A NEW WAY TO DETERMINE ULTRA LOW WEAR RATES IN A HIP SIMULATOR BY MEASURING THE ION AND PARTICLE RELEASE.

Abstract

In hip joint simulator studies, wear measurement is usually performed gravimetrically. This procedure is reliable for metal-on-polyethylene or ceramic-on-polyethylene bearings, in which relatively high amounts of abrasive wear particles are produced. With modern hard-on-hard bearings, volumetric wear decreases significantly up to 100 to 200-fold. The gravimetric method reaches its detection limit with metal-on-metal bearings and even more so with ceramic-on-ceramic bearings. This study establishes a new method of determining wear in hard-on-hard bearings by measuring the amount of worn particles/ions in the serum of hip simulators.

A wear study on three resurfacing hip implants (BHR^®, Smith& Nephew) was conducted using a hip joint simulator. Prior to the wear study, tests were performed to validate the detection power for high resolution-inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry (HR-ICP-MS). More importantly the system’s accuracy was compared to the gravimetric method, which is described in ISO 14243-2. The simulator was altered to run completely metal ion free. The ion concentration in the serum was measured every 100 000 cycles up to 1 500 000 cycles and subsequently in intervals of 500 000 cycles using HR-ICP-MS. The implants were neither removed from the simulator nor excessively cleaned during the course of the simulation. Serum was refreshed every 500 000 cycles. The serum samples were digested with purified nitric acid and hydrogen peroxide using a high pressure microwave autoclave in order to measure wear particles as well as dissolved ions. All steps were carried out under clean room conditions. Wear was calculated using the ion concentration and measured serum volume. Wear rates and transition from running-in to steady-state wear phases were calculated.

A detection power better than 0.028 μg/l for Co (cobalt), 0.017 μg/l for Cr (chromium) and 0.040 μg/l for Mo (molybdenum) was found for HR-ICP-MS. The validation of HR-ICP-MS showed good agreement between gravimetric data and measured ion concentrations. The tested implants showed similar wear behaviour. Implant wear resulted in high ion concentrations during the first 380 000 to 920 000 cycles. During this period, a mean wear rate of 6.96 mm3/10E6 cycles was determined. Subsequently, the wear rate significantly decreased to a mean wear rate of 0.37 mm3/10E6 cycles. Thus, a mean ratio between running-in and steady-state wear of 18.8 was found. The mean overall wear volume at the end of the simulation was 4.42 mm3.

This study showed that measuring the ion concentrations in the serum of hip simulators can be used to determine wear in metal-on-metal bearings. The main advantages of this new method are the ability to detect ultra-low wear rates and to precisely specify the duration of different wear phases. Because the implants do not have to be removed from the simulator and aggressive cleaning processes may be skipped, fluctuations in wear detection are extremely low. This in turn leads to a shorter duration of the simulation. Wear rates of the tested implants are low compared to polyethylene. Transferring the results to patient activity, wear would be the same during the first four to six months after implantation as in the next ten years. Minimizing the duration of running-in would be most effective in further reducing wear of metal-on-metal bearings.