Two different techniques to release subscapularis during total shoulder replacement (TSR) have been described (tenotomy and osteotomy) with no consensus as to which is superior. In this study we review the clinical outcomes of a sequential series of patients in whom a TSR for primary osteoarthritis had been performed using either technique at our institution. Subscapularis function was tested using a new graded belly press test, a modification of the traditional belly press test which is described for the first time here. All patients who underwent surgery at our institution between January 2002 and January 2010 and met the eligibility criteria, were included for analysis. Subscapularis function was assessed post-operatively using a range of functional assessments including; a graded belly press test, lift off test, and an assessment of each patient's range of movement.Aim
Methods
Subscapularis function following Total shoulder joint replacement has been a concern in recent literature. It has been postulated that lesser tuberosity osteotomy approach may have better Subscapularis function than transtendonous approach. To assess whether lesser tuberosity osteotomy vs. subscapularis tenotomy is better for post-operative function of subscapularis in total shoulder replacements done by a single surgeon in a District general hospital. 117 shoulder replacements performed by the senior author (TH) at Waikato district general hospital between years January 2002 to January 2010 were reviewed retrospectively. Revision replacement, inverse shoulder replacement & acute traumatic hemiarthroplasty were excluded. Patients with previous rotator cuff problems, previous surgery to subscapularis, rheumatoid arthritis and post-trauma sequelae were also excluded from the study. Inclusion criteria were normal subscapularis function and intact subscapularis on MRI pre-operatively. 41 shoulders were eligible to participate in study of which 1 pt died (bilateral TSR), 1 pt unfit to participate due to cervical disc problems. Of remaining 38 shoulders 11 shoulders had transtendonous and 27 shoulders had lesser tuberosity osteotomy approach. 37 shoulders were reviewed clinically for range of motion of the shoulder and subscapularis strength. Range of motion and subscapularis strength was significantly higher in the osteotomy group. All osteotomies were united on axillary radiograph. Lesser tuberosity osteotomy approach result in better subscapularis function than transtendonous approach.
