PAPER 40: CLINICIAN’S ABILITY FOR MONITORING MECHANICAL STATUS OF HEALING LENGTHENING CALLUS FROM PLAIN X-RAY PHOTOGRAM

Abstract

Objective: The purpose of the present study was to assess whether clinicians are actually able to evaluate the mechanical status of lengthening callus from plain radiographs.

Materials and Methods: 36 rats were employed in this study. Their left femurs were lengthened by 6 mm as a bone lengthening model. Rats were euthanized at 4 8 12 and 16 weeks after lengthening. Both femora were X-rayed and then bone density parameters (bone mineral content, bone mineral density and bone area) of lengthening callus were measured using pQCT. Three-point bending test was performed to determine the mechanical strength of the both bones. We defined the ratio of the strength of lengthening side to control side as estimated strength recovery rate (%). Then 20 orthopaedic surgeons evaluated only the X-ray photographs and tried to estimate the relative mechanical strength (%) of the affected side compared to the control side.

Results: Between the recovery percentage of mechanical strength and bone mineral content, a positive simple correlation (R2=0.11, p< 0.05) was seen. No significant correlation was seen between the recovery percentage of mechanical strength estimated by orthopaedists and the mechanical strength measured by three-point bending test (qualified doctors: R2=0.0793 p=0.291 unqualified doctors: R2=0.0523 p=0.394).

Discussion and conclusion: It became obvious that to estimate the strength of lengthening callus from plain radiographs alone is quite difficult as compared with the studies of the simple fracture model that have been reported until now.