Neer classification). Patients were reviewed clinically, radiographically and with Constant score assessment.
Union was acchieved at a mean follow up of 7.2 weeks. The mean Constant score at 6 months was 84, the mean DASH score 27.7. The following complications were seen during the follow-up period: 1 superficial infection settling with oral antibiotics and 1 non-union in a type 5 fracture requiring bone grafting.
Clavicle fractures of the lateral aspect are controversial. The mechanism of injury often results in ruptures of the adjacent coracoclavicular ligaments and create instability and increased motion between the proximal and distal fragment. The result of this series of cases are encouraging and we recommend the use of distal radius locking plates to treat unstable lateral clavicle fractures. However a larger study is needed to further evaluate mid- and long-term shoulder function.
This study compared the accuracy of reduction of intra-medullary nailed femoral shaft fractures, comparing conventional and computer navigation techniques.
Twenty femoral shaft fractures were created in human cadavers, with segmental defects ranging from 9–53mm in length. All fractures were fixed with antegrade 9mm diameter femoral nails on a radiolucent operating table. Five fractures (control) were fixed with conventional techniques. Fifteen fractures (study) were fixed with computer navigation, using fluoroscopic images of the normal femur to correct for length and rotation. The surgeon was blinded to defect size. Two landmark protocols were used in the study group referencing the piriform fossa (n=10) or proximal shaft axis (n=5). Postoperative CT scans, blindly reported by a musculoskeletal radiologist, were used to compare femoral length and rotation with the normal leg. Results were analysed using the Wilcoxon two-sample test.
The mean leg length discrepancy in the study group was 3.8mm (range 1–9), compared with 9.8mm(range 0–17) in the control group (p=0.076). The mean torsional deformity in the study group was 7.7 degrees (range 20–2) compared with 9 degrees (range 0–22) in the control group (p=0.86). Within the navigated study group, length discrepancy was similar in subgroups A (3.6mm) and B (4.2mm). Torsion appeared more accurate in group B (5.6 degrees) than group A (8.7 degrees), although not significantly.
Computer navigation appears to improve leg length discrepancy following femoral nailing. Technique modification during the study improved rotational accuracy, and with further improvement, will make this technique applicable to femoral fracture fixation.
Current orthopaedic practice involves an increasing use of operative fluoroscopic screening and radiation exposure. The AOA produces a booklet entitled “Radiation safety for orthopaedic surgeons” outlining the risks. There is a disparity between guidelines and actual clinical practice for trainee registrars.
To measure trainee fluoroscopy usage with and without consultants present. To audit trainees and hospitals adherence to the guidelines
All procedures in a 6 month period using II were analysed. Data for Procedure, Operating Surgeon, First Assistant and if Consultant Surgeon was present or absent was collected. Fluoroscopic Exposure Time was also recorded.
Procedures were grouped and times compared depending on the staff present. There were 121 cases included in the study. 44 cases were performed by the trainee with the consultant assisting and 76 were performed in the absence of the consultant.
A questionnaire based on the AOA guidelines was produced. All NSW advanced trainees in Orthopaedic surgery were asked to complete the anonymous questionnaire.
There was a significant difference of 32.18 seconds in mean exposure time per case with a p-value 0.0069 where the consultant was present or not. There was also a significant difference between consultants doing the same cases.
Other very significant findings were:
97% of trainees were not aware of the maintenance and inspection schedules equipment. 97% of trainees have practiced the incorrect technique of using the image receptor of the II machine as an operating table which maximizes scatter to the head and neck 65% regularly use continuous screening of II 65% admit to taking unnecessary II shots to ensure the perfect xray. 32% of trainees wore no thyroid protection, 87% no eye protection and 100% used no head and hand protection.
One registrar was exposed to 8131 seconds of II exposure during his 6 month rotation. Without the use of lead protection, the trainee registrar will have exceeded the annual limit of whole body exposure (20mSv/year) by more than 2-fold.
Dramatic decreases in exposure can be achieved by better discipline with the usage of II. This needs to be a fundamental part of registrar training.
The survey shows trainees are not aware, or fail to adhere to current guidelines and that hospitals are not providing appropriate safety equipment and not insisting that staff exercise safe practices.
To report the results of the intramedullary skeletal kinetic distractor (iskd) in patients with established leg length discrepancy following lower limb trauma.
12 patients with significant leg length discrepancy (> 20mm) following lower limb trauma were operated on using the iskd nail between september 2004 and december 2007. patients were followed up clinically and radiologically at minimum 18 months (mean: 27months range: 18–24 months).
8 femurs and 4 tibias were operated using the iskd nail. all patient in the series had successful completed treatements. the average leg length discrepancy was 38mm (91mm–21mm) and the average gained length was 37mm (76m–22mm). radiological union and bone consolidation were slow to occur. early weight bearing was permitted allowing earlier functional capacity. 6 patients required additional operations; 3 manipulation under anaesthesia for failed lengthening and 3 bone grafting for poor regenerate, 1 patient required more than one additional operation.
The iskd nail is an effective and reliable alternative technique for correcting leg length discrepancy in patients who have suffred lower limb trauma. it appears to mimic the results achieved with the use of a fine wire external fixator or a unilateral external fixator. the convenience of a fully implanted device is substantial. the complications are frequent but manageable with standard techniques.
Patient satisfaction has only recently gained attention as an outcome measure in orthopaedics, where it has been reported for joint replacement surgery. Little has been published regarding predictors of patient satisfaction in orthopaedic trauma. This study aims to explore the predictors of patient satisfaction, and of surgeon satisfaction, after orthopaedic trauma.
Adult patients admitted to hospital with fractures after motor vehicle trauma were surveyed on admission, and at six months. Demographic, injury, socio-economic and compensation-related factors were measured. The two outcomes were satisfaction with progress of the injury, and satisfaction with recovery. The treating surgeons were also surveyed at six months to determine surgeon satisfaction with progress, and recovery (using the same questions), and the presence or absence of fracture union and any complications. Multivariate analysis was used to determine significant predictors of satisfaction for both groups, and satisfaction rates were compared between surgeons and patients using multivariable analysis.
Of 306 patients recruited, 232 (75.8%) returned completed questionnaires, but only 141 (46.1%) surgeons responded. Patients rated their satisfaction with progress and recovery as 74.6% and 44.4%, respectively, whereas surgeon-rated satisfaction with progress and recovery was 88.0% and 66.7%, respectively (p< 0.0001). Significant predictors of patient dissatisfaction were: blaming others for the injury, being female, and using a lawyer. Patient-rated outcome was not significantly associated with objective injury or treatment factors. The only significant predictor of surgeon dissatisfaction was fracture non-union.
Orthopaedic surgeons overestimated the progress of the injury and the level of recovery compared to patients’ own ratings. Surgeons’ ratings are influenced by objective, treatment-related factors, whereas patients’ ratings were not. Measures of outcome commonly used b y orthopaedic surgeons, such as fracture union, do not predict patient satisfaction.
Quality outcomes from medical intervention are assumed by patients & the community. However such quality cannot be assured in every case. There are systems which can be developed which will make the safety of patients more assured. In any system of medical care, it is presumed that the practitioners who are taking care of the patient are qualified both in their basic qualification & also in their higher qualification. As well it is now accepted that appropriate credentialling occurs & that this is the purview of the hospital which will check the qualifications & currency of practice with the medical board & the higher degree & currency (participation in CPD) with the College concerned. They should also review the privileges which define the scope of practice.
In orthopaedic oncology it is now essential that a practitioner has completed a higher form of training such as a Fellowship. At the current time in this country there is no process of assurance of the quality of the education program but there is continuing development in this area. Peer review & audit remains problematic. The RACS demands that surgeons participate in an appropriate audit process yearly & that this reviews outcomes rather than just complications. The participation is however voluntary. Despite this, the participation rate is greater than 94% of all surgeons. Medical boards have been requested to make participation in a quality CPD program compulsory, but have not done so, & there are no sanctions for non participation – yet.
Most surgeons participate in regular morbidity & mortality meetings, but these are not truly audits of outcome. It would be wise for the Australian Sarcoma Group to develop outcome measures which could easily be collected. The desire to perform research should not be confused with audit which simply addresses quality at an appropriate expert level and which the community expects. Prospective collection & review of outcome measures will mean that trends in performance will be noted earlier. This is particularly important in adverse events.
These processes have been embraced by some branches of surgery more than others. Medical outcome reviews of performance have not been developed to such an extent in most disciplines for a variety of reasons, including the fact that surgical endpoints can be more easily identified. The same principles apply, however. It is important for the profession to participate in self audit or third parties will demand it, not necessarily in a way which we might prefer.
The Less Invasive Stabilisation System (LISS) was introduced with the aim to decrease the incidence of fracture nonunion and the need for primary bone grafting. We aim to describe the cases of nonunion of osteoporotic distal femoral fractures treated with the LISS at our institution and to review the cases of nonunion published in the literature.
Three cases of nonunion of osteoporotic distal femoral fractures treated with the LISS at our institution were identified. A thorough retrospective analysis of the available clinical information was performed. To identify all published papers on LISS, an exhaustive literature search was performed. The Medline and PubMed databases were searched for the following keywords: femoral fractures, distal femoral fractures, supracondylar, LISS, less invasive stabilization system and femoral no nunions. The search period was 1996 to 2008. All relevant studies were analysed.
Low energy trauma was responsible for the closed fractures encountered in our patients. Two patients sustained fractures around a joint arthroplasty: one fracture above a total knee arthroplasty and one fracture below a total hip arthroplasty. The operative technique consisted of indirect reduction on the traction table and minimally invasive percutaneous osteosynthesis. The postoperative radiographic alignment was satisfactory for all fractures. Aseptic nonunion was diagnosed in all patients. Implant failure occurred in two patients with fracture of the proximal screws in one case and fracture of the distal screws in the second case. No case s of failure of distal locking screws have previously been described in the literature. No other complications were identified. The literature search identified 21 cases of fracture nonunion. Six of these fractures occurred in osteoporotic bones as a result of low energy trauma. All 6 fractures were above a total knee arthroplasty.
The LISS is a new implant who has shown good results in the management of difficult distal femoral fractures. Its use is however not without problems: concerns with regards to inadequate or excessive rigidity and a demanding surgical technique are just some of the issues.
The c-jun oncogene is upregulated in a variety of cancers. c-jun has also been implicated in liposar-coma (LS) progression. A DNAzyme degrading c-jun mRNA was tested for effects on LS progression in vitro. A novel orthotopic model for LS was established in mice enabling in vivo evaluation of c-jun downregulation.
The human LS cell line (SW872) was transfected with Dz13, (DNAzyme degrading c-jun mRNA). A scrambled DNAzyme group and a non-transfected group were used as controls. Apoptosis of SW872 was evaluated with TUNEL, caspase inhibitor and Fas/FasL assays. The orthotopic mouse model involved injecting the SW872 cell line intramuscularly within the hind limb of nude mice, and calculating tumour volume on a weekly basis for 13 weeks. The effects of Dz13 transfection were then tested in this clinically relevant model.
In LS cells, caspase-10, but not Fas/FasL, was found to be responsible for apoptosis in Dz13-mediated c-jun knockdown. In the mouse model, tumour take in vivo was 100%, with growths resembling high grade aggressive LS, palpable at 8 weeks. SW872 cells grew within the muscle resembling the undifferentiated high grade malignant component of LS growth. The c-jun DNA-zyme inhibited the growth of LS in this model with at least 60% reduction of tumour weight or 70% reduction of tumour volume in the Dz13 cohort of animals at the end of the experiment. Tumour volumes were different between Dz13 and the control groups of animals by eleven days following injection (P< 0.05).
DNAzyme-mediated c-jun knockdown induces apoptosis in LS cells via caspase-10. This corresponds with reduced tumour growth in vivo. Clinically, downregulation of c-jun may proffer an improved treatment outcome for LS. The new model for LS described here will enable better testing of agents with therapeutic potential against LS.
To develop a novel modification of an existing technique
Using trigonometry a procedure for accurately measuring the rotational alignment of the proximal femur was devised. This technique was performed on the fracture table with standard image intensification views and required a series of simple calculations. With the knowledge of the proximal rotational geometry of the femur the fractures were fixed according to normative data of femoral neck anteversion.
The clinical correlation was then assessed.
The development of the technique was successful. It was clinically practical and was associated with accurate rotational alignment in patients after intramedullary nailing of femoral fractures. This method was seen to be a useful adjunct to current nailing techniques with both educational and clinical benefits.
The described technique has clinical application and may help surgeons avoid rotation al malalignment when undertaking intramedullary nailing of fractures of the femur.
The human RECK protein is often downregulated in cancer, which is thought to contribute to tumour progression. The role of RECK is not yet characterised in bone sarcomas. This study aims to determine the effects of increased human RECK protein expression in osteo-sarcoma and chondrosarcoma using cell invasion assays and tumour size on MRI.
The human osteosarcoma and chondrosarcoma cell lines (SaOS-2 and OUMS27 respectively) were cultured then transfected with either a plasmid containing the RECK gene, an empty vector, or not at all (control). Cells were incubated at 37 degrees within invasion chambers containing 75% matrigel. Cells invading the matrigel were counted after 3 days. Fifteen chondrosar-coma samples were stained using immunohistochemistry for the human RECK protein. RECK expression was determined to be positive or negative. MRI scans corresponding to tumour samples were viewed and the maximal tumour diameter out of all planes was manually determined with computer imaging software.
The SaOS-2 invasion assay demonstrated increased cell invasion in the RECK transfected group with an average of 502.3 invading cells, compared with 129.0 for the empty vector group (p=0.004) and 100.6 for the control group (p=0.001).
The OUMS-27 invasion assay also demonstrated increased cell invasion in RECK transfected cells with an average of 86.3 invading cells compared with 22.8 in the empty vector group (p=0.067) and 67.8 in the control group (p=0.17).
For MRI data, there were two distinct groups with roughly equal distributions of tumour grades. Group 1 had maximal tumour diameters of less than 70 mm, compared to group 2, being greater than 70mm (p=0.0006). In group 1 only 1/8 demonstrated RECK expression, while in group 2, 5/7 were RECK positive (p=0.041 Fisher exact test).
RECK overexpression in osteosarcoma and chondro-sarcoma cell lines appears to increase invasive capacity, and stands in contrast to RECK data in carcinomas. Furthermore, RECK expression in patient chondrosar-coma samples is associated with larger tumours. RECK may therefore function differently in sarcoma.
The average number of tube formations in the RECK transfected HMEC-1 cells was 67.8, compared with 42 in the empty vector group (p=0.03) and 54.1 in the control group (p=0.03). The average maximal wall thickness of tube formations was 100.7um versus 77.4um in the empty vector group (p=0.04) and 83.0um in the control group (p=0.09).
The volume of spinal procedures have increased over the last two decades (220% in lumbar region). A simultaneous increase in re-operation rates (up to 20%) has been reported. Our aim was to compare with literature the reoperation rates and complications for various spinal procedures from a peripheral unit and to provide this information to the patients
This was a retrospective study of all patients who underwent spinal surgery during the period 1995 to 2005 by one surgeon. Using ICDM-9 codes and private notes patients were identified and medical records were used to gather relevant data. The following information was extracted-demographics, diagnosis, ASA criteria, primary procedure, any complication/s, secondary procedures, duration of follow up and to secondary procedure. The index procedures were grouped into regional and according to indication. Both complications and reoperations were grouped into early (within three months) or delayed (after three months) from the index operation. Reoperation rates and complications were calculated and compared with literature.
Four hundred and thirty-nine patients formed the study population. Five patients had inadequate data and were excluded. 23 patients have since died. Demographics showed 22% were smokers and 9% were either unemployed or sickness beneficiary. The commonest diagnosis in the lumbar spine was disc herniation (194). Stenosis and disc degeneration were the next most common surgical indications. In the cervical spine 27 patients had disc herniation and 15 patients were operated for trauma. Lumbar discectomy was the commonest procedure-191 patients with one third having microdiscectomy. Instrumented fusion was performed in 97 while 37 patients underwent decompression only. The majority of cervical spine patients (46) had discectomy and fusion.
Stabilisation for trauma formed a reasonable workload in both cervical and lumbar regions. Early complications included dural tears (seven), neurological symptoms (eight), wound infections (12) and pulmonary embolism (one) and repeat disc herniation. Delayed problems included repeat disc herniation, pseudoarthrosis and implant related symptoms. Overall re-operation rate was 14.52% with 5.02% early and 9.4%delayed repeat surgery. Repeat discectomy (eight) and decompression and exploration (seven) were the common early reoperation whereas fusion post discectomy (19) and recurrent disc herniation (12) were indications for delayed intervention. Removal of metalware (8) was another large late re-operation group.
Our re-operation rates fall within the quoted figures in literature. However our early re-operation rates are somewhat higher. These figures help us to inform patients better at the time of consent for the primary procedure especially lumbar disc surgery as most of the re-operation were required after discectomy.
Posterior lumbar fusion is one of the most frequent procedures in spinal surgery. This study examined which factors predict physician-based outcomes in posterior lumbar fusion within the international spine registry Spine Tango.
This study used prospective consecutive hospital based documentation. Between May 2005 and October 2007 720 patients had been treated with posterior lumbar fusion for degenerative disease or spondylolisthesis. McNab criteria as commonly used physician-based outcomes were chosen as dependent outcome variable. We dichotomised the original McNab criteria combining “excellent” with “good” to “good”, and “fair” with “poor” to “poor”. Multivariate logistic regression was performed on following potential predictor-variables: age, gender, main pathology, number of previous spinal surgeries, number of spinal segments of posterior fusion, operation time, surgeon credentials, follow-up interval.
Median age was 63 years (range 13–90 yrs) with a female to male ratio of 6.3:3.7. Number of previous spinal surgeries (p< 0.001) and follow-up interval (p< 0.001) were found to be predictors of the dichotomised McNab criteria. Patients without previous spinal surgery showed the highest ratio of “good” to “poor” outcome (80.5%:19.5%). This ratio was almost consistently decreasing with the number of previous spinal surgeries to 40%:60% in patients with more than five previous surgeries. At six and twelve-weeks follow-up outcomes were significantly better than after one year, without significant differences between other follow-up intervals. Other examined co-variables showed no influence on the outcomes.
Predictors of physician-based outcomes in posterior lumbar fusion are “number of previous spinal surgeries” and “follow-up interval”. In patients with more than five previous spinal surgeries a higher likelihood of “poor” outcomes should be taken into consideration. A too positive outcome may occur at six or twelve-week’s follow-up.
A lumbar laminectomy is a commonly performed surgical procedure for the decompression of neural structures. The aim of this human cadaveric study is to establish the extent of pars interarticularis remaining at each lumbar level when a laminectomy is performed to the medial edge of the pedicle.
Seven human cadavers with intact lumbar spines were obtained for this study. The lumbar spine was dissected from the body and segmental disarticulation of each level was performed. The isolated lumbar levels had laminectomies performed exposing the neural canal. The vertical alignment of the laminectomy was orientated in line with the medial aspect of the ipsilateral pedicle. The remaining lateral pars interarticularis was measured with a calliper. The procedure was performed bilaterally at each isolated lumbar segment.
Five males and two female cadavers with an age range of sixty-eight years to ninety-five years at the time of death. Fourteen lumbar segments of each respective level were available for study except at L5, where only twelve was possible due the presence of a transitional vertebra in one of the specimens. Taken to the nearest mms, the average width of the remnant pars interarticularis at the L1 level was 4 mm, range 3–6 mm (SD 0.95); L2 6 mm, range 5–7 mm (SD 0.77); L3 8mm, range 4–9mm (SD 1.34); L4 11mm, range 9–14 mm (SD 1.31) and L5 16mm, range 13–17 mm (SD 1.15). One way analysis of variance for each of the groups were performed to establish that the difference recorded was greater than that expected by chance (p< 0.05). The results predictably established the gradual narrowing of the pars interarticularis as the levels ascend cranially from L5.
The medial wall of the pedicle could be used as an indirect means to establish a satisfactory remnant of the pars interarticularis following a laminectomy in the lower lumbar spine, at the levels of L3 to L5. However in the upper two levels direct visualisation of the pars is recommended.
The detailed anatomy of interconnectivity of intervertebral disc annular fibre layers remains unclear and a structural survey of interlammellar connectivity is required to understand this anatomy and mechanical behavior. The subsequent failure modes of the annulus under hydrostatic loading require definition to understand genesis of annular tears and disc herniation.
Interlamellar Connectivity. We imaged anterior annular sections from ovine lumbar discs. Using differential interference contrast microscopy we were able to reconstruct a three-dimensional image of the interconnecting bridging network between layers. Annular Disruption. The nuclei of ovine lumbar discs were gradually pressurised to failure by injecting a viscous radio-opaque gel via their inferior vertebrae. Investigation of the resulting annular disruption was carried out using micro-computed tomography and DIC microscopy. This allowed analysis of annular failure patterns and herniation, with analysis of the pathway of nuclear movement during prolapse in relation to annular fibre separation within and between fibre layers.
Interlamellar Connectivity. A high level of connectivity between apparently disparate bridging elements was revealed. The extended form of the bridging network is that of occasional substantial radial connections spanning many lamellae with a subsidiary fine branching network. The fibrous bridging network is highly integrated with the lamellar architecture via a collagen-based system of interconnectivity. In particular this bridging network appears to have a major role in anchoring leading edges of incomplete annular lamellae. Annular Disruption and Disc Herniation. Gel extrusion from the posterior annulus was the most common mode of disc failure. Unlike other regions of the annular wall, the posterior region was unable to distribute hydrostatic pressures circumferentially. In each extrusion case, severe disruption to the posterior annulus was observed. While intralamellar disruption occurred in the mid annulus, interlamellar disrupt ion occurred in the outer posterior annulus. Radial ruptures between lamellae always propagated in the mid-axial plane.
The interlamellar architecture of the annulus is far more complex than has previously been recognised and this paper further defines the microanatomy of the disc wall. The hydrostatic pressure failure mode of the posterior annulus mirrors clinic al sites of annular tear and disc prolapsed in the neutral loading position.
Anterior lumbar interbody fusion (ALIF) is an accepted surgical treatment for disabling discogenic pain. Additional posterior fixation has been advocated. This is a prospective clinic al study evaluating a stand-alone anterior fusion cage with an integrated titanium plate and four divergent locking screws.
Patients who had failed conservative management for lumbar discogenic pain were recruited into the study. All underwent diagnostic discography. Surgery was performed through an anterior retro-peritoneal approach. The fusion cage was packed with autogenous bone graft. Outcome measures included: Visual Analogue Scores (VAS), Oswestry Disability Index (ODI) and SF-36 data. Fine-cut CT was performed at one and two years post-operatively. Fusion was defined as continuous bony trabeculae joining the vertebral bodies.
Fifty levels were operated on in 39 patients with a mean age of 40.8 years (22–55). The mean operative time was less than 120 minutes, and mean blood loss less than 100 mls. Radiographic fusion at one year was 78% and 100% at two years. Two year mean VAS sc ores for back pain improved from 7.0 to 3.7 (p< 0.01) and for leg pain from 6.1 to 3.1 (p< 0.01). The mean ODI scores decreased from 50.7 to 31.7 (p< 0.01), and SF-36 (PCS) scores increased from 28.4 to 37.5 (p< 0.01). There were no major complications and no patients have required supplementary posterior fixation.
This technique is safe and is as effective as 360° fusion in achieving fusion in the management of discogenic back pain over one and two levels. This technique has the advantage of avoiding the morbidity associated with additional posterior fixation.
Post Traumatic Fixed Thoraco-Lumbar Spinal Deformity may result in pain, regional and or global spinal deformity and neural compromise. Treatment is demanding as osteotomy is required in either anterior alone or both anterior and posterior spinal columns with concomitant reconstruction. This paper reviews 15 years experience with these cases.
A retrospective review of 21 patients operated on over 15 years was conducted. Patients were grouped based on original thoraco-lumbar injury pattern – Type A, B and C. Osteotomies and reconstruction were performed from both anterior and posterior approaches dependent upon the pathology. Clinical and radiological follow up for all patients was a minimum of one year. Analysis of outcomes was performed in relation to the clinical and radiological success. Complications were recorded.
Sixteen patients had two-column involvement and five had only the anterior column affected. Initial injury patterns were – Type A–9, Type B–4, and Type C–8. Approaches were anterior in six (five in Type A injuries), posterior and anterior in 11 (five two-stage and six three-stage operations), and posterior only in four (one pedicle subtraction osteotomy, one vertebral column resection, one posterior reduction of a dislocation, and one case abandoned after the posterior procedure). Anterior reconstruction was performed with structural iliac crest (two), titanium mesh cages (14) and expanding corpectomy cages (three). All 14 cases requiring posterior stabilisation were treated with pedicle screw based systems. The global assessment of outcome was individualised to the original indication – mechanical pain, deformity, and or symptomatic spinal stenosis. Success (good or excellent outcome) was achieved in 16 cases. Failure (fair or poor outcome) occur red in three completed cases. These three cases had chronic pain (two major, one minor). Two patients had incomplete assessment – one dying of MI in recovery after a technically successful procedure – and one developing deep infection with abandonment of the later stages (see above). There was one non-union. There were no neurological complications.
Delayed treatment of late posttraumatic deformity is challenging however good results are achievable with attention to the specific clinical and biomechanical requirements of each case. Technical failure occurred with inadequately radical intervention on one occasion. Major chronic thoracotomy pain occurred in one otherwise technically successful reconstruction.
We retrospectively reviewed the results of patients having undergone single or two level Anterior Cervical Discectomy and Fusion with the use of the Cervios Cage (SYNTHES).
Participants were sent a questionnaire which included generic questions relating to ACDF such as dysphagia, hoarseness of voice and resolution of arm pain in addition to Oswestry Disability scores. Most patients underwent AP/Lateral and flexion/extension radiographs.
Lumbar Total Disc Replacement (LTDR) is an alternative to fusion for the surgical management of discogenic back pain not responding to conservative therapy. Theoretical advantages include preservation of motion and possible reduction in adjacent segment degeneration. The aim is to review the early results of LTDR in an Auckland private practice.
A prospective study was carried out on 32 consecutive patients treated with LTDR. Discogenic back pain was confirmed with plain radiographs, MRI and CT lumbar discogram. The Charité TDR was used in 19 patients and A-MAV in 13. Follow-up was to a minimum of two years. Patients completed Modified Roland Questionnaires (MRQ), Visual Analogue Pain Scores (VAPS) and Lower Back Outcome Scores (LBOS) pre and post-operatively. Patients’ notes and radiographs were reviewed.
All outcomes measures improved significantly. Mean MRQ scores improved from 14.2 to 6.4 and 4.8 (at one and two years respectively). Mean VAPS improved from 5.3 to 2.5 and 1.7. Mean LBOS improved from 33 to 52 and 57. 84% had radiographic evidence of motion at the level of the prosthesis. There were four major complications. A retroperitoneal haematoma, an incisional hernia, a ureteric stenosis and subsidence of the prosthesis each occurred in separate patients. These all occurred in the first ten patients of the study and were related to the approach. There were no major thrombo-embolic or infective complications and no revision surgery was required.
LTDR is a safe and effective surgical treatment of discogenic back pain. There is however, a steep learning curve with regard to the approach and a higher risk of complications during this time. Initial results are encouraging, but longer term follow-up needs to be performed.
As an example of benchmarking in spinal surgery using Spine Tango, we extracted data on dural tears, one of the most frequent types of complications in posterior spinal fusion. Little is known about their predictors. This study examined which factors predict the occurrence of dural tears in posterior spinal fusion.
Prospective consecutive documentation of hospital based interventions with an evidence level 2++. Between May 2005 and November 2006 data of 3437 patients were documented in the registry. Nine hundred and twenty nine patients, who had been treated with posterior spinal fusion after opening of the spinal canal, were included in this study. Dural tears being the most frequent type of complications in the registry were chosen as dependent outcome variable. Multiple linear regression with stepwise elimination was performed on potential predictor-variables of the occurrence of dural tears. Benchmarking compared the performance of single hospitals with international peers. Median age was 62.7 years (min 12.5, max 90.5 yrs) with a female to male ratio of 2:1. In 18 of 929 cases a dural tear occurred. Hospital (p=0.02) and number of segments of fusion (p=0.018) were found to be predictors of the occurrence of dural tears in posterior spinal fusion. Number of fusions per hospital (min 25, max 526) and academic status of hospital had no influence on the rate of dural tears. Fusions of four and more segments showed an increase of the rate of dural tears by a factor of three compared to fusions of less than four segments. There was no significant difference between fusions of one segment and fusions of two or three segments (1.3 vs. 1.9%) as well as between fusions of four or five segments and fusions of more than five segments (4.6 vs. 4.2%). Differences between hospitals remained when benchmarking dural tears with case mix.
Predictors of dural tears in posterior spinal fusion are
hospital and number of segments of fusion.
In fusions of four and more segments a threefold higher risk of dural tears in comparison to fusions of less than four segments should be taken into consideration.
Revision of a failed femoral component in the face of extensive bone loss is a major challenge. When the bone loss extends down below the isthmus it may be difficult to obtain longitudinal stability with a tapered or fully porous coated prosthesis. If subsidence occurs then recurrent dislocation can be an insoluble problem. This study reviews the use of a distally interlocked femoral component designed to address this challenging situation.
We have reviewed 21 cases in which extensive bone loss made the use of an interlocking prosthesis desirable. The average time from surgery was over four years. All patients completed an Oxford hip score and an EO-50. All radiographs were reviewed.
There were 14 males and seven females with an overall average age of 74 years at the time of surgery. Patients had had an average of two previous THR’s, and up to nine previous hip operations. One patient underwent re-revision because of subsidence related to screw cut out. There was one dislocation. Patient satisfaction was high with low Oxford hip scores compared with other revision prostheses, and good EO – 50 ratings.
This type of prosthesis offers a very satisfactory solution to difficult revision situations when bone loss makes the use of regular prostheses difficult. The prosthesis used in this study has a low offset and thus dislocation precautions should be emphasised.
Carpal tunnel syndrome requiring decompression is common at the world’s largest lamb processing plant. However there is little to guide us in advising patients on return to heavy manual work postoperatively. The purpose of this study was to establish current New Zealand practice and whether expeditious return to work was possible.
Following informed consent a retrospective review of those with neurophysiologically-confirmed carpal tunnel syndrome requiring decompression over four seasons was performed. Open, day-case surgery was performed in all cases by the senior author. Patient demographics, time to return to work, further absenteeism, pain-free interval and complications were examined. A prospective study in the subsequent season was then performed. Additional information gathered for previous seasons pre and 6 week postoperatively included QuickDASH, SF36, grip-strength visual analogue pain, paraesthesiae and numbness scores. Student’s t-test was used for statistical analysis. An email survey of the NZOA was also performed.
One hundred percent follow-up was achieved. In the retrospective group 281 in 187 patients were performed. The average time to return to light duties/rehabilitation was 11 (9 – 42) days. The mean pain free interval was 24 (10 – 63) days. Return to full-duties was on average 28 (10 – 70) dayswith three patients (1% of the total cohort) requiring further time off. Ninety-nine percent returned to their previous role. There were two infections. In the prospective group in this study, 26 hands underwent decompression in 13 patients. The average return to light duties/rehabilitation was 13 (10–25) days and to full duties 32 (21–56) days. Ninety-two percent returned to their previous role and there was one superficial infect ion. The improvement in mean total QuickDASH scores (total score possible 300) were from 140 points (standard deviation 63: 95% CI 101–178) to 68 (standard deviation 54; 95% CI 34–100) and this was statistically significant (p< 0.01). The difference in Short Form 36 scores was not statistically significant (p = 0.6). The differences in numbness, pain and paraesthesiae visual analogue scores were all statistically significant at 6 weeks after surgery (p< 0.01, p< 0.01 and p=0.01 respectively). All patients felt that the operation had been overall worthwhile and at the time of submission none had taken any further time off work. Examining lamb boners as a separate group and using Survival and Cox regression analysis the average return to full working duties for lamb boners was 29 days which is significantly different to New Zealand Orthopaedic surgical practice.
The unique population at this plant has allowed a culture to develop whereby early return to light duties after removal of sutures is expected. This culture, good patient education, and coordinated efforts at all levels of the care pathway are undoubtedly necessary for this level of achievement.
Limited wrist arthrodesis has been shown to be an effective treatment for the degenerative and unstable wrist, abolishing pain but limiting motion. The aim of the study was to assess the effect of excision of the scaphoid and triquetrum on wrist joint range of motion, in the setting of a limited midcarpal arthrodesis. Twelve cadaveric wrists had the range of motion measured, before and after, ulnar four-corner fusion (lunate, capitate, triquetrum and hamate fusion). This was measured again following sequential scaphoid and triquetral resection.
Scaphoid excision after four-corner arthrodesis resulted in a 12 degrees increase in the radio-ulnar (R-U) arc and 10 degrees increase in the flexion-extension (F-E) arc range of motion. Subsequent excision of the triquetrum, to produce a three-corner fusion, further increased R-U arc by seven degrees and F-E arc by six degrees.
These results demonstrate that three-corner fusion with excision of scaphoid and triquetrum results in improvement in wrist motion when compared to four-corner fusion with scaphoid excision alone. From this we conclude that triquetrum excision should be considered in Scapholunate advanced collapse (SLAC) wrist reconstruction to improve residual wrist range of motion.
Fractures of the proximal humerus can offer a difficult surgical challenge particularly if they occur in elderly patients and/or are a complex fracture configuration. Much of the morbidity of the surgery relates to the extensile delto-pectoral approach traditionally used for operative treatment of these fractures.
A minimally invasive technique for approaching these fractures has was developed using a proximal deltoid split approach at the anterior edge of the deltoid and sliding a precontoured proximal humeral locking plate submuscularly after provisional fracture reduction. This technique was tested in a cadaver model to identify “safe” and “at risk” holes in the plate for percutaneous fixation in relation to the axillary nerve.
A case series of eighteen patients who had surgery using this technique were reviewed. All patients achieved acceptable reductions and went on to unite without any signs of AVN or implant failure. One patient had a transient sensory disturbance in an axillary nerve distribution post op. One patient has asymptomatic fibrous union of the greater tuberosity.
Minimally invasive plate fixation using a lateral deltoid split approach is technically possible with excellent results. The danger zone around the axillary nerve has been identified and should be avoided with percutaneous fixation utilising this procedure. A jig to allow accurate MIPO fixation has been developed.
Treatment of complex proximal humeral fractures remains controversial. In situations where accurate fracture reduction and fixation cannot be obtained, arthroplasty may be the preferred surgical option. The traditional operation of hemiarthroplasty in these situations is technically challenging, and a good functional outcome is dependent on reduction and healing of the tuberosities. Reverse Shoulder Arthroplasty (RSA) has been suggested as an alternative, and we sought to analyse and compare functional outcomes following the two procedures.
Ten patients who underwent hemiarthroplasty for acute fracture of the proximal humerus between 1999 and 2003 were reviewed. All fractures were assessed intraoperatively for open reduction and internal fixation of the fracture, but deemed to be unsuitable for fixation. From 2003 our management in this clinical situation changed, and ten subsequent patients underwent reverse shoulder arthroplasty using the S.M.R. reverse shoulder prosthesis (Systema Multiplana Randell, Lima, Italy). Clinical and radiological follow up was carried out at a mean of 31 months (hemiarthroplasty patients) and 15 months (RSA patients) post operatively.
Subjectively seven of 10 patients in the reverse group and seven of 10 patients in the hemiarthroplasty group rated their outcome as ‘very good’ or ‘excellent’. The mean ASES scores were 65 (range 40–88) in the reverse group and 67 (26–100) in the hemiarthroplasty group. The mean Oxford shoulder score was 29 (15–56) in the reverse group and 22 (12–34) in the hemiarthroplasty group. The mean active forward elevation in the hemiarthroplasty group was 108° (range 50–180) and in the reverse group 115° (45–40), and active external rotation 49° (5–105) and 48° (10–90) respectively. Differences in outcome scores between the two groups were not statistic ally significant (p value> 0.05).
This study provides the first direct comparison between RSA and hemiarthroplasty for complex proximal humeral fractures. The expected functional gains with Reverse shoulder arthroplasty were not seen, suggesting its use as the primary treatment for acute fracture should remain guarded.
This case series aim to report our experience with the use of fragment specific fixation plating system and cancellous bone autograft in the elective treatment of distal radius malunions.
Fourteen patients who underwent distal radial corrective osteotomy by one surgeon were followed up retrospectively. All patients had elected for this procedure for the treatment of malunions of previous distal radial fracture. The follow up assessments include each patient’s subjective functional outcomes, the objective strength and range of motion testing, and the radiographic parameters. These subjective functional outcome data collected as measured by the Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand questionnaire (DASH) were compared with each patient’s pre-operative status. The motion, strength and radiographic appearances were assessed in relevance to the contralateral arm.
Dislocation of the elbow with associated fractures of the radial head and the coronoid process of the ulna have been referred to as the “terrible triad of the elbow” because of the difficulties in treating this injury and the poor outcomes.
The orthopaedic database, Orthoscope, was used to identify all patients with dislocation of the ulnohumeral joint and fracture of both the head of the radius and the coronoid process of the ulna, seen and treated at Auckland City Hospital since 1998.
All patients were invited to follow up appointments to evaluate the outcomes achieved. The research protocol was approved by the local research committee. Follow up appointments consisted of clinic al examination, assessing the range of elbow motion, an elbow radiograph and a functional assessment, using the DASH score and the American Shoulder and Elbow Society scoring systems.
There were 32 patients identified, from Orthoscope, and invited for follow up. Six patients, who had moved overseas, were lost to follow up and two others declined follow up. 23 patients (24 elbows) remained for evaluation. All patients returned for the described assessment protocol. There were 10 male patients and 13 female patients, with a mean age of 46.9 (range, 29 to 67 years). The average arc of ulnohumeral motion was 122 degrees (range; 110 degrees to 140 degrees) and that of forearm rotation was 138 degrees (range, 35 degrees to 170 degrees).
The radial head component was fixed in a standard fashion with repair, or replacement, and no radial head excisions were undertaken. Coronoid fractures were treated with screw fixation or suturing, with drill holes or anchors. To augment stability, a lateral ligament repair was undertaken in most patients. All patients, except one, would undergo the procedure again if needed.
Elbow fracture-dislocations are historically very unstable and are prone to numerous complications. With operative treatment of the radial head, with repair or replacement, to restore stability through radiocapitellar contact, coronoid and lateral ligament repair, good range of movement and stability can be achieved.
The authors are not aware of any research comparing computed tomography (CT) and avascular necrosis (AVN) of the scaphoid bone. The primary aim of our study was to investigate the use of longitudinal CT in predicting AVN of the proximal pole of the scaphoid, and subsequent fracture nonunion following internal fixation.
Thirty-two patients operated on by the senior author for scaphoid fracture were included. Preoperative CT scans were independently assessed for deformity, comminution, fracture position, proximal pole sclerosis, and bridging trabeculae. Intra-operative biopsy of the proximal pole was assessed independently by a blinded musculoskeletal histologist. AVN was determined by histology of a proximal pole biopsy, using the criteria described by Ficat. Post-operative CT scan was utilised to determine fracture union.
Preoperative CT features which significantly correlated with AVN were, increased radiodensity of the proximal pole, the absence of any bridging trabeculae comminution, dorsal cortical angle, proximal fracture and age less than 20. Features predictive of subsequent nonunion were fractures of the proximal, increased radiodensity of the proximal pole, and AVN.
Preoperative CT scan findings are significantly correlated with histologically confirmed AVN and fracture union. Preoperative longitudinal CT scan is of significant prognostic value and should be considered to assist in predicting outcome and assessing treatment options.
We determined the survival of primary total hip and knee replacements and patients who had undergone surgery between 1989 and 2007 in Dunedin with the aim to using these figures to provide information on
whether our arthroplasty population is changing, what the likely future demands are on follow-up services, whether we can predict which patients will require follow-up.
The initial search using records held by the audit department at Dunedin Hospital returned 6,328 patient records with total hip and knee arthroplasty between 1988 and 2007. These reports however, included many procedures which were neither hip/knee nor primary/revision total joint arthroplasty. The data was filtered, resulting in 4,773 hip and knee arthroplasties. The final data included 3194 primary total hip replacements and 1579 primary total knee replacements. Comorbidity scoring of these patients was also undertaken.
The mean age of patients who underwent primary hip replacement was 67.6 yrs (SD 12.4) and the mean age of patients who underwent a primary knee replacement was 70.8 yrs (SD 9.8). Around 25% of patients who have had a primary joint replacement died after a mean of 10 yrs after the operation. In the group of patients who died after 10 years, the mean age at surgery was around 74 years. The mean age at the time of death was around 80 years. No difference was found in the death rate, revision rate, and the combined outcomes with death or revision as the end point with respect to the following-THRs. TKR, the grade of the surgeon, the comorbidity score or in men vs. women as compared to the general population.
Patients over 59 years of age at time of primary arthroplasty have a > 90% chance of dying before the need for revision surgery. Patients of less than 51 years of age have a > 90% chance of requiring revision surgery. Patients of 55 years of age have a 50% chance of requiring revision surgery. In a setting of ongoing scarce resources symptomatic/questionnaire targeted follow-up with radiology may be the only long term viable solution.
Compared with general anaesthesia, brachial plexus (BP) anaesthesia improves patient satisfaction and accelerates hospital discharge after ambulatory hand surgery; however, variable success rates and typical onset times up to 30 minutes have limited its widespread use. Increasing availability of high-resolution portable ultrasound has renewed interest in more proximal approaches to the BP, previously thought to carry unacceptable risk. The aim of this study was to compare the onset times of ultrasound guided supraclavicular and infraclavicular BP block in patients undergoing ambulatory hand surgery.
With ethics committee approval, patients presenting for hand surgery were prospectively randomised to either supraclavicular (trunks/divisions) or infraclavicular (cords) BP block. A single experienced operator (MF) placed all blocks using ultrasound only guidance. A blinded observer (AP, SY) assessed pinprick sensory and motor block on 3-point scale (normal=2, reduced=1, absent=0) in the median, ulnar, radial and musculocutaneous nerve territories every five minutes, or until blocks were complete. A single general anaesthesia without influence from the unblended anaesthetist.
Of the first 27 patients recruited, block placement details and Intraoperative data are presented in There was a trend to faster onset times and higher success in group infraclavicular, however, this did not reach statistical significance.
Interim results are so far inconclusive for the superiority of one approach. Both techniques were well tolerated and had a high success rate for surgical anaesthesia.
Thromboembolic complications following lower limb arthroplasty are reported to be high. The aim of this of this study is to ascertain the incidence of symptomatic venous thromboembolic disease following lower limb arthroplasty without Pharmacological thrombo prophylaxis.
Retrospective review was undertaken of 752 patients following total hip or total knee replacement between January 1st 2002 and June 30th 2005.
Fifty one patients were considered high risk and received thrombopharmacologal prophylaxis with Clexane and Warfarin. Information on all patients was obtained from medical records, computerised information system, general practitioners and patients themselves to produce a complete picture of the three months immediately following the index arthroplasty. All patients who presented with calf symptoms suggestive of venous thrombosis, respiratory distress or died in that three months were investigated.
Two patients were lost to follow up. All others had full documentation. Twenty-nine patients presented with calf related symptoms and after ultrasound investigation nine (five THR, four TKR) were confirmed to have venous thrombosis and were treated. One of these patients developed tense haemarthrosis while on treatment. Twelve other patients presented with respiratory symptoms. Eight (six THR two TKR) were confirmed to have pulmonary embolism on either VQ scan or spiral CT. Four of these on VQ scan were low probability. All patients were treated for thromboembolic disease and while on treatment one patient developed persistent wound discharge and infection. Of the 51 patients treated with pharmacological prophylaxis one developed a DVT and five developed wound problems, one of which was major. Two patients died during the three month period, but neither was related to thromboembolic disease.
From the 699 patients the symptomatic DVT rate was 1.1%. Symptomatic pulmonary embolism rate was 1.5% including the low probability of VQ scans. There was no mortality from thromboembolism in this study. These results compare favourably with the recent literature. Our department has a policy to select patients for thromboembolic prophylaxis based on high risk factors. All other patients are fully informed of this risk and are treated with elevation, avoidance of swelling, early supervised and regular mobilisation. Our result from this study substantiate our policy for selection of patients for thromboembolic prophylaxis.
The aim of this study is to prepare for the introduction of the world’s first nationwide registry of all rotator cuff tears proceeding to operative management.
Patient’s are scored pre-operatively and again at six and 12 months post-op using the Flex SF functional scale, pain scales and work and activity levels. A questionnaire is filled out by the operating surgeon on the day of surgery detailing pathology and the operative methods used.
This study is a New Zealand Shoulder and Elbow Society initiative begun in 2007. New Zealand is ideally suited with a small, cohesive group of orthopaedic surgeons. Rotator cuff surgery is advancing rapidly with changes in surgical approach from open to arthroscopic, and repair methods from bone tunnels to various choices of anchors. A wide range of surgical methods are used within New Zealand, presenting an opportunity to use the large numbers generated by a registry to give valuable information guiding future treatment.
The operation day questionnaire includes information on tear size, surgical approach, repair methods, biceps and AC joint pathology and rehabilitation.
More than 100 patients have already been registered in the pilot study and a number have completed the six month questionnaire. These early results will be presented, along with important information for the large number of surgeons who will become involved when the nationwide registry commences.
Polyethylene wear and osteolysis continue to be associated with failure of total hip arthroplasty. The advent of highly cross linked polyethylene may potentially reduce such wear.
The aim of this study was to compare the rate of wear of acetabular polyethylene using conventional cross linked versus highly cross linked polyethylene.
From June 2001 to September 2003, 119 patients were followed prospectively for up to five years on an annual basis in a double blinded, randomised trial. The mean age of patients was 59 years (range 48 to 75 yrs). The radiographs have been analyzed using previously validated measurement software to assess linear, three dimensional and volumetric wear.
The five year results show significantly reduced wear rates for highly cross linked polyethylene compared to conventional polyethylene. There was no statistically significant difference between groups with respect to age, sex, operative side, surgeon, cup abduction angle, cup anteversion or size of cup.
The reduction in wear shown after five years with the highly cross linked polyethylene is highly encouraging and is consistent with in vitro wear simulator testing. This may reduce failure of total hip arthroplasties due to wear and osteolysis over the medium to long term.
We describe the clinical and radiological results of 38 total hip replacements (THR) using the JRI Furlong hydroxyapatite-ceramic (HAC) – coated femoral component in patients younger than 50 years. The mean age at the time of operation was 42 years and the mean length of follow-up was ten years. All patients receiving a Furlong HAC THR were entered into the study regardless of the primary pathology including patients who had undergone previous hip surgery.
The mean Harris hip sc ore improved from 44 before operation to 92 at the last post-operative review. After 12 years the cumulative survival for the stem was 100%. No femoral component was revised. Our results show that the Furlong HAC implant gives excellent long-term results in young patients with high demands.
Acetabular components of total hip joint replacement (THJR) in previously irradiated pelvis show high rates of failure. We present a literature review and a retrospective series evaluating the survival of acetabular cages in this difficult situation. Our hypothesis was that cage reinforcement of the acetabulum after previous pelvic irradiation would lead to early failure.
A cohort of 11 patients (12 hips) was identified, who had undergone THJR utilising an acetabular cage, after previous pelvic irradiation for malignant tumours. All operations were performed by a single surgeon in Waikato over the period of 1997–2007. Six patients (six hips) died within one year of their operation, the further five patients (six hips) were analysed for survival and radiograpical loosening of the acetabular component. Complications attributed to previous irradiation are also reported.
There is a paucity of literature of THJR survivorship after pelvic irradiation. The first series from the 1970’s showed 50% acetabular loosening at 5 years in cemented cups. Two conflicting series are published with 44% vs. 0% failure of uncemented cups. Only one previous series (22 hips) reports the use of acetabular reinforcement rings, and showed a 20% loosening and 10% deep infection rate at 4 years. In our cohort of 12 hips in 11 patients, only five patients survived greater than one year after joint replacement. The average follow up of the remaining six hips is five years (two to ten years). Two out of six of the acetabular cages have catastrophically failed. Of the remaining four cages, one is probably, and three are possibly radiologically loose. Two out of six have raised concerns in regards to deep infection that were not proven microbiologically. Overall of the patients who survived greater than one year after their THJR for pelvic irradiation, only four out of six of the acetabular cages remained insitu, and all had concerns raised in regards to radiographical loosening.
We report a high rate of clinical and radiographic failure of cage reconstruction of the acetabulum after previous pelvic irradiation. A superior method of acetabular reconstruction in this difficult situation is yet to emerge. Alternative methods of reconstruction continue to develop, with trabecular metal options a possible consideration.
Total hip replacement (THR) and total knee replacement (TKR) are the most successful operations in orthopaedics. In the US, there is a marked difference between black patients and white patients in the utilization of joint replacement therapy. An attempt has been made to study total joint replacement comparing Maoris’ and Caucasians in Gisborne.
Prospective study, 100 consecutive total joint replacements for osteoarthritis performed by a single surgeon [VSP] from Feb 2007 to July 2008 attending Gisborne Public Hospital. These cases have been studied independently by [RM, EW, VP]. T hose with arthritis other than osteoarthritis, a fracture neck of femur or secondaries or revision joint replacements or those who refused to give informed consent were excluded.
Medical notes were carefully scrutinised: surgeons pre-op notes, anaesthetic assessment, pre-operative and post operative information, early post operative complication.
Outcome assessment is obtained at 6 months in 50% of patients:
fifty-five percent were females; 40% Maori; 60% had THR and 40% TKR Patients with medical co-morbidities were stratified by anaesthetist Complications: one deep infection; one superficial infection, two stitch abscess; Hematoma two; one stiffness required manipulation. Complication did not appear to correlate with ethnic differences or ASA grading. No dislocation. No patient had or waiting for revision, No nerve damage. Womac scoring: all patients had excellent to good results [short follow up].
Because of high co morbidity, Maori were more likely than white patients to expect longer hospital course With anaesthetic stratification, complications can be minimised despite high ASA grade. There is no increase complication in Maori population
Previous studies have suggested that bone ongrowth occurs following revision hip arthroplasty to a tapered long stem distal fit modular prosthesis. This may affect outcome. We sought to quantify proximal bone ongrowth to one such prosthesis and correlate this with functional outcome.
A series of eight patients undergoing revision total hip arthroplasty with the a long taper, distal fit, grit blasted modular prosthesis (ZMR) had a CT performed within three months and then greater than one year following surgery. Changes in periprosthetic bone stock were measured. Functional scores at a minimum of five years were analysed.
Proximal bone ongrowth was generally poor and did not correlate with functional outcome score.
When more sensitive imaging is used to analyse bone ongrowth in this long stem distal fit prosthesis, proximal ongrowth is poor and not the key determinate of functional outcome.
In relation to the conduct of this study, no funding has been received from any source to support the costs of this study
To ascertain whether there is any relationship between the Oxford 12 scores gained six months post surgery and early revision for primary hip and knee arthroplasty.
The six month post surgery Oxford 12 scores were retrieved from the National Joint Registry (NJR) for the seven year period ending 31st December 2006. These were analysed in relation to revision of primary hip and knee procedures using three methods of statistical analysis; logistic regression, receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve and direct plotting of groups of scores against the proportion of hips revised for that same group.
Logistic regression: For every one unit increase in the Oxford score there was an 11% increased risk of revision (hips) and 12% (knees) within the first two years of surgery, 5 and 6% respectively between two and four years and 3 and 4% risk respectively between four and six years (p> 0.001).
The ROC Curve Analysis: demonstrated that a patient with a score greater than 20 (hips) or 28.5 (knees) or 24 (uni knees) has eight times the risk of needing a revision within two years compared to a person with a score equal or less than the above numbers. Alternatively the ROC analysis predicted 73% of the revisions within three years for all three arthroplasty groups.
Plotting Scores Against Revisions: Plotting scores in groups of five demonstrated an incremental increase in the risk during the first two years. A person with a score greater than 40 has; for hips 24 times, knees 27 times and uni knees 69 times the risk of a revision within two years compared to a person with a score between 16 and 20.
Monitoring of the six month post surgical Oxford 12 score is another tool in the surgeon’s armamentarium for deciding which patients need closer monitoring following arthroplasty surgery.
Bone tendon junction (BTJ) healing after injury is often slow, without restoration of fibrocartilage transition zone. Fibrocartilage formation has been observed near articular cartilage. It was hypothesised that articular cartilage interposition could stimulate fibrocartilage transition zone regeneration and improve BTJ healing.
Partial patellectomy repair was performed in goat. Articular cartilage harvested from excised patella segment was interposed between the patella and patellar tendon during repair. No cartilage interposition was used in control group. Samples were harvested at six, 12, and 24 weeks for histological examination (n=6 each). The histological images were digitised and analyzed using an image analysis system. Healing progress was assessed by the amount of new bone formation and fibrocartilage transition zone regeneration. Quantitative data were analyzed using SPSS version 14.0. Statistic al significance level was set at p < 0.05.
There was progressive increase in maximum new bone length and area of new bone formed with time (p< 0.05, Kruskal-Wallis test). No difference was observed between treatment groups. Articular cartilage interposition resulted in more fibrocartilage regeneration and higher proteoglycan uptake at all time points. At 24 weeks, length of fibrocartilage formed measured 7760 ± 629 μm with articular cartilage interposition, compared with 787± 274 μm in control (p = 0.002, Mann-Whitney test). Safranin O length measured 3301 ± 1236 μm with articular cartilage interposition, compared with 277 ± 187 μm in control (p = 0.03, Mann-Whitney test).
Autologous articular cartilage interposition stimulates fibrocartilage transition zone regeneration in BTJ repair without affecting bone formation.
Since September 1964, neonates born in New Plymouth have undergone clinical examination for Neonatal Instability of the Hip (NIH) in a structured clinical screening programme. Forty one thousand, five hundred and sixty three babies were born during the period of this study, of which 1,638 were diagnosed as having unstable hips. Six hundred and thirty three with persisting instability were splinted (1.6%), with five hips failing splintage. In addition, three unsplinted hips progressed to CDH, and there were four late-presenting (walking) cases of CDH, giving an overall failure rate for the programme of 0.29 per 1000 live births, with a late-presenting (walking) CDH incidence of 0.1 per 1000 live births. This study confirms that clinical screening for NIH by experienced orthopaedic examiners significantly lowers the incidence of late-presenting (walking) CDH.
To identify frequency and patterns of Oxford Phase 3 Unicompartmental Knee Arthroplasty (UKA) failure in New Zealand through analysis of national primary and revision data. Compare the results of this data with that of total knee arthroplasty and other international joint registers.
Retrospective audit examining all Oxford Phase 3 UKAs recorded in the New Zealand National Joint Register from January 2000 to December 2007 were analysed and then statistic al analysis performed to identify patterns of failure and reasons for revision.
Two thousand six hundred and twenty Oxford UKAs were performed by 99 Orthopædic Surgeons. The average age was 66.1 years (range 35–94).
Osteoarthritis was the primary diagnosis. Mean time to revision 839 days (2.3 years). Revision rate was 5.6% (n=148). The most common reasons for revision were pain (n=61, 41%), aseptic loosening (n=53, 36%), and bearing dislocation (n=16, 11%). Deep infection rate was 0.26% (7/2620) compared with 1.76% of total knee arthroplasties (564/32029). Six surgeons (high use & #8805;10 UKAs/year) performed 699 (26.7%) operations, revision rate 2.6%. Fifty-five surgeons (low use & #8804; two UKA/year) performed 283 (10.8%) operations, revision rate 10.6%. There was a statistically significant difference seen with an inverse relationship between surgeon experience and revision. The revision rate for the Oxford is three, two times greater than TKA.
UKA is now decreasing in New Zealand whilst Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA) continues to increase. The number of is now decreasing in New Zealand whilst Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA) continues to increase. The number of surgeons using Oxford UKA has increased by 19% but the number of Oxfords being done has fallen by 13%. High use surgeons’ revision rate is now higher than TKA. An inverse relationship between failure and surgeon experience exists which confirms Swedish Knee Arthroplasty register reports. The deep infection rate is less than TKA. Revisions were performed early for unexplained pain in the absence of obvious mechanical failure. This is against generally held wisdom for TKA and may reflect the perception that UKA is easily revised to TKA.
The minimally invasive technique recommended by the designers in the implantation of the OXF UKA make for a demanding procedure: most recorded failures are of a technical nature and occur within the first 2-years of implantation. Also, data from the Swedish and NZ National Joint Registries (NJR) show clearly that revision rates and surgeon experience are inversely related.
To present some technical points, using illustrative cases, where implantation has been associated with suboptimal outcome, or has lead to re-operation. To offer solutions for these potential problems
In 2004, data from the NZ NJR allowed analysis of all failures of OXF UKA leading to revision. The case notes and x-rays (where available) were studied (Hartnett et al, NZOA ASM, 2004). Clinical records of personal cases performed over 8 years up till July 2008 have also been studied and provide the illustrative cases.
On the tibial side, mismatch between the length of the keel on the tibial component and the bony slot created for it can cause the tibial component to be too posteriorally-sited. Also, if too much cement is used, posterior protrusion of cement may be difficult to detect at operation. The combination of these two may cause symptoms postero-medially. Ways of preventing these problems are outlined.
On the femoral side, NZJR records that aseptic loosening of the femoral component is a prominent cause of failure of OXF UKA. A number of techniques to improve cement intrusion can be implemented and are outlined. A case study of the only such encountered describes the possibility that the femoral intramedullary guide rod can inadvertently be driven into the femoral canal by knee motion during operation: this remained undetected until shown on the x-ray taken after operation.
Simple modifications of technique can minimise the chance of suboptimal outcome after OXF UKA surgery.
A previous audit of New Zealand Joint Registry data showed that, overall, OXF UKA had over three times the seven–year revision rate (RR) compared with TKA. Where the RR was calculated for surgeons performing one or more OXF UKA per month, however, the RR was comparable to that for all–surgeon TKA (Hartnett et al, NZOA ASM, 2007).
To audit and compare revisions of OXF UKA and TKA performed by one surgeon, as recorded in the New Zealand National Joint Registry, and to highlight a complication of OKF UKA unreported in the literature.
The data from a personal series of 177 consecutive medial Oxford (Phase three) cemented UKAs entered in the Registry from January 2000 to December 2007 was analysed. The number and reasons for revision of the cohort was compared with a similar personal cohort of 229 consecutive cemented TKAs performed over the same period. Comparison was also made between this personal data with that for all surgeons recorded in the Registry.
OXF UKAs were performed at a mean rate of 1.8 procedures per month. The prime indication was antero-medial osteoarthritis: valgus stress x-rays performed routinely had to establish adequate thickness of lateral articular cartilage and ACL had to be competent before the UKA was preferred to TKA. Fifty six (31.6%) of the 177 operations were performed as part of bilateral procedures under the one anaesthetic.
Two OXF UKAs were revised to TKA. In neither was there failure of fixation or integrity of the prosthesis: one case was revised for unexplained pain where OXF UKA was for post–traumatic medial OA. The 2nd revision followed recurrent haemarthrosis and subsequent joint destruction: arteriography found no arterial injury. The RR for personal OXF UKA was therefore 1.1%, which compares with personal TKA RR of 2.2% (difference not significant p=0.42). The RR for all OXF UKAs in NZ was 5.6%, and that for TKA was 1.8%. The difference between personal and national RR for OXF UKA is significant (p=0.010), and that for TKA is not (p=0.63).
Since 2000, two other revisions of OXF UKA outside the studied cohort both followed recurrent haemarthrosis causing joint destruction. The results of OXF UKA reported here confirm that an early revision rate comparable to TKA is achievable when this surgery is performed relatively frequently by the surgeon. Recurrent haemarthrosis occurring later after early successful OXF UKA surgery is not recorded in the English literature. It has been the most frequent reason for revision (three of four revisions).
Squeaking in ceramic total hip joint replacements has become a controversial topic. This study aims to document the incidence of squeaking and other noise generation in a single surgeon series for ceramic on ceramic total hip joint replacements. Possible aetiological for squeaking causes are explored.
All patients from public and private who received ceramic on ceramic total hip joint replacements (Stryker trident-accolade) from 2002 to 2007 were identified via the New Zealand Joint registry. Following ethics approval all patients were contacted for a phone interview to question as to whether they had noted any noise generation. Patients who demonstrated noise generation were reviewed in clinic for full history and examination. Data including age, sex, weight, primary diagnosis, head size and cup size were obtained from clinical notes. Post operative x-rays were reviewed to analyse cup abduction and version.
Forty one ceramic total hip joint replacements in a total of thirty seven patients were reviewed via telephone interviews. Three patients complained of squeaking in the ceramic bearing while one patient complained of a grinding and one other of clicking. Two of the three who had recognised the squeaking were both able to reproduce the squeaking in the clinic room. The third patient was noted to have crepitus from anterior patello-femoral osteoarthritis. There was no statistical difference in age, weight, primary diagnosis or head size. In terms of abduction and version of the acetabular cups that squeaked, one had twenty seven degrees of ante-version and forty seven degrees of abduction and the other fifteen degrees of anteversion and thirty degrees of anteversion. Four cups lay outside the recommended fifteen-thirty five degrees of anteversion and thirty five-fifty five degrees of abduction yet showed no squeaking. Neither patient is troubled by the squeaking and neither would seek revision surgery. The incidence of squeaking in ceramic on ceramic total hip joint replacements appears to be around five percent with a similar number of patients experiencing other noises. The position of the acetabular cup does not appear to be the sole contributor to the noise and other aetiological causes need to be further investigated.
Waitemata DHB serves a population of approximately 500,000. There are 396 general practitioners who refer to the services. Approximately 400 patients are referred per month. Budget constraints mean not all patients referred can be seen and various Ministry of Health guidelines and Health and Disability Commission rulings help to determine which patients will be seen.
All referrals to the service are assessed by one surgeon. There are specific requirements for referral of patients with certain complaints.
Assistance is given to the general practitioner in organising the more specialist investigations. Help is given to GPs by telephone for patient management particularly of the simpler conditions.
Approximately a quarter of patients referred are referred back to the GP. MRI and CT scans are arranged of which half are returned.
Time must be allocated within the department to allow this specialist liaison with GPs to occur.
Non-seated ceramic inserts have recently been identified as a common phenomenon in one popular modular ceramic system (16.4% of cases in Langdown et al. 2007. JBJS 89B (3):291–295). A preliminary audit at Tauranga Hospital demonstrated the same issue. However, most X-rays didn’t allow confirmation or exclusion of the problem.
A preliminary review of post-operative films of patients receiving modular ceramic acetabular implants at Tauranga Hospital was undertaken. A radiolucent jig was constructed to take images of three different modular ceramic acetabular systems. Images isocentered on the implants (seated & non-seated) were taken with variation in view given of the cup (rotation and plane of the X-ray beam relative to the implant face). Registrars & consultants were tested on their ability to detect non-seating on these images.
Two out of three acetabular systems showed non-seating in patients. Most films reviewed did not allow definitive decisions to be made about ceramic insert seating. The true incidence of non-seating in the arthroplasty population receiving modular ceramic implants is thus unknown. The images of the three systems taken in the radiolucent jig show the ability to detect non-seating is multifactorial. Implant specific differences in the shell and liner systems radiologic profile influence detection and education of surgeons may improve the chances of detection. The presence of the head of the femoral component limits detection of non-seating. The plane of the X-ray beam relative to the face of the cup along with the rotation of the non-seated region relative to the beam strongly influence detection. The plane of the X-ray beam relative to the face of the inserted acetabular component can be altered in post-operative films.
Typical post-arthroplasty hip films fail to consistently identify the occurrence of non-seating of modular ceramic acetabular inserts. Suggesting the true incidence remains unknown. Standard post-operative imaging needs to change to be confident of exclusion of this phenomenon in patients receiving modular ceramic implants.
The early results with highly cross-linked polyethylene have been encouraging and have increased the ability to use larger head diameters to improve the range of motion and decrease the dislocation rate, the commonest cause of early complications following total hip arthroplasty (THA). Wear rates with 32 mls heads have been satisfactory however there have been very few independent studies looking at early polyethylene wear in 36 mm heads. This study assessed the rate of polyethylene wear of a 36mm ceramic femoral head and a highly cross-linked polyethylene (X3 Stryker) liner in THA.
This prospective study reviewed 100 consecutive THAs in young patients (mean age 58 years) who had undergone THA with the same 36mm ceramic femoral head and highly cross linked polyethylene liner. All patients received the same femoral stem (ABG, Stryker) and acetabular cup (Trident, Stryker). Two surgeons performed all procedures. Patients were assessed radiologically immediately postoperatively, at 10 weeks and at one year. Validated computer software (Polyware) was used to assess both volumetric and linear wear.
At one year the mean two-dimensional linear wear rate was 0.51 mm/yr. Mean three-dimensional linear vector wear rate was 0.59 mls per year with a mean volumetric wear rate of 322.6 mms per three years. Cup size ranged from 52–62 mms and the correlation coefficient between cup size and three-dimensional linear wear rate was −0.100. The correlation coefficient between cup size and volumetric wear rate was −0.009 confirming no significant correlation between cup size and wear.
Larger size femoral heads are associated with a higher volumetric wear compared to linear wear rate when using conventional polyethylene. This study demonstrated much higher early linear wear rates compared to other studies using 28 and 32 mms heads. This higher rate may be associated with the creep phenomenon and early bedding-in in the early stages after a THA and although this is of concern these results should be interpreted with caution.
Whole blood metal ion levels remain a concern in those patients undergoing total hip replacement with metal bearing surfaces. The determination of baseline reference levels are essential if useful information can be gleaned from in vivo studies of functioning implants. We set out to prospectively determine chromium and cobalt metal ion concentrations in patients undergoing total hip replacement to determine reference levels of these metal ions.
100 patients with normal renal function, no occupational or environmental exposure to cobalt and chromium, and an absence of implanted metals were recruited into the study. Metal ion levels were determined using two different assay methods. Both ICP-MS (Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectroscopy) and GFAAS (Graphite Furnace Atomic Adsorption Spectroscopy) are well recognised analytical techniques for the quantification of trace elements. Levels were correlated with gender, age and place of residence.
There was considerable variability in whole blood metal ion levels, with the ICP-MS being more sensitive and consistent than the GFAAS method. Direct comparison of concentration levels determined by the two methods revealed no significant correlation. There was no correlation with age, gender and place of residence.
Our findings would favour the use of the ICP-MS to determine reference levels and as a baseline for metalion surveillance pre-operatively in patients undergoing metal-on-metal total hip replacements. We also determined that changes in whole blood metal ion levels are more significant than actual levels in patients who have undergone total hip replacement.
Dislocations remain a significant problem, especially after revision hip surgery. Revision of components, particularly in elderly patients with co-morbidities, can be fraught with complications. The surgeon’s options are sometimes restricted, particularly when the acetabular and femoral components are well fixed. Increased head lengths are often utilised to increase tissue tension, and thus improve stability.
As a niche solution we have designed a low cost modular femoral neck extender. They are manufactured from medical grade Cobalt-Chrome, conforming to ISO 200, CE mark and EN46001 standards. Available in three incremental lengths and with different connecting Morse tapers, increases in effective neck lengths of up to 49 mms can be achieved. When both the original acetabular and femoral components are well orientated, the resultant increased tissue tension imparts stability to the hip.
We present a series of five patients where we have used a femoral neck extender to achieve stability of a total hip replacement. Four patients had had multiple previous dislocations. One patient was unstable at the time of revision surgery because of a high hip centre. The average age of the patients was 72 years, and the number of previous dislocations averaged four. The average follow-up after surgery was 22 months. No patients have redislocated their hips.
We present our novel femoral neck extenders as an elegant and cost effective solution to convert an unstable hip to a stable hip, especially when the patient has well fixed and orientated components not in themselves requiring revision.
A randomised prospective study of four bearing surfaces in hip replacements is being conducted. The primary objective is to identify the best long term bearing surf ace clinically and radiographically, and metal ion levels have been measured in all cases.
Patients have been randomised to the four bearing surfaces viz. Ceramic-on-XLinked Polyethelene, Ceramic-on-Ceramic, Metal-on-Metal and Ceramic-on-Metal. Pre-operative blood samples and follow-up blood samples for metal ion analysis using ICP-MS method have been taken in all patients. As at February 2008 187 patients have been recruited, and metal ion levels at one year are available in 52 patients.
Metal ion levels are not increased with Ceramic-on-XLPE or Ceramic-on-Ceramic bearings. At one year follow-up the metal ion levels in Ceramic-on–Metal bearings is half that of Metal-on-Metal bearings using mean levels, and one third using median levels. Of note is that chromium levels in Ceramic-on-Metal bearings is the least elevated.
Due to the laboratory evidence that ceramic-on-metal bearings have the best surf ace wear characteristics with no head stripe wear on a ceramic head, and the laboratory and clinic al evidence of lower metal ion levels, Ceramic-on-Metal hip replacements could be one of the bearing surfaces of the future.
Correct component positioning in hip resurfacing is a key determinant for a successful outcome. The aim of the study was to compare the radiographic and perioperative clinical parameters between navigated and non-navigated resurfacing groups and to look at the effect of navigation on the learning curve.
Pre and post operative radiographs were analyzed with respect to neck-shaft angle, implant-shaft angle, notching, lateral position, and cup inclination. The target implant position was to place the femoral component in relative valgus to the neck-shaft angle using the smallest component without notching the femoral neck. The target cup position was 40–45 degrees inclination. Statistical analysis was performed comparing the two groups with respect to implant position, complications and differences between experienced verses inexperienced surgeons.
Data was recorded for 51 patients (24 navigated, 27 conventional). There was no significant difference in implant-shaft angle or presence of notching between the two groups. There were two cases of notching in the non-navigated cohort. Lateral positioning (central placement stem, centering component on shaft) was significantly more accurate for the navigated cases (P< 0. 001). There was no significant difference in cup inclination between the two groups. In the non-navigated group three patients were converted to a total hip replacement (one fracture, one impingement pain, one intra-operative notching) and there was 1 case of medial wall fracture of the acetabulum. There was a 14.8% complication rate for the non-navigated group with no complications in the navigated group. Complications experienced 2.6% vs. training 17.4%. Training navigated 0% vs Training non-navigated 30%; Experienced nav 0% vs. experienced non-navigated 5.5%.
Positioning of the femoral component in the lateral plane and A-P head-neck ratios is significantly more accurate with the use of computer navigation. Navigation allows for a relative valgus implant-shaft angle that is as accurate as conventional jigs. Navigation is useful as a teaching tool with a reduction in the learning curve and better radiographic placement of components.
Deterioration in knee joint proprioception has been postulated to occur following injury, resulting in further instability due to disruption of receptors and feedback mechanisms. Surgical reconstruction techniques may also influence post-operative proprioceptive ability (PA). We hypothesised that anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction techniques which disrupt the knee capsule would result in a decrease in PA.
Following ethical approval, a total of 48 subjects (mean age: 28.1 ± 10.5, 34 male, 14 female) undergoing ACL reconstruction surgery were included in the study. Fifteen subjects underwent “open” capsule ACL surgery and patellar tendon graft, whereas 33 subjects had “closed” capsule surgery with a hamstring tendon graft. Knee proprioception was measured on a custom-designed test apparatus incorporating electromagnetic position sensors (Polhemus Fastrack) located on femoral and tibial landmarks to accurately track knee angle during flexion-extension (no load). Leg flexion-extension under partial weight-bearing (5kg) was also evaluated. Pre-operative PA was assessed bilaterally, and then again on operated joints at three, six and twelve months post-op. Proprioceptive ability was measured as the cumulative absolute error in knee angle (°) between five repeat measurements and a target angle.
We observed no significant difference in PA between injured and contralateral knees prior to ACL reconstruction. Post-operatively, no significant difference in PA was observed between “open” versus “closed” ACL techniques, irrespective of loading conditions. While trends indicated that PA during knee extension (no load) and leg flexion (partial weight-bearing) improved over the 12 months compared to pre-operative values in closed ACL surgery, these were not significantly different to open ACL results.
The proportion of subjects whose PA improved in at least two out of the three post-op evaluations was also similar (approx 50%) across all groups, irrespective of joint loading. The only difference was PA during leg flexion under partial weight bearing, where 27% of open ACL surgery patients showed improvement in two or more follow-up tests, as opposed to 58% of closed ACL surgery patients.
We present a method to determine pre- and postoperative PA during knee flexion/extension under no load as well as under partial weight-bearing. We saw no significant difference in PA of the knee under no-load versus load. We also saw no significant difference in postoperative PA following open capsule, patellar tendon graft versus closed capsule, hamstring tendon graft ACL reconstruction technique after 1 year follow-up.
In major lower limb amputation, preservation of the knee joint significantly improves outcome. In the severely compromised limb, to preserve the knee joint, high tibial transection may be necessary creating a less than optimal stump. This study reviews the outcome in below knee amputees with stumps 10cm or shorter.
All 209 below knee (BK) amputees attending the New Zealand Artificial Limb Board’s Dunedin Centre were reviewed. The centre is the sole provider of prosthetic services in the southern region. Forty-four amputees (21% of total) had stumps of 10cm or less in length as measured by caliper rule. After a minimum twelve month follow-up these amputees were placed in two groups.
Group 1: Short Stump (10cm to 8cm) Group 2: Ultra Short Stump (7.5cm to 5cm)
Wood-Stanmore Grades were given for walking ability (Hanspal and Fisher 1991). Rehabilitation was further assessed using a modified Houghton Questionnaire (Houghton et al 1992).
Mean stump length for all 209 BK amputees was 12.5 centimeters (range 5 to 25 centimeters).
Nineteen amputees – Good to Excellent (Wood – Stanmore Grade V and V1) i.e. walking indoors and outdoors without aids and with near normal gait. (10 trauma, four dysvascular, four tumour, one infection). Fourteen amputees-Satisfactory (Grade 1V) i.e. walking aid indoors and outdoors (13 dysvascular, one congenital). 4 amputees – Fair Only (Grade 111) i.e. mostly indoors with frame (four dysvascular).
Six amputees – Good to Excellent (Grade V or V1) – (all trauma) One amputee – Fair Only (Grade 111) – (dysvascular)
Group one mostly had a posterior myocutaneous flap amputation with retention of the proximal fibula. In Group two, all had resection of the proximal fibula with varied flaps often with skin grafting. The patellar tendon was intact but two patients had lost the hamstring insertion with hyperextension of the knee, one requiring prosthesis with side steels and thigh corset. In group two the best results followed high resection of the common peroneal nerve and careful shaping of the tibial remnant. Cortical bone formed at the transection level allowing total contact prosthetic fitting with some end bearing.
BK amputation is described as optimally 12.5 centimeters to 17.5 centimeters below the knee joint (10 to 12.5 centimeters in vascular disease). Saving the knee should always be considered and with combined surgical and prosthetic skill a stump as short as five centimeters may be fitted satisfactorily particularly in the young and following trauma.
This study assessed factors responsible for exclusion of patients from bone donation at primary hip arthroplasty in order to improve bone banking.
Fifty-five patients underwent screening in preoperative clinics assessing their suitability for femoral head donation. Records at the bone bank were then reviewed post operatively to check whether bone had been harvested from these individuals during surgery.
Overall, 95% of the patients screened did not proceed to bone banking. After the initial screening stage 60% of patients were excluded. The majority of exclusions (70%) were unacceptable as donors because of their potential risk of transmission of disease to recipients. Although 40% were consented for donation, femoral heads from only 5% were harvested and sent for storage in the bone bank during hip arthroplasty.
Orthopaedic surgeons must take an active part in bone banking and alternative sources of bone grafts require exploration in the future to meet the increasing demand.
Recurrent patellar dislocation is a relatively common disorder in young patients. Historically, treatment options have been based on the underlying disorder predisposing the patient to the dislocation. This has resulted in various soft tissue reefing procedures, patella tendon realignment procedures and boney realignment procedures.
Further research has shown that the medial patello-femoral ligament (MPFL) is the primary restraint to lateral patella subluxation and dislocation. Many authors have published their successful treatment of recurrent patella dislocation by reconstruction of the medial patellofemoral ligament. The most widely used is autologous semitendinosis tendon grafts, as well as synthetic materials, and MPFL reconstructions may be combined with boney procedures. Varieties of fixation techniques have been described involving both the patella and femoral sides.
We present a technique of MPFL reconstruction using the autologous ipsilateral quadriceps tendon. Our technique avoids the morbidity associated with semitendinosis graft harvesting and the drill holes in, and potential resulting fracture of, the patella. The technique is also simple and is associated with decreased procedure costs.
We present the technique and a series of six patients (seven knees) with follow up ranging from eight months to nine years. The average age of patients at the time of surgery 16 to 28 years (mean = 20 years). There have been no redislocations. The median Kujala patellofemoral knee score at follow up was 97 out of 100 (Range 69–100). The results compare very favorably to published results using other techniques.
Our technique of reconstructing the MPFL is reliable, produces good results using an objective knee score, and is cost effective.
Seventy staff members participated from a potential pool of approximately one hundred staff on duty at the time. Of the seventy staff who participated in this research project a total of three staff members were within 50 mls of the correct amount for each of the three samples. Overall staff were very poor at estimating blood loss.
Staff working in the operating theatre, no matter what their affiliation or years of experience, are not accurate when estimating blood loss spilt into a patients bed. A tool that aids in blood loss estimation is a valuable addition to the theatre resource manual.
In January 2000 we introduced identical guidelines for the more rapid rehabilitation of Achilles tendon ruptures, whether treated operatively or non-operatively. A relaxed equinus cast was used to four weeks, then a CAM walker to eight weeks with supervised mobilisation. The aims of this study were to compare the outcomes of the operative and non-operative groups treated with the same rehabilitation program and audit the effectiveness of these guidelines.
The audit was retrospective from January 2000 till January 2008. The patients were identified from the Emergency Department admissions database, the hospital clinical coding system, the department’s surgical audit data and the hospital physiotherapy appointment system. The audit system was used to identify patients that had complications of their operative treatment, re-ruptures or readmissions. This study focused on the end points of re-rupture, readmission, complications including wound complications and infection.
Five hundred and eighty seven presentations were recorded as Achilles tendon injuries. One hundred and eighty patients were treated operatively and 407 patients were treated conservatively. Seventy five patients (42%) treated operatively and 126 patients (30%) of the non-operative group were rehabilitated in our hospital physiotherapy department. The remaining 386 patients (65.7% of all patients) received physiotherapy elsewhere or did not attend for further treatment. In the operative group there were two re-ruptures (1.1%) both treated in our hospital physiotherapy department. There were 2 wound complications (1.1%), one requiring re-operation. In the non operative group there were 15 re-ruptures (3.7%). Of these three had attended the hospital physiotherapy department (rerupture rate of 2.4%) In the non-operative group treated elsewhere there were 12 re-ruptures from 281 patients (4.2%).
Comparable results were found between operative and non-operative treatment when combined with close physiotherapy guidance. Non-operatively treated patients treated in the community may have higher re-rupture rates. The results are comparable to those in the literature suggesting that the guidelines are effective.
There is no consensus on the management of TA rupture. For operative management, TA have been repaired under general/spinal anaesthetic (GA) or LA. LA repair may be at least as effective and can reduce anaesthetic complications. LA can be performed as a day case and could have significant cost savings.
We retrospectively reviewed 80 patients (sample size 120), during the five year period 2001–2005 at Nelson Hospital, who’s ruptured TA was repaired under general anaesthetic (GA) or local anaesthetic (LA). All patients reviewed were at least six months post-op. We assessed at a clinic their long-term outcome, including pain and function. This included their range of motion and strength. Epidemiological data including risk factors was collected. Patients completed a Foot and Ankle questionnaire developed by the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. Complications such as infection or nerve damage were noted. Further patients are currently being seen to increase sample size.
Of the 80 TA that were repaired, 51 (64%) were repaired under GA, 29 (36%) under LA. Results thus far show similar levels of patient satisfaction. 82% of GA patients and 83% of LA patients reported no pain. Patient-reported weakness was 27% (GA) and 24% (LA). Single leg hop distance comparing injured with uninjured was 94% (GA) and 91% (LA). Maximum calf raises in 30 seconds comparing injured with uninjured was 84% (GA) and 82% (LA). Calf diameter on the injured side was 97% (GA) and 96% (LA) compared with the uninjured. The average theatre time was 38 minutes (LA) compared with 65 minutes. LA patients spent on average 0.26 days in hospital compared with 1.2 days, reflecting a greater proportion of day cases. LA patients had a quicker return to work, average 21 days versus 30. Complications in the GA group, included two deep vein thromboses and two pulmonary emboli. One patient from each group had a re-rupture. Results will be reviewed and further statistical analysis done once further patients have been seen.
There is no disadvantage in repairing a ruptured TA under LA with regards to long-term pain, function and patient satisfaction. LA repair avoids anaesthetist involvement and anaesthetic complications. Repair under LA results in significant cost savings due to less theatre time, a shorter hospital stay and a quicker return to work.
We assessed the rates of fracture healing in a number of patients in Southern Africa where the Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) is highly prevalent.
Our aim was to deduce whether rates of union were affected by HIV and its subsequent clinical stages, including the Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS). We evaluated 2376 patients with Weber B ankle fractures without talar shift. All the patients included in the study were tested for HIV using the Western Blot system and classified according to the WHO classification (Stages I–IV). From the sample group, 829 patients were HIV negative. 729 were HIV positive belonging to Stages I–III, whilst 755 were HIV positive in stage IV of the disease. Patients were all treated conservatively in below knee casts for a minimum of six weeks. All the patients were aged between 20 and 30. All patients were all part of similar socioeconomic circumstances and were non-smokers who used no dietary supplements.
From the sample of patients we reviewed, the results were as follows. In the HIV negative category, 56% of patients had fracture union at 4 weeks, 32% had fracture union at 6 weeks, 10.5% had fracture union at eight weeks and 1.5% of patients suffered non-union of the fractures. In the HIV positive group (WHO Stages I–III), 54.7% of patients had fracture union at 4 weeks, 33.7% had fracture union at 6 weeks, 10.2% had fracture union at 8 weeks and 1.26% of patients suffered non-union. From the HIV positive category (WHO Stage IV), 18.28% of patients had fracture union at four weeks, 32.72% had fracture union at 6 weeks, 36.56% had fracture union at 8 weeks and 12.45% of patients suffered non-union of the fractures. Healing and union were described as sufficient callous formation, no further displacement, and no malleolar tenderness at the time of cast removal. In addition to this, the patients must have been able to fully weight bear. There was no significant statistical difference in fracture union between patients who were HIV negative and the patients with HIV stages one to three. There were significant differences between the above mentioned groups and patients with Stage IV HIV/AIDS. In essence, the more progressive the disease, the higher the rates of non-union.
Intramedullary nailing is acknowledged as a safe and effective mode of treatment for many tibial fractures. Implant removal is frequently indicated either as an elective procedure following union or because of problems such as infection or delayed fracture union. It is therefore essential that intramedullary rod removal should be reasonably straightforward and atraumatic.
We describe three cases in which bony growth into the implant has made rod removal either difficult or impossible. We include photographs of two removed implants with clearly visible areas of osseo-integration with bony growth into the cannulation through the interlocking holes as well as radiographs demonstrating the same phenomenon.
The average time between insertion and removal was 16 months. In all cases an end cap had been used such that insertion of the extraction device was straightforward but for two patients nail removal was extremely difficult due to bone ingrowth and in the third patient the nail had to be left in-situ. All three implants were made of titanium and the patients were all active young males. The authors have never encountered this problem with steel rods and speculate that the osteointegrative property of titanium is the major causative factor.
We suggest that unremoved intramedullary rods represent a major risk in fracture management and that close monitoring of these implants should be undertaken.
Osteoporosis is common in elderly patients and is commonly associated with fractures of the neck of the femur. It is known that this condition is not treated optimally by orthopaedic services around the world. We aim to examine the level of osteoporosis treatment in this fracture and how effective we were in improving treatment for osteoporosis.
We retrospectively examined hospital documents from patients admitted between 1 January and 31 December 2004 with femoral neck fracture. All notes were retrieved and were complete. We examined the medications on admission, the place of residence, place of discharge, frequency of DEXA scanning and medications.
One hundred and twenty patients were admitted with fracture of the neck of the femur. This group consisted of 23 males with an average age of 76.7, 97 females with an average age of 83.7. Seventy five of these patients were admitted from home, 45 from a rest home. Four patients died prior to treatment, one refused treatment and subsequently died in a hospice. Osteoporotic medications on admission showed that 13 patients were on Bisphosphonate, 6 on Vitamin D and twelve on calcium supplements. Only 14 patients had had DEXA scans prior to admission. On admission eight patients were on no medications of any sort, 53 were on 1–4 medications, 53 were on 5–9 medications and 6 were on greater than 10 medications. On discharge from orthopaedic of the 120 patients 13 were on Bisphosphonate, six on Vitamin D, 13 on calcium supplements. Six patients were on no medications, 47 on 1–4 medications, 55 on 5–9 medications, nine on greater than 10 medications. On discharge from geriatric service, to which 69 patients had been referred 25 were on Bisphosphonate, 13 on Vitamin D, 18 on calcium supplements. One patient was on no medication. 20 were on 1–4 medications, 41 on 5–9 medications and seven on greater than 10 medications. Fifty four had had DEXA scans.
We found that the rate of treatment of osteoporosis in the community remains poor with no improvement while in the orthopaedic service.
On discharge from the geriatric service significant improvement in osteoporotic medication occurred but there was also an increased in polypharmacy.
Further work on the investigation and treatment of osteoporosis in this country is required.
Dirt-bike and motocross riding are popular recreational activities in New Zealand. There are many competitive and recreational events organised for children within our catchment area every year. T he aims of this study were to document the pattern of paediatric motorbike injuries admitted at our level one trauma centre.
Retrospective analysis of all patients under the age of 16 who were admitted to Waikato Hospital following a motorbike accident from January 2006 to May 2008. Patients were identifying using ICD 10 coding (U 651). Patient notes were retrieved and reviewed. Patients were excluded if they were not admitted from the emergency department.
There were 70 admissions identified in 58 patients on ICD coding. Three admissions were excluded. Nine patients had two or more separate admissions during the study period. Fifty-seven were male and the average age was 12.5 (range 6 to 15). There were 21 admissions in 2006, 27 in 2007 and 19 in the first five months of 2008. 64 (96%) were admitted under the orthopaedic/trauma service. 87% were helmeted and 73% were wearing protective gear. Motocross riding was responsible for 60% of admissions. No patients died. One patient had documented loss of consciousness at the scene and the mean injury severity score was 5.8 (range 1 to 27). There were 108 documented injuries and 28% of patients had multiple injuries. Of all injuries, lower extremity (33%) and upper extremity (28%) and head injuries (12%) were most common. Three percent of patients required surgery with 24.4% of these requiring multiple anaesthetics. The average length of stay was three days (range 1 to 10). One patient was transferred to another centre for spinal surgery and rehabilitation.
Severe motorbike injuries are common in Waikato. The number of severe injuries is increasing. Most injuries are associated with motocross and more than half require surgery. This increasing workload has financial implications on orthopaedic, trauma and emergency departments. Children riding motorbikes should wear helmets and protective gear at all times.
There has been debate in the literature over the years regarding whether
rib resection, and surgical approach have a significant impact on long term respiratory function following corrective surgery in idiopathic scoliosis patients.
We undertook a minimum 10 year review of prospective data in patients who had undergone corrective surgery for idiopathic scoliosis.
Patients had pre-operative, two year (where available) and 10 year follow-up respiratory function tests performed. Variables noted were sex, age at surgery, surgical approach, rib release (simple rib osteotomy, not resection), and percentage correction of curvature. All absolute respiratory function values were converted to percentages relative to a normal population of the same height, sex and age with reference to both arm span and height nomograms thus avoiding the need for a control group. Using accepted statistical norms and appropriate analysis we would be able to confirm a 10% difference in respiratory function.
A literature review was also undertaken as part of this study.
The only statistically significant change in respiratory function was a drop in FVC at 10 years in patients in whom a posterior approach had been used for correction without a rib release. In no other group (by other approach, sex, age, initial curvature, or curvature correction) was there a significant difference in long term respiratory function.
In our study the surgical approach did not have a significant impact on long term respiratory function. Rib release is a safe procedure to undertake as part of scoliosis correction.
Treatment of the young patient with medial compartment arthritis and a PCL deficient knee is a complex problem. This study evaluates the efficacy of the anteromedial opening wedge osteotomy for PCL deficient knees with medial compartment degenerative changes.
Eighteen patients have undergone an anteromedial opening wedge high tibial osteotomy for the PCL deficient varus knee. Patients were evaluated prospectively pre-operatively and at one and five years post surgery by visual analogue pain scores and patellofemoral pain scores, subjective IKDC, WOMAC and SF-36. Radiographic evaluation to determine correction in the coronal plane and the degree of slope increase was performed at one-year post surgery.
All patients reported and improvement in PCL instability. There was a significant improvement in visual analogue pain and patellofemoral pain sc ores, subjective IKDC, WOMAC and SF-36 and overall knee function at one and five years. Patients with less severe arthritis at the time of surgery performed better at five years.
This technique shows encouraging midterm results for a complex problem.
Better results are obtained with less significant arthritis at the time of surgery
Acute Low Back Screening Questionnaire (ALBSQ), designed to assess psychosocial variables identified as risk factors for continued back pain symptoms; Tampa Scale of Kinesiophobia (TSK), measuring fear of movement Clinical Back Pain Questionnaire (CBPQ), measuring pain and function.
The patients’ specific responses were used to develop the tailored psychosocial intervention.
Participants: Eighteen people (> 18 years) who could speak, read and understand English and who had participated in an exercise program for NSCLBP.
Design: Participants were guided with a set of pre-determined questions and encouraged to give personal opinions freely. Data were transcribed verbatim, read independently by 2 researchers and analysed thematically using grounded theory.
A large number of prognostic factors have been associated with recovery from an episode of back pain. The literature has placed much emphasis on psychosocial prognostic factors. The large number of prognostic factors and the lack of comparative analysis of different factors make their use difficult in clinical practice. The aim of this study was to evaluate the comparative usefulness of a range of factors to predict outcome using data from a randomized controlled trial. 312 patients with sub-acute to chronic back pain received a mechanical evaluation and were sub-grouped based on the presence or absence of directional preference (DP). Patients were then randomized to treatment that was matched or unmatched to that DP. Patients with a minimal reduction of 30% in RMDQ score were defined as the ‘good outcome’ group. 17 baseline variables were entered into a step-wise logistic regression analysis for their ability to predict a good outcome. 84 patients met the good outcome criteria and had a mean RMDQ decrease of 58.2% (9.8 points) in 4 visits. Leg pain, work status, depression, pain location, chronicity, and treatment assignment were significant predictors of outcome in univariate analysis. Only leg bothersomeness rating and treatment assignment survived multivariate analysis. Subjects with DP/centralization who received matched treatment had a 7.8 times greater likelihood of a good outcome. Matching patients to their DP is a stronger predictor of outcome than a range of other biopsychosocial factors.
literature review, 4 focus groups (n=18 CLBP patients), Physiotherapist Interviews (n=4), and then pilot-tested in a consenting sample of 10 CLBP patients [n=5 male, 5 female; mean (SD)= 50.5 (12.6) years], who completed the 10-metre Shuttle Walk Test, Oswestry Disability Index, NRS, Euro-Qol, Fear Avoidance, Back Beliefs, International Physical Activity and Self-Efficacy Questionnaires, at baseline and 8-week follow-up, and wore the activPAL™ accelerometer for 7 days pre and post intervention.
public hospital-based secondary care versus private community-based primary care in Ireland.
No significant difference was detected between groups or time points for either muscle (p> 0.05).
Modic changes(M) have been described in association to Degenerative Disc Disease(DDD). Type-I represents the inflammatory phase whereas Type-II describes fatty changes within the vertebral marrow and endplate. Type-III is more advanced degeneration and it indicates marked sclerosis adjacent to endplates.
Adjacent endplate levels showed worsening of M0 to M2 in 11 patients while no change was seen in 35 levels. Only 4 levels with M2 were seen, of which 3 levels did not change and 1 level continued to M3. 2 M3 improved to M2.
The reality of living with back pain was considered and patients were asked to rate the interference in aspects of Activities of daily living (ADL). They were then asked which type of support or encouragement they would find useful and how this should be provided. The effect of living with back pain was evaluated using PPMCC in relation to limitation to ADL against age, gender and exercise with no statistical significance demonstrated. However comparison was conducted with employment as a variable against pain on average day (r = −0.155 n=135) satisfaction (r= −0.153 n =132) expressed need for support (r = −1.05 n = 114). The question as to what style of support was clearly defined by the patients this was graphically analysed, demonstrating times and locations they would prefer.
In our cohort, clinical indications were:
• Degenerative Disc Disease (DDD)
271 patients
• Spondylolisthesis
55 patients
• Adjacent segment disease (ASD)
30 patients
• Spinal canal stenosis
18 patients
t-test was used for comparison between preoperative and postoperative scores and p-value was used to show the significance.
Patients with stenosis performed better when the procedure involved adjunct decompression. Similarly, results of decompression and fusion were better than Dynesys alone in patients with spondylolisthesis.
Dynesys was successfully controlled symptoms of DDD in the intermediate term. Dynesys can be used as surgical treatment for symptomatic ASD. Dynesys alone in the treatment of spondylolysthesis resulted in a 45% re-operation rate, and we believe it should not be recommended as an indication. Dynesys alone is not recommended as a treatment for symptomatic spinal stenosis.
This information was provided by the specialist nurses and orthopaedic surgeons within the SAC team. A multi-portal website was created to allow patients easy access to this information: and to also allow, the information to be updated as and when needed. A facility was also included to allow the provision of external resources that would be of benefit to the patient.
40 patients had primary lumbar discectomy of which 2 (5%) had dural tears. 20 patients had primary lumbar laminectomy of which 1 (5%) had a dural tear and 5 patients had revision lumbar discectomy of which 1 (20%) had a dural tear. All dural tears were repaired intraoperatively.
Conclusion: This study shows that the highest percentage of incidental durotomy was in revision lumbar surgery which was also slightly higher than the reported rates (8.1%–17.4%). The percentage of dural tears after primary discectomy and primary laminectomy was within range of the percentages reported in the literature (1%–7.1%) and (3.1%–13%) respectively. A multicentre prospective larger study which includes all different surgical procedures performed on the lumbar spine is needed to establish a more accurate incidence rate for this common complication.
Advances in implant design and instrumentation have led to total ankle replacement (TAR) becoming an attractive alternative to ankle fusion in selected cases. We present the short-term results for Mobility TAR with clinical and radiological findings.
The timing of surgery in treating closed ankle fractures requiring open reduction and internal fixation is dependent upon soft tissue swelling. At Exeter in 2001 one third of all trauma cases were operated on “out of hours,” in 2007 this was less than 10%, principally as a result of the lack of anaesthetic staff. The senior author has developed a technique of minimally invasive percutaneous plate osteosynthesis for ankle fracture fixation that may be undertaken at an early stage, despite the presence of swelling.
In a retrospective study 25 patients fixed with percutaneous osteosynthesis over four years were compared with a cohort of 25 patients selected at random who had undergone standard open reduction and internal fixation in the same time period. Particular attention was paid to time to surgery, time to discharge and complications. Patients undergoing percutaneous fixation were found from the hospital database. One patient was excluded because of a delay to surgery whilst being treated on the intensive care unit. Admission documentation, operation notes and clinic letters were used to ascertain the outcome. Pre and post-operative imaging was evaluated.
Over a four-year period the senior author performed minimally invasive percutaneous plate osteosynthesis on a total of 25 patients. The mean time to surgery was two days for the percutaneous cohort (range 0–5 days) compared with 4.1 days for the open cohort (range 1–11). Time to discharge was 4.2 days as opposed to 6.2 in the percutaneous group. There were no complications in the percutaneous cohort, as opposed to three in the standard cohort.
Preliminary results demonstrate a reduced waiting time for surgery and a quicker discharge when using minimally invasive percutaneous plate osteosynthesis technique for ankle fracture fixation. We believe that our institution is the first to develop this technique. Percutaneous fixation is an option when swelling precludes open surgery.
The influence of the timing of surgery for closed ankle fractures on complications is unclear. Previous studies have failed to demonstrate any associations with clear statistical support. This is a retrospective review of 221 patients presenting with closed ankle fractures treated with open reduction and internal fixation. The patients were similar in respect to age, gender, fracture type, surgeon grade, American Society of Anaesthesiologists grade, grade of anaesthetist and tourniquet time. Power analysis was performed for sample size. Patients were followed up until fracture union. The mean duration of inpatient care was greater in the delayed group (
The aim of this study was to determine the accuracy of Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) scanning compared to arthroscopic findings in patients presenting with chronic ankle pain and/or instability. We reviewed all patients who underwent arthroscopy of the ankle between December 2005 to July 2008 in our institution.
A total of 105 patients underwent arthroscopy for chronic ankle pain and/or instability. Twenty-four patients underwent MRI prior to the procedure. We compared the MRI findings with arthroscopic findings. We specifically examined for the anterior talofibular ligament (ATFL), calcaneofibular cigament (CFL) and osteochondral lesions(OCD). Arthroscopic findings were considered as a gold standard. There were 12 female and 12 male patients with an average age 39 years (11–65). The time interval between the MRI scan and arthroscopy was 7 months (2–18). In our study MRI had 100% specificity for the diagnosis of ATFL and CFL tears and osteochondral lesions. However sensitivity was low particularly for CFL tears. The accuracy of MRI in detecting ATFL tear was 91.7%, CFL tear was 87.5% and osteochondral lesion was 83.3%.
We conclude that MRI scanning has a very high specificity and positive predictive value in diagnosing tears of ATFT, CFL and osteochondral lesions. However sensitivity was low with MRI. In a symptomatic patient negative results on MRI must be viewed with caution and an arthroscopy is advisable for a definitive diagnosis and treatment.
The purpose of this study was to investigate whether apoptotic cells were present in these tissues with raised endothelial nitric oxide synthase (eNOS) and inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS) levels.