Total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is known to lead
to a reduction in periprosthetic bone mineral density (BMD). In theory,
this may lead to migration, instability and aseptic loosening of
the prosthetic components. Bisphosphonates inhibit bone resorption
and may reduce this loss in BMD. We hypothesised that treatment
with bisphosphonates and calcium would lead to improved BMD and
clinical outcomes compared with treatment with calcium supplementation
alone following TKA. A total of 26 patients, (nine male and 17 female,
mean age 67 years) were prospectively randomised into two study
groups: alendronate and calcium (bisphosphonate group, n = 14) or calcium
only (control group, n = 12). Dual energy X-ray absorptiometry (DEXA)
measurements were performed post-operatively, and at three months,
six months, one, two, four, and seven years post-operatively. Mean femoral metaphyseal BMD was significantly higher in the
bisphosphonate group compared with controls, up to four years following
surgery in some areas of the femur (p = 0.045). BMD was observed
to increase in the lateral tibial metaphysis in the bisphosphonate
group until seven years (p = 0.002), and was significantly higher than
that observed in the control group throughout (p = 0.024). There
were no significant differences between the groups in the central
femoral metaphyseal, tibial medial metaphyseal or diaphyseal regions
of interest (ROI) of either the femur or tibia. Bisphosphonate treatment after TKA may be of benefit for patients
with poor bone quality. However, further studies with a larger number
of patients are necessary to assess whether this is clinically beneficial. Cite this article:
We compared peri-prosthetic bone mineral density between identical cemented and cementless LCS rotating platform total knee arthroplasties. Two matched cohorts had dual energy x-ray absorptiometry scans two years post-operatively using a modified validated densitometric analysis protocol, to assess peri-prosthetic bone mineral density. The knee that was not operated on was also scanned to enable the calculation of a relative bone mineral density difference. Oxford Knee and American Knee Society scores were comparable in the two cohorts. Statistical analysis revealed no significant difference in absolute, or relative peri-prosthetic bone mineral density with respect to the method of fixation. However, the femoral peri-prosthetic bone mineral density and relative bone mineral density difference were significantly decreased, irrespective of the method of fixation, particularly in the anterior distal portion of the femur, with a mean reduction in relative bone mineral density difference of 27%. There was no difference in clinical outcome between the cemented and cementless LCS total knee arthroplasty. However, both produce stress-shielding around the femoral implants. This leads us to question the use of more expensive cementless total knee components.
Clinical experience of impaction bone grafting for revision knee arthroplasty is limited, with initial stability of the tibial tray emerging as a major concern. The length of the stem and its diameter have been altered to improve stability. Our aim was to investigate the effect of the type of stem, support of the rim and graft impaction on early stability of the tray. We developed a system for impaction grafting of trays which we used with morsellised bone in artificial tibiae. Trays with short, long thick or long thin stems were implanted, with or without support of the rim. They were cyclically loaded while measuring relative movement. Long-stemmed trays migrated 4.5 times less than short-stemmed trays, regardless of diameter. Those with support migrated 2.8 times less than those without. The migration of short-stemmed trays correlated inversely with the density of the impacted groups. That of impaction-grafted tibial trays was in the range reported for uncemented primary trays. Movements of short-stemmed trays without cortical support were largest and sensitive to the degree of compaction of the graft. If support of the rim was sufficient or a long stem was used, impacted morsellised bone graft achieved adequate initial stability.
