The aim of the study was to assess the effectiveness of surgical treatment for degenerative lumbar spinal stenosis (LSS) as compared with non-operative measures. Four university hospitals contributed, after agreement on study protocol, surgical rationale and non-operative procedures (For details, see We conclude that surgical treatment improves functional ability in lumbar spinal stenosis. We emphasize that improvement also occurs after nonoperative measures. We recommend starting treatment with non-operative measures during a 2-year surveillance period, as during this period only 10 per cent of the patients will need surgical intervention.
Since neurological claudication is a major symptom in lumbar spinal stenosis (LSS), walking distance is commonly used as a measure of the severity and surgical outcome in LSS. The aim of this study was to compare self-reported and treadmill-measured walking distances in a trial, in which 94 patients with moderate LSS had been randomized into conservative and surgical treatment. Among the 44 patients in conservative treatment, the treadmill-measured walking distance was more reproducible after 6 months than the self-reported distance; the intraclass correlation coefficients were 0.75 and 0.41, respectively. Among all the patients at baseline, the agreement between self-reported and measured walking distance was satisfactory (intraclass correlation 0.57), although male patients overwhelmed their performance by 200 meters. Such a shift was not found in women. For walking distance categorized as <
400, 400–1249 and ≥ 1250 meters, there was a fair agreement between self-report and treadmill (weighed kappa 0.42). However, when the analysis was restricted to those whose walking distance was restricted to <
1250 meters, the corresponding agreement was poor (intraclass correlation 0.26). The self-reported walking distance was closely correlated with Oswestry index at baseline (r = 0.26), and changes in these outcomes from randomization to the follow-up of 6 months showed a strong correlation with each other (r = 0.37). We conclude that walking distance is a fundamental element of disability in LSS. Self-reported walking distance seems to be an appropriate clinical tool, but its limited precision in relation to treadmill-measured distance must be considered, when walking ability is severely restricted.
Rehabilitation as a concept, and the practice of rehabilitation, have changed remarkably during the preceding years. Modern rehabilitation is multidisciplinary and multi-professional. The development and research of rehabilitation has also grown international. The contents of modern rehabilitation include medical, social and psychological aspects, and in vocational rehabilitation, the working conditions and organisational questions are dealt with as well (Jager 1999). Traditional methods in vocational rehabilitation and guidance include medical and psychological assessment, and work clinics assessment (which includes practical work assessment in the work place). Presently, the methods, have advanced and rehabilitation is not seen merely as a specific method for handicapped people. Various rehabilitation measures are flexibly applied, and rehabilitation includes elements of adult education, training of working skills, and ideas of on-the-job training and career advancement. The concepts, targets and contexts of rehabilitation and prevention can be described as follows: Primary Prevention: health education and ergonomic advice for general, non-disabled population. Secondary Prevention: early rehabilitation for groups at risk with early signs of disability. Tertiary Prevention: rehabilitation and habilitation of severely disabled to secure social integration. The outcome of rehabilitation has been studied extensively, but the number of randomised controlled trials (RCT) is not large in any of the major target groups of rehabilitation. Among musculoskeletal disorders, the best evidence for the efficacy of multidisciplinary rehabilitation is for sub-acute and chronic low back pain disorders. Systematic reviews have been performed in various other musculoskeletal disorders as well, e.g. in fibromyalgia and multilocational pain syndromes, where no clear evidence has yet been demonstrated. It should be noted though that RCT’s are not the only way to get information about the outcome, efficacy or effectiveness of rehabilitation, and vocational rehabilitation in particular. The outcome of vocational rehabilitation, i.e. the success of occupational integration, depends a great deal on the general employment outlook. This is generally known but often ignored. Various forms of supported employments have become more important than earlier. The European Social Fund’s Employment Horizon initiative has launched many projects in Europe. As a result, new training and employment approaches have been developed for disabled persons, including co-operatives, social enterprises and distance work. In practice, supported employment takes the form of individual training at the workplace and consists of finding suitable supported work, redesigning job requirements in co-operation with both employer and employee to fit the employee’s abilities, and ongoing support as long as it is needed. These programmes reflect the important values of the society. It is a valuable goal to help disabled people to integrate into society, which involves participation into working life. This makes it possible for them to preserve their dignity as well. In fact, how Society deals with its disabled people enables it to discover most clearly its basic values.