US SCREENING OF NEWBORN HIPS REFERRED TO HIP SCREENING CLINIC: DOES CLINICAL ASSESSMENT CONTRIBUTE ADDITIONAL BENEFITS?

Abstract

Aim: We wanted to ascertain if clinical examination confers any additional benefit to secondary/targeted ultrasound screening of neonatal hips.

Materials and Methods: Of the 30585 births (from 1997–2002) in the population served by our hospital, 2742 babies (8.96 percent) were referred to the Hip Screening Clinic by the neonatologists and general practitioners. They were examined clinically and by US scans by the specialist consultants. The findings were documented prospectively. Of these, 1862 hips were normal on clinical examination, 841 hips tense (clinical examination inconclusive).

Results: 233 hips were identified as abnormal by the US scans (Graf method). 106 (45 percent) of these were normal on clinical examination. In 88 of the hips with abnormal US scans (38 percent), clinical examination could not be performed reliably as the babies were tense. None of the hips identified as abnormal on clinical examination were normal on US scans.

Conclusion/Discussion: US scanning of hips in at-risk babies by an experienced paediatric radiologist will identify all the abnormal hips. This will release the paediatric orthopaedic surgeon from routine clinical examination of all these babies. This time can be utilised for running other clinics. Babies found to have abnormal hips on US scanning may be seen by the orthopaedic surgeon for treatment and follow-up. Parents of babies with normal hip US scans may be reassured by a nurse practitioner or a paediatric physiotherapist. This should lead to better utilisation of resources and cost savings.