METAL ON METAL BIG HEADS: ANALYSIS OF FIRST FAILURES AND CORRELATION WITH METAL IONS

Abstract

Metal on Metal coupling in total hip replacement has been widely used since many years. After the rebirth of resurfacing a new trend to use very large diameter metal-metal coupling with standard stem prostheses has been started. New prostheses, old and new problems. We analyze first failures with new large diameter metal on metal coupling.

The analysis focused on seven early failures of large diameter metal-metal prostheses (two resurfacing and five cementless prosthesis with XL head) over the first series of 350 cases (100 resurfacing and 250 cementless) in the first year. Synovial fluid aspiration have been performed in all failed patients searching for metal ions and bacterial proliferation. Moreover, prosthetic component positioning was also studied as a possible primum movens of these failures. Some failed patients underwent epicutaneous patch test for skin reaction to metal.

One resurface prosthesis failed as a result of an vascular necrosis and conseguent fracture of the femoral neck and revealed a moderate increment in metal ion concentration in blood and synovial fluid obtained at time of revision.

One resurface prosthesis failed as a result of an infected metallosis with a huge intraabdominal mass and revealed a huge increment in metal ion concentration in blood, addominal and synovial fluid. This patient underwent a lumbotomy to evacuate the abdominal retroperitoenal mass before prosthesis removal for a two step procedure.

Out of the five failures of metal on metal cementless prosthesis with XL head four were the result of aseptic loosening and one was the result of a low grade infection discovered at coltures after revision surgery. Three showed clear metallosis caused by wrong positioning (more than 50° of cup inclination). All of these three presented an articular noise and elevated blood and sinovial fluid metal ion concentration. The fourth patient with aseptic loosening had a good component positioning but demonstrated an epicutanous allergic reaction to Cobalt. Also one of the three patients with metallosis resulted allergic to Cobalt. The blood and sinovial metal ion values were always elevated but particularly high in patients with cup inclination over 50°.

Large head metal on metal prostheses demonstrated a higher percentage of early failure in our experience. They are very sensible to positioning. Blood and sinovial metal ion determination helps to promptly diagnose a bad metal on metal prosthetic functioning. A more accurate analysis about the different metals available on the market and their resistance to edge wear should not be delayed any further.