Abstract

Introduction: The senior author undertakes single stage revision hip arthroplasty for cases with no preoperative evidence of infection based on history and examination, ESR and CRP results and negative results from selective aspirations. Despite this a large proportion of intra-operative samples are positive for infection. The purpose of our study is to look at the results of intra-operative histology and microbiology samples in these cases and to assess the subsequent incidence of infection.

Methods: Retrospective case study comprising of 230 single stage revision total hip arthroplasties carried out by a single surgeon over 5 year period (2003–2008). Intra-operatively tissue samples were taken from multiple sites and sent for both histology and microbiology. Microbiology results were reported at 24hrs, 48hrs, 7 days and 21 days and correlated with histology reports.

Results: From a total number of 230 patients, we had 98 left and 132 right hip revision arthroplasties. There were 95 men and 135 women with a mean age of 73 years (range 40–93). Intra-operative microbiology was negative in 108 patients (46.95%), of which 3 patients’ histology samples were consistent with infection. Of the 122 microbiology positive patients (53.04%), there were 8 histology samples consistent with infection. The most frequent growths were of Coagulase negative Staphylococcus (64 cases) and Propionibacterium (18 cases). 3 cases subsequently developed deep infection.

Discussion: This study highlights a significant discrepancy between intra-operative microbiology and intra-operative histology results. There is also a very high discrepancy between pre-operative assessment and intra-operative microbiological findings although the majority of cases subsequently did not show any clinical evidence of infection.

Introduction: The Corail stem is a well proven femoral implant used for the past 22 years. It is the most common uncemented femoral stem used for total hip replacements in the UK. The stem was modified in 2004 with an increased neck taper to allow for an increased range of bearings and modular heads. This study reviews a series of primary total hip replacements using this recently modified Corail stem to assess if this implant is still performing to acceptable standards.

Method: A prospective patient database collated by 2 arthroplasty surgeons recorded data at the time of operation and subsequent follow up. All intra-operative and post-operative complications were recorded. Pre and postoperative oxford hip scores were analysed.

Results: 751 cases were reviewed. The average age was 63 with females accounting for 69%. The pinnacle cup was used in 83% of cases, with a polyethylene bearing in 48%. Survival of the stem at 3 years was 99.9% (1 periprosthetic fracture following a fall), the cup 99.6%, with overall survival of 99.5%. The most common intra operative complication was calcar fracture occurring in 0.9%. Dislocation occurred in 0.5%, subsidence in 0.3%, deep infection in 0.1% and leg length discrepancy requiring shoe raise in 0.1%. Average 3 year oxford hip score was 12.

Discussion: 3 year survival of both the femoral stem and the total hip replacement are above the quoted rates in the National Joint Registry’s 4th annual report for corail and uncemented stems (98.8% and 98.1% respectively), and also exceeds that of cemented stems (99.1%). The same report quotes similar rates of calcar fractures (0.8%), although we recorded no other perioperative complications. We conclude the new generation of Corail stem has excellent 3 year performance.