In a cadaveric study, the anterior shoulder capsule indicated the presence of the middle (MGHL) and inferior (IGHL) glenohumeral ligament by displaying folds. These folds became more prominent in adduction (AD) and internal rotation (IR), whereas they were smoothed out upon abduction (AB) and external rotation (ER). The present study was set up to determine whether this folding-unfolding mechanism (FUM) is influenced by the type of shoulder pathology. 300 consecutive shoulder arthroscopies were evaluated. 68 were done for instability, 21 for frozen shoulder and 221 for various pathologies in stable shoulders of which 100 for rotator cuff tears. Stable shoulders: The anterior band (AB) of the IGHL was marked by a prominent fold in IR and 30°AD. In full ER and 45°AB the fold was completely smoothed out. The MGHL was smooth in full ER and 15°AB. Frozen shoulders: The anterior capsule was smooth without visible folds in any degree of rotation, limited by the adhesive capsulitis. Releasing the capsule from the glenoid rim did not change this appearance. Unstable shoulders: In 17 shoulders with anterosuperior instability (SLAP and RCI lesions), the FUM of the anterior capsule had the same appearance as in stable shoulders. In 51 shoulders with anteroinferior instability, the MGHL and ABIGHL still formed prominent folds in IR. Full ER, increased up to 90° in some patients, did not result in smoothing of the folds, not even with up to 90°AB. After repair of the labroligamentous lesion and associated capsular shift, the FUM reappeared at 45°AB and ER that was reduced to 45°. These observations suggest that smoothing of the anteroinferior capsule at a maximum of 45°ER and 45°AB could be used as an indication of normal tension in the MGHL and IGHL. When the FUM does not occur within this range, these ligaments are probably insufficient, be it torn or stretched. During capsular shift, esp electrothermal, a reappearing FUM could be used to evaluate achievement of adequate capsular tension. When no folds at all are visible, even with full IR, this indicates a very tight capsule and likely a frozen shoulder, esp when rotation is decreased.
A series of 116 patients surgically treated, with exclusion of arthroplasty, between December 1996 and December 2002 for a fracture of the proximal humerus, was retrospectively reviewed. Only 44 patients (45 shoulders) were available for clinical and radiological follow-up, 21 were deceased, 36 refused to participate and 14 could not be traced. The mean age was 60 y (15–93 y), the mean follow up was 44 months (15–78 m.); 28 were women, 16 men. The fractures were classified according the Neer-classification but also according the different types of surgery they underwent: percutaneous or retrograde pinning without opening the fracture site, osteosynthesis with plate and screws, osteosynthesis with screws alone, bone-graft and osteosutures or a combination of two or more methods. Two-part fractures (10 out of 13 fractures), but also 9 of the 15 three-part fractures, were treated by pinning, whereas the remaining 2 and 3-part, the isolated fractures of tuberculi and two 4-part fractures needed open surgery and fixation. A plate was used in only 3 cases, screws alone in 6 cases, a cortical bone-graft with osteosutures in 4 cases and a combination of open fixation in 8 cases. Whenever possible a minimal invasive technique was thus preferred. 16 patients (35,7%) had complications: 6 were minor (pin migration, slight secondary displacement or impingement as a consequence of protruding hardware), but one non-union, 4 CRPS and 5 avascular necrosis occurred. Only one of the latter underwent shoulder-arthroplasty at time of review. Major complications occurred mainly in the more complex fracture types (3 or 4 part fractures) Mean values of Constant score, ASES-score, Neerscore, UCLA score and Simple Shoulder test were not statistically different, neither between fracture types nor between surgical techniques. Using a correlation analyses we found a negative correlation between age and scoring systems: the older the patient, the lower the score. Patient satisfaction was higher in the percutaneous or retrograde pinning group than the other types of open surgery. We can conclude that although no statistical differences could be observed in our series, minimal invasive surgical techniques, less prone to complications, are preferable in the treatment of two and three part fractures of the proximal humerus and 4-part fractures of the younger population.
This difference is significant (p=0,0000).