A reduced femoral offset in total hip replacement has been thought to be disadvantageous. We reviewed the results of 54 consecutive primary total hip replacements in 49 patients (mean age of 68 years) performed between August 1990 and December 1994, with a mean follow-up of 8.8 years ( At their latest follow-up, surviving patients had a significant improvement in the performance of their hip. Three had undergone revision, one each for deep infection, recurrent dislocation and late pain with subluxation. No hips had been revised, or were at risk of revision, for aseptic loosening. The mean annual linear rate of wear was 0.2 mm (
Hip prostheses that do not reproduce the patients’ preoperative femoral offset have been correlated with increased wear rate, instability, abductor weakness and reduced range of motion. We have reviewed the results of 54 primary low friction arthroplasties with low offset stem commonly called “¾ neck Charnley” in 49 patients (47 females and 2 males). There has been no publication in literature on the results of this stem. Mean age was 68 years (range 30 to 83). The operations were performed by one of us, (VR) as an orthopaedic trainee, with a mean follow up of 8.7 ± 2 years. The preoperative diagnosis was 40 OA, 8 protrusio, 2 DDH, 2 post-traumatic, 1 SUFE and 1 RA. The preoperative offset was 41.9 ± 7.1 mm (mean ± STD), weight 65 ± 8.4 kg, height 156.4 ± 8 cm. At their latest review 3 cases had been revised for infection or recurrent instability with a survivorship of 93.5% using Kaplan Meyer’s analysis. None of the femoral or acetabular components were loose or at risk of loosening. 16 cups showed demarcation in 1 zone of ≤ 1mm, and 2 cups had a 2 mm demarcation in 2 zones that was not progressive. 7 stems had ≤ 1mm demarcation in 1 zone, and 5 stems at 2 zones. Condensation at the tip of the stem was noted in 2 hips. The linear wear rate was 0.2 ± 0.08mm/year. Using Pearson’s correlation coefficient with P<
0.05, no statistically significant correlation was found between the preoperative offset and the linear wear rate. We believe that the surgeon should try to reproduce the patient’s femoral offset aiming for the best intra-operative soft tissue balance. The linear wear rate in this series is higher than previously reported in cases that survived for over 20 years from this unit. However, at this stage of analysis low offset Charnley stems produce good medium term results.