Aims

Recently, there has been considerable interest in quantifying the associations between bony abnormalities around and in the hip joint and osteoarthritis (OA). Our aim was to investigate the relationships between acetabular undercoverage, acetabular overcoverage, and femoroacetabular impingement (FAI) with OA of the hip, which currently remain controversial.

Excessive acetabular cover secondary to a retroverted acetabulum causes pincer impingement, which may cause early osteoarthritis of the hip. Our aim was to determine if there was a relationship between acetabular version and osteoarthritis of the hip. Using image processing and analysis software we studied 117 CT images of the hip in patients aged less than 65 years who had undergone a CT virtual colonoscopy. The mean CT joint space of the 18 hips with acetabular retroversion was narrower compared with the 99 hips with normal acetabular alignment (p < 0.0001). A correlation of r = 0.46 (p < 0.01) was found between right hip acetabular version and the mean right hip joint space and of r = 0.31 (p = 0.02) between left hip acetabular version and the mean left hip joint space. Acetabular retroversion is associated with radiological evidence of osteoarthritis of the hip. An understanding of the mechanical basis of osteoarthritis of the hip allows early treatment of the underlying structural abnormality and prevents progression of the degenerative condition

1. The capsular changes in osteoarthritis of the hip and their pathogenesis are described, and it is concluded that symptoms are due mainly to this abnormality. 2. The clinical significance and pathogenesis of subchondral sclerosis, cysts, osteophytes, secondary subluxation and new bone formation on the lower border of the femoral neck are discussed. 3. These bony features which can be seen in the radiograph may, under certain circumstances, be correlated with the symptoms. 4. The influence of joint debris and capsular fibrosis upon the symptoms arising in other osteoarthritic joints is considered. 5. The mechanism by which osteoarthritis develops in hip joints with an anatomical abnormality is discussed in relation to the normal functional anatomy of the hip. 6. The evolution of osteoarthritis in dysplasia of the hip is considered with special reference to its diagnosis, prognosis and early treatment. 7. The supposition that osteoarthritis is commonly due to progressive ischaemia in the femoral head has been investigated and is rejected. 8. The cause of idiopathic osteoarthritis remains obscure but the evidence suggests that constitutional rather than local conditions in the joint account for many of these cases

The division of osteoarthritis into primary and secondary varieties implies that these are aetiologically distinct entities, the former being due to some intrinsic defect of cartilage and the latter resulting from previous articular damage. This traditional concept is questioned and the hypothesis is advanced that osteoarthritis is always secondary to some underlying abnormality of the joint. A detailed clinical, radiographic and morbid anatomical study of 327 cases of osteoarthritis of the hip is presented. In all but twenty-seven some predisposing abnormality of the joint was diagnosed: 107 (33%) were associated with major pathology such as Perthes' disease or epiphysiolysis; minor acetabular dysplasia was present in sixty-seven (20%), with a male: female ratio of 1:10; minimal femoral head tilt was demonstrated in fifty-nine (18%), the male: female ratio being 14:1; and in forty-three (13%) there were features suggesting an underlying inflammatory arthritis. On the basis of this study a new classification is proposed and osteoarthritis of the hip is divided into three pathogenetic groups: 1) failure of essentially normal cartilage subjected to abnormal or incongruous loading for long periods; 2) damaged or defective cartilage failing under normal conditions of loading; 3) break-up of articular cartilage due to defective subchondral bone

We investigated the relationship between the pain experienced by 50 patients with osteoarthritis of the hip and the resting intra-articular pressure of the synovial fluid. We found a significant linear correlation between these factors, greater pain being experienced by patients with higher pressures. In 20 cases we showed that the pressure rises in extension and medial rotation and is least in flexion and mid-abduction. These results help to explain the benefits of rotation osteotomy of the hip and of psoas release. They also help explain the natural resting position of the hip in patients with an acute effusion and the fixed deformities associated with late osteoarthritis of the hip

1. The clinical and radiological results of seventy-one osteotomies for primary osteoarthritis of the hip performed with internal fixation have been examined two to eight years after operation. Advanced cases where osteotomy would have been purely a salvage procedure were excluded. 2. The hips were divided into two groups: one in a relatively early and the other in a later intermediate stage of the disease. The two criteria for inclusion in the "early" group were a) fiexion movement of 90 degrees or more, either with the patient conscious or completely relaxed under anaesthesia, and b) no collapse of bone seen in the radiograph. 3. The clinical results show that early osteotomy seldom fails to give relief of pain, which is closely correlated with improved function and a favourable assessment of the operation by the patient. A good range of flexion, not less than 70 degrees and frequently 90 degrees, is retained when the criteria mentioned above obtain. 4. The radiological assessment was based upon examination of the joint space, the cystic appearances and the degree of collapse of bone, if any, as seen in serial films. There was convincing evidence of regression indicating arrest of the arthritic process in 70 per cent of the "early" cases. 5. Regression after osteotomy appears to be a well-defined process which is more commonly observed and more complete when the osteotomy is performed sooner rather than at a later stage of the disease. With few exceptions a good radiological result is associated with a good clinical result. 6. Some of the possible causes of failure are discussed. Osteotomy is more likely to fail if delayed till stiffness is severe and collapse of bone has begun. Large cysts, rapid advance of the disease, and a valgus osteotomy in the presence of lateral subluxation may also prejudice the results. 7. This review offers good support for Nissen's suggestion that in primary osteoarthritis of the hip osteotomy should be performed early, while the joint is still mobile and capable of repair, in order to retain good function. 8. Relief from pain is not the only consideration in deciding when to operate; the prospects of arresting the disease and of stimulating a healing reaction in the disordered cancellous bone and articular cartilage by early osteotomy should always be kept in mind. 9. In many respects the findings of this review are complementary to those of Postel and Vaillant (1962) who reported excellent results from varus osteotomy of Pauwels' type in a series of cases of subluxation of the hip with pain but without frank secondary osteoarthritic change

Conclusions based on forty-six osteotomies show this to be a sound pain-relieving operation for osteoarthritis of the hip. The field of operation has been widened and some of the disadvantages have been avoided by nail and plate fixation. Early results from this method are similar to those from osteotomy and immobilisation in plaster, and it seems likely that the relief of pain will be just as enduring

A radiological review of two groups of intertrochanteric osteotomies of the femur for primary osteoarthritis of the hip has been made. Each group originally consisted of forty-one hips. In one group a Wainwright straight V-spline without compression had been used for fixation, and In the other group an AO angled plate with compression. The time for bony union was equal in the two groups but the incidence of non-union was lower in the AO group. Regression of cysts and of bone sclerosis was more frequent in the Wainwrlght group, possibly as a consequence of the greater medial displacement and varus angulation

1 . Intertrochanteric osteotomy is valuable in the treatment of patients with osteoarthritis of the hip, giving a high percentage of satisfactory results. It often relieves the pain immediately, is long-lasting in its effects, and may even increase the range of movement. 2. There is no evidence from our figures that the extent of medial displacement of the lower fragment influences the result as judged from relief of pain, performance, and the patient's assessment. Movement, however, is less improved if displacement exceeds half the diameter of the divided bone. 3. Our observations did not support the view that improvement is caused by a changed relationship between the upper fragment and the acetabulum. When measurements were possible the position of the upper fragment usually remained virtually unaltered. 4. Our figures confirm that in most patients relief of pain is immediate; that is to say, the patient is aware on regaining consciousness that his pain has gone, even though he formerly had pain at rest. Whatever may be the mechanism that relieves the pain, it acts immediately

1. Osteotomy for osteoarthritis of the hip induces a fibrin layer over the exposed bone which forms the basis of a fibrocellular protective mantle that can differentiate towards cartilage. 2. The process is accompanied by bone remodelling, which reduces sclerosis, resolves osteolytic foci and, in company with bone formation in the fibrous mantle, restores the subchondral plate. 3. Many important aspects of the pathogenesis of osteoarthritis and of its partial repair by osteotomy remain to be elucidated

We have reviewed 368 osteotomies carried out for osteoarthritis of the hip at the Nuffield Orthopaedic Centre. Survivorship analysis showed that 10 years after osteotomy 47% had required no further surgery, and even after 20 years 23% had still not had a hip replacement. Hips with moderate arthritic change showed significantly better results than those with more severe degeneration. Osteotomies with varus angulation as well as medial displacement showed longer survival

1. Almost all patients with osteoarthritis of the hip who consult the surgeon do so because they wish to be relieved of pain. They all have limitation of movement in varying degrees but most of them will be either unaware of it or will have accepted it. What is more important, they would not have sought medical advice because of stiffness if there had been no pain. The primary objective of operative treatment must therefore be to relieve pain. 2. Displacement osteotomy will give substantial relief from pain in a high proportion of cases and the relief is lasting. Perhaps that explains why this operation, advocated by McMurray and Malkin twenty-five years ago, is being practised more widely than ever to-day while its competitors (neurectomy, capsulectomy, arthroplasty) have steadily diminished in popularity. 3. The disadvantages of the operation are all related to post-operative immobilisation in plaster, which may induce further stiffness of the hip, even to the extent of ankylosis, or stiffness and pain in the knee. These disadvantages may be overcome to a considerable degree by internal fixation followed by sling suspension and early active movement. But when, under anaesthesia, the range of hip flexion is reduced to 45 degrees or less, the operation is always liable to result in ankylosis, and it is wise in these circumstances to take this possibility into account and warn the patient beforehand

1. Experimental evidence is advanced to suggest that the effect of the McMurray displacement osteotomy in osteoarthritis of the hip is to diminish the load carried by the head of the femur, firstly by correction of deformity, and secondly by a "pelvic support" action. 2. A review of seventy-five cases has revealed certain important details in selection and operative management. The end-results indicate that the operation, when correctly performed, is successful in relieving pain and diminishing disability

1. In fifteen patients with unilateral osteoarthritis of the hip bilateral measurements of the intraosseous pressure of the femoral neck and determination of femoral vein pressure were done simultaneously. These pressure examinations were followed by bilateral intraosseous phlebography of the proximal part of the femur. 2. In a second series of fifteen patients the intraosseous pressures of the femoral head and neck were measured simultaneously before operation for osteoarthritis. 3. The pressure in the femoral vein was equal on the two sides. The intraosseous pressure in the femoral neck was always higher in the arthritic hip than on the unaffected side. In hips with osteoarthritis the pressure in the femoral head was higher than the pressure in the neck. 4. Intraosseous phlebography indicated a state of intramedullary venous engorgement in osteoarthritis. The normal channels for venous drainage from the femoral head and neck were not visible in the phlebographs from the arthritic side. Instead, drainage took place through descending intramedullary vessels to the trochanteric region and down into the femoral shaft. The emptying of intraosseous contrast material from the arthritic hip was delayed. 5. The phlebographs indicated that the abnormally high intraosseous pressure observed in osteoarthritis is caused by a high resistance to flow across the cortex of the proximal part of the femur. 6. The aching rest pain typical of severe osteoarthritis was noted only in patients with intraosseous femoral neck pressure above 40 millimetres of mercury, an indication that this type of pain is caused by intramedullary hypertension. The decrease of arteriovenous pressure difference, caused by increase of resistance to venous outflow, is probably accompanied by disturbances of nutritive flow. This "venous ischaemia" may play an important role for the structural changes of cancellous bone in osteoarthritis

1. The synovial membrane and capsule in osteoarthritis of the hip have been studied in twenty-five cases. Dissections have been made on fresh cadavers to establish the normal structure and function of these tissues at different ages. 2. Fragments of bone and cartilage were found beneath the synovial surface in twenty-three cases of the twenty-five cases of osteoarthritis. 3. The source of these fragments is the degenerate articular surfaces. 4. The fibrosis of the synovial membrane and capsule follows the synovial hyperplasia which accompanies the phagocytosis of these fragments. 5. A similar histological picture has been produced by injecting fragmented cartilage into the knee joints of rabbits. The injected fragments are found beneath the surface, and synovial hyperplasia is followed by subsynovial fibrosis. 6. The greatest amount of this joint debris is found in the lowest part of the joint cavity. 7. The joint capsule is particularly sensitive to traction. 8. All parts of the capsule are tight in extension, which is the weight-bearing position. 9. Fibrotic shortening of the capsule in the lowest part of the joint cavity explains many of the symptoms and signs of the disease: pain is caused by an attempt to stretch the capsule; muscle spasm occurs in the muscles supplied by the sensory nerves of this part of the capsule; extension, medial rotation and abduction, which tighten this area, are lost first; progressive shortening causes deformity in the opposite direction, namely flexion, lateral rotation and adduction; the loss of extension causes a more rapid wearing of articular cartilage on weight bearing; subperiosteal new bone is formed on the under-surface of the neck of the femur. 10. The symptomatology is discussed

We reviewed the results of 277 intertrochanteric valgus-extension osteotomies performed between 1973 and 1975 for primary or secondary osteoarthritis. The average age of the patients was 51 years and follow-up varied from 11 to 15 years. At the latest evaluation 67% of the hips were good or excellent on the Merle D'Aubigne scale. Better results were obtained in patients under 40 years of age with unilateral involvement and a mechanical (secondary) aetiology. An elliptical femoral head, minimal subluxation and an adequate pre-operative range of motion were also favourable. There was radiographic evidence of regression of the arthritic changes in 39% of the hips at final review. Valgus-extension osteotomy is effective for secondary osteoarthritis of the hip in selected younger patients, but not for those with primary hip disease or a poor range of movement

1. The rate of non-union of 100 intertrochanteric osteotomies of the McMurray type, with internal fixation, is reported. One in five was not united one year after operation. The criteria of union are discussed. 2. The patient's disability in twelve ununited osteotomies has been assessed, and related to the mobility of the osteotomy. 3. The factors which prejudice union have been analysed. The principal cause of non-union appeared to be the varus angulation strain on a varus osteotomy displaced medially more than half the diameter of the bone. Obliquity inwards and upwards of the osteotomy was a contributory factor. The types of internal fixation used, the use of external splintage and the period of protected weight bearing with crutches did not appear to be related to the rate of union. 4. It is concluded that marked inward displacement of the osteotomy, combined with either obliquity of the osteotomy or a varus position, prejudices union; that the use of this technique is unfounded in principle and not supported empirically; and that displacement should be eschewed to avoid this complication of intertrochanteric osteotomy in the treatment of osteoarthritis of the hip

In a population-based study we identified a cohort of 282 women, whose children had been treated for osteoarthritis of the hip. The incidence of hip fracture in these mothers was 0.54 (95% CI 0.35 to 0.83) of that in the whole population of their age and sex. This finding could be explained by a genetic factor for increased rigidity of subchondral bone, making osteoarthritis more likely and osteoporosis less likely

1. One hundred and eight osteotomies were reviewed with regard to union, and fourteen were found to be ununited. In only one was non-union detected clinically; the others required radiographic demonstration. Tomographs were particularly helpful in confirming non-union. 2. Nine patients with non-union had pain, equal to or worse than before operation. The pain could not be distinguished from that of osteoarthritis of the hip. 3. Six of the patients with non-union needed an operation. Five had cancellous bone grafts followed by union in all except one. 4. The causes of non-union are reviewed. This complication was found to be less frequent in patients above sixty with stiff hips and bony collapse on the radiograph. Horizontal osteotomy with a displacement of not more than one-third of the diameter of the shaft reduced the incidence of non-union. The variable-angle nail-plate provided the best fixation. Traction provided no benefit and increased the incidence of non-union. Weight bearing is best avoided for eight weeks

1. A total of 120 Moore's arthroplasties in 111 patients were reviewed one to nine years after operation. 2. There was striking reduction in the severity of pain in 105 out of the 120 hips reviewed. Range of movement was improved in most patients but the degree of independence was improved less often. The reasons for this are discussed. 3. We draw the following conclusions regarding the place of Moore's arthroplasty. Firstly, it was a natural step in the evolution towards total hip replacement, an operation which promises to give more complete relief of symptoms and which seems likely to replace Moore's arthroplasty as the treatment of choice in osteoarthritis of the hip in the elderly. Secondly, Moore's arthroplasty is still a rational procedure for the treatment of degeneration if the acetabulum is not involved—for instance, in idiopathic avascular necrosis of the femoral head. Thirdly, it is certainly a valuable operation for some cases of recent fracture of the femoral neck. Avascular necrosis of the femoral head after trifin nailing can be satisfactorily treated by Moore's arthroplasty, particularly in the early stages before the acetabulum becomes involved. Finally, Moore's arthroplasty gave many fairly elderly patients considerable relief of pain at a time when nothing better was available. Much of the relief afforded has proved to be lasting, but deterioration sometimes occurred with time. In the few patients whose deterioration amounted to failure a definite cause for the failure was found. In the majority the deterioration was slight, and it seems likely that the operation will last most of these elderly patients for the rest of their lives