Painful peroneal spastic flatfeet without coalition or other known etiologies in adolescence, remains a difficult condition to treat. We present eight such cases with radiological and surgical evidence of bony abnormalities in the lateral subtalar region just anterior to the posterior facet. All patients had presented as tertiary referrals with recalcitrant pain and had undergone a trial of orthotics and physiotherapy. Diagnostic workup included a clinical and radiographic evaluation. Clinical examination consisted of gait examination, foot alignment, range of motion, torsional profile of the lower limbs and marking of symptomatic foci. All patients had standing weightbearing anteroposterior and lateral projections of the foot and ankle, CT and/or MRI scans of the foot. Coalitions and other known intra-articular pathologies like subtalar arthritis were ruled out. All patients had bilateral flatfeet but unilateral peroneal spasm. All patients had an accessory anterolateral talar facet (ATF) which was arising as an anterior and distal extension of the lateral process of the talus. This caused lateral impingement between the facet and the calcaneum, confirmed by bone edema around the sinus tarsi and marked at the apex of the angle of Gissane on MRI scans. All patients had stiff subtalar joints with very limited movement under anaesthesia, indicating peroneal muscle contracture. Patients were treated with a combination of facet excision, fractional peroneal and gastrosoleus lengthening and calcaneal lengthening to correct the flatfoot and prevent lateral impingement.