To investigate the longevity of uncemented fixation of a femoral
component in total hip arthroplasty (THA) in patients with Dorr
type C proximal femoral morphology. A total of 350 consecutive uncemented THA in 320 patients were
performed between 1983 and 1987, by a single surgeon using the Taperloc
femoral component. The 63 patients (68 hips) with Dorr type C proximal
femoral morphology were the focus of this review. The mean age of
the patients was 69 years (24 to 88) and mean follow-up was 16.6
years (ten to 29). Survival analysis included eight patients (eight
hips) who died without undergoing revision surgery prior to obtaining
ten years follow-up. All 55 surviving patients (60 hips) were available
for clinical assessment and radiographic review. As a comparator
group, the survival and implant fixation in the remaining 282 THAs
(257 patients) with Dorr type A and B morphology were evaluated.
The mean age of these patients was 52 years (20 to 82).Aims
Patients and Methods
We reviewed 123 second-generation uncemented total hip replacements performed on 115 patients by a single surgeon between 1993 and 1994. The acetabular component used in all cases was a fully porous-coated threaded hemispheric titanium shell (T-Tap ST) with a calcium ion stearate-free, isostatically compression-moulded polyethylene liner. The titanium femoral component used was a Taperloc with a reduced distal stem. No patient was lost to follow-up. Complete clinical and radiological follow-up was obtained for all 123 hips at a mean of 14 years (12 to 16). One femoral component was revised after a fracture, and three acetabular components for aseptic loosening. No additional femoral or acetabular components were judged loose by radiological criteria. Mild proximal femoral osteolysis was identified in two hips and minor acetabular osteolysis was present in four. The mean rate of penetration of the femoral head was 0.036 mm/year (0.000 to 0.227). These findings suggest that refinements in component design may be associated with excellent long-term fixation in cementless primary total hip replacement.
We studied a consecutive series of 285 uncemented total hip replacements in 260 patients using the Taperloc femoral component and the T-Tap acetabular component. The outcome of every hip was determined in both living and deceased patients. A complete clinical and radiological follow-up was obtained for 209 hips in 188 living patients, followed for a mean of 14.5 years (10 to 18.9). They were divided into two groups, obese and non-obese, as determined by their body mass index. There were 100 total hip replacements in 89 patients in the obese cohort (body mass index ≥ 30 kg/m2), and 109 in 99 non-obese (body mass index <
30 kg/m2) patients. A subgroup analysis of 31 patients of normal weight (body mass index 20 kg/m2 to 25 kg/m2) (33 hips) and 26 morbidly obese patients (body mass index ≥ 35 kg/m2) (30 hips) was also carried out. In the obese group five femoral components (5%) were revised and one (1%) was loose by radiological criteria. Femoral cortical osteolysis was seen in eight hips (8%). The acetabular component was revised in 57 hips (57%) and a further 17 (17%) were loose. The mean Harris hip score improved from 52 (30 to 66) pre-operatively to 89 (49 to 100) at final follow-up. Peri-operative complications occurred in seven patients (7%). In the non-obese group six (6%) femoral components were revised and one (1%) was loose. Femoral cortical osteolysis occurred in six hips (6%). The acetabular component was revised in 72 hips (66%) and a further 18 (17%) were loose. The mean Harris hip score increased from 53 (25 to 73) prior to surgery to 89 (53 to 100) at the time of each patient’s final follow-up radiograph. No statistically significant difference was identified between the obese and non-obese patients with regards to clinical and radiological outcome or complications. The subgroup analysis of patients of normal weight and those who were morbidly obese showed no statistically significant difference in the rate of revision of either component. Our findings suggest there is no evidence to support withholding total hip replacement from obese patients with arthritic hips on the grounds that their outcome will be less satisfactory than those who are not obese.
We followed 138 patients (145 hips) who had had uncemented total hip arthroplasty using the Taperloc femoral component for a mean of ten years (8 to 12.5). No patient was lost to follow-up; 31 (31 hips) died before the minimum time of eight years for inclusion in the study, and 30 of these still had their femoral component in place. One well-fixed prosthesis had been exchanged at the time of acetabular revision. Of the remaining 114 hips, one femoral component required revision for aseptic loosening and one for sepsis. Three other well-fixed femoral components were removed during acetabular revision. Complete clinical and radiological follow-up was obtained in the 109 hips which had not had revision. Clinically, 94 (87%) were rated good or excellent, eight (7%) fair and seven (6%) poor. The average Harris hip score increased from 48 before operation to 88 at the time of the last follow-up. Radiologically, 103 hips (94%) had fixation by bone ingrowth, three (3%) showed stable fibrous ingrowth and three (3%) were unstable. Osteolysis of the femoral cortex was seen in seven hips (6%), with major lysis in only one. At a mean follow-up of ten years, the results of the Taperloc femoral component are comparable with those of modern techniques of cementing in primary total hip arthroplasty.
