Randomised controlled trials (RCTs) that assessed
the efficacy of bracing for adolescent idiopathic scoliosis have suffered
from small sample sizes, low compliance and lack of willingness
to participate. The aim of this study was to assess the feasibility
of a comprehensive cohort study for evaluating both the efficacy
and the effectiveness of bracing in patients with adolescent idiopathic
scoliosis. Patients with curves at greater risk of progression were invited
to join a randomised controlled trial. Those who declined were given
the option to remain in the study and to choose whether they wished
to be braced or observed. Of 87 eligible patients (5 boys and 63
girls) identified over one year, 68 (78%) with mean age of 12.5
years (10 to 15) consented to participate, with a mean follow-up
of 168 weeks (0 to 290). Of these, 19 (28%) accepted randomisation.
Of those who declined randomisation, 18 (37%) chose a brace. Patients
who were more satisfied with their image were more likely to choose
bracing (Odds Ratio 4.1; 95% confidence interval 1.1 to 15.0; p = 0.035).
This comprehensive cohort study design facilitates the assessment
of both efficacy and effectiveness of bracing in patients with adolescent
idiopathic scoliosis, which is not feasible in a conventional randomised
controlled trial. Cite this article:
We report the kinematic and early clinical results
of a patient- and observer-blinded randomised controlled trial in which
CT scans were used to compare potential impingement-free range of
movement (ROM) and acetabular component cover between patients treated
with either the navigated ‘femur-first’ total hip arthroplasty (THA) method
(n = 66; male/female 29/37, mean age 62.5 years; 50 to 74) or conventional
THA (n = 69; male/female 35/34, mean age 62.9 years; 50 to 75).
The Hip Osteoarthritis Outcome Score, the Harris hip score, the
Euro-Qol-5D and the Mancuso THA patient expectations score were
assessed at six weeks, six months and one year after surgery. A
total of 48 of the patients (84%) in the navigated ‘femur-first’
group and 43 (65%) in the conventional group reached all the desirable
potential ROM boundaries without prosthetic impingement for activities
of daily living (ADL) in flexion, extension, abduction, adduction
and rotation (p = 0.016). Acetabular component cover and surface
contact with the host bone were >
87% in both groups. There was
a significant difference between the navigated and the conventional
groups’ Harris hip scores six weeks after surgery (p = 0.010). There
were no significant differences with respect to any clinical outcome
at six months and one year of follow-up. The navigated ‘femur-first’
technique improves the potential ROM for ADL without prosthetic
impingement, although there was no observed clinical difference
between the two treatment groups. Cite this article:
The February 2015 Children’s orthopaedics Roundup360 looks at: Hip dislocation in children with CTEV: two decades of experience; Population-based prevention of DDH in cerebral palsy: 20 years’ experience; Shoulder derotation in congenital plexus palsy; Back pain in the paediatric population: could MRI be the answer?; Intercondylar fracture of the humerus in children; The Dunn osteotomy in SUFE; Radiocapitellar line a myth!; Do ‘flatfooted’ children suffer?
The foot and ankle outcome score (FAOS) has been
evaluated for many conditions of the foot and ankle. We evaluated
its construct validity in 136 patients with osteoarthritis of the
ankle, its content validity in 37 patients and its responsiveness
in 39. Data were collected prospectively from the registry of patients
at our institution. All FAOS subscales were rated relevant by patients. The Pain,
Activities of Daily Living, and Quality of Life subscales showed
good correlation with the Physical Component score of the Short-Form-12v2.
All subscales except Symptoms were responsive to change after surgery. We concluded that the FAOS is a weak instrument for evaluating
osteoarthritis of the ankle. However, some of the FAOS subscales
have relative strengths that allow for its limited use while we
continue to seek other satisfactory outcome instruments. Cite this article:
Many different designs of total hip arthroplasty
(THA) with varying performance and cost are available. The identification
of those which are the most cost-effective could allow significant
cost-savings. We used an established Markov model to examine the
cost effectiveness of five frequently used categories of THA which differed
according to bearing surface and mode of fixation, using data from
the National Joint Registry for England and Wales. Kaplan–Meier
analyses of rates of revision for men and women were modelled with
parametric distributions. Costs of devices were provided by the
NHS Supply Chain and associated costs were taken from existing studies.
Lifetime costs, lifetime quality-adjusted-life-years (QALYs) and
the probability of a device being cost effective at a willingness
to pay £20 000/QALY were included in the models. The differences in QALYs between different categories of implant
were extremely small (<
0.0039 QALYs for men or women over the
patient’s lifetime) and differences in cost were also marginal (£2500
to £3000 in the same time period). As a result, the probability
of any particular device being the most cost effective was very
sensitive to small, plausible changes in quality of life estimates
and cost. Our results suggest that available evidence does not support
recommending a particular device on cost effectiveness grounds alone.
We would recommend that the choice of prosthesis should be determined
by the rate of revision, local costs and the preferences of the
surgeon and patient. Cite this article:
The Nottingham Hip Fracture Score (NHFS) was
developed to assess the risk of death following a fracture of the
hip, based on pre-operative patient characteristics. We performed
an independent validation of the NHFS, assessed the degree of geographical
variation that exists between different units within the United
Kingdom and attempted to define a NHFS level that is associated
with high risk of mortality. The NHFS was calculated retrospectively for consecutive patients
presenting with a fracture of the hip to two hospitals in England.
The observed 30-day mortality for each NHFS cohort was compared
with that predicted by the NHFS using the Hosmer–Lemeshow test.
The distribution of NHFS in the observed group was compared with
data from other hospitals in the United Kingdom. The proportion
of patients identified as high risk and the mortality within the
high risk group were assessed for groups defined using different
thresholds for the NHFS. In all 1079 hip fractures were included in the analysis, with
a mean age of 83 years (60 to 105), 284 (26%) male. Overall 30-day
mortality was 7.3%. The NHFS was a significant predictor of 30-day
mortality. Statistically significant differences in the distribution
of the NHFS were present between different units in England (p <
0.001). A NHFS ≥ 6 appears to be an appropriate cut-point to identify
patients at high risk of mortality following a fracture of the hip. Cite this article:
Fresh-frozen allograft bone is frequently used
in orthopaedic surgery. We investigated the incidence of allograft-related
infection and analysed the outcomes of recipients of bacterial culture-positive
allografts from our single-institute bone bank during bone transplantation.
The fresh-frozen allografts were harvested in a strict sterile environment
during total joint arthroplasty surgery and immediately stored in
a freezer at -78º to -68º C after packing. Between January 2007
and December 2012, 2024 patients received 2083 allografts with a
minimum of 12 months of follow-up. The overall allograft-associated
infection rate was 1.2% (24/2024). Swab cultures of 2083 allografts
taken before implantation revealed 21 (1.0%) positive findings.
The 21 recipients were given various antibiotics at the individual
orthopaedic surgeon’s discretion. At the latest follow-up, none
of these 21 recipients displayed clinical signs of infection following
treatment. Based on these findings, we conclude that an incidental positive
culture finding for allografts does not correlate with subsequent
surgical site infection. Additional prolonged post-operative antibiotic
therapy may not be necessary for recipients of fresh-frozen bone
allograft with positive culture findings. Cite this article:
The spiral blade modification of the Dynamic
Hip Screw (DHS) was designed for superior biomechanical fixation
in the osteoporotic femoral head. Our objective was to compare clinical
outcomes and in particular the incidence of loss of fixation. In a series of 197 consecutive patients over the age of 50 years
treated with DHS-blades (blades) and 242 patients treated with conventional
DHS (screw) for AO/OTA 31.A1 or A2 intertrochanteric fractures were
identified from a prospectively compiled database in a level 1 trauma
centre. Using propensity score matching, two groups comprising 177
matched patients were compiled and radiological and clinical outcomes
compared. In each group there were 66 males and 111 females. Mean
age was 83.6 (54 to 100) for the conventional DHS group and 83.8
(52 to 101) for the blade group. Loss of fixation occurred in two blades and 13 DHSs. None of
the blades had observable migration while nine DHSs had gross migration
within the femoral head before the fracture healed. There were two
versus four implant cut-outs respectively and one side plate pull-out
in the DHS group. There was no significant difference in mortality
and eventual walking ability between the groups. Multiple logistic
regression suggested that poor reduction (odds ratio (OR) 11.49,
95% confidence intervals (CI) 1.45 to 90.9, p = 0.021) and fixation
by DHS (OR 15.85, 95%CI 2.50 to 100.3, p = 0.003) were independent
predictors of loss of fixation. The spiral blade design may decrease the risk of implant migration
in the femoral head but does not reduce the incidence of cut-out
and reoperation. Reduction of the fracture is of paramount importance
since poor reduction was an independent predictor for loss of fixation
regardless of the implant being used. Cite this article:
Several studies have reported the rate of post-operative
mortality after the surgical treatment of a fracture of the hip,
but few data are available regarding the delayed morbidity. In this
prospective study, we identified 568 patients who underwent surgery
for a fracture of the hip and who were followed for one year. Multivariate
analysis was carried out to identify possible predictors of mortality
and morbidity. The 30-day, four-month and one-year rates of mortality
were 4.3%, 11.4%, and 18.8%, respectively. General complications
and pre-operative comorbidities represented the basic predictors
of mortality at any time interval (p <
0.01). In-hospital, four-month
and one-year general complications occurred in 29.4%, 18.6% and
6.7% of patients, respectively. After adjusting for confounding variables,
comorbidities and poor cognitive status determined the likelihood
of early and delayed general complications, respectively (p <
0.001). Operative delay was the main predictor of the length of
hospital stay (p <
0.001) and was directly related to in-hospital
(p = 0.017) and four-month complications (p = 0.008). Cite this article:
There have been many advances in the resuscitation
and early management of patients with severe injuries during the
last decade. These have come about as a result of the reorganisation
of civilian trauma services in countries such as Germany, Australia
and the United States, where the development of trauma systems has
allowed a concentration of expertise and research. The continuing
conflicts in the Middle East have also generated a significant increase
in expertise in the management of severe injuries, and soldiers
now survive injuries that would have been fatal in previous wars.
This military experience is being translated into civilian practice. The aim of this paper is to give orthopaedic surgeons a practical,
evidence-based guide to the current management of patients with
severe, multiple injuries. It must be emphasised that this depends
upon the expertise, experience and facilities available within the
local health-care system, and that the proposed guidelines will
inevitably have to be adapted to suit the local resources.
Like athletes, musicians are vulnerable to musculoskeletal
injuries that can be career ending or have a severe negative financial
impact. All ages are affected, with a peak incidence in the third
and fourth decades. Women are slightly more likely to be affected
than men. It is incumbent upon orthopaedic surgeons to be able to
complete a thorough physical assessment, be aware of the risk factors
associated with musculoskeletal symptoms in musicians, and have
a detailed knowledge of the specific syndromes they suffer and their
appropriate treatment. In this paper we review the common hand injuries that afflict
musicians and discuss their treatment. Cite this article:
We explore the limitations of complete reliance
on evidence-based medicine which can be diminished by confounding
issues and sampling bias. Other strategies which may be reasonably
invoked are discussed. Cite this article:
There are significant differences in the methods and styles of orthopaedic surgical training between continents, all with the aim to produce competent consultant surgeons, but the differences in training content and pathway are vast. We review and contrast the key differences between three continents.
The reported prevalence of an asymptomatic slip
of the contralateral hip in patients operated on for unilateral slipped
capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE) is as high as 40%. Based on a population-based
cohort of 2072 healthy adolescents (58% women) we report on radiological
and clinical findings suggestive of a possible previous SCFE. Common
threshold values for Southwick’s lateral head–shaft angle (≥ 13°)
and Murray’s tilt index (≥ 1.35) were used. New reference intervals
for these measurements at skeletal maturity are also presented. At follow-up the mean age of the patients was 18.6 years (17.2
to 20.1). All answered two questionnaires, had a clinical examination
and two hip radiographs. There was an association between a high head–shaft angle and
clinical findings associated with SCFE, such as reduced internal
rotation and increased external rotation. Also, 6.6% of the cohort
had Southwick’s lateral head–shaft angle ≥ 13°, suggestive of a
possible slip. Murray’s tilt index ≥ 1.35 was demonstrated in 13.1%
of the cohort, predominantly in men, in whom this finding was associated
with other radiological findings such as pistol-grip deformity or
focal prominence of the femoral neck, but no clinical findings suggestive
of SCFE. This study indicates that 6.6% of young adults have radiological
findings consistent with a prior SCFE, which seems to be more common
than previously reported. Cite this article:
We report the five year outcomes of a two-stage
approach for infected total hip replacement. This is a single-surgeon
experience at a tertiary centre where the more straightforward cases
are treated using single-stage exchange. This study highlights the
vital role of the multidisciplinary team in managing these cases. A total of 125 patients (51 male, 74 female) with a mean age
of 68 years (42 to 78) were reviewed prospectively. Functional status
was assessed using the Harris hip score (HHS). The mean HHS improved
from 38 (6 to 78.5) pre-operatively to 81.2 (33 to 98) post-operatively.
Staphylococcus species were isolated in 85 patients (68%). The rate of control of infection was 96% at five years. In all,
19 patients died during the period of the study. This represented
a one year mortality of 0.8% and an overall mortality of 15.2% at
five years. No patients were lost to follow-up. We report excellent control of infection in a series of complex
patients and infections using a two-stage revision protocol supported
by a multidisciplinary approach. The reason for the high rate of
mortality in these patients is not known. Cite this article:
We retrospectively reviewed 89 consecutive patients
(45 men and 44 women) with a mean age at the time of injury of 58
years (18 to 97) who had undergone external fixation after sustaining
a unilateral fracture of the distal humerus. Our objectives were
to determine the incidence of heterotopic ossification (HO); identify
risk factors associated with the development of HO; and characterise
the location, severity and resultant functional impairment attributable
to the presence of HO. HO was identified in 37 elbows (42%), mostly around the humerus
and along the course of the medial collateral ligament. HO was hazy
immature in five elbows (13.5%), mature discrete in 20 (54%), extensive
mature in 10 (27%), and complete bone bridges were present in two
elbows (5.5%). Mild functional impairment occurred in eight patients,
moderate in 27 and severe in two. HO was associated with less extension
(p = 0.032) and less overall flexion-to-extension movement (p =
0.022); the flexion-to-extension arc was <
100º in 21 elbows
(57%) with HO compared with 18 elbows (35%) without HO (p = 0.03).
HO was removed surgically in seven elbows. The development of HO was significantly associated with sustaining
a head injury (p = 0.015), delayed internal fixation (p = 0.027),
the method of fracture fixation (p = 0.039) and the use of bone
graft or substitute (p = 0.02).HO continues to be a substantial
complication after internal fixation for distal humerus fractures. Cite this article:
The October 2014 Trauma Roundup360 looks at: proximal humeral fractures in children; quadrilateral surface plates in transverse acetabular fractures; sleep deprivation and poor outcomes in trauma; bipolar hemiarthroplasty; skeletal traction; forefoot fractures; telemedicine in trauma; ketamine infusion for orthopaedic injuries; and improved functional outcomes seen with trauma networks.
A delay in establishing the diagnosis of an occult
fracture of the hip that remains unrecognised after plain radiography
can result in more complex treatment such as an arthroplasty being
required. This might be avoided by earlier diagnosis using MRI.
The aim of this study was to investigate the best MR imaging sequence
for diagnosing such fractures. From a consecutive cohort of 771
patients admitted between 2003 and 2011 with a clinically suspected
fracture of the hip, we retrospectively reviewed the MRI scans of
the 35 patients who had no evidence of a fracture on their plain
radiographs. In eight of these patients MR scanning excluded a fracture
but the remaining 27 patients had an abnormal scan: one with a fracture
of the pubic ramus, and in the other 26 a T1-weighted
coronal MRI showed a hip fracture with 100% sensitivity. T2-weighted
imaging was undertaken in 25 patients, in whom the diagnosis could
not be established with this scanning sequence alone, giving a sensitivity
of 84.0% for T2-weighted imaging. If there is a clinical suspicion of a hip fracture with normal
radiographs, T1-weighted coronal MRI is the best sequence
of images for identifying a fracture.
An atypical femoral fracture (AFF), with a transverse
fracture radiologically through the lateral cortex is a rare but serious
condition. In order to improve our ability to identify patients
with this condition, we retrospectively surveyed all subtrochanteric,
peri-implant and diaphyseal femoral fractures in patients aged ≥ 65
years who underwent surgical treatment at our hospital between 2004
and 2011. We describe the incidence of atypical fractures and their characteristics,
with observational data including a review of the hospital and general
practitioner records. Clinical outcomes were evaluated using the
Harris hip score (HHS) and the timed up-and-go (TUG) test. Atypical fractures only occurred in women with an incidence of
9.8 per 100 000 person-years. The incidence in those who were treated
with bisphosphonates was 79.0 per 100 000 person-years; eight of
17 fractures occurred around metal implants. There was a high incidence
of delayed union and revision surgery. A total of nine patients (ten
AFFs) were available for review at a mean follow-up of 36.5 months
(10 to 104). The clinical outcome was poor with a mean HHS of 58.9
(95% CI 47.4 to 70.4) and a mean TUG test of 25.7 s (95% CI 12.7
to 38.8). The delay in diagnosis and treatment of AFF may result from a
lack of knowledge of this condition. Cite this article:
