The objective of this study is to compare three dimensional (3D) postoperative motion between metal and ceramic bipolar hip hemiarthroplasty for femoral neck fracture. This study was conducted with forty cases (20 cases of metal bipolar hemiarthroplasty (4 males, 16 females), 20 cases of ceramic bipolar hemiarthroplasty (2 males, 18 females)) from November 2012 to November 2014. Average age was 80.8±7.5 years for the metal bipolar group and 79.3±10.5 years for the ceramic bipolar group. We obtained motion pictures from standing position to maximum abduction in flexion by fluoroscopy then analyzed by 2D–3D image matching method. The motion range of the “Shell angle”, “Stem neck angle” and the “Stem neck and shell angle” has been compared between the metal bipolar group and the ceramic bipolar group (Fig. 1). Metal bipolar showed greater variability of the Stem neck angle and Shell angle than ceramic bipolar. Six of the twenty cases reached unilateral oscillation angle of 37 degrees in metal bipolar. In other words, 30% of metal bipolar group revealed neck-shell impingement. No case reached oscillation angle of 58 degrees in ceramic bipolar group. There was no significant difference between the metal bipolar group and the ceramic bipolar group with respect to the difference of minimum and maximum angle of Stem neck angle (movement range of the stem neck) and Shell angle (movement range of the bipolar cup). On the other hand, difference of minimum and maximum angle of the Stem neck and shell angle (movement range of the inner head) was significantly greater in the metal bipolar group than the ceramic bipolar group. Movement, range of bipolar shell was significantly greater than that of inner head in both groups (Table 1).Materials and Methods
Results