We report 60 benign bone tumours treated by resection and curettage followed by the implantation of calcium hydroxyapatite ceramic (CHA). After follow-up of six to 60 months (average 36), no patient had local recurrence of the tumour or any adverse effects from the implants. In almost all cases radiography showed that the CHA was well-incorporated into the host bone, with new bone formation in and around the CHA. Corrective remodelling of deformed bone and normal fracture healing suggested that there was normal bone turnover in the presence of the CHA. Histology of biopsies from seven patients showed bone ingrowth into the pore structure of CHA in the central zone of some defects by one year after implantation. CHA appears to be a useful substitute for bone graft in the treatment of some benign tumours

We have reviewed 13 operations on 11 patients using curettage and polymethylmethacrylate cement for giant-cell tumour of bone (GCT) to assess the value of radiology in the early detection of recurrence. There were four recurrences, the most specific radiological sign on plain radiography was lysis of 5 mm or more at the cement-bone interface. This preceded clinical signs by a mean of four months and was identified at a mean of 3.75 months after operation. There was not always a complete sclerotic margin around the cement, but when it was present, there was never evidence of recurrence. MRI was helpful in assessing cases with evidence of recurrence. Frequent surveillance with plain radiography should continue for one year after operation irrespective of clinical signs of recurrence. When the appearance of the plain radiographs suggests recurrence, MRI should be performed and followed by image-guided needle biopsy

Aims

The purpose of this study was to clarify the clinical behaviour, prognosis, and optimum treatment of dedifferentiated low-grade osteosarcoma (DLOS) diagnosed based on molecular pathology.

Thirty-nine patients underwent reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament with carbon-fibre and a MacIntosh repair; all had a negative pivot shift test after operation. Some patients had persistent pain, mild effusion and synovial thickening; in 10 of these patients the symptoms warranted arthroscopic examination and biopsy at a mean of 16.9 months after the repair. Arthroscopy revealed that the carbon-fibre had not induced the formation of a "new ligament" and that the repair was merely covered by a thin, fibrous sheath. Histological investigations confirmed this finding, with only a suggestion of a fibroblastic response to carbon-fibre found in two patients. Particles of carbon-fibre were found scattered through the knees. Synovitis and breakdown of the skin over subcutaneous carbon-fibre complicated treatment. Failure of the carbon-fibre to bond to bone was detected radiographically

We treated 13 children with histologically confirmed cystic tuberculosis of bone. Ten had solitary cystic lesions and three had the multicystic form. Signs and symptoms were related mainly to the joint adjacent to the cyst. Most lesions were in the metaphyses of long bones. They were radiolucent, round or oval, and resembled pyogenic infections, aneurysmal and simple bone cysts, cartilaginous tumours or osteoid osteoma. Only two of the children had pulmonary tuberculosis. The Mantoux skin test was negative in four children and the ESR was normal in five. Curettage followed by anti-tuberculosis therapy for one year resulted in good healing, but two children had residual joint contractures. Biopsy should be taken from the cystic area rather than from the synovium when a joint is involved

The cost of clinical negligence in the UK has continued to rise despite no increase in claims numbers from 2016 to 2019. In the US, medical malpractice claim rates have fallen each year since 2001 and the payout rate has stabilized. In Germany, malpractice claim rates for spinal surgery fell yearly from 2012 to 2017, despite the number of spinal operations increasing. In Australia, public healthcare claim rates were largely static from 2008 to 2013, but private claims rose marginally. The cost of claims rose during the period. UK and Australian trends are therefore out of alignment with other international comparisons. Many of the claims in orthopaedics occur as a result of “failure to warn”, i.e. lack of adequately documented and appropriate consent. The UK and USA have similar rates (26% and 24% respectively), but in Germany the rate is 14% and in Australia only 2%. This paper considers the drivers for the increased cost of clinical negligence claims in the UK compared to the USA, Germany and Australia, from a spinal and orthopaedic point of view, with a focus on “failure to warn” and lack of compliance with the principles established in February 2015 in the Supreme Court in the case of Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board. The article provides a description of the prevailing medicolegal situation in the UK and also calculates, from publicly available data, the cost to the public purse of the failure to comply with the principles established. It shows that compliance with the Montgomery principles would have an immediate and lasting positive impact on the sums paid by NHS Resolution to settle negligence cases in a way that has already been established in the USA.

Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2020;102-B(5):550–555.

The healing of anterior cruciate ligaments reconstructed with the Leeds-Keio artificial ligament was observed by arthroscopy in 42 knees and biopsy in 19 knees at intervals from 3 to 24 months after implantation. By three months the implant was covered with immature new tissue, and a dense vascular network crossed its surface. At 12 months a new ligament had developed and matured, looking like the natural one in most cases. Histology at this stage showed abundant collagenous fibres running parallel and longitudinally, while the synovial membrane showed no more than very slight inflammatory changes. By 18 to 24 months, the new ligament often had the arthroscopic appearance of a normal anterior cruciate ligament. These results suggest that this scaffold type of artificial ligament is effective for cruciate reconstruction, giving satisfactory healing without significant complications

Six patients are described with idiopathic osteoporosis which began between the ages of 4 and 16 years. In four children the disorder was mild with pain in the back, vertebral collapse, qualitatively normal iliac bone biopsies, variable calcium balance and spontaneous recovery. The two remaining patients had progressive bone disease with deformity. One with a previously normal skeleton developed changes similar to those of osteogenesis imperfecta; in the other patient, who rapidly developed structural collapse associated with severe metaphysial osteoporosis, treatment was ineffective and the histological appearances of the bone suggested osteoblastic failure. Quantitative bone histology in four patients showed no evidence of excessive active resorption; and the ratio of Type III to Type I collagen in the skin was normal, in contrast to the findings in osteogenesis imperfecta. The significance of this study in relation to previous accounts is reviewed

It has been shown that in the puppy, two infarcts separated by an interval of four weeks produce a disorder of long duration which results in flattening and broadening of the femoral head and which reproduces the radiological changes seen in Perthes' disease in man. The histological appearances produced by two infarcts are characteristic. In this study the histological appearance of fifty-seven femoral head biopsy specimens in Perthes' disease in man have been studied. In 51 per cent of hips histopathological changes characteristic of double infarction were present, and there were grounds for postulating that double infarction might eventually occur in all cases. The findings support the concept that the deformation of the femoral head and the chronicity of Perthes' disease in man may be due at least as much or even more to repeated episodes of infarction and the ensuing abnormalities of growth as to mechanical factors related to weight-bearing

A case of the Jansen type of metaphysial dysostosis, followed for fifteen years from childhood to the age of nineteen, is reported. Radiographs taken at five years revealed the characteristic metaphysial changes in all the tubular bones, especially those of the hands and feet. The acetabular and glenoid areas, the costochondral junctions and the sternal ends of the clavicles were also involved. Radiographs taken at nineteen years, however, showed only marked deformities, which shows that the involvement of the metaphyses can regress by the end of growth. Biopsy of the lower end of radius at the age of twelve revealed changes in the growth plate or physis, especially in the zone of resting cartilage. This finding suggests that cellular function in this zone is disturbed by some unknown mechanism. Hence, the term physial dysostosis may be more accurate than metaphysial dysostosis

We studied prospectively a consecutive series of 50 patients with chronic osteomyelitis. Patients were allocated to the following treatment groups: 1) wide resection, with a clearance margin of 5 mm or more; 2) marginal resection, with a clearance margin of less than 5 mm; and 3) intralesional biopsy, with debulking of the infected area. All patients had a course of antibiotics, intravenously for six weeks followed by orally for a further six weeks. No patients in group 1 had recurrence. In patients treated by marginal resection (group 2), 8 of 29 (28%) had recurrence. All patients who had debulking had a recurrence within one year of surgery. We performed a survival analysis to determine the time of the recurrence of infection. In group 2 there was a higher rate of recurrence in type-B hosts (p < 0.05); no type-A hosts had recurrence. This information is of use in planning surgery for chronic osteomyelitis

We used MRI to examine the hips of 32 asymptomatic patients at 9 to 21 months after renal transplantation covered by high-dose corticosteroids. Five hips in three patients showed changes which indicate avascular necrosis, although radiographs, CT scans and isotope scans were normal. These patients had repeat MRI scans after another two years and three years. One patient with bilateral MRI changes developed symptoms and abnormal radiographs and CT and isotope scans in one hip nine months after the abnormal MRI. Intraosseous pressure was found to be raised in both hips, and core biopsies revealed necrotic bone on both sides. The other three hips have remained asymptomatic with unchanged MRI appearances three years after the initial MRI. It seems that idiopathic avascular necrosis does not always progress to bone collapse in the medium term

We have reviewed 22 patients from a total of 135 treated by autologous chondrocyte implantation (ACI) who had undergone further surgery for pain in the knee and mechanical symptoms after a mean of 10.5 months. There were 31 grafted lesions. At operation the findings included lifting (24/31) and detachment (3/31) of periosteal patches for which arthroscopic shaving was performed. Chondroplasty was undertaken on two new lesions, another required an ACI and a further patient required trimming of a meniscus. The mechanical symptoms resolved within two weeks. At the last review, two to 14 months from reoperation; 68% had improved, and 86% had normal or nearly normal IKDC scores. Of the 31 lesions, 30 (97%) had normal or nearly normal visual repair scores. Biopsy showed good integration with subchondral bone and the marginal interface in all specimens, most of which showed hyaline or hyaline-like cartilage (70%). Troublesome mechanical symptoms required surgery in 13% of ACI-treated patients and were attributed to periosteal extrusion. Simple arthroscopic debridement was curative

Five vascularised allografts of the knee joint were performed in dogs immunosuppressed with cyclosporin A and azathioprine. Three survived with normal function for 3 to 4 months after operation. One of the unsuccessful grafts had a failed vascular anastomosis, the other an inadequate blood level of cyclosporin A. All three successful grafts healed well. In two, bone scans, radiographs and biopsies were indistinguishable from successful autografts; in the third the blood supply to the graft failed despite patent anastomoses but the graft healed well with good function. All three grafts were rejected within 2 to 3 weeks of withdrawal of cyclosporin A and azathioprine. In non-immunosuppressed dogs, allografts of the knee, both vascularised and non-vascularised, were rejected within a few days of operation. In two non-vascularised allografts, administration of cyclosporin and azathioprine had no apparent effect on the rate of rejection of the graft

Thirty-four patients wtih fibrodysplasia (syn., myositis) ossificans progressiva are described. Marked delay in diagnosis was usual, but all had characteristic skeletal malformations and ectopic ossification. The clinical features included: four types of malformation of the big toe, reduction defects of all digits, deafness, baldness of the scalp, and mental retardation. Progression of disability was erratic in all, but severe restriction of movement of the shoulder and spine was usual by the age of 10 years; the hips were usually involved by the age of 20 years; and most patients were confined to a chair by the age of 30 years. Exacerbating factors included trauma to the muscles, biopsy of the lumps, operations to excise ectopic bone, intramuscular injections, careless venepuncture and dental therapy. Progression of disability did not appear to be influenced by any form of medical treatment and therefore management of the patients must concentrate on the avoidance of exacerbating factors

1. A patient wholly insensitive to painful stimuli as judged by psychical, physical, reflex and autonomic responses, showed multiple arthropathies. 2. Biopsy specimens of skin and periosteum from the region of the hip joint showed free nerve terminals similar in morphology to endings considered to subserve pain in normal subjects. The abnormality related to defective pain sensation therefore appears not to be due to a defect in the peripheral nerve endings for pain, but to be located more centrally in the nervous system. 3. In this patient, and in some patients with syringomyelia, arthropathy is associated with selective impairment of pain sensibility of the involved joints. It appears that tissue damage from the wear and tear of normal activity of a joint, if this damage is unheralded because of impairment of pain sense, can lead to arthropathy. 4. It is noted that further experimental evidence is still required to elucidate the role of various modalities of innervation in the maintenance of normal structure and function of joints

The systemic effects of diabetes mellitus are well recognised. The heart, kidney, central and peripheral nervous systems, and the distal parts of the limbs are often the site of end-organ damage resulting from ischaemia. Infarction of large muscle groups in the limb, not associated with gangrene, is uncommon. There have been few reported cases other than radiological descriptions of diabetic muscle infarcts. While previous reports have illustrated some of the clinical and radiological characteristics of this condition, the paucity of published cases makes it difficult to determine the most appropriate methods of diagnosis and treatment. During a five-year period we treated 14 patients with diabetes mellitus, aged from 32 to 59 years, who were referred to a musculoskeletal oncology service for suspected soft-tissue sarcoma, but were subsequently found to have a diabetic muscle infarct. Closed needle biopsy was performed in 13 without complications. In 12 patients, the symptoms resolved without surgical treatment

Discitis is uncommon in children and presents in different ways at different ages. It is most difficult to diagnose in the uncommunicative toddler of one to three years of age. We present 11 consecutive cases. The non-specific clinical features included refusal to walk (63%), back pain (27%), inability to flex the lower back (50%) and a loss of lumbar lordosis (40%). Laboratory tests were unhelpful and cultures of blood and disc tissue were negative. MRI reduces the diagnostic delay and may help to avoid the requirement for a biopsy. In 75% of cases it demonstrated a paravertebral inflammatory mass, which helped to determine the duration of the oral therapy given after initial intravenous antibiotics. At a mean follow-up of 21 months (10 to 40), all the spines were mobile and the patients free from pain. Radiological fusion occurred in 20% and was predictable after two years. At follow-up, MRI showed variable appearances: changes in the vertebral body usually resolved at 24 months and recovery of the disc was seen after 34 months

A protocol for the treatment of subacute haematogenous osteomyelitis has been used and evaluated in 71 children. A group of 26 children with a radiologically "aggressive" lesion had biopsy followed by antibiotics and immobilisation for six weeks. A group of 45 children with 48 cavities in the metaphysis or the epiphysis or both was further subdivided according to the presence or absence of clinical signs of pus at subperiosteal level or in a joint. Children with evidence of pus had operation followed by antibiotics and immobilisation while the remaining children were treated similarly but without operation. Intravenous cloxacillin or flucloxacillin and benzylpenicillin were given in hospital for 48 hours and oral antibiotics and immobilisation were then continued at home for six weeks. Staphylococcus aureus was the only pathogen cultured. In all, 91% were cured by a single course of treatment. Of the 48 metaphysial and epiphysial lesions, 77% were treated without operation; and of these, 87% were cured by a single course of treatment, this figure reaching 94% in children under 11 years old