Cannulated screw is commonly used in the fixation of proximal femoral neck fractures. In the literature, several configurations had been proposed for best mechanical support with clinical experiences or biomechanical tests. Although screws in triangle configuration contribute certain fixation stability, but sometimes the surgeons made their own choices have to conduct another fixation pattern for some factors such as fracture type, economic issues, and so on. Therefore the aim of this study is to analyze the mechanical responses of a fractured femur fixed with screws in different configurations, screw materials and screw diameters with finite element method, trying to find the most stable construct.

A solid femur model was built from the CT images of a standard saw bone. Three fracture types of the femoral neck were created according to Pauwel's classification (30?, 50?, 70?) by CAD software. The models of implanted screws were built according to a commercial cannulated screw (Stryker Osteosynthesis, Schoenkirchen/Kiel, Germany) with diameter 6.5mm and 4.5mm by CAD software, too. Three fixation configurations were analyzed in this study, including triangle with superior single screw with titanium diameter 6.5mm, triangle with inferior single screw with diameter 6.5mm and diamond with four stainless screw diameter 4.5mm (fig.1). Totally there were nine models constructed in this study, and all of them were then imported into ANSYS WORKBENCH v14 (Swanson Analysis, Houston, PA, USA) to mesh and further analysis. 700N vertical downward force was applied on the femur head and the distal end of femur shaft was totally fixed.

The triangle fixation with superior single screw resulted in a best stability, but the fracture fixed with screws in a diamond configuration has least fracture gap. The difference of the maximum displacement of the femur head with Pauwel's classification 70?between triangle fixation with superior single screw and diamond configuration is only 0.03mm (1.72–1.69 mm). In most unstable femoral neck fracture [Pauwel's classification 70], the maximum gap distance is 0.59mm under the diamond configuration, while it is 0.63mm as the fracture fixed with a triangle configuration.

Therefore, this study suggests that four 4.5mm stainless screws in a diamond configuration is an alternative for proximal femur fracture once 6.5mm titanium screws are not available.