Abstract
Purpose: Locked plating has become a commonly used technique in complex fracture and nonunion work. The combination of locked and unlocked screws in the same construct has been referred to as “hybrid” fixation. Little work is available to direct the specifics of this fixation method. The purpose of this study was to determine the relative contribution of the number and location of locked screws on the properties of hybrid plate constructs in an osteoporotic bone model.
Method: A prefabricated osteoporotic model was used for reproducibility (composite cylinders 35 mm in diameter and consisting of a 2.5 mm fiberglass shell filled with 10 lb/ft3 polyurethane). A 5mm gap model was used, and fixed with a 12 hole plate. Six different constructs were tested including 2 unlocked and 4 hybrid configurations. All screws were bicortical and placed with 4Nm of torque. Baseline removal (loosening) torque was recorded for each screw for comparison with removal torque after cyclic loading. Testing was performed with ±8Nm of torsional load and run to 100,000 cycles. Stiffness of each construct was measured at 10,000 cycle increments and the removal torque of each screw was recorded at the conclusion of the 100,000 cycles.
Results: Stiffness of the constructs was most affected by the number of screws. No effect was seen with the replacement of one or two unlocked screws with locked screws on each side of the gap. Replacement of three unlocked screws with locked screws increased the stiffness of the construct (p< 0.001).
Conclusion: At least three bicortical locked screws on each side of a construct are needed to increase the stiffness and decrease the loss of stiffness over 100,000 cycles of torsional stress in an osteoporotic surrogate model. Locked screws placed between the fracture and unlocked screws protect the unlocked screws from loosening and may have some clinical utility in fatigue of the construct.
Correspondence should be addressed to Meghan Corbeil, Meetings Coordinator Email: meghan@canorth.org
