Mesenchymal stem cells (MSC) have been used for bone regenerative applications as an alternative approach to bone grafting. Selecting the appropriate source of MSC is vital for the success of this therapeutic approach. MSC can be obtained from various tissues, but the most used sources of MSC are Bone marrow (BMSC), followed by adipose tissue (ASC). A donor-matched comparison of these two sources of MSC ensures robust and reliable results.

Despite the similarities in morphology and immunophenotype of donor-matched ASC and BMSC, differences existed in their proliferation and in vitro differentiation potential, particularly osteogenic differentiation that was superior for BMSC, compared to ASC. However, these differences were substantially influenced by donor variations. In vivo, although the upregulated expression of osteogenesis-related genes in both ASC and BMSC, more bone was regenerated in the calvarial defects treated with BMSC compared to ASC, especially during the initial period of healing. According to these findings, compared to ASC, BMSC may result in faster regeneration and healing, when used for bone regenerative applications.