Advertisement for orthosearch.org.uk
Orthopaedic Proceedings Logo

Receive monthly Table of Contents alerts from Orthopaedic Proceedings

Comprehensive article alerts can be set up and managed through your account settings

View my account settings

Visit Orthopaedic Proceedings at:

Loading...

Loading...

Volume 94-B, Issue SUPP_V March 2012 Crieff, Scotland, 22 January 2010

ND Clement D MacDonald CH Howie LC Biant

There is limited literature regarding the outcome of hip and knee arthroplasty (THR and TKR) in the Super-Elderly (≥80yrs). The aim is to compare the outcome of THR and TKR in the Super-Elderly with a standard-age cohort of patients. From January 2006 to August 2008; 1290 TKR and 1344 THR were performed at the study institute. Comorbidity, length of stay, patient satisfaction, Oxford knee or hip scores, and SF12 scores were recorded prospectively. The Oxford Score and SF12 were recorded at one year. The mode age range was 65-74yrs for TKR (n=492) and THR (n=495), deemed the standard cohort. 185 TKR and 171 THR were performed in the Super-Elderly. Outcome in this cohort was compared to the standard.

The standard cohort had a greater absolute improvement in Oxford knee scores (15.8 and 14.7.p=0.2). Improvement of absolute Oxford hip scores revealed no difference (20.0 and 20.2.p=0.8), but the Super-Elderly had a greater improvement in pain components (11.0 vs.12.0.p=0.05) with a lesser improvement of the functional components (9.0.vs.8.2.p=0.05). There was a greater improvement in the physical component of the SF-12 score in the standard cohort for both TKR and THR (10.6.vs.7.9.p=0.05 and 14.4.vs.10.4.p=<0.01, respectively).

No significant difference was seen in comorbidities, but the Super-Elderly patients had a longer hospital stay for TKR (6.2.vs.8.3.p=0.01) and THR (5.9.vs.9.0.p=0.01).

The Super-Elderly were more satisfied with their surgery (p=0.05).

Super-Elderly patients have comparable outcomes to their younger counterparts and are more satisfied with their surgery, but they may require a longer length of stay.


SS Jameson S Gupta A Lamb L Sher WA Wallace MR Reed

From August 2009, all doctors were subject to the European Working Time Directive (EWTD) restrictions of 48 hours of work per week. Changes to rota patterns have been introduced over the last two years to accommodate for these impending changes, sacrificing ‘normal working hours’ training opportunities for out-of-hours service provision. We have analysed the elogbook data to establish whether operative experience has been affected.

A survey of trainees (ST3-8) was performed in February 2009 to establish shift patterns in units around the UK. All operative data entered into the elogbook during 2008 at these units was analysed according to type of shift (24hr on call with normal work the following day, 24hr on call then off next working day, or shifts including nights).

66% of units relied on traditional 24hrs on call in February 2009. When compared with these units, trainees working shifts had 18% less operative experience (564 to 471 operations) over the six years of training, with a 51% reduction in elective experience (288 to 140 operations). In the mid years of training, between ST3-5, operative experience fell from 418 to 302 operations (25% reduction) when shifts were introduced.

This national data reflects the situation in UK hospitals in 2009, prior to the implementation of a maximum of 48 hours. It is expected that most hospitals will need to convert to shift-type working patterns to fall within the law. This could have significant implications for elective orthopaedic training in the UK.


Paul J Jenkins Kar Teoh Philip M Simpson Jayshree Dave AHWR Simpson Steffen Breusch

Clostridium difficile is associated with a range of gastrointestinal disorders ranging from diarrhoea to toxic megacolon. Alteration of the normal gut flora by antibiotics is a key predisposing factor. Although antibiotic prophylaxis is routinely administered during joint replacement surgery, there has been controversy about both type and duration of prophylaxis. The primary aim of this study was to determine the incidence of C. diff associated disease (CDAD) following hip and knee replacement and to investigate potential risk factors.

A laboratory database was interrogated to identify patients developing CDAD after hip or knee replacement from January 2006 to December 2008. A database of arthroplasty patients was used to identify a control group of patients without CDAD to compare the effects of prescription of antibiotics for reasons other prophylaxis of deep infection, comorbidity and the use of gastroprotective agents.

Eight patients developed CDAD. There were 1.7 cases of CDAD per 1000 joint replacements. Patients developing CDAD were more likely to have been prescribed additional antibiotics (p=0.047). There were no differences in the use of gastroprotective agents (p=0.703). A trial of a new prophylaxis regime would require 43,198 patients in each arm to show a reduction to 1 case per 1000 procedures.

Cefuroxime based antibiotic prophylaxis is safe in patients undergoing elective joint replacement. Extremely large studies would be required to show marginal clinical benefits of new regimes. One prophylaxis policy will not suit all orthopaedic patient groups or procedures.


SV Karuppiah M Downing RE Broadbent M Christie CA Carnegie G Ashcroft AJ Johnstone

Due to its popularity of intramedullary nails (IMN) high success rate, newer design (titanium) IMN system have been introduced to replace stainless steel system. However the stability provided by the titanium IMN

may not be adequate, there by influencing the union rate.

We aimed to compare the results of both IMN systems via prospective clinical study and biomechanical testing using RSA.

Biomechanical study

This study was done in an experimental set-up which consisted of a physically simulated femoral shaft fractures models fixed with a stainless steel (Russell Taylor) or Titanium (Trigen) IM nailing system. Two common fracture configurations with stimulated weight bearing conditions were used and the axis of fragment movements recorded.

Clinical study

The data on two groups of patients were collected as part of a prospective cohort study. Details of the implant, such as size of nail, cross screw lengths, screw thickness, etc. was collected. Patients were followed up for a minimum of 4 months and details of clinical complications recorded


LA Kash Khan E Will JF Keating

The aims of this study were to undertake a prospective randomised trial to compare functional outcome, and range of motion after treatment of medial collateral ligament injuries by either early unprotected mobilisation or mobilisation with a hinged brace.

Patients were randomised into either unprotected mobilisation or mobilisation with a hinged brace. Assessments occurred at 2 weeks, 6 weeks, 3 months and 6 months. Outcome measures included validated questionnaires (International Knee Documentation Committee and Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score scores), range of motion measurements and strength testing.

Eighty six patients (mean age 30.4) were recruited. There were 53 men and 33 women. The mode of injury was sport in 56 patients (65%) with football, rugby and skiing being the most common types of sport involved.

The mean time to return to full weight bearing was 3 weeks in both groups. The mean time to return to work was 4.6 weeks in the braced group and 4.1 weeks in the non-braced group (p=0.79).

Return to running was at a mean of 14.3 weeks in the braced group and 12.8 weeks in the non-braced group (p=0.64). Return to full sport was 22 weeks in the braced group and 22.1 weeks in the non-braced group (p=0.99). There was no significant difference in range of movement or pain scores between the two groups at 2,6,12 and 24 weeks.

The use of a hinged knee brace does not influence recovery after a medial collateral injury.


D Macdonald D McDonald R Siegmeth H Monaghan A Deakin N Scott A Kinninmonth

Patients undergoing total knee arthroplasty (TKA) experience significant postoperative pain. This impedes early mobilization and delays hospital discharge. A prospective audit of 1081 patients undergoing primary TKA during 2008 was completed. All patients followed a programme including preoperative patient education, pre-emptive analgesia, spinal/epidural anaesthesia with propofol sedation, intra-articular soft tissue wound infiltration, postoperative high volume ropivacaine boluses with an intra-articular catheter and early mobilization. Primary outcome measure was length of stay. Secondary outcomes were verbal analogue pain scores on movement, time to mobilization, nausea and vomiting scores, urinary catheterization for retention, need for rescue analgesia, range of motion at discharge and six weeks postoperatively. The median day of discharge was postoperative day four. Median pain score on mobilization was three for first postoperative night, day one and two. 35% of patients ambulated on the day of surgery and 95% of patients within 24 hours. 79% patients experienced no nausea or vomiting. Catheterization rate was 6.9%. Rescue analgesia was required in 5% of cases. The median day of discharge was postoperative day four. Median range of motion was 85° on discharge and 93° at six weeks postoperatively. This comprehensive care plan provides satisfactory postoperative analgesia allowing early safe ambulation and discharge.


G.H. Smith R.E. Anakwe R.J. Wallace J.E. McEachan

The suture properties associated with a successful tendon repair are: high tensile strength, little tissue response, good handling characteristics and minimal plastic deformation. Plastic deformation contributes to gap formation at a tendon repair site. Gaps greater than 4mm are prone to failing. This study investigates whether the plastic deformation demonstrated by two commonly used suture materials can be reduced by manual pre-tensioning.

Twenty sutures of both Prolene 3/0 (Ethicon, UK) and Ethibond 3/0 (Excel, Johnson and Johnson, UK) were tested. Half of the sutures in each group were manually pre-tensioned prior to knot tying and half were knotted without pre-tensioning. All knots were standard surgical knots with six throws. The suture lengths were measured before and after a standardised cyclical loading regime on an Instron tensile tester. The regime was designed to represent the finger flexion forces produced in a typical rehabilitation programme. All sutures were subsequently tested to their ultimate tensile strength.

After cyclical loading the pre-tensioned sutures demonstrated a mean increase in suture length of 0.7% (range 0.1-1.9%). The sutures not pre-tensioned showed a mean increase of 5.4% (range 3.3-7%). This equates to 87% less plastic deformation (p <0.05 Students' T-test) upon pre-tensioning. There were no differences with Ethibond. Pre-tensioning had no effect on ultimate tensile strength for either group.

Manual pre-tensioning reduces plastic deformation in Prolene 3/0 sutures without affecting the ultimate tensile strength. This simple technique could theoretically diminish gap formation at the site of a tendon repair.


JG Cowie C Thomson JC McKinley

A Morton's neuroma is a painful forefoot disorder characterised by plantar pain and toe paraesthesia. Many treatments have been tried including modification of shoe wear, injections and surgery. The results from different treatment modalities are extremely variable in the scientific literature.

We reviewed 79 patients who presented with an ultrasound proven Morton's Neuromata at an average of 60 months following treatment in a patient blind randomised trial.

35 had surgery with resection of the Morton's Neuromata. We compared the results of the patients who had had a steroid injection and surgery, a steroid injection alone, a placebo injection and then surgery and a placebo injection alone.

We looked at the requirement for further consultations, pain scores, activity restrictions, footwear restriction, overall satisfaction with their treatment and overall quality of life scores. We found no significant difference between the groups. Overall 80% of the surgical patients had a good or excellent result and 67% of the non- operatively managed patients had a good or excellent result. There was no difference in their quality of life scores.

Previous studies have shown little benefit in steroid injections in the treatment of Morton's Neuromata. We conclude at the five year mark there is no significant differences between operating on Morton's Neuromata and treating them conservatively.

Further research should focus on comparing operative vs conservative treatment in the short to medium term. In order to justify the risks and costs of surgery.


BM Sabnis ERR Dunstan JA Ballantyne IJ Brenkel

Rivaroxiban is a factor Xa inhibitor and is a newer oral alternative for thromboprophylaxis after joint replacements. Its major advantage is its oral administration and hence better patient compliance. However there are some doubts about its efficacy compared to dalteparin/heparin. We have recently changed over from using dalteparin injections to rivaroxiban tablets for thromboprophylaxis after hip replacements. We assessed our results to find efficacy and specificity of its action in patients undergoing THR.

504 patients underwent hip replacement in last 2 years. 316 were treated with dalteparin injections (fragmin) for thromboprophylaxis while 189 patients were treated with oral rivaroxiban for 35 days after their hip replacement.

Average haemoglobin drop at 24 hours postop was 2.79 in Rivaroxiban group compared to 3. 10 in dalteparin group. 19 patients (of 189 i.e. 10.05%) required postop blood transfusion in rivaroxiban group as against 60 (of 315 i.e. 19.04%) in Dalteparin group. This difference was statistically significant. Incidence of DVT was no different in either groups, but the number of patients was too small to compare this.

Rivaroxiban appears to be more specific in its action and our results suggest a significant reduction in postop blood transfusion following hip replacements without any increase in rate of Deep Vein Thrombosis. We would like to present our findings and discuss role of oral thromboprophylaxis after joint replacements.