53 patients required revision of both components. There were 49 stem only revisions. 4 patients were re-revised for recurrent loosening and 2 for infection. There were 14 dislocations. Of these, 4 required secondary stabilisation and 2 underwent Girdlestone’s excision arthroplasty for recurrent dislocation. 46 of the 64 patients who attended final follow-up had no changes in their X-ray appearances compared to the immediately post-operative films. 9 of the stems and 9 of the cups had signs of progressive lucent lines around the cement mantle. This gives a survivorship of 89% at ten years with reoperation for any cause as the end-point.
All patients received postal questionnaires comprising the Oxford Hip Score, the HOOS score and a satisfaction score. Routine yearly radiological examination was also undertaken. Demographic data are shown in Table 1.
Activity scores in the HOOS hip survey were not significantly different in the three groups. There was no difference in satisfaction scores and whether patients would have the same operation again.