We treated 60 patients with type III Pilon fractures (Ruedi and Allgower Classification) between 1996 and 2005. The fractures were distracted and then fixed with an Ilizarov circular ring fixator, without the use of open surgery. No internal fixation was used for the tibia or fibula. No bone grafting was performed. The average time from injury to frame application was four days. The patient stayed ib frame for a mean time of 15 weeks. No second operative procedure was needed. All cases united in good alignment. The patients were reviewed from ten years to nine months after frame removal. Four separate evaluations were performed (functional, objective, radiological and an SF-36). The function and the range of movement were better than the radiological assessment suggested. This method of treatment gives better results with fewer complications than open surgery with internal fixation
The site of the non-union is approached through the pre-existing scar and any remaining metalwork is removed. The ends of the non-union are mobilised and bone is resected from both ends until there is fresh bleeding. The two bone ends are fashioned such that one will fit as a spike inside the medullary cavity of the other. The bone ends are held in position with two temporary K wires until the frame has been applied. A standard four ring Ilizarov frame is applied with Rancho pins in the proximal humerus and a half ring in the distal humerus. The temporary K wires are removed and the frame is compressed to increase the contact between the bone ends. The routine hospital stay is one week and the patients are given intravenous antibiotics throughout their admission. They are reviewed in the outpatient clinic at monthly intervals and the frame is used to compress the bone ends by two to three millimetres on each visit. When there are radiographic signs of union the frame is removed under a general anaesthetic.
Non-unions of the supracondylar area of the humerus are uncommon but they produce profound functional disability. We have successfully treated a series of these non-unions surgically using the Coventry hip screw. This is a large metaphyseal screw which is applied through both humeral condyles and then compressed on to a single 4. 5mm narrow tibial plate applied to the lateral aspect of the humeral shaft. Between 1993 and 2000 we operated on thirteen consecutive patients aged 20 to 81 years (mean age 51 years). All the patients had a severe functional disability. The mean time to surgery was 23 months following their accidents. The average follow up was 16 months (range 8–18 months). All but two of the thirteen patients went on to bony union. The mean time to radiological union was six months (2 to 12 months). The mean arc of flexion doubled to 90 degrees. Until now, the recommended operative technique for stabilisation of non-unions of the distal humerus is identical to that described for primary fracture repair, and involves fixation with two 3. 5 mm plates at 90 degrees. In our experience, this was the technique usually used at the initial operation/s, and is therefore likely to fail again. This correlates with the reported 6–12% non-union rate in the literature. In this series, stable fixation was achieved by using the Coventry hip screw.
This paper describes the outcome of type III pilon fractures of the distal tibia treated primarily with an Ilizarov ring fixator. Only patients with an intra-articular fracture of the tibial plafond on plainradiographs that corresponded to type III pattern with the system of Rfiedi andAllgower were included. There were thirteen patients with a mean age of 45 (range 29–65), twelve males and one female. The mechanism of injury in all the patients was high-speed road traffic accident. Operative fixation consisted of fracture reduction and stabilisation using the llizarov circular frame external fixator and olive tipped wires. Further insult to the already damaged soft tissues was avoided. Bony union was achieved in all cases. Treatment in the frame lasted between 3 and 10 months (average 6. 3 months). Neither deep infection nor soft tissue complications occurred. Outcome measurements included the Olerud ankle score, modified Ovadia and Beals radiological criteria, and the SF-36 Health Questionnaire. Wound and deep infections were successfully avoided and bony union was achieved in all our patients. This compares well with other fixation techniques. The use of the llizarov circular frame external fixator without any additional internal reduction or fixation procedures is a definite option for the treatment of these high-energy injuries.
Between 1993 and 2000 we treated 14 patients with nonunion of fractures of the distal humerus; 11 had already had previous fixation which had failed. The mean time to surgery was 21 months after injury. All the fractures were very low which made it difficult to obtain a firm hold of the small distal fragment. The problem of fixation was addressed by inserting a Coventry infant hip screw into the humeral condyles. The screw has a thread of wide diameter which gives excellent purchase on the small distal fragment. The condyles can then be compressed on to the humeral shaft using a 4.5 mm narrow tibial dynamic plate. Of these 14 difficult cases of nonunion, 12 progressed to union.
We treated 19 patients with established nonunion of the radius and/or ulna by the excision of avascular bone and the grafting of blocks of corticocancellous bone from the iliac crest, augmented by rigid plate fixation under compression. This allowed early mobilisation, and bony union was achieved between three and 24 months after operation in all but one of the patients. The single failure was attributed to the excessive length of the defect (100 mm) and inadequate fixation.
Between 1994 and 1999, we treated six patients with avascular necrosis of the talus by excision of the necrotic body of the talus and tibiocalcaneal fusion using an Ilizarov frame. This was combined with corticotomy and a lengthening procedure. Shortening was corrected in all patients except two, who were over 60 years of age. All patients had previous operations which had failed. All achieved solid bony fusion, with five out of six having either a good or an excellent result. We conclude that this is an effective reconstructive technique which gives a good functional result.
We used the Ilizarov circular external fixator to treat 16 patients with persistent nonunion of the diaphysis of the humerus despite surgical treatment. All patients had pain and severe functional impairment of the affected arm. In ten, nonunion followed intramedullary nailing. We successfully treated these by a closed technique. The nail was left in place and the fracture compressed over it. The fractures of the other six patients had previously been fixed by various methods. We explored these nonunions, removed the fixation devices and excised fibrous tissue and dead bone before stabilising with the Ilizarov fixator. In five patients union was achieved. Bone grafting was not required. In the single patient in whom treatment failed, there had been a severely comminuted open fracture. All except one patient had reduction of pain, and all reported an improvement in function.
We reviewed 26 consecutive men of mean age 28 years who had had wedge bone grafting and Herbert screw fixation for symptomatic established nonunion of the waist of the scaphoid. The period between injury and operation averaged 30 months (10 to 96), and 11 of the 26 patients had had previous operations, seven with bone grafts. At a mean follow-up of 14 months (6 to 42) 25 fractures (95%) had united at a median time of four months. Symptoms were improved in all patients. The outcome was not related to the time between injury and surgery or to pre-existing degenerative changes. Previous surgery carried a worse prognosis. The technique is difficult but can achieve union even when previous surgery and bone grafting have failed. The usual result is improved function and some relief of pain.