Our statistical shape analysis showed that size is the primary geometrical variation factor in the medial meniscus. Shape variations are primarily focused in the posterior horn, suggesting that these variations could influence cartilage contact pressures. Variations in meniscal geometry are known to influence stresses and strains inside the meniscus and the articulating cartilage surfaces. This geometry-dependent functioning emphasizes that understanding the natural variation in meniscus geometry is essential for a correct selection of allograft menisci and even more crucial for the definition of different sizes for synthetic meniscal implants. Moreover, the design of such implants requires a description of 3D meniscus geometry. Therefore, the aim of this study was to quantify 3D meniscus geometry and to determine whether variation in medial meniscus geometry is size or shape driven.Summary
Introduction
The various disorders of the patellofemoral joint, from pain syndrome to maltracking and arthritis, form a significant subset of knee disorders (Callaghan and Selfe 2007). Several studies have shown significant geography and gender based variation in incidence rates of these disorders and of osteoarthritis in general (Woolf 2003). A number of previous studies have examined patellar shape in this context, focusing primarily on the use of 2D measurements of bony geometry to classify patellar shapes and identify high-risk groups (Baumgartl 1964; Ficat 1970). Recent developments in imaging and statistical analysis have enabled a more sophisticated approach, characterised by statistical shape models which account for three dimensional shape differences (Bryan 2008). Incorporating soft tissue data into these analyses, however, has been a challenge due to factors including the necessity of multi-modality images, absence of repeatable landmarks, and complexity of the surfaces involved. We present here a novel method which has potential to significantly improve analysis of soft tissue geometry in joints. It is built using Arthron, a UCD-developed biomechanics analysis software package. The shape modelling process consists of three phases: pre-processing, consistent surface parameterization, and statistical shape analysis. The pre-processing phase consists of several mesh processing operations that prepare the input surfaces for shape modelling. Consistent surface parameterizations are implemented using the minimum description length (MDL) correspondence method (Davies 2002) [Fig. 1]. The statistical shape analysis phase involves the reporting and visualization of geometric variation at the input surface. An algorithm was developed to measure the cartilage thickness at each node on the patellar surface mesh. The initial step in this process was to calculate surface normal vectors at each point. These vectors were then projected through the cartilage surface model in order to calculate the thickness [Fig. 2]. The Matlab software was used to aggregate all cartilage thickness values in a given subgroup and after being normalised for the average patellar centroid size for the subgroup, these thicknesses were visualised on the average shape. Pilot study data consisted of 19 Caucasian (7 female, 12 male) and 13 Japanese (7 female, 6 male) subjects. These data originated from studies performed by DePuy Orthopaedics Inc. Initial results show ethnicity effects in cartilage thickness to be more significant than gender effects [Fig. 3]. After correcting for patellar centroid size, male subjects display 9% greater average thickness than female subjects, while Caucasian subjects display 17% greater average thickness than Asian subjects. Areas of statistically significant differences (t < 0.05) were found to coincide with expected areas of patellofemoral contact through the flexion cycle, showing the potential for the thickness differential to impact upon patellar kinematics. Principal component analysis of the thickness distributions gives more detailed information about modes of variation. With further development, this method has potential to enable sophisticated analysis of localised variation in soft tissue geometry, thereby improving understanding of the impact of joint geometry on disease formation.
The management of the dysplastic hip represents a clinical and a technical challenge to the paediatric orthopaedic surgeon. There is a great deal of variation in the degree and direction of acetabular dysplasia. Preoperative planning in the dysplastic hip is still largely based on plain radiographs. However, these plain films are a 2D projection of a 3D structure and measurement is prone to inaccuracy as a result. Hip arthrography is used in an attempt to analyse the 3D morphology of the hip. However, this still employs a 2D projection of a 3D structure and in addition has the risk of general anaesthesia and infection. Geometrical analysis based on multiplanar imaging with CT scans has been shown to reduce analysis variability. We present a system for morphological analysis and preoperative of the paediatric hip using this model. Our system can be used to determine the most appropriate osteotomy based on morphology. This system should increase the accuracy of preoperative planning and reduce the need for arthrography.
Locking plates are widely used in clinical practice for the surgical treatment of complex proximal humerus fractures, especially in osteoporotic bone. The aim of this study is to assess the biomechanical influence of the infero-medial locking screws on maintaining reduction of the fragments in a proximal humerus fracture. A standard 3-part proximal humerus fracture was created in fourth generation humerus saw bones. Each specimen was anatomically reduced and secured with a PHILOS locking plate. Eleven of the specimens had infero-medial locking screws inserted, and 11 specimens did not. Each humerus sawbone underwent cyclical loading at 532N, as previous studies showed this was the maximum force at the glenohumeral joint. The absolute inter-fragmentary motion was recorded using an infra-red motion analysis device. Each specimen was then loaded to failure.Purpose
Materials & Methods
Athletes significantly alter their lumbar spinal motion when performing squat lifting at heavy weights. This altered motion effects a change in pressure in the posterior annulus of lumbar discs.
48 athletes performed 6 lifts at 40% maximum, 4 lifts at 60% maximum and 2 lifts at 80% maximum. Zebris 3-D motion analysis system used to measure lumbar spine motion. Exercise then repeated with weight lifting support belt. 4 cadaveric sheep spinal motion segments fixed to tension/compression loading frame, allowing compression replicating the forces seen in in vivo study. Pressure measurement achieved using a Flexiforce single element force sensor strip, positioned at posterior annulus. Posterior annulus pressure measured during axial compression and on compression with specimen fixed at 3° of extension.Hypothesis
Methods
3-D motion analysis of lumbar spinal motion in athletes, during squat weight lifting. Pressure measurement of the posterior annulus following the motion analysis study.
4 cadaveric sheep spinal motion segments mounted in purpose built jig, replicating angulation seen in the in vivo motion study. These samples were then fixed to a tension/compression loading frame, replicating the forces seen in the in vivo study. Pressure measurement was achieved using a Flexiforce single element force sensor strip, positioned at the posterior annulus. Posterior annulus pressure was measured during axial compression and on compression with the specimen fixed at 3° of extension.
Significant decrease (p<
0.05) in flexion in all groups when lifting at 40% max was compared with lifting at 60% and 80% of max. Flexion from calibrated zero point ranged from 24.7° (40% group), to 6.8° (80% group). A progressively significant increase (p<
0.05) seen in extension in groups studied when lifting at 40% max was compared with lifting at 60% and 80% max lift. Extension from a calibrated zero point ranged from − 1.5° (40% group), to − 20.3° (80% group). No statistically significant difference found between motion seen when performing the exercise as a ‘free’ squat or when lifting using a support belt in any group studied. Initial uniform rise in measured pressure readings to a pressure of 350–400N, in the axially loaded and extension loaded specimens. Pressure experienced by the axially loaded group then gradually dropped below the pressure exerted by the loading frame, while the pressure experienced in the posterior annulus of the extension loaded specimens progressively increased. Comparing axially loaded specimens with specimens loaded in extension, there was an average increase in pressure of 36.4% in the posterior annulus, when the spine was loaded in 3° of extension at a pressure equivalent to the 80% lift in the in vivo motion study, in comparison to axial loading.
The cervical spine exhibits the greatest range of motion amongst the spinal segments due to its tri-planar components of movement. As a result, measurement of movements has proved difficult. A variety of methods have been used in an attempt to measure these movements but none have provided satisfactory triplanar data. This paper uses the Zebris ultrasonic 3-D motion analysis system to measure flexion, extension, range of lateral bending and range of axial rotation in five similar male and five similar female subjects with no history of neck injuries. The subjects were tested unrestrained and in soft and hard collars, as well as in Philadelphia, Miami J and Minerva orthoses. Results show that the Minerva is the most stable construct for restriction of movement in all planes in both groups (p<
0.001 vs. all groups (p=0.01 vs. Philadelphia in female extension), ANOVA). In the male group, the standard hard collar provides the second best resistance to flexion, lateral bending and axial rotation. The female group showed no one orthosis in second place overall. Looking at these results allows ranking of the measured orthoses in order of their three-dimensional stability. Furthermore, they validate the Zebris as a reliable and safe method of measurement of the complex movements of the cervical spine with low intersubject variability. In conclusion, this paper, for the first time presents reproducible data incorporating the composite triplanar movements of the cervical spine thus allowing comparative analysis of the three-dimensional construct stability of the studied orthoses. In addition, these results validate the use of the Zebris system for measurement of cervical spine motion.
Complex foot and ankle surgery and reconstruction require accurate preoperative planning. In the foot procedures are challenging and can be associated with a range of complications. The aim of planning is to correct only the deformity and prevent extensive surgery. Knowledge of foot and ankle morphometry is vital. For comparison between different subjects the coordinate system must be constant. To the authors knowledge there has been no previous description of a coordinate system for the foot and ankle. CT images of ten anatomically normal feet were segmented in a general purpose segmentation program for grey value images and imported to a shape analysis program for biomechanics. A coordinate frame was defined in a 3 × 3 identity matrix using the inter-malleolar axis and a fibular diaphyseal centroidal axis in the construction. Centroidal vectors were defined in the metatarsals. Correlation of metatarsal length, inter-metatarsal angles, inter-malleolar distance and height was carried out. The forefoot was examined in relation to the medial and lateral columns. Metatarsal length had a significant correlation within each column and between the two columns notably in the 3rd (0.525 – 0.965) metatarsal at the columns junction. The 3rd metatarsals also correlated significantly (−0.583) with the inter-metatarsal angles. There was a weak correlation between the 1st 3rd and the 3rd 5th inter-metatarsal angles directly however, each had a large correlation with the 1st 5th inter-metatarsal angle (0.734 – 0.950). There was also a large correlation between the individual’s stature and the metatarsal length and the inter-malleolar distance. We have presented a means defining a coordinate system for three dimensional analyses in the foot and ankle. This coordinate system can be used for meaningful comparison of data between multiple subjects. We have shown that this coordinate system to be effective in practice in the morphometrical analysis of the normal forefoot.
Graft choices for revision anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction and complex ligament reconstructions of the knee are controversial. The aim of our study was to analyze the biomechanical effect of harvesting bone plugs from both the distal and proximal poles of the patella, to simulate a simultaneous harvesting of a Bone – Patellar Tendon – Bone and Quadriceps Tendon – Bone grafts, in a transverse stress environment. Sixty Bovine Patellae were analysed. They were divided into 4 groups – based on the residual bone bridge (percentage of total length of patella) remaining after bone plug resection. 0 – 10%, 11 – 20%, 21 – 30% and >
30%. All patellae were tested in a modified 4 – point bending environment, to a maximum load of 10,000N, in a customized designed jig. This method simulates the axial bending stress on the patella during knee flexion. All dimensions of the patellae were recorded including Depth of patella at bone resection and wall thickness adjacent to plug resection site. All patellae with a 0% bone bridge fractured (Ultimate Tensile Strength/UTS) at a mean Tensile Force of 5863N (Range 3140 – 8730N). There was a subgroup of incomplete fractures – extra-articular fractures – which fractured at 6542N (Range 5085 – 9180N). The remaining specimens failed to fracture. Comparing the UTS and the patellar dimensions, using Weibull’s Statistical Analysis we demonstrated that less than 60% bone plug resection carried a very low probability of fracture. This study demonstrates the safe criteria for bone – tendon graft harvesting from both the proximal and distal poles of the patella. With regards to a normal human patella, a 40% bone – bridge is approximately a 20mm bone – bridge. We conclude that the simultaneous harvesting of Bone – Patellar Tendon – Bone and Quadriceps Tendon – bone grafts from a patella has no significant increase in the fracture risk of the patella.
Hallux rigidus was first described in 1887. Many aetiological factors have been postulated, but none has been supported by scientific evidence. We have examined the static and dynamic imbalances in the first metatarsophalangeal joint which we postulated could be the cause of this condition. We performed a finite-element analysis study on a male subject and calculated a mathematical model of the joint when subjected to both normal and abnormal physiological loads. The results gave statistically significant evidence for an increase in tension of the plantar fascia as the cause of abnormal stress on the articular cartilage rather than mismatch of the articular surfaces or subclinical muscle contractures. Our study indicated a clinical potential cause of hallux rigidus and challenged the many aetiological theories. It could influence the choice of surgical procedure for the treatment of early grades of hallux rigidus.
joint incongruency, an increased tension in the Flexor Hallicus Brevis and an increased tension in the plantar fascia.
Many pedicle screw instrumentation systems are currently available to the spine surgeon. Each system has its unique characteristics. It is important for the surgeon to understand the differences in these pedicle screw systems1 Following the introduction of a new spinal instrumentation set to our clinical practice we encountered two cases of pedicle screw breakage. We thus decided to investigate the mechanism of this screw failure (screw A) in these particular cases and to compare the biomechanical properties, through independent analysis, of a variety of pedicle screws from different manufacturers. Samples of the broken pedicle screws were retrieved at surgery. Surface analysis of the fracture area using the electron microscope, demonstrated features consistent with fatigue fracture. Pedicle screws of comparable size from a variety of manufacturers were gathered for independent analysis. Shadowgraph analysis was performed of each screw allowing multiple measurements to be taken of the screw’s geometry. Using this data stress concentration factors were determined demonstrating screw A to have larger values than all the other screws ranging from 2 – 3.6 times the nominal stress. The smaller teeth of screw A, spaced further apart than in the other screws, means that the large proportion of the load which would be carried by the threads is distributed over a smaller area resulting in higher stresses in the threads. The sharp corner at the root of the thread, acting as a stress concentrator, would become the focal point of these high stresses, and magnify them by 2 to 3.6 times. These increased stresses most likely account for an increased susceptibility to fatigue fracture seen in screw A. In conclusion it is important to be careful with the introduction and use of new pedicle screw materials and designs, that all the standard biomechanical testing has been performed to a satisfactory standard. Knowing the physical characteristics of the available pedicle screw instrumentation systems may allow the choice of pedicle screw best suited for a given clinical situation.
Slipped upper femoral epiphysis (SUFE) is a condition, which affects the immature hip joint. Many theories have been postulated as to its underlying aetiology however; its exact cause is, as yet unknown. The final common pathway appears to be failure of the of the growth plate to resist shearing forces, giving rise to displacement of the femoral head. We hypothesized that the lubricating ability of the synovial fluid in hip joints of children with SUFE was defective, thereby allowing increasing shear forces on the physis to occur, so that when the joint is loaded it will fail at its weakest point, namely the capital epiphysis.
The aim of this study is to evaluate the effectiveness of the application of vibration, during the femoral cementation, as a cementing technique. It has been demonstrated that when vibration of a constant frequency was utilised, flow of low viscosity cement increased with vibration of increasing amplitude up to a particular acceleration. Above this acceleration there was little additional benefit. It has also been shown that when constant amplitude was used the flow increase was uniform over a wide frequency range, eventually falling off over a particular frequency. These results prove that the flow of orthopaedic bone cement is significantly affected by mechanical vibration of the receiving structure. It is our hypothesis that vibration promotes the ingress of bone cement into cancellous bone. The effect of mechanical vibration in the frequency range 0–500 Hz on the cadaveric human femur has been assessed in the past. It was found that when the bone was fixed at both ends, its resonant frequency was markedly affected by end loading and damping. If the conditions of the experiment were designed to simulate the condition of the femur when prepared for a total hip replacement, it was found that the bone did not resonate but behaved in a mass-like mode. The significance of this observation is that in the event of vibration being applied to enhance the penetration of orthopaedic bone cement, the movement induced in the bone will be proportional to the force applied regardless of frequency.
In contrast, the coronal femoral osteotomies had a worse healing response. The alignment of the fracture line perpendicular to the plane of motion of the joint exposes the repair tissue within it to increased shear and tensile stresses. This may play a negative role in the repair of these coronal defects when compared to sagittal osteotomies, which are relatively protected from the high transarticular pressures and showed a greater tendency to remodel their articular surface.
Percutaneous Radiofrequency Ablation (RFA) has become the method of choice in the treatment of a wide spectrum of disorders. It was introduced for the treatment of Trigeminal Neuralgia and has since been used both extensively and successfully in the treatment of this disorder. Over the past two decades it has been advocated in the treatment of hepatic metastases, lung tumours and cerebral tumours. In 1992 Rosenthal et al reported using this procedure for the treatment of Osteoid Osteomas with good outcome. Further case series have supported this modality of treatment. However, the biomechanical effects of RFA on cortical bone have not been reported to date. The study comprised of 16 large white land-raised male pigs. All were between 70–80kg in weight at the time of treatment. RFA was performed on the femur, tibia and humerus of each animal 24 hours, 1 week and 4 weeks before euthanisation. RFA was carried out via a percutaneous technique under fluoroscopic guidance. The fibula was not treated in each case and used as an intrinsic control to account for inter-group variability. The Modulus of Rigidity, Maximum Torsional Strength of all bones were determined and compared. There were three pathological fractures, all occurring in the hemerii and all occurring at 4 weeks post treatment. The Modulus of Rigidity and Maximum Torsional strength were significantly reduced at 24 hours and 1 week when compared with the control. However in the 4 weeks group the biomechanical strength of cortical bone was not significantly different and had almost returned to normal which is contradictory to the clinical setting. There was no significant difference at 24 hours and 1 week. RFA has become well established as the method of choice for the treatment of Osteoid Osteomas, however the biomechanical consequences of this procedure have not been reported to date. The torsional strength of RF ablated cortical bone is severely attenuated after 1 week, 40% reduction in torsional strength when compared with the control group. This study demonstrated that RFA of cortical bone is an effective treatment for cortical lesions however the biomechanical weakness promotes the need for weight-bearing restrictions when managing these patients postoperatively.