Abstract
Background & Objectives: Statins have been shown to stimulate bone formation in vivo and in vitro in rodent models1 generating interest in the possibility that they may be useful therapeutic agents for osteoporosis. The major clinical consequence of osteoporosis are fractures that occur and although there is no firm evidence, there is a perceived associated delay in fracture repair. We examined the influence of atorvastatin on fracture repair in an ovariectomised rat fracture model.
Methods: 126 Sprague-Dawley rats had an ovariectomy (OVX) at three months and a femoral fracture (F) at six months. The fracture consisted of an open osteotomy held with an external fixator. All animals were randomly assigned into groups 1. OVX+F and early atorvastatin; 2. OVX+F and late atorvastatin; 3. OVX+F. Atorvas-tatin (5mg/kg) was given daily by oral gavage for three months in-group 1 between OVX and fracture and from time of fracture to sacrifice in-group 2. Outcome measures were histology, peripheral quantitative computed tomography (pQCT), biomechanical strength testing (BST) and digital radiography. Digital radiographs were taken at time of OVX, fracture (confirming satisfactory reduction) and sacrifice from which relative bone density (BMD) measurements were calculated.
Results: Non-statin treated animals moved significantly more in 4 days post-fracture (p=0.015), had signifi-cantly more relative (p=0.037) and total BMD (distal femur) than statin treated (p=0.040, early and p=0.036, late treatment). Total BMD at the fracture site was also significantly greater in the OVX+F than the late statin group (p=0.047) while in the adjacent site of the con-tralateral limb, the early statin group had significantly more (p=0.018) than the late statin group. However no differences were found between the early statin and OVX+F groups. Histologically, the rate of repair increased significantly in early statin (p=0.013) and OVX+F (p=0.011) groups. BST data showed no signifi-cant difference in stiffness at six or eight weeks.
Conclusion: Fractures healed in all three groups. Statins did not prevent OVX induced bone loss. Initial evidence suggests that early statin treatment may have a positive effect on early fracture, as shown by x-ray analysis and histology, however this effect was lost by week 8. Overall the evidence suggests that atorvastatin may have impaired fracture repair, particularly with late administration (relative BMD and pQCT results).
Correspondence should be addressed to Mr Carlos Wigderowitz, Senior Lecturer, University Department of Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgery, Ninewells Hospital and Medical School, Dundee DD1 9SY.
