header advert
Orthopaedic Proceedings Logo

Receive monthly Table of Contents alerts from Orthopaedic Proceedings

Comprehensive article alerts can be set up and managed through your account settings

View my account settings

Visit Orthopaedic Proceedings at:

Loading...

Loading...

Volume 98-B, Issue SUPP_18 November 2016 Scottish Committee for Orthopaedics and Trauma (SCOT) September 2016

Competition ratios for Core Surgical Training (CST) and Higher Specialist Training in Trauma & Orthopaedic (T&O) surgery have decreased over the last 5 years. Whilst multifactorial, one reason thought to contribute to career decision- making, is junior doctors' experience whilst working in that specialty. This study aimed to identify ‘who’ is currently working on the “1st on call” tier in T&O in the UK, and what clinical activities are undertaken.

Collaborators were recruited between 12/09/2015 – 17/01/2016 via the BOTA networks. Data was prospectively collected between 18/01/2015 and 22/01/2015. Each collaborator completed a coded clinical activity diary for all doctors on the “1st on call” rota for T&O in their hospital. Activity parameters included doctor grade, rota gaps, operative and clinic exposure, on call activity, and ward cover.

221 collaborators submitted clinical activity data regarding 933 junior doctors from 100 T&O departments in the UK. 30 rota gaps were identified. The mean number of junior tier doctors was 9 (range 1–23). The “Lost Tribe” comprised Foundation Year 2 (26%), Core Surgical Trainee (19%), Trust Grade (20%), and locum doctors (13%), amongst other grades. During the study period, 2.5% of the ‘Lost Tribe’s' time was allocated to clinic, 2.7% to theatre, 27% to ward cover and 34.6% to zero sessions.

Doctors-in-training make up a minority of the workforce and as such, the T&O profession need to do more to ensure that junior doctors are exposed to clinics and operative lists to specifically address the balance between training and service delivery.


S. Downie D. Adamson A. Jariwala

There is comprehensive data addressing the 6 to 18-month survival in patients with pathological neck of femur (NOF) fractures due to bony metastases. However, little is known about early mortality in this group. The aim was to quantify 30 and 90-day mortality in patients with pathological NOF lesions/fractures and identify biochemical markers associated with early death.

Orthopaedic trauma lists over one year were used to identify patients with a pathological NOF fracture/lesion.

33 patients had a metastatic NOF fracture/lesion and were compared to a control group of age and gender-matched non-pathological NOF fractures. Time from referral to surgery was higher in patients with a pathological fracture compared to a pathological lesion (average 7.4 and 0.6 days, p<0.05). 30 and 90-day mortality was higher in the metastatic group compared to controls (15% 5/33 vs 9% 3/33 p<0.05, and 42% 14/33 vs 12% 4/33 p<0.01, respectively).

Patients with early mortality had lower average sodium (135 vs 138, p<0.05), creatinine (48 vs 62, p<0.05) and APTT (27 vs 32, p<0.05). They had a higher average WCC (11.3 vs 7, p<0.05) and CRP (55 vs 18, p<0.01). Metastatic patients with early mortality had lower albumin (20 vs 30, p<0.01) and haemoglobin (102 vs 121, p<0.01), which were higher in the control NOF group with early mortality (albumin 28 and haemoglobin 118 respectively, p<0.05).

Patients with pathological NOF lesions have multiple biochemical abnormalities associated with early mortality. A prospective study is proposed to assess whether correction of these abnormalities can improve survival in this group.


N.D. Clement S.S. Muschik J.N.A. Gibson

There is limited long term evidence to support instrumented fusion as an adjunct to decompression for foraminal stenosis in the presence of single level degenerative disc disease.

We report the long term outcome of a prospective randomised controlled trial. Forty-four patients with single-level disc disease were randomly assigned to three groups (spinal decompression (Group 1), decompression and instrumented posterolateral fusion (Group 2), or decompression and instrumented posterolateral fusion plus transforaminal interbody fusion (Group 3). Spinal disability (Dallas, Roland Morris, and Lower Back Outcome Score [LBOS]), and quality of life (EuroQol (EQ) and short form (SF-) 36 questionnaires) were assessed before and at after surgery by independent researchers.

At mean of 15 years follow up 33 (75%) patients were available for assessment. All groups observed a significant improvement in the EQ-5D at final follow up. Group 1 demonstrated significantly better functional outcome at final follow up according to the Dallas, Roland Morris, LBOS, and EQ-5D (3L and VAS) scores when compared to the other two groups (p<0.01). The SF-36 score demonstrated that group 1 had significantly better generic health scores compared to groups 2 and 3. Regression analysis was used to adjust for the differences in general health between the groups and demonstrated no significant difference between the groups in the spine specific scores: Dallas (p>0.15), Roland Morris (p>0.37), or the LBOS (p>0.32).

Fusion in combination with decompression for the treatment of foraminal stenosis and single level degenerative disc disease offers no long term functional benefit over decompression in isolation.


L.A. Robiati K.E. Bugler T.O. White J.T Reid

Soft tissue Intravenous drug abuse is known to be associated with significant health problems including soft tissue infections. Our department observed a concerning increase in the level of admissions of drug users presenting with severe soft tissue infections after injecting “Legal Highs”. These findings contributed to the body of evidence which led to the introduction of a Temporary Banning Order on these agents in Scotland in April 2015. The aim of this study was to investigate the effectiveness of banning orders on reducing patients presenting with soft tissue infections associated with intravenous drug abuse.

All admissions to the Orthopaedic trauma unit with soft tissue infections over three six-month periods in 2013, 2014 and 2015 were investigated. Those associated with intravenous drug usage were identified. Cases were reviewed to assess patient demographics, co-morbidities, infection characteristics and management.

There was a three-fold increase in hospital admissions for soft tissue infections resulting from intravenous drug use between 2013 and 2014. In 2013, 9.1% of admissions were related to use of “Legal Highs”, whilst in 2014 this had increased to 68.8%. After April 2015 there was a 28% reduction in admissions of intravenous drug use related soft tissue infections with “Legal High” associated admissions reduced to 39%.

“Legal Highs” were responsible for the dramatic increase in admissions associated with soft tissue infections resulting from intravenous drug abuse seen between 2013 and 2014. Introduction of Temporary Banning Orders for “Legal Highs” in April 2015 has been instrumental in reducing these admissions.


T. Mcmillan D. Neilly T. Gardner D. Cairns K. Kumar S. Barker

Lateral Epicondylitis is a common condition caused by angiofibroblastic hyperplasia of the tendinous insertion. Its treatment is varied and includes rest, physiotherapy, corticosteroid injection and surgical release. Of late, the role of Platelet Rich Plasma (PRP) injections have been explored, with positive results.

We prospectively assessed the outcomes of lateral epicondylitis treated with PRP injections and compared the outcomes of ultrasound guided and ‘blind’ injection.

This was a single centre prospective cohort study. Patient were assessed with the Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand (DASH) Score. PRP was injected into and around the common extensor origin either with or without ultrasound guidance. The primary outcome measure was DASH score at 3 months.

45 (23F:22M) patients were recruited. The mean age was 50 years (range 35 to 79). The mean duration of follow-up was 106 days. The average pre-injection DASH score for both groups combined was 45.5 (11.7–87.5). The mean DASH score at 3 months follow-up was 27.7. The ultrasound guided injection group had a mean improvement in DASH score from 45.5 to 31.2. The “blind” injection group had a mean improvement in DASH from 44.4 to 27.7. No complications were noted. There was no statistically significant difference in improvement in DASH score between the two groups.

Our study provides further evidence to support of the use of PRP injections in the treatment of epicondylitis of the elbow. Interestingly, however, we found that the use of Ultrasound guidance does not appear to improve patient outcomes.


J.W. Lim N.L. Foster D. Ridley L.R. Johnston B.A. Clift

The use of Birmingham hip resurfacing (BHR) remains controversial due to the increased revision rate in female patients. We compared the outcomes of BHR in female patients to an age matched total hip arthroplasty(THA) cohort. We reviewed the pain, function and total Harris Hip Scores(HHS), and Kaplan-Meir survivorship for BHR and THA cohorts from a prospective regional arthroplasty database.

There were 234 patients in each cohort, with mean age of 51 years. The BHR cohort had significantly better function and total HHS at all points of the 5-year study, but not for the post-operative pain score. The 5-year revision rate for the BHR cohort was significantly higher than the THA cohort (6.8% vs 3.4%, p=0.001). The main reason for revision in the BHR cohort was aseptic loosening (n=8), followed by metallosis (n=3). The 5-year Kaplan-Meier survivorship was 92.6% (95% CI±1.7%) and 96.4% (95% CI±1.3%) for the BHR and THA cohort (p=0.001).

BHR can give significantly better functional outcomes than THA. The vast majority of female patients were happy with BHR and did not need further surgery at the 5-year stage. This is somewhat at odds with the recent reputation of the procedure. The 10-year result of the same cohort is warranted to provide further data. Our study is not a recommendation to still offer BHR to female patients, but rather to inject a note of realism into the debate. There are implications for future implant development in that these results do validate resurfacing as a functionally valuable option for active patients.


I.R. Murray Z. Gonzalez J. Baily J. Iredale H. Simpson B. Peault N.C. Henderson

Scar tissue formation secondary to acute muscle injury, surgical wounding and compartment syndrome can result in significant functional impairment and predispose to further injury. The source of fibroblasts, and the molecular mechanisms driving their activation and persistence in skeletal muscle fibrosis are not known. We hypothesized that cells expressing PDGFRβ become fibroblasts in response to injury and that targeting αv integrins in these cells reduces skeletal muscle fibrosis.

We used double-fluorescent reporter mice to demonstrate that cells expressing PDGFRβ become activated myofibroblasts in response to cardiotoxin (CTX) induced skeletal muscle injury. Following injury, PDGFRβ+ cells moved from perivascular locations into the interstitium in a distribution characteristic of fibroblasts, and showed marked induction of fibroblastic genes including αSMA and collagen1 (all p<0.0001). To confirm that αv integrins present on PDGFRβ cells critically regulate skeletal muscle fibrosis we used Itgavflox/flox;PDGFRβ-Cre mice (transgenic mice in which αv integrins are ‘knocked-down’ in PDGFRβ+ cells). These mice were significantly protected from CTX induced fibrosis (p<0.01). To demonstrate potential clinical utility of targeting αv integrins, we used a small molecule inhibitor of αv integrins (CWHM12). Treatment with CWHM12 significantly reduced fibrosis when delivered from the time of injury (p<0.01) and when delivered after the fibrotic response had become established (p<0.01).

We have identified a core pathway regulating fibrosis in skeletal muscle. Pharmacologic inhibition of αv integrins has potential clinical utility in the treatment and prevention of skeletal muscle fibrosis.


H.W. Sargeant P. Nunag

Tranexamic Acid (TA) has been shown to reduce transfusion rates in Total Knee Replacement (TKR) without complication. In our unit it was added to our routine enhanced recovery protocol. No other changes were made to the protocol at this time and as such we sought to examine the effects of TA on wound complication and transfusion rate.

All patients undergoing primary TKR over a 12 month period were identified. Notes and online records were reviewed to collate demographics, length of stay, use of TA, thromboprophylaxis, blood transfusion, wound complications and haemoglobin levels. All patients received a Columbus navigated TKR with a tourniquet. Only patients who received 14 days of Dalteparin for thromboprophylaxis were included.

124 patients were included, 72 receiving TA and 52 not. Mean age was 70. Four patients required a blood transfusion all of whom did not receive TA (p = 0.029). Mean change in Hb was 22 without TA and 21 with (p = 0.859). Mean length of stay was 6.83 days without Tranexamic Acid and 5.15 with (p < 0.001). 15% of patients (n=11) of the TA group had a wound complication, with 40% of patients (n=21) in the non TA group (p = 0.003). There was one ultrasound confirmed DVT (non TA group). No patients were diagnosed with pulmonary embolus.

In our unit we have demonstrated a significantly lower transfusion rate, wound complication rate and length of stay, without any significant increase in thromboembolic disease with the use of TA in TKR.


M.A.A. Khan A. Faulkner A. Macinnes L. Gwozdziewicz R. Sehgal B. Haughton A. Misra

Peri-prosthetic wound infections can complicate total knee arthroplasty (TKA) in 1–1.5% of cases and may require the input of a combined orthopaedic and plastic surgery team. Failure of optimal management can result in periprosthetic joint infection, arthrodesis or in severe cases limb amputation.

A retrospective 11-year review of TKA patients was undertaken in a single unit. Data was collected on a proforma and patient demographics were identified by case note analysis. Incidence of periprosthetic wound infections was recorded. A protocol to standardise treatment was subsequently developed following multidisciplinary input.

56 patients over 11 years developed periprosthetic wound infection. 33 patients were available for analysis. The male:female ratio 1:0.7 with a mean age of 70 years (range: 32–88 years). 5 (15%) developed superficial infections, 4 (12%) patients developed cellulitis requiring antibiotics, 14 (42%) with superficial wound dehiscence and 2 (6%) required washout of the prosthesis with long-term antibiotic therapy. 4 (12%) were managed without plastics involvement, one leading to arthrodesis and 4 (12%) had plastic surgical input, with one leading to arthrodesis. The mean time before plastic surgical review after initial suspicion of infection was 13 weeks.

The management of periprosthetic wound infections following TKA are variable and can require a multidiscplinary ortho-plastic approach. Early plastic surgical involvement in specific cases may improve outcome. Our proposed management protocol would facilitate in standardising the management of these complex patients.


C.E.H. Scott W.M. Oliver D. MacDonald F.A. Wade M. Moran S.J. Breusch

Risk of revision following total knee replacement is relatively high in patients under 55 years of age, but little is reported regarding non-revision outcomes. This study aims to identify predictors of dissatisfaction following TKR in patients younger than 55 years of age.

We assessed 177 TKRs (157 consecutive patients) from 2008 to 2013. Data was collected on age, sex, implant, indication, BMI, social deprivation, range of motion, and prior knee surgery in addition to Oxford Knee Score (OKS) and SF-12 score. Postoperative data included knee range of motion, complications, and OKS, SF-12 score and satisfaction measures at one year.

Overall, 24.9% of patients (44/177) were unsure or dissatisfied with their TKR. Significant predictors of dissatisfaction on univariable analysis (p<0.05) included: Kellgren-Lawrence grade 1/2 osteoarthritis; indication; poor preoperative OKS; postoperative complications; and poor improvements in OKS and pain component score (PCS) of the SF-12. Odds ratios for dissatisfaction by indication compared to primary OA: OA with previous meniscectomy 2.86; OA in multiply operated knee 2.94; OA with other knee surgery 1.7; OA with BMI>40kgm-2 2; OA post-fracture 3.3; and inflammatory arthropathy 0.23. Multivariable analysis showed poor preoperative OKS, poor improvement in OKS and postoperative stiffness, particularly flexion of <90°, independently predicted dissatisfaction (p<0.005).

Patients coming to TKR when under 55 years of age differ from the ‘average’ arthroplasty population, often having complex knee histories and indications for surgery, and an elevated risk of dissatisfaction.