PAPER 29: IS TITANIUM ALLOY STRONGER THAN STAINLESS STEEL AS THE MATERIAL FOR LOCKED NAILS AND SCREWS?

Abstract

Objectives: The purpose of this biomechanical study was to compare the mechanical properties of locked nails and screws made from either stainless steel or titanium alloy.

Methods: The specially designed locked nails and screws with the same structures were made from either stainless steel or titanium alloy. The structural factors investigated included inner diameter and root radius for locking screws and outer diameter and nail hole size for locked nails. The mechanical properties investigated included bending stiffness, strength, and fatigue life. Finite element models were used to simulate the mechanical tests and compute the stress concentration factors.

Results: Increasing the root radius and the inner diameter could effectively increase the fatigue strength of the locking screws. Fatigue strength increased more in titanium than in stainless steel screws, especially when the inner diameter was increased. In contrast, the titanium locked nails were much weaker than their stainless steel counterparts. Finite element models could closely predict the results of the biomechanical tests with a correlation coefficient that ranged from −0.58 to −0.84 for screws and was −0.98 for nails. The stress concentration factors ranged from 1 to 1.81 for screws and from 3.06 to 4.17 for nails.

Conclusions: With larger root radius and inner diameter, titanium locking screws could provide much stronger fatigue strength than stainless steel counterparts. However, titanium locked nails might lose their advantages of superior mechanical strength because of high notch sensitivity and this limitation should be a critical concern clinically. Finite element analyses could be reliably used in research and development of locked nails and locking screws.