We used the MacIntosh over-the-top repair combined with a popliteal tendon plasty in 273 athletically active patients with chronic incapacitating functional instability due to anterior cruciate ligament rupture; 244 were reviewed at three to nine years after operation. We describe the technique and its results, with functional evaluation by the Tegner and Lysholm system. Excellent or good results were obtained in 71%; most of the 29% fair or poor results were due to extensive meniscal and degenerative changes. In a group of 11 patients with excellent results arthroscopic and histological findings were encouraging, showing good incorporation of the graft.

In 30 rabbits, the medial meniscus was used to replace the anterior or posterior cruciate ligament. The changes that took place were followed in histological sections, obtained both from the area of insertion into bone and from the intra-articular part of the graft. There was a gradual differentiation to chondroid tissue, with subsequent calcific deposition and no appearance of normal ligamentous tissue. The strength of the graft after 52 weeks was only one-quarter of that of the normal ligament. Our results do not justify the use of the meniscus to replace a torn cruciate ligament.

The paper reports an experimental investigation into the mechanisms whereby the joints of living animals maintain their precise contours. The normal patter of joint incongruity in the rabbit's hip having first been established, three groups of experimental animals underwent operative procedures designed to reduce the joint pressure to a level unrealistic in normal life. In one group the hip was dislocated by manipulation; in a second group the muscles around the hip joint were divided; and in a third group the hind limb was disarticulated through the knee. When the animals were killed at intervals of a few weeks after the operations the experimental hip joint showed increased congruity in all cases. It is concluded that in immature animals there is a mechanism in joints to control the modelling of their shapes towards an ideal incongruity, and that that mechanisms is pressure sensitive.