In orthopaedic surgery, as in many other surgical fields, there is a clear tendency towards the use of minimally invasive procedures. These techniques are increasingly being implemented almost routinely for procedures such as spine and pelvis surgery. However, for fracture treatment and for applications involving small bones, such as hand and foot surgery, these systems are hardly ever used. We introduce a new system for image based guidance in traumatology.

We included 20 patients with a fracture of the fifth metatarsal. They were randomised on admission into two groups. Ten patients in the metatarsal group were operated conventionally and ten were operated with the assistance of a new image guidance system. This system is based on 2D-fluoro images which are acquired with a conventional c-arm and are transferred to the system workstation. After detecting marked tools, it can be used to display trajectories for K-wire guidance in the c-arm shot.

The average duration of surgery (time from incision to suture) in the image-based group was 12.7 minutes ± 5.5 (min. 6, max. 23), in the conventional group it was 17 minutes ± 6.5 (min. 7, max. 28) (p=0.086). The average duration of radiation was 18 seconds ± 8.5 (min. 6, max 36) in the image-based group vs. 32.4 seconds ± 19.4 (min. 12, max. 66) in the conventional group (p=0.057). An average of 4.7 C-arm shots ± 2 (min 2, max 9) were necessary in the image-based group to position the K-wire. For the conventional group, 8.2 shots ± 2.3 (min 4, max 12) were used (p=0.0073). It took 1.6 trials ± 0.7 (min.1, max. 3) to position the K-wire for the image-based procedures, in the conventional group 2.7 trials ± 0.9 (min. 1, max 4) were necessary (p=0.0084). There were no malfunctions or adverse events in any of the image-based navigational cases. No screws needed to be replaced in the image-based group. In the conventional group, two screws were replaced intra-operatively because they were too short in the control c-arm shot, and the screw threads did not bridge the fracture gap completely, leading to insufficient compression.

In this pilot study with only a small sample size, the image-based guidance system could be integrated into the existing surgical workflow and was used for applications, where existing navigation systems are not commonly used. The technology gives the surgeon additional information and can reduce the number of trials for perfect implant positioning. This potentially increases the safety of the surgical procedure and spares intact bone substance which is essential for the footing of implants in small bones and fragment fixation. Whether these factors contribute to a reduction in complications or revision rate must be confirmed in larger prospective studies.

Fractures of the femoral head are a challenging problem. The most often performed head preserving procedure worldwide is closed reduction and insertion of cannulated screws under fluoroscopic control. The use of navigation is still experimental in general trauma since rigid reference markers must be attached to all fragments. The examined system (Surgix®, Tel Aviv, Israel) is a fluoroscopy based image analysing system. It consists of a workstation and X-ray opaque markers in surgical tools. When the tool is visible in a C-arm shot a trajectory is displayed as additional layer in the image to serve as guidance for the surgeon.

Forty synthetic femurs (Synbone®, Malans, Switzerland) were used and placed inside foam to simulate the soft tissue of the thigh. The models were equipped with 4.5mm radio-opaque markers at the fovea capitis femoris as target point. The aim was to bring the tip of a K-wire as close as possible to the target point entering the bone at the lateral base of the greater trochanter in a center-center position. Twenty were done under image guidance and 20 were operated the conventional way. Outcome measures included the accuracy (the distance between the tip of the wire and the target in a CT), the number of guide wire insertions, procedure duration, radiation exposure and learning curve.

In the image guided group optimal guide wire placement was accomplished on first pass in 65% of the cases as compared to 5% in the conventional group (p = < 0.0001). The average number of trial and error was significantly lower in the guided group (1.7 vs. 5.8, p = < 0.0001). Consequently the average duration of the guided procedure was significantly shorter (p = 0.0008) along with radiation exposure time reduced by over 70% (p = 0.0002). The guidance system hit averaged 5.8 mm off target as compared to 5.3 mm for the freehand method (p = 0.3319).

Image based guidance significantly shortened the procedure, reduced the radiation exposure and the number of trials without changing the surgeons workflow and can be used in trauma cases were reference marker based navigation is not applicable.