Abstract
Introduction and Aims: Pivotal to most clubfoot management protocols is Achilles tendon lengthening or tenotomy to address hindfoot deformity. The effectiveness of Botulinum A toxin (BTX-A) in defunctioning the triceps surae muscle complex as an alternative to tenotomy was investigated.
Method: Newborns, infants and children referred for suspected clubfoot deformity to the authors’ institution from September 1, 2000 to September 17, 2003 were reviewed consecutively for inclusion in this prospective study. Patients underwent manipulation and castings (above knee casts) emulating Ponseti’s principles until hindfoot stall was encountered. In order to defunction the triceps surae muscle complex, BTX-A at 10 IU per kilogram was injected into this muscle complex. Outcome measures included surgical rate, Pirani clubfoot score, ankle dorsiflexion with knee in flexion and extension, and recurrences. Patients were divided according to age: Group I (< 30 days old) and Group II (> 30 days and < 8 month old).
Results: Fifty-one patients with 73 feet met the criteria for inclusion in the study with 29 patients in Group I and 22 in Group II. Mean age of Group I was 16 months (2.5–33 months) and average follow-up was nine months post-BTX-A injection (1 week-27 months post-injection). Mean age of Group II was 23.5 months (3.8–44.6 months) and average follow-up was 15 months post BTX-A injection (1 week–27 months post-injection). Ankle dorsiflexion in knee flexion and extension remained above 20/15 degrees, respectively, and Pirani scores below 0.5 following BTX-A injection for both groups. All but one patient (one foot) who reached the point of hindfoot stall during the protocol of manipulations and castings had successful defunctioning of the triceps surae complex using a single BTX-A injection. This one patient out of 51 (1.9% of patients and 1.3% of feet) did not respond to the protocol. Of the 50 patients who responded to the protocol, nine patients lost some degree of dorsiflexion due to non-compliance with boots and bars, with fitting problems accounting for two cases. All these patients have corrected with either a return to manipulations and casting alone (one patient), or a combination of repeated BTX-A injection and further manipulations and castings (eight patients)
Conclusion: These results are comparable to those reported in the literature using Ponseti’s method or the physical therapy method and were achieved without the need of tenotomy or more frequent manipulations. The use of BTX-A as an adjunctive therapy in the non-invasive approach of manipulation and casting in idiopathic clubfoot is an effective and safe alternative and one that may be preferable to parents.
These abstracts were prepared by Editorial Secretary, George Sikorski. Correspondence should be addressed to Australian Orthopaedic Association, Ground Floor, The William Bland Centre, 229 Macquarie Street, Sydney, NSW 2000, Australia.
At least one of the authors is receiving or has received material benefits or support from a commercial source.
