IS IT VALID? – ANTERIOR PELVIC PLANE IN IMAGE-FREE NAVIGATION-ASSISTED TOTAL HIP ARTHROPLASTY

Abstract

The anterior pelvic plane has been introduced as a concept of the reference plane to image free navigation-assisted cup placement of total hip arthroplasty. With the neutral pelvis, the anteversion relative to the conventional coordinate system is equal to the that of relation to the anatomical coordinate system. This is the rationale of image free navigation system. But, currently, two major concerns about image-free navigation assisted total hip arthroplasty are tilting of anatomic coordinate system and the cutaneous palpation procedure. Therefore, it was the goal of this study to provide both the bone anterior pelvic plane (Bone_APP) and the overlying soft tissue plane (Soft_APP) simultaneously, and to find possible correlations of biometrical parameters and effect of ante-version were an additional motivation of this study. 23 Korean adult patients underwent image-free navigation-assisted total hip arthroplasty. The tilting of Bone_APP, soft tissue thickness on ASIS, pubis, and then tilting of Soft_APP, and anteversion of cup were measured with reconstructed CT and 3D workstation system.

The average age was 66.1 years, the average height was 162.5cm at a weight of 59.2 kg. The average body mass index was 22.3. And the average lumbar lordosis was measured as 30.4 degrees. The soft tissue on the level of the pubis was 17.6 mm thicker than that on the level of ASIS in average. In all cases, Soft_APP was positive, that is from 3.5 to 16.5 degrees of backward rotation. We also found a high-intersubject variability in the Bone_APP from 13.4 of forward rotatation to 23 degrees of backward rotation. Overall, there are no correlation between biometrical parameters and difference of navigated data to others measured on CT. Averaged navigated data was 22.4 degrees. The average anatomic, operative, and planar anteversion were 29.2, 27.2 and 21.3 degrees respectively. The value of anteversion measured on the transverse plane and sagittal plane shows higher than navigated anteversion in paired comparison. This could be comprehended that the navigation system had under-estimated the anteversion than that of transverse and sagittal plane, This means navigation assessed pelvic plane as back ward tilting rather than forward tilting intraoperatively.

None of cases showed the Bone_APP was parallel to conventional coordinate system. Comparing the variable bone APP tilt, all of cases showed an backward tilted soft tissue plane. There were no correlation between bone APP and biometrical parameters. Overall, navigated data were less than anatomic and operative anteversion. Rather than anatomic coordinate system (Bone-APP), backward tilting due to overlying soft tissue (Soft-APP) might to make the navigated data have the tendency to under-estimated the anteversion of cup measured with CT. In conclusion, anterior pelvic plane does not satisfactory reliability with should be easily identified during operation. Image-free navigation system would take into account variations of individuals including both bone tilt and soft tissue plane.