We present a series of 16 patients who have had a failed ankle arthroplasty converted to an ankle arthrodesis using a surgical technique of bone grafting with internal fixation. We describe our technique using tricortical autograft from the iliac crest to preserve length and an emphasis is placed on maintaining the malleoli and subtalar joint.

A successful fusion was achieved in all cases with few complications. Our post operative AOFAS improved to a mean of 70 with good patient satisfaction and compares well to other published series. From this series and an extensive review of the literature we have found fusion rates following failed arthroplasty in patients with degenerative arthritis to be very high. In this group of patients a high fusion rate and good clinical result can be achieved when the principles of this surgical technique are adhered to.

It would appear that a distinction should be made between treating patients with poor quality bone and more extensive bone loss, as is often the case with rheumatoid patients; and the patients with a non inflammatory arthropathy and better bone quality. The intramedullary nail would appear to be the preferred option in patients with inflammatory polyarthropathy where preservation of the subtalar joint is probably not of relevance as it is usually extensively involved in the disease process, and a higher rate of complications can be anticipated with internal fixation.

Aim

This controlled study uses gait analysis to evaluate patients' pre- and post-ankle arthroplasty, post-ankle arthrodesis and compares the results with a healthy control group to assess whether these theoretical benefits are borne out in clinical practice.