Abstract
Introduction: It is common practice to use additional antibiotics in bone cement for revision hip surgery. Ideally antibiotic elution would initially be rapid and then reduce to zero in order to reduce the risk of antibiotic resistance developing. There is evidence that the addition of antibiotics to bone cement leads to deterioration in mechanical properties. We have carried out a study to see if the addition of vancomycin to Palacos R40G and Smartset GHV affects their in-vitro antibiotic elution and mechanical properties.
Methods: Palacos R40G (contains 0.5g gentamycin per 40g mix) and Smartset GHV (contains 1g gentamycin per 40g mix) were used. 40g samples of the two cements with no additional vancomycin, 1g and 2g vancomycin were prepared by a standard method using vacuum mixing in a syringe. Antibiotic elution over a five week period was measured using an immunoassay method. Standard mechanical testing was carried out according to methods defined in ISO 5833.
Results: Smartset GHV eluted double the quantity of gentamycin as Palacos R40G, as would be expected. Both cements eluted more gentamycin when vancomycin was added. Smartset appears to elute more vancomycin than Palacos initially and then shows a more rapid tailing off. The mechanical properties of the two cements were the same with no statistical differences found between them. Both showed deterioration in flexural strength with addition of increasing vancomycin.
Discussion: Smartset may have improved qualities of antibiotic elution as compared with Palacos with similar mechanical properties. The presence of higher initial quantities of gentamycin does not lead to reduced mechanical properties.
Correspondence should be addressed to The Secretary, BHS, c/o BOA, The Royal College of Surgeons, 35–43 Lincoln’s Inn Fields, London WC2A 3PE.
