In 1980, Morrison and O’Brien reported their experiences with the reconstruction of an amputated thumb using a wrap-around neurovascular free flap from the great toe, but its indication has been limited distal to the metacarpophalangeal joint. We have performed 37 wrap-around free flaps from the great toe for the reconstruction of thumbs amputated at distal or proximal to the MP joint. The amputation was distal and proximal to the MP joint in 25 and 12 cases respectively. The opposition of reconstructed thumb to the other fingers was completely possible in all cases amputated distal to the MP joint. In the 12 cases amputated proximal to the MP joint of the thumb, opposition was completely possible in 6 cases in which the lilac bone block was fixated in the position of 30° flexion and 45° internal rotation. However, in the other six cases in the fixation of 30° flexion and 30° internal rotation, the opposition of the reconstructed thumb to the ring and little fingers was impossible in five cases and only to the little finger in one case. We concluded that amputation proximal to the MP joint is not an absolute contraindication to the wraparound free flap procedure for thumb reconstruction. However, for a better functional outcome we recommend iliac bone block fixation in the position of 30° flexion and 45° internal rotation.