Patients & Methods

A series of patients with problems following failed hallux valgus surgery presenting to a tertiary referral unit is presented. There were 47 patients with 55 problematic feet, 45 were female. The mean age was 59 years (Range 25–79). The failed bunions were compared to a prospectively collected series of 80 patients with successful 1st metatarsal osteotomies, 40 ludloff and 40 scarf osteotomies.

Before the index surgery, all the patients in the failed group, the predominant symptom was pain. Only 53% admitted deformity was an issue. A wide spectrum of procedures were performed, 13 Wilson's, 11 Keller's, 8 Chevron, 3 Bunionectomy, 2 Scarf, 1 Basal and 1 Mitchell's. In 16 patients the original procedure was unknown. The mean time to developing problems was 9.4 years (Range 0–45) with mean time to presentation 13.6 years. (Range 0–47) Radiographs revealed 2/3 of patients had relative shortening of the first metatarsal. Over 80% of x-rays demonstrated evidence of degenerative change. The mean AOFAS score deteriorated with increased shortening.

The failed bunions had statistically significantly different AOFAS pain scores (15.1 vs 31.9 p < 0.05), function scores (25.02 vs 31.9 p < 0.05). Additionally, the hallux valgus angle was significantly higher (24 vs 11.7 p < 0.05) although there was no change in DMMA between the two groups (13 vs 7.6 p > 0.05). There was a significantly higher incidence of first ray shortening (12% vs 0% p < 0.05).