Abstract
Purpose: In 1996, we reported the results of 65 coracoid blocks for chronic anterior instability. We found 6% true recurrence and 34% persistent apprhension. In order to improve these results, we modified our operative technique, associating capsuloplasty in the event of hyperlaxity. The purpose of the present work was to assess mid-term results.
Material and methods: Eighty-eight coracoid blocks were performed between 1995 and 2000 by the same operator. In 41 cases, the classical technique was used. In 47 cases we associated capsuloplasty. The indication for surgery was documented recurrent instability in all cases, with radiographic, MRI or endoscopic confirmation of an anteroinferior capusloligament lesion. Capsuloplasty was associated if signs suggested hyperlaxity: self-reducing dislocation, absence of notch, external rotation arm to body (RE1) greater than 80°, presence of a significant groove, laxity of the inferior flap of a T capsulotomy. Mean patient age was 24 years (14–42) and mean follow-up was 40 months (24–60). Clinical results were assessed with the Duplay criteria and three x-rays were obtained (standard AP, Lamy lateral view and glenoid lateral view).
Results: Eighty-five percent of the patients achieved a good or very good result according to the Duplay criteria. Eighty-eight percent of the blocks held without modification and 12% developed osteolysis. There were no cases of degeneration. One patient experienced recurrent dislocaion. The rate of persistent apprehension declined (12%) compared with our earlier experience. This improvement was achieved at the cost of greater loss of RE1 in the group with capsuloplasty (−20° versus −8°), but without impact on sports activity (82£% returned to their sports activities including 72% at the same level without significant difference between the groups with and without capsulotomy).
Discussion: These results demonstrate that capsuloplasty is warranted if there are signs of hyperlaxity. This technique allowed us to improve results concerning recurrence and persistent apprehension at the cost of less mobility but without effect on sports activities. We detail the objective criteria used to define hyperlaxity and describe the usual clinical expression of radiographic, arthroscopic, and arthroscopic findings.
The abstracts were prepared by Docteur Jean Barthas. Correspondence should be addressed to him at Secrétariat de la Société S.O.F.C.O.T., 56 rue Boissonade, 75014 Paris.
